All right. Good evening. Good evening, everybody. It is five o'clock, November 17th. We're going to go ahead and start the Land Use and Zoning Committee. If all the council members will make their way to the dais, thank you. We'll go ahead and start with introductions to the left. Ken Amaro, City Council, District 1. Reggie Gaffney, Julia, District 8. Good afternoon. Rockman Johnson, District 14, the west side. Joe Carlucci, District 5. Kevin Carrico, District 4. Randy White, District 12. Terrence Harvey, Office of General Counsel. Susan Kelly, Planning Department. Aaron Abney, Planning Department. Casey Cox, Planning Department. All right. Thank you. And just for the record, Council Member Diamond has an excused absence. Is that what I'm hearing? Okay. All right. So, Council Member Diamond will not be with us tonight. And we want to introduce our page this evening, Ms. Layla Terrell. Thank you. Give her a round of applause from La Villa School of the Arts. It's majoring in creative writing. They don't call it majoring, but it's what they specialize in there. So, with that, we're going to go ahead. Did you need? You good? Okay. All right. We're going to go ahead to, hold on one second. Eric, are you here, sir? Or Mr. IT? I just need the cue pulled up. Oh, wait. Okay. Okay. There we go. I'm good now. All right. Thank you, sir. All right. Item number one, 2026-124. Let's open the public hearing. No speaker cards. We'll continue this public hearing until 12-126. Item number two, 2026-125. Let's open the public hearing. No speaker cards. We'll continue this public hearing until 12-126. Item number three, 2026-126. Open the public hearing. No speaker cards. We'll continue this public hearing until 1-5-26. Item number four, 2026-127. Let's open the public hearing and get a staff report. Do we need a staff report on this? No staff report. All right. Do we have any speaker cards? No speaker cards. We'll go ahead and close the public hearing and bring it back to the committee. All right. We have a motion and a second on the substitute. All in favor of the substitute, signify by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? Substitute carries. All right. We have a motion and a second on the bill on the substitute to re-refer. This is the ballot. Ballot vote. Open the ballot. Record your vote. He was here for introduction. Six yays. Zero nays. By reaction, you have substituted and re-referred. Item number four, 2026-127. Item number five, 2026-436. Open the public hearing. No speaker cards. We'll continue this public hearing until 12-126. Item number six, 2026-523. Open the public hearing. No speaker cards. We'll continue this public hearing until 12-126. Item number seven, 2026-524. Open the public hearing. No speaker cards. We'll continue this public hearing until 12-126. Item number eight, 2026-556. Councilmembers, please declare your ex parte communication at this time. Go in once. Item number eight, 2026-556. Any ex parte? Councilmember Gaffney, you're recognized. Thank you. Through the chair, I do actually do have ex parte. I met with the applicant last week in the green room last week. We agreed to meet up prior to the night meeting. However, I have not met with him. So what I would like to do, I'm not sure if he's here tonight. Mr. Anthony, I don't see him. So what I would like to do, because I was supposed to meet with the applicant of this legislation, and we didn't get a chance to meet. So what I would like to do is defer this bill, one cycle. I'll reach out to him, I guess, tomorrow. And hopefully we can meet before the next LUC. Okay. And last call for the applicant, Anthony I.K. Are you here? All right. I will grant a one cycle deferral, and then after that we will vote on it. And hopefully the planning department will reach out to Mr. I.K. and let him know that attending the vote for the public hearing and his bill to get his rezoning, he needs to attend. So with that, we'll grant the one cycle deferral. Do we need to open the public hearing again, Mr. Harvey? Or can we just have an additional public hearing on the next? Just keep it open. Okay. All right. And what's the next? The next one will be December 1st. All right. So we're going to go ahead and reopen the public hearing, and we're going to continue this public hearing until 12-1-26. All right. Item number 9, 2026-558. Council members, please declare your ex parte communication at this time. Going once, going twice, seeing none. All right. Councilman Gaffney, you recognized. Hey. Thank you, Thuda Chair. I want to declare ex parte. Mr. Curtis Hart reached out to me yesterday, asked me, did I have any questions in regarding this legislation? I'll make sure everything gets filed up in legislative services. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Councilman Johnson, you're recognized. Thank you so much. I have additional ex parte. Although I did declare ex parte before, I spoke with Mr. Hart. I actually called him. I also spoke with Pastor Willie Barnes of St. Paul, as well as Ms. Betty Burney, who is a representative of St. Paul. And they were asking about clarification on the project so I could be able to put in something on their behalf. So I'll speak to it when that comes up. But this is being filed with legislative services. Thank you. Councilmember White, you're recognized. Mr. Alder-Clear, ex parte. I spoke with Mr. Hart. He called me yesterday and gave me some information, and that will be filed. All right. Thank you so much. With that, we have no other ex parte. Let's open the public hearing and get a staff report. Thank you. 2026-558 requests to rezone approximately nine acres for a property with frontage along Richardson Road. They're seeking to rezone from RLD 60 to RLD 40 to allow for the development of single-family homes on smaller lots consistent with RLD 40 standards, which would be a minimum lot width of 40 feet and 4,000 square feet in size. The property is in the LDR land use category, which permits up to seven units per acre. At this density, the maximum number of homes that could be built on the site is 63 single-family dwellings. The applicant has indicated that the intent is to be less than the maximum. Staff finds a request consistent with the comprehensive plan. The site is within the urban area, where LDR supports compact single-family neighborhoods that are connected to both city water and city sewer. The rezoning furthers policies encouraging efficient growth, additional housing supply, and redevelopment of underutilized residential parcels. The site is surrounded by all sides by LDR designations. RLD 60 zone properties are within the immediate area, and other institutional uses include neighboring parcels operating as a church. Recent rezonings nearby include a PUD for townhomes, and this is on the east side of New Kings Road. This demonstrates an established pattern of existing neighborhood-scale developments, and will allow a logical continuation of single-family developments within and along Richardson Road. New Kings Road, which is a primary nearby arterial roadway, is operating at 75% capacity. Transportation ran an analysis on what the expected daily trips per first 63 homes would be, which is the maximum that would be allowed to be built there, and it would produce 573 daily trips, which would not bring the nearby roadway out of capacity, given the proposed development. For these reasons and those in the staff report, we forward a recommendation of approval. The application was heard at the September 17th Planning Commission meeting. There were several speakers in opposition citing concerns about traffic, given that Richardson Road provides only a one-way in, one-way out connection to New Kings Road, along with concerns about flooding in the area and incompatibility with the surrounding neighborhood. The applicant clarified that under the existing RLD-60 zoning, the subdivision would include 32 dwellings, but they intend to develop 42 lots if the property is rezoned to RLD-40. The commission expressed no concerns and found the proposed development consistent and voted unanimously for approval. All right. Thank you so much. We have two speaker cards, and Mr. Hart, if you will. We don't have a card for you, so if you'll fill one out. I'll apologize. Okay. Yeah, no, you're fine. We'll go to you first, and then the next card is do not wish to speak, so Mr. Curtis Hart, name and address, please. Curtis Hart, 8051, Tara Lane. Mr. Chairman, this is an application to rezone a small nine-acre parcel to RLD-40. I have met with several individuals as members of a church and not members of the church, and I have agreed to change my application to RLD-50 rather than 40. Any questions, be glad to answer them. All right. Yes, sir. No one is in the queue. So next we have Christopher Robinson, and he is in opposition and checked. He does not wish to speak and or questions only. So with that, we have no other speakers, and we're going to go ahead and close the public hearing and bring it back to committee. Amendment. Yep. Yep. We have, well, we did get a motion and second on the bill, but we're going to go to Council Member Johnson. You're recognized. Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. I am just wanting to put it in that I spoke with, as I shared in Exparte, with Pastor Willie Barnes. The reason I'm involved, Pastor Barnes is my fraternity brother and friend, and I'm very familiar with St. Paul. I want to thank Mr. Hart for going out into the community consistently several times and meeting with them, as well as Ms. Betty, the Honorable Betty Seabrook-Burney, former school board chair. They just asked that I stay into the record, Mr. Chair, that they respectfully request the committee carefully consider and the planning department the long-term effects of the proposal. They are agreeing to this, which is why they're not here tonight, but they have agreed for the 50-foot lots, and so this is a great compromise to see when the community and developers can come together. But I did this letter that I received from Reverend Barnes, or Dr. Barnes, will be placed into the Exparte file so that it can be put in the record. Thank you. Okay. Thank you so much for that. Mr. Hart, do we need to, is that an actual amendment, or is that just something he needs to agree to, Mr. Harvey? Well, you guys will need to amend the bill so that way it's reflected, because it's less intense. You won't have to send it back down and re-advertise and re-notice, because it is less intense. But we will need an amendment. With that, I move to amend, Mr. Chair. Okay. We have a motion and a second on the amendment. All in favor of the amendment, signify by saying aye. Any opposed? The amendment carries. All right. So, I guess, all right. We have a motion and a second on the bill as amended. No one in the queue. Let's open the ballot. Record the vote. Six yays. Zero nays. By your action, you have approved 2026-558 as amended. Item number 10, 2026-657. Council members, please declare your ex parte communication at this time. I think everybody should be getting in the queue. All right. Council member Gaffney, you're recognized. Thank you. Through the chair, I'd like to declare ex parte. I spoke with Mr. Cockerell today. He informed me that he'll be increasing the parking spaces, I think, from 15 to 24 parking spaces. He also asked me, did I have any questions? And I make sure everything gets filed with legislative services. Thank you. All right. Council member White, you're recognized. I'll declare ex parte. I spoke to Mr. Cockerell, I think, yesterday. And this morning, I wrote out and looked at the facility myself, and that will be filed. Council member Arias, you're recognized. No, it's not on. Okay. All right. Thank you, chair. I'd like to declare ex parte. I've received numerous emails, about 12 in opposition, regarding this matter. I've also spoken to the applicant, Mr. Josh Cockerell, regarding this. And I also drove by the site just right now, actually, before OZ, to look at the facilities, and it's all currently being filed. Thank you. Council member Kairiko, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have ex parte to declare. I have nine emails in opposition. I had one phone call from Ms. Roberta Thomas in opposition. And I also took a phone call from the applicant's representative, Mr. Cockerell, explaining the changes in the parking, and that there was more parking, and that's all we got. So, we'll get it filed with legislative services. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. Councilman Johnson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I rise to declare additional ex parte. I've received 12 emails in opposition to this legislation. I also got the same phone call from Ms. Roberta Thomas, and I spoke to Mr. Cockerell about an hour ago, 30 minutes to an hour ago, to give me the information on the new parking structure that's being filed with legislative services. Thank you. All right. Councilmember White, you're recognized. Yes, sir. Sorry. Through the chair, I've admitted the emails that I have received, and those have been filed also. Thank you. All right. And I will go ahead and declare ex parte. I met with Steve Matchett on November 16th at 1030 in my office to discuss the previous PUD and what's being proposed now. I texted with Josh Cockerell today, and he let me know about the new site plan, the parking conditions. And then also on 1117, and prior to that, we have about 17 emails that we're going to be filing for legislative services. So with that, we have no one else in the queue for ex parte. Let's open the public hearing and get a staff report. Thank you. This is PUD rezoning ordinance 2026-657, seeking to rezone approximately 1.05 acres of property from a PUD. The current PUD is from 2017 to a new PUD, with the sole changes to add beer and wine sales for on-premises consumption. All existing recreational uses approved under the current PUD, which would include batting cages, miniature golf, soccer training, and related recreation open space uses will remain unchanged. The proposed alcohol beverage use is strictly accessory and must operate in conjunction with the recreation facilities and food services. A beer and wine service will be physically separated, occurring exclusively within a designated enclosed area, and not visible along the measurement line from the nearby school, which is the Harvest Community School. The PUD design does include landscaping and site orientation that further shields the facility from surrounding uses, and the recreational layout and existing buffers ensure that it's all contained on site. Again, this is just to add beer and wine sales only. We find it's consistent with the comprehensive plan with the ROS land use category. We find it meets internal and external criteria. So for these reasons and those outlined in the staff report, we forward a recommendation of approval with one condition in your agenda. This is a condition that's currently on the PUD, so we're just forwarding it to the new one. And then you also have a revised Exhibit 4 site plan that's dated November 16th that shows additional parking on site application was heard by Planning Commission on October 8th, where there were several speakers in opposition, expressing concerns about the additional alcohol sales, given the proximity to the existing school and the potential for traffic and noise that would be generated by the use. The Planning Commission agreed with these concerns raised by the community, and they ultimately voted unanimously to deny the PUD rezoning. Thank you. All right. First, we have Mr. Josh Cockrell. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Josh Cockrell, 200 North Lars Street. Staff, thank you so much for that report. As stated at the last Land Use Zoning Committee meeting, I took on this project after the Planning Commission, and just highlighting a few things about this. This is a facility that's been here since 1996 through an existing PUD. And this PUD, the owner that purchased this a year ago and implying for this addition to the PUD by adding beer and wine sales, nothing was changed in this PUD with the exception of adding beer and wine. So the PUD was still operating as it is currently today, meaning nothing has changed. What has changed since then was the addition of the beer and wine. Since then, he opened the facility after he bought it last year. He opened the facility right prior to summer and closed it thereafter summer back in August in order to put $150,000 plus in improvements in the facility. We're talking about updating the batting cage equipment and machinery, the nets, updating the mini golf turf. He updated and painted the building that's on site, put a new roof on it, updated the turf on the soccer field. So we made quite a bit of a number of improvements, including to the restrooms. We're coming and restriping the parking lot. At our last meeting, we heard quite a number of concerns regarding parking. It was something that the community had made about it. And what I did is I presented to you a new site plan for you all to look at. This site plan actually gets rid of the existing soccer field and adds an additional 14 parking spaces. So instead of the existing 15 parking spaces that have been here on this facility, we now have a total of 24 parking spaces. That will alleviate quite a number of the parking concerns that were pre-existing that would continue to operate today if this does not move forward. We are asking to add beer and wine. So even if beer and wine does not get approved today or does not move forward through final council vote, the facility will continue operating as it is, meaning with the 15 parking spaces and as it continues to do as it has been. This is a concession that we're willing to make in order to have beer and wine sales on this property is to alleviate that concern. Now, we have heard from the community. I've heard from, I even showed Mr. Match a little bit ago the parking plan and hearing from him as well. They still are adamant about not wanting beer and wine. I've been around through this city. I was even at Bravo's just this past weekend for my kid's birthday party and they have beer and wine. You know, it's a kid's entertainment facility. I was at Chuck E. Cheese at another birthday party, beer and wine. It is not abnormal to have beer and wine and even liquor at a lot of our entertainment facilities, whether they're skating rinks, movie theaters, whether they are our city parks even having alcohol sales at them as well. It is not an abnormality to have these. I know some of your districts have entertainment facilities that offer alcohol. It's not abnormal. It's not abnormal to have them even, and we'll talk further about it if it becomes an issue, and which I have not heard from the church otherwise, to have beer and wine adjacent to a church even, much less a school. We have a church right next door to Bravo's in your district, Councilmember Arias, that serves beer and wine. So that's not abnormal. The issue here, and why we're here today, is to ask simply for beer and wine sales at this pre-existing PUD and property that would not change otherwise. Thank you, sir. I ask for your support on this, and I have any questions you may have thereafter. All right. Thank you. We will give you time for rebuttal after we go through the rest of the cards. Next. I'm going to call a few names, and if you all want to come down to the front row, we have some seats reserved for all the next speakers just so we can have everyone kind of be in order here. So next we have Steve Matchett, followed by T.W. Moore, Larry Wagner, Lisa Ransom, Debbie Gelwix, and then Robert Petty. So if all of y'all wouldn't mind making your way down to the front row, and we have Mr. Steve Matchett first. