Civic › Miami-Dade County, FL › November 16, 2026

Planning Advisory Board - Nov 16, 2026

Miami-Dade County, FL Board of County Commissioners November 16, 2026 205 minutes
▶ Watch original video Interactive viewer Search Miami-Dade County meetings

Transcript

SPEAKER_0121:22

I'm William McCrea, the chair of the Miami-Dade County Planning Advisory Board. If we can all stand now for the Pledge of Allegiance. All right, thank you. I would like to welcome you all to the PAB's public hearing on the October 2025 cycle, application number CDMP 2025-0020, May 2026 cycle, application number CDMP 2026-0007. Staff, please call the roll.

SPEAKER_0322:15

Good afternoon for the roll. Elisa Zapata, Carlos Diaz-Padron, Ivo Fernandez Jr., Eric Fresco, Solomon Genet, Michael Gangora, Horatio Huembez, Frank Lago, Max Lozner, Michael Montiel, J. Will Morris, Daniel Rogers, Vice Chair Thomas, Chair McRae, Miami-Dade School Board Representative Natalie Simon, Homestead Air Reserve Base, Larry Ventura. Mr. Chair, you do have quorum.

SPEAKER_0123:07

So the PAB was established by the Miami-Dade County Charter and consists of 17 members. The PAB members are appointed by the Board of County Commissioners, four at-large members, one non-voting member representing Miami-Dade County Public Schools, and one non-voting member representing Homestead Air Reserve Base. We are all residents of Miami-Dade County and serve on this board without pay. It is our responsibility to make recommendations to the Commission on planning-related issues. The public hearings will be conducted by the PAB acting as the county's local planning agency with assistance from the Department of Regulatory and Economic Resources Department. The purpose of this hearing is for the PAB to receive public comments on the proposed CDMP amendments and initial recommendations of the department. The recommendations of the affected community councils and to make recommendations to the County Commission regarding adoption of these small-scale applications. Persons wishing to speak during the hearing should fill out a speaker card at the desk in the lobby and indicate the application they wish to address. A little bit about the public hearing procedure. Staff from the planning division is going to summarize the CDMP application. Public comments will be heard next. At the conclusion of the public hearing for that agenda item, the Planning Advisory Board will adopt the resolution with its recommendation for the Board of County Commissioners. Heading off into the chair's report. We've got no items here to address. Let's kick it off here with Mr. Garrett Rowe. If you could please get us started and introduce the first item.

SPEAKER_0424:48

Good afternoon, and thank you, Mr. Chair, board members. I'm Garrett Rowe, ladies and gentlemen. I'm Garrett Rowe, chief of the Metropolitan Planning Section within the Regulatory and Economic Resources Department. And I'm joined here today on the day as the chair, board members, by Assistant County Attorney, Mr. Christina Rabianet, with Planning and Development Manager from the department, Mr. Alex David. And we have other staff here from RER who will be assisting with conducting the meeting today, including Mr. John Lucas, who is queued up and ready to go on the first item, the first application, Mr. Chair. Other county staff are here, including members of our environmental team, DERM included, and they will be helping to answer questions as we go along. So I just wanted to point out, Mr. Chair, board members, that at each of your spaces on the desks there on the dais, we have distributed, revised, and replaced pages for both CDMP applications. The first application, CDMP 2025-0020, revisions were made to the supplemental report that updates on where we are today from when we initially published the staff recommendation, right? It calls attention to changes made by the applicant, additional information submitted to us that we have analyzed, and that has resulted in an update to the staff recommendation, right, which Mr. Lucas will walk through. And for CDMP 2026-0007, we also issued revised and replaced pages, which updates the proposed recommendations from staff, the recommended changes to the application that we include in the report, as well as updates to the environmental analysis, right? So those replacement pages are included, as well as copy of a resolution from the Board of County Commissioners, right? Resolution 1177-25, that speaks to the second item on the agenda, the CQRM application. So with that, Mr. Chair, I will ask Mr. Lucas to present the first application, if it's your pleasure.

SPEAKER_0127:24

All right, thank you, Mr. Rowe. Mr. Lucas, you're recognized.

SPEAKER_0227:29

Good afternoon. If we could pull up the presentation, please. There should be a staff presentation. That's correct. Good afternoon, members of the Board. My name is John Lucas. As Garrett mentioned, I'm a planner within the Regulatory and Economic Resources Department of the county. And today, I have the pleasure of presenting before you CDMP Amendment 2025-0020, also known as 288th Street, LLC. This application is being submitted concurrently with Zoning Application 2025-000254. This application seeks to redesignate a 10.15 gross acre parcel from a state density residential to business and office. The parcel is located on the southwest corner of Chrome Avenue and 288th Street

SPEAKER_0529:00

in unincorporated Miami-Dade County, just north of Homestead.

SPEAKER_0229:06

This parcel is within and also abuts the urban development boundary. On this slide, you can see the current next to the proposed land use map. Under the proposed designation, the CDMP would allow for up to 473,715 square feet of retail, but this is capped at 122,000 square feet by the proffered Declaration of Restrictions. This proffered Declaration of Restrictions, on top of standard clauses, also includes a commitments on environmental monitoring and restoration, a trip cap requirement of no more than 276 AM peak hour trips,

SPEAKER_0530:04

a conditional prohibition on overnight parking on the property, a requirement for proportionate share mitigation for roadway improvements. Staff's recommendation for this application is to adopt with the acceptance of the proffered Declaration of Restrictions. This application was presented in front of Community Council 14, whose members decided to transmit the application without a recommendation. The main reasons for staff's recommendation of adopt with the acceptance of proffered Declaration of Restrictions are the CDMP Policy LU-88B, which provides that the distribution of neighborhood and community-serving retail should reflect the spatial distribution of the residential population and other salient considerations. At the same time, the site's location, which is inside the UDB, and at the intersection of major roadways, Chrome, and 288th Street. That can accommodate, is able to accommodate, a limited neighborhood commercial node. And another reason is that there were no objections raised by any of the reviewing agencies. One additional factor to consider with this application is that in the event of passing and receiving a business zoning designation, it could invite an alternative use under Florida's Live Local Act that could allow development of up to 250 units per acre. For visual reference, here you can see the site as viewed from Chrome Avenue and another looking west on 288th Street. On this next slide, you can see the property looking south with the property on the right-hand side and a northeast view from the property. That development there is, these pictures are a couple months old, so that development is further along by now. Following this board's vote, the next step for this item will be to advance to the Board of County Commissioners on this Thursday, November 19th.

SPEAKER_0633:12

Thank you, Mr. Lucas. Does the board have any questions for staff? Board Member Lawson, you're recognized.

SPEAKER_0733:29

Thank you, Mr. Chair. Can you just walk me through the trip cap and what the origin of that was and what you're hoping to accomplish by including that in the Declaration of Restrictions?

SPEAKER_0533:44

The trip cap is related to the amount of development on the property, and it's based on a formula about, you know, the amount of development and the generation of trips that that would cause. So it's restricted to an amount of square footage, but at the same time, it will depend on whether there's, let's say, a type of supermarket development or what other development is on the property. So based on formulas, you end up with that. It's a way of restricting the amount of development and the trips that it would generate.

SPEAKER_0734:30

Are there certain business categories that would likely run afoul of the trip cap?

SPEAKER_0834:37

Were they to be developed on that site? If I may, Mr. Loesner and Mr. Chair. So, you know, certainly there are different types of developments that could be built on the site, but, you know, the operation of the trip cap, really, it imposes a limitation, right, that whatever the type of development that may be considered, it has to operate within that cap, right? So it is based on the development that's proposed, the total square footage, and then it basically prescribes that any other development being considered should operate within that cap.

SPEAKER_0535:13

Yes, even with the same square footage, different developments have different trips generated. So that puts a limit in that type of development. Okay. Thank you.

SPEAKER_0635:31

All right. Board Member Gungor, you recognize?

SPEAKER_0935:34

Thank you. And first of all, I apologize to the applicant and the board members. I have a hearing disability, and the county does not have any assistance today to assist me, so I may miss some of the presentation. And I apologize if my questions become slightly repetitive. Really, my biggest question for you is, as you know, the county had consistently recommended denial of the application even as recently as September 15th before the Community Council. The county recently, as of today, handed us a revised Exhibit 1A that now recommends approval, and they say they recommend approval primarily based on retail needs information you provided. I'm assuming that the retail needs information is what is in our agenda on page A7, something that was received on September 1st, 2026, retail feasibility needs assessment. Is that correct?

SPEAKER_0536:29

Yes, it's based on the follow-up retail needs feasibility.

SPEAKER_0936:37

I guess it really got my curiosity. At first, I wasn't, like, super reading this very carefully, but it's just unusual to me as a new board member that they recommend denial, denial, denial, even as recently as September 15th before Community Council, and then they changed their minds. So I assume it's what's called the retail feasibility needs assessment that I referenced. This was written by some company called Lambert Advisory, and the other thing that got my attention is it's not signed by anybody. There's no individual's name. Nobody has signed it. There's no professional identified with any type of degree or accreditation, and not to say that this is not accurate because everybody uses AI, but it's quite clearly the AI format report. So then when I got online, I was like, I wanted to see, well, who's Lambert Advisory? And the first thing it shows you when you Google the name is that their offices have been closed. It's a big red box that they no longer have offices. That doesn't mean they don't exist. Since the pandemic, lots of people work from home, but there's just no information on who issued this report that caused the county to change their longstanding recommendation of denial to approval based on this report. So I guess my question is, who's Lambert Advisory and who issued this report?

SPEAKER_0537:54

Well, them, I don't know looking online, but they, you know, certainly I know staff from that company. And originally they had submitted an application with a bit of a different reasoning that we did not find appropriate or that would have us recommend adopt. And later on they hired this shop to do a more thorough analysis. And with that, it caused the change in the recommendation.

SPEAKER_0938:33

And I'll ask the county a lot, but really my question for you, because I'm in the Austin County, is what you haven't answered is, who's Lambert Advisory and what individual from Lambert Advisory issued this retail feasibility needs assessment that caused the county to change their opinion? So, if I may, Mr. Chair. You may, but I can't answer. He hired Lambert, I'm assuming. He's staff. He's staff.

Speaker38:56

So you can, yes, Mr. Lucas is RER staff.

SPEAKER_0939:01

You hired Lambert. No.

SPEAKER_0839:03

No, no. So Lambert Advisory is a consultant that, I guess the consultant actually is Paul Lambert, which the applicant can speak to his hiring and the process of him preparing the report. But they did submit this report to us, right? And, you know, we've analyzed the report.

SPEAKER_0939:27

And just to take a... I'm going to ask you that when it's my time to ask you questions. But my question for them, which is really... So the applicant can speak to the question. I'm not of them. I think what's confusing here. Who issued this report? Yeah. And what are your qualifications of the person that is...

SPEAKER_0639:39

So, yeah, so we'll get to the applicant now after we're finished with any questions for staff and definitely be able to address that question. Did you have another question for staff?

SPEAKER_0939:47

I haven't heard an answer. Who issued the report? Mr. Gongora. The report was commissioned by the applicant.

SPEAKER_0539:54

And the applicant submitted it to the department for consideration.

SPEAKER_0939:59

Okay. And that's Mr. Lambert? No.

SPEAKER_0540:02

This is the representative for the applicant.

SPEAKER_0940:05

Okay. Yes.

SPEAKER_1040:07

Would you like me to clarify this, Mr. Chair, or... Yes, go ahead and bring it up. Nobody's here from Lambert. If I may. Hugo Arza, 701 Brickell Avenue with Holland and Knight. I'm joined today by the property owner, Edward Perez, and my colleague, Joey Vasquez. Board member Gongora, I'm the attorney representing the property owner. Mr. Lucas works for the county. So you were asking him the question. I don't know who's who yet. Right. Well, that's why I figured I'd get up and try and clarify. So Paul Lambert was hired by my client. Paul, Mr. Lambert has produced any number of studies over the years with the county. I think county staff. And I think Mr. Lucas was alluding to the fact that they had numerous meetings. I don't know if the copy that you have simply isn't signed. I mean, it's possible that they uploaded an unsigned copy. I can assure you, Mr. Lambert has both experience and has worked with county staff over many years providing precisely these kinds of retail needs analysis. So we sought him out to provide an analysis that would show the need for commercial uses in this area. That's the.

SPEAKER_0941:06

OK, thank you. And thank you for speaking so loudly. I hear you great.

SPEAKER_1041:10

Awesome. I am accused of a lot of things. Being quiet is not one of them.

SPEAKER_0941:14

So, yeah, OK, in the future, just from my perspective and then I'll move on, like if you're going to issue a report that the government is going to base their decisions on, I think it should say who the person is that issued the report and what their qualifications are. I've read all of the reports since I've joined here and over many years, and I've just never seen a report that doesn't identify the author or who their qualifications are, which makes it difficult for me to give it the kind of credibility that you would want us to.

SPEAKER_0641:43

So appreciate that for the for staff.

SPEAKER_0941:51

Yeah. OK, thank you. I will staff for staff. Got it. To the applicant after. OK, now that I understand Lambert, let me go back to staff. And today is my event today, so I apologize. But we came in and you gave us an amended Exhibit 1A that we're supposed to consider from the dais. As staff, why don't you redline these to make it easy for us to see the changes? Or perhaps you can tell us briefly, what are the changes in Exhibit 1A that changed from when we got the agenda?

SPEAKER_0842:22

OK, so the exhibit, right, let's refer to it as such. What it is is a supplement to the staff's initial recommendation report, right? So it's presented as an additional document, but that it changes the staff recommendation from deny to adopt with acceptance of the proffered covenant. And it explains that the basis for that change is the fact that in our initial recommendation report, the applicant presented information that was not directly related to the request for commercial at this location, right? But then subsequently, the study, the report, the Lambert report was submitted that provides the justification now relating to the request. And we are at least generally in agreement with the report and its conclusions, right? It points out that commercial in this location, there is some need for commercial. And so with that, we now support the application because the basis for the request now directly relates to the request, right? And our analysis of the request, for one, impacts to county services and facilities. A primary component of our analysis identifies that the capacity to serve the project as proposed is there, right? It does not violate level of service standards. And as a result, we conclude that, yes, this application, we do now support the application. So we recommend adopt with acceptance of the proffered covenant.

SPEAKER_0944:17

I kind of got that, but I'm just trying to take bite-sized pieces. You guys had been recommending denial for quite some time, which I'm not really sure why. It doesn't seem like a huge impact use to me. But as recently as September 15th at the community council, I read the minutes, somebody showed up from the county and recommended denial, denial, denial. So the community council sent it with no recommendation to us. This retail feasibility needs assessment was received September 1st. The community council meeting was September 15th. So the whole reason you're telling us you changed your opinion is based on an assessment that you had two weeks before the community council meeting. So, like, it just doesn't add up to me. Like, I find something very weird. It's denial, denial, denial. You get a September 1st assessment not signed by anybody. You have it. You go before community council, somebody from the county. You still recommend denial. Something changes the next month. You now recommend that we approve it based on this report that you had since September 1st. And then really my specific question was when we walked in today, there was a one-page change from when we got the agenda last week. So there's a lot of changes. And I don't know about the other board members, but, like, I actually spent the whole day reading this, which is not easy the way you give us the information. You don't redline, you don't let us know what changes from one moment to the next. So you have to read the whole next addendum to try to figure out what changed. Wait a minute until you're done. Okay. Is your sole basis for changing your recommendation to approval the retail feasibility needs assessment of September 1st?

SPEAKER_0846:11

So we received the report September 1st. Is it the report I'm referring to, though?

Speaker46:20

I want to make sure that I understand what changed your mind. Is it that report?

SPEAKER_0546:24

Excuse me. So there is the report and there's also the covenant. And by the time that the community council met, we had not resolved all the issues with the covenant. So we were not fully satisfied in order to change the recommendation at that time.

