Civic › St. Petersburg, FL › November 19, 2026

City Council - Nov 19, 2026

St. Petersburg, FL City Council November 19, 2026 220 minutes
▶ Watch original video Interactive viewer Search St. Petersburg meetings

Transcript

Speaker0:01

Welcome to the City of St. Petersburg City Council Meeting. Your elected officials are Mayor Ken Welch, District 1, Hopley Gerdes, District 2, Brandy Gabbard, District 3, Mike Harding, District 4 and Council Chair, Lissette Hanowitz, District 5, Deborah Figg Sanders, District 6, Gina Driscoll, District 7, Corey Gibbons Jr., and District 8 and Council Vice Chair, Ritchie Floyd. Welcome, everyone, to the November 19, 2026 City Council Meeting. Clerk, if I can have a roll call, please. Harding. Here. Hanowitz. Here. Rick Sanders. Driscoll. Here. Gibbons. Here. Floyd. Here. Gerdes and Gabbard. Okay, today we'll have our invocation given by Reverend Tracy Ashley of the Clearwater United Methodist Church. If you can please stand and then remain standing for the Pledge of Allegiance. Good afternoon. Good afternoon. I bring you greetings from Clearview, and thank you for allowing me to be with you today. Let's pray. Gracious and loving God, as Thanksgiving approaches, I am reminded of an old hymn I learned as a child. We gather together to ask the Lord's blessing. And so today we gather together asking your blessing upon this city, its people, and those entrusted with its leadership. The hymn speaks of God's will, your will, Lord, being made known to us. And we know something about your will. You have called us to love you and to love our neighbors. And these are not two separate commandments, but one inseparable calling. We cannot claim to love you while disregarding those whom you love. The hymn also reminds us that you forget not your own. And we believe that means every one of us, every sacred, precious life. Lord, you do not forget the family struggling to pay the rent and the neighbor sleeping without shelter, the elderly person choosing between groceries and medicine, or the working parent wondering how to make ends meet. You do not forget those still recovering from storms, those whose homes and livelihoods remain uncertain, and those who fear that the progress of our city may leave them behind. And so, loving God, if you do not forget them, how can we remind us that loving our neighbors is more than a good intention or a comforting sentiment? It requires something of us. It calls us to do the difficult work of protecting the dignity and humanity and well-being of every person, especially those with the least power to protect themselves. Oh, Lord, give us the courage to do what is right, even when it is costly, even when it is inconvenient, even when it requires us to choose the needs of people over the promises of greater profits or corporate growth or prosperity that not everyone will share, maybe only a few. As decisions are made about housing, development, recovery, public resources, remind us, God, that behind every proposal, every budget line, every parcel of land are human lives. Help us remember that true progress is not measured simply by what we build or how much economy grows, but by whether people can remain in their homes, provide for their families, and live with dignity in the community they love. God, this afternoon, bless our mayor, our city council members, city staff, and all who serve this community. Give them wisdom to listen, courage to make difficult decisions, humility to reconsider, and compassion to see those whose voices are too often unheard. May St. Petersburg continue becoming a city where prosperity is shared, where justice and mercy walk together, and where no one is treated as expendable or forgotten. For we are all your own, O God, and we are all neighbors. Amen. Amen. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Reverend, for that application. Thank you. Next up, we have our approval of our agenda. Move the approval. Second. A motion and a second. Clerk, if you can open the machine for voting. Council members, please enter your votes. Seeing that all present council members have voted, clerk, please tally and announce the vote. Madam Chair, motion to approve the agenda passes unanimously with council members Fick-Sanders, Gabbard, and Gerdes being absent. Thank you. We have the consent agenda. Are there any cards? No cards, Madam Chair. Okay, the only thing I'll note is CB-8. There is a resolution ordering a special assessment of a paving of an alley in District 4. This is a petition from the abutting property owners, which requires 51% approval, and has been many years that these neighbors have wanted their alley paved. So, I just wanted to congratulate them on finally getting this done, and given with Amendment 3, I would figure we're going to see more of this. So, with that, I'll entertain the motion. Move the approval. Second. We have a motion and a second. Clerk, if you can open the machine for voting. Council members, please enter your votes. Seeing that all present council members have voted, clerk, please tally and announce the vote. Madam Chair, motion to approve the consent agenda passes unanimously with council members Fick-Sanders, Gabbard, and Gerdes being absent. Thank you. Next, we move to open forum. I will know, council members, as we know, we have five council members here today. If anyone needs to get up, just let me know, because obviously we cannot hold a meeting without quorum, and four people is not enough. So, if someone needs to take a break, just let me know. And I was planning to take a break anyhow after E5, just to make sure we're fine. Okay. With that being said, let's move on to open forum. If you wish to address city council on subjects other than public hearing or quasi-judicial items listed on the agenda, please sign up with the clerk. Only the individual wishing to speak may sign the open forum sheet. Only city residents, owners of property, business owners in the city, or their employees may speak. All issues discussed under open forum must be limited to issues related to the city of St. Petersburg government. If you are speaking to an item on the agenda, you may only speak once during the open forum or when the item comes up on the agenda. Applause is not permitted except in connection with awards and presentations. In order to provide an opportunity for all citizens to address council, each individual will be given three minutes to speak, and after which the microphone will be muted. If you wish to address city council through the Zoom meeting, you must use a raise hand feature button in the Zoom app or enter star nine on your phone at the time the agenda item is addressed. When it's your turn to speak, you'll be unmuted and asked to state your name and address. At the conclusion of your comments or when you reach the three-minute time limit, you will be muted. All raised hands will be lowered after each agenda item. Regardless of the method of participation used, normal rules apply, including the three-minute time limits on comments, the requirement that any presentation materials must be submitted in advance of the meeting and the rules of decorum. If live public comment is disrupted by violations of the rules of decorum, the chair is authorized to accept public comment by alternate means, including by email only, and we do have speakers, and we'll call them two at a time, Madam Chair. First two speakers, Sarah Shellman and Lee Bryant, please go to either podium, state your name and address for the record, and you will have three minutes to, or across the street, and you have three minutes to address city council. Go ahead. Thank you. Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Sarah Shellman. I reside at 1804 East Hamilton in Tampa, but I'm employed by the Florida Orchestra as principal second violinist, so I am employed and spend much of my time here in St. Pete. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you to all of the city council for the opportunity to address you. I'm grateful for all the work you do for St. Petersburg and the communities that make up the city. I also recognize that you wouldn't be giving your time. You didn't care deeply about this corner of the world, which is what also brings me here today. My house may be on the other side of the bridge, but my professional and musical home is with the Florida Orchestra, which counts St. Petersburg as home to its offices and St. Petersburg as a foundation for its very existence. TFO has been an anchor tenant and partner of the Mahaffey Theater for over 60 years, and allowing the orchestra and venue works to take over management of the theater provides a tremendous opportunity for all parties involved. I'd like to focus particularly on the benefits for TFO and the city itself. I don't think that anyone can dispute that St. Petersburg is one of the brightest gems in the jewel box that is the Tampa Bay area. One of the biggest reasons is its status as a destination for the arts. The visual arts scene is the most nationally prominent at this point. You have the Dolly, the MFA, the James Museum, all the murals. There are many others, of course, and I mean no disrespect by not listing them all. The performing arts scene here exhibits the same world-class qualities, and it's exemplified by organizations such as the Florida Orchestra. The biggest difference, insofar as I can tell, is that the museums have a physical base here, a true home, a place from which to forge the connections and relationships that make for a vibrant community. We all know that TFO is key to the fabric of this area's culture. We bring music and vital human connection to thousands of people every season, all while dealing with the logistical challenges of being homeless, for lack of a better word. Allowing us to partner and managing them happy would allow us to redirect the time and resources spent meeting those challenges into serving the community more deeply. In other words, forging even more human connections. As the Florida Orchestra's secure position would strengthen St. Petersburg's reputation as a destination for arts and culture, the city itself would gain even more renown, civic pride, and visitors as a result. As you can see, everyone stands to greatly benefit from this partnership, from this place, to call home. Thank you again for everything that you do to make St. Petersburg the gem of a city that it is, and please vote yes on the agreement with the Florida Orchestra. Thank you. Thank you. Good afternoon, Chair Hennewick. Members of the City Council, my name is Lee Bryant, and I live at 331 26th Street North. I'm here today to urge the City Council to take a leading role in the Bay Area by formally encouraging Mayor Welch and Chief Holloway to end the St. Petersburg Police Department's 287G agreement with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Our city was told that St. Pete had no choice but to enter into this agreement. But when we look closely at Florida law, a clear distinction emerges. The state statutes mandate that county sheriffs and detention facilities must participate in 287G programs. Municipalities are not required by state law to enter into these agreements. Cities across Florida have recognized this legal reality and have chosen not to deputize their local officers as federal immigration agents. True public safety is built on trust, and 287G actively erodes that foundation. When residents feared that a routine traffic stop, a call to report a domestic dispute, or coming forward as a witness to a crime could lead to family separation, people stop calling the police. Crimes go unreported. Dangerous individuals remain uninvestigated, and every single neighborhood in our wonderful city becomes less safe as a result. Furthermore, our limited local tax dollars and police resources should be focused on the priorities of St. Pete residents, not subsidizing federal law enforcement duties. Even when the police department states that its role is limited, the very existence of this agreement sends a message of fear throughout our neighborhoods, keeping families from going to work, supporting local businesses, going to church, or something I know a little bit about, going to school. St. Petersburg prides itself on being a welcoming, inclusive city that leads with courage and compassion. Leading does not mean waiting for other cities to act. It means setting a standard. We have a choice, and I urge this council to review the legal authority before you to reaffirm that our police department answers to the people of St. Pete and take the decisive step to terminate 287G. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Thanks to the speakers, Madam Chair. I believe it's Christina Williams and Roger Covey. Please go to either podium. State your name, address, or cross street, and you will have three minutes to address city council. Good afternoon. My name is Christina Williams, and I live off of 4th Street and 83rd Avenue. Go ahead. Is that better? Okay. I'm here today to encourage city council members also to discuss leaving the 287G agreement. We have seen throughout this country what happens when ICE agents invade cities. Trust in local police is eroded. Crimes such as domestic violence, sexual assault, and trafficking go unreported due to fear of deportation. People are afraid to leave their homes to go to work, school, or go to the doctor or hospital for urgent care. Since January 2025, over 60 people have died while in ICE custody. I'm sure you've seen the videos of the inhumane actions ICE agents are using on community members, brutal, unnecessary force shooting people as they flee, and the horrifying scene we saw recently in Houston where an agent chased after a man in his car, hit him, ran him over, and broke his leg. Their justification is always the same. They feared for their life. And time and time again, when video evidence of the encounter is available, it proves their account to be false. They are reckless, and there has been little to no accountability to rein them in. Their priority is the number of people detained, no matter what the cost. We do not want this in St. Pete. There has been an increase in ICE sightings and detainments in Hillsborough County, and more agents have been spotted in St. Pete recently. 600 students in Wymama have disappeared from classrooms, afraid to attend, as it may lead to them being ripped apart from their families. According to track data, about 71% of people detained had no criminal convictions, zero. The majority of those with convictions were for minor offensives, such as traffic violations. Only 3% of detained individuals had a violent felony conviction. I would like to believe that everyone on this council is here because you care about St. Pete. You care about our community and the people in it. We are living in a historic time in our country. How do you want to show up? How do you want to be remembered? Speaking out against injustice and standing up for those who are vulnerable is not easy. It requires courage, empathy, and willingness to put others before yourself. It may not feel comfortable, but is your discomfort worth the life of someone that it may save? Yesterday, the Tallahassee City Commission passed an item to create a plan to exit the city's 287G agreement at their next meeting. This agreement is voluntary, and there is a path out. The city's website states that the city of St. Petersburg works to create a diverse, vibrant city, guided by principled progress and intentional inclusivity. If this council wants to uphold this initiative, they should be protecting and standing up for our neighbors and joining Tallahassee in being a leader in exiting this agreement. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Go ahead, sir. Thank you. My name is Roger Covey. I live at 4974 Oxford Avenue North, St. Petersburg. You saw it earlier this week on the national news, a woman beaten and pepper sprayed by three ICE agents. She was handcuffed after they forced her to the ground. She was 12 weeks pregnant. She was released six hours later with no charges. ICE helpfully explained basically that she started it. That is another example in the long litany of abuses by ICE from people drowning in the Rio Grande River entangled by barbed wire to Alligator Alcatraz to Renee Good and Jeffrey Preddy. The cruelty is the point. The city of St. Petersburg is contractually obligated through the 287G agreement to cooperate with ICE to, in effect, be their eyes and ears in the St. Petersburg community. No vote was ever taken to enter this agreement. What we ask for is very straightforward. Put the 287G agreement on the City Council agenda. Have a discussion and vote. Thank you. Thank you. Next two speakers. Next two speakers, Madam Chair. Chair Mitchell Kuhn and Paul Kurtz, please go to either podium, state your name, address, or cross street, and you'll have three minutes to address City Council. Dear members of the St. Petersburg City Council, my name is Mitchell Kuhn, and I reside at 10901 Brighton Bay Boulevard Northeast, here in St. Petersburg, Florida. I am principal oboist of the Florida Orchestra. Before joining the orchestra, I served in the same position with the Metropolitan Opera Orchestra. I've also performed with every professional orchestra in Florida, and I feel confident in saying that the Florida Orchestra is, frankly, the best. However, I believe the orchestra's greatest challenge and perhaps its greatest obstacle to future growth is the lack of a permanent home. The absence of a permanent home has real consequences. In the two seasons since I've been here, we've lost two exceptionally talented musicians to orchestras in Kansas City and Milwaukee. I've spoken with both personally, and they told me that the lack of a permanent hall was a major factor in their decision to leave. And this isn't simply a problem of the past. I know musicians currently in the orchestra who are actively looking for opportunities elsewhere, in part because of the lack of a permanent home. We have also seen musicians leave for orchestras like the Boston Symphony, the Los Angeles Philharmonic, and the National Symphony. Think about what we lose when musicians of this caliber leave our city. Not just their contributions to the orchestra, but to their contributions to the broader artistic vibrancy of our community. We have an orchestra capable of achieving tremendous things and growing to something truly world-class, but we need the infrastructure to support that ambition. An agreement allowing the Florida Orchestra to manage the Mahaffey Theater in partnership with Venue Works would be an enormous step forward. It would give us a true home and the opportunity to revitalize the hall for our musicians and audiences. This isn't just an investment in the orchestra, it's an investment in St. Petersburg. A thriving orchestra with a permanent home can become a defining asset for this city, attracting visitors, enriching downtown, creating educational opportunities, and giving residents an institution they can take tremendous pride in. Today, the Council has an opportunity to make a real and tangible difference in the lives of the musicians of the Florida Orchestra and the artistic community of Tampa Bay. Please help us fulfill a vision of the future of what the Florida Orchestra could look like. Residing in a hall we're proud to call our own, a place audiences are genuinely excited to visit, a cultural destination recognized throughout the country, and an orchestra that continues to attract and retain the very best musicians. I believe that this future is within reach and that this agreement is a critical step towards making it a reality. I sincerely hope that you will vote yes on the amendment with the Florida Orchestra. Thank you. Thank you. The next two speakers, Madam Chair. Oh, no, there's Paul. He hasn't gone yet. That's fine. You just got the mom saved. Go ahead. Go ahead. Good afternoon, Council. My name is Paul Kurtz. I live at 910 31st Terrace Northeast here in St. Pete. I'm here to speak in support of Item G, the 31st Street South Safety Improvement Study. Thank you to Council Member Floyd for bringing that forward. I believe this is a worthy project. It's been going on for about two years now, and it makes some important safety recommendations for that corridor. One of the things I'd also like to note is that the city is planning to resurface 31st Street next year, so this is a timely item as well. Some of the safety improvements, if approved in the HLUT committee, could be adapted into the resurfacing project and gain some efficiency so that when the plan ultimately gets implemented, we wouldn't be doing double work. So this important safety plan is going to actually start at 22nd. The whole corridor starts up at, I think, 5th North, I think, but 22nd South to Pinellas Point is the area in question now for these safety improvements. So I urge you to consider supporting the 31st Street study when it goes to HLUT, and hopefully we can see some nice improvements on safety improvements on that corridor next year. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Now. Now. Madam Chair, we have a speaker here, Bill Liderski. It says that his address is in Gulfport. I want to confirm whether or not you are an employee here or you own a business. Is there a Bill, what's the name? Bill Liderski. Bill Liderski. Are you an employee? Are you a Gulfport resident? You can't speak here. You have to be a resident of St. Pete or employee or have to own a business. No, sir. No, sir, it's not. Separate city. All right, next two speakers, Madam Chair, Jameika Williams and Sean McCurdy. Please go to either podium, state your name, address, or across the street, and you'll have three minutes to address city council. Go ahead, Jameika. Good afternoon. I'm Jameika Williams, and I live at Tenton Crescent Lake Drive here in St. Pete. I am speaking today in opposition to the proposed language in item two that would bar Neighborhood Association board members from serving on the Community Planning and Preservation Commission and the Development Review Commission. As a neighborhood association board member myself, I know firsthand what that commitment means. We are volunteers who give up our evenings and weekends because we care deeply about our city, and we understand how local policy affects everyday residents and want to build stronger communities. Showing up and listening to neighbors and dedicating unpaid time to civic life are the exact traits that make someone a strong, thoughtful leader, the kind of person any city board should welcome, not disqualify. And avoiding conflicts of interest during quasi-judicial hearings is a fair goal, and we already have a specific process that enables us to avoid that direct conflict. A blanket bin, in my opinion, is too far, and I think it singles out everyday community volunteers while leaving developers and real estate professionals that might have a real conflict of interest eligible to be a seat at the table. And St. Pete, I believe, is strongest when residents who are already stepping up to serve their neighborhoods are welcome into broader public service, not shut out for it. And so I urge you all to strike this restriction from Item 2 and to keep these commissions open to neighborhood leaders who help make this city run. Thank you. Thank you. Go ahead, sir. My name is Sean McCurdy. I live at 2640 Dartmouth Avenue North here in St. Petersburg. I am a new resident here in St. Petersburg. I came here in the spring from the city of Pittsburgh. We were very excited about coming here. One of the reasons we came to St. Petersburg is because of the unique neighborhoods. I was just thinking about all the things that we've had happen in historic Kenwood and in the Kenwood area. We had a Halloween event that attracted over 300 people to Seminole Park. We had a garden workshop recently. And this past Sunday, we had Porch Music Day, which had over 15 performers and musicians come into our neighborhood, and it was just incredible. Our community supports the public dining for public arts, so I think most of you know historic Kenwood is an artist enclave. The arts are very important to our neighborhood. When we came to St. Pete, we had a hard time finding a house. And being from Pittsburgh, those of you that remember Mr. Rogers, we wrote a letter into our neighborhood saying we want to be your neighbor. We're very fortunate that we found a house in Kenwood, and we're so proud to be St. Pete residents now. All the programs that I talked about and one I didn't talk about yet, Bungalow Fest is coming up in February, February 6, 2026, or 2027. I'm sorry, the reason it's near and dear to my heart is I'm working on that event. I'm a volunteer, but it does fund our Community Cares Program, our Kenwood Kids Program, obviously the arts, and many others. So I'm here because our programs in Kenwood would not be possible without our community leaders, those that lead our neighborhood. And without them, those programs would not be possible. Many times, I think we all find volunteers wear many hats. So it's not unusual for someone to be involved with their neighborhood, also serve on maybe a city board or commission. So today I'm here to speak in favor of allowing our neighborhood leaders to continue to participate and be a part of city government. So I do support Kona's position. I love what Kona does. I truly think St. Pete is special because of our neighborhoods, and I truly hope that you continue to allow our neighborhood leaders to be a part of the process. Thank you. Thank you. Final two speakers, Madam Chief Alves and Jeff Molter. Please go to either podium, state your name, address, or cross street, and you have three minutes to adjust to the council. Hi, council. Franklin Alves. I live at 1026 Ninth Avenue South here speaking on behalf of the Council of Neighborhood Associations. I just wanted to go over a few items on the agenda. The first one will be my favorite, CP Heights Neighborhood Plan. It's been a long time coming for them, and they've done great work advocating for this plan to get over the finish line. So I'm very excited that it's here today. They'll be talking about it. Listen to what they're saying, what's in the plan, in their presentation. They've taken a lot of time to voice how they want to make their neighborhood special for them, and I'm very excited to see that go over the finish line. Alternatively, as you saw from the emails that you got, in the LDR 2006-5, we were all very disappointed to see the exclusion of neighborhood boards and board members from participating in the CPC and DRC neighborhood service shouldn't be punished in that way. It's an enormous part of our civic life and our civic duties and what makes St. Pete special. And so, as you heard today and you've seen in emails, that we are in opposition of that new code in there. In addition to what's in that, I'm also very excited that that also has our neighborhood signs code amendment as part of that. That has been a long time coming as well. Neighborhoods have been spending a lot of volunteer hours, service time to get signs for their communities, and this text amendment will just make that so much easier for them. I'm very excited that that's part of this and that ideally next year we can make it a much easier and smoother process for neighborhood associations to start kind of assisting in getting that signs over the finish line. I have two more things, so I promise I'll be quick about it. I know that Chief Holloway will be presenting today. One thing that I've seen from his quarterly presentations and something that I kind of always get curious about after that is knowing the age of folks that have committed certain crimes in part of that presentation. I always feel like that's lacking in that and knowing that the age group would really help in kind of telling an additional story of what's going on within our neighborhoods and within our city. I know that personally from even within my own neighborhood. That's kind of the number one question that we ask. You know, you hear about carjackings or any types of violence. What's the age group of that? And for us, sadly, it's usually always teenagers. So I think bringing that here and having that be part of the conversation is important. And then lastly, since this is kind of the last meeting before Thanksgiving, I just wanted to say that we have some of the best staff. They've taken a lot of time to walk me through these different things, understanding how the code process works, the different things that they're working on. And I just want to say that I'm very thankful for the time that they've that they've taken to explain to us and for all the time that they take for neighborhood associations and presenting to them. So thank you. Thank you. Go ahead. Hi, members of the city council. My name is Jeff Malter, and I thank you for letting me speak to you today. I reside at 838 20th Avenue North in St. Petersburg, and I am the concertmaster of the Florida Orchestra. I've been the concertmaster of the Florida Orchestra for the last 20 years. And over those many years, I have felt the wonderful love of this city for this orchestra, and that relationship has meant a lot to me. We at the orchestra spend countless hours trying to design programs and offerings that appeal to the entire community, and we have been, I think, very successful with that, whether it's a performance of Beethoven or Billy Joel or Broadway or one of our wonderful youth offerings or our matinee programs that occur early in the day that helps serve some members of our community. I just feel like we have had such a great relationship with the city. So I would really encourage you to vote yes on the continued relationship and give us a permanent home. My colleague Mitchell spoke very eloquently, as did Sarah, about how important that is to making our job to provide for the community so much easier. So I thank you for your time. Thank you. More speakers, Madam Chair. No Zoom speakers, Madam Chair. Great. Thank you. Okay. We close open forum, and we move to reports. The first item is F1. You didn't sign a open forum. I did. I'm on that seat. Hold on a second. That's... John Shaw, I didn't hear you. Hold on a second. So why don't we go ahead? We can reopen forum, and obviously we have another speaker, too, and we'll take you, too. Go ahead. John Shaw and Susan Betzer, please state your name, address, or cross street. You have three minutes to address the city council. All right. Yeah, sorry about that. I signed up. Hello. My name is John Shaw, and I reside at 4945 2nd Avenue North in St. Petersburg. I'm currently serving in my 31st year with the Florida Orchestra as the organization's principal percussionist. And I, too, am here to ask you for your vote and support in regard to the agreement between the Mahaffey Theater and the Florida Orchestra. As a longtime member of the orchestra, I've got a lot of wonderful memories of my time helping our organization serve this community. And a majority of those moments are tied to the Mahaffey Theater. It was on that stage I won my national audition to be invited to join this orchestra. I even met my wife, Anna Kate, who's the orchestra's principal harpist, on that stage as well. By my modest calculations, I've performed in the Mahaffey over 1,200 times over the last 30 years for somewhere between one and a half million and two million patrons. My daughter practically grew up backstage, having accompanied me and my wife to countless concert nights. We actually even have some cute video for napping in a beanbag chair while Yo-Yo Ma performed on stage. From my vantage point as a performer, I've seen firsthand the impact that this partnership between the Mahaffey and TFO has on the population of our city and the nourishment of its collective soul. The impact we've had on the legions of schoolchildren through live performances and educational outreach training. The excitement and attention that we've brought to the city through our collaborations with amazing artists like Cynthia Erivo, Sting, Seal, Ixak Perlman, Yo-Yo Ma, as well as all the legendary performances that the Florida Orchestra has given on a weekly basis for almost 60 years. We are the people who know this theater and community best. And we can tap into the potential to continue to serve this community in the greatest way possible. To do so, the partnership between the Mahaffey and the Florida Orchestra must become permanent. With a real place to call home, we will have the ability to plan and schedule more efficiently. And in doing so, we'll be able to fulfill the theater's potential to its fullest. The theater would be curated by the people who know it best. TFO can guide the cultural vision of the Mahaffey while Venue Works handles daily operations and bookings. Perhaps more than any other facet of a city's makeup, its commitment to the arts is what makes it a desirable and fulfilling place to call home. St. Petersburg's own nickname is the City of the Arts. The jewel in St. Pete's Ground is the Florida Orchestra, which is the largest professional orchestra in the state and one of the best in the entire country. For nearly 60 years, and I've been there for more than half of them, the Mahaffey has been one of our homes. It's time to make it our permanent home. It will be cared for by the people who, again, know it best. St. Petersburg will be served in the best possible way. Thank you all so much for what you do. Thank you. Thank you for the opportunity to speak today. I'm Susan Betzer. I've been a St. Petersburg resident since we moved here from Rhode Island in 1971 and came to 1830 Crescent Lake Drive in the house where we still live. And we're proud members of the Crescent Lake neighborhood. About two years after arriving, we discovered the Florida Orchestra, and we have subscribed ever since. We've watched it grow into one of the distinguished first-rate orchestras in the nation. Given its reputation and its significance, it's astounding that our orchestra has risen to these heights with no permanent home during its entire 59 years of existence. This critical goal of having a home is finally within reach at the beautiful Mahaffey Theater, a place that, in the 1980s, was a civic auditorium, the Bayfront Center, with all the ambiance of a Greyhound bus terminal. The community worked together, then, to transform it into a real theater with a traditional European feel. Renovating Mahaffey was first suggested to City Council member Sally Wallace, one of the first women on St. Petersburg City Council, by St. Petersburg local orchestra board member Tom Dunn. The council approved it unanimously. St. Petersburg rallied to the project. A generous lead gift from the Mahaffey family inspired literally thousands of individual donors. At least a thousand gave more than a thousand dollars each. You can still see the names of the chair sponsors on the backs of the seats. Look for them. When the Mahaffey family sponsored six chairs, a friend said to Mark, But there are only three children in your family. Who is Patty? Mark replied. That's our dog. This is the level of devotion this orchestra has inspired. Back then, city staff and city council members worked together with orchestra professionals, volunteers and donors and enthusiastic people from the community who weren't working just for the orchestra. They were working to make something that the whole city would be incredibly proud of. And they worked, helped on the construction and design together to transform Mahaffey into the beautiful performance hall we have today. Now, finally, today, we have the opportunity to make the Mahaffey a permanent home for the orchestra for great music and music education, and a variety of other programs that benefit the entire community. The orchestra, through its management company, as you've heard, will be able to offer other arts, entertainment, educational programs, at the level of excellence equal to this community. Thank you, Ms. Pastor. Ms. Pastor, that's right. I urge you to vote yes on the Florida Orchestra Agreement today. We close open forum, and now we move to reports. Next up, F1, St. Petersburg Police Department, quarterly report. Chief Holloway, good afternoon, Chief. Good afternoon, Madam Chair, Councilmembers. It's going to be our third quarterly report for this year. The period of time is going to occur from July, August, and September. Overall, crime is down by 3%. Our five-year trend, crime is down by 17%. For this quarter, violent crime is up by 10%. Five-year trend, crime is down by 7%. Property crime is down by 7.5%. Overall, five-year, property crime is down by 25%. Thank you, sir. Our homicides for this period, we've had three for this quarter. They all happened in July. Like we say, one is too many, but they all were closed out with an arrest. One was a domestic, one was robbery, and one was an argument. Also want to give a shout-out to our officers and also to the Criminal Investigation Division. Again, agency our size or city our size, we have closed out all our homicides in the past four years with either an arrest or some type of closure. So we have no open homicide from 2022 until now. Our NIVAS report, again, just to remind city council, this is a unit that we created that anytime we have a shots fire call, we have detects that will go out and collect the shell casing to see how we can link those cases to other shootings that happened throughout the city during this quarter. Last quarter, we had 85 cases, but we were able to link 46 to NIBIT. Stolen guns, we're still getting better at that. I wish we could hit zero, but I know that's probably never going to happen. Last quarter, we had 43 guns that were stolen out of cars, this time around 37. Last quarter, we had 35 taken out of cars, this quarter 27. Again, like the city council told everyone, you have a right to carry a gun, just be responsible gun owners. Please take your guns out of your car, and please make sure you secure your weapons at all times. Our crime, again, as we talked about earlier, is still trending in a downward trajectory. Robberies for the year to date is up by 4%, not 48%, 4%, and down 5-year trend is 16%. Burglaries are down by 8%. Overall, for a 5-year trend is down by 30%. Auto theft is down by 5%, and 5-year trend is down by 45%. Again, that's just things through technology, the community working with us, and the great work that the officers are out there doing. We're going to report crimes going down. You're also going to see where some arrests will go down also with crime, but then we do peak where you see auto theft. Again, these young kids are still taking cars, and somebody asked earlier. We do do a breakdown. We talk to our clergy members after this meeting. We also have a quarterly meeting with our clergy leaders. We'll let them know the race, the sex, and the age of the juveniles that are still in cars and what areas so that we can possibly work on trying to turn these kids' lives around. Traffic stats for the quarter are some areas up. We still have our traffic units that are out there enforcing a traffic law throughout the city. We still do traffic enforcement in certain areas. We post it online to let people know that we're going to be there, but we still catch people driving at a high rate of speed. Our home unit, again, that's the unit that works with the sheriff's office throughout the county. We make sure that once a child has committed a crime or violent felony that we do checks. Our past units still can make sure they make contact with our unhoused individuals and see how we can give them assistance throughout the city. Again, through Council Member Driscoll, we just want to show you where we go throughout the city. As you can see, we go just about everywhere where we can encounter a homeless, unhoused individual and see how we can help them with the issues that we're having. We also work with other departments throughout the city so we can bring these residents' help. Park, Walk, and Talk, as you can see for this quarter, we really spiked up. We want to make sure we continue to get the ulcers out of our car at least one hour a week where they make contact with people in the community. The job is not to make an arrest. It's for us to get out and know the other 98% of the community and how can we address issues that are happening in their community, whether it's dealing with unhoused individual traffic operations or just anything that we can help out in their community. The Eagle Eye program has only got eight people that signed up for this quarter, but we know there are more people out there as people sometimes just don't give us that information. What we do when a violent crime happens in the neighborhood, our detective will go door-to-door, knock on the door, ask people if they do have some type of doorbell camera or some type of cameras that we can see. We can go back and see what happened during that incident. That has helped us close out a lot of our cases, especially on homicide cases where we can see what happened before and after the incident. Use of force, still, again, our agency reports any time an officer uses force. During this quarter, we had no citizen complaint on the use of force. I had to go back to that. So we used force 352 times, and we had zero complaint. People complain about how officers are using force. We did have some in-house use of force that we looked at because make sure they follow the policy and procedure. Our call program is going very strong. I was just up in New York talking about our program throughout. As you can see, 97% of these calls that we go on, we do not send law enforcement out. We've had zero incident where our navigators have been involved in any type of violent crime, and it also shows you the areas that we send most of our navigators to. During this period of time, we had over 1,200 contacts. Our forward together program at the city council sign-off, and as the mayor brought it up, as you can see, is very strong. It still remains strong through our partners here at Gulf Coast. And I always like to bring that up. These kids that are arrested, 61% of those children have not re-offended. We are getting the help that they need. So that says a lot about new people coming in. And now the kids call their counselors, coaches. So these coaches are making contact with these young individuals and putting them back on track. Through our PAL League, we also continue to make sure working with parks and recs where these kids cannot afford certain things, where it's fees or equipment that we try to get those kids the equipment that they need so they can get back doing other things. And that was a million dollars that were put into this program through the mayor's office. The last thing I want to talk about is accreditation. This past quarter, we received our CALEA accreditation. That is a national accreditation. St. Petersburg Police Department is the longest-lasting police department in the nation that has been accredited since 1985. We have never asked for an extension. We've always received our accreditation through a CALEA, and we also have been on our state accreditation since 2003. So thanks to the men and women, that's a long time to be accredited nationally. So with that, I'll open up for any questions. Council Member Gibbons. Thank you so much, Chair, and thank you, Chief, for being here. And since you're here, it was brought up, and I hope you can answer the question by the corner president, some information that it seems like we have that we may be able to share, which is those arrest demographics. Is that correct? Did I hear you say that? That is correct. Next week, I'm sorry, the following week, we meet with the clergy members, and we do a deeper dive so they can see that, so they can talk to people in their community. Is it possible, Chief, in the future, we can, for transparency purposes, maybe share just a broad overview of what those numbers look like here in these meetings when you give your quarterly report? If the council wants those numbers, I can be more than happy. It'll make a little bit longer, but I can either send it to you or I do the... Doesn't have to be anything in-depth, but just something general. Thank you. I appreciate that, Chief. Specifically regarding youth, that's what I'm looking for. That makes your job a little bit easier. And then my other question for you, speaking of youth, was regarding school zone safety initiative. We had spoken about some of those cameras being installed. I know there was an initiative that we had talked about possibly rolling out, but there were some funding issues. Can you speak a little bit to that, Chief? Because I know that conversation's come up recently. So as we keep talking about installing cameras around the school, those speed cameras, there's some funding involved in it. There's also the signage that's going to be involved in it. A lot of agencies look at when are we going to do that. As we spoke about, most of these cameras collect revenue, so to speak. But our problem with where we look at it is, so if a school is closed on a Saturday afternoon and you go by that school zone at 40 miles an hour, and you can get a ticket. So then we have to go back and figure out it's not supposed to be that period of time. So it's really working with the vendors, because a lot of people don't know when a school is open, when a school is closed, and where are we going to put these cameras, where are we going to start off with these cameras. So we're still doing a study on that. I know at Hillburg County they're still looking at it because there was still some issues. So once we see some clarity with that, we'll be more than happy to bring it to the mayor's office, get it legal, and bring it before city council to see if that's something that we want to invest in with that type of money. Do we have any timeline on that, Chief? We're still waiting for some of the cases to clear over in Tampa to see how those work out. So maybe in 2027 we can bring it up, we can look at it again. Sounds good. Thank you, Chief, and thank you, Chair. You're welcome. Thank you. Chief, I know that this has been discussed before, but just because it's been brought up as a meeting and you're here on 287G and what your statements have been before on that, if you can just kind of touch upon that and the City of St. Pete. Sure. So, again, I did sign a 287G agreement. Since we've had this agreement in place, none of our police officers have been trained. They have not contacted us. So when they contact us, we will train officers. We already have identified those officers that will be trained. We have not arrested anyone under 287G since we've had this. You can also go online. They show you all the agencies that have arrested people under the 287G. So we have not been trained in it. And we also have not received any money from the federal government. We have not applied for any grants to be paid for by the federal government for 287G. Okay. And in terms of, I believe there are also Florida statutes that have been cited by the state, right, that could be applicable in this circumstance, correct? Yes, that has been, and Legal has talked about that also. It says that we will, since they will, that we will do everything possible to make sure that we follow that rule. If not, then people can be, I'll turn to counsel on that one. Okay. And I don't know, Legal, if you want to add anything. I agree, Chair, with what the Chief said. We have looked at it before, determined it does apply to municipalities. And the Chief's statement is accurate as to what's required under that law. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Chief. Next up, we have F3, which is a resolution accepted in the St. Pete Heights neighborhood plan. And I believe Kaylee will be presenting on that. Good afternoon. Kaylee Saginowski, Neighborhood Relations Manager, here today. We're going to talk about the St. Pete Heights neighborhood plan. So, St. Pete Heights is one of our relatively newer neighborhood associations. They were formerly organized under the name Highland Grove, but reestablished in May of 2018, voted to change the name to St. Pete Heights, and decided on some smaller boundaries. So, the neighborhood as it exists today is from 30th to 38th Avenues North, and from I-275 to 28th Street North on the west side. Since they reorganized, the neighborhood association has been very active. And one of the primary ways that we've worked with them as a neighborhood relations department is through our partnership grants. So, they've received two from us so far. The first in 2019 for a neighborhood branding campaign. They partnered with local artist Leo Gomez to develop a new font and logo for the neighborhood that kind of captures their identity and history. And then they obtained another grant in 2021 to put that logo on some neighborhood identity signs that you can see throughout the neighborhood today. When the neighborhood reorganized, conversations started very early on about creating a neighborhood plan. Neighborhood plans are great because they give us a place to talk about residents' priorities and document their shared vision for the future. So, some of the early conversations with the neighborhood, some of the strengths that they identified of St. Pete Heights was the central location, their spacious lots with big backyards, the architectural diversity and welcoming atmosphere of the neighborhood, and again, some appreciation for that active neighborhood association. I believe we also have some representatives from the neighborhood here today. Some opportunities for improvement were also identified in those early conversations. So, things like adding green space to the neighborhood, increasing its safety and walkability, and potentially adding some neighborhood-serving businesses. So, in order to begin drafting this neighborhood plan, this plan was written completely in-house by the neighborhood relations team. We hosted a kickoff meeting, four different workshops, and a draft plan review meeting. And all of those were publicized with postcards, door hangers, and through the neighborhood association's social media and email distribution list. So, you can see right here a little bit more detailed about those four workshops that we hosted. The first was on green space, beautification, and neighborhood character. The second was about transportation. Third was business development and codes. And then the fourth workshop was for neighborhood engagement, public safety, and sustainability. After those workshops, staff presented a draft plan to the neighborhood in September of 2025. And then when I took over this position in October of 2025, St. Pete Heights leadership asked to meet and discuss the plan, and they requested some revisions. They were looking for something a little bit more succinct that really clarified the neighborhood's goals for the next 5, 10, 15 years. So, they wanted something that as soon as you pick it up, it was very clear what their vision for the future was. So, we obviously agreed to do those revisions and work with them, and we released a post-workshops online survey to make sure that we had the latest and greatest feedback from all of the neighborhood residents. And then we went to work revising the plan, and the neighborhood was very patient with me while I was out on maternity leave, and that brings us to the present day. So, the next few slides we're going to talk about in terms of those four workshop categories that I just presented. And you'll see a bolded statement at the top of each of these slides that I'll read out loud because these are the vision statements that resulted from those themed areas. So, for green space and beautification, St. Pete Heights will have an attractive, safe, and well-maintained public space and will prioritize the addition of accessible green space within its boundaries. Again, the Neighborhood Association is very active, and they lead regular neighborhood cleanups and improvement projects. They also got another grant from the city in 2023 to plant trees and right-of-ways throughout their neighborhood. And while it might look like the neighborhood is close to several public parks and green spaces from a bird's-eye view, residents were said that they feel disconnected from these places because of major roadways, incomplete pedestrian connections, and so they're hoping that some of those barriers can be removed and hoping that green space can be added to the neighborhood itself. They also expressed a desire for more trees and enhanced landscaping along their main corridors. For transportation and mobility, the vision statement is that St. Pete Heights will be a safe, connected, and accessible neighborhood with a complete pedestrian network, effective traffic calming, and multimodal transportation options that allow residents to comfortably walk, bike, drive, and use public transit. Speeding issues were actually part of the original impetus for St. Pete Heights to reestablish, and their residents remain very committed to continuing their advocacy. So whether that's for traffic calming measures through within the neighborhood or advocating to FDOT to extend the sound barriers on I-275 on the east side of the neighborhood. Residents said that they would also like to see a completed sidewalk grid, safer intersections, and some microbiality amenities like e-bikes and scooter hubs. For business development and redevelopment, the vision is that St. Pete Heights will encourage neighborhood-scale development, including neighborhood-serving businesses and appropriate missing middle housing along major corridors, while promoting economic opportunity, reinvestment, and development that benefits the existing residents. So there are some businesses currently in St. Pete Heights, especially in the southwest corner and along the perimeter, but these are mostly light industrial uses, auto shops, and that kind of thing, and residents said they would like to see more shops that they could go to on a daily basis. So coffee shops, restaurants, even like gyms, bookstores, those types of things. For neighborhood character and engagement, St. Pete Heights will preserve and enhance the neighborhood's identity and character while fostering a strong, engaged, and connected community. They'd like to continue some of the thoughtful development and growth throughout the neighborhood and continue to expand residents' opportunities to connect with each other and volunteer. And for public safety, St. Pete Heights residents would like to continue to feel safe, secure, and confident using public spaces and moving throughout the community. This could continue to be accomplished through improved street and pedestrian lighting, reduced speeding and cut-through traffic, and by addressing some of the nuisance activity and poor property conditions in the neighborhood. So switching gears now to some of the recommended actions that came out of these discussions, you'll see these are no longer organized by the workshop titles, but rather by the city org chart. So each of these are organized into one of our administrations. So in the Housing and Neighborhood Services Administration, neighborhood residents would like to see expanded beautification efforts through neighborhood cleanups and the code compliance process, and they'd like to encourage and incentivize the development of missing middle housing. Under the Community Enrichment Administration, residents would like to see that publicly accessible green space and recreational use within the neighborhood boundaries. In the Public Works Administration, again, that complete sidewalk grid, improved landscaping on medians, fixing broken sidewalks, curbs, and catch basins, increasing the general tree canopy, and then paving alleys, filling potholes, and adding public trash bins. In the City Development Administration, they'd like to see upgraded bike lanes where they're feasible, the addition of public e-bike and scooter hubs within the neighborhood, some safety improvements at intersections, attaining and retaining neighborhood-serving businesses, public art, and then in the public safety administrations, there was requests for additional park walk and talks and directed patrols, and continued and expanded engagement opportunities with police and fire. So this neighborhood plan did go to the CPPC on November 9th and was approved unanimously, but you can see here some of the projects that we just reviewed in the left-hand column and their alignment with the comp plan on the right-hand column. And so for next steps, with your approval here today, this plan will be considered final, and then we can start talking about opportunities to fund some of the projects that we just went over. So those can potentially happen through our Neighborhood Partnership Grants, which is $20,000 a year per neighborhood. Those are funded through the General Fund as well as the Capital Improvement Fund. And then there's also funding in the Capital Improvement Fund for neighborhood enhancement, and some of those dollars could potentially be used here as well. And with that, I will take any questions. So I'm curious. I know Amendment 3 just passed, and we're talking about grant programs, and so I don't want to get everyone's hopes high about grants that may not exist in FY28 because what we're looking at are huge deficits. So if the administration could talk a little bit about that. Yeah, thank you, Chair, and that's a good point. I mean, obviously for us, Amendment 3 is a real paradigm shift for local government in the state of Florida, and everything is going to have to be looked at. So as we go into FY28, you know, we'll certainly be taking a look at everything. You know, I want to compliment Kaylee in the neighborhood on getting through the neighborhood plan, and I think there are maybe some grants available this year that we can look at. And there's also some public works, CIP-type funding that we can look at for some of the items that were mentioned there. But it is going to be more challenging on a going-forward basis for grants. Okay. Thank you. Council, Vice Chair Floyd. Thanks. Oh, I'm sorry. There was a public comment before. Okay. Madam Chair, we have one speaker, Brian Kansanias-Scarcella. Scarcella, please go to either podium, state your name, address, or cross street, and you'll have three minutes to address city council. Hi, everyone. I'm Brian Kansanias-Scarcella, 3100 Yale Street North, St. Pete Heights. Many of you already know me, but what some of you may not know is that I also serve as the president of the St. Pete Heights Neighborhood Association. I'm joined today by my board members, Barry Ezell, and Vice President Kevin Elliott, as well as Bella Arango, who's following us now on St. Pete TV. Hi, Bella. We're here to express our strong support for the acceptance of the St. Pete Heights Neighborhood Plan, which received unanimous support from the CPPC. We began this process nearly three years ago in January of 2024, and while we encountered challenges along the way, we're grateful to finally be reaching this milestone. We'd especially like to recognize Amy Foster, Joe Waugh, Kaylee Zaganowski, Jennifer Jern, and the entire Neighborhood Relations team for their dedication throughout this process. We're also so grateful to our council member, Richie Floyd, for his continued support. Of course, none of this would be possible without the residents and community members who have helped shape this plan. A neighborhood plan is bigger than any one neighborhood association. As we know, St. Pete is a city of neighborhoods, and so this neighborhood plan, we believe, belongs to the entire community. Our plan reflects several priorities identified by residents. First, accessible green space. Our neighborhood currently has no public parks within its boundaries. Establishing one remains a major priority, alongside expanding our tree canopy, neighborhood beautification, and public arts projects. Secondly, safer streets and better connectivity. That means traffic calming, completing our sidewalk network, improving access to public transportation, and supporting bicycle and micromobility options. Thirdly, thoughtful neighborhood-scale development. We envision more neighborhood-serving businesses, walkable destinations, and housing options that complement our community and that serve everyone. These priorities reflect a shared vision for a safer, greener, more connected, and more vibrant St. Pete Heights. We understand that this may be the first neighborhood plan developed entirely in-house by city staff, and we really hope that this experience benefits future planning efforts. We respectfully urge council to accept the plan. Finally, while reaching this milestone is something to celebrate, acceptance of the neighborhood plan is really just the beginning, as you know. We look forward to working with our neighbors and the city to turn this shared vision into meaningful improvements for our community. Thank you so much for your consideration today, and you are also all welcome to attend our neighborhood plan celebration on December 17th at the Linking Heights Neighborhood Pub at 6.30 p.m. Thank you. Thank you. Any more speakers? No more speakers, Madam Chair. Okay. How about Chair Floyd? Thanks. I just pushed my button to say congratulations. It's been a long, sometimes arduous process to get to this point. I remember going to meetings about this neighborhood plan years ago, so I'm glad to see it come to fruition, and I hope to be able to work with the neighborhood to get that green space that is pretty desperately needed, in my opinion, and I can't wait to see what the neighborhood accomplishes in the future. Thanks, Chair. Thank you. Council Member Driscoll. Thank you, and thank you, Kaylee, for the presentation and for shepherding the neighborhood association through this process. I know it's not easy, and, you know, my understanding is that once you got involved, it started to move forward with greater efficiency, and I so appreciate that. Brian and the residents of St. Pete Heights, I have been able to watch this as something of a spectator because it's not in my district, but because of working with Brian, I've been able to see how much work was put into this and how much care was put into the plan and the neighborhood. It is exactly why we need neighborhood plans and exactly why we should be looking for ways to do more of them. The level of engagement that grew along the way is exactly what you want from active neighborhoods. to think that this group just decided they took nothing. Like, there was no neighborhood association, and they built something from the ground up is something to be celebrated and admired and going forward along with implementing the plan and making sure that those projects happen. And trust me, there are ways to find money. Do not worry. And you all are so determined that I know you're going to make it happen whatever you want. But I hope that along with implementing the plan, you will serve as an example and pay it forward. You know, find other neighborhood associations that want to start this process, aren't sure where to start, want to reinvigorate their neighborhood association and aren't sure where to start. You have this wonderful experience and knowledge now, and I hope that you'll share it so that more neighborhoods in St. Petersburg can benefit from your hard work and your relentless optimism in making a better neighborhood in St. Pete. Thank you. Thank you. Well, first of all, thank you for the plan. I have to say you did a great job, Kaylee. As you know, I met Brian back when he was president of the neighborhood because I was president of Crescent Lake back in the day, and I know how important the neighborhood plans are. And I believe back in the 1980s, we were able to get a lot of plans done, and I think there was federal money that came in. And so there were a lot of plans that were done in the city a long time ago, and it's a very expensive process. And there was a while where we couldn't get any plans done for neighborhoods. And you all in-house figured out a way to try to get these plans done, which is a feat upon itself. So you've done a fantastic job to do this, so I want to congratulate you on that because I know it's not easy, and it does take a lot of work. I mean, from what I understand, a cost of one of these plans outside of, like, doing it in-house is in the hundreds of thousands of dollars. That's correct. Right. And we are a city of neighborhoods, so it's not just one neighborhood that wants a plan. It's a lot of neighborhoods that want a plan. So the fact that you were able to kind of find a way to do it in-house and save that money that we did not have says a lot for your group, and so I'm very thankful for that. And I'm thankful to the neighborhood for actually being there and pushing it because it doesn't just take one person. It takes a lot of people in the neighborhood to be part of this and to give input. And so to actually get those neighbors together, sometimes it's not that easy. So that you did that through the years says a lot about the work. So I'm very excited about approving this and the one that, you know, the first one, I think, right? And so the first one that we've seen in a long time that has been done in-house, so I'm thankful for that. And in terms of the grants, we can find money somewhere, but we may have issues here in the city of St. Petersburg with our own money. It doesn't mean we may not find money somewhere else, but we may have some issues here. I just want to make sure because that is a conversation I'm not going to pretend not to have and start having after Amendment 3. It's going to start next year for real when we start looking at the budget. And that's part of the conversation I'm not just having here in the city, here in council chambers, but with my neighborhoods. And I am having serious conversations because I want people to understand what's coming. I don't want it to be a shock. So that's part of the reason, but it doesn't take away from my congratulations. So with that being said, a motion? We have a motion and a second. Clerk, if you can open the machine for voting. Council members, please enter your votes. Seeing that all present council members have voted, Clerk, please tally announce the vote. Chair, motion to approve. Agenda F-3 passes unanimously with Council Member Fick-Sanders, Gabbard, and Gurdis being absent. Thank you. And thank you very much. Okay. Next up, we have ordinances, and I will ask, we're at 2.40. If any council members need a break, I could do it now. I could do it after the ordinances and take a little break. So just let me know. Well, I just want to make sure. Okay. E1. Opposed ordinance number 656H, an ordinance of the City of St. Petersburg renewing the ad valorem property taxes exemption created by ordinance number 561H until December 31st, 2030, amending the city code by deleting Chapter 28, Articles 1 and 2 in their entirety and replacing with a new Chapter 28, Article 1 and Article 2, providing definitions, authority, and applicability, providing process for applications, determinations, and appeals, providing penalties, and providing an effective date. The public hearing for this item is on December 3rd, 2026, and we have no cards, Madam Chair. Move approval. Second. We have a motion and a second. Clerk, if you can open the machine for voting. Council members, seeing that all present council members have voted, clerk, please tell and I'll also vote. Madam Chair, motion to approve a joint of E1 passes unanimously. Council members Vic Sanders, Gabbard, and Gerdes being absent. Thank you. Next up, thank you. We have E2. Madam Chair, there are two ordinances associated with E2. Do you want me to read them both? Yes, please. Thank you. Proposed ordinance number 657H, an ordinance of the City of St. Petersburg, Florida, creating a registry of qualified contractors for reapplication, and consultation services in accordance with state law, I'm sorry, admitting city code section 16.70.010.1 to add the option to use qualified contractors for required reapplication conferences, providing for servability and providing an effective date. The public hearing is scheduled for December 3rd, 2026. Proposed ordinance number 658H, an ordinance of the City of St. Petersburg, amending chapter 16 land development regulations to make changes and updates to regulations based on new state laws related to compatibility, manufacture homes, glazing requirements, chickies, synthetic turf, shopping cart retention, and platting. Excuse me, making clarifying changes to sections related to hexagon block sidewalks, forges, garages, carports, and submissions of applications, revising height requirements and setbacks in special flood hazard zone areas, revising requirements for commission membership, amending third party historic designation application requirements, providing for a neighborhood sign program, providing definitions, correcting typographical errors, amending chapter 8 of the City Code to make concurrent changes related to hexagon block sidewalks, providing for servability and providing an effective date. And December 3rd, 2026, is the public hearing for this item as well and that was done in one breath. You have what? That was done in one breath. You can breathe now. You did a good job. No cards? Okay. Derek, I have questions and I think other council members do. I'll start off because as you know, in open forum, we had some commentary on this item and we also had lots of emails that we received. Specifically, I mean, there are lots of things in this item, but specifically on the membership of the CPPC and DRC that would be members of board member or director of a neighborhood association would not be able to serve on either one of those. So starting off, could you please just state the reasoning for this, where this came out? I know we haven't had discussion about this in any city council committees or anything like that. and so the first time I saw it was here. So if you can give us background, please. Yes, of course. Thank you for the opportunity to do that. Derek Kilbourne, director for the city's planning department. And for anybody who's following the package, specifically, the question relates to section 31 and section 32 of the ordinance. And very simply, what it states is that if you are serving as a member of the Development Review Commission or the Community Planning and Preservation Commission that you would not hold a position, an official position on a board for the related neighborhood association. Okay, now going back to give you a little context in history where this came from. Historically, when commissioners were being onboarded to one of those two commissions, DRC or CPPC, they were advised to withdraw their positions in these neighborhood associations, business associations, or other groups or organizations that routinely bring business in front of those two commissions. And the purpose for doing that was to minimize conflicts that could be raised either in the public hearing itself or afterwards if there was litigation and certain things were being challenged. So over the many years there was this mutual understanding and it worked. In the last year and a half we have onboarded several commissioners to the CPPC that were already in officer positions with their neighborhood associations. So for a period of time we were using Grace to just kind of work through those situations. In the fall of this year, so in September and October we know that there were some issues happening in one of the neighborhood associations and the city started to receive correspondence raising concerns and questions about individuals who serve on