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Steve Matchett, my address is on file, members of the committee. This item was introduced at City Council in late August. Since then, there have been seven public hearings and several deferrals along the way to where we're here tonight. At all these meetings, the Arlington neighborhood has turned out strong to testify and oppose this rezoning. They have sent you scores of emails. They have been patient through this process and look forward to the prospect that after almost three months, a final committee vote can occur here tonight. You and the Planning Commission members have heard from scores of the area residents testifying to the traffic impacts of the proposed development, which is located adjacent to the Hartsfield-Fort Caroline roundabout. You've seen on the site plan how the development clusters its outside bar and seating in the property's extreme northwest corner, literally a few steps from the roundabout's pavement and across the street from Harvest Community School, for which the applicant also needs a distance waiver. You don't have to go out 1,500 feet for that waiver either. School is right across the street. It's more like 50 feet away, and there's been no hardship given to justify any distance variance. You've heard the concerns over the introduction of alcohol sales into a facility that was designed for youth in sports, and that they now want to target corporate events and celebrations, and this is from their written description, which has not been revised. In a party atmosphere with amplified music, full food service, food trucks, and the sale of beer and wine. I always thought those kinds of places were called restaurants and that they required commercial zoning. That is what this place does not have, a commercial zoning that is unlike all the other examples cited by the applicant. All those do not exist in a middle of residential neighborhoods, literally. You have heard testimony from surrounding neighborhoods and homeowners associations, and not just some, but all of these. Ashley Green, Raymer Villa, Brittany Bluff, Colony Cove, Fort Caroline Club Estates. That neighborhood is united. You've heard from the adjacent neighbors, two of which are battling severe health issues and are here tonight to talk to you as well. You've heard from a former city planner who just happened to write the staff report for this item 30 years ago. What is noteworthy about all this neighborhood input is that it has been unanimous in its opposition, as was the Arlington CPAC when it voted on this item back in August, as was the Planning Commission when a rare unanimous denial on October 8th voted to deny this. And now, hopefully here tonight, we're asking you to deny this proposed rezoning. Thank you. All right. Thank you, sir. Next, we have T.W. Moore. My name is Thomas Moore. I live at 4096 Cove St. John's Road, Jacksonville. The reason I'm here tonight is because I was appalled two weeks ago when the applicant put in his new site plan for that time, and it didn't fly. So two weeks later, we're back with another new site plan. I agree with a previous speaker. This is going to go on and on and on. Now we're up to 24 parking places for 173, unless they've revised that number, people. Most people don't live six to a car. So there's going to be extra cars out there. Where will they park? There's no parking. This was a batting cage. I moved here 33 years ago, and the batting cage came along just a couple of years after I moved here. Good idea for the kids, practice, build their skills. Coaches can work with them. Great idea. It was not a beer garden, but that's what the attempt here is, is to turn it in to an outside party. Soon, towards the end of the evening probably, people will have taken on enough beer that they'll straggle out, walk into a road where there's no place to maneuver, and there'll be injuries. So I cannot see any reason for granting this. This is a residential, quiet area. If you need a beer, you can go up to the shopping centers. I think that the only thing that we're against is beer and wine, although loud noise and so on is not desirable either. But the beer and wine, not a good idea. Thank you. All right. Thank you, sir. Next, we have Larry Wagner. Larry Wagner, 5654 Nesbitt Lane. I've been a resident of Arlington for close to 40 years and have enjoyed its neighborly distinctions through this. I'm not particularly, I don't live particularly close to this, but I drive by on the roundabout on a regular basis, usually being passed by people doing 45 and 50 miles an hour down Fort Carolyn Road. And I think the traffic can also be attested to by the number of times the palm trees in the roundabout have been replaced. So this is a high traffic area. The argument is not number of parking spaces, whether it's three or 300. The argument is alcoholic beverages. And as the previous speaker has said, this has been kind of going on and on. And it looks like y'all are looking for an excuse to have beer and wine there. Like, let's find some reason to approve this. I'm reminded of the quadruplex apartment complex y'all approved at the end of St. Isabel Drive about five years ago that was surrounded by single-family residential. This committee approved that. Yeah, sure, fine, go for it. It was defeated in city council. We'll be at city council opposing this again. And if y'all don't go ahead and say, yeah, this is not the right place for this type of operation, I give you a final comment is, for those of you who have visited the site, perhaps you have noticed the 12-inch tree branch that's been against the fence now for weeks and weeks and weeks. The property is not being maintained now. I doubt if it will be in the future. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Next we have Lisa Ransom. Good afternoon, Lisa Ransom. I'm a 32-year resident of the Arlington area living half a mile from this location. I'm opposed to the ordinance because the proposed PUD would allow the intensification of an entertainment use with an outdoor eating establishment and services for beer and wine. Seeds for approximately 172 people with parking. The use would further expand a spot land use of ROS to allow general commercial uses in the area that has developed with single-family uses in schools. The only alcohol sales in a general area are located in commercial districts and are either in enclosed buildings or solely allow for package sales, not for an outdoor on-site consumption. In addition, the agent mentioned at the November 4th LUZ that this business would be similar to those in Riverside, which is not true because those uses in Riverside and San Marco operate in commercial zones and can sell alcohol by right or package stores or bonafide restaurants. That is, Metro Diner and Chuck E. Cheese are in commercial zones and are enclosed. I'd like you to take a look at Ordinance 2010-847E, which is the ordinance for the Greater Arlington Beaches Vision Plan. It was adopted under Mayor Payton, and it was a study that involved strong community involvement and city council approval. There's a map inside of that vision plan. It talks about targeted mixed-use areas, which denotes University Boulevard, Rohera Road, and Townsend Boulevard as the targeted misuse areas. It does not show on the map Hartsfield Road. One of the guiding principles was to identify, preserve, protect, promote, and enhance the neighborhood assets and character of the Greater Arlington Beaches communities. Throughout this process, the steering committee placed the utmost emphasis on preserving and protecting its neighborhoods. The building uses, scale, and character should be as compatible with the neighborhoods, as stated in the Objective 1.1.2. Complementary Renewal also describes redevelopment that is compatible with the existing built environment, existing built environment, in terms of building youth, scale, and character, which would be residential. Location Distribution. It also stated that the maximum compatibility with surrounding uses would support growth in appropriate locations. Again, I mentioned the map. The document identifies nodes and corridors that support the most intense growth throughout the neighborhood. Zoning regulations, as stated, should be evaluated for consistency with the vision presented in the document as it relates to neighborhood compatibility. And the fact that city council approved those statements, those are not my personal statements, we highly recommend and would request that you deny this PUD for beer and wine at Hartsfield and Fort Caroline Road. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Next, we have Debbie Gelwix. Hi, Debbie Gelwix. My address is on file. I wanted to say that our community opposes the sale of beer and wine, and not a graphic designer here, but this is the map that I drew up. So as you can see, all of this area around there is residential. We have this school across the street. The ingress and egress is right at the batting cages. We have a church down here. We have a church down here. And we have another school on Hartsfield Road. So everywhere else is either single or townhouse areas residential. This residential goes all the way down Fort Caroline. It goes down most of Hartsfield. We're not opposed of the situation if it was all the way down at Hartsfield and Merrill, because that's commercial. I would not be opposed if it was on east or west of Fort Caroline, because once you get to university, Merrill Road, they are commercial. So that is the problem with the residential area. My next fact is the Harvest School that is right across the street. I talked with the secretary. They said their hours are from Monday to Thursday, 7.30 to 3.00. They have after-school activities that last right now until about 5, 5.30. During the spring and fall, they last until about 6 o'clock. This involves inside the school and their soccer field right across the street. Fact three, there was no meeting set up by the agent or the owner that was suggested by the city council last two weeks. We did not receive the revised last two weeks. I think we were just handed it right now. So as is suggested by city council, there has been no effort on their part for meetings. Fact four, the batting cages have been closed for the last couple months. Our community is afraid that this is going to become a venue, not just a recreational. So you're going to have people drinking outside, music outside, and it's going to hurt the residential communities around there. Thank you very much. Thank you. Next we have Robert Petty. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, ladies and gentlemen of the council for your time tonight and for your service to our community. My name is Robert Petty, and I live at 8256 Fort Caroline Road, right next door to the applicant's property. Due to my chemotherapy treatments, I was unable to attend the last meeting, but I did watch it in entirety on recording. And I'm here tonight, despite not feeling great, to address some of the points raised. Mr. Chairman, you closed that portion of the meeting last time by saying your vote was still open to change, but that you needed a solid reason why alcohol sales should not be allowed, and that kids present wasn't good enough. I hope to give the council several reasons, and I believe they're pretty straightforward. First, the applicant has repeatedly emphasized the money invested in this property as a whole. However, I believe the intention from the beginning was to introduce a restaurant and bar into an existing sports facility, and I think you can kind of read into that with their willingness to give up yet another sports activity or their soccer field to provide parking for their beer and wine sales. Their website, which was taken down just prior to these hearings beginning, advertised lunch, dinner specials, beer and wine, and music until midnight, with very little emphasis of the sports activities. That tells me where their priorities were headed. The surrounding homeowners, myself included, have also invested heavily in their properties, many much more than the $150,000 they've invested. We chose this section of Arlington because it was quiet, safe, and removed from the noise and congestion of commercial areas. We didn't choose Riverside, the South Side, or Beach Boulevard. We chose this neighborhood for what it was, and we shouldn't have to sacrifice that because somebody wants to introduce a different type of business here. We choose peace and quiet and late-night music in a bar, not late-night music in a bar next door. Secondly, and perhaps most importantly, the law exists for a reason. Our city has established restrictions on alcohol sales near schools to protect children and preserve the character of surrounding neighborhoods. A waiver is an exception, not an entitlement. I do not believe the applicant has demonstrated a hardship that justifies one. Furthermore, we've already seen repeated issues involving them, violating the city's noise and sign ordinances, resulting in multiple calls to JSO and to the city. That raises a legitimate question. If a waiver is granted with stipulations, who will be responsible to enforce them? Will that burden fall on the very residents who must live with the consequences? Are we expected to monitor the violations, document them, file the complaints, and wait for someone to act? That is a reasonable burden. That is an unreasonable burden to place on a neighborhood and to those of us that live here. Thank you. Sorry. Yeah, your time is up, but we appreciate that. All right, next. I'm going to read the next couple of speakers, and if you all want to come on down to the front, that would be great. Jack Ogin, Ed Radloff, Burt McLaughlin, Brenda McLaughlin, Joe Newton, and Laura Ogin. Come on down. Come on down. And first up, we have Jack Ogin. Good evening, guys and gals. My name is Jack Ogin. I'm at 6101 Raintree Road. Just to let you know, I'm a retired fireman for 31 years at the fire department. I've been retired for eight years. My son's working at Station 27, which is down the road as a lieutenant in rescue. I'm just going to try to give you some heads up about that road. It's basically called Dead Man's Curve. It's called Dead Man's Curve for a reason, because I don't know if you've been out there or even looked at this property or looked around, but trees have been replaced there about three or four times in the middle of that roundabout. Not only that, you can see all the crosses with the flowers and all the memorials on it, stuff for all the deaths and stuff that happened over there. I don't think alcohol is going to help that at all, being around that area. I coached baseball down the road at Arlington for years. We used those batting cages. I think that this thing going through with the batting cages is basically a Trojan horse trying to manipulate the neighborhood. There's a lot of good people, innocent good people that live in that area, the schools, the church. Everybody in there abides by the rules. That road has a speed limit of 35 miles an hour on it for a reason, because people fly through there. The drugs and all the other stuff that comes with the alcohol. I know you're just talking about alcohol and stuff, but me just being on different bars and stuff with girls getting roofied and all that kind of stuff, you're inviting a bad situation in that neighborhood. I hope you pay close attention to it, because I will, and I know my son will. I know every incident goes on over in that area. Councilman Cressabinney, back in the day, I built a boat shed. It was three inches above what it was supposed to be legally. Cressabinney called me on the phone personally and said, Jack, you're three inches above. I said, you were talking about three inches. He said, I know, but if you do three inches, your neighbor's going to go four or five. Neighbors after that one go six or seven. When I first moved into that neighborhood over there, rules were rules, and you didn't violate them. And I went ahead and paid for the shed to come down and everything and abide by the rules. I hope you all go ahead and do this. And I can't even put bark out there by my runway or whatever, because without the city coming by harassing me about different things. So with that, I expect you to be strict with this ordinance or whatever you've got to do as far as this special situation here. It's not a good recipe, because there'll be people paying the price for this. And other than that, I said my piece. Thank you all. All right. Thank you, sir. Next, we have Ed Radloff. Good evening. Ed Radloff, address on file. I would first like to give our thanks to Council Member Romero to be here tonight to listen to the citizens in our district on this ordinance. I'd also like to thank the council members that went by the property today to take a look at it. Mr. Cockrell stated two weeks ago that Colony Cove, which is a neighborhood I live in, is a mile away, where there are 14 neighborhoods within one mile of that proposed batting cage doing alcohol sales. This is a residential area. It isn't a commercial area. An exception was made 30 years ago to provide a sports outlet for young kids, because Arlington was known for its baseball teams, Little League teams. And the community came together, and an agreement was made. Now we are faced with them trying to go ahead and basically put beer on wine. As you've heard from many of the residents and neighbors here