SPEAKER_0946:39

Okay.

SPEAKER_0846:40

Yes.

SPEAKER_0946:42

All right. I kind of follow it. The report seems to back up their need for a grocery store in the area. I guess my question to the county would be, in the future, do you think it would be a good idea to have somebody sign the report and identify who the author of these reports are? Because everybody uses a little bit of AI, but it's clear from the format of this report that it's an AI-generated report. Like, did that give the county any concern that maybe you want to know who's writing it?

SPEAKER_0847:11

So we have substantial experience working with this consultant, and the consultant has actually done work for the county, right? So, you know, the presentation of the report, I get it, and we will make sure that going forward, right, it addresses your concern, right? But, you know, we had no issue with the report, with the experience we've had with the person who has prepared it, right? So, and, you know, on the basis of the change to the REC, right, as we are working through issues, and I think at the committee council, we did point out to the board that we were in discussions with the applicants, that they were making efforts to address the issues, and the applicant can, in his presentation, will walk through, you know, all that we've gone through in updating the information that they presented in support of the application, right? So, as we are working through, we inform the board as to where we are, right? And when we met with the committee council, we acknowledged that even though our recommendation at the time was denial, Mr. Lucas pointed out, correctly so, that we had the report, we were waiting on updates to the covenant, the Crawford covenant, and also there was a discrepancy between the study, the economic, the needs assessment study, and the traffic study that we needed to reconcile, which that was reconciled as well. So, you know, so it's just that we were working through to get to conclusion, right? And now we're at conclusion. Once we got to that point, we issued the supplement updating our analysis and updating our recommendation.

SPEAKER_0948:59

Okay, thank you. I think the applicant did a very good job. I mean, they're trying to get the property changed in use. The part that I didn't understand about the county is if you're going to recommend denial over an extended period of time, including recently at community council, I think it would be easier for the board if we just got like a one, something simple that identified the changes. The only thing that I could read from your memo was you changed it based on three things. That's what your memo says. This needs assessment report, which I think you should hold out for something a little bit more professional and compelling. And I also didn't understand if you had it before community council, while you were still recommending denial at community council, and yet now changed your mind based on that report. And then whatever your follow-up analysis is, which we don't know, it's some vague thing, your conversations with them. So I don't think this is a major change. It's basically allowing a grocery store. But it's just odd. The way that it was done for me was odd and difficult to read. Thanks, Board Member Gongora.

Speaker50:05

Did you have any other questions for the applicant? Well, to staff. Okay, perfect. Board Member Diaz-Padron, you're recognized. All right.

SPEAKER_1150:28

No, I'm just kidding. And I'm not a strong voice as our good friend here. On that trip count, maximum, I don't think I've seen that a lot here. Could you just give me a very short explanation? I'm not questioning it. I'm just trying to understand it. That's all. What's it used for? Better word. What do you – is that a limitation? Or is that something you try to limit? And how do you limit that? That's what I'm trying to understand. It's – If you prefer to me to ask that after the presentation, I'm not going to say for the plaintiff because I'm used to doing trial work. But from the applicant, from the applicant is fine too. Whatever you prefer.

Speaker51:06

Yeah.

SPEAKER_1151:06

Mr. Diaz-Padron, I – Should I do it with the applicant?

SPEAKER_0851:08

No, I can answer. We can answer. So the trip caps sets a maximum number of trips that can be generated by any type of development on a particular piece of property. Right? Now, in this instance, the business and office land use designation allows a certain threshold of development that exceeds what the applicant is saying that they're going to do. Right? And so it may be – we have two, I guess, measures of limiting the development on the property. One is square footage. Which is the normal one, right? That's typical. Right. Second is trip caps. Now, trip caps are not unusual, right? We've used trip caps – I haven't seen a lot here, but maybe – Yeah. But, yeah, we've used them quite a bit, actually, right? The trip cap basically allows you to – if you are doing different types of development than what you originally were contemplating, then it basically sets how much you can impact the roadways to the level of the development that you initially are proposing or that you, you know, present that you're going to be doing. Right?

SPEAKER_1152:24

So basically – and I don't want to cut you off, but I know that the chairman is going to kill me in a minute. Basically, what you're saying is it depends on the type of business there, and the business that they are proposing now satisfies your trip count. Correct? Maximum. Is that fair? Or is there a limitation to the type of businesses that change in the future? If they want to change something in the future and they come, listen, we're going to change it now to build, I don't know, a sports stadium. They say, no, the trip count for that is 10,000, so you can't build a sports stadium. All right. Got it. Okay.

SPEAKER_0652:54

Any other questions for staff here? Yeah. Board Member Rogers, you're recognized.

SPEAKER_1253:00

Yeah. I just want to follow up real quickly because I also thought in reading the materials that one of the changes was also the legal interpretation of the Live Local Act that changed. Am I correct about that? Now, before, the recommendation for denial was based upon consideration of the Live Local Act, but then legal advised you shouldn't consider that, so now the recommendation is without consideration of that?

SPEAKER_0853:22

So the reference to Live Local is a reference and acknowledgement that the site, if redesignated as requested, could be developed under the Live Local provisions, right? So now we raise that to call attention to the fact that, by the way, regardless what we recommend, this is a possibility. That possibility remains, even with the change in our recommendation.

SPEAKER_1253:52

And then kind of tying in to that, the trip caps and then the covenant on the discussion of prohibiting overnight parking, would those be preempted by the Live Local Act also, or would those covenants still be in place even with the preemption of the Live Local Act? And if this is best directed to county attorney, let me know.

SPEAKER_0854:11

You know, and that's a very, I guess, good question. It's one that we have not vetted, right? Let me put it that way, and the attorney can follow up.

SPEAKER_1154:26

These covenant provisions could still be enforced by the county.

SPEAKER_0654:31

Okay, great. Thank you. All right, any other questions for the applicant? I mean, for staff. All right, now let's get to Mr. Arza here. You're recognized for your application. Thank you, Mr. Lucas.

SPEAKER_0554:45

Okay, thank you.

SPEAKER_1054:46

Thank you. Again, Hugo Arza, 701 Burkle Avenue, representing 288th Street, LLC. Their property owner, Edward Perez, joins me today, as well as my colleague, Joey Vasquez. Yeah, it took us like four questions to get to the crux, and thank you, Mr. Rogers. But, yeah, I mean, I've been doing this for a while. Sometimes you've got to sort of call something by a different name, and I think one of the uses of a trip cap is to ensure that the development on a site doesn't exceed certain traffic impacts. And so what this covenant does, and I'm going to go through my presentation anyway, but it's fresh in my mind. What this covenant does is it limits any development on this site to 276 a.m. peak trips. That could be the commercial project that ties into what we intend to do. Mr. Perez lives in the area, bought this property because it would take him and his wife that much longer to get to a grocery store because everything out there has grown, and we're going to show all of that. But if for whatever reason the world changes, something else happens, any other development on this site will have to live, and to the county attorney's assertion, we'll have to live by that trip cap. That severely limits the ability to use this for anything else, or if you do use it for something like live local, you're capped at the same amount of traffic, so now your impacts are consistent with whether it's – So a positive recommendation by this board this afternoon or by the BCC ultimately later this week would not, at the end of the day, we believe, create a single additional trip or traffic impact no matter what gets developed on there because of the trip cap. So I think that's – I think starting with Mr. Lozner, Mr. Gangara, Theis Padron, and then Mr. Rogers, all of you kind of kept picking at the string, and it finally unraveled. But I think you all – that's exactly what we're trying to do. The overnight parking is another effort in which, obviously, folks who live in places tend to park their cars overnight. You know, it's natural, right? So those are some of the – we've got to get creative sometimes. Otherwise, we'll never see another change to commercial land, and we'll never build another shopping center. So sometimes we have to try and find a solution. So you've seen a lot of the slides, application slides. Again, you know, what I want to call out in the next couple of slides for you is just the location. We're on Chrome. Obviously, I trust that most or all of you have probably driven Chrome in the last few years. It is a five-lane, 100-foot-wide right-of-way at this point. 288th Street is a half-section-line road, and to the east, actually, of Chrome operates as a four-lane road. So this is an intersection that is of a substantial size to accommodate a commercial development of this size. Got into a lot of the procedural history, and I think the points are well taken. This application was originally going to community council in April. About three or four days before that April meeting, we received the recommendation, and the recommendation was for denial. The recommendation was for denial due to, at the time, staff's belief that we had not conclusively shown that there was a need for additional retail in the area. I made the decision with my client's consultation to seek a deferral of that April meeting. I didn't want to go before the community council without a more persuasive argument. We worked, and again, to answer the questions that I think we have, Paul Lambert does very much exist. He has done work in the past for the county. He's done work for applicants. He's been doing this for, I don't know, 25, 30 years. I know I sat through a number of multi-hour meetings, and so I don't know if the report these days. Every report seems to be at least put through AI or generated by AI, but I can assure you that substantial work was done. This was not some cut-and-paste job.

SPEAKER_1358:16

This was a very well-thought-out process, and in fact, it took us most of the summer to get there.

SPEAKER_1058:21

April, defer the item. Ultimately, we got the draft in, and honestly, my client needed to continue moving forward with this process, so we moved forward to the community council meeting in the middle of September. Staff had a couple of weeks to review the report. They still had some follow-up questions. At that point, rather than deferring again, again, in consultation with my client, I said, why don't we move forward? And I think if you listen to the transcript there, what you'll see is staff, and I thank them for this,

SPEAKER_1358:52

very much went out of their way to say, like, hey, they've been working with us. They're showing us the needs. We're working with them. We've got to kind of keep going with this. We're not all the way there yet. We expressed the same concerns or the same sentiments, and as a result of that, community council unanimously recommended transmit, not a denial. They basically said, okay, continue working. Let's see where you guys get to when you get to PAB. We are before PAB now, and then obviously over the last few weeks, we've been able to finish addressing the concerns that we have. So that's the chronology here, and again, I want to thank staff for working with us, but it would not be fair to say that somehow this came in at the last minute or was a last-minute change. I mean, I'd say probably by the third week of April, we had our first specific meeting on the needs analysis for this property. It's the second week of November, so it's been seven months, so we've been working hard for this, but we are appreciative that we now have staff's recommendation. You've seen some of these slides, again, inside the urban development boundary at the intersection of a section and a half-section line road. I think I love this picture, the one on the left. You can kind of see that's from our street corner. That's the intersection that we're in. So, again, you know, multi-lanes in both directions. Again, sometimes we look at an aerial and think to ourselves, this is a more rural area, a more agrarian area. Obviously, chrome has been expanded in a way that it can accommodate, and I think that that's one of the reasons why we are, among others, that we enjoy staff's recommendation today. The picture on the right is any one of the within half a mile to a mile, there have been 800 units approved over the last couple of years, and we'll get into that in a second. Here are some of the other uses. I think what's telling about this one is take a look at our little square and then the distance to US 1. You used to be able to cover that distance in probably five to ten minutes, and I think what we've just sort of all learned and certainly the residents in that area have learned is that that's not really possible anymore. So there are grocery stores and there's shopping opportunities over on US 1, but it gets more and more difficult every day to make that. And so for the folks that live to the west of US 1, the ability to have some shopping and some additional retail resources in their neighborhood is a great use. You may say to yourself, oh, I've seen commercial on chrome. How does that work? That's because the CD&P calls for certain nodes to have commercial all on chrome. So all the way up from 136th Street, 200, 232, 248, 272, and now we're proposing the same kind of thing. So, again, I think along a major, major F-dot roadway like chrome, it makes sense to have additional retail resources. The car traffic already moving through there is in the tens of thousands of cars every day, whether it's people going to the Keys, whether it's people coming and going to work. And so capturing those folks, preventing them from driving east, going to US 1, taxing other resources made sense to us when we filed the application. And I think after submitting the needs analysis and other backup documentation, staff agrees with that conclusion. I referenced this. Star is our property. Caddy Corner, the picture that you saw from Mr. Lucas showed some of the homes being built. That's in the green and the yellow right above it. And then a little further up on 272nd Street. So, and then really that starts at about six blocks below that. So it starts at like 278th Street. So within 10 blocks of us, there's a more than 600 unit project approved. All that's approved. All of that is either under construction or will be under construction in the near future. The stuff in the south is all completely under construction. The stuff in the north is just getting started. But the point holds. You've added more residential rooftops to this area. This will be even more folks who will have no choice but to drive east to US 1. Or can we find a complimentary place to provide some resource, some retail? And we think that our site does that. This slide is really good, too, because not only did I hyperfocus a second ago on the 800 or so units that we saw that have been approved more recently in the near vicinity, there's a lot of people who live out in the Redland, including my client. And they live out there. And so for them, the growth that's occurred inside the urban development boundary has the effect of making it more difficult for them to get to where they need to go, right? And so by providing something that they need in near proximity, in closer proximity, avoiding having to go all the way to US 1 or go to a grocery store, being able to do it along Chrome, I think is the benefit. And so we threw up the circle of a couple of miles, and so now you can kind of see that you capture a lot of folks who live out in the Redland, a lot of folks who've made their lives out there, who are having to drive a lot longer distances these days. This will help address that. Obviously, it also captures the closer in group inside the urban development boundary that has seen that density increase. We've talked quite a bit about the retail needs analysis. I won't belabor the points, but these are all of the major, you know, conclusions. I referenced the number of vehicles. Chrome has an average daily traffic of 30,000 vehicles, so it is ripe for an opportunity. That exists today, right? I mean, that's what's out there. That's what's out there with the projects that are already coming. So this is a location that really can support that commercial use. And then the unmet demand, how much more retail we need. I've been doing this for a while, and it kind of goes in cycles to some extent. You guys have seen me do a lot of housing applications over the last 8, 10, 12 years, and those of you that have been on the board for that entire time, it's all I've probably gotten up here to do. You're starting, and you will continue to now see the market address. Homes have been built. People need to shop. People need to work. People need to do other things. You know, we can't all just function in a home and have nowhere to go to do our other business needs. And so this helps us start to do some of that. We found that there's very little inventory out there. There's a great demand for it. Chrome is the right place for it with the traffic that already exists, just the normal traffic that's already on Chrome. And that east-west that I keep referring to, getting out the US-1, becomes more and more difficult every day. If we can keep something out west, it's of benefit to the community. We can't be here, though, even if we prove that without meeting your levels of service or your land-use-settlement policy, LUAD. That one is the one that governs any land-use change whatsoever. And so we've hit the highlights there, you know, accommodating economic growth in this case. The population has grown now. We're providing for the services, services and level of standards. We obviously have to, you know, meet all levels of standards, whether it's water, whether it's roadways, whatever it may be. And we do so. And then compatibility, nearby land uses. And, again, commercial is generally not going to be found to be inconsistent with residential. We need commercial, and we can drive around town and see any number of shopping centers next to homes. I know I've been asked the question in the past. We don't have a site plan yet. My client has said, I would like to go through this process and then sit down. What that means is one of two things. Either the project will be designed without any variances whatsoever and then is approved administratively with the caps and everything we're putting in place, or there will have to be a subsequent hearing. I know I'm pushing for option A, and I think he is, too. The idea would be to develop a shopping center that meets the zoning code on 10 acres. That should be very doable. Covenant, we've spoken about quite a bit. We were still working through the Covenant and the particulars of the Covenant at the time that we went to the hearing back in September. We added the trip cap language, and it really specified that. We added, we reduced, I think at one point we were at like 151,000 total square feet on the property, and we dropped that down to 122,000. And we made clear that you could have up to a grocery store of 60,000 square feet. The overnight parking had been in for a while, but we included it and maintained it. So that's the draft covenant that you have today. And I started by kind of pointing out what that cap limitation does. And we think it should be sufficient to give some comfort that whatever gets developed here, which we have every intention of being commercial, can't provide for any more traffic than the commercial development you all would be moving forward with a recommendation of approval today. The factors I've been going through throughout, I would urge you to just take a look at the maps. I trust that most or not all of you, I know Mr. Lozner lives in near proximity to this area, at least from down south. You've probably driven out there for one reason or the other. You've seen the growth that's gone on. You know how frustrating it is, no matter where you live in the county, to have to take a really long amount of time to get to a basic need. Pick up lunch, grocery store, dry cleaners, whatever the case may be. Being able to provide that, that's going to be a benefit to the residents that have been living out there for a long time, that have seen new developments come out there, and to those newer residents who now don't tax the resources the same way. Keep in mind those maps. Keep in mind that area. Keep in mind the view of Chrome and 288th, kind of a five-lane and a four-lane intersection. I mean, this is a big intersection. This is not being shoehorned into a little one-lane road where it's going to create a problem. This is being put in the right place. So I'm happy to answer any other questions. I think we've already addressed a few back and forth. But again, we would urge you to follow staff's recommendation. I recommend adoption with the Proffert Covenant and allow us to move forward to the BCC.