neighborhood association boards and also serve as members on one of these commissions. And so when we received a written correspondence in our department also at City Hall we were about a week out from posting the development review commission package that you are seeing now. So what we did is we could see that that was a growing issue so we put it into the DRC package to elevate it up for everyone's consideration and discussion to decide should this be a formal prohibition by putting it into the ordinance or is there something else or other direction that the council would want to provide. So that is the purpose for why it is in here now and because everything was happening quickly for example we received that letter on October 23rd we had to post the DRC report by October 28th the DRC meeting was November 4th and two days later we had to have this package in for the first reading. One of the things that we were intending to add to mirror the past policy was business associations and other organizations that routinely bring business in front of those two commissions and we were intending to do that for the final public hearing package so that you would have all that language in there. But that's the history of why we were bringing it forward now under these conditions and circumstances. Okay. Which is understandable why we are getting all the emails on this now obviously because there hasn't been a discussion on this. Before I get into some of the mechanics of this specific issue I want to ask legal when it comes to any board members serving whether it's CPPC DRC whether it's city council there are certain ethical rules there are certain voting conflicts that have to be disclosed so on and so forth so tell me specifically doesn't that apply to them anybody who works on DRC or in CPPC and that's true we do give conflict training to both DRC and CPPC commissioners when they're on boarded both what applies under Florida law and what applies under the city rules governed by council resolution for all qualified boards which city council DRC and CPPC are all included along with the code enforcement board I will say to Derek's point we hadn't really this hadn't been an issue because we explained that there could be a situation where you would have to recuse yourself more and so people usually voluntarily remove that possibility also so we explained how they can do that and I think that another thing that's important that there's more the most noticeable conflict is generally a financial conflict and that's not something you have here with volunteer boards it's more of when you get into the realm of appearance of conflict and that actually goes up by the way our LDRs are written because so many of our applications require applicants to go to the neighborhood and provide notice to neighborhood associations and Kona and solicit their input so we do get formalized letters from neighborhoods very often in our applications so let's say that there is someone in any board that is a little lax on the appearance of impropriety issue okay if I served on a board even though I'm not paid on that board and I think that there could be an issue I would recuse myself plain and simple I may not legally need to do it but I would do it not necessarily when you have volunteers that serve on these boards they may not take it as seriously but it is important for us because obviously legal repercussions happen right if you have issues with a board member so why as opposed to tackling it and just not appointing that person again because that seems to be a much more direct way of handling it than putting it in an ordinance because the reality is we get they get appointed they get appointed by a term for a term or whatever there could be rules about that whatever and you can deal with those issues and then they don't have to get reappointed we have to confirm those appointments it would seem to me that these type of things could be dealt with in that framework as opposed to putting something in an ordinance and now basically bars anyone that is a board member or director in any neighborhood association which they're not paid positions or anything like that and just like any other you know I think it was discussed by some of the speakers here I mean there could be a bias perceived in a variety of people that serve on these boards because it's a small community and so there are always going to be people that somehow are connected one way or the other to something and so I would just figure isn't that much more narrow approach to dealing with the issue as opposed to putting something in an ordinance as broad and basically takes a whole set of people out of running for something and by the way people that bring a level of experience yes I just want to clarify it doesn't prevent the application it's just preventing concurrent service so we still would be taking applications from people it's just no I understand that during their term I understand that okay I just didn't want to say that those people weren't welcome to apply after this that's not the intention oh I get it I just don't see why we have to do it in an ordinance rather that it's done at the level where it can be done without the need for an ordinance and just barring a whole group of people just because they're part of a neighborhood association this is you're correct madam chair this is just one way to do it it could also be addition like I said we have our conflicts with dealing with members between other boards and that's also where you get the city specific conflict of you have to sit out if you're within a thousand feet it could be added to a revised version of that resolution or some form of that and it could also just be something that is put in application materials for appointment but that would be something on administration's side with how the next administration does their appointment right I mean there are lots of ways that this could be tackled I just don't see the need that it needs to be put in an ordinance in the way that it is and then apply to a much broader set of people when not necessary so that's just my initial thoughts on it but this is first reading so I want to hear from other council members council member Givens thank you chair and I'm glad I'm going after you because those are my sentiments exactly first of all I acknowledge all the hard work that went into this but I still ask the same question could we have gotten here a different way why the form of an ordinance we recuse ourselves I feel like neighborhood leaders could do the same thing plus I feel like it could appear to give an advantage to developers so just my personal position and also what I have heard resoundingly from constituents is that this to me silences neighborhood leaders and I feel like neighborhood leaders know best what their neighbors want and need so I don't want to do anything that appears that we're giving neighborhood leaders an unfair role in this and so again I just want us to be careful with how we bring this forward because I always always want to act on behalf of and in the best interest of our constituents and never give them the appearance that we are trying to remove them from the process thank you chair thank you council member I mean by chair floyd thanks Derek you mentioned this impacting a number of commissioners do you know exactly what that number is three okay all right but I know of three that I know of three that you know of and this is between cppc and drc cppc just cppc okay and then I guess you know just to touch on a couple of things that have already come up talking about doing it by ordinance versus council members using that information to themselves I mean I do understand why you would want to codify something because we feel if we felt like it was the appropriate thing to do then we could set the standard and then you know people people previously or later on have to follow it so I understand why it got brought forward this way so I guess you know to be frank like I've been receiving correspondence about this about one commissioner in particular and I don't make rules for one person that just doesn't seem quite right to me having said that I would say that I think the requests that we avoid any sort of appearance of impropriety or anything like that or conflict I think it's a reasonable request like and so I would just zoom out a little bit and say you mentioned give me just one second to gather my thoughts I don't really see you mentioned there being like a convention that people recuse themselves but is it possible that we just codify that instead like if you serve on a board of a neighborhood and something comes up that impacts that neighborhood then we could do the recusal I assume this is a legal question yeah so we were thinking about that as well but then when you use there was some I saw in some of the emails that there was some suggested language but when you're talking about in code what is really affecting a neighborhood and even some of our large rezoning packages for some of the ones about like CHAA that's going to disproportionately affect some neighborhoods way more than some of our interior neighborhoods so your neighborhood associations in the coastal high hazard area would be disproportionately affected so are they all now recusing themselves so there is a difficult balance there and that if we're not going to codify just saying that we're not going to do it I would recommend that it's cleaner to just leave it alone instead of trying to peace out and then let the normal conflict training and rules with ethics and those discussions that we do have already just keep going in place because trying to codify that I think might actually create more problems and be really hard to draft something that wasn't too overbroad I think okay that makes sense that makes sense but then I am brought to the point of like you know the appearance of conflict I think this is a very good conversation to have and you know if you know presented with like a platter of things like leave it how it is uh prevent concurrent service uh some secret third thing like uh I would love there might be a secret yeah I don't know yeah uh because we haven't been able to have this discussion I mean if it's just leave it how it is or put this in there like I honestly like even despite what I've said like I'm interested in putting it in there but I do think that this is a broader conversation than what we're having today I heard why it was going on like this but I do struggle to make a change like this sort of on the fly like and so say we don't do it in LDR there's a resolution that describes this as well maybe we revisit that or something like yes that's another option too and again with a package this large this is generally like Derek said this had been kind of a general understanding so when we do LDR cleanups and there's any kind of like I guess unclarity but I don't think that's a word sorry I'm I'm working with 80 right now but generally we use this package to clean up but I we don't expect that we're gonna we never get through one of these with this many pages where there isn't one thing that comes up that so it would be totally okay to take these out and then refer it for a discussion at a later date this isn't time sensitive like some of the other things in the package so if at public hearing you wanted to move the package without these sections that's why they are divided out in their own section so they can be severed out cleanly and then we can go back and revisit that another day in a discussion on the other options and that's also something that council can choose to do yeah that would my preference would be uh because this issue is one we haven't been able to have a committee meeting on or anything like that uh my preference would be for us to uh just separate this specific piece of it and have that conversation uh in more depth together with uh less time pressure um because I think it's a worthwhile conversation to have and I understand where it's coming from uh but you know I this is this is our my first conversation with y'all about it so uh that's what I would say I don't know what we need to do today I know this is just first reading so we could have that discussion again at the next one but that's what I think we should do okay thank you thank you Councilmember Harding thank you chair I uh appreciate the work you've done I appreciate Councilmember Floyd's comments he pretty much covered what I was uh was thinking the the the the kind of the genesis of this it it did we have did we have too many of our commissioners who were continually recusing themselves um or or which way did we go did we have problems with forum or did we have problems with with folks understanding how that they need to or in in recent times I can tell you no but I don't know what the original genesis for this practice was because this goes back a very long time even to preceding commissions that were the environmental development commission planning and visioning commission and the historic preservation commission so there's a very long timeline in history on this policy but um in current you know the last few years and the timeline that we've been following with the last year and a half that has not generally been a problem but clearly there was something happening this fall that raised this issue and and we felt it was uh visible enough to merit some clarification through this process understood okay I I thank you for that um I would uh I would side with with vice chair Floyd that uh that I think this is a topic that that merits further discussion um and I would uh I would I would be in favor of bringing this back for discussion we carve it a carve it out of this package and uh and keep it going thank you thank you councilmember driscoll thank you thank you for the um the insight on that I think we're all waiting to hear more it really after giving it a lot of thought it just feels like we're singling out um neighborhood leaders and I want I want more opportunities for them not fewer and I know as a past way in the past neighborhood president myself um if I had stayed with that instead of running for office I would have wanted more opportunities and we spend time telling people there are so many ways to serve the city without having to run a campaign and get on a ballot I want this to continue to continue to be an option the singling out comes from me thinking about the other types of um commissioners who serve on cvpc drc and every type you can think of a scenario where they would have a conflict of interest so why wouldn't we exclude architects why wouldn't we exclude engineers why wouldn't we exclude someone who happens to be a member of preserve the berg it is a question i'm making sure you're done um well we actually have in the past asked a commissioner on cvpc before I was part of the board to and before it was preserve the berg to step down from their leadership role in order to serve at cvpc because preserve the berg is involved in pretty much all of our preservation applications with the city so there is precedent for that and that's mr michaels if you weren't sure it was mr michaels but I know there was some question about favoring with the architects engineers with the language that's already in code and that language is actually carried down from requirements these boards serve as your technical experience boards so they're required if we can fill these positions to have these folks on there so that's why they're in there we do need to have them to maintain our technical qualifications on those boards but again this wasn't trying to exclude anybody but we appreciate the feedback and obviously with drafting we will that any consideration going forward council thank you well as we've seen with um with boards that have just been created haven't even been filled out yet we've shown that we also value lived experience and just because someone doesn't have technical expertise in an area doesn't mean that their point of view and the way that they approach something you know a case um is not valid i i think it's important to hear the neighborhood perspective on things because they're the ones on the ground they're the ones um there every day and we're seeing um more engagement now with our neighborhood associations they've gotten strong and that's because of people who um really see what the potential is there i don't want to miss that when decisions are being made about our growth about changes to our codes and things like that i see them as a very valuable part of the process and in my opinion the best way to address any concerns would be to look at the training and the education around conflicts of interest and see how do we make that benefit everybody more so that's what i would be in favor of and i i do hope that um you can find plenty of examples where having that neighborhood leader um on the commission was actually a benefit thanks thank you so look and like my sheriff i understand why this is here and so i'm not faulting you and the reality is this came for us to us without any information so i completely understand i will say whoever serves on a commission on cppc or drc that's causing a discussion at city council about an issue that's not where you want to be period we're going to have a discussion at some point which council members want and frankly the reality of what that conversation is and bringing up people's names and things that happen and all that is not something that you want to go through i'll be honest with you i understand the need for the conversation this is not a pretty one and so you know any organization if you serve on the board of any organization and you are your your ethics or there is an appearance of impropriety if that's getting called it's a problem and you would figure that people take the initiative to do to say the right thing at the meeting make sure things are clear active appropriate way because you definitely it hurts the organization if those lines are blurred right but the blanket the blanket no neighborhood organizations i just that's a no-go for me i just don't see it's necessary because i think there are lots of tools in the toolbox that can take care of these issues without having to go this far um and somehow we've i know commissioner michaels has been on the board a variety of times for many many years and it's somehow worked uh so they're so they do bring a lot of experience and look i know that neighborhood associations get spicy just like city council cppc and drc right and sometimes you know there may be an issue that comes before them and they happen to be involved with the neighborhood and you know that goes sideways somehow but i i i think everyone involved needs to take a breath and think about the repercussions of what we're talking about and then figure out the right way so we don't have a rule that brings in people that don't need to be encompassed in this and would be great people serving on our boards bringing lots of good experience so that's what i'm going to say about this it sounds like you have five which is the majority of city council that really doesn't like that statement there so i don't know if somebody wants to say because here's the thing if this comes back next week then everyone's going to come back again and so if we just take that out and then somebody wants to bring in a new business site and we could do that but i wouldn't want to drag a bunch of people here for next week so we can remove that language these these two um from section 31 and 32 subsection c for the package uh next time around if somebody has a motion because i can't make a motion council member driscoll oh yeah sorry no i was just gonna oh you're trying to name no you're trying to find it because i went i went somewhere else and then i couldn't get back to it 27 here yes if i may if we're going to motions um i know these were presented as a and b because they're a unified staff report but unlike our map amendments they can't be voted on and especially since it looks like we're going to be fiddling with the second one a little bit if we could take a vote on the first ordinance separate it doing the registry first yeah we'll do that thank you okay there is a motion to approve e2a second we have a motion second on e2a clerk if you can open the machine for voting council members please enter your votes and seeing that all present council members have voted clerk please tally announce the vote madam chair motion to approve agenda e2a passes unanimously with council members fix sanders gabbard and gardeners being absent thank you and then we have e2b um council member driscoll yes i'm uh move approval of item e2b with the striking of section 31c and 32c it's just section 31 and section 32 of the ordinance oh the whole thing okay sections yeah the sections of the ordinance themselves okay they're in the code they were going to be new subsection c's but it's just section 31 and 32 of the ordinance itself okay so i'll move approval of item e2b um with the striking of sections 31 and 32. okay did i do right yep is that right that right everybody's the attorneys are agreement so we must be good i know so we have a motion and a second clerk if you can open the machine for voting council members please enter your votes seeing that all present council members have voted clerk please tally and ask the vote madam chair motion to approve a giant e2b with the striking of sections 31 and 32 passes unanimously with council members fix sanders gabbard and girders being absent thank you thank you very much okay we move to e3 heather in ordinance excuse me pause ordinance 659h in ordinance of the city of st petersburg amending section 11-53 subsection 1 of the city code related to loud and ruckus noise emitted from motor vehicles in the travel portion of a right-of-way providing for separability and providing an effective date the public hearing for this item is also on december 3rd 2026 and we do not have any cars thank you and this is an item it came to my attention uh constitution brought up an issue i looked up our ordinance it didn't match the state statute and it's supposed to match the state statute it's just a cleanup heather yes yes that's correct motion a second clerk if you can open the machine for voting council members please enter your votes seeing that all present council members have voted clerk please tally announce to vote madam chair motion to approve a giant of e3 passes unanimously councilman ruffick sanders gabbard and girders being absent thank you next up we have e4 clerk excuse me proposed ordinance number 660h in ordinance in accordance with section 1.02 subsection c subsection 3 st petersburg city charter authorizing the grant of a public utility easement to duke energy florida llc a florida limited liability company dba duke energy within city owned williams park located at 332nd avenue north st petersburg florida authorizing the mayor or his designee to execute all documents necessary to effectuate this ordinance and provide an effective date the public hearing for this item is also on december 3rd 26th and we do not have any speakers thank you we have approval second i have a motion a second clerk if you can open the machine council members please enter your votes seeing that all present council members have voted clerk please tally announce the vote madam chair motion to approve agenda e4 passes unanimously with council member vick sanders gabbard and girders being absent thank you aaron next up we have e5 clerk opposed ordinance number 661h in ordinance concerning the procedural requirements for a council member to take oath including the oath of office taken by council members as well as other city officials and members of city boards and commissions making findings regarding the need to clarify those procedural requirements admitting city code chapter 2 to clarify those procedural requirements