tonight, it is a very dangerous intersection. And we're also faced with increased traffic due to the addition of Madison Pimes. And so for people that live in Arlington, traffic has increased on Hartsfield because people want to get away from Merrill Road. And so we are seeing increased traffic coming down Hartsfield. And when you come down Hartsfield at night, it's not very well lit. And so if you start adding a nighttime venue, and for those of us who were here two weeks ago and left with the arts market, that's exactly what they're looking for, loud music and party atmosphere at night. That's a recipe for danger. It's a recipe for disaster. I would urge the members tonight to vote no on Ordinance 0657. Thank you. Thanks, sir. Next, we have Bert McLaughlin and Brenda. I'm Brenda McLaughlin, 3651 Hartsfield Road. My husband's sitting here. He gets real winded if he stands up and starts talking, so he wanted me to present this. Go ahead. Basically, we've been in the area for almost 40 years, 39 years out of 50 years of marriage. We originally built Baseball Heaven in 1996. If we'd have known it was going to come to this, it was to help kids in the area. And we were coaching our son at the time, who's in heaven now. But anyway, we were coaching our son, and my husband took several teams to state championships. And anyway, he was successful at it, and he wanted to help kids in the area. And it was never intended to become a tavern or a bar or anything like that. It was just to help kids in the area. It was successful until his health cell was reclining, and we sold it to a professional baseball player who was later called back up to the pros. And then the last two sales, we had nothing to do with. But we made sure that the gentleman that purchased it was going to keep that same type of business. You cannot compare this area to a commercial area. It's predominantly residential. Some people like to party. Our grandson, he moved to San Marco because he wanted to be in a partying area. We like to be in a residential area that's quiet, and so that's the way we would like it to stay. When you go, when you're at your home in the evenings, we live next door to this facility, like I said, because we build it. And when you're at your home in the evenings, you don't want unexpected situations where there's going to be JSO called or not so much JSO, because we didn't call them when they were called twice back in March because of the loud music and everything. We didn't call because the neighbors had already called us and said, how can y'all even hear? I can't even hear my TV that's in the middle of my house. So what we're trying to say, this is not a commercial area, and it's not a situation where you've got somebody that's going to have a New Year's party, which we all have neighbors like that that have these loud parties, and you think, well, thank God this don't happen once a year. Or you have an issue with somebody throwing a birthday party, which that's what we think figured happened on March the 8th. But this is going to be happening every day, the drinking and the, well, I'll say beer and wine. But we also know that that leads to, ensues to other things when people are consuming alcohol. We've been at ball fields before where people have come up and they had been drinking, and they start arguing with the other parents about, you know, how the game's going and stuff, and we've had to ask these parents to leave. So I just ask you to deny this, because it's not for a residential area. Thank you, ma'am. Did Mr. McLaughlin want to speak, or we can lower the podium down if we need to? The first thing I'd like to say is the gentleman said the last time that he was up here that I lost my right to say anything when I sold it. I want to agree with him. I did. I lost my right when I sold it, but I didn't sell it because I wanted to. I sold it because I had to, because of my health. But I'll tell you this, when I started Baseball Heaven, it was because I loved kids so darn much, especially the younger kids. And I built it. I didn't only own it. I built it myself. And I built it because of so many kids. A lot of them didn't have the money to go to Baseball Heaven. So I'd take them over there, and we'd bat for free, teach them how to bat, and just have a good time. I wish I could do it today. So it breaks my heart to see it go back to alcohol, because alcohol was the only problem that was ever caused in any small kids' baseball games. And there wasn't no alcohol. We had no problems. And that was the main reason I did it. And I wish this guy a great relationship with Baseball Heaven. I hope he does well. But without the alcohol. That was my next comment. We wish them success, but not with the alcohol. We wish them success in this business, but not with the alcohol. It's just not a good mix with the children. All right. Thank you. Thank you. The last thing I want to tell you is that it can be run financially good if you're there every day working it hard and controlling it. You can make a good living doing it. And if you second mortgage your house like we did to build it. And, sir, before you go, can you state your name and address for the record? 36-51 Hartsville Road. That's my entrance to my house and the entrance to Baseball Heaven is 20 feet apart. Yes, sir. All right. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. And we'll get to Brenda. Next, we have Kathy Berger, I believe. Are you here? Come on down. And after Kathy, we have Eunice Barnum, if you want to come down to the front, followed by Joe Newton, Laura Ogan, and then Kishla Tirado-Morales, maybe? Yeah. Okay. And then Arthur Ressler. So those are the next speakers. If you all want to get ready and lined up, that'd be great. So, Ms. Kathy Berger, you are up. Name and address, please. Kathy Berger, 11354 Skimmer Court. I am down the road from the area in question. I don't have anything prepared to talk about. I'm just an avid softball player. I've played for 50-some-odd years. I've been in criminal justice for 42 years. I don't see how a beer and wine sales equates to harsher activities. I also know that I've played at several parks around here where they carry their own on. I also know that, according to the JSO stats, the issues in that area are not necessarily related to drinking. Several residents here have valid concerns, which can be solved with working with the company that owns the batting cage to make it comprehensible. But I grew up playing in a little neighborhood park in Minnesota where my dad and his friends, who all played traveling underhand fast pitch, brought a case of beer. They played their hearts out and then sat around and drank. Nobody drove home drunk. There was no issues with it. I play adult softball. I play adult competitive softball. I play senior softball. And there's no issues with that. I've been to several of the parks here, and people drink at the parks. I've picked up garbage at all the parks because of what's left there by non-participating people who are attending the parks. I just think that this is a missed opportunity for growth. And I think the concerns of the residents can be addressed through other alternatives in preventing one person from selling beer and wine. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Next, we have Eunice Barnum. Good evening. Dr. Eunice Barnum, and my address is on file. What do we pay you all for? I'm sitting here reading the law. We have 46 attorneys that we pay a salary to that's supposed to educate you all about the law. What happened to the law that says you cannot, shall not, put a liquor store within 500 feet of a school, a church? What happened to that law? Well, I'm still reading it out here. And if you all get to decide who can put what on their property, what do we need you for? Let people put whatever they want wherever they want it. It's their property. What are we going to pay you all to decide? Then you decide to let them do it anyway. It doesn't make any sense. If they get to choose and put what they want on their property, we don't need you all. They own the property. They get to do as they choose. If the law says no, and then you say yes, something is wrong. Have a great day. All right. Next we have Joe Newton. Thank you, counsel. I actually own the property at Zero Hartsfield. My name is Joe Newton. I am the neighbor to the south of this property, so I butt up against it. This is my first opportunity to speak. Longtime resident in Arlington. We have a nonprofit down the road at the Gazebo Shopping Center, the Artist Connection Theater, that we have built up over the last five years. It's a volunteer. It's a passion that we have, and so we share with this community a lot of history. I went to the high school, Terry Parker High School, and so I've been around for quite a while. During the day, I'm a real estate broker, and so I serve as an assistant broker for Keller Williams Atlantic Partners. I have been a real estate agent in Jacksonville for over 10 years. I'm a team leader there. I oversee 290 agents in four locations in two states. We do over a billion dollars in real estate transactions. I teach, do property evaluations, and understand the value of property. My biggest concern, along with the ones that have been voiced here, I'm in opposition to this change. My biggest concern, outside of just the fee simple use of my property, is the value effect. The nonconformity of this plan will create a deficit to the property values that surround it. In real estate, it's a very simple principle. It's not complicated. When you put something in the middle of a stable environment that's different, it has the effect of lessening the property values around it. It can be from 5% to 15% reduction. I think this particular endeavor is, from the beginning, it was nonconforming. There was a lot of efforts made to try to mitigate that along the way. It was, in essence, a recreational area. Then it was recreational with concessions, but the main focus was recreation. At each moment, we've been creating a kind of a cumulative commercial intensification of this property. And every time we do that, we affect the value of the properties around it. And so now we're moving into a phase where it's not so much recreational, it's much more of a food service, and then the alcohol added to that. So we've gone from recreational with some concession to an eatery and kind of a bar atmosphere with some recreation on the side. I think that's a fundamental shift in the usage of this property. That will create a problem with the values around it. When you create something that's nonconforming in an area, you lessen the number of people who might be interested in purchasing, and that's going to cause a market problem for you. All right. Thank you, sir. Next, we have Laura Ogin, maybe Ogin. Evening. My name is Laura Ogin. I live at 6101 Raintree Road. Been there for almost 40 years, raised four children. I have a hard time believing that we're still talking about the same thing, and it keeps getting referred. It's been proven that it shouldn't be allowed, but yet still here we are. I agree that the alcohol is just a trojan for something more, because if he decides, oh, we'll just give up the soccer, then is he really there for the activities and maybe some food? 24 parking spots are not going to fix the problem. You're going to line up on the side of the street. When you're approaching the north end of Hartsfield, it's a hill. So you're coming over a curve with a hill. That's blindsiding people. You add liquor to that. You're going to have issues. Not to mention you have no time frame listed of the hours that they're going to be open. So you have 60 feet of area, which is the road and the easement, from the Batting Cages property going west to Hillcrest. You have 154 townhome families. Somehow I don't think that they're going to want loud music going on until God knows what time. It's ridiculous to think that we're standing here talking about this when I believe none of y'all would want that in your neighborhoods. But yet here we are for Arlington, and we're on, what, our fifth or sixth time having this on the ballot or on the docket here? That's ridiculous. Thank you. All right. Thank you, ma'am. Next we have Kishla Tirado Morales. Sorry. Who's speaking? I'm the interpreter for Miguel Garcia. Yes. Okay. And the gentleman here is? Michelle Garcia. Oh, Miguel Garcia? Yes. Okay. Great. Thank you. Go ahead. Good evening. First of all, since I bought this property, my neighbor from the back is being harassing me. Yes, I've been calling the city hall. He's been calling the city hall. He's been calling the city hall. I've been having an inspector coming over. I've been doing all of it with permissions and permits. That property has been listed, like, for over a year, two years, nobody bought it. I bought it. I've remodeled. I've remodeled. I've been doing the ceiling, everything with permits. I've spent a lot of money on the machines. Because the others that were viejas, they were bad. I've bought new machines. There were, like, old machines. There wasn't working, so I bought new ones. I've spent around $60,000. I've spent, like, $100,000 just fixing the whole property. I even bought a food truck that cost me over $45,000 just to sell food. I had to close the barring cage because everything was too old. I wasn't able to work with that. So I bought everything new and fixed the whole thing. And in three months that it's been open, I lost over $24,000. Actually, the person who lost the most here has been me. I'm just here requesting a permit just to sell wine and beer and modulate. It's been asked because of the customers. They asked me why I don't sell wine and beer just to have it with the food. I'm doing everything else, moderate. Nothing big, nothing exciting. I never had a problem, I never had a problem with nobody. Not even a fight there. We actually bring a new business to Jacksonville. I bought two more properties to actually do more business and bring more business to Jacksonville. To bring Latin food. And actually, if I try my best, I've been pushed back everywhere I go. We'll give you ten seconds just because of the interpreter time lapse. Excuse me? Okay. Okay. And let me ask a question. Why those people, they can talk a long time, a long time, and me, I cannot spend talking more time here? We gave everyone three minutes. Okay. But there are, like, ten, eleven people, and it's only me. Yep. So I think that you have to give me more time to speak. Yeah. Mr. Cockrell can maybe help explain that to you. Next, we're going to go to Arthur Ressler. Come on down. And then it looks like we have a lot of other people that do not wish to speak. So you'll be the last. Oh, did you want to speak? I'm here. You might as well. Okay. Name and address. Arthur Ressler, 5475 North River Road. I actually hadn't planned to speak. I came here in support of people elsewhere in Arlington. I'm over on the west side of Arlington. I hope that if somebody tries to do this to my neighborhood, what they're trying to do to their neighborhood, I hope they'll all come out and weigh against it, as I came here this evening, to weigh against what seems to me to be a gross intrusion into a perfectly decent residential neighborhood. So I hope on behalf of those folks in that part of Arlington that you will do what seems to be right by them, and maybe someday you'll all do right by me. They try to do the same thing to me. Thank you all. Have a good evening. All right. Thank you, sir. All right. The following speakers checked that they do not wish to speak. If you change your mind and you want to come on down, just step up and come down to the podium. Joanne McIntosh is in opposition. Brett Fails is in opposition. Dori Davis is in opposition. Ralph Glutter is in opposition. Karen Poole, opposition. Barbara O'Connell opposes. Nicole Dinarine-Arcy is in opposition. Christy Stowers, opposition. And Manti Phillips is in opposition. So with that, we will go ahead and give a rebuttal time for three minutes to the applicant. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You know, I also have a real estate license and 15 years in my background in economic development. And what I've seen across this city overall throughout all of our communities in the time that I've been before you and that you've heard many applicants before you is that a lot is changing in this city. Progress is difficult. Change is difficult. This facility has been here for 30 years. And it hasn't changed. Heck, 30 years ago, JTB was, I think, probably Tulane Road. I think probably Councilmember Randy White was not even a chief back then yet. You know, Councilmember Carlucci, your grandfather might have been serving still. And Ken Amara was probably doing traffic reporting back then. You know, a lot has changed in 30 years. Progress is tough. But, you know, things have changed over the years. If it wasn't for recreational facilities evolving and changing, we wouldn't have the great facility like Beach Bowl that we have in Beach Boulevard and Councilmember's District as well. You know, the CRA overlay, I'm going to point that out. I mean, it was changed and actually amended not long ago to allow for breweries such as the Lazy Manatee and the alcohol distance was actually, limitations were actually even reduced. Because things are changing, you know, to allow facilities to come in. This is no different, you know. You know, I presented this new site plan because I heard the concerns, the applicant, the owner and I heard concerns of the parking issues that are preexisting, that aren't going to change otherwise unless we are addressing these matters. And this is an opportunity for us to address this and to codify this change by presenting this. Otherwise, we're going to stick with our 15 spots and there's nothing the community can do about it but complain to the city and continue to complain to the city. Here we're trying to be proactive and make those adjustments and changes. This business here, if I might point out real quick, is only open, so you guys know for the record, is open Tuesday through Thursday, 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Friday and Sunday, 10 a.m. to 9 p.m. We're even willing to look at conditions for the sale of beer and wine after school hours. You know, maybe it's 3 p.m. and we end it at 8 p.m. You know, we can't address, and it isn't my applicant's problem to address, the preexisting traffic issues on this road. They preexist. Nothing we can do about that or any dead man's curve for that matter. They all preexist. But we are looking at this. We can talk about hypotheticals all day long. Y'all hear them every single time we're up here, and it's a lot of fear and uncertainty. But that's the great part about progress is that we have an opportunity to take this head on and to embrace the greatness of the city and economic development in general. This is a great batting cage facility that has a new era ahead of itself, one that I know some of you in your facilities, Councilmember Gaffney, and some of you would love to have in your area, because citizens will come and want to hit baseballs. You know, what's wrong with having a beer, a glass of wine? People are not getting drunk at these facilities. I don't see people getting drunk at Topgolf or other recreational facilities, and they go bowling in some of your districts. This is no different. I'm asking you to consider this and take a long, hard look at it so that we can provide the ample parking that's needed. And one thing, too, real quick, Chairman. No, sir. No, thank you. That's three minutes. Sorry. All right. All right. So with that, we have no other speakers in the queue, so we will go ahead and bring it back, or we'll close the public hearing and bring it back to committee. So we have a, do we have an amendment that needs to be taken up, Mr. Harvey? Yeah. Okay. So we need a motion on the amendment? All right. We have a motion and a second on the amendment. Can someone please explain the amendment? The amendment is a previous amendment that carried over from the last PUD, but it states all SAG lenses, drop lenses, and convex lenses shall be prohibited. Illumination levels at all property lines shall not exceed one-half-foot candles when the building or parking areas are located adjacent to the residential areas. All lighting lamp sources shall be metal highlight, compact fluorescent, or LED. The maximum light pole height shall not exceed 20 feet, and an exterior lighting design plan including a photometrics plan pole and fixtures schedule shall be submitted at the time of verification for compliance and review approval by the planning department. All right. So what we're going to do is we're going to go ahead and take up the amendment, vote on it, and then we're going to get a motion, a second on the bill, and then we're going to open discussion. So with that, all in favor of the amendment, signify by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment carries. All right. We have a motion and a second on the bill as amended. Now we will go to our speakers in the queue. Council Member Amaro, you are recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Good evening, everyone. First, let me say thank you to the community that came out tonight to voice its concern. My heart is moved by the two individuals, the gentleman in the wheelchair who is fighting a fight of his life, as well as the gentleman who foregoed his chemo treatment to be able to be here to express his position tonight. I want to thank the committee members who took the time to drive by and take a look at the location in question. And I want to thank the property owner for making the investment in the Arlington community to pursue his dream of owning a business. All that said, there are some things that are inherently wrong with the request. I know for the committee, it's one of the difficult tasks of trying to make a decision based on competent and substantial evidence weighing the community concerned with the rights of the property owner. When the property owner purchased his property, he inherited the conditions that are there. Historically, the conditions say no alcohol sale. That's the existing condition right now in the simplest of terms. As you've heard, there's a church and a school within the restricted distance from this property. I believe that this request or this application should be denied. It should be denied because right now what's being asked is not compatible with the adjoining uses and the general character of the area. What's being asked is not consistent with the community safety and the community welfare and the community health. What's being asked is a potential problem adversely affecting the vehicular traffic and the parking in that area. I'm all for small business trying to make a living, but you have to fit in. There are rules and there are guidance in our societies that establish this. When we have the Planning Commission and the CPAC coming out against it, I think you see the consensus and the agreement between these two bodies as to that this is a bad fit for this area. As you deliberate, I want you to hear the voices, I want you to look at the facts, and I want you to deny this request. Thank you. All right. Thank you, Council Member Morrow. Next, we have Council Member Johnson. You're recognized. If I may. May I ask a question, please? Absolutely. Mr. Cockrell, if you don't mind, through the chair to Mr. Cockrell. I'm looking through. I want to make sure that I'm making the right decision as I look through the maps. I had a chance to drive over there a couple times, actually, because I wanted to see there were some changes that you said were coming. My question for you is the community meeting. We talked about that before. Did you get an opportunity to have a meeting with the community? I don't know. If so, why or why not? And what were the findings from that meeting? I did not meet with the community, and I did not because, again, I'm here before you regarding this application for one reason. That's for the approval of beer and wine on an existing PUD, and that's the reason why we're here. When we were at this last meeting at LUZ, the community was absolutely adamant, and still, as you heard tonight, adamant, that they don't want beer and wine. So this is not moving forward without the approval of beer and wine, nor do any changes that we're proposing. So to meet with the community when they're absolutely adamant of beer and wine would have gotten nowhere in that discussion. So my question is, again, which was not answered, so did you try to put a meeting together? I said I did not, sir. Okay. Thank you. Is there someone from the community who I could speak with to that? Would you have met with them had you been invited to a meeting? I see two hands there. Could you come up, please, and state your name? Thank you again, Mr. Cockle. Could you come up and do the chair? Thank you, Mr. Chair, for indulging. Through the chair. Go ahead. Name and address, ma'am. Lisa Ransom, 7755 Lynchburg Court East. As far as neighborhood meetings, we do meet, of course, with the Arlington CPAC monthly, and we talked about it at that meeting. But as far as our neighborhoods, we have e-mails going on. I've not heard of any requests for a meeting, but, yes, we would have met with them, of course, if he had requested one. Could there have been a possibility, just at least having the conversation, would you have been open to see what? I'm always open for a conversation, sure. Okay. Thank you. Mr. Cockrell, through the chair, did you go to any of the CPAC meetings and bring the proposal to CPACs? Let me back up. I did not, and, again, if you may recall from my introduction earlier this evening, I did not take on this project or asked to take on this project until after planning commission. So that would be a no. No, no, okay. Thank you. And, again, I will state that, and I would like to hear from the community, the community would still oppose beer and wine, as you've heard tonight, whether I met with them or not. So I do want to point that for the record. Okay. I appreciate that. You may be seated, but what we just heard from the community, Mr. Chair, is somebody who said that, I guess I'm assuming a representative who said not only would they have met, but they would be open to the possibility. And that's, I'm just going by what the young lady just said. And so I, we're not under oath, but I'm assuming that would be the truth. So thank you for sharing. Thank you, Mr. Cockrell. Mr. Chair, I appreciate the indulgence. All right. Well, next we have Council Member White. You're recognized. Yes, sir. Through the chair, if you'll allow it. The gentleman, did you roll up there because you wanted to say something? I'm sorry. Thank you. Thank you, Chair. Okay. No problem. Council Member Arias, you're recognized. All right. Thank you, Chair. So this property, I did drive by there today, recently, to really get a grasp of the traffic issue. And so when I drove by there, one of the things that concerned me was the fact that there, I might be wrong, but there was only one entrance, one exit to this property. And I wanted to actually drive into the property, but I had to maneuver and do some sort of U-turns and park on the side to kind of navigate that part. I didn't like that about having to access that property. Now, I don't have an issue. I'll be honest with you guys. I don't have an issue with beer and wine. I don't think that just because they have beer and wine, Olive Jackson was going to say, let's go to Arlington and let's drink there. I really don't think this is going to be an issue. All right. However, all right, there's big factors here involved in the fact that this is a PUD to PUD, meaning we could have some concessions or some sort of certain conditions to change things. But the fact of the matter is that this is a batting cage. They have a food truck on site, and now they're wanting to add an additional type of use for the facility. And that's where I'm kind of like, we're kind of Frankensteining this piece of property, and that's where I don't like. If this was all done in one cohesive, like, type of business, like a Bravo's, like that was mentioned, or a Topgolf that was mentioned, I would completely understand. But right now, I see a food truck operating as a kitchen, and then potentially a bar, I don't know where, and then additional parking spaces. So something about this just doesn't look like it fits the characteristics of the neighborhood. And like Councilmember Murrow said, you know, I'm pro-business. If anybody here knows that I always back up any kind of small business, I am the guy, 100%, without a doubt. But sometimes you have to make sure that it makes sense. And right now, I'm not finding this making sense for this part of town. If it was in District 11, my district, would I have an issue with it? It all depends on where it's going to be placed, but for the most part, I probably wouldn't, but that's not to diminish what you guys are trying to convey here. So in this case, where I stand, where I'm not sure how to go, is very simple. I'm going the route of the Councilmember, because he has the most competent, substantial evidence, because he understands his neighborhood, his district. And so if you guys are all vocal, and you guys are all here, representing your district, and you elected that individual there to represent you all, that's where I'm going right now. Once again, though, I will be honest, I don't think up here in Wine, it's going to really make a crazy amount of traffic coming to your neighborhood. But I'm kind of torn right now, and because of that, I'm just going to go with the District Councilmember. Thank you. All right. Councilmember Carricko, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I do have a few questions for the owner, so if we could have the translator and the owner come up. I want to hear directly from the owner. Como se llama, senor? Senor Garcia. Senor Garcia. Senor Garcia, gracias. Thanks for being here. Neighbors are worried about parties and noise. What are your plans to mitigate late-night parties and noise and things that might be concerning to them? The business closed at the latest at 9. 9. 9 o'clock. The hours that you operate will mitigate those concerns. And what about the parking? ¿Dónde van a poner tantos carros? I was going to grab the soccer field. Oh, could the translator? I'm sorry, I didn't mean to. Yeah, we don't have a translator. Can you say it on the record? I'll do it. Where are they going to park the extra cars? I was going to use the soccer field because I wasn't using it. I was willing to do 14 more parking lots. So we saw that the applicant in his representation added more parking. So parking noise, to me, those things have been mitigated. And thank you. Those were just quick questions that I had. And I'll just go on the record to say where I stand on this. I don't see a problem with this. It's adding beer and wine. They're adding more parking spaces. We actually have a planning department approval. So the planning department recommends approval. No one has put that on the record yet. So let me go ahead and state that. The planning department has approved it. It wasn't unanimous in planning commission. There were some different opinions. But I think from last time that we had this hearing, where it was a split decision, we couldn't get it out of committee, the applicant has gone back and made some changes, adding parking, addressed some concerns. So I am comfortable with this beer and wine addition. I don't think it's going to ruin the Arlington neighborhood. I have full respect for the district councilman and what he sees. But I've been around this roundabout. I have some friends that live close to there. We go to their house frequently, and I've never seen a traffic backup. I think this is a use that is consistent with just adding some additional services to the recreation that's already happening. So I'm going to be a yes. I don't know where the rest of my crew stands, but I just wanted to put all those thoughts on the record now. Gracias, senor. All right. Thank you, sir. Pregunta? Si. I've been always being able to work with the city, as they asked me for. But since I opened Baton Kish, I've been called by the city all the time. My neighbors call the city all the time. I don't know. It's because of racism, because I'm Latin. I've been trying to do my best. Everything you ask me for, I do it. I get it done. But the business is like a hate, like a hatred campaign. See, escuche, I hear you. This is the part where we have to ask questions for you to speak. But I appreciate you putting your thoughts on the record there. And unfortunately, my time is up. But thank you. I stand where I stand and appreciate you coming down. Thank you, sir. All right. Next, we have Council Member Arias, followed by Council Member Romero. And if no one else, any? You're good? Okay. You're good? Okay. Council Member Romero. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just wanted, on the record, that the applicant has implied that it's personal, and perhaps it's his perception, perhaps it's his reality. But the position that I'm taking, the position that the community is taking, has nothing to do with the individual. It has to do with the use of the facility and its compatibility with the community. And please, as you deliberate, you know, I was on LUZ, I've seen split recommendations before. So that's not unusual. It's, you know, sometimes it's a planning commission on the right side and planning department on the other side. So the split recommendation is not a real indication of right or wrong. So I think it has to, in your deliberation, please listen to the concerns of the community. Thank you. All right. Thank you, Mr. Romero. We don't have any other speakers in the queue. I'll just go ahead and give a few thoughts here. So, by and large, I think we need to separate, you know, beer and wine at batting cages and beer and wine at this batting cage. So am I okay with beer and wine at batting cages? Sure. But it just depends on where it's at. This is not in a commercial district. I went out there yesterday. Did we go out yesterday? Or this morning? Yeah, yeah, we went out this morning to look at this, and I'm glad that I went out there and actually looked at it. It seemed to be a lot of seating for a batting cage, and it seemed to be pivoting towards more of a restaurant than a recreational batting cage. And I don't say that with, you know, lightly, because I know the owner has put a lot of money into the batting cages. I saw that when I was there. He said that when he was up here, so I'm not trying to diminish that. But this is not a commercial zoning, and I think allowing the beer and wine is just opening it up to become more of a restaurant type of use. I think the primary use for this is recreational. Personally, I don't like the additional parking and removing the soccer field. I like the soccer field. I think the soccer field was cool. I could see a picture of my kids being at the soccer field, playing, just doing whatever. And to be perfectly honest, the parking along the street, I know maybe y'all might not like that. That's where I parked, because I couldn't get in, because the gates were locked. But it was fine. I mean, I'm sorry, but, like, it was fine. It was not a concern for me, at least. So that's where I'm at. I don't like the soccer field being removed in lieu of additional parking. Now, in full disclosure, they are allowed to have a food truck there, by right. They are allowed to have seats there. They are allowed to have events there. Their current PUD does not restrict any of that. So for the neighborhood and the community listening, there are things pretty much that they are allowed to do as it stands right now. And there's nothing the city can do about that, because we all have property rights, and we all have business and family to feed. So I just want that to be clear and on the record. So for me, that's where I'm leaning right now. So we don't have any other speakers in the queue. We've got other things to get to on the agenda. We do have an amendment that was passed, and we do have a motion on the bill, correct, Mr. Harvey? So we're ready to open the ballot? That is correct. But there's also an additional amendment. If you guys were to adopt this site plan, you would need to move that amendment as well. And so that would be amending Exhibit 4 of the current legislation to have the revised site plan. Okay. I'm not going to support that new site plan just because it removes the soccer field. But if someone wants to make a motion for that, then so be it. All right. We have a motion in a second on the new site plan that removes the soccer for the additional parking. Anybody on the CARECO amend that? Yeah. Real quick, because the applicant did take the time to revise the site plan and enter it into exhibit. I think we owe it to them to take it up here and vote on it. So they listened to the community's concerns last hearing. They changed the site plan so they could add more parking, so they could alleviate people parking on the street. So that's why I moved the amendment. I