SPEAKER_141:08:17

All right. Thank you, Mr. Arza. Do we have any questions for the applicant? All right.

SPEAKER_151:08:25

Board Member Thomas.

SPEAKER_141:08:27

Vice Chair, you're recognized.

SPEAKER_151:08:28

Thank you. I just want to thank Board Member Rogers for putting the nail on the head with local issue and Member Gron-Gorla for highlighting the need to maybe streamline how we get our applications, and especially when there's as many changes as this one's had. Also, staff. I realize you're working towards the best goal, and sometimes that takes time, and the applicant's timeline and yours don't always line up. So I think that's why we're here. I will say I liked the creativeness that you guys put into addressing the concerns of what the land use is because it's a double-edged sword. Sometimes you come before us and you say you can't consider the zoning piece. You can only consider the land use piece because that's your role. But if we consider just the land use piece, we have to look at the possibility of what could be there, and that could be live local. So I'm grateful that there's some limitations that might discourage that, and I'm grateful to the applicant for agreeing to it. So I'd like to hear from my fellow board members before we vote on it, but I'm definitely in favor.

SPEAKER_141:09:47

Any questions? Any questions for the applicant here? Board Member Lozner.

SPEAKER_161:09:51

Yeah, sorry not to go down the rabbit hole, but just to be sure, you're comfortable with the trip cap? You think it's commensurate with the amount of square feet that you're limited to? It's not burdensome in terms of the kind of commercial development?

SPEAKER_131:10:05

No, the square footage limitation and the trip cap limitation are consistent with each other. We made sure of that. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Alistair.

SPEAKER_161:10:14

Mr. Chair, I'll move to adopt and with acceptance of the proper declaration of restriction.

SPEAKER_141:10:21

Just a step ahead. We need to finish with questions and then get to public hearing. Any other questions for the applicant? All right, Board Member Rogers. Yeah, just community outreach, right? Nobody spoke at community council. I don't know if anybody's going to speak here, so I guess I assume you guys have.

SPEAKER_131:10:37

Yeah, we've been – yeah, so we had two opportunities to go to community council because we deferred at the April meeting and then went back in September. We have spoken to the neighbor next door. There's a church. I've spoken a couple times with the pastor. We've promised to kind of maintain lines of communication. I think there's concerns once the property is developed is there going to be development impacts, right, on an adjacent property owner. So I have his contact information and we'll be in touch with him. But, yeah, there was – Mr. Rogers, there was no – yeah, there was no – certainly not a group of folks or anything like that. And I think a lot of it is because the folks out there are typically used to seeing people wanting to build more homes and the idea that they might get something that they want to use. We'd like to think that that's the reason why it's generally been – you know, we haven't seen much by way of more – any opposition whatsoever.

SPEAKER_141:11:27

Any other questions for the applicant before we go to public hearing? All right, Board Member Fernandez, you're recognized.

SPEAKER_171:11:35

So, again, I think this is a perfect example of, you know, zoning being outdated, right, and not being able to anticipate the growth of a community, in this case the county, right? I mean, we look at the map and we see it's a 25-acre estate zoning, and you're saying this is going to impact it. The problem is that if you look at an aerial map right now of that area, it doesn't look like 25 units per acre estate zoning, right? It's much denser. It's a lot more traffic there. There's a lot more homes, a lot more families. And it's almost like we're working backwards to try to mitigate some of the issues. And the issue is, in order to provide services to these folks in these homes, you've got to have complementary zoning, and that's having commercial zoning, support zoning that will create opportunities for these folks to live and be able to get, you know, their food and their groceries within a respectable amount of time. If you look at the map that Hugo showed in the previous map, there were five or six grocery stores all lined up against US-1. The problem is they're all out of capacity, right? They're serving homestead. They're serving all the new development along the urban boundary, right, which are all catered to 250 units to the acre, not 25. So even if they're within a reasonable distance, maybe a 20-minute drive, they're going to be at a capacity because they won't be able to service those folks and all the folks that are in this immediate area from the west and the north. So you can see just simply by looking at the arrow map that there is all these gaping holes in which services need to be provided in these areas to be able to keep up with the density. And I just, again, I think it's just outdated zoning that we just don't, we can't keep, we don't seem to catch up with, right? So I think it's a great project. I think it's a good location for it. And I think we need more of these particularly. And I think the responsible thing is that it's done on a brand-new major eight-lane highway, right? That's where it's supposed to be. You talk about trips. Everybody's still driving right by there every day. They're just going further down to a different grocery store, right? So they'll be able to stop here and not drive as farther or a longer distance to get to the same services. So I think it's a great, great product.

SPEAKER_141:13:47

For a question. All right, yeah, so no, no, we're still in questions. Questions for the applicant. All right, let's go ahead and get it moving here. All right, all right. So we're now going to open the public hearing for application number CDMP-2025-0020. I do not have any speaker cards. Does anyone here wish to speak on this item? All right, seeing none, we are now closing the public hearing. Now, board member Diaz-Padron, you're recognized.

SPEAKER_131:14:50

Thank you. Thank you.

SPEAKER_141:14:55

Board member Lozner, you're recognized.

SPEAKER_161:14:58

Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll move to adopt with the acceptance of the proffered declaration of restrictions.

SPEAKER_141:15:04

Got a motion. We've got a second. Vice Chair Thomas, motion to second. Please call roll.

SPEAKER_181:15:12

Okay, so the motion on this application was made by board member Lozner, and that was to adopt with acceptance of the proffered declaration of restrictions, and that was seconded by Vice Chair Thomas. Okay. On the motion, Carlos Diaz-Padron. Ivo Fernandez.

SPEAKER_171:15:36

Yes.

SPEAKER_181:15:37

Michael Gongora.

SPEAKER_161:15:38

Yes.

SPEAKER_181:15:40

Frank Lago.

SPEAKER_161:15:41

Yes.

SPEAKER_181:15:42

Max Lozner.

SPEAKER_161:15:43

Yes.

SPEAKER_181:15:44

Michael Montiel.

SPEAKER_161:15:45

Yes.

SPEAKER_181:15:46

Daniel Rogers.

SPEAKER_161:15:49

Yes.

SPEAKER_181:15:50

Vice Chair Thomas. Chair McRae.

Speaker1:15:53

Yes.

SPEAKER_181:15:54

Motion passes 9 to 0.

SPEAKER_131:15:57

Thank you all. Appreciate your consideration. Happy Thanksgiving.

SPEAKER_141:15:59

All right. And now for the second CD&P application on the agenda, I would like to call back Mr. Garrett Rowe so he can briefly get us set up here to get moving. Mr. Rowe, you're recognized.

SPEAKER_201:16:14

Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I guess if the staff presentation can be queued by the audio team. So, Mr. Chair, we have Mr. McCall who's going to walk us through the CD&P application, but I need to provide a bit of background before he does. This application addresses the Seaquarium, the Miami Seaquarium property, right, which has operated within the county for over 70 years. It's a historic and important county asset, right, that has unfortunately closed to the public last year, October. And, you know, it's under, and if you want to click to the next slide, it's okay. It's under lease currently by MS Leisure Company, but that lease, the board of county commissioners has approved through resolution 1177-25, which a copy has been provided to you all, right, has approved that lease be reassigned. And ultimately, this is to redevelop and revitalize the Seaquarium for the attraction that it's been, of course, in a different nature, right, but that it maintains its significance to the county. And so the board resolution, in addition to directing the lease be assigned to this new entity, Resilient Aquarium LLC, who are, I guess, in terms of this whole proceedings, if this lease goes through, would be the tenants, the new tenants on the property. The resolution directed also that there's a negotiation for the lease to be amended and restated with the Resilient Aquarium team, and that it directed also that the county takes all actions necessary for the submittal of land use zoning permitting applications that are required to facilitate the revitalization of the Seaquarium property, right? The resolution contemplates a proposed program of development, right, not necessarily including maximum intensities, but particular uses that would be included within the overall development of the property. It includes aquarium, accredited aquarium, with no marine mammals, and, of course, you know, we understand the issue the county had with mammals that were on the site previously. It includes four immersive marine and aquatic-based experiences, education, conservation, and research-type operations, wellness spaces, wellness spaces, preservation of the—there's a currently a—it's called the Buckminster Fuller Dome, which is a historic structure on the site today, the cause for—sorry, preservation of that structure, and cause for a marina development, which includes wet slips, as well as dry-stack boat storage, fueling, et cetera. Parking, of course, for the entire development, and green areas within the overall footprint. To facilitate the development contemplated, right, currently Park and Recreation is the named owner of the parcel on the county's behalf, right? Multiple requests have been filed, right, to—which includes the CDMP application, and, you know, you may hear conversation about these different applications, which includes, of course, I mentioned the lease, which that's traveling through a separate process. The lease is not—not being considered here by this board. It will be dealt with by the board of county commissioners, but you may hear discussion about the lease today. Applications filed also include environmental resource permit application with the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, as well as Class I Coastal Construction Permit application that addresses because of where the property is, and the overall development includes a marina with—with—with boat slips that's necessary, but those permits are being dealt with outside of this process as well, related to the overall development, but being processed outside of this process. We have the CDMP application, which speaks to 36.5 acres of upland area, part of the overall folio for this aquarium, and, as well, being processed a concurrent zoning application that speaks to both the upland area that's subject of the CDMP application and submerged lands. So if you want to go to the next slide. So on this slide, we put side-by-side the—on the right, you will see the CDMP application area, which is the 36.5-acre uplands, and to the left, you'll see a plan of the overall development, which the resilient aquarium team are here and will make a presentation on the proposed project after the staff presentation, and, you know, I'm sure they will go into more details on this overall master plan, right? But this here, just to show you the difference between the area addressed by the overall project and the CDMP application site. Now, a portion of the marina will be on the CDMP application site, right? The dry stack and the parking, and so it's inextricably linked, right? Although the marina, the wet slips component, as shown on the graphic to your right, is outside the footprint, it's linked to the overall marina development—part of the overall marina development and linked to the CDMP application. And as a result of that, in the application package are materials addressing activities on the submerged lands, where you see the boat slips are the wet slips, and the covenant that's proffered includes commitments and limitations that imposes certain conditions on the overall development. Simply because it's linked to the CDMP application site, basically says, if you're going to develop a marina which includes any portion of this property, you are going to abide by these limitations and standards, right? So, just a bit of background, board members, for—so that we put the discussions in the proper perspective. You know, there are several things occurring at the same time. The lease to be amended and restated and, you know, being dealt with with Resilient Aquarium, LLC, the various CDMP—the various AM permits, the two permits I mentioned, as well as the concurrent zoning application, all occurring, you know, they're progressing, being processed now. But the primary subject of this hearing is the CDMP application. So, there are linkages, right, but the subject of the hearing is the CDMP application. So, with that, Mr. Chair, board members, I'll ask Mr. McCall to walk you through the requests of the CDMP application and the staff recommendation.

SPEAKER_191:24:56

Good afternoon, Chairman McRae and board members, James McCall, Strategic Metro Planner. Before you today for your review is application CDMP 2026-0007, Miami Seaquarium. The applicant is Miami-Dade County Parks, Recreation, and Open Spaces Department requesting to redesignate the site from Parks and Recreation, currently on 31.21 acres, and Institutions, Utilities and Communications on 5.3 acres, to a new designation of Special District. The second part of the request is to amend the CDMP land use element, Special District text, to create this aquarium activity area, Special District. The site's located at 4400 Rickenbacker Causeway, this is south of the causeway, it's the southwesternmost part of Virginia Key, total acreage 36.5. It's being processed as a small-scale CDMP application due to the site acreage, and the site is currently zoned GU, Interim District. On the left, you will see the existing CDMP land uses, Parks and Recreation in green, Institutions, Utilities and Communications in blue. To the right, you will see the proposed CDMP land use of Special District, and that's in the yellow with a blue hatch. The staff recommendation is to adopt with changes and with acceptance of the proffered declaration of restrictions. The changes are mainly to add a geographic description to the top portion, in yellow at the top. So the 36.507-acre portion of the upland, we provided the folio number. This is a 36.5-acre portion of a larger folio, 300 acres, more or less, located on Virginia Key, south of Rickenbacker Causeway. Toward the bottom of the left side of the page, you will see some language that we struck out and then added. It basically refers to wet slips as an adjacent property use. So what Chief Rowe was discussing earlier with the wet slips and the marina, some of the marina uses being in the water or outside of the CDMP upland area. And then on the right side, the wet slips are proposed as part of the marina and the overall sequerium redevelopment proposal, but are not within the sequerium area, activity area, special district that is being proposed under the CDMP amendment.