and providing an effective date and the public hearing for this item is also on december 3rd 2026 and we do not have any speakers madam chair move approval second we have a motion and a second clerk if you can open the machine for voting council members please enter your votes seeing that all present council members have now voted clerk please tally announce the vote madam chair motion to approve agenda e5 passes unanimously with council member vick sanders gabbard girders being absent thank you thank you brett next up we have i1 this is a legal item heather this is your item this is this is the last thing i swear then you could go home and rest okay so this is a request for a request for an approval of a second amendment to a settlement agreement between westminster shores which is a property located on the south side and bahama shores neighborhood on the north side and the city it was from 2008 it originally occurred from our main switch to the ldrs that we had in 2007 2008 when this redevelopment was first being planned and there was some disagreement of whether the old code would apply or the newer code would apply which resulted in a lawsuit and this settlement agreement was formed the settlement agreement has been amended one time in 2018 and that addressed requested changes in the site plan which is exactly what's being proposed here in the same process is that the applicant westminster shores would like to amend their site plan and to be able to do that they have requested an amendment to this settlement agreement if this passes council today then the application will go forward to drc if drc does not approve the site plan modification then the site plan will just revert to what was in place at the first amendment okay i'll entertain the motion of everything anybody wants to make move to approval i can have a motion second clerk if you can open the machine for voting council members please enter your votes seeing that all present council members have voted clerk please tally announce the vote madam chair motion to approve adjournment i1 passes unanimously with council members fick sanders gabbard girders being absent thank you um next up we have reports for continual reports but here's the thing obviously other council members can hold off going to the bathroom longer than i can and i this point have to take it so thank you chair i thought somebody was going to take it up at some point with that being said we're going to take a 10 minute we'll get back at 3 30. um meeting is at this point in recess one two three four five report items a cra item another report item and a couple of other quick items and then public hearings at 501 our vice chair needs to leave we have to start that public hearing at 501 our vice chair has a flight today it was supposed to be tomorrow and unfortunately got rescheduled tonight and we don't want to miss he didn't want to miss the flight and we don't want to miss it you don't i mean we don't want you to miss a flight so i just want to make sure i put that out there so efficiency is key because we only have five people here and if he has to leave we have no quorum okay with that being said um we move on to f2 aubrey good afternoon good afternoon uh chair and council members aubrey phillips director of strategic initiatives and grants pleased to be with you this afternoon to provide an overview of the city's grants activities during fiscal year 2026 we can oh i have the clicker all right so during fy26 council city council accepted 29 grant awards totaling approximately 172.5 million dollars federal funding accounted for the overwhelming majority of this at 21 awards for 168 million dollars this unusually high federal total is primarily attributed to the 159.9 million dollar community development block grant for disaster recovery initial allocation and while that single award significantly affects the overall total the portfolio is still reflects a diverse mix of investments across different city priorities and services this slide compares the number and value of awards accepted during each quarter over the last four fiscal years as you can see the amount accepted in fy26 was highly concentrated in that second quarter because that was when the disaster recovery allocation was brought forward to city council for acceptance this really illustrates that the number of awards alone doesn't tell the full story a relatively small number of major awards can materially change the amount of funding we have coming into the city from grants here we see a historical trend since fiscal year 2015 where we have seen a growth in our grant grant revenues received as we've discussed previously at bf and t the budget finance and taxation committee grant availability is inherently dynamic funding levels are affected by federal and state priorities disaster appropriations legislative decisions program cycles and the competitiveness of the individual applications we put forward the key takeaway here is that we have to maintain both a ready pipeline of projects and the capacity to respond when significant opportunities become available to really leverage the funding that's available in addition to the awards that came forward to city council for acceptance in fiscal year 26 we also received notice of another 15 awards totaling 19.9 million dollars that are still working through the grant agreement process and are anticipated to come forward to for city council acceptance in the future one of these 15 is the fy25 community project funding for the police public safety vehicles that was accepted by city council november 5th this these agreements will come forward moving forward and then to give you a picture on our grants efforts citywide so the grant activity extends well beyond the awards that ultimately come forward to council during fiscal year 26 the grants working group reviewed 62 different grant opportunities that had advanced through departmental and staff review as of the end of the fiscal year 31 of these were pending a decision from the grantor eight applications remained in progress nine had been awarded and 13 were not awarded one of these we did not pursue because of the timing and strategy didn't ultimately align with the city's goals that grants working group really provides a coordinated city-wide review of grant opportunities that includes finance budgeting and marketing representatives and it really helps us to confirm strategic alignment make sure we're coordinating across departments that we are able to make and maintain all of our commitments to matching costs and things before we pursue a grant opportunity just want to note here these 62 that came to the grants working group are just a sliver of the pie of what departments and our team in the central grants department looks at in terms of evaluating opportunities and then we wanted to flag for council a few changes to federal policy and what we're seeing in particularly the federal grant landscape and how we're making sure that the city is ready to respond so the federal grant environment as you all are aware is continuing to change these changes are affecting both how we compete for funding and how we manage awards first there are proposed changes to the federal uniform guidance that are going to bring expected to bring additional documentation oversight and executive order requirements for new and renewed grant awards moving forward there's also the 21st century road to housing act that will be being implemented moving forward that we're watching for how that impacts uh the flexibility of some of our recurring funding from hud third we're seeing that application windows for federal opportunities are getting shorter uh opportunities that historically had a 90 day time period from the notice of funding opportunity being issued to the application being due are now coming down to 60 days some have even been as short as 43 days um so that is really making uh meaning that the city has to position itself to be ready to apply for a grant before that notice of funding opportunity comes out so locally this has meant these changes have all meant greater administrative demands for managing grants more uncertainty during project delivery less time to develop competitive applications after a notice of funding of opportunity is released our response to this has been we're preparing earlier so we're working on an ongoing basis with departments about what projects may be grant ready and may be wanting to seek grant funding so that we're ready before the opportunities come out we've also been strengthening compliance procedures working collaboratively with departments to strengthen our capacity for grant administration and grant compliance and advancing grant management tools that are supporting compliance monitoring and reporting to make sure that those dollars that we've been awarded and that city council accepted ultimately do come back to the city and help offset the cost that we've incurred finally we're developing our project pipeline and looking at opportunities based not only on funding availability but also on project readiness strategic fit and risk the central takeaway here is that our future success in both securing and managing grants is increasingly dependent on action we're taking before grant opportunity comes forward to make sure that we're ready to take advantage of those opportunities that become available and that we're able to effectively manage the grants that the city receives so finally in summary fy26 was an exceptional year with the first allocation of disaster recovery funds coming forward it's also really emphasized the importance of coordinated planning project readiness and sound grant administration i express my appreciation to council for your support of the grants that we've pursued and to all of the departments who are integral partners in pursuing all these grant opportunities thank you um thank you for your report typically we have this mbfnt it was moved here um because of changes to schedule aubrey great job i know that the sunrise saint pete is a lot of work um but i want to i guess highlight the fact that the large amount this time around is because it's driven by that that's not the standard that's the anomaly correct and the standard is going to be much lower and going back to whatever levels we had before or less okay okay that's the takeaway thank you you have next item f6 so again aubrey phillips director of strategic initiatives and grants so for this item this is two agreements uh between the u.s department of housing and urban development pinellas county and the city of st petersburg related to the reallocation of community development block grant disaster recovery funds these agreements address a federal geocoding error that caused funds that were intended for the city to be included in pinellas county's original allocation today we're asking council to approve agreements and the related appropriation so that the correction to this misallocation can move forward the resolution before council has three primary components first it approves the three-party agreement among hud pinellas county and the city this agreement establishes the structure for connect correcting the allocation of approximately 173.7 million dollars in community development block grant disaster recovery funds second it approves a separate coordination agreement between the county and the city that agreement establishes how the parties will coordinate the use and oversight of these funds and finally the resolution authorizes the execution of both agreements and appropriates 126 million to the city's community development block grant for disaster recovery fund these agreements establish the framework for the reallocation importantly they do not by themselves approve specific changes to any individual city disaster recovery programs those changes will proceed through the required action plan amendment and public participation processes which we'll touch on in just a moment so the central issue here that these agreements are addressing is an allocation error when hud calculated the original community development block grant for disaster recovery allocations approximately 173.681 million associated with unmet needs in the city of st petersburg was included in pinellas county's award because of a geocoding error correcting that error requires a formal agreement among all three parties hud pinellas county and the city we've coordinated with hud and the county and have brought forward these agreements council approval however is needed to authorize the city to enter into that agreement and execute the companion coordination agreement that that that the three-party agreement specifies and that agreement is with the county and then accept and appropriate the funds transferred to the city the practical result here is that the award structure will better align the funding with the jurisdictions responsible for administrative recovery programs so for st petersburg this these agreements put the city in the position to direct an additional 126 million dollars towards housing recovery subject of course to federal requirements and hud's approval of our amended action plan the total amount of funds affected by the allocation was approximately 173.7 million under the proposed framework 126 million of that will be transferred to the city for eligible housing recovery activities again subject to federal requirements and hud approval the city has discretion in how these funds will be distributed among our disaster recovery programs the remaining 47.7 million would stay with pinellas county for eligible infrastructures that provide a shared benefit to both city and county residents and are mutually agreed upon by both the city and the county the important distinction here between these two funding components is that the city has direct discretion and administration over the 126 million and the city and county must mutually approve the projects and scopes that will be supported by the 47.7 million that's retained by the county the structure is allowing the city to direct additional funds to housing based on local recovery needs while preserving a collaborative process for projects that benefit both jurisdictions so what these two agreements establish each serves a different purpose the first the hud county city agreement or the three-party agreement three-party agreement provides the framework for the reallocation it transfers 126 million to the city retains 47.7 million for the county for the shared benefit infrastructure projects and it anticipates federal register changes that importantly will add milton as a qualifying disaster for the city unlike our original allocation which only allowed idalia and helene as qualifying disasters the three-party agreement will become effective once it's signed by hud the county and the city the county is due to consider this agreement just in december the second document the county city coordination agreement establishes how the city and county will work together after the reallocation it confirms the city's discretion over the transferred housing funds requires mutual approval of shared infrastructure projects and clarifies that each party remains responsible for compliance associated with the funds it administers together these agreements provide both the authority for the reallocation and the operating framework for how we will coordinate and oversee these funds so council approval is an important and critical step but it is not the final step before we can see these funds coming into our community to help folks recover if council adopts the resolution the agreements must next be signed by all three parties the city will then prepare and publish an amended cdbgdr community development block grant for disaster recovery action plan for a 30-day public comment period required by federal regulations that process will explain the proposed program and funding changes and provide residents and stakeholders with an opportunity to comment on that draft plan after considering public input will amend that will submit the amended action plan to hud hud will then have 45 days to conduct their review and approve or respond to our draft plan implementation can ultimately begin after hud approves the amended action plan and other federal requirements are satisfied this sequence makes sure that we follow all of those federal regulations before those new allocated funding is committed to specific program changes so administration is recommending adoption of the resolution before city council the resolution would approve the hud's county city agreement it would also approve the county city coordination agreement it would authorize the city attorney's office to approve non-substantive changes authorize the mayor or the mayor's designee to execute the agreements and related documents and appropriate the 126 million to the cdbgdr fund 1118 approval will allow the city to proceed with execution of the agreements the public action plan amendment process and ultimately submitting for hud review and approval before rolling out these additional funds to help support our community's recovery in summary the proposed agreements correct the structure of the original federal awards provide the city with the authority over 126 million for housing recovery and establish a coordinated approach with pinellas county for the remaining shared benefit funding for infrastructure projects we're happy to answer any questions thank you vice chair floyd thanks i just put myself on here to say uh i'm happy to see that this is going through but one thing that means a lot to me is the inclusion of people who received damage during hurricane milton uh really never made much sense that we weren't going to be able to support people uh it was very devastating all across our community and i'm glad to see it here and i can't wait to uh continue the work to get this money out to everyone thanks thank you great job aubrey breaking down the main agreements uh in a very convoluted set of terms that had to happen typically it's hard for anybody to get money back from someone that gets it that they're not supposed to get it so the fact that we got this all done is says something to everyone that was involved i'm sure they're people's hearts were they were they were i'm sure nervous at points in time to make sure this was all got done but it seems like everyone did the right thing and the money landed where it's supposed to be and also great job on the administration recommendation you broke it down really nicely so thank you move approval of item six second i have a motion and a second clerk if you can open the machine for voting council members please enter your votes and that all council members have voted clerk please tally announce the vote madam madam chair motion to approve a john f6 passes unanimously with council member fix sanders gabbard and girders being absent thank you next up f7 hi hello good afternoon council jess riddell special projects manager for housing and neighborhood services administration here to discuss the mental health rfa award recommendations under the sunrise st pete non-profit community support services program so our agenda for today just a brief overview of cdbgdr the program itself what our rfa included and then the review committee recommendations for your approval so community development block grant disaster recovery funds are appropriated by congress through hud in response to disasters the city received funds for idalia and helene and as you just heard from aubrey funding for milton is forthcoming we conducted our initial unmet needs analysis and received public input which drove what programs we built into our action plan that action plan was approved by city council in june 2025 approved by hud in august 2025 and then we received our signed grant agreement from hud in february 2026. this slide just shows you the budget breakdown of each program as listed in our action plan as it currently stands today so this does not include any of the forthcoming budgetary reallocations based on what aubrey just shared that's that will come later so as of right now six million dollars is allocated to the non-profit community support services program the overall purpose of this program is to strengthen the community by helping non-profits offer the care and support people need after a disaster we heard from residents and non-profits during our public input processes that the storm significantly increased demand for services like mental health counseling trauma recovery support food security programs and housing stabilization programs so that's what we're aiming to address through this program there will be a series of funding opportunities issued each with a different focus area tied to these unmet needs and the first request for applications or rfa that we issued focuses on mental health services and wraparound support and that's the rfa that i'm here to talk to you about today this slide just shows you the eligibility criteria that organizations needed to meet in order to respond to the rfa they were required to be a registered non-profit established in the city and in operation for at least three years be in good standing with local state and federal governments and have prior experience conducting similar work the rfa outlines the scope of work as creating an interconnected ecosystem of care comprised of three core services case management as the center of the ecosystem where the clients enter and then assertive outreach and clinical mental health services as the other two core services the vision here is that you have these distinct services operated by agencies who have that specific expertise but conducted in a way where each core service coordinates and works together so you have clients coming in through case management receiving that hands-on support and connection to needed resources they're also able to enroll clients straight into the clinical mental health services they need through that partnership with that entity that agency and then you have the assertive outreach team making sure the community knows about resources and resources services and resources available providing that critical connection at the front door but also responding to neighborhoods after a disaster or a shooting or following up with clients that we've lost contact with so really having a role at the front middle and back end of service provision so while these are distinct core services they all work together to ensure clients receive the care that they need and i'll kind of dive into each from here so as i mentioned case management is the central point of this model this is where clients access the program services they can walk into an in-person location they can call they can inquire online the organization who administers this uh this core service conducts client intake including needs assessments and required verifications for each client they will assign a case manager who who provides that hands-on support meets each person where they are and helps them get where they need to go to meet their needs so the approach here looks like sitting with the person to help them call a resource and make an appointment or calling on behalf of that resident not just handing them an outdated list of of resources and saying good luck it's that feeling of i got you we'll figure this out together as i mentioned the case management organization will also be able to directly enroll clients into mental health services such as counseling or psychiatric evaluations and medication management if they are seeking those services they'll also be able to provide limited emergency assistance for housing costs such as rent or utility assistance in an emergency situation there is a very narrow scope allowed by hood but it is allowable um you know we've seen in other programs that you know sometimes you can't even attempt to address the mental health need