think we owe it to them to vote on it. Whether you want to pass the bill or not, I think that's what we should do as a body. So thank you for the second, Mr. Arias. And I hope you'll support me on that. Whether you pass it or not, I think it's the right thing to do. All right. Completely agree. We want to hear that. Thank you for making that motion. Council Member Arias, you're in the queue for the CARECO amendment. Thank you, sir. Yeah, and that's exactly why I will support it. But I do have one question to the applicant or to whoever it is. Mr. Cockrell, if you don't mind coming up. You know, I heard and I'm seeing here 176 seating, whatever the case is, or 150, whatever that number is. You have a total of 15, you're going to have a total of 24 parking spots now, correct? Yes. And let me clarify. That number that the community is deriving, the original site plan, this is before I got involved. My property owner had an architect draft a site plan, a site plan that was not drafted by an engineer, not a site plan that I would have had my engineers, who you have before you, and Bowman Engineering drafted for you. Placed a bunch of tables around the site, something that shouldn't have been done, just a concept for some reason or another. But those tables are not going to be on the site. The seating area is in that northwest corner. You see what the pavilions are, the gazebos. That's the seating area. And so the community derived, based on counting what they saw in that speculative plan concept, a bunch of tables and chairs sitting around, they counted those. So they got derived 172, 173 numbers. That is nonexistent. Through the chair, how many are you guys planning on having? I mean, how many? And chairs. I don't see a clock, so I'm assuming I could take 20 minutes on this. At the discretion of the chair. But we're not trying to open the public. Through the chair, I meant to Council Member, it's about 50. How many? About 50. Five, zero? Probably 50 chairs in the end of the pavilion there. So, okay, so you're looking at having 50, your capacity, you're going to have a sticker that says what your seating capacity is. It will say 50, is what you're saying? Yes, sir. That's correct. Well, then you have way too many parking spots. We have a lot of parking spots. Yeah, because it's one space for every four guests. We have way too many parking. Yes, sir. So we accommodated the concern of the community of having so many parking, not enough parking, but adding the additional parking based on community concerns. So we have way too many parking. But we're basing it on based on the community concern. And through the chair, that was my biggest concern is like 175, like why so many seats? And then A, you're going to have too little parking, but it seems to be the contrary. They're going to have less people, more parking, which is good. But at the end of the day, it still doesn't take away from the fact of what I stated earlier. But, yeah, there you go. Thank you. Yeah. And real quick, just on that point, I'll make this. That parking is, I guess, just for the restaurant component, right? So there is still putt-putt golf there. There's still batting cages there. So there's other uses there that are going to need parking. So Mr. Gaffney. I addressed that. Nope. Mr. Gaffney, you're recognized. Thank you to the chair. Question, this, I guess, it's not a dumb question, but I guess the amendment could still pass in terms of the parking, and the bill could still fail. I guess my question to the applicant, would you still be interested in the parking if we can't get that passed, the alcohol, the wine? Absolutely not. So you say not? Absolutely not, no. The parking is a concept that we are providing as a condition should the beer and wine pass. But otherwise, no, the site will stay as is, the beer and wine does not pass. Okay, so I just want to make sure, Clint, I'm pretty sure all my colleagues heard that as well. So pretty much what he said, you know, if he can't get beer and wine, he do not want an addition to parking. So I just want to make sure, you know, I just want to be clear. My last question, is anyone using a park in terms of the soccer field? I mean, that's, I'm not sure if kids use it or not. Yes, kids will be using it and so forth, as well as the 11-hole mini-putting course and the nine batting cages. And yes, the parking spaces itself is for the entire facility, not just for the seating, for the amenity of the food truck. The parking is for the entire facility, not just for, like I said, the food truck. Okay, all right, thank you. All right, we have no one else in the queue. All in. You want me to do the thing? All right, so all in favor of the CARECO amendment for the revised Exhibit 4, correct? All right, signify by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? Nay, the amendment passes. You want to move those amendments? All right, we have a motion and second on the bill as twice amended, correct? So we're going to roll those up into one amendment. Thank you so much. Mr. Gaffney, you are recognized. I just want to provide clarification. So I'm a yes on the parking, but I'm a no on the bill. I'm not, and I'm not a no, I mean, I'm not for the alcohol and wine. So I just want to put that on the record. All right. All right, with that, we have no one else in the queue. We have the motion on the table. So let's open the ballot, record your vote. One yay, five nays. By your action, you have denied 226, 657. Do we need to redo that? Okay. So, okay, so we have a, do we need to do that first or reconsider? Okay. Motion to reconsider. All right. We have a motion and a second to reconsider. Just for the audience out there, what just happened, whenever there is a vote, the bill is teed up and positioned in the affirmative. So if we vote for it or against it, we have to reconsider it, change the affirmation to a denial, vote for the denial, and then it goes forward as a denial. So that's what we're doing right now. It's more of a procedural thing. Don't freak out. So with that, we have a motion to reconsider and a second. All in favor of the reconsideration, signify by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? The reconsideration passes. So we have a motion. Do we need to take the motions on the amendments? Can we just go straight to that? All right, we have a motion and a second to deny. With that, ballot? Open the ballot. Now, green. We already did. Yeah. All right. Hold on, Mr. Carrico. Yep. So that way you all can hear. So yes, the current amendment that's before you guys right now is to amend the bill to deny, and once that is approved, then you will vote to do it. All in favor of the amendment to deny, signify by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment. Thank you, Mr. Carrico. We appreciate you. Past three-time Chair L.U.Z. Should have listened to you. That's what he was looking for, ladies and gentlemen. Motion and a second on the bill as amended. Now, open the ballot, record your vote. Voting yes is to deny. Everybody. The green button. Five yays, one nay. By your action, you have denied. Oh, low blow. By your action, you have denied 2026-657. All right. All right. Thank you, Mr. Amaro. Did you want to say anything, or are you heading out? I just want to say thank you for your work. I know this is difficult work, but I believe you've made the right decision here. I would encourage the property owner to continue to work in the community. I would like to see his business successful, and I think that opportunity is still there. Thank you. All right. Thank you for coming, Mr. Amaro. We appreciate it when the district council person shows up for their community and for his colleagues. So thank you for that. Thank you, community, for coming out again and again and again. We really appreciate it. I've been in your seat before. I know it's not fun. A lot of things are ebbing and flowing. Things are going fast. So we really appreciate it. Thank you for bearing with the process that we have. With that, we'll go to item number 11, 2026-690. Open the public hearing. No speaker cards. We'll continue this public hearing until 12-1-26. Item number 12, 2026-691. Open the public hearing. No speaker cards. We'll continue this public hearing until 12-1-26. Item number 13, 2026-745. Council members, please declare your ex parte communication at this time. Council Member Gaffney, you're recognized. Hey, thank you. Through the chair, I met with TR Hairline in my office today. I also met with Ms. Page. Johnson in my office today. I also met with Ms. Page a few weeks ago to discuss this legislation. I made sure everything gets filed with legislative services. All right. Thank you so much. We don't have any other ex parte on this one. So let's open the public hearing and get a staff report. Thank you. This is a PUD rezoning ordinance 2026-745, which is seeking to rezone approximately 1,097 acres located west of Lynn Turner Road and north of Braddock Road from a PUD that was approved in 2022, known as the Thomas Creek. They are rezoning to a new PUD. The amendment does not change the existing entitlements, which already allow 2,300 residential units and approximately 125,000 square feet of commercial uses. Instead, the request seeks to modify conditions imposed under the current PUD. The previously approved PUD includes 15 conditions, many tied to transportation methodology, fair share contract administration, roadway cross sections, and lighting standards. The amendment updates the transportation conditions to reflect the transition from a fair share contract to the city's mobility fee system while retaining development-specific transportation reviews. Staff in the transportation division have re-evaluated the prior conditions and issued a set of revised traffic requirements. These revised conditions you do have a copy of. It has striked through of what's changing and underlining what's being added to those 15 conditions. The amendment updates the transportation conditions to reflect the transition from the fair share contract to the city's mobility system while retaining, again, the site-specific transportation reviews. The fair share contract was terminated by the developer and the city to allow transportation funds previously designated for Lynn Turner Road improvements to be used for roadway improvement throughout the mobility zone. This is Zone 4. This change provides the city greater flexibility to address transportation needs and to prioritize improvements within the zone. We have reviewed the application. It meets all the requirements of the or is compatible with the underlying land use category, which is MU with a site-specific policy. It creates a master plan, mixed-use community. We find it meets internal and external compatibility. So for these reasons and those in the staff report, we are forwarding a recommendation of approval. You do have a revised Exhibit 3 and Exhibit 4 in front of you as well. And again, those revised 15 conditions. Application was heard by the Planning Commission on October 22nd, where there were no speakers in opposition. There was little discussion amongst the commissioners, and they voted unanimously for approval. They approved the conditions that are listed in your agenda, but they had the understanding that the Planning Department was going to work with the applicant to revise those conditions, which is what you have before you today. I'm here for any questions that you have. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Abney. And before we go to the speakers, we do have some ex parte from one of the council members. Council Member Arias, you're recognized. All right. Thank you, Chair. I'd like to declare ex parte on 11-12. I spoke to the applicant regarding the mobility fees, and it's currently being filed. Thank you. Thank you. And I also have ex parte to claim, as I did receive an email from Ms. Johnson in support, letting me know that there were no changes in the density or intensity to the PUD. And she also let me know that she met with the Planning Department to discuss the transportation memo, and that has already been filed with legislative services. So with that being said, we'll go to the cards. Ms. Paige Johnston, you're recognized. Thank you, Vice Chair. Paige Johnson, 1301 River Place Boulevard. On behalf of the applicant, I know it sounds like a lot when staff reads through the discussion on the conditions, but essentially what this PUD to PUD did is there was a condition in the prior original PUD in 2022 that referenced the fair share contract and a specific sector fund for the fair share contract. We moved away earlier this year from the fair share contract to a mobility fee agreement, which is pursuant to the city code. Those fair share agreements, there's a few out there still remaining, but not many. And so we're proceeding with a mobility fee agreement with the city. And as a result, that PUD condition that involved the fair share agreement needed to be modified. And so that's what we've done. In addition, when we met with Lurie Spannister and other city staff, there were other conditions that we simply updated within the transportation memo prior to just address, to make sure moving forward it was clear what version of the documents were being addressed. All more housekeeping, more or less. We also had additional conversations with Council Member Gaffney. And as a result of those conversations, we had submitted this revised written description and revised site plan yesterday. The purpose of the revised site plan is to remove the optional access that was shown on the site plan between PUD B and PUDs C and D that no longer exist. And the other item that we addressed in the written description is that there is an entrance on Braddock Road. If the traffic studies show that a signalization improvement is needed at Braddock Road, we will pay for that installation and signalization or perform the work for the signalization. And so that's been incorporated into the written description and into the site plan. Ms. Spannister refuted after we made these additions. And if you have questions, you can ask her directly. But the transportation planning did say that that addresses their concerns. And so I believe all the concerns have been addressed. And I'll just stand by for questions. All right. Thank you, Ms. Johnson. We have one more speaker card. Thomas Hatcher did not mark in support or oppose, but did mark questions only. So for the record. He is our traffic engineer in case there were questions. All right. So he's raising his hand. He's there. Are you in support? He's in support. With the thumbs up. All right. Those are our only speaker cards. We'll go ahead and close this public hearing and bring it back to committee. We have a motion and second on the amendment. If you could explain the amendment, Mr. Harvey, we'd appreciate it. So the amendment incorporates the 15 conditions as previously stated by the staff and also by the applicant. It also includes a revised exhibit three with the revised written description dated 1116 and the revised exhibit four, revised site plan dated 1116 as well. All right. 15 conditions. I'm sure everyone has combed over them and are ready to decide on that. So we do have the amendment on the floor. All in favor of the amendment signify by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed say nay. The amendment carries. We've got a motion and a second on the bill as amended with the 15 conditions. I see no one in the queue. So let's open the ballot and record your vote. Five yays. Zero nays. By your action, you've approved 2026-0745. Thank you for your time. Appreciate it. All right. Thank you. Moving on to page 11, item 14, 2026-0781. Let's open the public hearing and get a staff report. Thank you. Ordinance 2026-781 is for a small scale land use amendment for 49 Boland Street North between Berry Avenue and Alton Avenue. All of those are local roads. The applicant seeks to change approximately 0.76 of an acre from community general commercial, which is CGC, to medium density residential, MDR, in order to permit residential development. The subject parcel is located at the northeast corner of Boland Street and Alton Avenue. The area to the north of the site is designated MDR and contains single-family homes. The area to the south and east is designated CGC. To the west of the side are parcels recently designated MDR. That was in 2020, and those contain single-family homes. The proposed MDR land use will allow for residential development, which is compatible with the residential uses to the north and west, and will help to accommodate future population growth. For these reasons and those in the staff report, the planning department recommends approval. Planning commission heard this item at their meeting on November 5th and voted unanimously to approve with minimal discussion. Thank you. All right. Thank you for the report. We've got one. Speaker card, Richie Mullaney. Richie Mullaney with Driver McAfee. One independent drive suite 1200 on behalf of the applicant. Just for a little bit of additional context here, this is actually phase two of a residential project. The parcel directly to the north is under common ownership where there's already some houses about to be in development. And so this land use amendment is from CGC to MDR to facilitate the rest of that residential development. It's consistent with, of course, what's right across the street, as was mentioned, and the MDR to the north just moves that transition between MDR and CGC just down just a little bit. I'm here for any questions. Thank you. All right. Thank you for that. We have no other speaker cards. Let's close this public hearing and bring it back to committee. Got a motion second on the bill. We have no one on the queue. Please open the ballot and record your vote. Five yays, zero nays. By your action, you have approved 2026-0781. Moving on to item 15, 2026-0782. Council members, please declare any ex parte. We'll start with Council Member Adias. Thank you, sir. I'd like to declare ex parte. I spoke to the applicant, Ms. Cindy Trimmer, regarding this matter on November 11th, and it's currently being filed. Thank you. All right. Thank you for that. I also had a meeting in my office, so I will declare my ex parte with Cindy Trimmer, who went over the details of this rezoning. And that also occurred on the same date, November 11th, and that has been filed with legislative services. No other speakers in the queue. So let's open the public hearing and get a staff report. Thank you. 2026-0782 seeks to rezone approximately 0.76 acres at 49 Bolling Street North. From commercial