SPEAKER_211:28:01

Reasons for staff's recommendation. Redevelopment and revitalization of the historic Miami sequerium is consistent with Objective LU1 and Policies LU1C and LU10A of the CDMP land use element. This objective and policies require the county to prioritize infill development within the urban area and to redevelop substandard or underdeveloped environmentally suitable areas. The application and overall development contemplated for Miami sequerium balance competing policy objectives of environmental stewardship with economic growth and development. This balance is demonstrated through commitments in the Proffert Covenant that go beyond the CDMP application site and address concerns generated by the proposed marina. The approval of the application would be consistent with criteria in CDMP land use policy LU8E, which is the policy we use to evaluate land use plan map amendment applications. Redevelopment of the site would generate jobs and provide economic and recreational benefits to the county residents. With the exception of roadways, public services and facilities have capacity to serve the application as proposed. The proposed aquarium, educational and commercial redevelopment, would be compatible with abutting institutional uses and recreation areas. The Proffert Covenant commits to preserve and adaptively reuse Buckminster Fuller's Golden Dome and the Flipper House. The application also would support transit ridership and pedestrianism. The covenant as submitted by Resilient Aquarium, you know, the tenant that is working as a public-private partnership with the Parks Department, this covenant commits to a slip limitation, limits the marina to no more than 552 boat slips, and also that the slips are proposed on the CDMP application site, whereas the 295 wet slips are proposed on the adjacent submerged lands. The second condition, natural resources protection, requires minimum clearance between the deepest part of the boats or the vessel draft and the top of the benthic resources, the bay bottom where the seagrass and corals are existing, prohibition of boats with drafts greater than 8 feet from using the marina, there is to be a baseline assessment of the existing benthic resources prior to construction and subsequent annual reporting to identify any impacts to the benthic resources. There's a commitment to require inventory reporting of the inventory of boats using the marina, and the commitment to prohibit boats over 200 feet long from using the marina, except those that obtain dockmaster approval, but then all boats are still subject to that 8-foot draft, maximum draft, of the bottom of the boat. Dredging is prohibited, except within the existing boat basin. This is consistent with CDMP policies CM5F, CON9A, and CON9B. This protects seagrass and hard-bottom communities. Manatees are protected during and after construction of the marina, and also subject to a Class 1 permit for marine operating permit or other operating permit as required for the marina. The fifth condition, a vessel inventory. There is to be an up-to-date electronic registry inventory of all vessels permanently or transiently stored within the marina, and the vessel inventory is to be reported to the county annually or upon request. Marina access, this condition 6, requires a 100-foot wide channel with a minimum 20-foot setback from adjacent shoals. Also, the larger marina patrons with 100-foot or larger length boats are to use the westernmost channel basin and to ingress and egress the marina to and from the northwest within the channel. There's a channel location requirement for navigable channels to be located with direct and indirect impacts to minimize direct and indirect impacts to seagrass beds and other benthic resources. Condition 8 requires, as a public amenity, a bay walk, open space, and public access, open to the public and free, along the bay perimeter of the property, with uninterrupted connections to Rickenbacker Causeway on the west side and on the east side, and it requires 10% of the uplands to be open space, green space. Condition 9, landscaping, requires Florida-friendly landscaping and xeriscaping, predominantly native trees, to be on the site. The motorboat exclusion zone around Rickenbacker Causeway, this prohibits structures from being placed which would allow the mooring of motorboats in certain areas. Condition 11, the applicant is committed to a higher standard, a higher design standard, the 100-year three-day storm event as opposed to the 100-year one-day storm event. Condition 12, the clean marina certification under Florida Department of Environmental Protection will be sought within one year after opening, and renewal will be sought on an annual basis by the applicant. Condition 13, required parking for the proposed marina would be provided on the uplands, shall be provided on the uplands part of the property. Mitigation, condition 14, mitigation is required for impacts to the benthic habitat. That would have to be done within Miami-Dade County. Public safety condition, there will be four marina slips. Two would be made available to the village of Key Biscayne and two for the Miami-Dade County. One for the county within the wet slip area and one for the county within the dry rack storage. Historic resources, Chief Rowe mentioned the preservation, adaptive reuse of Buckminster Fuller's Dome and the Flipper House. Condition 17, these are experimental environmental initiatives, innovative initiatives that go beyond typical standards, implemented where feasible. As long as there's a positive impact to the health of Biscayne Bay. So these would include coral sod, sponge docks, oyster wetlands, blue and green roofs to retain stormwater. Condition 18 is the non-water dependent structures, a prohibition of non-water dependent structures over tidal waters. That would include the submerged lands and the mangrove wetlands. Application scheduled. Today we're at Planning Advisory Board and the next step is final action on the CDMP application scheduled for Thursday, Miami-Dade County Board of County Commissioners. That concludes my presentation and I'll be happy to have any questions.

SPEAKER_221:36:16

Thank you, Mr. McCall. Does the board have any questions here for staff? Board Member Rogers, you recognize.

SPEAKER_231:36:23

I'm just wondering why we need the new special district. Like I didn't see normally we include in our packet kind of this is what the current land use allows and so this is what the new district allows. And so is it they just couldn't have done all of this with the old, the existing land use and they need this or is there some different purpose?

SPEAKER_211:36:43

Sure. So under the existing land use, the sequarium predates the CDMP. So what's currently developed at Sequarium is 114,000 square feet of development. Under the special district, it would allow a larger, they're proposing a 1.5 floor area ratio, which would allow 2.3 million, a little bit above 2.3 million square feet in educational, recreational amenities.

SPEAKER_251:37:21

And Mr. Chair, if I may, just to follow up on that, there's a bit of history here with this site in that there's development that the county had sought to accommodate on the property that went through legal challenge, right? And ultimately, the challenge concluded in that there were not enough standards in the comprehensive plan that facilitated the use contemplated at the time, right? Now, it's in our opinion that the park and rec and the institution's categories, right, could allow development like what's being proposed here. But the special district approach answers the question definitively that because it includes the uses, it includes the standards for development, it provides the conditions for how the site should be developed, it answers the question conclusively, at least, you know, as presented and in our view, that would address that question, right? So that's the ultimate reasoning behind the special district.

SPEAKER_231:38:39

Okay, that's very helpful. Thank you. When was that litigation? Was that recently or is that way back in history?

SPEAKER_251:38:47

In the 90s, early 90s.

SPEAKER_221:38:49

Before I was a lawyer. Okay, thanks. All right, Vice Chair Thomas, you recognize.

SPEAKER_261:38:55

Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is actually to the county attorney and potentially staff. I have a question about the land use change and how it relates to the existing lease agreement. I understand, as you explained, there's a potential for someone to acquire the lease and an amendment that's in process of the lease. If a land use change is granted under the special use, is there anything in the current lease agreement that would not be able to function? For example, under the current lease agreement, there's a use that they have. If we change the land use to the special district, would they still be able to do what they're doing today? Which I realize they're not actually operating, but under the lease agreement.

SPEAKER_241:39:51

My understanding is that the lease is being negotiated to be consistent with this proposed development that's contemplated by the CDMP application, but the BC...

SPEAKER_261:39:59

That's not my question. My question is actually relating to the existing lease, which has not been changed. We're now contemplating changing the land use, and now we'll have new land use and an existing lease until such time as it's changed. Will we be taking rights away from the current leaseholder by doing that?

SPEAKER_251:40:19

I can answer that if you'd like, Mr. Thomas and Mr. Chair. Certainly, the lawfully existing uses are recognized by the CDMP, regardless of whatever change may occur. So the change in the two special districts would not remove the ability, at least to continue the uses that the site has already been approved for. The site has the zoning approvals in place, right? And, you know, existing zoning is consistent with the CDMP.

SPEAKER_261:40:54

Fair enough. I appreciate that answer. That's very helpful to me because I didn't want to wind up in a situation where we're recommending something that may be a little out of order.

SPEAKER_221:41:06

Does the board have any other questions for staff here? All right. Board Member Ngor, you recognize.

SPEAKER_271:41:11

Thank you. I guess I don't know if this is for the attorney or who, but there's a lot of information in our agenda, but I don't think we vote necessarily on all of it. Included in our agenda was some information, I guess, about a legal challenge, about whether this requires a referendum or a vote of the commission. I assume for our purposes that we're assuming that letter is incorrect and that the county commission is authorized to vote, so whatever we recommend to them is okay.

SPEAKER_241:41:47

I'm sorry. Could you repeat this? Let me say it another way. You included in our package information about a legal challenge

Speaker1:41:53

to the way this is being done. I assume for us was to disregard that. Is that correct?

SPEAKER_241:41:59

That's not what the PAB is going to recommend on today.

SPEAKER_271:42:03

Okay. Ignore it. Right. So we're not – because I'm from the beach. You know, like you hear all these things together. You hear the land use changes, the zoning, the lease. Like I'm used to like hearing these all together, but for today's purposes, we're just hearing the creation of the special district and the proposed land use changes on the map and the text amendments, correct?

SPEAKER_241:42:26

But to adopt or deny adopted changes recommended by staff and accept the proffered declaration of restrictions.

SPEAKER_271:42:32

Okay. Because, like, there's lease information in here, but we're not supposed to consider that, right?

SPEAKER_241:42:36

That's not before this board.

SPEAKER_271:42:38

Okay. And there's information in our agenda. I guess it's about the 295 wet slips being created from water. That's a rezoning change I assume that the county commission deals with. We're not to consider that either.

SPEAKER_241:42:49

There are wet slip provisions of this application, and I need to review to see if that is one of them.

SPEAKER_251:42:57

Yeah. Specific to the wet slips, Mr. Gongora, the covenant that's part of the CDMP application imposes a limit on how many wet slips can be built in association with this particular CDMP site, right? So that's certainly within the realm of considerations of the board. You know, whatever is in the covenant, you know, again, even though the wet slips are not within the footprint of the CDMP site, the parking, the dry dock, parts of the marina as a whole are on the CDMP site. And so the commitment here is, or the limitation is, any wet slips that's going to be developed in association with or as part of a project that is within or at least partly on this property has to be limited to no more than 295 wet slips. So that's the context for which the slips would be addressed. It's a limitation.

SPEAKER_271:44:06

Okay, but that's not part of what we've heard on, right? That's not part of the special district or the land text amendments?

SPEAKER_251:44:13

Yeah, the special district text as proposed with staff's recommended changes does include that limitation.

SPEAKER_271:44:24

Okay. Yes. About 295 spaces.

SPEAKER_251:44:27

Correct, maximum.

SPEAKER_271:44:29

Okay, thank you.

SPEAKER_221:44:32

All right, board member Montiel, you recognize.

SPEAKER_281:44:35

Thank you. I have a couple questions for staff. First question, did community council take place on this one? And if so, what was the result?

SPEAKER_251:44:45

We did have a scheduled community council meeting, but there was no quorum, so no action was taken.

SPEAKER_281:44:54

Okay, thank you. And my second question, I'm curious as to what staff used in terms of determining the limitation on the number of slips. As I read the application, it didn't seem to me that the environmental aspect had been totally completed yet or was still being evaluated. So I'm curious as to how those numbers were determined and whether or not there's anybody here from Durham or any of the other environmental departments to speak on this today.

SPEAKER_251:45:35

So the number of slips were included as part of the overall project plan, right? The wet slips initially was actually considered at 325 to be the maximum. We know it's currently proposed at 295. We have evaluated the application and we've evaluated the number of slips consistent with the policies of the CDMP. And also the fact is that the permits, the class one permit and the environmental resource permit that the state will also is actually considering, those are ultimately going to be speaking to what scope of development for the slips, what that would be, right? So conceivably they could come back with a different number, you know, more or less, whatever the case is. If it's more, then of course, this application would limit it to the 295. But if it's less, then ultimately that would not be a problem because the CDMP sets the broad threshold of what you can build on any particular property. And your then subsequent approvals sets the exact amount of development. So it can always be less, you know, through zoning or the environmental review process. And there are members of the environmental team that are here that can help answer questions as well.

SPEAKER_281:47:14

Yeah. So I understand what you're saying in terms of, you know, we're setting a cap. And if the, during their permit application process, it's determined that a lesser number is recommended, then they would ultimately be bound by that. But I'm still a little hesitant personally, inserting a number under a CDMP application for items that seem to be governed by another body, right? I'm a little bit unsure as to why that limitation is being placed in our CDMP application. If I know what you're saying, it falls within the footprint, right? But it doesn't seem to me that we should be opining on something of that nature.

SPEAKER_251:48:02

Yeah. And I understand the, I guess, the concern. You can look at it this way. The CDMP application sets a maximum. Under no circumstance would you be able to attain more, right? It can always be less based on the subsequent processes, whatever they dictate, but it cannot ever be more than what the CDMP is setting as the maximum threshold, right? So from that perspective, it's a good thing that we're including the caps here, right? And then the permits will ultimately determine the ultimate development. Will it be less than what is stated as the cap, right? Or will it be up to that cap? So, you know, I see it as a positive thing, imposing limitations. And, you know, our analysis has gone through evaluation of potential impacts to the environmental resources within the submerged lands, as well as on the application, the CDMP application site as well, right? So, yeah.

SPEAKER_281:49:14

Final question just for clarification. So the final 200 and, is it 295? That final number, was that proffered by the applicant or was that proffered, that specific figure proffered by the county?

SPEAKER_251:49:28

So I guess a nuance I must make clear, when you say the applicant, the applicant in this case is park and rec, right? So it's the county, right? So, you know, in resilient aquarium LLC is the, I guess, contract lessee under the terms of the lease. Let me use that term, right? So, or should we say the proposed lessees in this case, right? It's ultimately their development proposal, right? And, you know, it started out with the 325 wet slips, reduced now to 295.

SPEAKER_221:50:12

Vice Chair Thomas, a question.

SPEAKER_261:50:17

Just as a follow-up, I think what you're hearing from some of the board members is some uneasiness because of the very unusual set of facts that we're supposed to opine on. So, for example, you're telling us that we're only looking at a application that is upland, but we're going to consider things that are not part of the upland. And it includes a maximum number. So it's not like a apartment complex that we're looking at where you're capping the number of units per acre. That's part of the application itself. This is something that's not part of the application, right? If I'm getting it correct, but we're going to be making a recommendation on something that's not part of it. And then to further complicate things, I think I heard you say the current land use would allow for what's being proposed, but we're doing it because of some other reason. Did I get that right? I just want to clarify and make sure because there's a lot of moving pieces and I want to make sure we're...

SPEAKER_251:51:34

Yeah, correct. Now, let me say that, you know, we started as staff, started from a position of discomfort as you're expressing here as well, right? But having gone through analysis of the application, right? And with the covenant conditions, you know, we are sensitive to ensuring that whatever happens here is not damaging to Biscayne Bay or to the environmental resources and, you know, that the manatees are protected and so forth, that ultimately the project is a good steward of the area and the property, right? That's a primary objective.

SPEAKER_261:52:18

We recognize that. I think it's really more a process trying to understand why we're looking at pieces of this that don't seem logically like we should do.

SPEAKER_251:52:27

So I will say the fact that the application, the overall project has a component, which is the marina, of which a part is on the application site and the remainder is abutting but not on the application site. Our analysis looked at the marina as a whole and evaluated with the question of under what conditions would we ultimately or could we be ultimately okay with this marina development? And that's given rise to the various conditions that's included within the covenant. Right? And the language that, the changes we recommend to the language.

SPEAKER_261:53:20

And the... I understand that and that's all well and good. Is there a technical reason why the marina is not included as part of the CDMP recommendation? I mean, we're including it but we're not including it. I'm just trying to understand why.

SPEAKER_251:53:38

The water, the submerged lands are designated water on the CDMP land use map, right? And that designation already allows for marina and water dependent uses, right? Subject to the very same policies that we've evaluated this application against up to this point. So, you know, the designation change is not needed to accommodate the wet slips, right? And, you know, the application, I guess, or review of the application, we took into account, right? The link between the uplands and the submerged lands. And, you know, we took a more holistic view to our analysis of the application, not just the footprint of the CDMP acreage, but we looked at also how would the marina operate as far as, you know, impacts on the Bay Area as well. And we took that into account in analyzing the application.

SPEAKER_221:54:57

Right. Any other questions here for staff before we get to the applicant?

SPEAKER_231:55:01

Just one follow-up on that, right? Roger. So, kind of getting back to the original question of, you know, this being permitted, right, and you can have this marina under the current CDMP without this special district, right? Is there, under the current, is there a cap on the number of slips in the marina? Because this would, so this would be something new in the special district pursuant to this covenant that's being attached to it that doesn't exist in the current CDMP.

SPEAKER_251:55:32

Yeah. And Mr. Rogers, thank you for that question because it highlights the fact the current allowance does not have a cap, right? The special district would impose one.

SPEAKER_231:55:42

Okay. Thank you.

SPEAKER_221:55:44

All right. I think if we can now hear from the applicant. Thank you, Mr. McCall.