or other support needs that someone has when they're about to lose their housing for example and so sometimes you need to address that immediate stabilization crisis first and then get into the rest of what they need from there this part does require additional verifications and duplication of benefits checks per cdbgdr rule so it is a more intensive process when providing this kind of like sub piece of the assistance and then finally the case management organization will be responsible for facilitating the overall partnership between themselves and the other organizations who are involved in this moving into assertive outreach this is the proactive method of meeting residents where they are in the community building that trust and rapport and community and connecting them to needed program program and community resources excuse me the organization who administers outreach for us will be doing outreach through a variety of activities such as canvassing or door knocking attending events partnering with other organizations even showing up to a neighborhood or on site somewhere after a significant event occurs like a violent crime or hurricane to provide that immediate presence and support and connection so this is a mechanism to let residents know about the services available and if the resident's interested and ready right then to make that connection to the case management team to do intake and assign a case manager but there are also times when outreach may be at someone's door sharing this information about the program but they also hear that hey there's a child in the home who needs something to do over the summer and they're like oh have you heard about the rec center down the street they have summer camp and here's some information so this approach goes back to what we just talked about on the case management slide where it's not about here's a flyer good luck it's having a conversation hearing what that immediate or urgent need is and helping connect people accordingly and onto the final core service clinical mental health services so as i mentioned residents will be able to through their case manager directly enroll into clinical mental health services through this program so that looks like having a pool of clinical providers available to residents who offer services like counseling psychiatric evaluations medication management other services all providers must be appropriately licensed supervised and credentialed according to florida law and in addition to individual client services they also there are instances where clinical support may be needed on site at the program office at community events directly after a significant event occurs in the community and so this agency will also facilitate having clinical providers present on site when needed moving into funding a total of 1.25 million dollars was available under this rfa this was the combined total for all three core services so you can see the award cap for each on the slide up to 725 000 for case management up to 175 000 for outreach and up to 350 000 for clinical mental health services applicants were able to apply for one or more of the core service types in the period of performance is one year this was the timeline generally applications opened july 27th they were due august 28th the committee met on september 21st and october 6th we had our 30-day required appeals period for cdbgdr and no appeals were received received 11 applications in total all of which met minimum eligibility criteria and this table here just shows the breakdown of which organizations applied for which core services and you can see some applied for one two or all three core services our review committee was made up of a cross-departmental team alissa elsner from neighborhood relations zee foolin from the police department kylie noonan from coast compliance assistance helen rhymes from housing community development and then myself the committee met on september 21st they recommended awards for the case management and assertive outreach core services in that meeting recommending the highest scored application in both of those categories which was perk for both the committee shortlisted the top two scores for clinical mental health services which were directions for living in gulf coast jfcs and just requested some additional information the committee reviewed that information came back on october 6 to deliberate and recommended that the clinical mental health services award go to gulf coast for next steps administration recommends approval of the committee's award recommendations for each core service as follows perk under one agreement will receive about 722 000 for administering case management and about seven 175 000 for assertive outreach gulf coast will receive 350 000 to administer clinical mental health services sub-recipient agreements will be fully executed upon council approval with an effective date of december 1st 2026 and run for one year and with that i'm happy to answer any questions thank you i have a question yeah um how did you come up with the award caps for each category case management 725 assertive outreach 175 and then yeah that's a good question so in our cdbgdr action plan the award for um each award under the mental health i'm sorry under the non-profit program is 1.25 million so we had that number to work with and then we kind of reverse engineered it based on the three core services looking at other programs the city operates and trying to make sure we're hitting certain um not ratios but that it's aligned with what the need would be but still having that maximum 1.25 cap to work with per our action plan okay i was just wondering it seems like case management is so much more than the mental health services part and yeah and there are so they're the central point right so every single client is coming in through them first receiving case management and for cdbgdr there is more of an administrative burden on the case management award because every client's coming in through there so identity verification income verification duplication of benefits verification that's not applicable to every single client coming in but if anyone gets that emergency housing assistance then those additional requirements apply and so we need to make sure that they have staff available at the capacity needed to do those way more intensive checks and paperwork than we're used to in other programs um councilmember gibbons thank you chair uh and thank you so much for this um i just wanted to press my button to just say that i'm happy to approve these award amounts um to your point as a case manager i know how much work goes into it um so i won't comment today um my ask and expectations for perk and gulf coast i know they're listening um but i do have high expectations um but i know that you all can deliver um because i've seen them do it before um on other things but i i do just want to press my button to say that i i just am happy to see these organizations be selected because i can speak personally to the work that they've done and i know the lives that they've impacted so i'm excited to vote for this so thank you chair move approval second voting council members please enter your votes seeing that all present council members have voted clerk please tally announce the vote madam chair motion to approve a giant f-6 passes unanimously with council members vick sanders gabbert girders being absent thank you thank you jess next up we have f4 mark height hello good afternoon chair vice chair and committee members mark vanloo assistant director housing community development here uh before you today to bring the phase two of namaste homes 16th square phase two project this is located on martin luther king jr street south at about 16th avenue south they will construct an additional four units on the north end of the original 16 square 11 unit project these will consist of two bedroom two and a half bath for sale townhomes be restricted to buyers with household income at 100 of area area median income or less for 15 years the project is shovel ready and will begin construction shortly after funding approval this is the location of the site which i'm sure you're you're all familiar with this is a site plan view of the four units and additional parking that will serve the original 11 units as well as the new four unit uh addition the numbers for this project uh total project costs about 1.866 million uh breaks down to 466 000 plus for per unit city funds requested our 400 000 which breaks down to 100 000 per unit subsidy that is consistent with other recent for sale affordable workforce housing projects that we have supported and uh our the 400 000 represents about 21 of the total project budget the financing plan is developer will construct the homes using a bank construction loan and will fully recoup the cost once the units are sold through the purchase price down payment assistance and the requested 400 000 city gap funding from the housing capital improvement project fund and administration recommends city council approve 400 000 in housing capital improvement project funding for namaste homes 16th square phase two i'm happy to answer any questions you may have yep thanks uh i'm supportive of this i just want to point out there's you know coming up another uh affordable housing project and it's just i just want to state out loud the numbers on like uh affordable home ownership it's just very expensive i mean this is a reasonable one you've done a good job to get it reasonable but you know when we've got another one coming up half the subsidy deeper affordability for rentals um i just want to make sure everybody's on the same page that it's it's difficult to do home ownership um and just something to keep in our heads absolutely thanks yes uh vice chair floyd number did stand out it's right at that threshold for me is what i would say it's getting more and more difficult all the time for it's just really virtually impossible for uh say an 80 percent ami person to purchase a home uh these days with interest rates where they are insurance and property tax costs where they are so and then the cost to develop uh for sale housing is different than uh rental housing there are different codes and rules that have to be followed so it is challenging very challenging also member driscoll thank you if anyone else has had an opportunity when when like the first phase of these townhouses were done to actually see them it really makes your day to know that people are able to attain home ownership with something really nice i mean they did an amazing job with these townhouses and i remember frederick showing me the pile of dirt next door that he's like now we got to get the rest of these done and it took a long time to to get to this point where um both sides could figure out how to how to make it work and i'm just thrilled that we're at this point now where that can be completed out and i'm i'm really hoping that we see more from um the same company because they're doing it right and they're creating home um you know home ownership opportunities for people for homes that they can be proud of it's it's really amazing so i'm uh wishing namaste the best and um i thank you for the work that you've done to make this happen thank you and i'll move approval second voting council members please enter your votes seeing that all present council members with voting uh seeing that all council members voting clerk please tally announced vote madam chair motion to approve a giant f4 passes unanimously with council members fick sanders gabbard and gurdish being absent thank you mark next up we have f8 good afternoon bath good afternoon chair hanowitz vice chair floyd members of city council beth herring dean managing director for city administration move that down since i'm down here i do want to clarify just i did listen to open forum and i want to clarify we do not have an item on the agenda for approval today this is just a report item sort of an update on where we are on the mahaffey theater management agreement um so as you all know the city began an rfp process for management of the mahaffey theater in december 2025 and after going through the official procurement process the selection committee did reject the sole proposal in april of 2026 following that process we received several unsolicited proposals and or expressions of interest those include the florida orchestra we began discussions with them in late april or may i'm not quite sure uh and we've been working with them throughout uh throughout the uh last few months we did receive an official written proposal from vinnick sports group on august 4th from live nation on august 5th a letter of interest from ruth eckert hall on august 7th and a letter a proposal from legacy management dr brian liggen on september 11th of this year um so and although uh the orchestra's terms and working with the orchestra we we we did uh work on a term sheet although that those terms did not require the least amount of subsidy comparatively speaking with the other proposals um administration did decide to move forward with the orchestra because it it did in fact uh it was in fact a reduction in the subsidy from what big three subsidy was so the subsidy on the under the orchestra would have been lower than it had been and of course um we did feel that the uh the greater expense was balanced by the opportunity to have the mahaffey theater as the home of the florida orchestra that is certainly something i think we value so over the last few months we did work uh city staff worked earnestly to finalize uh the term sheet and work on an agreement for council approval i know i i had the opportunity to brief uh many of uh you council members at the end of august i believe uh on that term sheet and uh and uh worked with legal they had a draft agreement to me in october we went back and forth on some of the um some of the uh details and received uh the final draft from legal on friday november 6th i was on vacation but we received it on the 6th so um that draft has not been officially shared with the orchestra but when i did return to um to the city obviously after the election and knowing the impacts of amendment 3 i asked if we you know if we were moving this forward and and and honestly the answer was you know with the passage of amendment 3 and the orchestra proposal not being the least subsidized of the proposals uh the decision was made to allow the next administration uh to move this forward so there was no guarantee since i just got the uh the last uh draft on november 5th that we would actually have it um in time for the december 10th meeting um given the time frame and having things to turn in it's certainly possible but there was no guarantee but i think really the the the overarching conversation was that uh due to costs and the tough budget conversations we know are happening um the decision was made to defer so just as far as the numbers go and these are approximate numbers but over the course of a five-year agreement um the orchestra the the city's commitment or city's investment uh under the orchestra proposal would be approximately 4.745 million dollars that's operating in capital dollars i want to make sure that that's clear under live nation's proposal um the city's investment over the five-year term would be about 4.6 million dollars however live nation in their proposal did offer or commit to a 2.5 million dollar capital uh investment so if you wanted to net that out you could depending on how you look at it um the vinnik sports group model was completely different so their model actually has uh has the city creating a an operating account or an operating fund of 1 million dollars and then after that was established the city would be required to contribute up to a maximum of 500 000 each year to bring that um to a million dollars so with that and the insurance cost the maximum uh cost or investment for the city over the course of the five years would be um approximately 3.73 million dollars so um and with under the vinnik group uh proposal there was an opportunity for the city to um uh to potentially profit share if and when that operating fund was the balance was over 1.5 million dollars um again that's just an opportunity there there's no guarantee there um ruth eckert hall did not submit a financial proposal so we don't have any numbers from uh from them to compare and legacy management also did not submit the financial proposal so i want to make it really clear that city administration still believes that this is a viable option it's not that the option wasn't viable it's that with amendment three we're looking at this through a different lens like we're looking through for you know everything through a different lens and so we thought it was the most appropriate and responsible thing to allow the new administration to make this final decision and to move it forward thank you um just a quick question before we go to public comment originally you had said uh there was um a request for proposal obviously nothing was picked and then there was supposed to be another request for proposal but administration didn't go forward with another request for proposal which i think some of the parties that submitted new proposals mentioned so what was the reason for not going doing a request for proposal like it was done the first time around well um thank you for that question chair and you know under the city code we're not required to do a request for proposals for management of mahafi we went through the process and we only got one proposal um and some of the people who you know have come in later didn't propose under that original rfp i'm not sure why they did or didn't but you know in talking to the mahafi um to the to the orchestra and and you know i want to thank the public and the musicians that came out today listening to the musicians today it's really reminiscent of our internal conversations you know this idea of the home of the florida orchestra was very powerful to us this made a lot of sense to us um we thought there were a lot of positives we had called council members and said look you know um we know there's some differences of opinion on this but we plan to try and go forward uh with the orchestra on this because of these reasons and then like beth said you know circumstances have changed significantly and we're going to have to look at all our facilities that are subsidized by the general fund but at the time we liked the proposal we wanted to go forward we didn't want to go through another rfp that could have taken six months that's the bottom line answer to your question and then in terms of the capital needs of the mahafi because this issue has come up before when we've had these discussions and i don't want to get lost on you know given the conversations we're having we have the 20 million dollars right that we have talked about which is 10 million from the tdc and 10 million from us but that's all up in the air right which is for electrical right and other yes we still intend to apply but again yes right but i just want to make sure like yes we have all the information electrical and some other electrical plumbing and production uh equipment okay so it needs 20 million dollars of work and then there is more that's just the mechanics of things that doesn't include all the other stuff we're fine we're finalizing the study as we speak yes okay i just want just just to be clear i don't want to confuse things but part of this also was with the in-town tiff right right no right and and that's going to have to be a discussion next year about that tiff and what happens with it right and so just want to be clear about no no i understand that we're going to have a discussion about the tiff and i don't know if they're if the county is having any discussion about tiffs county-wide and what's going to happen with tiffs after amendment three because money that goes in the tiff does not go into the general fund which does not pay for services and our general fund is going to be depleted next year 35 million dollars which increases to you know 59 million dollars and so on and so forth and so i was wondering about the tiff part and what's going to happen and we haven't made a decision on that okay um public comment i'm sorry this madam chair this was an item that i brought forward and i haven't i hadn't been given the opportunity to even introduce it and now it seems that a discussion has started and i had requested to speak first it is tradition that the chair speaks last um but i just want to make it clear to everyone that um this is an item that i brought forward um i have i would have loved the opportunity to explain why i brought it forward um i welcome the public comment and i am perfectly willing to wait until then to start our um a rich discussion around this but it is unfortunate that um the um the tint of the conversation has already been um contaminated a little bit i'm sorry about that thank you madam chair well council member driscoll um as chair i can run the meeting yes okay and you are going to be able to speak and i did not there is no tinting or anything i asked staff a question that was not part of their presentation that i want to hear so that way we all have the information we need that's all public comment first two speakers madam chair julie baker and david stowe please go to either podium state your name address or cross street and you have three minutes to address city council good afternoon i'm julie baker 1604 cumberland court in palm harbor but i'm here as an employee of the florida orchestra i was asked by mr mark mahaffi to read the letter he sent to city council in support of the florida orchestra agreement to manage the mahaffi theater dear members of the saint peters petersburg city council as most of you know i have supported the mahaffi theater over the many years that the theater has bore my family's name during the years of bill edwards management of the theater many times i assisted bill in supporting various events at our venue my wife marianne and i have also strongly supported the florida orchestra over many years we feel that both the mahaffi theater and the florida orchestra are very important assets to the saint petersburg and the tampa bay area it has come to my attention that our city and the florida orchestra have negotiated an agreement whereby the florida orchestra with venue works will manage the mahaffi theater starting in 2027 for the next five years this arrangement makes very good sense for me for the following reasons the florida orchestra is a saint pete treasure the florida orchestra has been a partner and anchor tenant of the mahaffi theater for nearly 60 years the orchestra brings world-class music education programs and thousands of patrons downtown every season putting the theater in the hands of the orchestra means it would be cared for by the people who know it best good stewardship of a public asset this agreement lets the city do what it does best while experienced arts professionals and event managers run the theater it is good stewardship of a public asset and of taxpayer dollars a smart partnership for the city during this time of uncertainty the mahaffi has been operating with a skeleton crew and book venue booking has begun for the next season tfo and venue works are ready to rebuild the team and fill next season's calendar with great shows starting as soon as possible a clear plan and a team devoted to saint pete tfo knows saint petersburg arts community well it has worked for years with local artists schools arts organizations and the audiences who fill mahaffi that local knowledge paired with venue works experience running theaters across the country gives the mahaffi the best of both tfo will guide the theater's cultural vision and venue works will handle daily operations and booking both are focused on saint pete on behalf of my family and my company