office to residential medium density A, the request will facilitate future residential development, eliminate split zoning on commonly owned properties, and align the site with the adjoining RMDA zone parcel to the north. Staff finds the proposed rezoning consistent with the 2045 comprehensive plan. MDR supports medium density residential development and serves as an appropriate transition between commercial and residential uses. The site is located within the urban priority area and is serviced by existing water and sewer infrastructure supporting infill redevelopment of an underutilized property. The request is compatible with surrounding development, which includes single-family homes to the north and west, and commercial uses along Atlantic Boulevard corridor. Staff also notes a nearby rezoning approved under Ordinance 2025-339 that converted property from CRO to RMDA, allowing new residential development in the area. The proposed rezoning continues this transition and creates a consistent zoning pattern within the neighborhood. For these reasons and those in the staff report, we forward a recommendation of approval. The item was heard at the November 5th Planning Commission meeting where there were no speakers in opposition and little discussion amongst the commissioners, and they voted unanimously for approval. All right. Thank you for the report. We have one speaker card, Mr. Richie Mullaney. Richie Mullaney with Driver McAfee 1 Independent Drive Suite 1200 on behalf of the applicant. This, of course, is the companion rezoning for phase two of this residential project. Like I mentioned in the land use amendment, this is the same ownership as the parcel just to the north to continue residential development. As mentioned in the staff report, right across the street, there was a recent rezoning and land use amendment identical to this to facilitate some single-family homes. This really is an extension of that development pattern and is consistent and compatible with the surrounding area. This also would be consistent with the original platting of the property as well. I'll stand by for any questions, but thank you for your time. All right. Thank you. You are the only speaker card, so we'll go ahead and close the public hearing and bring it back to committee. Got a motion, second on the bill. And I was in the queue, please open the ballot and record your vote. And Council Member Gaffney is coming back. We'll go ahead and get him on the record today, this time. Five yays, zero nays. By your action, you've approved 2026-0782. Moving on, page 12, item 16, 2026-0785. Let's open the public hearing and get a staff report. Ordinance 2026-785 is for a small-scale land use amendment to change approximately 1.06 acres at 7248 Theon Street from low-density residential LDR to residential professional institutional RPI. This is to allow for a single-family home and an event venue. The subject site is currently occupied by a single-family dwelling and is surrounded by land designated as LDR. Single-family residential uses are located north, west, east, and south of the site. The parcel fronts Theon Street, which is the local road, between Old Kings Road and a railroad line. It has limited access only via Theon Street. The subject site is not located at or near a commercial node, corridor, or center. RPI is a commercial category, primarily intended to accommodate medium-to-high-density residential, office, institutional, and some neighborhood commercial uses. RPI is generally intended to provide transitional uses between commercial office and residential uses. The subject site is a residential parcel in the middle of a residential area, accessed via a local road. Entitling commercial uses at this location is not compatible with the existing single-family residential uses surrounding the site, and does not provide a transitional use between residential and commercial. For these reasons and those in the staff report, the Planning Department recommends denial. This item was heard at the November 5th Planning Commission meeting. Commissioners discussed the site's compliance with ADA requirements and also hours of operation. Ultimately, they voted to approve the item. And I'm happy to take any questions. Thank you. Well, thank you for that. We have one speaker card, Mr. Mike Herzberg. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. As staff indicated, what's being proposed here is a venue for small gatherings. No other commercial uses are to be permitted under this companion PUD. And the department and I have worked with the district councilman to try and figure out the right land use category for such uses. Maybe you've heard of these or seen these before. These what we call rustic chic barn weddings, which have now become about 20% of all wedding venues are now being held in these. Maybe you've gone to one of these in a quiet, out-of-the-way place. They're typically in a rural setting, an event that seems more serene than a banquet hall located in a major shopping center along some major roadway in town. Again, these locations provide a refined, rustic chic, all offering for picturesque views and a relaxed atmosphere. Looking at the surrounding counties as it relates to this use, St. John's County allows this use in their open rural district, which is really our RR zoning district, by right. Nassau County also allows this in their open rural district, similar to RRR, by right. And finally, Clay County permits these uses in both the agricultural and agricultural residential districts, by right. So again, it's something that most areas are seeing these as an allowable use in these more rural areas. As staff said, the parcels within the suburban area, according to the plan designated LDR and rural residential zoning, this is really, again, seeking a small, intimate setting, offering people to slow down and enjoy the moment for a family reunion, a wedding, or an anniversary. It's not a banquet hall, hotel room that's rented out every night. It seemed appropriate that the land use category for this would be AGR, or RR. Instead, the department opined that this should be in the RPI category, that that would be the least intensive category to allow this use. And I would understand that if this were something of the nature of a facility on Blanding Boulevard or something of that. The department did provide us the RPI, and therefore, we're seeking an RPI land use with a restrictive, excuse me, PUD zoning. The department's analysis and consistency evaluation hinges primarily on the fact that this is RPI and that RPI is a commercial category. The comp plan, as it relates to suburban area, which we're again in, is intended to accommodate low to medium density residential development. Secondary uses include schools, churches, daycares, community centers, uses which could have these same types of activity, even bed and breakfasts. So, therefore, what I'm contending is that most of this can already occur in these rural areas through other uses. Staff also found that we were not in or near a commercial node. The RPI has no suggestion. The RPI category has no suggestion or requirement that you be at or near a node. That's in the commercial category. The CGC category is the only one that suggests proximity to those nodes. Also, I would like to point out the staff report, page 12 of the staff report indicates that there are nothing around here but residential uses, and you can see that on the drawing there. I'd ask you to look at the handout at 10960 Old Kings Road, which is the site of Jones Maintenance Equipment. Thank you, Mr. Hersberg. With that, I will stand by for any questions and ask you to look at the handout. You were just a little too lengthy. All right, sir. Thank you. There are no other speaker cards, so we will – do you have questions now, or should we go ahead and close the public hearing? Do you have a statement, Council Member Rodriguez, or do you want to ask questions to the applicant? Okay. Go ahead. You're recognized for questions. Thank you, Chair. Mr. Hersberg, so if I understand correctly, I just want to understand what the request is from you or your client. Are you stating that you would like to go from LDR to AGR or RR versus RPI? Is that what I'm understanding? And if so, Mr. Harvey, if that's what his intention are, is what do we as a body have to do to have that conversation with everybody here? Through the Chair, we are not requesting that. It was my contention as part of the presentation that those would be appropriate land use categories given the allowable uses within them. The Department has reviewed the matter and decided that this use must be in the RPI, so we are pressing forward with just the RPI to allow the use. Sorry, sir. Thank you. All right, if that is the only question, we'll go ahead and close this public hearing and bring it back to committee. All right, we have a motion and a second on the bill. I heard a compelling argument from the applicant that definitely establishes competent and substantial evidence surrounding counties, all the different uses. We have planning commission approval, so I think that's enough for me. There's no one in opposition to this, so no neighbors have an issue with it, so I'm going to be in support, but we will go ahead and go to the queue and recognize Councilmember Adrias, followed by Councilmember Gaffney, Jr. If you don't mind, Chair, I'd like to hear from the District Councilmember. Of course, yes. Councilmember Gaffney, Jr. Thank you, Chair, for recognizing me. And to your point, just like the planning commission and everything else that you mentioned, I'm going to support this, and I'll make sure I support my reasons in the next legislation while I'm supporting this. All right, thank you for putting that on the record. Councilmember Adrias. All right, thank you, Chair. As you know, I've done a lot of caterings in my life, and I've actually gone to venues such as this, some in Callahan, some in St. Johns County, Tringali Farm, and it's exactly what this is. It's somebody that occupies a property, a residence, but they have a barn that they use for wedding venues or corporate events, whatever the case is. So, I see no issues with this. I see that there are neighbors, but clearly nobody's here in opposition. This has been around for a while now, and I truly believe that this is a good fit for this neighborhood based off of the type of use. So, I'll be supporting this. Thank you. All right, thank you. No one else in the queue? Please open the ballot and record your vote. 5 A's, 0 A's. By your action, you've approved 2026-0785. Moving on to item 17, 2026-0786. Councilmembers, please declare any ex parte communication you may have, starting with Councilmember Arias, followed by Gaffney, Jr. All right, thank you, sir. I just like to declare ex parte. I did receive an email from the applicant stating the purpose of this, and it's currently being filed as we speak. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Councilmember Gaffney, Jr. Thank you. Through the chair, I also wanted to declare ex parte. I also met with the applicant. I also met with the owner as well. We met multiple times. I made sure everything gets filed with legislative services. Thank you. All right, thank you. We have no one else in the queue. Let's open the public hearing and get a staff report. Thank you. This is PUD rezoning, Ordinance 2026-786, seeking to rezone approximately 1.06 acres for a property on Thine Street, which is going from RR Acre to a PUD. The applicant proposes to retain the existing single-family residence while adding a commercial wedding and event venue on the property. The proposed venue would allow up to 120 attendees, with a maximum of four events per month operating until midnight on weekends and 10 p.m. on weeknights. Staff reviewed the request and finds that the proposal is inconsistent with the comprehensive plan. Approval would represent an expansion of commercial activity into a location where surrounding uses are entirely residential. Staff finds that the proposal fails to achieve adequate external compatibility. Wedding and event activities would introduce increased traffic, parking demands, noise, lighting, and event-related activity immediately adjacent to neighboring homes. While there are other wedding venues within the immediate area, such as Congrean Penn, which operates on roughly 202 acres, this site is only one acre and provides little separation between the event activities and neighboring residences. We have concerns related to parking and circulation on site. While the applicant proposes all parking to be accommodated on site, there's no formal parking layout. Vehicles would park on existing grassy areas throughout the property, including beneath the oak treats that line the driveway. Staff in the city landscape architect determined that the plan does not adequately address required parking and ADA accessibility. Overflow parking is expected to spill onto nearby residential streets, which are not accommodated or designed to accommodate this type of event traffic. The application also seeks exemptions from Part 12 landscaping requirements, which would include buffer requirements typically required between commercial and residential uses. So, for these reasons and those contained in the staff report, the planning department is forwarding a recommendation of denial. The application was heard by planning commission. There were no speakers in opposition and little discussion. The commissioners found that given the rural character of the area and the presence of similar wedding venues on comparable size lots within the city, the request would not adversely impact the surrounding area and would be compatible with the rural character. So, they voted unanimously for approval. Thank you. All right. Thank you very much. We do have one speaker card. We'll go ahead and have Mr. Herzberg speak, and then we have a few council members lined up for questions. Mr. Chairman, I will be brief. Thank you. As to the issue of commercial use and proximity, again, we have just 350 feet away Jones Maintenance Equipment offering a full line of new and used mowers and lawn equipment, as well as services and repairs on equipment, as well. So, I will say commercial is already in the area. Arguably, the intended use is ancillary to the principal use of the property. As single family. This is not a full-time operation. We're, again, four times a month at the maximum. I believe that the previous handout provided substantial competent evidence and analysis of the goals, objectives, and policies that show that it would be compliant with the comprehensive plan. As to the issues of internal compatibility and external compatibility, again, I think calling this a commercial use at this scale is somewhat difficult. I do understand the issue, and I think the department has raised those issues well. However, considering that a rural church could be in this area, and they are in the area, and they don't have the parking. They use grass parking. I would ask you to simply consider those criteria and humbly request your support of the result. Thank you. All right. Thank you, Mr. Herzberg. We have several members in the queue. Let's start with the district councilman first. We'll go ahead and skip up to Council Member Gaffney, Jr. You're recognized. Thank you, Tudor Chair. I'm going to go ahead and, I guess, put my calls and my case on the record. You know, I'm going to support this. I'm very familiar with this area. It's not too far from congregating and paying. There's several churches in this area as well who use the churches for event halls. I appreciate Helena Aaron and the planning department, Casey, and the rest of you guys for doing your due diligence and, you know, recommending them. But after spending a lot of time in this area getting to know the owner, you know, the applicant, you know, just understanding this project. We talked about the uses, restrictions. I also, as a councilperson, did my due diligence and knocked on doors as well and spoke with neighbors, you know. So I feel very comfortable about this. They're going to be ending at a certain time, not past 10 o'clock. We talked about the music. We talked about, you know, the wetlands. We also talked about the events can't end past 120. And to Mr. Herzberg's point, you know, congregating and paying us within, like, walking distances. It's also Jones maintenance supplies not too far as well. So I'm supporting those for all those reasons. Like I said, I definitely appreciate the planning department for, you know, at least their recommendations. But I feel like we have the right uses and the right restrictions within this putt, you know. So I do have one question for the planning department because my choice is more so for this owner, not so much, you know, in the business. But if he was to sell his property, what would happen? I just, that's my only question. Through the chair to Councilman Gaffney. So if this PUD is approved and he sells it, then the uses do run with the land. So any business owner could run the wedding and event space there under the limitations that are within the rent and description. Within the same, within the same limitations and the same restrictions. Okay. That's, that's, that's the only thing. But yeah, so I support this tonight for all the reasons I just mentioned. All right. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Councilmember Gaffney, Jr. Next we'll go to Dr. Johnson. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Acting Chair, through the chair to the, to Mr. Hertzberg. My question was more about, I heard you, and by the way, what a great voice. I mean, you should do that more. That's good. I like that. Brought some very commercial usage. Very good. Very good. What is the, are you guys going to be working? The two questions I had, one is about the time, right? With ending at 10 o'clock, while I certainly understand and respect it, I know the area, I've driven out there, I've been to Conquer and Penn many, many times. I know this area intimately. What is the, I mean, I'm just imagining a person having a wedding that they have to shut it down at 10 o'clock? Through the chair, sir, those would be weekday. The weekends would allow a midnight operation, and obviously. Because, like, there's nothing there. Correct. But the principal use is these folks home. They want to go to bed. They want to be able to have these activities. It's time for you folks to go. Thank you for being here. You've enjoyed the evening. The sun has set. Stick it in the city in the room. Right, right, right. Sir, the next question is about Conquer and Penn. Are they, obviously, it's so close. As Councilman Gaffney alluded, it is in walking distance. And I know they have those new cottages or whatever out there. It's really, really nice at Conquer and Penn. Are they working with Conquer and Penn? I'd love to see businesses working together. Are they doing these kinds of things together? Through the chair, no, sir. I think the scale of this is really a much smaller venue, so there is no association with Conquer and Penn, sir. Just curious. Okay. Thank you for answering. Thank you for hearing my questions. All right, Dr. Johnson. Next, we have Councilmember Arias from District 11. Thank you, sir. As you saw the commotion I had here, essentially, my biggest issue that I have here, Mr. Herzberg, through the chair, is going to be the parking component. And I see here that you put on number eight, you talked about the compact parking, which is great. So you have that into account. Where is the parking going to be? Through the chair, sir. The site plan is convoluted with everything on there. But the parking would be in between those oak trees. So if you look closely, and I know it's tough, and I apologize, you have to get a lot on one plan of that size. There are three spaces that are designated between each of those oak trees. So the vehicles could park in that area. I think it accommodated at least 50 parking spaces or right around 50 parking spaces, which should be more than... Thank you, sir. Thank you. The oak trees that you're talking about, are the oak trees inside the property? Yes, sir. The oak trees run the length of the driveway. Thank you. Because I heard from the planning department, if I misunderstood, was parking on the street on the outside. And excuse me, go ahead. You don't mind, Mr. Chair. Through the chair to Councilman Ario. So we were concerned about overflow parking going out into the street. But they do have designated spots in the grassy area between the trees. Okay. Thank you. Because I was looking at the Google Maps and I do see a spot there. So I wanted to make sure that you are going to be using that spot. I want to make sure that we protect the neighbors. And it is a one-way road anyway. So we don't want to convolute that whole area there. But with that being said, I feel better about this as it is. So I will be supporting this. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Next, we have Councilman McGaffey. You're recognized. Yeah. Thank you to the chair. I just want to add on, in terms of the overflow parking, we talked about that, me and the owner. It's a nearby business. So in the business have talked to the owner. And they are willing to allow overflow parking to park at this business. It's within walking distance. So they'll be using golf carts. So they can park at this Jones maintenance supply. It's within, I think, like 60 to 70 feet. And so they'll be taking a golf cart to the wedding venue, if it's over 50 cars. You know, so keep in mind, you know, there's a venue on the whole, like, 100 people anyway. So, I mean, yeah, it might not even get to that unless it's just, you know, Kevin Carrico getting married or something like that. But, yeah. But, yeah. But, no, in terms of overflow parking, so we have discussed it with the, we have discussed it with the Jones maintenance. So they can overflow park over there. All right. Thank you. All right. Councilmember Carrico, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And, yes, I did have a very large event when I became president, about 735 people. But I had a very intimate wedding with just my wife and our children and a few witnesses. So no need for that. I wasn't going to be on the queue until you put my name on the record. So I support this because of the competent, substantial evidence that you put down on the record, Councilman Gabbany Jr. You clearly articulated your case. And you, as the expert, being the district councilman, as well as the support of the planning commission, gives me enough competent, substantial evidence to vote in support of this bill. So it might not be right for my wedding, but a lot of weddings will be there and make great memories in your district. So I will support. Thank you. All right. Councilmember White, you're recognized. Yes, or not a question, but a statement, if you'll allow me, Mr. Chair. Mr. Jones, you can just raise your hand. You're Jim's brother, right? You're a little better looking, but Jim, but that's a fine family out there on that side of town. And I think I've met you before, but we're glad to push it through for you. Thank you. All right. We have no one else in the queue. So did we get a motion? Do we have a motion in a second on this? All right. Let's open the ballot. Record your vote. Six yays. Zero nays. By your action, you've approved 2026-786. Item number 18. Thank you, all. What's up? Oh, yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Herzberg. Item number 18, 2026-787. Let's open the public hearing. Oh, yeah, Mr. Carricko, you're recognized. Sorry about that, Mr. Chair, and I'll ask Mr. Harvey if it's appropriate. I was sitting in the chairman's seat, so I didn't have my notes in front of me. I do have ex parte on the last bill, as I did receive an email from Mr. Herzberg saying that he was representing the owner and asked if I had any questions. So I did receive that email. I didn't put that on the record. Is it substantial for me to put that on the record now? All right. So my ex parte on 2026-0786 has already been filed, and it is now on the record. Thank you, Mr. Harvey and Mr. Chair. All right. Thank you so much. Next, we were on 2026-787. Let's open the public hearing and get a staff report. Ordinance 2026-787 is for a small-scale land use amendment to change 3.78 acres at 11160 New Kings Road, 6909 and 6939 Dunn Avenue, and a portion of 10980 Brad Avenue from residential, professional, institutional, which is RPI, and LDR, low density residential, to recreation open space, ROS. The subject parcels are on the northwestern quadrant of the intersection of New Kings Road and Dunn Avenue. The parcels are not contiguous. Specifically, two parcels abut an RV park to the north and two abutted to the south. The existing RV park, which is located in between those four parcels, is already designated as ROS from an amendment in 2020. The applicant has stated that their intent is to expand the RV park. Trout River abuts the subject site to the north. Dinsmore Boat Ramp is located across New Kings Road from the subject site and clearly abuts the Trout River. However, the proposed ROS designation would support recreational access to the river and the boat ramp. For these reasons and those in the staff report, the Planning Department recommends approval. This item was heard at the November 5th Planning Commission meeting. The commission voted unanimously to approve the item with no discussion. Thank you. All right. Thank you. We have one speaker card. Cindy Trimmer. Thank you so much. Good evening. Cindy Trimmer, 1 Independent Drive, Suite 1200, on behalf of the applicant. As Susan mentioned, if you look at the map in front of you, there is a large parcel in the center of what's being proposed to be changed. That parcel has been a mobile home RV park dating back to the 70s. When my client purchased it, it had 40-odd outstanding code violations, hadn't been maintained. He has since brought that property into full compliance, has been operating on a wait list, and has been working to acquire these kind of dilapidated and underutilized parcels that surround it. His intention for those is to expand the RV park to include additional pads and additional amenities, including a park space. With that, I will stand by for questions. All right. Thank you. We don't have any other speaker cards and no one in the queue, so let's close the public hearing and bring it back to the committee. All right. We have a motion and a second on the bill. No one in the queue. Let's open the ballot. Record your vote. 6-8, 0-8. By your action, you've approved for 2026-787. Item number 19, 2026-788. Council Members, please declare your ex parte communication at this time. Council Member Gaffney, you're recognized. Thank you. Through the Chair, I want to rise to declare ex parte. I spoke with Ms. Tremmer last week. I have to get the date. I'm not sure, but she asked me did I have any questions. She explained this legislation. We just talked about the buffers, the current land use, and I make sure everything gets fine with legislative services. Thank you. Council Member Arias, you're recognized. Thank you, Chair. Also, declare ex parte. I spoke to the applicant on November 16th regarding the project briefing and reports from the staff, and it's currently being filed. Thank you. All right. Oh, Council Member Gaffney, you're recognized. Sorry about that, Mr. Chair. Yes, I do need to claim to the next parte as I had a meeting with Cindy Trevor in my office one week ago today, which I believe was the 10th or 11th. Either way, it will be filed with legislative services, and she just came to brief me on the proposed legislation and see if I had any questions, and that's all. So we'll get it filed. Thank you. And I have ex parte to declare. I had a team's call with Cindy Tremmer on November 16th at 1030, and we will have this paperwork filed with legislative services. All right. With that, we have no other exports today, so let's open the public hearing and get a staff report. Thank you. Thank you, 2026-788, seeks to rezone approximately 3.78 acres located along New Kings Road. From residential low-density 60 to recreation and open space, the property consists of four parcels located west of New Kings Road between Dunn Avenue and Trout River. The property directly abuts an existing RV park located at 11134 New Kings Road, which was rezoned from RLD 60 to ROS under Ordinance 2020-0091. The current application is intended to expand that existing RV park use. Staff finds a rezoning consistent with the 2045 comprehensive plan. The ROS land use category is intended primarily for recreational and open space activities and specifically identifies travel trailer parks as a secondary use. This is located within the North Jacksonville Shared Vision and Master Plan, which recommends maintaining parks and recreational open space opportunities in the North Jacksonville area. Staff finds a request consistent with those recommendations. The surrounding area contains a mix of residential, recreational, and commercial uses. Properties to the south include an existing RV park, single-family homes, and commercial uses, while commercial retail uses occur along New Kings Road. Staff finds proposed ROS zoning to be compatible with the surrounding development pattern, particularly given its direct connection to the existing RV park operation. The site has access to major transportation facilities, including New Kings Road, which is an F-DOT principal arterial roadway, and Dunn Avenue, which is a collector roadway, and is located less than two miles from I-295. For these reasons and those outlined in the staff report, we forward a recommendation of approval. The item was heard at the November 5th Planning Commission meeting, where there were no speakers in opposition, and they voted unanimously for approval. All right, thank you. We have one speaker card, Cindy Trimmer. Cindy Trimmer, 1 Independent Drive, Suite 1200, on behalf of the applicant. We'll stand by the staff report, and they're available for questions. All right, thank you. We have no other speaker cards and no one in the queue. Let's close the public hearing and bring it back to committee. All right, we have a motion. Do we get a second? Did someone say a second? All right, we have a motion and a second on the bill. Councilman Gaffney, you're recognized. Thank you, through the chat. This will be brief. I wrote about the property that's in question this past Sunday. It's already an RV park, and like I said, they just suspended it, so it's no issues, and I made sure, you know, it had buffers and trees and things. And it's pretty much in the rural areas. It's off like Dunn's and U.S. 1, which is going back towards like Nassau County. So I just want to put that in the record. All right. Councilman Johnson, you're recognized. I just want to say, since it's applicable in this space, that while I am going to support this, I do think it makes sense, and I did look at this earlier, this is one of the other pieces I see. It's almost like I think I heard the term Frankenstein earlier tonight on another issue. The code is still broken. I'm going to say it again, and this is one of the issues that could be fixed if we just put some elbow grease together and fix the code and get it right once and for all for all of us, including our land use team as well as us that sit on the stairs. Thank you. All right. We have no one else in the queue. Let's open the ballot and record your vote. Okay. Yeah, no problem. It's too bad this didn't happen on the batting cages. It would have been real suspenseful. Everyone's smiling. Everyone's laughing. Everyone's laughing. Six yays. Zero nays. By reaction, you have approved 2026-7. Was that 789 or 788? Okay, 788. Sorry. Now action item 20, 2026-789. Council members, please declare your ex parte communication at this time. Council member Arias, you're recognized. Thank you, Chair. Currently filing ex parte for November 16th full call with Ms. Cindy Trimmer regarding this and is currently being filed as we speak. Thank you. Council member Carricka, you're recognized. Thank you. We're signing the same meeting last week as before Ms. Trimmer came and basically just presented all of her applications that were on file for this meeting. So we reviewed them and didn't have any specific questions. But there was a conversation that will be logged and entered into the record and filed with legislative services. So thank you for recognizing me. Council member White, you're recognized. I'll declare ex parte. Ms. Trimmer come to my office and everything will be filed. Right. And I feel like I have ex parte, but I can't find the form, so we will get it filed before Council. So with that, we have no other ex parte in the public hearing. You can get a staff report. Thank you. This is PUD rezoning ordinance 2026-789 seeking to rezone approximately 7.12 acres for a property that's located just off of Fort Caroline Road from RLD 90 to a PUD. They are seeking the PUD to allow for the development of a 21 single-family lot subdivision utilizing standards generally consistent with the RLD's 60 zoning district. The property is currently an undeveloped portion of land on the rear part of the Fort Caroline Christian Church. The church parcel is not included in the proposed development, and the PUD will limit it to 21 single-family homes and adopt a specific conceptual site plan and then the regulations within that written description. Staff finds the request consistent with the low-density residential land use category and the comp plan. The proposed density remains below the maximum density allowed under this category, and development continues the existing residential character of the area. Staff finds the proposal achieves internal compatibility through perimeter landscaping, residential scale, and certain development standards. The PUD will utilize a stormwater facility and open space as buffering elements. They'll also include a 10-foot landscape buffer provided around the perimeter. We've also determined that it meets external compatibility. Properties north, east, and west of the site are developed with single-family neighborhoods that are zoned RLD 90, while properties to the south of the site are developed under an older residential PUD with smaller residential lots. We find that the proposed subdivision serves as an appropriate transition between the larger lots in the neighboring subdivisions and the smaller residential lots to the south. So for these reasons and those in the staff report, we forward a recommendation of approval. This was heard at Planning Commission, where there were two speakers in opposition. Both property owners, these are property owners to the north with access along Allenby Drive. Their concerns primarily related to access along their driveway during the construction and potential roadway improvements. The applicant explained that access through the existing church property would be established during a civil plan review. The Planning Commission expressed no concerns regarding the proposal, and they voted unanimously for approval. All right. We have a few speaker cards. First up, Cindy Trimmer. Good evening. Cindy Trimmer, 1 Independent Drive, Suite 1200, on behalf of the applicant. I've passed out for you the site plan that was before this body a few years ago that was not successful, that proposed to do about 69 townhomes on this site. After that was not successful, we negotiated a settlement with the surrounding neighborhood and have settled on doing 21 60-foot lots. So the original proposal was about 9.5 units an acre. We're now under 3 units an acre. A couple of the things that did come up, and we've gotten questions, so I'd like the opportunity to state on the record just so it's clear. Allenby Road is a public road back through further north than this site. The applicant would have to bring that road up to current standards. When that road's taken offline to do the paving and make the improvements, they will have to construct a temporary road that would run through this site down through the church to connect to Fort Caroline. So at all times, everybody on Allenby Road will have access to Fort Caroline Road. They will not be cut off. Currently, the folks on Allenby Road have to drag their garbage cans the whole way down to Fort Caroline and had asked if there would be an opportunity to have a different designated garbage drop-off point if the road is improved and garbage trucks are able to come further down Allenby Road after this is developed. We had spoken with development services, and that's something that they and the waste management hauler would be open to during permitting. There's a way to designate a different, designated drop-off space. It would just have to be shown during that 10-set review that there is full access for the vehicles to get further down Allenby Road. Likewise, with mail, they have to currently come the whole way up to Fort Caroline for the mail drop-off. There could potentially be an opportunity for that to be moved back further, but some of the neighbors' stated concerns were the fact that they do have to walk up and down the whole way on Allenby, and