SPEAKER_291:55:59

So, good afternoon. Thank you for your time today, Mr. Chairman, members of the Planning Advisory Board, County Administration, and everyone joining us. My name is David Martin. I'm the CEO at Terra. I want to begin by thanking you

SPEAKER_301:56:12

and for this opportunity today. Today represents an important milestone

SPEAKER_291:56:17

and what has been an extraordinary journey, not simply to redevelop the Miami Sea Quorum, but to recognize, you know, what this extraordinary piece of Miami's waterfront, you know, can mean for our community and future generations. For more than 70 years, the Miami Sea Quorum has been part of it, of the history and identity of Miami-Dade County. For generations of families, it was a place of discovery, education, childhood memories. It introduced countless children to the wonders of marine life and to the extraordinary natural environment that surrounds us. But we also recognize that this aquarium history is complicated. The facility has deteriorated, its operations have become outdated, and the expectations

Speaker1:57:00

of our community, particularly around animal welfare,

SPEAKER_301:57:03

environmental stewardship, and public access have fundamentally changed. We cannot simply recreate this aquarium of yesterday. We need to revitalize it. We have a responsibility to create something better for tomorrow, and that is what brings us here today. When we began this process over a year ago, we understood that a property this important in a location, this environmentally sensitive, required a very different approach to development. We knew we could not approach this as simply another real estate project. We had to approach it with civic responsibility. Over many months, we've engaged extensively with environmental organizations, community stakeholders, marine scientists, public officials, and the Miami-Dade County administration, from transit to RER to parks to planning and zoning. We participated in countless meetings and presentations, workshops, conversations. Some have been supportive, and others have been challenging. And many have required us to reconsider aspects of our original proposal. For instance, that 295 number, we worked on a lease amendment where potentially we could reduce it to 262, and that's actually adopted in the amendment to the lease that we're currently negotiating with the county. But that is exactly what meaningful community engagement is supposed to accomplish, right? We didn't enter this process believing we had every answer. And just a quick answer, the marina has designed an area that's already dredged. In the 1940s, this property was dredged. That's been the cap and line where we designed the wet slips, not beyond that. There was additional lands that we could have used, but we limited it to the number of piers. There were like eight piers, and potentially, if we get the state to approve, we may be able to go to 262 with only five piers. This is not the same proposal we started with. It's a better proposal because of the people who participated in the process. We've listened to concerns about the protecting Biscayne Bay, seagrass, manatees, boating safety, marine operations. Currently, there are several boats that are around this aquarium, currently prop scarring and discharging in the bay. We're going to have, you know, several, several navigational channel improvements. We're going to have marine patrol. That's going to be four slips for marine patrol, plus a substation for public safety. And we work collaboratively with the county administration and our environmental and technical teams to translate that input into those changes. What is particularly important about today's presentation is that these conversations have not simply resulted in promises or aspirational statements. They've helped shape the proposed lease, the environmental conditions, the CD&P declaration, and also a covenant that will guide the future development and operation of this property. These documents address issues from limitations on dredging to protecting sensitive marine habitats to public waterfront access, marina operating standards, clean marina certification, environmental monitoring, and historic preservation. We've reduced and refined the marina program and footprint. We've incorporated protections for seagrass and marine life. We have a great restoration project we're working on, provided public safety boating facilities and a comprehensive approach that environmental stewardship. We're proposing a continuous public baywalk, new open spaces and opportunities for families to experience Biscayne Bay without purchasing a ticket. We've established a science advisory council involving leading researchers from University of Miami to help inform our environmental strategy, fisheries experts, coral experts, aquaculture experts. We've committed to pursuing innovative restoration initiatives, including living shorelines, working with local company called Kind Design that's going to be working on the living seawall, hopefully. Corals, coral sodding and transplantation that we're going to be doing. Sponges that are going to be, all the docks are going to have sponges and they're going to be, which is one of the best water quality solutions. Oysters that we're going to be creating next to the oyster wetlands that are going to be able to filter all stormwater. And these are ideas that we want to pilot for hopefully more waterfront development whenever it occurs, that we start doing, using green infrastructure for this, you know, with the ambition of making this site a model of how development and environmental restoration can work together. We also recognize that environmental stewardship requires good intentions, clear standards, ongoing monitoring, transparency and accountability. You know, our other land use and environmental attorneys will walk you through these provisions in greater detail today, including the distinction between our binding requirements and environmental initiatives. You know, community engagement is real meaningful in this project and I want to sincerely thank all the environmental organizations and everyone here, community members, county staff, who've devoted their time and energy to making this proposal better. We may not agree on every issue, but I believe we share a common objective, a healthier Biscayne Bay and a better future for this extraordinary property. I also want to speak briefly about what this opportunity means to me personally. As a lifelong Miamian, I believe our city is recent and poor moment. It's an evolution. We're no longer a city, just a growing city. We're becoming a global city and with that growth comes a responsibility to think beyond our individual buildings and projects. We must ourselves, you know, what kind of community we want to leave behind, what are the public spaces we're creating, how are we protecting the natural environment and making Miami so special? You know, what experiences, institutions and places are we creating for our children? The Miami Sea Aquarium gives us that opportunity to answer those questions. University of Miami will have a conservation and education center with a coal futures lab at this location. Imagine a place where a child can walk along the water with their family, discover marine life, learn from real scientists and develop an appreciation for the environment that will stay with them for the rest of their lives. Imagine a waterfront where historic landmarks are preserved, where residents can enjoy the shoreline without paying admission, where science, education, recreation, conservation come together. Imagine transforming an aging, deteriorating facility into a living lab, a place that not only teaches people about the environment but actively contributes to understanding and restoring it. That is the future we're working toward. Our ambition is not to simply build a better aquarium, to create a new relationship for our community in Biscayne Bay at this location, a place where families can reconnect with nature, education inspires stewardship, public access and environmental responsibility central to the experience. And where future generations can look back and say we took an extraordinary opportunity, something meaningful within it. I recognize that today's hearing is ultimately about land use, planning policy, environmental protections and commitments and conditions and those specifics associated with this application. We respect the importance of this review. Our team has worked closely with several departments and county staff and the administrator to develop a framework that we believe responsibly revitalizes, provides public benefits of environmental protection. We understand that this is not the end of the process. There will be additional reviews, permitting requirements, a whole regulatory process way beyond this engagement with State Department of Environmental Protection, Army Corps of Engineers, Fish and Wildlife, just so many different organizations and regulatory organizations. And our commitment to engagement will continue. But I hope as you consider the application today, you see more than a land use amendment. I hope you see an opportunity to turn a difficult chapter in Miami's history into something positive, enduring and worthy of this extraordinary place. So that is the responsibility we've embraced and that is the opportunity for us today. With that, I'd like to turn the presentation over to our land use council, Brian Adler from Bills and Sundberg. He will walk you through the CD&P application and planning framework followed by our environmental council and advisor who will help explain the extensive environmental protections and commitments incorporated into the proposal. Thank you guys. Thank you so much. Thank you, Mr. Martin. Oh, you're recognized, Mr. Rath. Yeah. Just do want to highlight one thing. I know we've got a ton of people that have taken time to come down here. So if we could just keep it moving so we could get to everyone. All right. Thanks.

SPEAKER_312:05:20

Good afternoon, Mr. Chair. For the record, Brian Adler with Law Offices at Bills and Sundberg, 1450 Brickell Avenue, Suite 2300, here on behalf of Resilient Aquarium, which, as has been noted, is an affiliate of Terra. Aside from David Martin, the CEO of Terra, we also have Lily Alvarez and Gabriela Krutzenberg from Terra. You're also going to hear from several other individuals that are joining me today. We've got Dennis Kerbell and Spencer Crowley from Ackerman. Dennis also does land use. Spencer focuses on the marina. We have Noah Valenstein from Brightwater Strategies, John McWilliams, the traffic engineer from Kimley Horn, Hernando Navas, the civil engineer from Shwepke Shishkin. Don't worry, not everybody's coming up. I'm just letting you know our team that's here that's also here to answer any questions. Kirk Lofgren from Ocean Consulting and Brian May from Capital City Consulting. I appreciate the opportunity to present today and I know you want to keep this moving. So luckily for you, a lot of my presentation was already done by staff and through the questions. So you do get a little bit of a pass on some of that. I'm going to see if I can. Okay. So you heard David Martin's vision of how to revitalize this asset. This asset, and as is noted, it is a county asset and that's why the county is the applicant. Historically, this had been recognized as the third largest income-producing asset in the county by the lease. That lease is in bankruptcy right now. It is shuttered. This is an opportunity, a once-in-a-generation opportunity to really revitalize and upgrade this aquarium. I know you're all familiar with the location of this aquarium. It is the gateway to Key Biscayne. As you traverse, either from the shoreline or from Key Biscayne, the Golden Dome stands out and that's going to be something that is celebrated as part of the application. So you've heard that this has been in existence for over 70 years. The Buckminster Fuller Dome was designed in 1960. It is a geodesic dome that is being preserved on site. It is going to be repurposed and it's going to be revitalized to its glory and surrounding it's going to be a lawn that's able to be utilized for it as well. This says, 1963, Miami's first monorail opens. It was actually the United States' first suspended monorail, first suspended rail in the United States. So we all know the history, the stories, we've seen the articles. It is ripe for redevelopment and to take it to the next level. One of the questions that was asked by Board Member Montiel was how did you go from the 325 slips down to 295? This slide shows you. It was determined that this area could be more sensitive. One and a half peers were removed. That brought that number down from 325 to 295 and you can see the elimination of those peers. So it was not a random number. It was actually a number based on a review and evaluation of the conditions out there and a determination made after input from the community to say, okay, we're going to lower that number to 295. You mentioned that you normally see two applications or the intermix of the zoning and the land use. This is an intermix of, it's intersectional between many different levels of government from planning, zoning, administrative, because there's going to be an administrative site plan review, environmental, state, and regulatory permits. That is all involved. So what you have in front of you is the left side is the CDMP application. That is for the uplands. The right side is the zoning application. And that's not what's here before you, but this is to present to you because I know that's something that you also stated you were interested in, so I'm just going to spend a moment to say the uplands is outlined is the same as the CDMP, as the zoning uplands that's going to be the subject of a rezoning to Red Pad. The other area is the submerged lands. As you look at other marinas in the county, whether it's haulover, whether it's Crandon, whether it's Black Point Marina, the waters remain designated water. In the comprehensive plan it says your water-based facilities is based on and attached to the uplands. And I'm going to go into some of the other questions that you raised as you were going through. So this is, I think, one of the things you said is we like to see what the existing land use is and what the future is. The left shows you right now the property has got two designations. One is Parks and Recreation. The other is Institutions, Utilities, and Communications, often for FPL or University of Miami, those type of institutions. What is being proposed is this Aquarium Activity Area Special District. So the question was what is a special district? Why are we going to special districts? This is not the first special district. This is the text from the code. A special district on the CDMP land use plan map comprises areas with unique characteristics where special land use provisions are warranted. Special districts may be approved on properties that are inside the UDB and a minimum of 10 acres. What a special district does is you carve out the limitations. So you go to most designations, business and office. It allows a whole host of uses, industrial, a whole host of uses. And residential. And then there are some mixed use ones. But this is one where we have a theme park, we have marinas, we have conservation, education. This is a mix. And what a special district does is it allows you to create the district and impose the limitations. So the ones that you may have recalled, the most recent one is, there are three recent ones you may know. Lotham Trail, that's the most known one. Lotham Trail, for those of you who are on the board, that was a special district. The West Naranja Bus Rapid Transit Multifamily Access District was a special district, and the West End Princeton District was a special district. This is creating an additional special district. One of the things that came out was, and what was being discussed, the CDMP imposes a maximum limitation. It is not granting the uses. The uses are granted through zoning applications, environmental permitting, ASPR, and all the other intersectional county divisions that review applications. What this does is it sets maximum. So, for example, in the comprehensive plan, the maximum FAR is 2.0. This imposes a limit lower than that, at 1.5. If that wasn't in there, it would be 2.0. With regard to the wet slips, as Mr. Rowe noted, properties that are designated water are eligible for marinas. Right now, there is no limitation on the marinas. What the comprehensive plan does, what you're seeing is, oh, this is what's being permitted. It's actually an imposition of limitations of maximums that can be sought under the comprehensive plan. The companion zoning application, so while this is a 1.5 FAR, the companion zoning application has a 0.73. What this says is, in 2060, if you come in and want to redevelop, you can't go above that 1.5. The 295 slip stays in the, these are all, unless there is an amendment, these are the limitations that are in there. It does not guarantee that you're approved. You still must go through, and it does not at all circumvent the regulatory authority of the county, and that's been reiterated, I think, even in the declarations as well. I'm going to go back one more again. Oh, I'm not sure. Oh, here we go. Okay. So with regard to the special districts and why not leaving the status quo, the litigation was brought up. The litigation stemmed from a 1991 approval. At the time, comprehensive plans are governed by many different things and what can be approved, but its genesis is from state statute, and there used to be administrative codes and state statutes, but these dictates, and there still are administrative codes, but language has changed over time. At the time of that review and approval, it said you must have specific standards, et cetera, within the comprehensive plan. Those are not in the parks and recreation. That's been changed over time and loosened to general standards, but if we were to stay parks and recreation, we would have to write in standards into the parks and recreation category, which could potentially open the door for other reviews or standards or changes within the parks and recreation category. Sorry. By creating a special district, you are saying, this district is this area, it is on this property, and this property cannot seek approvals above those numbers. Again, the numbers that are being sought are much less on the square footage side than is in the comprehensive plan because your comprehensive plan sets your upper limits. In business and office, your upper limits would be 2.0 and others. This is, again, just imposing some artificial lower standards. I'm just seeing if there were any other questions that I missed that were addressed. So I'm not going to, most of my next few slides have been addressed by staff and the amendments. I've just bolded some of the areas so you can see what is required or what is provided as what can be in the district. And these are categories. So one is an aquarium. That is something that actually will be provided. This is this aquarium. It will have a no marine mammal aquarium. That's one item. And then interactive. So this is going to be a theme park. Education, conservation, research. You heard Mr. Martin talk about a science council being led and members are from the University of Miami and other members in the science field. And then preservation of the iconic aquarium dome and the flipper house. Historic preservation is part of your comprehensive plan. As you know, this property has gone into disrepair. Many buildings have gone into disrepair, need to be demolished. The iconic dome is being saved and repurposed, as is the flipper house. Those are the, a lot of the other items like the whale pool, those are things that you're not looking to preserve or to save. And again, this just details, as it's in your staff report, the other items that are within the application. And I'm not going to repeat what staff went through, so if you don't mind, I'll just go a little quicker. Okay, so this is an illustration of what is the comprehensive conceptual plan of what's proposed to go through zoning. You've got the marina and dry stack. So you've got a dry stack that's toward the top of the screen. To the left of that is the kayak launch. Mr. Martin referenced the bay walk. Very often, if a property doesn't meet certain conditions, they provide a bay walk. And that bay walk is often six feet through going through different things. That's not the case here. This is a bay walk that's being provided because this has been, as you know, as has been noted, the county is the owner of this property. There has been a lot of input from every division of the county, much more so than probably most applications, and including historic preservation. The Buckminster Dome and Flipper House are being preserved. There's going to be a marker, photographs, and documentation of the structures that are on site, even those that are not going to be preserved. Traffic, transit, etc. One of the things is the bay walk. And this is something that's very interesting for parks. It is an 18-foot wide bay walk that goes from around the entire shoreline. There will be two connections for pedestrian and bicyclists. One on the eastern side and one on the western side. The eastern side by Hobie Beach, and then the western side may either connect through near the Research Conservation Center toward the Education Center you see, or it may be able to connect, if possible, with Rosenstiel and create an even larger bay walk. As shown, the shoreline bay walk is almost three-quarters of a mile wide, long, 18 feet wide. When you connect it to the streets, as currently proposed, that's a .97. So we'll call it a one-mile walk there and back with the majority of that on the bay. That is a public amenity that is not enjoyed by the public here and I would dare say almost anywhere in the county. This is something that has been committed to at many different levels. The kayak launch will be a free public kayak launch on there. As you go around, there's going to be a fisherman's village. This will have restaurants, sea marine-themed restaurants, again, the preservation of the Buckminster Dome. This was the Sea Lion Dome. This will not be the Sea Lion Dome. This will be for events. Imagine art shows that may be placed there. Imagine weddings being placed there, markets, different things. It is surrounded by a large lawn that extends that space. The immersive marine and aquatic-based experiences, which you'll see a little bit shortly. Obviously, the marina. And then wellness centers, a lagoon. There is a mangrove lagoon that's currently on site that is staying, that is being preserved on site. And actually, there's opportunities to enhance it. And then, again, the education center. The idea is not to come in and create a better situation that is there now, both for the asset itself, but for the bay. And we're going to hear from some of our experts on some of the things that are being proposed. But for the bay, for the public, for the experience, for the education. This shows some of the items that are being proposed on site. So there's going to be a lot of green space. Off the baywalk will be Pocket Park off the baywalk. As part of the lease, there's a commitment to increase native canopy by 30%. There's going to be shade trees, trees over the baywalk. The baywalk is called an ocean walk here. An aquarium, which we'll show you shortly. The golden dome, which I've mentioned. The education center, which will also allow public participation and review and educational experiences for children and families. A Miami wave pool. Restaurant space that features both inside and outside, really celebrating its location on the bay with views of all places. The harbor house and art installations. The golden dome has a lot of possibilities for the future. So these are some of the commitments that we discussed. The three-quarter mile baywalk. That's going to be open to the public at no charge. It's going to be open from sunrise to two hours after sunset. For safety reasons, that's a minimum. There may be times it's extended. But for safety reasons, it's anticipated to be closed overnight. But it's going to be open to the public free of charge from morning until two hours after sunset. A commitment in the lease to expend a $10 million minimum on this. We believe those numbers are going to become significantly higher. than that. That's your floor. We mentioned the baywalk, so I'll just go through a little quickly. These are pictures, renderings of what's anticipated. This is the kayak launch off the baywalk. There's a bicycle lane, which you can see on the left. There's pedestrian walking lanes. This is a section for the kayak launch, so you can see how it works. And again, the 18-foot-wide baywalk is adjacent to it, so it's really an extension of that. This is the fisherman's village with markets, the aquarium and marine-themed markets and restaurants. We're going to have a close-up of that. So education and public view of the water and of some of the concepts that are being explored is throughout the entire length of the boardwalk. Within this aquarium itself, so there's a ticketed and non-ticketed area. This is within the area. This is within the ticketed area, but this is this aquarium trail. It wraps around the dome. It wraps around the aquarium. And the idea is to connect it from the aquarium and kind of create this spine, if you will, for the site and interweave all the different components together, always celebrating the aquarium and the marine life. This is what it's intended to look like, shaded from the elements. The aquarium, they're seeking to bring an accredited aquarium to Miami. I recently was in an accredited aquarium elsewhere, and it was such a draw and such a great experience. And that's something that we do not have here in Miami. And you can probably think of places that have it, like Georgia, Sydney, Boston. This would put Miami on the map with aquariums. The Golden Dome we've spoken a bit about, but that's the lawn area. So there's a lot of possibilities with the lawn area. That's just some ideas. The idea would be art installations as well. This is, I'm not going to go through everything on the, if you give me a second, I can't see the slide number on the bottom. Okay. So this is, this is, this is for the aquarium. And you can see, again, the aquarium is the anchor, but it's anticipating to bring all the different components along the baywalk, et cetera, to connect it with the aquarium, not just to create an aquarium that you just go, go look at and say, oh, there's, there's glass and there's tanks. It's actually to learn about and some of the things that they're seeking to do. Underwater observation, time-lapse imagery, as well as, as real-time imagery. So time-lapse imagery, coral growing over time, things like that, that are within the, within the water. And then again, connecting it to different areas within the site. I mentioned the restaurant earlier. Restaurant, again, toward the bay, but also able to see other places, slightly elevated in areas, so you can actually observe other areas within the park. Again, open-themed, open-themed restaurant and covered areas outside. That is the location of the restaurant. And that's, that's a rendering of what it would look like. The harbor house. This is more than a traditional harbor house. Commitments are being made to allow a 1,500 square foot substation to be utilized for public safety on site. And that would be provided to the county at, at no rent for the site. And, as well as tenant improvements, those are things that are being worked through right now to provide additional public safety on site for the county. and I'm going to turn it over.

