Civic › Jacksonville, FL › November 16, 2026

Rules Committee - Nov 16, 2026

Jacksonville, FL City Council November 16, 2026 149 minutes
▶ Watch original video Interactive viewer Search Jacksonville meetings

Transcript

Speaker0:01

Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the Monday, November 16th, rules meeting. I call the meeting to order, and we'll start with introductions to my left of Mr. Dennis. Good morning, Garrett Dennis, Administration. Colleen Hampsey, Council Research. Harla Schell, Office of General Counsel. Trista Carraher, Council Auditor's Office. Good morning, Jacoby Pittman, District 10. Ron Salem, Group 2 at Large. Ken Amar, City Council District 1. Mike Gay, District 2. Good morning, Tyrona Clark-Murray, District 9. Good morning, Michael Boylan, District 6. All right, thank you all, and Councilman Lannan is excused this morning. So with that, do we have any public comment? Thank you. All right, our first speaker, the Cornell Oliver. Come on down. You'll be given two minutes to speak to an item on the agenda. Give your name and address or say it's on file. Yes, my name is Cardinal Oliver. I want to talk to Cardinal Oliver. Address is on file. I want to speak to a number of items. 2,026-0320, item 2,026-0803. I want to talk about the 1866 Civil Rights Act. And in projects like this, I want to see some compliance and some uniformity. I'm also asking to protect eight—I'm also proposing eight city charter amendments addressing civil rights compliance, oversight commission, community investment fund, and annual audit reports. Public land protections include protection and community assets such as the Charles Booby Clark Park and Poole and reviewing the ordinance of 2026-0808. So all in a nutshell, I had to write this up very quickly. But the thing about it is, is that there are some specific opportunities with the access of development that is happening in this community. And the people in this community that should get first divs are American Freedmen. And the priorities are very clear. I don't have no allegiance. I have—what's the word I would say? I don't owe nobody nothing in this country except myself and my own. If America comes first, American Freedmen come first. And on a local level, change must start here right now. So I'm asking that this committee take in consideration of what I have offered today, and I yield the rest of my time. Thank you, sir. Our next speaker will be Chloe Kuhn. Come on down and give your name and address or say it's on file for the record in two minutes. Sure. Good morning. My name is Chloe Kuhn. My address is on file. And I'm here today regarding the pathways to urban agriculture in support of this and also in support of the amendments renaming market sales to community access days and increasing the number of days to 70. I work for Riverside Avondale Preservation. My role is with the Riverside Arts Market specifically. So I have really seen firsthand how important the local agricultural community is, how well-received it is. But through my role at Riverside Avondale Preservation, we also have a community garden of our own. It's celebrating its 10th anniversary, and it's such a great asset to our neighborhood, to our community, that we really feel that this is something that every community and every neighborhood should have. The increase of the access days to 70 is also really powerful. We see neighbors come to visit. We see neighbors come and learn in the garden. We see them gather. We just recently had a celebration of the garden with, you know, a moonlit pizza dinner, and it really just brought people together. Whether you see those conversations happening, you see people appreciating the garden. And so it's really something that I encourage the committee to consider, that you want to make it as easy as possible for neighbors to enjoy these community assets. And increasing up to 70 would really allow that without any hindrance. So thank you for the consideration, and I see the rest of my time. All right. Thank you. Our next speaker will be Blake Harper. My name is Blake Harper, Information on File. We're taking this opportunity with respect to the board appointments at the library to discuss the policy of the board. This is a policy-level, strategic focus of the board. This isn't a specific book issue. But I want you to see here five books that are in the library that are going to be an example of what we're talking about. If you look down here at the first page I've given you, this is off of the library website. If you look down at the bottom, it says, Inclusion of Explicit Text or Explicit Illustrations or Frankness of Expression. I don't have time to do a show-and-tell on each one of these books. But in this, we're talking about strap-ons and butt plugs and torpedo vibrators and all sorts of graphic descriptions of how those are used. That stuff is not supposed to be available to children. Michael Boylan's left, but when Michael and I and Ron, when you and I were children, it was safe for a child to go into a library. When our children were that age, it was safe for them to go into a library. It's no longer safe for a child to go into a library because they can find a book that has graphic illustrations of sex, sexual activities in the library. They're trying to normalize and drive sex into the children. The bottom line is the children need to be protected. That's what this is about. We need to protect the children. We need to make sure that the policy of the library is not sourced from outside of this community. That's what community standards are. And we need to make sure that they put policies in place to protect the children. All right. Thank you. I'd like to recognize Councilman Arias has joined us as well. Welcome this morning. Our next speaker is Nathan Ballantyne. Come on down and give your name and address for the record or say it's on file. You've got two minutes, sir. Good morning. My name is Nathan Ballantyne. Thank you all for having me. Overalls Farm Grows at 125 East 7th Street. We're here today to support amendments to and then passage of 260807, all about making community market gardens permissible by right in Jacksonville. Due to insufficient code, the community garden at IFAS Ag Extension operating on Superior Street for the last 49 years has never technically had a legal right to operate since it's growing on a vacant lot that does not have another primary use to hide under. As Councilwoman Pittman knows all too well, it took Earth's Farm and Market four years to secure a certificate of use to operate their flagship urban farm to provide community food access, nutrition, culinary, and gardening education within their food desert community. When we planted the seeds to grow our third neighborhood farm in Springfield to feed our community, though we enjoyed a waiting list of well over 100 neighborhood families in the endorsement of over 350 additional community members, planning repeatedly told us that to do so was not permissible without a $5,000 PUD application. While overwhelming community support and state level protections for our agricultural enterprise allowed us to overcome these local attempts to limit our operation, as we've long said, it shouldn't be this hard to grow food with and for our neighbors. To point out the absurd level for our zoning code update that's needed to make community market gardens permissible, allow me to share with you what our zoning on 7th Street currently allows by right. Medical, medical, medical, medical, medical, dental, and chiropractor offices, professional offices, facilities for the production of prosthetics, duplexes, multiple family dwellings, private clubs, schools, churches, parks, playgrounds, and play fields, recreational or community structures, home for the aged and orphans, libraries, museums, and community centers, radio and television broadcasting studios. Thank you. All right. Thank you, sir. Our next speaker will be Jessica Mayer. Give your name and address for the record. Good morning. My name is Jessica Mayer. My address is 234 14th Avenue North Jacksonville Beach. I'm here speaking in support of Pathways to Urban Ag. I represent Dig Local Network, the nonprofit that organizes the Atlantic Beach Farmers Market, the Beaches Green Market, and also innumerable residents and small businesses of Duval County. I also represent the Dutton Island and Jarbo Park Community Gardens in the Beaches Areas. I'm here to earnestly implore the City Council to embrace critical amendments to increase market garden days and allow cross sales among Duval County growers. Through firsthand experiences, I know that legal organized community gathering days will create opportunities to strengthen our local food systems, expand access to nutritious food, and foster the business-to-business sales that keep resources and capital within our communities and local economy. These regular accessible spaces really to conduct and gather reveal our reliance and interdependence with one another. The spaces demonstrate growing practice transparency and facilitate a more informed relationship with the greater food system that help people understand where their food comes from and how it's grown, and the value of participating in a localized ecosystem. I believe the right to collaborate will create economic opportunities, bolster local food resilience, and build connection of people, planet, and purpose here in our region. The locally grown food is sustainable, superior in freshness and nutrient density, and it promises true wealth through generational wellness and prosperity for the individuals in our community. Again, I sincerely ask the City Council to embrace the critical amendments under review, which make this legislation relevant and useful policy for all involved and invested, making neighborhood-friendly community market gardens permissible by Wright & Jacksonville. All right. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Our next speaker will be Mikey Howell. Come on down and give your name and address or say it's on file, and you'll be given two minutes, sir. I'm Mikey Howell. My address is on file. I'm representing Chandanko Farms, and I'm here in support of formerly the Free to Garden Act Ordinance 2026-08-07. So, the group of us that's here today, Jess and I had a meeting over time, unpaid, after the market yesterday, to plan the market manager coalition and Bold City Trusted Growers just to get organized so other markets and other farmers can be efficient and do their job. Nathan has been a mentor of mine, has taught me some stuff about business. He's actually, we've done business together. Lorraine Husband is the reason I have 300 yards of mulch at my farm currently. Jennifer Leggett brought tarps to my house after you guys were code enforcing me, giving me warnings about my intolerable front yard that looked nicer than most of the yards on my street. And Miss Shelley, I worked with at Earth's Farm and Market, Councilwoman Pittman's Farm, and this is just a fluke, right? I just came. I didn't even sign in to be here today, but amongst our organizing. But that's what this is. We just need the ability to do work, right? We work harder than everyone. None of this stuff that I'm talking about is paid, income-based, we're on the clock type stuff, right? Like, this is after we've done our work, before we've done our work. Just to do our work, we have to have extensive conversation, a lot, a lot, a lot of unpaid energy just to do our job. And then to have this be a barrier, it's really, it's tough. Like, unimaginably tough for us competing against the biggest systems on the planet, right? The food system and pharmaceutical system and petroleum. So, please give us a right to do what we need to do. All right. Thank you, sir. Next is Laureen Husband. I'll go down and give you name and address for the record or say it's on file and you have two minutes. Good morning, Council Members. My name is Dr. Laureen Husband. I am the chair of the Duval Food Policy Council and the co-founder of Just Food Network. I would like to thank Councilman Arias for introducing this legislation and I'm seeking your support in the amendments that we are asking for, seeking for an increase to permissible market days from the number allocated right now to 70, at least 70 days per year. Just this weekend, Just Food Network, in partnership with other organizations, we were able to create over 91 residential gardens in 32209. And some of those neighbors have enough space on their farms to be able, I mean, in their backyards to be able to grow enough food to serve that community. What those residents will be asking for, and I'm asking for your consideration, is that they're able to partner with other markets to sell their produce so that they can extend their dollars. Most of those residents in 32209 are either on fixed incomes and this would really drastically increase the ability to support themselves and their families by selling to other markets. So anything you can do to increase affordability for our residents in Jacksonville, especially those in food insecure neighborhoods and others would be greatly appreciated. Thank you for all you do. All right, thank you. Next speaker is Addison Patrick. Come on down and give your name and address for the record or say it's on file and you'll have two minutes. Good morning, everyone. My name is Addison Liberty Patrick and my address is on file. I'm here today to address the legislative text of item number 40, 2026-0931, which is on its second reading, I believe. I am addressing this as a resident and as the appellant in a pending election law appeal before the 5th District Court of Appeal case number 5D 2026-2449, which directly interprets parts of our ordinance code. So this proposed proposal here, 2026-0931, amends how our candidates qualify under Florida Statutes Chapter 99 and how qualifying papers are filed with the supervisor of elections. Because this council is actively rewriting procedural texts of this today, there's a drafting gap in the bill that invites future legislation against the city if left unaddressed. Specifically, in my pending appeal, a circuit court ruled that local charter residency requirements such as the 183-day rule and charter section 5.04 cannot be enforced through the statutory challenge procedures in Florida Statute 99.0211. Yet, just days ago, the 3rd District Court of Appeal reaffirmed that municipal qualifications in Chapter 99 state statutes must be read and applied together, not treated as mutually exclusive. So, I can send more information through email about the specifics here. But before the bill advances to the November 24th public hearing, I respectfully ask that the committee and OGC consider some clarification on the record or via amendment whether incorporating some of these procedures will preserve full statutory enforcement under the Jacksonville Charter Residency Standards under 99.0211. Thank you so much. All right. All right. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Ms. Addison, Mr. Boylan, Councilman Boylan would like to speak to you in the green room. And I'd like to recognize Councilmember Peluso has joined us. Welcome this morning. Our next speaker is Mr. John J. Nooney. Come on down, Mr. Nooney, and give your name and address for the record and address something that's one of the items on our agenda. All right. Hello. I am John J. Nooney, Jacksonville City Council Resolution 2023-0819. I'm in City Council District 4, CPAC Planning District 3, Raymond Day, Duval County Public School District 3, Cindy Pearson. All right. All right. I'll be addressing the Frida Garden, you know, 2026-08-07. You know, amendment number one, revised definitions of community gardens to include land managed and maintained by an entity expanded to a county. Amendment three passed. We're marketing to the world. It's food. It's food. And so here and, you know, tomorrow I'll be in St. John's County. Also, real quick, you know, I'm making a donation right here. It is the 2026-0004. And that's our parks trust fund. And, you know, you know, make it a garden park. All right. Also, two, you know, where is the J-Sub amendment on this? You know, 4-H. Okay. I'm just down to 40 seconds. Also, number eight, 2026-08-09, 900,000. Don't withdraw it. You know, Karen Bowling, Dr. Sarah Lynn Grass. You know, you know, amendment three passed. Warehouse Park, J-Sub Park on Pottsburg Creek. You know, I still need a pardon, by the way. 2026-0928, Al Ferraro, Administrative Services Park on Pottsburg Creek. The Tree Commission. You know, we have 29 million bucks just sitting there. And you know what? You can have an unbelievable orchard with that one. So, anyway. All right. Thank you, sir. Thank you for listening. So going to our agenda, the first items that we'll take up will be on page 14, item number 20. A couple of little housekeeping items before we get into the agenda. I want everybody to have an opportunity to speak, but we're going to go ahead and do the three minutes the first time, two minutes the second time, and then down to one minute just so we can make sure everybody has an opportunity to speak on all of our discussions. So item number 20, 2026-0871. Get a motion on the bill. I've got a motion. I'll get a second. I've got a second. So it's Mr. Christopher A. Jansen here. Come on down, sir, and give your explanation of your desire to serve on the Jack's Human Rights Commission. Thank you, counsel. My name is Chris Jansen, Dr. Chris Jansen. I'm an associate professor at University of North Florida. My address is 4518 Shaky Leaf Lane. I'm an associate professor at University of North Florida. Been engaged in a lot of community work over the years. Had the privilege to partner with the Jacksonville Human Rights Commission by hosting a Gracious Space Conversation in 2025. It would be an honor to support the mission and directives in collaboration with the council to serve as a commissioner. All right. Thank you, sir. No speakers in the queue. All good. Thank you, Mr. Jansen. So I've got a motion and a second on the bill. Let's open the ballot and record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. All right. By your action, you've approved 2026-0871. Thank you, counsel. Dr. Jansen, we'll announce your name after the final vote Tuesday night's council meeting. You're welcome to be here. It's not required. And thank you for your service, sir. Thank you. The next item we'll go to is on page 15, item number 23, 2026-0874. I've got a motion and a second on the bill. Is Monica D. Richardson here? Monica D. Richardson. Good morning. I'm Rudy Jamieson, executive director, JHRC. Monica Richardson should have been here. I'm not sure of what happened. I'll follow up with her and I'll let you all know. All right. We'll go ahead and defer that if it's Mr. Dennis's desire. Okay. I hope so. I'll let you know. All right. So we will defer 2026-0874. Mr. Bullen. Just for the record, I'd exchanged emails with Ms. Richardson a couple of days ago in advance of seeing the agenda. And I was not aware that she didn't meet the 75% threshold. So I'd mentioned I don't know if you need to be at the meeting because unless you didn't meet that. And maybe she didn't know she didn't meet it, but I think I may have led her astray by letting her know she didn't need to attend. Okay. And that's fine. We'll defer it. Thank you. But being that she only had 70%. Yeah. I understand completely. I did not know at the time when we exchanged emails. Okay. All right. No problem whatsoever. All right. The next items we're going to go to are for the council members that are present here. And we'll go to page six, item number seven. Item number seven, 2026-0807. I've got a motion to second on amendment. Ms. Kerriher. Through the chair to the committee. The amendment covers four just technical corrections to the bill. The first one is to revise the definition of community garden to include land managed and maintained by an entity. That would be in addition to individuals or groups of individuals. Just to make that definition consistent with the definition for market garden. We'll revise the definition of market garden to mirror language within the criteria regarding what can be sold onsite. We'll strike the reference to the sale of food or agricultural products within the community gardens criteria, which was inadvertently included in the bill. And lastly, we'll correct some scrivener's errors. Thank you. Mr. Peluso on the amendment. Okay. Mr. Arias on this amendment. Okay. So nobody in the queue on this amendment. All in favor of the amendment, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Likewise. None. The amendment carries. I've got a motion to second on the bill as amended. I've got a motion to second on the bill as amended. Let me go ahead to Councilmember Peluso first. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Chair, for that. Obviously, as you've heard today and you've heard throughout several months, this bill is of great importance to a lot of people in our community. Myself and Councilmember Arias really kind of took this on with the leadership of the administration, so we're very grateful to them and, of course, the community activists. I do have two amendments that were brought to us. I had a meeting with folks on Friday, spoke with our attorneys about it, and they can explain them, but there's two different amendments. One is that we're going to expand the number of market days to 52 days. That's the request. And the second one is that 50% of goods that could be sold on one of those market days has to be from the land in which they work. That allows for cross sales. So I believe that the 52 days is perfectly fine with the administration. I think the cross sales, there's a little bit of concern about actual enforcement of that. However, I think that it's, I don't think it's going to be that much of an issue based on what we've, the conversations we've had with the local farmers here in the community. I asked that somebody take those two amendments up, and I think, I saw Terrence here earlier. I thought that he was drafting it. Unless, Michelle, unless you know, is he in the audience? I can't see. I can't see where he is. Why are you that far back? Get on up here. If you'll allow for it, Chair. I appreciate it. Good morning, Terrence Harvey with the Office of General Counsel. That is correct. But it's my understanding that once the motion is made and done here at the committee level, that the amendment for, that you're proposing will be drafted and presented at a later time. So I don't need to draft it right now in order for them to act on it, but you do need to get it approved first. We talked about it. We talked about drafting. Looking to see if we can get someone to offer those amendments. Thank you. Thank you, Chair. So I would, I guess we could say just moved the 52 days for the market, for market, and then 50% for cross sales. If I... Through the Chair, 50% of goods sold during a market day must be yielded from the land in which they own, allowing for the other 50% to be cross sales. So moved, Michelle. We got a second. We got a second. Okay. So we've got a motion and a second on the extent of the number of days. So the speakers in the queue, Dr. Salem, are you on this current amendment? Basic questions about the queue. Okay. Let's... Go ahead then, sir. It's time to get on early. Yeah. I was wanting to go to the introducers first and then go ahead, sir. Thank you, Chair. Through the Chair to Councilmember Arias, I have not kept up with this probably as I should have. So let me just ask some very basic questions. Does this allow you to have a garden on your residential property? If you don't mind, Michelle, can you answer all these questions since we have the bill drafted through all you all? And on the other part, too, this is also part two of, like, legislations. We've already done the home occupation bill, and I think that's what you're talking about, not necessarily this garden, this urban agricultural garden. But, yes, you can sell on your property through the home occupation bill if that's what you're asking. No, that's not what I asked. I said, are you allowed to have a... Does this allow you to have a garden on your residential property? Through the Chair to Councilmember Salem, my understanding is that anyone can grow a garden on the residential property. I would defer to Mr. Harvey if he wants to expand on that. Through the Chair to Councilmember Salem, Aaron Amney, Chief of Current Planning. So, yes. So what this bill will do is it will make it clear in the zoning code that you could take a vacant parcel in a residential neighborhood and grow on it. And then also you can do market garden days, which would allow you to do the on sale from the vacant parcel. The home occupation bill that's already went through already covers properties that have a residential home on it and you can grow and sell through the home occupation bill. But this is more geared towards those vacant parcels in residential zone properties. And then it also does make it clear in other commercial categories like commercial neighborhoods, CCG1 and CCG2, that you could also do that. I need to follow up, please. Please. Please. Okay. Aaron, please come back because you said a couple things that I want to make sure I'm clear on. You said if there's a vacant piece of property next to the residential property, they can grow on that. Through the Chair to Councilmember Salem, yes. Yeah. So a vacant parcel through this, it would allow you to either have a community garden, which is just the growing on site, but then you could also do market gardens, which would allow for the on site sales. And then there's limitations to it. So part four is where we're now discussing the amount of days that you could do the one sales. Okay. And you're telling me through the Chair, a previous bill allows you to grow, have a garden on your residential property. So the home occupation bill, like we have never regulated, like if you have your home on your property and you're growing flowers, food in your backyard, we have never stopped that. You're allowed to do that. This is more taking into the account those vacant parcels and you growing on it without a primary use. Okay. If you're in a neighborhood that has a HOA and there are covenants and restrictions that would prohibit this, how would that impact this bill? That's going to rule. Any deed restrictions, any covenants, those things must be met first. So we cannot trump an HOA by enacting this ordinance. What will happen is the state legislature actually allowed under the home occupation bill to allow you to have certain rights to do on your property. And that's already state statute. So there are certain regulations or certain things that you're allowed to do to grow produce and things on your property without creating a nuisance. But because it is an HOA, this ordinance would not just allow you to just go into that neighborhood without taking in consideration the rules and bylaws and the other governing acts of that HOA. Okay. Through the chair again. You said without creating a nuisance. Let's just take a scenario here where somebody is growing tomatoes in their front yard. Sure. Not in their backyard, but in their front yard. And other neighbors felt like that was an eyesore. It lowered the value of their property because of the way that this looks. How would that be addressed? So under the state statute, that's permitted if it is a part of their home occupation. And the way that our home occupation code provides and also the way that the state statute provides, you still have to meet our regular code requirements regarding issues as it relates to certain setbacks, certain things like that. So you can't just throw a tomato by your mailbox without meeting all the other requirements. The state statute as it relates to that HOA portion that we were talking about, it also states that there are certain things that are required. So if there is an easement or if there is a certain viewpoint because there's a lake in the back, you can't do certain things to hinder those people's rights. You can't grow a certain amount along your property line, but that's under that state statute that governs that part. Is this, do we have people growing vegetables, I've not seen this, in their front yards presently? In Murray Hill? In Murray Hill, where I grew up, by the way. In their front yards and backyards. And this is well accepted in Murray Hill, okay? Okay. And there aren't people that are concerned about how this may be viewed by, if they were trying to sell their house and that kind of thing. Through the chair, I'm sorry. I just think it's important to get these issues out, Mr. Chair. That's why I'm... Even at some time. We're going to drop the hammer on the three minutes, so we need to go ahead and get this addressed and these concerns, as well as I don't think it got answered about the just growing a residential garden, not for sale, but just having a garden. Well, does it make a difference whether you're selling it or not selling it? Just, I mean, believe it or not, I had an area in my backyard 40 years ago where I grew some vegetables, but, you know, stopped doing it. So, through the chair to Council Member Peluso, you're telling me this is very common in Murray Hill, where, in a very residential area, that people are growing vegetables or whatever in their front yards, backyards, it's well accepted, and it's allowed through whatever HOAs that are over there. Through the chair to Council Member Salem, first off, there's no HOAs in that general area. So, the question that you had about HOAs, yeah, it gets preempted for a lot of this, because I would assume that many people would have those exact same concerns. I grew up in an HOA community, so I would think that it would be something that people don't like. Meanwhile, though, Riverside, Springfield, Murray Hill, and then beyond, North Riverside and into parts of Newtown and College Gardens, there's a number of, whether it be community gardens or gardens on people's property. As I knocked on doors, yeah, there's a ton in Murray Hill. And I don't know if you also recall, probably about 15 years ago, we had a massive hen and chicken law that was passed here in the city, because people also keep chickens and hens on their land, which, if you go around Riverside, you'll hear chickens in the morning. Point being is, it would be something that even I would probably have considered, if I was just looking at it on face value, as, oh yeah, are people really going to like these kind of eyesores? But they're not. They just aren't. I think it's made the communities and the neighborhoods substantially more unique and individualized, and I think we kind of love that in those communities, and frankly, the home values have skyrocketed. So, if anything else, I can tell you that it hasn't hurt anything over there. I'll stop there, Chair, and allow others to jump in. All right. Thank you. Next, I've got Councilman Amaro on the, are you on the amendment? Yes, sir. Okay, go ahead, sir. Thank you, Mr. Harvey. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just a quick question. I'm going to support the 52 days. I know the industry was pushing for 70, and it sounds like 52 is where things have settled. I'm just curious as to, just visually, are we, these sales going to be from stands, like the roadside stands that we see, and if so, are those stands permanent? No. So, these sales would, I guess you would imagine it like a yard sale. So, it's not anything, they're not permitted to cause any additional traffic concerns or anything like that. So, similar to like the home occupation bill, which has regulations on parking and things like that. The market sales are imagined to be similar to a yard sale. So, they're supposed to be housed on site on that community garden or on that actual garden. Right. Next, let me go to Councilmember Pittman. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Let me go to Councilmember Boyd. I'll make sure I get, stay in the right order. I'll come right to you later. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate the opportunity. A couple of things. I think it's a great bill in context, in terms of the opportunity to be able to grow and market, you know, vegetables and the like. My concern, and quite honestly, when we were hearing public comment a fair amount recently, it sounded to me that the bill talked about only 12 days of market sales. And people were saying, well, does that preclude them from selling at other times? And the fact of the matter is, they can sell 365 days a year. Explicit in the bill, it says individual sales and prearranged pickups involving no more than five customers on site at any one time shall not constitute a public sales day. So they can sell every day. Now, I live in a cul-de-sac. I've got a neighbor who might grow vegetables and allow him every weekend to have cars piling up in my cul-de-sac, our cul-de-sac. Once a month is fine. So I would, I guess through the chair to the introducers, how does that concern of folks who, blanket bills like these make it difficult to address the exceptions in this process. And I want to make sure that how is it, I have a situation where they can do it 52 days or 50 every weekend. I suspect that's going to be troublesome over a period of time. And the resentment of neighbors is saying, hey, why did we let this happen? How did we let this happen? To the chair, to Council Member Borland. I think you're speaking more to this amendment, right? So the amendment hasn't been voted on. Absolutely. That's why I'm speaking to the amendment. That's why. The first thing I will say is, yeah, the 52 days would allow for once a week, right? For the purposes of harvest and how long, you know, vegetables last, you kind of want to have a large day to do something. And you are correct that you could sell every day at this moment, right? If you're doing small batch sales. I think that, but that's not, do you have a vacant lot in your property? Because right now that sounds like a home occupation thing more than it does kind of the market day thing. So like. Either way, but my, I don't happen in my neighborhood to have that, but you know, the scenario doesn't, it still applies. It could. I think, I think the question is, or I think the, the, the reason for the bill and why we think it's going to be so successful is, I don't believe it's going to be in those kinds of neighborhoods. I don't think you're going to see the activation in a, in a relatively built out neighborhood already. It's going to be in areas where there's a lot of vacant lots, where there's a lot of potential for future activation, where there's a lot more, you know, people that I think are generally interested in this kind of stuff. And I, and I just, that, that scenario that you just placed in front of me, I don't think that's something that you're going to see a lot of. And currently under home occupation, they could still do it. Well, I don't want to be the district councilman where it does happen one time. And I'm happy to bring somebody else up, or somebody else from the crew. And I, I'm, I'm trying to help this get done. I'm just trying to address what I think would be a common concern when we say, open it up to say in that scenario, that it's going to be very difficult to, to enforce. Thank you. And, and through the chair, if you want, we have a number of growers here that can come up and kind of speak to that. All right. Thank you. So now let me go to Councilmember Pittman. The chair and to the sponsors. First of all, I want to say thank you. I did have an opportunity to come to a couple of the meetings. And, you know, it's, it's very important that you hear from the people that this will impact. Right. And I'm glad that Mr. Boylan, Councilman Boylan asked that question, but I, I just don't feel with the individuals that are out there. This will be in, in cul-de-sacs and things like that. Um, you know, one of my concerns is what impacts to, um, to selling regarding amendments that will take place next, next in the upcoming year. Right. Which is, um, for individuals who receive EBT cards, you know, now they will have to go out and look for employment and or their EBT's will be discontinued. Right. So, and I, and I'm looking, y'all know, usually I'm down the way down the street, but that will be a problem. Um, and a lot of the individuals where most of these farmers and gardeners are in a lot in the inner city, um, or in vulnerable neighborhoods where they need to grow, um, you know, some of their, their own food. And I just believe if, you know, there's options, you know, they may not have, um, fresh produce in their community where they can go. And, and, and I'll ask, I guess, Ms. Husband to come up and, and, and, and really talk about the individuals that are here and the individuals that are participating in the policy program. Um, what areas are you seeing, um, that's needed, number one? And I think I heard you say, uh, you had 91 gardeners that signed up, signed up, um, this weekend. Can you tell me where most of those are? Um, so this weekend's effort was concentrated in 32209. However, we, last year we created over 168 gardens on the west side. So, um, and we're seeing that the need really is not even income-based. The need is about people wanting to control what they're eating, what's going into their food as far as chemicals, what kind of soil it's being, uh, grown in. Is that soil clean? Is it contributing to more diseases? And then figuring ways to make that strategy also work to not only address their health, but also their income. Um, but most importantly, it also creates an opportunity for creating community and reducing, reducing crime in our neighborhoods. And, and again, thank you, um, for that because you're going to need, uh, and, and I'm more concerned because I work with the, um, less fortunate and vulnerable communities. Right? So, whatever amendment that we approve, I want to make sure that it's diverse enough that if individuals who want to grow their own food, secondly, I do agree. When we, when we know better, we do better because we want to make sure we put, um, food in our bodies that is healthy for us. And I also know that the health department is looking to do that as well and working with some of these farmers that are out there. So, I, I think it's a good bill, one of the things, um, and the amendment, um, what I do like is that you have people who are coming down, not just at the city council meeting, but at the community, I mean, at the committee meetings like this, right? Like, sharing what is needed rather than, you know, we, we, we pushing stuff on them. Um, so, and we have all of the right people in this room to talk about it. So, um, you know, I support it. Um, I know I'm, you know, riding on out, but I, I do think we need to look toward the future because there's a lot of things that's getting ready to come down the pipeline that, um, affect, um, like I said, you know, vulnerable communities as well as people want to learn more and how to eat healthy and live longer. All right. Thank you. Uh, let me go to the council member. You're not on the queue. Okay, great. Thank you. Let me go to Dr. Salem. Thank you, chair. I'm very sensitive to the issue that council member Boylan brought up and that, uh, you're, you've got a house, you've got someone growing and they're bringing, uh, cars in every Saturday or every Sunday, you know, whether it's a cul-de-sac or not. And I hear, when I hear words like rarely or probably won't occur and that kind of thing, that, that, I mean, we've got to protect everybody here. And, uh, I don't know how to do that. Uh, obviously if you have an HOA, you can, you can block it that way. But I wouldn't want to, uh, necessarily keep them from growing, but you, you definitely want to be able to control the traffic in your neighborhood. So, I'm interested in a way that, uh, we can protect those, those instances where it's not on the west side or where it's very common, Murray Hill, but, you know, somebody in a neighborhood turns their yard into a, a, a garden and are bringing traffic in that other people don't want to see. So, how do you protect that? How do you stop that? How do you protect that homeowner? Because I, I can see what's going to happen. This bill passes and we're going to have people coming up here during public comment and saying, look what you've done. And they're going to show us pictures and, and they're going to show us traffic and that kind of thing. So, if someone can explain to me how we can prevent that one person, uh, make, if, if you could come up and if you've got a way to do that, I'm, I'm all ears. Um, thank you. Through the chair to Councilman Salem, this is, um, Helena Parola with the planning department. I just want to make a few things clear. Right now you're allowed to grow wherever you want. So, someone can grow in their front yard and can, um, grow food in their front yard today. This bill specifically addresses vacant lots in residential areas. So, your neighbor, if they're living in their house and they're growing and they want to sell what they grow from their house, that would fall under the home occupation bill, which I know we previously discussed. And that home occupation bill has different requirements. One, that you can't increase, um, traffic more than a regular residential, um, area would be, which would be two to three cars coming up to your house at a time. Two, they would have to sell from their house. So, an individual person would get out of their car, grab whatever they need to grab. Um, the retail sale would happen there and then they would leave. So, it's a, it's a low intensity thing when you have a residential structure and you're under the home occupation bill. So, this bill that you have in front of you right now is for vacant lots in residential areas. So, that's when you are allowed to grow. And then, as the bill stands right now, 12 days a year, you're allowed to sell what you grow, um, with the amendments that would be increased. To 52 weeks. Correct. Right, correct. So, you're looking at, I'm, I'm, I'm sorry, 52 days, which would be every weekend, potentially. Oh, yeah, yeah, you could do it, you could do it all in, uh, a couple of months or you could spread it out to once a month. And, I mean, to me, that's significant depending on where you live and painting the scenario that Council Member Boylan did. Um, I don't have an answer, but, but I, through this discussion, I think we should try to protect those people. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Uh, Ms. Murray, you're still in the queue. I don't, okay. Right, we're still, still on the amendment. Okay, okay. All right, uh, let me, Mr. Boylan on the amendment. I, I thank you. I appreciate, appreciate it. Ms. Boylan, come on back up just real quick. Um, how do, so you say 52. Who's going to be counting? Is there a countdown clock we put on every time they use it? I mean, the enforceability of that seems to be very difficult to do. It would be done through code enforcement, and generally how our code enforcement works, um, today it would be complaint driven. I've got a, such an area like this, I'm just playing devil's advocate in this process. I, I've got a guy who's been counting. This is their 53rd date, but this is, like, next door. Uh, and code enforcement's going to say, well, how do we know? Uh, I, it just, I mean, I appreciate the importance of this, and I, I get it, and I, I want to, but I think Councilman Salem did a much better job than I did about concerning and protecting the neighbors. I had a similar scenario in my neighborhood. A woman, lovingly, as I understand, not in my neighborhood, but, uh, from another constituent, who was having a lower bakery. She was doing that home occupation thing. And it was becoming an issue because cars were blocking her, these other neighbors' driveways and that sort of thing. So, I, I, that's why I was sensitive to the concern of this. Uh, so, it has to be a vacant lot. How do, do they need permission of owner of that, of that, of that lot in order to, to grow on it? Um, yes, it would have to be owner, the owner would be the one either growing on the lot, growing and selling on the lot, or giving permission to whoever is doing that. All right, so it could be a different owner, but they have, you have to have written permission to, in order to grow on that lot. Correct. And demonstrate a written permission to do so. Yes. All right. Well, those were helpful to me, but again, it doesn't eliminate the concern I have about those protecting the neighbors, uh, in this kind of scenario. Not to say, I don't want to do this, I just want to get a better answer to the question as to how do we protect those neighbors. Um, if I could add one more thing, just to reiterate, it is only for vacant lots in a neighborhood. So, there might not be that many of them there, as Councilman Peluso, um, said previously. And it might not be as much of an issue as we're concerned about. All right. Thank you. Let me go to, uh, Councilmember Arias. Thank you, Chair. I've been waiting here anxiously. All right. Um, so I, I hear all the concerns from all of you guys right now, and I think they're valid. I think this is a perfect time to ask these questions, the tough questions. Um, but what I've heard a lot of today is protecting homeowners, which I 100% agree with. But I also want to make sure that we also protect the other part of the community, the other part of this bill, right? And that's the reason why we're here today. Um, as Ms. Parola already stated, this is literally for vacant lots. Uh, it doesn't affect HOAs. And realistically, if anybody could sell right now, they can. I, I, when I used to live in Kernan, somebody right next to me used to sell honey from her house constantly, right? So that will not change, and it's not changing. It's really based on vacant lots. Um, Jacksonville has 747 square miles, right? It's a large city. There's a lot of vacant land, but for the most part, you're looking at vacant land in different parts of Jacksonville. Currently, where, where these, uh, individuals are, they're going to continue working in those areas wherever they're at. I don't see an influx of people saying, we're going to move to Jacksonville now because of this bill passing, and we're going to go take over all of Jacksonville. They're going to continue doing what they're doing right now. And realistically, when I stated last week, it's like, have an open heart, open mind. That's exactly what this is today. Um, so the amendment that Ms. Clark-Murray is proposing, I, I definitely agree with it. It's 52 days, not 52 weeks. There are seasons that are more heavier. That way, they can sell more those days, um, whether it's summer or fall, whatever the produce is, or whatever the, the actual, uh, component is. So, I just encourage you guys to support this. If we see an issue happening, we could always come back and say, you know what, we're going to change it. We could do that. We have the power to do that. But for now, what I would recommend is continue with the 52 days because at the end of the day, let's give them an opportunity to show what they're made of, what they can do, how much of community power there can be to our community, and continue giving, um, people what they, what we need in Jacksonville. That's good food. Um, so just open heart, open mind, and, um, that's all I have for now unless you guys have more questions. But honestly, uh, Council Member Salem, your questions are great, and keep on asking them because this is what we're here for today. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Let's go to Council Member Peluso. Thank you, Chair, and I just don't want to kind of belabor the point. I'd like to see these amendments, you know, what, what the debate is on them. Uh, but, but to the questions that were brought up, I mean, keep in mind, state law, the home occupation law has been, in, in, enforced for the past year. And I don't think we've seen a massive and intense increase in the amount of, uh, home occupation issues. To the point of these vacant lots, yeah, I think, I think you're looking at most of the districts that are being affected by this. There's six, seven, eight, nine, uh, twelve, which has a lot of agricultural land already. So it's kind of our agricultural heartbeat, if you will. Uh, probably some in 14, and I think probably, probably a little bit in District 4, um, you know, kind of the south side area. Like, that's where you're seeing vacant lots of a size where you can really kind of see the opportunity, uh, uh, flourish. I don't, I can't imagine District 6 has a ton of areas where you can see a lot of stuff. Maybe there's a few parcels, um, but I bet, I bet Mandra would love some of these, uh, you know, especially if it's fresh food and vegetables. But, but to the point of what Councilmember Arias said, if this becomes some sort of crisis or, or property rights issue, then I think we'd talk about it. Um, to the point of the 52 days, uh, uh, that was kind of a compromise. Um, some of the, some of the folks who have been advocating for this for a while asked for 70 days. We thought that 50 to 52 made a little more sense because that way you could do once a week. All that to say, I mean, you know, meet with these folks after today. If you have any more questions, I, I had a good almost hour with them on Friday and just really kind of hashed out some of these, some of these issues. Making sure that they would, uh, uh, meet the, meet the moment and make, and get you guys all on board and, you know, excited to see how this bill progresses. I think no matter what, we're, we're making real progress on, on an issue that we've been hearing about for a long time. And our council meetings are late already, so we can, we can solve that by, uh, by passing bills like this and not having people come and talk to us for 30 minutes about it. Thanks guys. Oh, you're fine. Go ahead. Councilmember Bowen. Thank you. Uh, this 50% yield, uh, can you speak to, to the chair, to either gentleman to speak to that? Thank you, chair. Uh, the 50% yield is just, it's about cross, um, cross sales. So the, the big concern was, okay, well, what if, what if I could do cross sales and there was no limitation on, on how much was, uh, product that I grow, vice that of what other people can grow. You just didn't want somebody to, to take a stand, put it in a vacant lot and just get, you know, I don't know, go to Winn-Dixie or, or fresh markets. Right that day and then, you know, put it up and, put it up there and say, ah, yeah, this is all stuff that I grew and it's $40 for this, you know, organic, whatever. So it was just a matter of, we want to make sure that it was, A, advertised appropriately as to where the stuff was grown and, B, that, uh, that you can get 50% of it must be something. And I appreciate all of that. Uh, again, it's an enforcement issue. How do you know it's 52 days and not 60 days? How do you know it's 50%? Who's going to make a determination as to those kind of things? I want to do this. I want to support it. I just make sure those concerns are evident and out there. All right. Very well taken. Chair, uh, can I also say one more thing to Mr. Boylan's, um, question? Go ahead. Thank you. Uh, so Mr. Boylan, uh, through the chair, the other part of it is, um, imagine you're a grower, whether, let's use honey example again, um, and you can't make it to the market that day and you say, hey, can you please sell this for me? That's also the, the idea behind it, right? So thank you. Thank you. So there's no, no other speakers in the queue. I would just like to, uh, have the planning department come back up and, and clarify a statement that home businesses, about the number of cars, that is, doesn't change the normal, uh, I guess pattern of vehicles in the community? Uh, to the chair, so yeah, so through the home occupation, which our code now matches the state regulations, you can't create traffic out of character for a residential neighborhood. So through that home occupation bill, they can sell from site. But again, like, you know, you can't be like having cars park all down the street. So, but, but again, that's through the home occupation bill. This one's on those vacant lots outside of that. So kind of like the, uh, race car issue I've got in my district that changes the character. So, uh, so it's, uh, thank you. That's all I, I got for y'all. So I, I deal with, uh, several of these home businesses, uh, that, uh, we have not been able to get rectified, uh, because of state legislation. So that, that, that, that's, that's a concern that, the biggest concern that I, I've heard and that I have is about the vehicles coming in and impacting the community. Uh, so I, I support the, uh, the amendment and this bill. I just also want to be sensitive to the surrounding community that, you know, the, the growers and sellers are mindful of that. And that if it starts coming back, then we're going to have to, uh, uh, deal with it. So that, that, that's my concerns with it. So we have a motion and a second on the amendment. All in favor of the amendment, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Likewise, none. The amendment carries and we roll these up as, as one. And can I get a motion and a second on the bill as amended? Did I do that right, Michelle? Right. Okay. So we've got a motion and a second on the bill as rolled up amended. All right. Ms. Clark Murray, you're recognized. Thank you, Chair. Through the chair to Ms. Parola, or it could be any of the bill introducers. Just, um, I know there is a lot in this bill. And then the, um, the, um, the home business bill that was passed some months ago, I, I know that it was very, it was voluminous. So is there going to be any education for those who are going to engage in this practice? Will there be a piece where they, because if you want to know the rules, you need to either, someone needs to teach you the rules or you need to read about the rules. So is there an education piece in here, or is that a consideration for amending this bill? Excuse me. Through the chair to Councilman Clark, uh, Councilwoman Clark Murray, um, we've been working with the urban ag community, and I know that they have a number of educational outreach ways that they will communicate and teach the public. We've also been working with UF IFAS and the, um, their agriculture section there. And I know that there are a number of ways that they are going to reach out as well. This is also rolled into the current food plan that was recently finalized and addressed. And that has a number of outreach opportunities to address these types of concerns as well. Thank you so much for that. So I think through the chair to the committee, one way to alleviate some of the concerns that were mentioned here is the fact, do you know those who engage in, in their home gardens and they want to sell what they grow? Do they know the rules? Do they know what, what criteria is required for them to be able to conduct that type of business? No, I think that's important. And they said that there is an educational piece. There are some groups who will, who intend to educate those who aren't going to engage in this. And, and, uh, through the chair to legislative services, please add me as a co-sponsor. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Let me go to, uh, Dr. Salem. Thank you, chair. I'm going to support the bill, but I'm looking out at some of the big supporters of this. And I think it, I would encourage you to police this to some extent and educate to, to touch on what council member Clark Murray was just saying. I think the more that y'all can educate people, particularly on this traffic issue to make sure that does not. The last thing you want is people coming to the podium as you did to say, I had 25 cars parked in front of my house and that, that will be problematic for all of us. So, uh, help educate and police it as best you can in various parts of town to make sure it, it accomplishes what you and us want to accomplish. Thank you, chair. All right. Thank you. Let me go to council member Pittman. To the chair and I guess Ms. Parola or one of the representatives, um, in the community. I'd like to, to know in terms of marketing, you brought up a very good, um, point. Is there a way that when they apply for permits or anything like that, um, that they can get an informational brochure of the do's and don'ts? You know, when, when I think about that, I think about JEA because again, you'll have to use the water. And then when they're applying for permitting that they'll be able to get the information for the do's and don'ts. Cause you have some individuals who just like to try to see if they can do it right. But they need to know, um, the do's and don'ts where you have most professional people out in the audience that do that either for, you know, or leave a living. And so, you know, they're speaking to the choir, but as they do their work, they need to make sure that they share with them. When you get your permit, you should get some information on how to, on how to, how to do this of the do's and don'ts. And I don't know if that's something, you know, that we can do as a city or is that going to cost more money, um, to market. Can you share that with Ms. Perot? Um, yes. Thank you. Um, Councilwoman Pittman right now there, this is a buy right ordinance, so they will not be coming in for a permit. So we don't have that opportunity where they're crossing paths with the city when they start what they're, um, going to do grow and sell them on the vacant lot. However, as stated previously, we are working with UF IFAS and the extension office and through the agricultural community. And I know there are a number of different ideas, um, that are set in motion right now to teach people how to garden, to teach people what the rules are, to make sure everybody stays within those parameters. So, um, it is a good use moving forward and there are no concerns for the out extra community surrounding where they're doing that. Thank you. Since we're rolling this out, if we can get other municipality departments. to maybe help with this, um, because right now it's only a few of them, but if they can share the information that can be printed, because a lot of, some of the municipal, the departments print newsletters and we get bills in the mail. So, um, so if we can partner with them, not just IFAS, but, you know, a little bit, um, openly and more diverse in areas. And I guess, Miss, Miss, um, Husband, Dr. Husband, when you come up, how do you feel about that? And if you think that's, that's possible? We can't hear you. Good, good morning again. We're already working on creating best practices on how this, uh, legislation is going to look like addressing the do's and don'ts. And we actually do have funding through the Food Policy Council that we'll be able to deploy this information to the community. Perfect. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Let me go to Council Member Bolin. Dr. Husband, come on back down for a quick second. I want to, I enjoyed very much what Council Member Salem suggested. And to that end, let me push this envelope just a little bit further in the context of that process. Through the organization, is it a way for people to can register or let you know, I'm on day 28 of my 52, so that there is some documentation, uh, that your office or your associations have with respect to say, you can justify, and when someone says, they've been doing this for 72 days. No, we've got records showing they've only done it for 45 days or whatever. And the same thing in the context. So that's what, taking it to that next level of having a documented evidence of the number of days that each one has their market sales. Uh, the Food Policy Council would, would be glad to take that on. I think that's a great idea. And ask people to do that. Again, we want to avoid, all of us want to avoid the bad actors in this process. And I think, uh, the association, and sometimes the government, believe it or not, can't solve every problem. So, we appreciate you taking that on. Thank you. Thank you. All right. So, I think we've got, got to a good point on this. And we've got good commitments and promises. So, uh, we'll, we'll hold everyone to that. So, no other speakers in the queue. Uh, let's open, open the ballot and record your vote. Six J's, zero Nays. All right. By your action, you're approved. 2026-08-07 as amended. Thank everyone for being here on that one. So, the next item we're going to go to is on page 10. Page 10, item number 14. 2026-0848. Can I get a motion on the bill? Can I get a second? I've got a motion and a second on the bill. All right. Ms. Clark-Murray, you're recognized. 14. 14. 14. Okay. 2026-0848. 