mahaffi apartment company i strongly urge all of our city council to ratify this important agreement now thank you for your attention to this important matter best personal regards mark t mahaffi chairman of the board thank you good afternoon i'm dave still i'm the national director of business development with venue works so i'm actually here from iowa today so here to really proud to share our relationship with florida orchestra and really our commitment to the mahaffi theater so venue works is a national employee-owned venue management company our employees are the owners of the company we don't answer to a corporate investment group uh we we have the responsibility of running our buildings uh efficiently and effectively um and uh and and really building those relationships uh within our communities and uh and running the successful businesses for uh our owners or our or our clients which in this case would be the city uh our executive team uh our experience spans many properties uh styles from arenas to sports facilities convention centers uh but deep uh in theaters our ceo steve peters uh deep passions of the theater uh and he's built a really a family uh this this uh company is built with family values and we're really excited for this opportunity and um our partnership with the florida orchestra um you know that resonates with us uh we're excited to be able to bring our day-to-day operational expertise uh to the floor with them and realize uh that it's not just the day-to-day operation of the building maintaining it cleaning it opening the doors but it's really uh the content and what goes on the stage and we recognize that the florida orchestra has a deep uh relationship and connection to the community we want to grow that we come in with our nationwide expertise on being able to book uh national um acts whether it's concerts or uh artists or um you know even international flavors for uh performing arts and uh meetings things like that but uh it doesn't stop there it really comes back to the the community um again as a employee-owned company we we really resonate with uh our communities that we work in our employees not only are the ownership of the company but they're residents of the community and they realize that connecting to the community is going to bring success to that building um so uh it's just a really fun thing listening to everybody talk uh that's been really a great afternoon for me just to listen to the the deep connection that this theater has with the community and we're really excited about it so what we want to do is just come in build the the um the program bring in national acts bring in community uh acts and really elevate the community and create uh content and atmosphere that uh everyone would be proud of thank you next two speakers madam chair is either ignario or ignazio villa or and john dunley please go to either podium state your name address or cross street and you will have three minutes to address you to come ignacio barromiela president and ceo of the florida orchestra 244 second avenue north in st petersburg 33701 good afternoon chair and members of council thank you for your time and thank you for to city staff for the work behind this agreement so far i'm here to ask you to approve it with the item submitted for clarification that we provided to council member genetic school for nearly 60 years the florida orchestra has made its home at the mahafi we are its largest and most visible performer but we have never seen ourselves as just a tenant we have been a partner to the city to the theater and to the people who fill its seats every season we bring world-class music education programs and thousands of patrons downtown people who have dinner park and shop before the curtain goes up this agreement turns that partnership into a commitment it puts the mahafi in the hands of the people who know it best it is also good stewardship the city owns this landmark and is a jewel for our community this agreement lets the city keep its focus on governing while experienced arts professionals and event managers run the theater establishing a shared vision for this important public asset and this is the right moment the mahafi dedicated staff have kept the doors open through this transition and booking for next season is already underway the florida orchestra and venue works are ready to build on that work grow the team fill next season's calendar with great shows and deepen the the relationship we mahafi and our local arts community and here's how we're going to do it we know St. Petersburg arts community for years we have worked with local artists schools arts organizations and the audiences who love this theater venue works brings decades of experience running theaters across the country and here it will focus on one venue the mahafi theater the orchestra will guide the theater's cultural vision venue works will handle handle daily operations and booking both of us strongly focus on St. Petersburg that means a mahafi that works harder for local artists with doors open wider to the people who need the stage time and a diverse audience it means national touring arts along hometown talent and it strengthens our plans for a center for music education and innovation right here in St. Petersburg this community has already shown its confidence in us the orchestra is an unprecedented period of audience development and our confidence with concerts that range from beethoven to sting and syntheree evil giving to the orchestra has more than double in five years and a historic 10 million dollar gift the largest in our history has strengthened us for the long term St. Petersburg is a city of the arts and the mahafi is one of its brightest stages today we ask that you approve this agreement and let us take the baton we look forward to working with you and this whole community for what comes next thank you so much and i'm here to answer any questions you might have afterwards thank you good afternoon council members i'm john donnelly 545 5th avenue northeast i'm a volunteer and board member with the florida orchestra my remarks are a love story because i've fallen in love in st petersburg not once but twice first with my wife when we were young reporters in 1980 who met at the st pete times and in later years with the florida orchestra and not just with the world-class music more so with the um with the joy of music tfo brings in so many ways to our community the free family concerts in the park last month 211 bus loads of every fourth grader and fifth grader in the county and surrounding areas coming to our youth concerts more than 10 000 students coming to that i recently had a chance to help out the tfo musicians volunteering at an instrument petting zoo at lakewood elementary where the music teachers brought in about 100 kids all day long and they got a chance to pick up the violin pick up the drum pick up the glockenspiel and play them hands-on i mean it was total chaos but it was so so great the joy of music that was in that room two weeks ago at the mahaffey in the atrium before a concert i watched an intimate performance in a semicircle about like this with seven players three world-class musicians from the tfo and four young men teenagers from a from a juvenile detention center who had signed up to learn violin uh about two months ago and they performed as one ensemble six beautiful pieces the last one they wrote themselves the the young men these were kids who've had tough time in life i had tears streaming down my face i had to duck into the men's room i looked around there was not a dry eye in the room at the mahaffey this is the tfo in our community this is why i love it so much i mentioned this because like all orchestras tfo is at risk the phoenix and nashville orchestras suddenly shut their doors last month fired all their musicians went out of business one of them got a one-year stopgap funding but it's in peril the good news here is the tfo is very well managed by ignacio and the team and and the board were on solid financial footing for now but there's no guarantee that will last we're subject to the same pressures as everybody everybody else so i'm short on time i'll cut i'll i'll cut cut to the end this contract before you is the single greatest opportunity tfo will ever have to build a foundation that will endure we need an answer for our donors who've been asking who want their philanthropy to endure and they ask us you can't just keep being vagabonds you need a home this is what we need to keep tfo as the musical heartbeat of our community for the next 60 years thank you next two speakers madam chair helen helen french and rick christman please go to either podium state your name address or cross street and you have three minutes to address city council good afternoon thank you city council thank you chair for hearing me helen french my address is 791st avenue north and i work at 102nd avenue north suite 130 i'm the the executive director of the st petersburg arts alliance and i'm here to speak on behalf of um supporting the management agreement between the florida orchestra and the mahafi theater as we've heard from many people for nearly 60 years the florida orchestra has been more than just a tenant they've been a partner with the city and with our community every season the tfo brings world class music into our community it supports music education which i've been benefited from and as a performing artist and deeply grateful for they bring programs to thousands of patrons every single year they bring tourism downtown they bring people out to eat they are a cultural jewel at the arts alliance we work with artists and arts organizations across st pete every day and we see how tfo works alongside local artists schools arts organizations and the audiences who come to the mahafi they know this theater they want to call it their permanent home they love this community and it shows in the work they do every day they care about our town and they care about artists under this agreement the local knowledge as we've heard will be paired with venue works who has experience running theaters across the country tfo is going to guide the artistic journey and venue works will guide the day-to-day operations it is clear to me that both are committed to st pete i want to stress another point when a venue is led by people who understand what artists need everyone benefits that understanding makes for sound budgeting and smart smart programming artists who are treated well in a venue will come back to that venue touring acts will tell other touring acts local artists will put down roots and reinvest in the community they will work and they will partner with those who support them taking care of how artists is and how they are treated in a theater fills helps fill a calendar season after season and this is good stewardship of a public asset and of taxpayer dollars timing matters too while management of the mahafi has been left unsettled the theater has been running with a trimmed down staff a theater that sits empty or underutilized hurts us twice it hurts our economy because there are fewer ticket sales and fewer economic drivers fewer dinners fewer visitors downtown and it hurts our spirit because a dark stage tells our artists and our audience the place is on hold tfo and venue works are ready to move and fill the calendar right away the florida orchestra and the mahafi are both st pete treasures so i believe that this would be they would both be good stewards working together thank you for your time good afternoon madam chair members of city council rick christman 102nd avenue south st petersburg florida i'm here to speak in support of the city entering into a management agreement with tfo for 58 years florida's largest and best orchestra has performed at the mahafi theater no other arts organization or performer has performed more often or knows and understands the theater better than tfo however during those 58 years the orchestra's agreement has not been with the city but instead has always been as a sub lessee with a management company and while various management companies who have managed the theater have worked with tfo regarding scheduling tfo has always had challenges with getting all the dates it needs and getting them in a timely fashion that all changes with the approval of a management agreement between the orchestra and the city but i also recognize with the passage of amendment three council needs to look at its expenditures and expenses closer than it ever has and that there will be some very difficult decisions council will have to make due to its passage this is one of those decisions putting it as simply as possible council has to decide whether the mahafi theater remains open or closes if because of amendment three the city can no longer afford to keep the theater open and either manage the theater itself or pay another entity like tfo to manage it then there's no reason to approve the agreement with tfo however if closing the theater is not an option council is willing to consider then the city needs to enter into an agreement with someone to manage the theater and that someone should be tfo think about this if it costs less for the city to manage the theater than what it is paid to a management company and if the city had the booking relationships it would have managed the theater for the past 58 years but the city doesn't have the booking relationships nor does it cost less for the city to manage the theater which is exactly why turning the management over to a known entity like tfo makes sense i also want to address the ramifications of punting the decision to the next administration first delaying a decision means the city has to continue managing the theater and incurring the costs in doing so second delaying a decision puts the 2027 season at risk as programming for that season needs to begin now before the top performers are all booked up lastly as the city intends on submitting an application to the tdc delaying a decision could cause the tdc to pass on awarding any funding due to the uncertainty regarding the theater status and management with the approval of tfo as manager council could send a powerful message to not only the arts community but to the community as a whole that we truly are a city of the arts that arts and culture are the drivers of our quality of life and economy and that st petersburg is and should be and should always be the home of the florida's largest and best orchestra thank you for your time and we'd appreciate your support next two speakers madam chair jason mathis and ed montanero please go to either podium state your name address or cross street and you have three minutes to address city council good afternoon council chair chair hanowitz city council it's good good to see you all again ed montanero 100 2nd avenue south i'm here today in support of the management agreement between the mahaffey theater and the florida orchestra having the privilege of serving on this council i understand the responsibility that comes with a decision like this to protect the private public's investment development while preserving the institutions that make our city special i believe this agreement moves us in the right direction on both both parts first it establishes a more sustainable financial model for the theater by placing greater operating responsibility on the orchestra and its management partner this agreement creates a path to reduce the operating subsidy the city currently provides while maintaining a valuable public asset it's it's a responsible approach that aligns the operating costs and responsibility of helping protect taxpayer dollars second it provides the florida orchestra with the stability of the home at the mahaffey theater for the term of the agreement this commitment is important it gives the orchestra musicians supporters audiences in the audiences confidence that this outstanding cultural institution will continue to be a important part of st petersburg's future the florida orchestra has been an important part of our city for many years in 2017 city council designated part of first street florida orchestra away that was more than just a street renaming it was a statement about the important role that the orchestra plays in our city's identify identity and quality of life this agreement builds on that legacy and helps ensure that the orchestra continues to call st petersburg home we are a city of the arts a thriving institution like the florida orchestra brings people downtown supports our restaurants and local businesses attracts visitors contributes to the quality of life of our community and it makes our city a special place for people to work live work and raise a family we should approach this agreement with confidence and optimism this is an opportunity to build a stronger partnership and protect a treasured community asset it also positions the mahaffey theater and the florida florida orchestra for long-term success we've always been a city that embraces innovation celebrates the arts and looks confidently to the future this agreement helps ensure the mahaffey theater and the florida orchestra remains a source of pride inspiration and excellence for generations to come thank you jason mathis i think he's gone i'm going to call the next speaker madam chair chris steinocker please go to either podium state your name and address or across street you have three minutes to address city council hello my name is chris steinocker president and ceo of the st petersburg chamber of commerce at 100 2nd avenue north i did come here to as well as everybody else here to share our support for uh approving this management agreement city staff and administration's clarification of that i guess we're just not there yet but i was hopeful we were um i was hopeful for all the reasons you heard today i was hopeful because of the history we heard from the sharing of our neighbors and the crowdsourcing that we how we got florida orchestra and mahaffey to where it is today i was hopeful because of the impact you heard from the players themselves their families and the community who have shaped this and shaped saint pete this is saint pete i was hopeful that we were there today because of the trust and growth of the professional staff ignacio's vision of saint pete is goosebump good we support it and the team and partners he's brought together is nothing short of spectacular bravo ignacio finally i was hopeful because the timing is right by approving today you allow the administration and the partners now to put together the best application for this 10 million dollars if we want to get out of this hole we have to find other people's money if we thought we were going to get this 10 million dollars three years ago when we were hopeful that that was the case when we knew we needed it even then and we didn't have the application in the with the matching dollars and now i don't know if we can compete with this kind of uncertainty in front of us and i'm concerned that we will have a theater and a jewel that goes dark finally i was hopeful because this is how you get economic development started to position saint pete as the crown jewel of culture in the state of florida is the unique position that will attract the right kind of growth to us as florida defines itself saint pete continues to show itself as the place where economic development can happen these kind of uncertainties send the message to everybody else so i'm hopeful for you all that you see the support and growth of the community that wants this agreement and i'm hopeful from administration we can move this forward because if we lose again and not get the other 10 million from the tdc i am really concerned of we are digging the hole that we cannot get out of and then good partners are going to find other ways to do this we want st petersburg and the florida orchestra and the mahaffey theater to be that crown jewel we ask for some sort of work to speed this up so we can get it done by the end of this year so that we literally can apply for that in january we appreciate that thank you thank you okay council member driscoll thank you so i read this item forward and asked for it as a report item because last week um i sent an email to a few in the administration asking for uh an update and what where are we at with the agreement with tfo for the mahaffey um didn't get a response for a while and then eventually i got a phone call from bath saying oh the administration decided um to not move forward with it and to just wait for the next administration to handle it and i said well and she said she was letting all all council members know this is the only time when we can discuss it because it's something that we would vote on and so it was necessary to bring this to a city council meeting for us to be able to talk with each other and also to give the administration an opportunity to further explain their decision which i feel is a bit short-sighted and disappointed to say the least right now the city is managing the mahaffey and later in this meeting we are going we are being asked to approve um in the budget cleanup over 2.2 million dollars for the mahaffey for operating expenses because what they're figuring in is that the city will continue to operate the mahaffey indefinitely meanwhile so 2.2 million and some change meanwhile we've received the draft agreements you see how close we are i mean we're they're down to like smaller in my opinion smaller negotiation items um i looked at the copy the red line copy that was received by the florida orchestra for this and just in my humble opinion nothing in there is a deal breaker nothing this can all be hashed out and if we don't we've got 2.2 million going to the operating expenses this was never supposed to be the plan to operate it for this long we had meetings with beth and james in august to go over the terms and at that time they told me there was just really one sticking point that was not balanced among city council members on i think it was the term length or something like that just one item left to work out in august and here we're sitting here the week before thanksgiving and we still have nothing and meanwhile the city continues to spend money operating the mahaffey the restaurant is dark um the programming is minimal and yet we have a willing and enthusiastic partner in tfo and venue works ready to go they have let me tell you i have never seen for a non-profit i have never seen a development department that worked as hard as this one does those guys have raised the money that comes from confidence and it's not just from the mahaffey family although i love that we were able to hear from them i loved the letter from mark this is the family whose name is literally on the building asking us to move forward with this and finalize it yes there are others that have come out and after you know late to the ball and saying oh we would like to do something but these are the folks who have been working day and night to put together something that we can be proud of together real community partners they're partnering they want to partner with us on the tdc funding you know what happens if we if we don't move forward with this agreement now those applications are due on january 15th so what we're being told by the administration is that the new mayor will be sworn on in january 7th and here you go you've got a week to submit this grant funding and get this partnership done that is unfair to our city our residents the tfo venue works it's unfair to everybody especially when we are this close to agreement i was in the audience when mayor welch stood at the mahaffey on the stage to give welcoming remarks and announced a commitment to making the mahaffey a permanent home for the florida orchestra we are at that point right now it's time to seal the deal so that we can get access to funding so that their rockstar development