SPEAKER_332:25:30

Yep.

SPEAKER_302:25:31

And if we could just keep it as brief as possible, we've got a lot of speaker cards here. I think, I think we should, we should run. I'll just try to be as quickly as possible here. This slide's important, guys. It's, it's, members, this is a property that was dredged in the 1940s. the, it's aquarium property was artificially filled

SPEAKER_342:25:50

in the 1940s. So, this is not a natural environment.

SPEAKER_302:25:55

So, we're, what we're actually doing is, is kind of restoring and regenerating

Speaker2:26:00

the bay with a lot of the fresh water and oysters and coals and,

SPEAKER_342:26:03

and living seawalls that we're working on. This just talks about some thematic living library, you know, you know, how we're working on the living lab. And there's a lot of environmental engineers and, and amazing advisors that are working with us on this project. You know, this is some of the work that we're doing on sponges, on oyster wetlands, on coral sodding, on seagrass restoration. So, really cool stuff that I think is going to be a model for future projects. Here's our science council from University of Miami. Here's kind of an example of the, of the sponges on the bottom left, the oyster wetland on the top left, and kind of how this green infrastructure is working. So these are just some examples that you could see. This is a 3D printed seawall, which is a very unique, a new company that's been building this and, and really very helpful to the environment. Here's another example of that here. And here show, here you show the, the baywalk as well as setbacks and, and kind of all the protection of wetlands and everything else. There is a need for marina slips. Miami-Dade County is probably one of the largest, if not the largest, number of boating licenses in the country from a county standpoint. And we have a limitation on number of slips. Again, our goal is to make this the most environmentally friendly marina and have all these requirements on clean marina certification, improving the markers and navigational channels of the area. Access and mobility, one of the big moves here, the prior sequerum DRA had an approval for 650 slips, PM peak hour trips. We are, our proposal is going to be at 600. So we're looking at a 550 trip count reduction from PM peak hour trips with our target program for what we're developing and all the uses that we've shown you. This just talks a little bit about a lot of our commitments that are embedded in the covenant or in the lease, including no new dredging. That basin language is specific to silt removal that's in this small basin at the site. So it's really, that's the focus there, but we're not dredging around the shoreline and there's a covenant that we'll never be able to do that. We'll have a pump out station, which I think is important currently. There's several boats there. On the weekends, there's hundreds of boats there. We're going to be able to organize and store these boats in an environmentally friendly way and that's our goal and objective. So this just goes through some of those commitments. Here's some of the CD&P declaration and conditions and manatee protection initiatives that we're working on, even though University of Miami's study basically says this is a low manatee zone area based on all their research and analysis. And we have those reports that we've provided the county and Fish and Wildlife as well. Here's just motorboat exclusions. We have a lot of channel locations, a lot of interesting good things that we're doing that are basically conditions that are being imposed upon us that we feel are appropriate and just wanted to share those with you. And obviously, this is all part of the lease, the CD&P and the environmental conditions that I think have been discussed. and so just wanted to kind of fly through this so we could get to the public comment. Here we go. We talked about all this stuff. Waste reduction is we're going to be working on that. Stormwater wildlife coordination, public education. We're going to have boating education as part of the program. It's one of the conditions of our lease as well. And there's a series of environmental objectives that we have to adhere to. And, you know, we're preserving all the mangroves that exist there and expanding those mangroves. And so we could talk a little more about all that mitigation. Just want to speed through it. Thank you, Chairman. I appreciate it. Wanted to rush, run through so we could get to public comment. I really appreciate your time. Have an entire team here for any questions or comments. Thank you so much, guys. Thank you.

SPEAKER_332:30:12

Appreciate it, Mr. Martin and Mr. Adler. Board members, if you have any questions for the applicant. Questions for the applicant. All right. Can we save them until the end of public comment? Let's go ahead and do that after public comment, sure. All right. So I'm now going to open public hearing for application number CDMP 2026-00007. Seeing as to how many cards we do have here, we want to give everyone a chance to speak, but we are going to have to limit it based off the time we have left. So we're going to give everyone a chance to speak. I'm going to start calling you guys two by two. If you can go ahead and start getting lined up. We're going to give everybody at least one minute to respond. All right. One minute to provide your public comments. All right. If we could go ahead and cue that up. All right. So all right. So our first speaker, we're going to call them two by two. First, let's go ahead and get started with Felix Mastelier, who's in favor, and then Julia Pagliades, who's against.

SPEAKER_322:31:22

Good afternoon, Chair and members of the board. Felix Mastelier, 5861 Southwest Miami, Florida. As a five-year-old attending Feinberg-Fisher Elementary, one of the best memories was attending this aquarium. You know, the excitement of the dome and the water, the bay, feeling that up close. Today, the place is closed, as you all know. It looks horrible. It's sad, falling apart. I'm glad that Parks is doing something about it and making a change. They picked a local developer, which makes a difference to me, right? Not somebody from another state telling us what to do. You know, someday, I would like this to become true so I could take my son there. He could create memories with his kids. You know, what I like about it is it creates limitations, protections for the site for good. That takes a place if you agree with the deal. If the deal falls apart, someone else can come and take over the existing lease under bankruptcy and, you know, continue doing these things that are not limited. So, thank you. Please approve.

SPEAKER_332:32:25

Thank you. Thank you for coming down here. Julia, give me just one second. I'm going to go ahead and call the next two, Brian Gomez and Erin Stauber. But, Julia, please state your name and address for the record. Thank you for being here.

SPEAKER_372:32:37

Good afternoon. My name is Julia Poliade, 7928 East Drive, 33141. Today, I'm speaking on behalf of Friends in Biscayne Bay regarding the proposed application. Our concern is not simply what is being proposed but how the county is handling it. This application is proceeding as a small-scale CDMP amendment covering approximately 36 acres of upland property while the associated zoning application encompasses a substantially larger area including approximately 58 acres of publicly owned submerged lands. These are interconnected components of a single project yet the county is advancing separate approval processes without providing the public with a clear, comprehensive picture of the proposal or its implications. The small-scale amendment processes also provides fewer formal opportunities for public and regulatory review than the standard CDMP amendment process. Given the project's scale, environmental sensitivity, and implications for public lands and surrounding communities, we question whether this expedited process is appropriate for a proposal of such a magnitude. The recent deferral of the proposed lease... Thank you very much.

SPEAKER_332:33:39

You go ahead and wrap up if you want to wrap up. Just go ahead. Just make it very brief. I'll give you some time. There's a lot more to say. Wrap it up. Just get a little brief.

SPEAKER_372:33:47

The recent deferral of the proposed lease following last-minute developments and unresolved questions further illustrates the problems with advancing these interconnected decisions. We repeatedly requested publicly advertised interactive community workshops and charrettes involving county staff, the applicant, regulatory agencies, and residents. We respectfully ask this board to recommend deferral of the amendment until the public has had a meaningful opportunity to review the complete proposal, discuss alternatives, and participate in shaping decisions that will affect Virginia King and Biscayne Bay for generations. Thank you.

SPEAKER_332:34:20

Brian Gomez. We have Brian Gomez. So he was in favor. We'll go ahead and get to the next one. Aaron Stauber, Diego Garcia Estrada. Please state your name and address for the record.

SPEAKER_382:34:38

Good afternoon, board members. Aaron Stauber, Bell Harbor. I'm here to ask you to do one thing. Don't allow the county to fast-track this massive sequarium to redevelopment by calling it a small-scale amendment. Under Florida law, this board is the county's local planning agency charged with overseeing the integrity and effectiveness of our comprehensive planning process. Now is exactly where your responsibility matters. The county's asking you to approve this as a small-scale amendment because it supposedly involves only 36 acres of upland. Come on. We all know that's not the whole project. The application contemplates over 56 acres of county-owned submerged land in our Biscayne Bay Aquatic Preserve for a massive 847-boat marina, including yachts up to 200 feet long. That's over 93 acres of interconnected development. The RER staff just said minutes ago that the upland and submerged land are, quote, inextricably linked. The county wants you to consider the marina when discussing all the beautiful benefits of the project, but then pretend it doesn't exist when deciding how much regulatory scrutiny it deserves. How does that make any sense? Thank you. Oh, excuse me. I have a handout I'd like to give you. It contains 15 of the significant environmental impacts that staff, it quotes, the staff reports are not addressed and still are concerned to the staff from the marina that you are asked not to consider in this comprehensive development. Thank you, Mr. Starber. If you get it

SPEAKER_332:36:22

to Ms. Stillings right there, she'll get it to us, all right? Appreciate you for coming down. All right, so we've got Diego Estrada, Diego Garcia Estrada and Amanda Prieto. All right, no, Diego Estrada, he was here in support. You're recognized. Please say your name and address.

SPEAKER_392:36:47

Yes. I live at 13456 Southwest 108th Street, Circle North. My name is Amanda Prieto and I am the Chief Operating Officer for Miami Waterkeeper. We're very happy to see creative solutions that prioritize green infrastructure and improving water quality, but we have serious concerns about the scale, process, and impacts of this application. Today, you're weighing in with the information before you and whether it meets existing CDMP policies. Because we're short on time, I'm just going to pull out two. CDMP Coastal Element 5F states, at a minimum, construction of marinas shall not destroy or degrade seagrass habitats used by endangered or threatened species. 4A says, areas used for congregation and feeding must be protected from human activities. In the reviews before you, staff mentioned this is critical habitat for manatees. Manatees are designated as federally threatened. RER acknowledges there will be direct and indirect impacts to seagrass. Durham says no determination can be made on impacts at this time. I'll wrap up. In fact, Fish and Wildlife recommended the total number of slips, both dry and wet, be limited to 250, but I don't see that in your packet. More time is needed to address these concerns. There should be no peers over this seagrass. We strongly urge you to defer or deny this application today. Thank you. Thanks for coming down, Amanda.

SPEAKER_332:38:14

All right, so we've got next two are Jacobo Quiroz and Maria Guevara. Jacobo Quiroz. Jacobo Quiroz was here in support of the item.

SPEAKER_402:38:36

Hello, I'm Flora Guevara, resident of Biscayne, live at 150 Ocean Lane Drive. For 17 years, I've watched Miami grow. I've been seeing Biscayne Bay pay the price. I spend time by the ocean almost every day. I see the dead coral, the seagrass disappearing, the tides getting higher every year. Biscayne Bay is the jewel in Miami's crown, and we've pushed her to the limit for decades, and today, you are being asked to take even more from her. These are three things about this project that really worry me. First, the marina. This land use change opens the door to a massive marina on 56 acres of public bay bottom, 56 underwater acres nobody sees. There's a big difference between a rendering with a few boats and the daily reality of an operating marina with over 800 boats. That's where the money is, and that's where the damage will be. More boats mean more pressure on a bay where many days we already can get in the water. Second, the process. Month of public meetings, negotiations with little transparency, documents arriving at the very last minute, three public reviews squeezed into one week. This is not a public process. This is a race. Why the rush? This is our land, and this is our decision. So I ask this board to defer this change. Thank you.

SPEAKER_332:39:56

Thank you, Maria, for coming down. All right. So next we have Andrew Gerwitsch and Valeria Donets. Andrew Gerwitsch, Valeria Donets.

SPEAKER_412:40:19

Good afternoon, chair and members of the board. My name is Andrew Gerwitsch, 455 Northeast 39th Street, Miami, Florida, 33137. I remember visiting this aquarium with my family as a child, so this property has always had some personal significance to me. I'm here today to express my support for its redevelopment. I believe this is a tremendous opportunity to revitalize a property that has been underutilized for far too long and transformed it into something that benefits the entire community. Miami-Dade has a limited amount of publicly accessible waterfront, and I think it's important we take advantage of opportunities like this to open up more of Biscayne Bay for residents and visitors to enjoy rather than allowing such a valuable piece of waterfront property to sit vacant and deteriorate. We should continue encouraging responsible investment in our community, particularly projects that create meaningful public spaces, improve waterfront access, incorporate green infrastructure, provide educational opportunities, and include strong environmental protection. I believe this redevelopment is a positive step forward for Miami-Dade County and respectfully urge the board to recommend its approval. Thank you. Thank you, Andrew.