2026-0848. My, my apologies, Chair. Did you call me? He actually recognized me. Um, through the, to the Chair, if we would allow Council Member Arias to discuss the bill, then maybe he'll answer my question. Very well. All right. Thank you. All right. Council Member Arias, you're recognized. All right. Thank you, Chair. Um, you're going to see I have a couple of these coming up today. And essentially, these are some of the remaining dollars from my carryover legislation that I have in the past from strategic dollars that I've had. In this case, this is for Northeast Florida School of Special Education. They have a track that needs desperate repair. And so I've been out there multiple times. I've been with the children there running around and that track really needs some, some repair. That way I could really beat them in running. So, um, in this case, this bill is just essentially a carryover. It was, it was part of my carryovers that I've had for a couple of years to be able to finally put these dollars to use. And that's all it is. Thank you. All right. So let me go to, uh, Dr. Salem. Thank you, Chair. Through the Chair to Council Member Arias, let me make sure I understand. These are dollars that presently fell into the reserves at, on September 30th. Is that correct? No. These are dollars that I've carried over from my legislation. So they're, they're still, Ms. Michelle, you may be able to give more context, but these are, are dollars already encumbered that I've had to file legislation in the past to carry the over to this year. Okay. So they're not sitting in reserves. They're sitting in a carryover fund, if I'm not mistaken. So sometime last, in the last budget year, Council Member Arias passed a bill to, to keep these dollars from falling into the reserves. Is that correct? Through the Chair to Council Member Salem, that's correct. There was legislation that authorized the carryover of these dollars to the current fiscal year. How much was carried over? It was roughly 90 something thousand dollars through the Chair. Is that, through the Chair, is that correct? Through the Chair to Council Member Salem, for this particular original contract that was for the Northeast Florida Immigrant Resource Alliance, it was six, $76,000 was carried over approximately $76,000. Okay. Maybe I'm, I'm not, I'm confused. It sounds like he passed a, a, a bill in the last budget year that moved a, a lump sum of money into this budget year, and he's got several bills that he, that are coming up to, to, uh, to pay, to pay for. What was the total dollar amount that he passed, was it one bill, I'm assuming? Two bills. Okay. There were two bills that you passed to move these dollars into this budget year. Do you all have those through the Chair? Through the Chair to Council Member Salem. If you give me a moment, I can pull those up. Okay. I'll, I'll let other, I'd like to know the total amount before we move on. Go ahead. Go ahead, Ms. Garrett. Through the Chair to Council Member Salem, uh, Bill 2026-712 authorized the carryover of $91,181. Through the Chair to Council Member Salem, that's correct. And it sounds like you're going to spend that total $91,181 with several bills today. Is that correct? Three bills. Okay. Thank you, Chair. Right. No other speakers in the queue. Well, I've got a motion second on the bill. Let's open the ballot and record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. By your action, you're approved, 2026-0848. The next item we'll go to is on page 11, item number 15, 2026-0849. Can I get a motion on the bill? I've got a motion second on the bill. Ms. Murray recognized. Thank you, Chair. I want to be added as a co-sponsor. Thank you. All right. No other speakers in the queue. Please add me as a co-sponsor as well. Let's open the ballot and record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. By your action, you're approved, 2026-0849. The next item that we're going to go to will be on page 12, item number 16, 2026-0853. Can I get a motion on the bill? A motion second on the bill. All right. Let me go first to Dr. Salem. Thank you, Chair. Can the auditors tell me the original source of these dollars? Through the Chair to Council Member Salem, the original funding source was $15,000 came from the LBFL Development Center contract that was never executed, and $5,000 came from the direct contract with Northeast Florida Immigrant Resource Alliance, which also was not executed. Okay. But what was, was this, even going back further than that, was this like part of a budget where we were dividing up dollars at the end of the year? How far does this go back? Through the Chair to Council Member Salem, $15,000 of it goes back to fiscal 23-24 budget ordinance direct contracts, and the remaining $5,000 comes from fiscal 24-25 council strategic initiative dollars. Okay. Goes back pretty far. Okay. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Let me go to Council Member Morrow. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Through the Chair to the bill sponsor. These $20,000 to an entity that, according to sunbiz.org, is out of Orlando, sunbiz.org latest filing is out of Orlando. These $20,000, why can't they go to JSEP? This, this, this number one, to me, is troubling. It's a duplicitous, number one. JSEP already provides counseling, support services for small businesses. Why are you using these monies to give some other party to do something that's already being done? Through the Chair, I thank you, Mr. Morrow, for that question. So these are strategic dollars that we as council members have purview as to where in the community we want to put our dollars towards. In this case, while the headquarters is out of Orlando, they do have offices here in Jacksonville. They've been operating in Jacksonville for many years. We actually have representatives from Prospera here right now. If you want to ask them some questions, we can. However, there are many instances where we've funded initiatives that are, I don't want to say duplicative of what we do in the city, but they are essentially almost the same category. So this is no different than that. And in my opinion, the reason why I'm funding this one, number one, they're in my district. Number two, I've seen the great work that they've done many years. I've actually been involved in a lot of numerous efforts to help them, you know, just get out there in the community. And so the reason why I'm actually requesting a waiver in this case is because, as I stated, there's three bills that I have coming up. One we already passed. The other one was going to be for FSCJ's culinary program. And I only had $20,000 remaining. And so in this case, we have a provision that says you have to have $25,000 minimum threshold. And so the reason why we're looking for a waiver is for this very reason is because I only had $20,000 remaining for them. So technically, the order that should have been taken up would have been Northeast Florida School of Special Education, then FSCJ, and then this one, which is why we had $20,000 remaining. But hopefully that answers your question plus the other question as to why it's $20,000. Thank you. Appreciate the effort, sir. I'm going to be a no because I think we're already doing the work here. And if we're going to make the investment, let's put it where it's already being done. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Let me go to Councilwoman Clark Murray. Thank you, Chair. Through the chair to the bill sponsor. Here's the issue I have with the bill is it is less than the amount in regards to the waiver is the issue that I have. So we, Councilmember Salem, sponsored a bill that we had to give at a minimum $25,000 to an entity. And there have been other bills that we have not approved because it didn't meet that threshold and others who have not given funding to certain entities because they don't have the, what they wanted to give does not meet that threshold. So how do we explain to people, Councilmembers, such as Councilmember Johnson, if we approve this bill with the waiver? Thank you, Chair. Okay, thank you. And through the chair. So I was actually going to say the same thing. And we, as the auditors, currently there's many bills that have gone this year through our process that have had the need for a waiver. So this is not a uncommon thing. The reason why I'm even proposing this, and normally I wouldn't even do that, is because when I was going through the dollars remaining, I was like, well, I only have $20,000. What am I supposed to do with this? Right? And so in this case, I was like, I knew I wanted to help them out, but I was like, I need to put a waiver out there. Otherwise, I would have to take money from the other ones that I had already committed to. And that was my issue. I committed to the culinary program and to the School of Special Education before committing to them. And by the time I came to them, I only had $20,000 remaining. And that was the only reason why I needed a waiver. If I had $30,000 remaining, and I decided to say $15,000 for you, $15,000 for you, then obviously I'm going against what the essence of what we're supposed to do here. But the reason why I'm doing this is because that's all I had remaining available. All right. Thank you so much for that. Through the chair to Councilmember Arias. So have you considered, is this entity in your district? So is it possible for you to take $5,000 of your CBA dollars and add so that we meet that threshold? So, yes and no. It would have been. However, I've already committed all my CBA dollars. I have Fort Family Regional Park and the Deerworth Children's Rotary Park, and I'm putting over close to a million dollars, if not a million dollars. I'm actually having to use other dollars from the Parks Department to complete the project. So I've already exhausted my CBA dollars towards our park system. All right. And, sorry, it is in my district, which is why I've identified them. So I still try to keep it in the same area. And if I may just add one more remark to Councilmember Amaro's question is the fact that we do a lot of workforce development, right? So we focus on so many different components of workforce development that so many entities that we can't just pick one. We need a community to help us out. And while our JSEP department is great, they also need help. And that's the reason why we normally partner with nonprofits in our community to be able to help our community out even more. So that's kind of the reason why. Thank you. All right. Thank you so much for that. Thank you, Chair. All right. Thank you. Let me go to Dr. Salem. This is a scary thought, but Councilmember Clark-Murray brought up my question about your CBA to get it to $25,000. I understand why you can't, but it'd be great if you did, because I'm going to support it anyway. But there's a couple other waivers that are coming up here that I'm going to be raising issues on, and I just wish you had $5,000 somewhere. Thank you. All right. Let me go to Councilmember Aris here in the queue. All right. Thank you. Okay. No other speakers in the queue. On this one, I'm going to support it right now, so we'll just see how it progresses, and I reserve my right to change my vote later. So let's open the ballot and record your vote. Four yays, two nays. By your action, you've approved 2026-0853. Next item we'll go to is on page 15, item number 25, 2026-0885. I've got a motion on the bill. I've got a motion and a second on the bill, and Dr. Salem, you're recognized. Thank you, Chair. I noticed that the dollars that are generated, 90% goes to the Building Inspection Fund and 10% to the Affordable Trust Fund. Are there restrictions on where these dollars can go? Because my impression was the dollars generated would have to go back to the same source, and if there's not a restriction, I have an amendment that I'm going to bring up. Terrence Harvey, Office of General Counsel. So that provision is actually going to be stricken. The pool 100% is going to the Public Works Department as the generating source for the work that was done. So you're telling me the bill is going to be, this is going to be amended? Correct. When? Today? Yes. Oh. Through the Chair to Council Member Salem, I think Director Sickler would like to ask one of you to move that amendment, is my understanding. But I still have a question. Do these dollars have to go back to this Building Inspection Fund? That is correct. It does. It does. It does. I'll make the amendment for 100%. I'm going to do you a favor. Council Member Dennis. Thank you. I'm going to, I'll make a motion that 100% go back to the Building Inspection Fund. All right. I've got a motion and a second on this. Mr. Dennis, you're in the queue. Is that on this amendment? Through the Chair to Council Member Salem, I was going to ask if you would do the amendment for the administration to help us out here. So thank you so much. Thank you. All right. No other speakers in the queue on the amendment. All in favor of the amendment, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Likewise, none. The amendment carries. I'm going to give a motion and a second on the bill as amended. All right. I've got a motion and a second on the bill as amended. So no speakers in the queue. I have a couple of questions with Ms. Sickler would come on up and give a little bit of an overview of what the intent of this legislation is. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Nina Sickler, Public Works, to the Chair and the Committee. This process was requested by developers and by NFPA. They identified other municipalities out of state that were successful in providing the service. The goal is, or the plan for this is, if it's passed, that this offers an opportunity for an applicant to submit their plans and receive both their civil and building permits in 30 days or less. This is a partnership between the applicant and the city because currently about 50% of the time of an application is in the hands of the applicant. So this is a partnership between our city reviewers and the developers, design professionals, and the owners to meet in several steps in this process to ensure that there are no questions about the comments, that everybody's on the same page. We've had six pilots that all were achieved in less than 30 days, ranging anywhere from 18 to 28 days in achieving both types of permits. And this is, we've discussed this frequently with the meetings we've had with developers, both on the process and the fee, and have received a very positive feedback. All right, so you mentioned about the process, the 30-day process. So when you get a submission, what is the time frame that y'all have to turn that back around? So when a project has been evaluated and deemed to be eligible, and they submit their first submittal of plans and documents, the city has to review it in five days, five business days. And then subsequent to that, the applicant has five days for the design professional to return those revised plans. On the second set of submittals, we have about three days to review the second submittal, and the applicant has the same number of days. So again, it's a partnership, making sure that everybody is moving towards that same goal. All right. Thank you. Let me go to Council Member Clark Murray. Thank you, Chair. Good morning, Ms. Sickler. So really interesting. My primary question was about the time, if it actually is reducing the time as opposed to the previous process. So it seems as if it is. And just I know there was a great deal of information in this bill that was already or the process was already existing. So are there any – so JEA, JFRD, Planning Department, Public Works, the Environmental Quality Division, they already have those POCs selected. So you don't have any issues with determining who those people are. That is correct. They've been involved in the pilots, and so every person on that list has been part of the process to date and understands the new steps. Okay. Do you anticipate – through the Chair, do you anticipate there being an increase in the fee, or is the fee pretty much going to be flat at this time? Because I know that if there is an increase, then you'll have to come back to City Council for that. So the fee is – was established to start at $20,000. That was based on the hours that were spent in the six pilots. Okay. And so we've provided some flexibility to adjust that. If there is a great demand and we have to either add on consultants or need staff overtime in order to keep up, that's what the flexibility in the increase might be. Right now we don't anticipate that being needed until we look at the workload. There's also an – an exceptional project fee for something very, very large. And again, the applicant would know that before they began the process of paying for the permit. And so therefore, we would calculate that, again, based on the additional staff hours required to perform that service. Thank you for that. And once again, through the Chair, thank you for defining – exceptional. Because I was wondering, how do you define – how does that person, the director, determine whether or not a particular project is exceptional and it's based on the scale of the project? Okay. All right. Thank you for that. Thank you, Chair. All right. Thank you. So a couple more questions. The – you referenced the size of project. So are we going to keep this at a – the initial, I guess, period here we talked about when we met about sunset? Have we got any more thoughts on what the sunset would be on this here, the size of the projects that would fall into this, and commercial slash residential? Certainly. So currently, what we believe will not be eligible will be subdivisions because of the size and the number of structures that are involved in those. So we expect, though, commercial and potentially some large residential, but primarily this will be a commercial industrial type of project. Part of the pilot did include, say, an amenity center for a subdivision because it was one sort of isolated set of facilities, but a broad subdivision would not – would not be eligible at this time. In terms of a sunset, I believe we discussed the plan to provide reporting at the six-month mark and the 12-month mark for the committee and for the council to identify – or to know how many projects went through the process in those time frames, the success of those – of those projects to understand what time frame were being achieved. All right. All right. Is that currently in the legislation or does that need to be introduced as an amendment? It is not currently written in the legislation. It is not currently written in the legislation. I think that would be beneficial if someone would want to introduce the sunset, the commercial parameters as well in this here. That would be beneficial in the project if someone's willing to introduce that. I've got a motion, and I've got a second. So for discussion on this, Councilman Arias, are you on this amendment? Okay. So no other speakers in the queue on the amendment. It's all in favor of the amendment to – or, Michelle? So the Chair could, I get some clarity on what exactly that amendment is regarding the sunset provision and the – Right. So the sunset would be the six-month and 12-month review. The reporting. Reporting. Reporting. That that's – that's required and that this here is for commercial facilities only. I think if you would like to also include it for, like I mentioned, the amenity center at a subdivision, whether, you know – That would be still a commercial – Versus residential homes. I guess we'll – there may be some small townhome communities that a developer may be interested in running through the process. And so I think it's, you know, it's up to the committee whether they want to limit those types of facilities from this process. Clarify that, the last statement you made about the townhomes. So, for instance, the difference between a large subdivision that may have 200 homes, that would be too difficult for all of us to review and turn around in 30 days. However, if it was a smaller residential townhome community with, say, you know, a dozen townhomes or whether it's an amenity center within a subdivision, we've even heard from some developers who may be working on, say, a $8,000 or $10,000 – a 10,000 square foot home where the owner may be interested. So, again, you know, it's really up to the will of the committee and the council whether they want to limit that or not. Otherwise, if we don't limit it now, we can do it through the application process. We will be looking for eligibility and using it and determining from a program perspective whether those projects are eligible. Okay, so you're saying you can regulate the size and the facility that this would uncover, so we would not need to include that. The only thing we would need to include in the amendment would be the sunset or the reporting for six and 12 months. That's correct. I believe because the legislation already includes an eligibility application process that we could limit those without having to provide specific language about which projects are eligible. So it's just – the amendment is just for the six and 12-month reporting. Did that clarify that, Michelle? Through the chair, yes, it does. I think perhaps the word sunset is not appropriate here because sunset would mean the requirements would expire and no longer be applicable. I think you just mean the reporting requirement would be at six months and 12 months. Is that correct? Correct. Thank you. All right. Mr. Chair, just as the introducer of the amendment, I'll go ahead and amend the amendment to reflect exactly what you just said. Just keep this thing kosher. So I've got a motion and a second to amend the amendment. So now let me go to Council Member Clark-Murray on the amended amendment. Thank you, Chair. Actually, my question was just answered. I needed to know exactly why the sunset or now we've revised the term so that it is expire and what exactly was going to sunset or expire. So now that I have a better understanding that it has to do with the reporting requirements, I am fine with that. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Let me go to Dr. Salem. Thank you, Chair. Chair, I spent a half hour or so with Director Sickler on this bill, and it seems to me having a big net where developers, if it's a 10,000-square-foot home and they're in a rush and they want to pay a large fee to expedite it, we ought to allow them to do that, amenity, whatever it is. I would be comfortable in allowing Director Sickler and her team to decide that. Right, and I think we're pretty well. Yes. I'm just supporting your – I was on the queue, so I was going to say something. All right. Thank you, sir. Let me go to Council Member Arias. Are you on the amendment? Okay. I'll come back to you then. So we're on the amendment. So on the amendment to the amendment, and so I've got a motion in a second. On the amendment to the amendment, all in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Likewise, none. So the amendment to the amendment carries. I get a motion on the bill as amended. Amended as amended. Through the chair to the committee. So you just approved an amendment to the Boylan amendment. Now someone needs to move the Boylan amendment as amended, and if that gets approved, I'll ask if you want to roll those up. Okay. So I've got a motion in a second on the Boylan amendment as amended. So I've got a motion in a second. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Likewise, none. The amendment to the amendment carries, and we can roll them up. And so now can I get a motion in a second on the bill as amended? I've got a motion in a second on the bill as amended. Council Member Arias, you've been waiting a while. Thank you, Chair. Ms. Ziegler, if you don't mind, please, coming up here. I have four questions, and through a chair. I have three minutes. All right. Good. So we're looking at, I'm seeing here, I'm reading on the amendments, $20,000 of a fee may be increased to $40,000 potentially. What is the cost breakdown on that? Like, how did you determine what goes from $20,000 to $40,000? Obviously, it's size, but yes, but there has to be a cost breakdown. Through the chair to Council Member Arias. So the additional fee would be based on the need to either, because of workload, if there are a great deal of them, in order to either pay overtime for our staff or bring on a consultant to assist with keeping up with the workload. This process is very labor intensive. We meet several times. I think it's five times with about 12 to 15 attendees on the city side alone. And so if there are a large number of these, it would require a lot of personal attendance and review. So that's the additional fee, the first $20,000 to $40,000. Okay. So through the chair, with that part, are you guys even incorporating any AI software or any kind of software in general? Because you mentioned staff, but why are we not really touching into technology right now to save developers money? That's a very good question. And we are pursuing AI review. That is going through several modules right now. I think we have three of them working to be over 90% accurate, but it's not geared right now towards Express Lane, because Express Lane is so specific to the project. We meet with all of the folks involved in the project, and that part of it is not as easily handled by AI. Thank you. So that part is not really in motion right now for the express review. It is in motion, but not for express reviewing. Yes. Okay. That's correct. Last two questions with a minute left. What if the project gets stuck in review, let's say with comments, COJ comments, are we going to issue these developers a refund or some sort of partial refund? Because if we're talking about a 30-day express review provision, but you guys end up taking 90 or 120 days, there's nothing expressed about that. So what are we going to do to take care of our developers? That's a very good question. So we are going to be charging this fee in three tranches. The first 25% is the initial review. If the developer is not able to complete their portion, which is the returning in five days, they will forego their part. If we, if the city is unable to, then we will look at ways of either pausing the process or refunding the portions that they've paid to date. So they're not paying it all up front. We will be step-by-step determining at what point who is able to or not able to complete their obligations. Well, thank you, Chair. And that, I'm glad you're looking out for them as well, too, and taking ownership of that part. So thank you for pausing the program or whatever the case is for that. Thank you, sir. All right. Thank you. So a couple more questions. I don't have any other speakers in the queue right now. We recently approved the third-party reviewer process and where they have to take the exam. And so I'm curious to why, if they take the exam to be approved, they're a local or just a Florida-registered engineer, why are we not taking their design instead of trying to go through it and just basically that would be the express lane? There are, I think there are two parts to that question. So for the private provider, those folks have to be independent from the original designer. So for private provider, it's essentially for those folks who are qualified as private providers to serve in the capacity of the city. It's not exactly the same as if the developer's designer submits their information and gets through the process faster. This is a very personalized process of making sure that all of the city's obligations are met without holding up the project. Okay. All right. I may come back to you here in a second. I want to call up Mr. Henry Vort with AVA Civil Engineers. It's quite familiar with the design process. And just, if you could, sir, give your name and address for the record. Henry Vort, AVA Engineers, 4201 Bay Meadows Road, Jacksonville, Florida. Thank you, sir, for being here this morning. Looking at this bill, this process, from your professional position, do you have any concerns or support or anything in regards to this bill? Actually, I'm in support of the bill, Ms. Nina, and I was on the mayor's committee that I didn't help them with the bill, but I helped them with the concepts, so to speak. I'm for the concept because right now developers are spending a lot of money. When you borrow money to bill something, just like a mortgage, we're all paying pretty high premiums. Sometimes we see people paying $50,000, $60,000, $80,000 a month for a construction loan. It drags on for six, seven, eight months to get a 10-set through the city. It's a lot of money, so the $20,000 that Ms. Nina and the city is proposing is well within what a lot of my clients are more than willing to pay to expedite a process for the city. So the $20,000 and the way that she's presenting the bill sounds great, and I really hope it works because, again, every client I've got wants to pay the money to get this done. The only thing I have a concern is with the city's staff is that sometimes they're a little difficult to get in touch with and all this. If we've only got one week as an engineer to do or make a lot of comments come true in a week is going to be a little difficult sometimes. Maybe this will help streamline things. Maybe it will help speed things up. Again, I'm for it, but I have some concerns, and I'm sure it's like any ordinance. It will have some rough patches, but I think if they work with us and we work with them because all the engineers I've talked to are for this, a lot of engineers are skeptical that it's not going to happen. I just want everybody to know I'm for it. I'm from Jacksonville. I want to see this happen for a lot of reasons, and it will be good for Jacksonville. So, again, some of the concerns are about what happens if I can't do everything I need to do in a week's time. That's going to be on us, and our clients are going to have to understand that we might not be able to get it done. But as long as we can all work through this as a team, the city, us as private engineers, and the community, I think Jacksonville will be the better place in the state to have people come to Jacksonville. Because right now we have clients that are very old and been around for a long time. I'm old. I've been around for a long time. My firm's been in business 31 years, and we have people that say they don't want to work in Jacksonville or build anything in Jacksonville. So, again, I just wanted to pass that little bit of information on Mr. Chairman, if that. All right. So, just stand by here a minute. Let me go to the queue here. Let me go to Councilmember Bolin. This question is time for you. Through the chair, it's Ms. Sickler. A couple of things. I think I like the bill. I like the obvious impact it could have. But I am concerned about the others who don't qualify for this kind