team can say hey we've got our permanent home write that check that's how this works this isn't a time to get scared what scares me is if we don't do anything are we just just going to darken everything in our city that's owned by the city no we have an opportunity to keep the lights on and make the lights shine brighter than ever so let's do it i know that this is not an agreement that can be approved today what i'm asking for is support to urge the administration to get this done and get it done before the end of this year that's my ask on the table i really look forward to hearing what you all think of the current situation and i really welcome any new ideas that can help us save this deal thank you thank you vice chair floyd thank you um i looked over the other uh i guess bids for lack of a better word proposals uh and i i'm glad you mentioned it i'm obviously going to be thinking of things through like a fiscal lens after amendment three you all have heard it from me before and you're definitely going to hear from me in the future um but what i saw from them was uh deals that were all what i would describe as in the same like universe as uh this one that we've negotiated without having information key information uh put into them specifically like that i feel like council for the most part you know i don't know if everyone feels this way but i do feel like for the most part uh many of us have articulated to you that uh to administration that we want to see the orchestra protected in any agreement that you bring us about the mahaffey and that's going to have some sort of financial impact on any agreement that gets brought forward well you have an agreement that has that locked in with a partner in venue works that uh you know i went and looked through uh their portfolio and they're i'm very comfortable with them and uh you have it and it's close to being done i i do think that you know it'd be my per uh it would be my preference for us to uh you know get get what we need to in this agreement so that we can move it forward and i know that it was an agreement negotiated before amendment three well you know i mean while we're negotiating it say amendment three happened and now we have to have further considerations but don't don't don't give up is what i would say like and i'm not saying that that's like your intent or anything but i would i would hope that we could uh make something like this work uh i do wish actually i'll step back and i'll say i do wish that people when we just had the bid process i wish everybody just bid on it so we could have gone through that like that would have made everyone's life easier um but that's not what happened that's not where we are today uh so uh i i mean my preference would be for us to get this deal to a place where we can all feel comfortable with it i believe that it's possible um it's up to administration to get that done so i would just add my voice to one that says just you know do the best you can i recognize it's a short time frame but i would love to see it as soon as possible as well um and i think that the orchestra and venue works like they're going to understand if we go back and we say hey look amendment three happened we have to you know have a the tone of the discussion shifted a little bit but i think that they're interested in getting this done and so um i'll leave it there thanks thank you council member kivins thank you very much i i think an institution um as sacred as the florida orchestra deserves more than just temporary stages and uncertain leases um i can personally attest to the impact that this organization has had on my personal life um as someone who was not athletically inclined um i was a musician and i discovered my passion and my love for the arts honestly through my school field trips to the florida orchestra um and thanks to that i was able to introduce the next generation to the florida orchestra though you'd all didn't even mention it i hate that you didn't but the work that you do with the gathering of women 52 weeks out of the year we're talking every saturday we have musicians who volunteer their time not getting any paychecks to teach kids in south saint pete jordan's park specifically how to play instruments that's their first introduction most of them to an instrument being able to put their hands on that it's something to be said about that so yes building something takes time it takes a vision but it also takes partnership public private partnerships and i think it is time long overdue for the florida orchestra to have a permanent home um it's very difficult to negotiate contracts and that sort of thing with artists and you know musicians when you don't have certainty and so i i don't think it's fair for the florida orchestra to be treated like that stepchild um they've been great partners and what i don't want to see is for us to lose this partnership i think we have an opportunity uh listen amendment three passed we get it lots of unintended consequences no matter how you voted and here we are and i'm sure you know administration i'm sure they get it there's gonna have to be some discussions that we have to revisit but at the same time i think it's time for us to move forward uh so i support moving the hat them a happy forward let's move this agreement forward and let's help find them a permanent home thank you chair thank you council member harding thank you chair i will not be coming to the next meeting council vice chair floyd will speak for me for the second time today he is speaking my truth which is uh for two gentlemen who are uh fairly far apart in the way that we look at the world sometimes um i am i am following you today um i i enjoyed the way uh vice chair floyd put that my my thoughts are that um overwhelmingly that um that regardless of what we do and how we move this for we do need to look at this as it's been going on to the the lens of uh of amendment three because this is pre-amendment three and so this needs to be reconsidered at the same time um and vice chair floyd said it well we heard from um almost probably six maybe seven maybe eight of us up here that anything that we do um with them happy theater needs to uh take into account the the florida orchestra and um and to that point that probably the easiest uh way to accommodate that is just to work with the florida orchestra so um so i think we should look at this again um i i am i am in favor of uh of us of us moving this forward i think that i am i'm struggling with how we would get to the time frames um how we would get to january 15th if we if we don't move this forward now it's one of the dominoes that has to fall in order for us to to submit that application um so if administration is willing to look at it again um in the in the time that we have left in this year though uh we'll find my support as well thank you chair thank you um beth with the tdc and the application and all that explain to us a little bit what that process is and what part of the issue i've had with the mahaffee is the fact that we as a city have not had a plan for the mahaffee honestly i've mentioned this everybody's talking about the mahaffee and how much they care and guess what we have not had a plan in terms of capital improvements for the mahaffee period as much as everybody here cares about it what's the plan oh we're rushing january 15th that's our plan and now we have to speed up and do all the things because january 15th is around the corner where was everybody trying to plan out the the success of the mahaffee for the next 20 years or 30 years and making sure that we're putting the money into the happy so we're not in this place that's my issue it's great everybody here is on the same page no one here doesn't love the mahaffee and the orchestra and all the programs but we should not be here in this spot right now without a plan for how we're going to get money in the future with amendment three now which is going to make it even more difficult for us that's what i'm trying to say when the money was flowing we could have invested in the mahaffee and we didn't the last time we did uh a major improvement to the mahaffee was when 20 years ago 25 years ago 25 years ago 2005 yes 2005 2005 20 years ago so 20 years ago we have to put in 20 million dollars for elect for real things that you're not going to see you're just not going to see it's like you going into your house and changing the plumbing all the stuff that nobody wants to do and the electrical and it costs a lot of money and then you go back and you're like huh it costs what and that does not include all the other things that have to be done to it that is my frustration when i asked my questions at the beginning it wasn't against what's happening it's my frustration did i want the city to run the mahaffee theater no i was one of the people here on city council that said i don't want bill edwards to be gone without us having a plan as to what we're going to do because i knew that we would be doing it ourselves and we don't run theaters we didn't have a plan and that was my concern whether we liked the last agreement or we didn't like the last agreement that wasn't the point the point is we're here because there was no plan b because we did a request for a proposal and it won't work out and now it got pulled do i like being here no none of us like being here so i want to make myself really clear in terms of why i asked questions why i thought they were important to ask where we are in capital improvements what are we doing for the future and long term not just this agreement i do think it's extremely important that we have a discussion because we are going to have to look at our facilities we've talked about putting money into the marina i'll tell you right right now that's something that we're going to have to relook at and determine whether or not we're going to go forward based on amendment three that's like with any other one of our properties we're going to have to be making those decisions coming up pretty soon next year at city council and trying to figure out are we going to go forward with the marina spend a hundred and something million dollars that we're we're going to be losing budget you know in our general fund 300 million or something in the next five years and that doesn't include the the cost incrementals that's only less money we're getting because of amendment three that doesn't include that differential of every year cost rise four or five percent nobody thinking about that so yeah conversations are going to be pretty ugly and i'm not making and i'm not going to say it's not so i want this to happen but this is a reality we have amendment three and we need to figure out how this is going to work i need to really understand the numbers just like vice chair floyd said just like council member harding said we have an agreement is great but in reality we need to financially understand well how is this going to be sustained this is not a two-year thing a three-year thing this is a long-term thing and what is the plan and i don't think that's too much to ask because we have plans for many things that are 20-year plans we should have a plan and if this is something that the community wants to invest in with the little monies that we have then we're going to have to figure those things out but i don't know what's going to happen with the cra in downtown and those monies and we still have the historic gas plant and we have an msc that's falling apart and i could go on and on and on and so yes when i bring up these issues yes it worries me it all worries me and i don't like any of it i don't like any of the ugly decisions that are going to have to come into the future so i don't think right now we don't have anything in terms of an agreement and frankly we need more information in terms of how this is going to work with amendment three because what was figured out does not include amendment three and i know we've had conversations about and it's not fair because we have other issues the airport the marina all these things that now are being looked at in a certain way so i think we need to kind of figure those things out and to me it's not a no correct to me it's trying to get the information as to what is our future based on what just happened i don't know a week ago i've even forgotten like how far that election happened it's it's nine days yes or more no more ten yes however long it's it's been um and so that's where i'm at with this and i do think there is a way to work things but we need to really understand the numbers and i think everybody needs to understand where they stand in terms of capital improvements and what's going to happen with the facility and how it's going to really be run and i think the public needs to understand all that because it's great to put you see a headline in the newspaper there's an agreement and everything's standing and people don't know don't realize the ball's going to drop in three years or two years because next year's budget's great it's fy 28 fy 29 that's going to be really ugly so um i've spoken enough and council member driscoll wants to speak and and by sheer floyd is probably having uh anxiety right now for his flight so thank you well i think that um if we if we sit around and decide to do nothing and if we decide to be paralyzed by amendment three um our city is going to look very different very fast this is a discussion our our council chair brought up some really good points about tough decisions that have to be made and we have to know how are we going to take care of the city assets in light of these new reductions in money to pay for things like improvements but one of the solutions for that is public-private partnerships i do not believe out of everybody that said oh we'd like to submit a proposal i didn't look at a single one of them as some sugar daddy that's going to come in and just pay for everything there is a cost there is always a cost but what we have today is the result of months of negotiations of talking about what a real partnership would look like for the mahafi we have already laid out um potential funding opportunities to make the capital improvements that are necessary and yes there are always questions about where's the money going to come from there's always that but we've already got potential solutions for this it's just going to be up to the city council to decide whether those are the solutions they want to pursue that's not what we're talking about here today we're talking about the fact that the city does not want to manage the mahafi indefinitely we want to get back to where we have a partner we have one we have one that's ready to go right now and they've been vetted and we are down to changes to the draft agreement that i look at and i think it might take me longer to have a to drink a cup of coffee than to figure this out because both sides really want to get to yes and i think we have that opportunity i i mean this the red line copy that i got from um the orchestra it's minimal minimal now there is still some back and forth to do but i don't think it's going to take that long to accomplish this did you want to no i i just wanted to just to clarify i appreciate the comments and i appreciate what everyone said and i just want to make it clear that it's not a matter of the value of the orchestra and and i also do would want to clarify that we have not provided a copy to the orchestra and we have not seen their red lines back so we do not know what those are um so well they're out they're out no i understand but but have a copy sit down and let's let's get this done because because what's on the line right now is that really the future of the orchestra and the future of them happy i don't want them going to clearwater i don't want them going to tampa they're already being schmoozed to go there we need to keep them here this is incredibly important and it's at a time where nobody has a problem with these partners you know i you know we can't we can't approve an agreement today because we don't have a final agreement in front of us but what city council can do is ask for you to bring this forward bring something forward and and a best effort or what is it that's in the contract is it um i think it was like best efforts is something that uh is always interesting to try to define but i know that you want this too and what we can do is ask the administration since i see that my colleagues agree with me this is why i love bringing these things forward to council so i can hear uh what everyone else is thinking but i think that you know given today's date our last meeting of the year is on december 10th and i think it's you know given what what is the the point that we're at the fact that we're so close these are the partners i think we can deal with rain rain or shine i really believe in them and so what we can do is ask therefore i'm going to make a motion for city council to urge the administration to make a best effort to bring forward a final agreement for the mahaffee management with tfo slash venue works um no later than december 10th i have a motion second clerk if you can open the mission for voting council members please enter your votes seeing that all present council members have voted clerk please now announce a vote madam madam chair the motion to approve agenda f8 the motion to request urge administration to bring an agreement before december 8th passes unanimously 10th sorry passes unanimously with council members fick sanders gabbard girders voting absent all of the council members voting yes thank you beth if i may just take one more moment and i apologize i just really want to publicly thank the staff at the mahaffee theater for everything that they've been doing over the last few months because the theater has been busy and they've been working their little tushies off to make sure that the guests can come and enjoy not only the orchestra but all of the other events so i really want to make sure that i publicly acknowledge the work that they've done they're not the only ones that have been working their two shoes off you have so thank thank you thank you i i don't normally use that word i only repeated but thank you beth for everything you do we really appreciate it um thank you for everyone that's been here we're gonna try to hurry up real quick recess at city council and convene at cra cra2 this is marks yes it is would you make a quick absolutely uh for you today is approval of 2.2 million dollars for whitney loft hunter brady long project i have a presentation if you'd like to see it make a motion motion second you have a motion and a second clerk if you can open the machine i was going to say one thing oh vice chair floyd yeah i know i know i know but this is a very good affordable housing deal thank you for bringing it forward okay my pleasure thank you for the work we have a motion a second clerk if you can open machine for voting council members please enter your votes seeing that all present council members have voted clerk please tally announce the vote madam chair motion to approve a john cra2 passes unanimously with council members vick sanders galbert girders being absent thank you adjourned the cra reconvene at city council f5 move we have a motion a second clerk if you can open a machine for voting council members please enter your votes seeing that all present council members is voted clerk please tally announce the vote madam chair motion to approve a john f5 passes unanimously council members vick sanders galbert girders being absent um we have g1 new business referral to hlut it's the 31st street complete street study by sheriff floyd yes you can move approval if you want yeah i'm asking for us to uh refer to hlut uh the 31st street complete street study and i'll move approval second we have a motion a second we have one card please go to either podium state your name and address or cross street you have three minutes to address city council hi my name is kristen ehrlich i'm with connect panelist um as you may know uh 2386 granada circle west and it sounds like maybe you're getting a positive vote and i will try to keep it quick connect panels does have an amazing grant that we've been awarded to plant trees on 31st street south and just part of the timing here we would really love to wrap up that agreement with the city so we can start planting in march or february which my understanding it goes perfectly well with the proposed 31st street complete street study plan um so to the extent that this can go to committee expeditiously would be great to do in december so we can know by january with our vendors of what's going on um that's my main point here we're really happy the plan is looking really great and it's been about two years this has been ongoing this complete street study is supposed to be completed last year we're really excited i mean this is a great moment for us and it's been a long time coming so i appreciate your vote today and hoping this is some good news thank you thank you for coming we have a motion a second clerk if you can open the machine for voting council members please enter your votes seeing that all present council members have voted clerk please tally announce a vote madam chair motion to approve agenda g1 passes unanimously councilmember fix sanders gabbard curtis being absent thank you next item is an action item uh it is respectfully this my item from the cal respectfully requesting city council approval to remove the following items from the cal referral list one the discussion regarding the provision of street murals and potential alternatives for public art and place making opportunities this was council member gabbards and potential changes to the city code related to historic preservation and designation this is council member gabbards we have a motion and a second clerk if you can open the machine for voting council members please enter your votes seeing that all present council members have voted clerk please tally announce a vote madam chair motion to approve agenda h1 passes unanimously council members fixed standard gabbard girders being absent thank you next up we have public hearings we have j1 proposed ordinance number 6538 in ordinance enacting year and appropriation adjustments for fiscal year 2026 for the operating budget and capital improvement program but program budget and adjustments to the fiscal year 2027 budget and providing an effective date we have no cards manager thank you move approval thank you we have a motion a second clerk if you can open the machine for voting council members please enter your votes seeing that all present council members have voted clerk please tally announce the vote madam chair motion to approve agenda item j1 passes unanimously gabbard girders being absent thank you next up we have open forum are there any speakers we close open forum none and soon great we go to announcements any announcements council member given thank you i'll be brief chair i just want to again uh remind everyone as we come into the thanksgiving season there may be some folks who are not as blessed as others um so positive impact wish to be a blessing and help distribute uh thanksgiving giveaway bags um so there'll be gift cards in those as well that'll be taking place this saturday um at 1770 22nd street south um from 7 30 a.m to 11 a.m and then also uh from 11 a.m to 2 p.m uh saturday shops will be giving out turkeys as well at the trop so thank you chair thank you vice chair floyd thanks i love a turkey giveaway um and no i do always a fun event yeah uh i just want to say thank you all for bearing with me today and i have plenty of time so i appreciate it i wanted to make sure we made it by 5 15 and we have so thank you everyone for moving it along so you can make your flight and not miss it and then it's our fault so thank you everyone for a great meeting happy thanksgiving and enjoy your week meeting adjourned