SPEAKER_352:41:25

My name is Valeria Donets. My address is 4600 Southwest 67th Avenue, 33155, and I'm a science coordinator for Friends of Biscayne Bay, and I'm speaking to you in regards to sequerium application. So my background is actually in marine atmospheric chemistry, and I got my degree in an institution that sits on the parcel that is adjacent to sequerium, so talk about somebody who's invested in redevelopment. But we must cover some of the more important things. So on Friday, DERM came out with an assessment, and if you look through that assessment, you don't see a lot of really good things. So for once, there is the marine footprint overlaps with the federally designated critical manatee habitat, which applicants' assessment does not adequately address. DERM also cautions against relying on a single-day manatee survey, county's own observation spanning 1996-2025, document manatee feeding activity and the adjacent shoals. Importantly, DERM note that the marina could obstruct, establish manatee travel corridors, and redirect vessel traffic toward those feeding grounds, increasing the potential for collisions.

SPEAKER_332:42:30

Thank you for coming down, Valeria. Up next, we've got Katie Verona and Gregory Frankel. Katie Verona was here in support. I'll go ahead and skip over that one now. Gregory Frankel was here against the item. We'll go ahead and continue here to Puhan Patel and Rose Harvey. You're recognized.

SPEAKER_422:43:13

Thank you. Good afternoon, Chair and members of the Planning Advisory Board. My name is Poojan and my address is 6861 Southwest 44th Street, 33155. As a lifelong Floridian, I've deeply understood the duty we have as stewards of our land. Development in Miami has been a contentious issue for locals, especially when there is a yearning for infrastructure that serves the public. I understand that a decision this big deserves care and I want it done right as well, but I worry about what happens if the project falls through. We could lose the protections and the plans such as the ban on marine mammals securing public space for civilians like myself to enjoy and loss of lands earmarked for research and conservation efforts. We have a real chance right now to turn this site into something that we all can be proud of and I'd hate to see it slip away to be dredged up. I ask you to move this forward today with a positive recommendation. Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_332:44:06

Thank you for coming down. All right, so Rose Harvey, no Rose Harvey, she was here against the item. Ruth Oviedo and then Cecile Sanchez.

SPEAKER_432:44:29

Hello, Rose Haney, 472 Glenridge Road, Key Biscayne. I'm here to ask you to provide more time so the public can have some input in this massive project. We attended, many of us, like 40 people, attended a meeting last week and there wasn't a quorum so they didn't make a presentation. We didn't get any information. We really need to have input on the plan because I don't know if you've seen the proposal. They haven't shown you where there's like a 100-foot wall with about 500 boats blocking the view of the bay right off Rickenbacker. In addition, many of the boats that are in the marina, they're right near very shallow waters that there's turtles and manatees that are around there and for sure, more boats, you're going to have more propellers damaging the seagrass. Okay.

SPEAKER_332:45:34

If you could just wrap up quickly.

SPEAKER_432:45:36

Okay, I'm going to try to wrap up very quickly. There are already four marinas within a mile in the area. Okay? Just four large marinas. We don't need more boat traffic there. It's like a zoo of boats on the weekend and it's damaging the bay. I request that you get try to allow for an RFP to get some more proposals for that wonderful piece of land that could be a benefit to all the community of Dade County. Thank you.

SPEAKER_332:46:07

Thanks, Rose. So we've got Ruth Oviedo and then Rob Piper. I'm sorry, man. Did I have you spill out a... It's all right. Did you have a speaker card filled out?

SPEAKER_442:46:22

Cecile Sanchez, you called me. Cecile, I did call you.

Speaker2:46:24

My apologies, Cecile. If we could queue up the clock for Cecile,

SPEAKER_442:46:27

you're right. 260 Cypress Drive, Key Biscayne. I come again to ask to deny this application. If I can say what I would like is for that to be a park for everybody in Dade County to enjoy. We don't need that monstrous marina there. We still haven't seen a diagram of this massive storage for boats. We're talking about 500 and some boats that are going to be dry docked right there next to the causeway. People go to Virginia Key. They go to the beaches in Cranglin Park and Cape Florida. They go to enjoy the outdoors. We're so lucky where we live. We don't want this commercial space there. You're going to disgrace. It's going to ruin Virginia Key. Apart from that, as a resident of Key Biscayne and I'm 80 years old, I and many are scared to death of what's going to happen with the traffic jams. Please, let the community have a say on all of this. Thank you.

SPEAKER_332:47:44

Thank you, Cecil.

SPEAKER_362:47:46

All right, you're recognized. Good afternoon, folks. My name is Rob Piper, 1401 Southwest 17 Terrace. Yeah, I just wanted to speak. Please bear with me as I am not an expert. And now I guess that, well, it's a good thing that environmental and wildlife concerns have been addressed in this plan. Only, well, as I understand it, no impact studies have been done on these proposed land use changes, at least not that I'm aware of. If I'm wrong, I apologize. And I do know that the Virginia Key Advisory Board actually voted on a resolution against this entire project, as well as the Commission's Recreation, Tourism, and Resiliency Committee voted to defer approval of the said lease. So I would just ask that at minimum, vote against the land use changes, or at least defer until there can be some serious, transparent, and robust public review of this lease and the impacts that potentially could come from these land use changes. Thank you.

SPEAKER_332:48:52

Appreciate it. All right. Ruth Oviedo, I think I've called before while she was here in support. Sofia Castillo. Sofia Castillo is here in support of the item. Charlotte Balcells. Let's go with Sofia first. If you could please state your name and address.

SPEAKER_452:49:26

Hi, good afternoon. My name is Sofia Castillo. My address is 11450 Southwest 75 Terrace, Miami 33173. I'm coming before you, Mr. Chair, representing myself, representing my family in support of that development in Key Biscayne, in Virginia Cain. We're coming representing this beautiful development. I have two children. My oldest one was the only one that had the privilege of joining the Seaquarium now closed, the Seaquarium that was open for 70 years and now closed. This beautiful development is going to be for future generations to enjoy. I have smaller, smaller, smallest children that I would like them to come and visit and enjoy with their families, with my, with the little cousins as well. This is a development that is going to bring so much joy for all the families in Miami. We have been residents for over 15 years and we would like to see that coming for future generations. Thank you.

SPEAKER_332:50:30

Thank you, Sophia, for coming. Charlotte, you recognize.

SPEAKER_462:50:35

All right. Good afternoon. My name is Charlotte. My address is 9836 Southwest 193rd Street and I'm coming today as a student from the University of Miami and someone who was also born and raised here in Miami, Florida. One thing that I think everybody complains about in Miami, especially someone my age and my peers, is the lack of third spaces in community and I feel as though this project would offer a perfect solution to that and these third spaces really are integral to strengthening our community and garnering a deep appreciation not just for Miami but for one another and this deal is one that actually, for me, I feel took the feedback of the people and will make it a reality which is not something we really find that much these days and this deal doesn't just mean a renewal of some lease to me. It means seeing my school and my home work towards something that I am proud of and most importantly it's hope and tangible action that shows things can change for the better so I hope the board will approve. Thank you.

SPEAKER_332:51:29

Thank you for coming down and keeping it under.

SPEAKER_472:51:32

Chair, my name is Gregory Frankel. I was called up earlier but I didn't get a chance to speak. I just wanted to have a second. I was an against speaker.

SPEAKER_332:51:51

Yep, I do see it on here. Go ahead.

SPEAKER_472:51:52

Okay, thanks. So Gregory Frankel, I live in Coconut Grove, 2990 Mathla Street and the point I just want to make is not specific to whether this is a good project or a bad project or whether the redevelopment of this aquarium site should happen or not. I think the point I'd like to make is kind of going back to Aaron Staubert's comment which is about the process and I think one of the advisory board members even pointed out earlier this is a very unusual process, right? And so you have to ask yourselves as a planning advisory board why is this highly unusual process being taken? And I think it lies in the small scale CDMP amendment that's trying to be pushed through. And so they're trying to detach the marina because that would put it over the 50-acre requirement and it would, by having a large-scale amendment, would therefore invite state oversight and multiple public hearings and that's what the proponents are trying to avoid. So I would like you to consider that and to consider not putting it through a small scale but maybe putting it through as a large-scale amendment. Thanks.

SPEAKER_332:53:01

All right, so we've got Gaira Belandia and Laura Karam.

SPEAKER_482:53:25

Good afternoon, chair, commissioners, board. My name is Gaira Belandia. I live in 3163 Southwest 17th Street, Miami, Florida, 33145. One of my favorite things about living near Virginia Key is the wildlife and nature beauty of the island. One of the most important responsibilities we have as a community is protecting our environment, especially in a place as unique as Virginia Key. That is why I was glad to see that this project includes protection for wildlife and plants to bring more native trees and plants to the island. And no whales, dolphins, or any other mammals. Obviously, that is very, very important. I believe we can create spaces for our community to enjoy while still respecting and protecting the environment around us. Virginia Key is a special place in protecting its wildlife matters not just to me, but to a future generation who deserve to experience it. So I advise to vote. Yes. Thank you.

SPEAKER_332:54:35

Thank you for coming down. All right. So Laura Karam, she was here in support of the item. Gabriel Mejia and Martha Bomares. Do we have a Christopher Wands?

SPEAKER_512:55:00

You recognize. Good afternoon, chair and members of the Planning Advisory Board. My name is Gabriel Mejia. I live at 16229 Southwest 44th Terrace. I was born in Miami. I was raised here. I've lived here my whole life. And this aquarium was always a large part in making my childhood special and I think the city special. You know, you look around nowadays, you always see kids just looking down at their phones, their faces and devices. And this project is a new chapter and an opportunity. It's an opportunity to bring back a place for families like mine to visit. And I'd love to have a place where one day I can maybe take a family of my own. It's a place where they could learn and enjoy the water without having dolphins or whales in tanks. It also saves a landmark which all of us remember quite fondly. It's a chance to do right by Virginia Key and by Miami. And I hope you'll help us do that by recommending approval.

SPEAKER_502:55:49

Thank you. Thank you, Gabriel, for keeping it under. All right, Mr. Christopher Wands.

SPEAKER_522:55:56

Good evening. My name is Christopher Wands. I live at 7421 Center Bay Drive in North Bay Village, 33141. I'm originally from New York, but I fell of Miami as a kid on Biscayne Bay, later competing on the U.S. sailing team. That brought me to the University of Miami long before the recent wave of Northeasterners, and this is where I chose to raise my family now. Part of the why I support this project is who's behind it. David Martin of Terra was born and raised here in his work from the Overtown Youth Center to reshaping Coconut Grove and redefining our city as a whole. For a city this great, we have very few places where we can eat, enjoy the bay on the water, and this project changes that. With a bay walk, a public marina, and new restaurants, it creates jobs with a ripple effect to local businesses. It protects the bay with no new dredging and permanent marine research with the University of Miami. As a new dad, a new aquarium with no marine mammals is exactly where I would want to take my daughter. I urge you guys to support it. We need this for our city and make our city a better place. Thank you.

SPEAKER_502:56:57

Thank you, Christopher. So Martha Pomares has not, don't think she's here, but she was here in support. We've got Kathy Strafaci and Maria Eugenia Rodriguez.

SPEAKER_532:57:23

I'm Kathy Strafaci from Miami native. I live at 8320 Southwest 52nd Avenue, Miami, Florida, 33143. I'm asking you to approve this measure. I am a long, obviously long-time resident of Miami. I grew up going to the Sea Aquarium in those naive days, enjoyed the thrill of everything I learned and saw there. And though I look back at that with different eyes, with a different mindset, understanding what the environment was and how the animals were treated, I look back at it as it created a lifelong love of the water, that lifelong love of the water is what brought me back to Miami. But what's always been so discouraging for me as I raise my children here is there was never a place for them to learn about the water, to learn about marine life. I had to go to Atlanta, I had to go to Boston, I had to go to Monterey, I had to go to places outside of my own city to learn about marine life. This gives us an opportunity to educate our children in a responsible, meaningful way.

SPEAKER_502:58:28

Thank you. Appreciate you for coming down.

SPEAKER_542:58:33

Should I start? Okay. Members of the board, my comments are not in opposition to the redevelopment of the Seaquarium. I'm in opposition to approving development rights before establishing their legality, environmental consequences, and public safety implications like the one that you stated in your memo about the firefighters. I urge you to recommend deferral until the type project is evaluated. Public land must be governed by the public interest. I don't think the Seaquarium needs a developer and need a philanthropist to become a park. Open to everybody. Thank you.

SPEAKER_502:59:09

Thank you so much for coming today and I think you've got record time, so thanks for that. Sari Shapiro, you're recognized.

SPEAKER_552:59:22

Hello, my name is Sari Levin Shapiro from 7610 Center Bay Drive. I also was born and raised right here in Miami and growing up, remember visiting Miami Sea Aquarium as a child. And today, I do see an incredible opportunity to reimagine this iconic property into something that will benefit our community and the future generations. What excites me most about this opportunity is to transform a shuttered property into a vibrant, publicly accessible waterfront destination. This project will deliver at least $10 million of free public spaces including a beautiful baywalk, green spaces, and greater access to Biscayne Bay for everyone to enjoy. Equally as exciting is the educational component as a University of Miami alum, I am especially proud of the proposed partnership with the University to advance marine science research and the restoration of Biscayne Bay. It also addresses our community's need for more boat slips, but in a safe and regulated manner with a certified clean marina. I believe this is a tremendous opportunity for all of us locals. Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_503:00:30

Thank you so much. All right. I'm out of speaker cards here. Do we have anybody else here in the public that does wish to speak that has not filled out a card? Yep. If you can, just go ahead and come on down, state your name and we'll get the card filled out. All right. If you could please state your name and address for the record and then just get the card in.

SPEAKER_563:00:58

Yeah, I did complete a card. I'm sorry. Good afternoon. Sunless Martin.

SPEAKER_503:01:04

Sunless Martin.

SPEAKER_563:01:04

You're recognized. Biscayne Boulevard.

SPEAKER_573:01:07

Okay.

SPEAKER_563:01:07

Good afternoon, Chair and members of the Planning Advisory Committee. I'm here in support of this project. This is an opportunity to transform an iconic Miami landmark into a world-class destination that benefits our residents and our visitors. The proposed benefits include free park, free public baywalk, marine research, educational facilities, and environmental restoration initiatives represent meaningful economic and community benefits. Most importantly, we have an opportunity to reconnect our community with Biscayne, Bay, while creating jobs, supporting tourism, and strengthening Miami's position as a global destination. I encourage you. I encourage your favorable consideration. Thank you.

SPEAKER_503:01:53

Thank you. Appreciate it. All right. If you could please state your name and address here for the record.

SPEAKER_583:01:58

Good afternoon, Chairman. My name is Luis Stella Cruz, 640 Allendale Road, Key Biscayne, Florida. Although I am a recently elected council member for the village of Key Biscayne, I'm here in my individual capacity and not as a representative of the village. So for Key Biscayne residents, the Rickenbacker Causeway is our essential access route. We need credible analysis of peak weekend traffic, simultaneous events, service vehicles, emergency access, and evacuation. If the applicant says the marina is outside today's application, explain how its associated impacts have nevertheless been included in the analysis of the upland development. Please also explain why this proposal qualifies as a small-scale processing and identify the enforceable restrictions on development and marina supporting uses. Before recommending this change, compare it with an aquarium and public park alternative without the mega marina and restore the community's opportunity for a local hearing. Thank you. Thanks so much for coming today.

SPEAKER_503:03:02

All right. Do we have any other speakers, any other member of the public here wishing to testify on this item? All right. We're now going to close the public hearing. Do we have any questions, any discussion here from the board? Board Member Lawson, you're recognized. Yeah, Mr. Chair. I'm going to go ahead and make a motion and then I guess we can, you know, debate just to get things in the proper posture. So I'm going to go ahead and move to adopt what changes and with the proper declaration of restrictions. Yeah, so we did skip a little bit of questions here so we'll entertain that motion just a little bit. Vice Chair Thomas, you're recognized.