of expedition review, how it's going to impact them. And then secondly, any thought to, given Amendment 3 and everything else, that the reallocation of these additional dollars will give you the opportunity to enhance your staff so that we're not compromising all the other permits that don't qualify for this kind of review? Through the chair to Councilmember Bolin. So, this is one of eight strategies that we've been taking on over the last year and a half. One of them, as Councilmember Arias referred to, is our AI initiative. We are having great success in developing the rules needed in AI to review plans. And that is a very cost-effective process. So, we see that as an option for those who are not interested or able to justify $20,000. The AI, my expectation is it's under $1,000 for AI review. So, that would be a lot more affordable. We also have a business assistance initiative that is in soft launch right now, where we have folks identified for businesses to come into our permitting office before they sign a lease, before they plan to open a business, in order to walk them through all the permits required to give them the expectations. So, we have a number of initiatives. I appreciate that very much. But specifically to the earmarking, how those dollars will be used to supplant and support the operation of the department, can you speak to, is that intentional? Is that built into this bill that the administration is willing to say, and these dollars will be used and stay within the planning department, or I guess it would be development services, to augment the staff that are necessary to expedite all of these permits? Yes, that's correct. Thank you. The dollars paid into the building fund will stay within the permitting divisions in order to make sure that all permits are effective. I want to make sure that was explicit in the bill. Thank you. Thank you. Councilman Arias, you're in the queue. Thank you, Chair. Ms. Sikler, through the chair. So, thank you for – that was one of my questions as well, too, as Mr. Boylan expressed, is, you know, what about the smaller businesses? You know, they can't afford $20,000. So, the fact that AI is going to be a $1,000 review process, that's awesome to hear. Two questions remaining are, are you going to have a dedicated team, as the gentleman just spoke about? You know, when you're looking at these processes and we're caught up in the comments section of it, to have them also be caught up in the same comment section as somebody with a regular permit that's not having an expedited permit, that could be an issue. So, are you sharing the same individuals, or are you going to have a dedicated team for this to make sure that it truly is express service? Through the chair to Councilmember Arias, that is the reason we are charging the fee for staff hours. By charging the cost of the additional service, it allows us to fund, whether it's positions, if that's allowed, through the budget process, or through consultants, to make sure that the regular queue of permits are not negatively impacted. Okay, and that's what I thought. So, here's my next part. Realistically, through the chair, how many expedited permits are you going to see in this threshold of the $20,000? Are you looking at about $1,000 per year is what I'm calculating, $500 to $1,000 per year, correct? The initial will be much smaller than that, that we can accommodate. Can you give me a number of what year? We are looking at probably $100 or so in the year. Okay, through the chair. Let's say it is $100,000, and they're paying $20,000. You're looking at $2 million in revenue. It's going to be more than $100,000. 100% guarantee that. I calculated between $500,000 to $1,000. Let's say we have $1,000. You're looking at $20 million in revenue, right, which is great for our city. But my question to you is, is $20,000 really what is needed to support the personnel that you need to expedite this? Is it not $10,000 to get started? Do you have a tier breakdown? Maybe we start at 10, 15, 20, 40, whatever the case is. I don't think that our permits are created equally. Whatever this individual needs may not be the same thing I need. So why $20,000 as a minimum threshold when you may only need to use maybe $6,000 of city resources and staff members for that? $20,000 seems like a pretty high number to get started. So to my last question to this, have we done any kind of community workshops with the stakeholders in our community? Because I feel like I said, $20,000, it might be a number that you came up with with five hours of what it will take, like you said earlier. But I just think it's a number that was just made up. And if we have 500 permits requested, that's over $10 million in revenue. That's well more than what you need. Thank you. Thank you, Chair, to Councilmember Aria. So as I mentioned, we did six pilots. We documented the hours that were associated with those pilots. And those pilots, and I do have a spreadsheet that identifies those of you. I would be glad to share that with you. Those hours are what was put together in order to determine the initial fee. And so in terms of different permits, what I'll let you know is that this is on top of the regular permit fee. These are the additional meetings and coordination that are required. The permit fees that are normally charged are already, will still be charged. And those are more specific to the type of project. These meetings, regardless of whether it's a large industrial or a fast food restaurant, we still have 12 people at each of these meetings. And so that's the type of additional work that was documented in the spreadsheet. And I will be glad, again, to share that with you. Thank you, Chair. Just one more question on that part, please. So, Ms. Zickler, you said that you had pilot meetings or whatever they were. Who did you have them with? Sure. These pilots were actual submitted applications from, we had a fast food restaurant, we had a grocer, we had a storage area, we had a private road network, a amenity center, and an amenity center pool. So those were with those developers, their entire team throughout the entire 30-day or less process. So they are not individual meetings. They were the entire application process. Got it, and I'm done. My point to this is that they were not community stakeholder meetings, is my point. A meeting to really have developers at the table to really address this issue. I hear the gentleman, I heard his concerns were similar concerns that I had. I see the good in this bill. I think this is great for our city. I just think that we still need more input from our community versus just having individualized pilot meetings with those applicants. That's my only concern. That's it. If I may, we met with NEFPA monthly. This was one of the topics. We also have a specific permitting task force that Mr. Thorpe mentioned, which met to discuss these. So while it wasn't the general community, it was developers, and it wasn't just the developers who applied. It was a broad range that we met with probably on a monthly basis over the last year. All right. Thank you. Let me go to Michelle. You're the chair to the committee and maybe to Council Member Boylan specifically. But I'll need you all to clarify. You passed the Boylan Amendment, which added this reporting requirement at six months and 12 months. But it's not clear to me at what point that starts and what are your metrics that you're looking for in those reports. Okay. So the time would start once the legislation become codified. So that would be the day one. So what we're looking for, the successes and the, where the, what we, adjustments that we need to make to, I guess, basically measuring the successes of it and how it's, if it's being effective or not. And as the reporting of all the, I believe, had said they've had six of them they've done now, we would be looking for a report if there's, in six months, if there's 50 of them, we would want to report on how all 50 progressed, whether they completed the full permitting review or if some stopped midstream, just what, what happened on that process of getting the permit issued. Okay. So to the chair, we'll use the effective date of the legislation to start the six month and 12 month period and we'll measure successes, recommendations, measurements of effectiveness and outcomes. Correct. Thank you. Yes. Dr. Salem. To the chair, I was going to suggest number completed in that, in that period of time, number that are still outstanding and observations on maybe changes that could be made to the program to make it more effective. Correct. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. A couple of more questions I got for you, Ms. Sickler. In the, in the one week review that y'all will have and then you turn it back over for corrections, how are y'all going to handle traffic concerns? Any department that's not necessarily under the, the building or the planning. So to get that response back from those departments that the applicant needs to be able to resubmit. All of those departments and divisions have been engaged. You mentioned traffic. There's traffic is both in development services as well as the, the traffic engineering division, which is part of public work. So many of those are already within my department. Those that are not, we have already been through a great deal of training and outreach to each of those, each of those departments and divisions, EQD, others that are already built into the process that we've developed. All right. I just want to make sure we're clear and on the record about all these questions that come back to the, the applicant that they're, they're aware and they're under the timeline to get it turned back around as well. The other issue that I've heard is when the applicant gets it, gets it returned to them for corrections, they resubmit it and then they get another request back with a whole list of new questions. And it needs to be basically streamlined into answer what the, the concerns are from the first return and not to keep having these repeated, oh, what about this and this item and that item to where we're basically streamlined into one return, answer those questions and we don't keep compiling more requests. Correct. That's really a beauty of having everybody in the same room at each of these meetings is that all of those things get worked out. So there's not multiple questions or things that come back that weren't meeting expectations or that were not expressed as clearly as you can in person or on a virtual call. Okay. So I think that kind of addresses everything. Um, so if I, between now and then council night, if there's more concerns, I'll, I'll reach out to you. Uh, so with that, I've got a motion and a second on the bill as amended. Let's open the ballot and record your vote. Six jays, zero nays. By your action, you're approved 20, 26, 0, 8, 8, 5. So thank you. Thank you everyone. Thank you, Mr. Vort for being here this morning. All right. This is back to the beginning of our agenda. Finally, item number one, 20, 20, 24, 0, 9, 9, 9, 6, 6 is deferred at the request of council member Carrico. Item number two, 20, 26, 0, 1, 9, 2 is deferred at the request of council president Howland. Item number three, 20, 26, 0, 2, 2, 7 is deferred at the request of council member Diamond. Item number four, 20, 26, 0, 3, 2, 0 is deferred at the request of council member White. Item number five, 20, 26, 0, 6, 7, 7 is deferred at the request of council member Carlucci. Item number seven, we've already taken action on. Item number eight, 20, 26, 0, 8, 0, 9. Can you have a motion on the withdrawal? I've got a motion. I've got a motion on the second on the withdrawal. No speakers in the queue. Open the ballot and record your vote. 6 yays, 0 nays. By your action, you've approved the withdrawal. In number 20, 26, 0, 8, 0, 9. Item number nine, 20, 26, 0, 8, 1, 0. I've got a motion on the withdrawal. I've got a motion in the queue. Open the ballot and record your vote. 6 yays, 0 nays. Open a ballot, record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate the opportunity. I know with this being withdrawn, but the conversations I've had with folks, I think this is a great opportunity. I appreciate Councilman Diamond withdrawing it, but I think it's a matter we might want to give some thought to. It's a great opportunity. I know there's some of the private sector interested in seeing this happen, and I think it's an opportunity that we should continue to explore. Thank you. All right. Thank you. By your action, you've approved the withdrawal of 2026-0810. Item number 10, 2026-0818 is deferred at the request of the administration. Item number 11, 2026-0822 is deferred at the request of the administration. Item number 12, 2026-0845, can you get a motion on the bill? I've got a motion and a second on the bill. No speakers in the queue. Open a ballot and record your vote. 6-A, zero nays. By your action, you've approved 2026-0845. Item number 13, 2026-0846, can you get a motion on the amendment? I've got a motion and a second on the amendment. Ms. Carrier. Through the chair to the committee, the amendment will include a reference within the bill to the application that was submitted and the payment of the fee. We'll also remove the waiver of subsection 745-105, I-1, requiring the honoree to have achieved prominence. This waiver is not required as part of this bill. All right. And no speakers in the queue. On the amendment. All in favor of the amendment, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Likewise. None. The amendment carries. I'm going to get a motion and a second on the bill as amended. I've got a motion and a second on the bill as amended. Dr. Salem, you're recognized. Thank you, Chair. It just seems like this council continues, and this is not a reference to Councilmember Clark Murray because it's happened many times, the ordinance says they have to have been passed for five years, and now we're pushing people that are living. Now, one could make the argument that you want to honor somebody when they're alive to enjoy the fact that they've been honored, but that's not the way the ordinance reads, and this is getting worse and worse. I mean, it's a continuing process that either we need to change the ordinance code or because we're violating it every single time, and there are good people out there that I'd like to recognize that have passed, but they haven't been passed five years, so frankly, I'm waiting to honor them, and I'll be off the council, but I'll work with somebody when I'm gone. This is just not what we should be doing. All right. Thank you. Let me go to Councilmember Clark Murray. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Councilmember Salem, for those words because I do understand, and I'm a person. I look at the ordinances, the code that applies to a particular bill, and so I also think about my mentors. One of my mentors is the Honorable Warren Jones, and he often tells me about the intent, what was the thought process in regards to many of the existing ordinances that we have, and the Honorable Past President, I'm sorry, Past President Matt Carlucci, the two of them, they are just a wealth of information, and I bring the two of them up to say this, is that they talked about why that particular five years deceased portion is in the code, and it was because during the time that the city was consolidated, and after, immediately after, there was a great deal of corruption. So they wanted to make sure that the names of those who were honored, it would not come back to bite them because it was found that they went to jail or went to prison or were involved in various nefarious and illegal activities with their positions. So with that being said, and in particular for this particular honorary street designation, this gentleman is a bishop, so I think he's beyond reproach, and he has various churches under him, and he's been a pastor for 45 years, and he's been in this location for 45 years, and I can, I've been to his church before, and I wasn't campaigning, so I think this is a sure bet in terms of this will not be one of the bills that we pass in which we do approve this waiver that will come back and we'll regret it. For example, we can talk about the Cesar Chavez bill that we, we, we, I don't know why I have an issue with, we rescinded that particular, what was it, resolution, because later on it was found that what he had done to women, but I don't think we have to worry about that in this particular case, but I do understand your concerns. Thank you, Chair. Other speakers in the queue, I've got a motion and a second of the bill as amended. Let's open the ballot and record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. By your action, you're approved, 2026-0846, and I agree with Councilman Dr. Salem on this, that maybe we need to look at the, the ordinance to change it to where, like if you've got some that you're wanting to get, get in, in, in, that's been deceased, and that hasn't met the five year, that you'd have that opportunity. I'd be willing to, to look, look back at that as well. So that takes us to our next item, number 14, 20, uh, we've already taken action on item 15, we've taken actions, 16, we've taken action. That takes us to item number 17, 2026-0858 is deferred at the request of administration. That takes us to item number 18, 2026-0868, get a motion on the amendment. I've got a motion, a second on the amendment. Ms. Carriher. Through the chair to the committee, the amendment will remove the waiver of code section 106-303, which is not needed for this bill. We'll correct some scrivener's errors and attach a revised exhibit one, which is the BT, to correct the account information. All right. No speakers in the queue on the amendment. All in favor of the amendment, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, likewise? None. The amendment carries. I've got a motion, a second on the bill as amended. I've got a motion, a second on the bill as amended. Ms. Clark-Murray recognized. Let's see. Thank you, Chair. Is there anyone here for this bill? Is there the mayor's office of general counsel? Thank you so much. So my good friend and colleague, the Honorable Michael Borland, asked a good question some months ago. It may have been last year, in regards to the city and litigation. He asked a question in terms of what we received from the complainant. So, and he said, well, was it worth it? So in this case, is it just, through the Chair, is it just more convenient to settle as opposed to go to the full, I guess, go to court over this particular case? Is it just easier just to settle? Through the Chair, Councilwoman Clark-Murray. So, and I will tell you, Councilwoman, I generally do try to have individual meetings. Talk a little closer to the microphone. Sorry, I generally do try to have individual meetings with all of you prior to bringing the litigation. In the event that it doesn't get passed, we don't put a lot on the record because it is still pending litigation. So I apologize if for whatever reason that did not get scheduled. And I'm happy to come and speak with you further before final council vote as well. But yes, ma'am, there was a lot of work done on this case and there is an issue that had taken place as a disability discrimination case and it's regarding a promotion exam that this gentleman wanted to sit for and it's regarding the accommodations that we did not provide for him. Um, and I can say this on the record because it's, it's a matter of fact, um, the entire time I've worked at OGC, which is going on 15 years, we've never had a finding of calls from the EEOC. And in this particular case, the EEOC determined that the city had in fact discriminated against Mr. Stefanco. Um, it was brought to my attention by a couple of council members that they would, he did indicate that he would not sit for any further promotion exams, even though he has five years left with the city, he entered drop in January. Um, and I was going to ask, um, if Councilman Salem would be willing to maybe move the amendment to allow me to amend the settlement agreement because he has agreed to put that in writing. I know that was a concern that you had when we met that if he was willing to say it during deposition that he would not sit for any further promotion exams. Is that something that could be added to the settlement agreement? And he has agreed to do that, but I would need to, and I had spoken with Mr. Fopolis about it. Um, I would need to amend the settlement agreement just to, to have it all buttoned up. So if you would move that additional amendment for me, I would appreciate it since you were the first to, to raise it. Okay. Well, thank you so much because I do actually still have the floor. Oh, I'm so sorry. But I do understand. Yeah. I mean, but, um, but, um, but you did answer. Answer my question in, in your discussion. And I do apologize also. Time for me is extremely short and I think we did have a, we text each other about it. So, yeah, so I did have that one particular question after reading the entire, um, the entire bill. So, but I will relinquish the floor at this time. So then. Thank you. Before we go to Mrs. Salem for that motion, um, Mr. Boylan. Okay. Go ahead, Mrs. Salem. Yeah. I'd, I'd like to amend the bill that this gentleman will not sit for the exam at any point in the future. Is that sufficient? Rita? Um, yes, sir. So that will be, the way that, that will get, um, really codified is that will be the settlement agreement will get amended and the settlement agreement is an exhibit to the bill. Um, and so we'll get new signatures on that, that settlement agreement and attach it to the bill. Yes, sir. Uh, it's been second, all in favor of the amendment, any opposition, amendment carries. Uh, Mr. Boylan, do you still? I move the bill as amended. To the chair, did you want to roll up those two amendments into one? Yes, that would be the, uh, the proper thing. I was trying to give him the floor because he was still in the queue. Uh, we go ahead and, uh, you're called to roll them up. Uh, move the bill as amended, uh, roll up the amendments and move the bill. All right. So we're, we're in the correct posture at this point. Can I get a motion? That's what I'm looking for. You've got it. Okay. And it's been second, but I'm just to say, I just wanted to comment, uh, and I appreciate, uh, Clark Murray, Council Member Clark Murray recalling comments I made at prior time. You know, sometimes it is expeditious to settle, uh, because it's less costly sometimes as well. But there are instances, however, I think you, you, you pointed out even in this conversation that there have been practices or policies in place that maybe we were better to, to settle than to, to take it to court because we might have had some issues. But that's a learning process for HR and everyone involved. Ms. Mayors, do you want to comment on that very quickly? Yes, sir. Um, I just want to say that we definitely take the opportunity with each of these cases when we find things that need to be done, um, possibly could have done better or different, we do sit down and round table them. And we often involve the administration as well as anyone in HR that touched it. Right. And even since the last disability discrimination I was in front of you on, um, there have been a lot of changes made. And I'm, I'm, I'm, I like that to be part of my job is not just to litigate cases, but to try to make changes that we don't have that exact same fact pattern again. And I think it was important to point that out. So I appreciate the opportunity to do so, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. Right. No other speakers in the queue. The, the bill has been moved and second. The bill as amended has been moved and seconded. Let's open the ballot and record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. By your action to approve 2026-0868 as amended. Next item, number 19, 2026-0870 is deferred at the request of administration. Item 20, we've already taken action. Brings us to item number 21, 2026-0872. Can I have a motion on the bill? I've got a motion and second on the bill. Those speakers in the queue, open the ballot and record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. By your action to approve 2026-0872. Item number 22, 2026-0873. Can I have a motion on the bill? I've got a motion and second on the bill. Those speakers in the queue, open the ballot and record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. By your action to approve 2026-0873. Item 23, we've already taken, I'm sorry, item 23 is 2026-0874 is deferred at the request of administration. Item number 24, 2026-0875. Got a motion on the bill? I've got a motion and second on the bill. Mr. Bowling, you're recognized. Actually, Mr. Chair, I want to circle back. I'm not to call for reconsider, but item number 21, I was hoping that I could hear you pronounce the name of the gentleman who's been reappointed there. Mr. Bowling, I'm dying to hear it. If you're here, please come on up and tell us how to proper pronunciation. So, I'm going to say it fast, but you've got to follow me. Shiva Malapa. Okay, so let's break it up. Let's break it up. S-H-I-V-A Shiva is one, and we all like the mall, M-A-L-L mall, and then Appa, A-P-P-A, Appa. So, Shiva Malapa is fine. Okay, well, I'm going to go ahead and apologize to you right now. You know, Mr. Bowling, I, you know, we sent an invite to you to come to the Diwali celebrations because to, if you ever come, you would have familiarized yourself with not only my name, a hundred of other names that you would have to do. Thank you very much. Appreciate it. All right. Thank you for, yeah, if you would, I guess, since you did come up and speak, give your name and address. My name is Mahesh Shiva Malapa. Address is 7837 Mount Rainier Drive. All right. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Thank you, everyone. All right. Let's see. I think we were on 24. All right. Item number 24, 2026-0875 has already been. I've got a motion and a second on it. No speakers in the queue. Open the ballot. Record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. All right. By your action, you're approved. 2026-0875. Next item 25, we've already taken action on. That takes us, our next item, 2026-09-05 is on second, as well as 0915. Item 28, 2026-09-07 is on second, as well as 29, item 29, 0-9-1-8. Item 30, 2026-09-2-1 is on second. Item 31, 2026-09-2-2 is on second. Item 32, 2026-09-2-3 is on second. And then item number 33, 2026-09-2-4. Can you get a motion on the bill? I've got a motion and a second on the bill. No speakers in the queue. Open the ballot. Record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. By your action, you're approved. 2026-09-2-4. Item number 34, 2026-09-2-5. Get a motion on the bill. Got a motion and a second on the bill. No speakers in the queue. Open the ballot. Record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. By your action, you're approved, 2026-09-2-5. The next items are on second, 2026-09-2-6, 0-9-2-7, 0-9-2-8, 0-9-2-9. And that brings us to item number 39, 2026-09-3-0. Get a motion on the bill. I've got a motion and a second on the resolution. No speakers in the queue. I'd like to be added as a co-sponsor. I've got a motion and a second on the bill. Open the ballot. Record your vote. Six jays, zero nays. All right. By your action, you have approved 2026-09-3-0. And item number 40, 2026-09-3-1 is on second. Dr. Salem, you're recognized. Yeah, we're at the end of our agenda. Thank you, Chair. I just want everyone to know that clock up there is bugging the hell out of me. And I have asked Mr. Dennis to take care of that. If not, I'm going to bring a ladder from home and get up there and do it. Because, I mean, we wait much longer. We're going to change time again. Thank you in advance, Mr. Dennis. Let me go through the queue here now. So we've got Mr. Bolin. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to note the passing of my predecessor in the seat, Matt Schellenberg. And I'm grateful that we were able to pass the resolution at the last council meeting to recognizing his contribution and service. I do not have any information at this point in time. But we'll certainly pass it along when we have it. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Let me go to the birthday girl, Ms. Tarona Clark-Murray. Thank you, Chair. And actually, it's my birthday. And so, because I am here all day, y'all, I am giving you all brunch slash lunch. So we have fish and grits in the Bob Johnson room. So when we are officially dismissed, we can go over and have some fish and grits. And you can enjoy yourselves. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Mr. Dennis. Through the chair to Councilman Salem, I heard your stomach growling over here. So I made sure to let powers that be to know to go ahead and get that changed. And on another note to the committee, 2026-0822, I took off my readers. That's Solomon Olapati going to the Construction Trade Board. And I know in the last committee that, Chairman, that you received some information regarding Mr. Olapati. I just want to ask, if you all received any information regarding any of the appointments to the Construction Trade Qualifying Board, any board, please forward over to us. Because you all may come across something or someone shared some information that we may not have. So, you know, moving forward with, you know, if you could just, again, provide some information or whatever information that you may receive regarding this appointee or any appointee in the future. Thank you. Thank you. All right. And in regards to that, you know, I have received information, but I'm waiting for Tallahassee to confirm. So I'm not going to just send something out that's not been confirmed. If I get something confirmed, then I'll gladly share it. But I want to get all my facts together before I even put anything out there. And I ask that with you as well, because you had mentioned that the last meeting you had got a letter that none of us here as well had. So anything that you get, we ask that you share it with us as well. So, you know, the whole point that we've got to ensure that we're charged with as a committee here is making sure that we get the right people in the right place to protect and ensure the integrity of the city of Jacksonville and all of our boards. And that's what we're all here to do, not to block or prevent somebody, but just to make sure that we've got the best for our city and our people. So with that, I have no other speakers in the queue, so we are adjourned.