SPEAKER_593:03:43

He got it going. All right. First of all, thank you for everyone who came out, both the applicant as well as the people who wanted to speak on the item. I particularly appreciate the council that came up and addressed all the questions we had related to process. That was very helpful to me. I think I've sat out in the audience and I've listened to PAB hearings before and it's very easy to fall into the idea that this is a zoning hearing and that we get to make an ultimate decision. This is about land use and we get to make a recommendation. We don't get to make the final decision. So I wanted to ask staff some questions related to the comments that were made by the public in particular. There were several people who requested deferral. Having sat up here for a little while, just please confirm that's not an option for us. We don't get to defer items.

SPEAKER_533:04:50

No, the PAB can't defer this item. It's already set and advertised for the Board of County Commissioners meeting on November 19.

SPEAKER_593:04:58

All right. So that is not something we can do. Someone mentioned that it does not contemplate the marina, this application. That was actually the very first thing we started off with was confusion as to why it did. And then council explained why it's included and that's because part of the CDMP includes this water area which allows for marinas. And staff, would you just confirm that that is correct?

SPEAKER_563:05:26

Correct.

SPEAKER_593:05:26

Someone requested an RFP for proposals, additional RFPs for proposals. I hear that. That's not something, would you just confirm that that's out of the purview of this Board?

SPEAKER_533:05:44

Yes, confirmed.

SPEAKER_593:05:47

Impact studies, concerned that this is moving too fast, there haven't been impact studies. Would you describe where in the process these types of impact studies are done?

SPEAKER_603:05:58

I will have to admit I'm not too sure what impact studies are being referred to. And for the primary point that we've done the traffic analysis, we've done the environmental analysis and so forth, so I'm not sure if there are additional studies that's being referred to that we need to look at. I don't know. But at this point, the required analysis has been done, right? And our recommendation is based on that.

SPEAKER_593:06:35

So I wanted to go through and make sure you understood that we heard you, that there are constraints around how we operate as a Board. There are rules that we have. And someone mentioned the unusual process that was described at the beginning. That was not to infer that there was something unusual here. That was because this was out of the norm for us to look at. We don't see things like this on a regular basis. So I wanted to clarify that and make sure that was understood. From a planning perspective, I appreciate that because there already exists the ability to do a marina, that we're going to put some rules around it. So that's helpful. So from a land use perspective, we don't get to look at the project. We're getting a view of it. That's great. And as someone who, as a child, got on the school bus and went to this aquarium and then later on got to follow the school bus to see my kids go to this aquarium, it's near and dear to my heart and it's very special that I get to have a voice on it and make a recommendation. So I'm grateful for that. I'm grateful for the applicant for putting together what looks to be a really impressive plan and thoughtful and forward-looking beyond this generation. I'm grateful to the people who came out and spoke about their concerns about it, of which I'm sure all of those things as we go forward will continue to be addressed and there will be more opportunities to have those discussions. I think it gets lost how much has to be done from all the different regulatory agencies for this to see the light of day. And those are the things that should be done. And I think there will be more opportunity for voices to be heard and those concerns to be vetted. So that's really all I have to say on the item, but thank you. Board Member Gangloir.

SPEAKER_573:08:40

Thank you for those very thoughtful comments because I had a lot of those same thoughts hearing this presentation. And to the members of the public that spoke both for and against it, your time is appreciated and your input is appreciated here. I'm also relatively new. So as was just stated, many of your concerns regarding the rezoning, the terms of the lease, the additional environmental steps that need to take place aren't really before us today. We're here on these land use amendments. So that's the way the county is set up. When I first looked at this and when I saw the renderings, it made me think of Valencia. I happened to go to Valencia earlier this year on vacation and they have a really beautiful aquatic facility that in some instances looks a little similar to some of the things being presented. And it was one of the reasons that made me want to visit there and wanted to see the aquarium and it was fantastic. And like many of you, including the presenter, I'm a native Miamian and also have the memories of going to this aquarium as a child. I did not go there with my own children, but I did have the opportunity to attend many nighttime events, which also took place at this aquarium for adults over the years and realized what an interesting facility that is for events. Looking at this, I think everybody loves the proposal to upgrade what used to be this aquarium, to have a marine facility, an aquatic center, a public baywalk. I think everybody that spoke thinks that's fabulous. I certainly do. Opinions may be mixed on the marine and fishermen's village with restaurants, but I personally think that would be a really interesting and good upgrade for the facility. I think the main point of contention and concern is really the environmental impact and how those particularly wet-slip spaces could potentially impact the environment. I think the presenter has done a good job of trying to mitigate those concerns and presenting what they will do to ensure that the marine life, the manatees, and the corals are not impacted by the facility. But that's not really for us today as I see it. I don't see that we really have a say on what's presently designated as water and what the county commission may ultimately do with regard to those wet slips. But what's before us today is very interesting and timely. It's not perfect, but nothing in life is perfect. And the fact that we have somebody who's willing to put up a lot of money to upgrade that facility is really special today. I think that most of the concerns that we have will be taken up by the county commission, either under their review of the lease or under their zoning considerations. So for today's purposes, I know we're having the discussion. I think a motion was made. I'm going to second it and hear what further comments we may have from this board.

SPEAKER_503:11:52

Thank you. Do we have any other members here wishing to speak? Board Member Rogers?

SPEAKER_513:11:57

I just have a question for the staff. A number of members of the public wondered whether or why this wasn't being done as a large-scale amendment versus a small-scale. My understanding is because you don't need to change the land use of the submerged land, but is there any possibility that this could be or is this really truly a small-scale amendment?

SPEAKER_603:12:21

As it's filed, the application is a small-scale amendment as it seeks to change the land use of less than 50 acres. The state statutes dictates what's standard versus small-scale. For land use changes, any application that's over 50 acres, right? That's standard. So this is less than and so small-scale. The application has been filed as a small-scale. It will continue as such unless the board account commissioners take action to convert it to a standard. That's the only possibility of it being, at this point, being considered as a standard if the board decides to convert it.

SPEAKER_503:13:08

Thank you. Do we have any other questions? Board member from Fitzgerald, do you recognize? No, not talking questions. Discussion, discussion. Are we already on the motion? Yeah, motion or second? See it? Yeah, just making sure we didn't have any other discussion before entertaining the motion. Motion or second? Let's go ahead and, Mr. Montiel, did you have some comments? I have a few comments. All right, let's go ahead. Let's hear Mr. Montiel. I don't know. Carlos, do you have?

SPEAKER_623:13:36

No, I just want, I have something to say. I can't remember.

SPEAKER_503:13:41

I thought you were skipping. I thought you were skipping what you wanted to say. Did you want to, all right, we'll go ahead and hear you first and then, no, no, no, we're not arguing the motion now. It's just discussion. We're not discussing the motion. We're discussing the motion. No, we haven't, we haven't had any substantive discussion here on the motion.

SPEAKER_623:13:59

Would you like to,

SPEAKER_503:14:01

would you like to jump in after, after we hear from Mr. Montiel? So then you can discuss the motion.

SPEAKER_623:14:05

Are we asking questions or are we discussing the motion?

SPEAKER_503:14:07

Discussion. It's just discussion. He made the motion before anybody had a conversation or a comment.

SPEAKER_623:14:11

I know. So we're just, we're discussing the motion.

SPEAKER_503:14:13

No, the motion hasn't been entertained.

SPEAKER_623:14:15

When you start discussing the motion.

SPEAKER_503:14:17

Okay. All right. Let's go ahead. Mr. Montiel.

SPEAKER_613:14:21

I'm confused as well, but I'd like to make some comments as well. I do appreciate everybody coming down here and I think that this is a project that has a lot of great aspects and I'm hesitant to, to look for the perfect project because we're going to be waiting forever. And so I, I do like the, the aquarium aspect. I do like a lot of the public aspects. I especially appreciate that it's a local developer, somebody with David Martin's experience. And it's clear to me that he cares about the city. And that means a lot to me in terms of, it takes a certain amount of faith on our end to, to evaluate a project like this. I also feel at the same time hesitant about the environmental aspect. Everything that we've read in our materials seems to indicate that there are additional environmental concerns that need to be addressed. I don't think that it's our place to do so, unfortunately, because I, I feel strongly that those need to be addressed. I'm aware that several of these things will be addressed during the permitting processes and et cetera, et cetera. But I, I think it's important that we put it on the record and hopefully the county commissioners will evaluate this that I believe strongly that this has not been fully vetted on the environmental side. Despite the, I believe, good faith, you know, what should I call them? The, the good faith proposition from the, from the developer that, that these environmental studies will be carefully considered. I do believe that to be true, but it's difficult for me to push it forward without having a full analysis as is. But that being said, I don't think it's within our purview or within our ability to do so, considering that marina already has, or water already has the ability to, to produce this marina. So, I'm hesitant about it. I'm hesitant about the traffic to Kiva Skain as well, but it seems to me that those need to be determined by other agencies and not necessarily by our view. And because of that, you know, I'm, I'm hesitant, but generally in favor of this project.

SPEAKER_503:16:54

All right. Board Member Fernandez.

SPEAKER_633:16:59

So, I grew up, you know, just like a lot of the board members and a lot of the residents here in the area. And, you know, part of my, I have a hobby and I, my hobby is to collect old postcards. So, I've been collecting vintage postcards of Miami back since the 20s. And you, you look at how Miami's evolved, right? Miami was the playground of, of the, of America, right? We had Sequeria, we had Monkey Jungle, we had Para Jungle. We had all these amazing, you know, things that people came down here to do. And, and you can see that as Miami's grown, we, we haven't, we've lost that kind of playground feel, right? We're, we're a big city, we're a global city. And, and you can see how something like Sequeria eventually started to deteriorate and fade, right? It doesn't attract as many people anymore. There aren't as many tourists as there used to be here. I think Para Jungle was a perfect example of that, right? It, it relocated to an area where people thought it would be even, even be a larger tourist attraction and it didn't do very well. It ended up becoming something of a private public partnerships. I get to be, I get to be involved in a lot of private public partnerships on the housing side. And, you know, it's unfortunate. It's the only way that projects can be sustainable. Not everybody, someone said we need a, a philanthropist that would take care and, and donate millions of dollars to this project. I don't see anybody stepping forward to do that. And I think it's important that when a project like this that is not of a major intensity, nobody's asking to do 600 condominiums here, we're looking to open up the water to open up public land to give it back to the residents. There has to be some sort of component that has to be able to generate money for that to be sustainable. Just the county doesn't have that kind of money and it just doesn't happen on its own. So there has to be a balance between private and public projects. because I think this is as respectable and, um, respectable and as, as, uh, what's the word I'm looking for? Um, honest of a project that we can provide here. I mean, it's really giving back, exposing, opening up Key Biscayne or, or this area to its residents and, and the future in our nation. So I think it's a, it's a great proposal.

SPEAKER_503:19:27

Thank you, board member. Uh, so now we're, we want to speak on the motion or you just want to provide comments? All right, go ahead. You're recognized.

SPEAKER_623:19:34

So I'm going to echo what, what most of them are doing. I'm very much in favor of the project. Uh, I, personally, I know a lot of folks here have an issue with the marinas, except I, I personally believe that this county needs more marinas. There's no marinas been being built in this county for the last 20, 25 years. Now, I talk to some of my friends and they say, we don't need more marinas, but those are the guys, some, most of these are the ones that my good friends, very lucky, live in Gables and State, with their house, the boat behind the house. In order to use this gorgeous bay that we have that goes from here all the way down to the Keys, you have to access the bay. And the only way to access the bay is to build some more marinas. And I know we're looking at the big part of the marina part and the ocean, and the water, but they're also building a great deal of the dry storage. Those allow normal, everyday, 30-footers, 50-footers, 50-footers, no, obviously not, 20, 30-foot boats to go out and access the bay. So I think that this project is, I'm very much supportive of it. I think an icing on the cake, and I know he's here, I'm not, I don't know him personally, but an icing on the cake, and I know what I've read, is that the project is being built by Mr. Martin, which has a reputation in this county. He delivers and delivers and delivers. You know what, that's an icing on the cake, because I would have been in favor with this project the way it is, but that's an icing going to take that again. So I'm very supportive of the project.

SPEAKER_503:21:04

All right, so now, all right, here we go. Board Member Lago, you recognize.

SPEAKER_643:21:10

Thank you, Chair. Just wanted to add my two cents. I wasn't going to speak on the item, but I drive to Kibbiskayan constantly. I'm there five, six times a week, and it's depressing going down the Rickenbacker Causeway. On the left, you have Marine Stadium that's been in the same condition for 30 years, nothing going on, not activated. Maybe you have some concerts going on on weekends. Then you get to Crandon Tennis Center, and as soon as we took out the tennis tournament, the stadium is falling apart, the clay courts have been closed for two years, no activation. What is this going to become? Is this going to become another eyesore as well? We have a very creative project here that's been brought to us by a local developer that's thought of many great things, and this activates the space for all people that live in Miami-Dade County. I think it's a great project, I support it, and I would second that motion to move the project as well. Thank you.

SPEAKER_503:22:07

All right, thank you. So we had board member Laszner's motion, and we did have Mr. Gongora second beforehand, right? Can we go ahead and call the roll on that motion?

SPEAKER_653:22:19

Okay, so the motion as I heard it was to move to adopt with staff recommended changes, and with the proffered declaration of restrictions, and that was, a motion was made by board member Laszner and seconded by board member Gongora. So on that motion, Carlos Diaz-Padron, Ivo Fernandez,

SPEAKER_633:22:45

Yes.

SPEAKER_653:22:46

Michael Gongora,

SPEAKER_633:22:47

Yes.

SPEAKER_653:22:48

Sorry? Yes, thank you. Frank Lago, Max Laszner,

SPEAKER_623:22:55

Yes.

SPEAKER_653:22:57

Michael Montiel,

SPEAKER_623:22:58

Yes.

SPEAKER_663:23:00

Daniel Rogers,

SPEAKER_623:23:01

Yes.

SPEAKER_653:23:02

Vice Chair Thomas,

SPEAKER_503:23:03

Yes.

SPEAKER_653:23:05

Chair McRae,

SPEAKER_503:23:06

Yes.

SPEAKER_663:23:07

Motion passes nine to zero.

SPEAKER_503:23:09

All right, thank you. Mr. Chair, can I move to transmit all of our recommendations to the board of county commissioners?

SPEAKER_673:23:16

All right, moves there, second.

SPEAKER_503:23:20

All right, second by Vice Chair Thomas. All right, Mr. Rural, if we could go ahead and move over to staff announcements here.

SPEAKER_673:23:30

Oh, I was just going to say thank you all for your time and for the input of the community. Thank you, Mr. Adler.

SPEAKER_503:23:35

All right, Mr. Rural, let's see if you can bring us home here with staff announcements.

SPEAKER_603:23:41

So, thank you, Mr. Chair, and at this point just one announcement regarding, just one announcement regarding one prior effort regarding smart plan corridors that Mr. Board Member Thomas had raised. We're looking to address that then with the board

Speaker3:24:00

at the next meeting, right? But beyond that, no additional comments, no additional issues at this point, I guess except to wish everyone a happy Thanksgiving next week, all right, so.

SPEAKER_673:24:15

Absolutely. Well, thank you for that. Oh, sorry.

SPEAKER_663:24:17

One more thing. We'll be sending out to you the application report, the matrix that shows all the applications filed and what you voted on, so we'll be emailing that to you. And then the next and final meeting will be on Monday, December 7th at 2 o'clock, and we're also going to be having on the agenda the PAB elections for the chair and the vice chair. So thank you.

SPEAKER_673:24:45

Thanks. All right. We've got no new business. Board member Lousner moves to adjourn. Do we have a second? Second. All right. We've got a second. Meeting's adjourned. Thank you all for holding tight.