this would be adding additional traffic to Allenby, and there would be a preference to have those drop-off spots move further back. Aaron mentioned, in addition to normal compatibility, we have agreed to have the retention along the Colony Cove border, and we have agreed also to have a buffer around this subdivision. Normally, you don't have to have landscape buffers between single-family, but that was something that the community requested and the applicant was happy to do. I will stand by for questions after hearing anybody else that has comments. All right. Next, we have Ed Radloff. Ed Radloff, address on file. Two years ago, we were down here fighting the 70 townhomes, and we were successful as a community to get that defeated. It was at that time that the applicant appealed, and then they approached us about reaching some sort of compromise, and we sat down as a community, and we agreed to the RLD 60. So, we are in support of this measure. I think this is a very good example of when a community and a developer come together and come to a resolution. I mean, we are an RLD 90 community, but changes are happening, and the compromise was to go to RLD 60. So, I, too, had a conversation with Cindy today I'd like to report, but Cindy has been – we've had open dialogue, and so we are in support of this measure. Thank you. All right. Thank you, sir. Next, two speakers do not wish to speak. Christy Stowers is in opposition, and Nicole Denon-Avey. Okay. Got it. Are they – are you in support back there, or just wrong bill? Okay. Okay. Cool. We will do whatever we got to do with these. I'll mark them. But, okay. And with that, we have no other speakers in the queue, so let's close the public hearing and bring back to the committee. We have a motion and a second on the bill. No one in the queue. Let's open the ballot and record your vote. Five yays, zero nays. By your action, you've approved 2026-789. All right. That brings us to our last action item of the evening, I believe, which is item 2026-807. Let's open the public hearing and get a staff report. Thank you. So, this is legislation ordinance 2026-807, which seeks to update the zoning code to formally incorporate urban agriculture into the zoning code by establishing definitions, permitted uses, and operating standards for community and market gardens throughout the city. The primary purpose of this legislation is to provide a clear regulation for small-scale urban agricultural activities, which are not currently well-defined in the zoning code. So, what does this ordinance do? It adds definitions for community gardens, market gardens, and urban agriculture. It permits community gardens and market gardens by right in a range of residential and commercial zoning districts. It also establishes performance standards to address structures, size and height, signage limitations, composting and waste management, heavy equipment restrictions, noise, odor, and nuisance controls, food safety regulations, and environmental compliance standards. Community gardens are intended primarily for cultivation and community use and do not allow on-site sales. Market gardens allow the on-site sales of product grown on the property subject to operational limitations, which would include a maximum of 12 public sales days per calendar year. The 12 days was established similar to code regulations on garage sales, which would occur on residential lots. The market day limitation does not apply to the zoning districts of CCG1, CCG2, and CN. As those are truly commercial districts, the limitations are just for the residential districts. While expanding permissions, the ordinance includes regulations to mitigate potential impacts related to noise, traffic, waste, odors, and commercial intensities. These safeguards ensure that gardens remain compatible with their surroundings. The amendment also supports resilience, sustainability, and public health initiatives by promoting local food sources that align with the city of Jacksonville's food plans. So, for these reasons and those in the staff report, we are forwarding a recommendation of approval. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Council Member Arias, did you want to speak first before the public hearing, or did you want to let the speakers come up? Okay. Okay. I didn't know you popped up. Yeah. He wanted to steal all y'all's thunder. All right. So, come on down if you're here for this and you know you're speaking. This is the last bill. So, we have Sonia, Hanlon, Michelle, Wilson, Nathan, Valentin, and Lorene, husband, John Nooney, and Eugene Ford. Come on down, everybody. So, first we have Sonia Hanlon. My name is Sonia Hanlon. My address is 7264 Wedgwood Drive, and I am the owner of B-Well Greens Company, a local microgreens farm here in Jacksonville, and a former market gardener. And I'm here to support the ordinance 2026-0807 and urge for you all to support it as well. One of the privileges of what I do is getting to connect with the community regularly. And what I notice when I connect with these people is that there's so many that have a disconnect with where their food comes from. They don't know who grows it. They don't know how it's produced. They don't know how it's transported. And I believe that market gardens and community gardens are the way to bridge the disconnect to people and their food. They're about so much more than just growing vegetables. They're about places that people can learn, share, gather, build relationships with each other, and become more involved in their local food systems. But growing the food is just a part of the equation. Local growers also need consistent opportunities to get the food into the hands of our community. The improved increase in market days will create more opportunities for year-round connections between growers and residents. And allowing the cross-sales between businesses gives small producers opportunities to support one another, reach more customers, and strengthen our local food economy. And these benefits go much beyond just businesses. Access to fresh, locally grown food, combined with education and opportunities to be active, will help encourage healthier lifestyles. Preventative health doesn't just start in doctors' offices. It can start in our backyards. Sometimes it starts with just conversations, with access to nutrient-dense food and meaningful connections with others. These spaces will bring people outside, strengthen relationships, and create a greater sense of community. As a small farmer, I've seen how powerful it can be when someone connects with their food for the first time. Something as simple as that conversation, or just trying a new vegetable, or a child recognizing that food comes from more than just a grocery store, is a very powerful experience. I believe we have an opportunity to build a healthier, more educated, and more connected community, while creating meaningful opportunities for our local growers and small businesses. I ask that you support Pathway to Urban Ag and to make neighborhood-friendly community and market gardens permissible by right. Because ultimately, we're not just growing food, we're growing healthier people, a stronger small business community, stronger neighborhoods, and ultimately, a stronger Jacksonville. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Next, we have Michelle Wilson. Good evening. My name is Michelle Wilson. My address is on file. To save a little time, I'm going to pass my comments over to my friends. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Next, we have Nathan Ballantyne. Ballantyne. Good evening. My name is Nathan Ballantyne. Overalls Farm grows at 125 East 7th Street. As you already know, we are here today to encourage Amendment 2 and then passage of 2026-0807 to update Jacksonville's zoning code, making neighborhood-friendly market and community gardens permissible by right. As City Council has heard ad nauseum, evidenced by the more than 100 unique speakers who have addressed this body since April on the topic, there is overwhelming support for this policy. In the words of Councilman Arias, let's give the people what they want. Thank you. All right. Next, we have Dr. Laureen Husband. Good evening. I will reserve my comments for a later date since it's getting late. Thank you. All right. Thank you. We won't fight you on that. Next, we have John Nooney. Hello. I am John J. Nooney, Jacksonville City Council Resolution, 2023-0819. I'm in City Council District 4, Kevin Carrico, CPAC Planning District 3, Raymond Day True Commission. Duval County Public Schools, 2025-0867. Mr. Nooney, please speak to the bill. This is Cindy Pearson. Yeah, I am. Okay. Amendment 3 passed. It's statewide. It's real. 2026-08-07 is the entire city 4-H. Now, the rules amendment, you know, I'm right here from, you know, I'm just reading it right here. Mr. Nooney. Mr. Nooney. Yes. We don't need you to read the amendment. You can speak to the bill, or we're going to close the public hearing. Speak to the bill. I am speaking to the bill. No, you're not. You're reading it. Do not make me call you out of order, sir. Speak to the bill or sit down. Well, under rule amendment one. You're either out of order or you're speaking to the bill. I am speaking to the bill. Go ahead. Add counties. You know, this is statewide, worldwide. This is to the bill. I support it. Okay. And, no, you know, I'm going to these other counties. Here's Clay County. You know, 4-H. You know, I had a citrus orchard. I had 50 trees. Tomorrow is the tree commission meeting. We've got $29 million in cash. You know what they say to me at the tree commission? Nooney. We don't save trees. We plant trees. So, whoever has control of the property will immediately have the ability for a citrus orchard. So, you know, and as far as the people behind, I've been invited to their gardens. I mean, do they have a citrus tree? You know, Myers-Lenons, you know, the grapefruits, you know, the... Mr. Nooney, you can't just say fruit names and trees. You've got to speak to the bill. Well, the bill, okay, well, the bill, okay, is there any J-sub language in this? You know, that's, you know, again, you know, I would hope that that would be a consideration. And I support, you know, the market garden, you know, if it's a piece of vacant land, you know, that now you can have 52 days, you know, to sell. I mean, that's great. That's like every weekend, you know, this is going to be... This is a potential revenue source, you know, not only for Duval County, but for the entire state or anyone else who wants to, you know, participate in this. All right. Thank you for listening. Next, we have Eugene Ford. Yes, that's a tough act to follow. Eugene Trey Ford III, representing Duval Swano Water Conservation District. And from what I'm hearing, it's already going to be unanimous. I think we wore you guys down, and I think we wore ourselves out as well, because to get this many unanimous means we didn't ask for enough, in my perspective. So I do have to... I want to echo a little bit what Mr. Nooney said about J-sub and about being able to invest more into urban agriculture, take it beyond permissibility and into fostering and investing in it. And I think that what some of his comments were, make a lot of sense, because we have a unique opportunity in Jacksonville, Florida, based on how large we are, based on the number of parks, number of land, or the amount of land. And so thank you guys for that unanimous decision. Hopefully to see you at the Farm City Luncheon on Thursday. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Next, Jennifer Leggett is in support, and Jack does not wish to speak. So with that, we will close the public hearing and bring it back to committee. All right. We have a motion and a second on the amendment. Mr. Arias, do you want to explain the amendment, or Mr. Harvey, do you want to explain it? I'll explain it very quick, sir. Essentially, going from 12 days to 52 days, I agree with Eugene, not enough. I would have liked to have 70 or 100 days, but I think this is a good start right now. And then the second part is having a 50% so that they could also sell from other businesses. So for example, let's say you own a honey-producing farm, whatever the case is, and you can't make it to that market that day, I could sell for you. And then there's more amendments, and that's when you take over, Mr. Harvey. Yes. So the rules amendment also includes the revision of definition of community gardens to include the land managed and maintained by an entity, and also to revise the definition of market garden to mirror the language of 656-401. There's also some scrivener's errors that were notated by the council auditor's office that will also be incorporated in. All right. All in favor of that amendment, signify by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment carries. All right. We have a motion and a second on the bill as amended. Were you on the amendment? It doesn't matter. Go ahead. I'll be on the bill. I supported the amendment. A couple things. Thanks for keeping Mr. Nooney in check. He was speaking of JSEB. I think he was referring to JSEFs, Jacksonville Small and Emerging Farms. But that program doesn't exist. So sorry, Mr. Nooney, for trying. But you did try. A serious question, though. Trey, would you come up? Soil and water conservationist. Question for you. Since we are in committee, this is where the sausage is made. If you don't think that we did enough on this bill, this is the last stop before we send it to full council. Is there a particular amendment or a particular idea that you have that will strengthen this bill because your crew, the man and the overalls included, have been here relentlessly for months? This is a big, major community issue. I don't want to pack it up and send it to full council if it hasn't got its full due diligence here in committee. This is the last bill of the night, 744. We're normally here until 9 o'clock. Do you have any concrete recommendations for a change to this bill that would make it stronger? I'd be willing to at least listen. You know, to the bill directly, I love your idea of JSEF, maybe establishing one, so that the funding necessary to get started and that there's just more partnership between the city, I would say, private nonprofits and those farmers. So what that might look like or just an example of what I've seen being done by nonprofit organizations is in grand part, Just Food Network just delivered 75 garden beds to the area. That's not to say each one of these homeowners is going to start a farming business necessarily. Some of them are just going to use that for their own food. But seeing some type of investment, after seeing $28 million go to Publix, you know, if we can get $2.8 million to farmers, market managers, farmers, things like that. So I don't know if it would really apply to the ordinance and the bill itself, but to those of you who are planning to be here in March and May, maybe something to look at. Yeah, and I appreciate you speaking on behalf of those who are here advocating for this type of legislation. It's going to be hard to earmark dollars to the bill. So I don't think that's going to be something that we would take up tonight. But I think Councilman Arias was looking to speak to that. Yes? So I'll yield my time to Councilman Arias. If he has anything he'd like to strengthen, as he is one of the co-sponsors, I'll defer to him. All right. Councilman Arias, you're recognized. Thank you, Chair. Co-introducer, not co-sponsor. All right. But nevertheless, I agree with Mr. Carrico. What I stated earlier was the fact that, you know, when we propose new legislation, we want to see how the community works. Obviously, we're going to make sure that we hold you guys accountable. You guys have no issues with that part. But I do want to say that let's explore this again in 6 to 12 months to see how this has evolved. And then from there, we can actually add more to this. Maybe the 52 days won't be enough. And if we see that you guys have been good neighbors or have been no issues with code compliance or whatever the case is, then I don't see a world where we can extend this. So I think this is a good start to the conversation. And if anything, it's actually a way to progress our city moving forward. I do want to commend Jennifer, Nathan, Angela, Roxy, Dr. Lorraine, yourself, Bill, Sonia, Michelle, and so many individuals who have came here. You guys have been here since April, like you said. That means about 16 city council meetings. You've had public notice meetings with myself and other members like Mr. Peluso. I've done site visits with you all. You guys have came to committees. You guys have worked your you-know-what off. All right. So I commend you guys. This is exactly why you guys have full support from council. Not one person has voted to oppose this because of the work that you guys have done. So I really want to say that it's you guys that take all the credit. You guys make me look good. You make us look good with our city. So just continue to do the great work. We have full support on you guys and we have full faith. And I just hope that in, like you said, next election cycle, maybe in July, start having the conversation again as to where you guys stand. And then maybe at some point in the fall of next year, we could explore other options as well, too. Thank you. And if I can plant a quick seed, maybe this is an opportunity for city council to work more closely with Duval Sona Water, which was defunded. And maybe this would alleviate some of the pressures that came in at city council meetings. So just as an additional governing body and special district government. Thank you. Okay. All right. We have no other speakers in the queue. And we have a motion and a second already. All right. Open the ballot. Record your vote. Five yays. Zero nays. By your action, you've approved. Proof 2026, 807. All right. Ladies and gentlemen, the following bills are deferred with a public hearing next cycle on 12-126. Bill number 2026, 833, 834, 835, 836, 837, 838, 839, 840, 841. What? Oh, that Joe? Oh. Please, Joe Lister, please come down to the front. Joe Lister, please come down to the front. 842, 843, 844, 887, 888, 880. No, wait, wait, wait, wait. Back up, back up, back up. The following bills are on second reading. 2026, 887, 888, 889, 890, 891, 892, 893, 894, 895, 896, 897, 914, and 89, and 915, and 918. What? You good? Okay. Councilman Johnson. Yes, sir. Quick announcement, Mr. Chair. Thank you so much, Mr. Lister, and whoever else wants to know, especially those that are interested in affordable housing, on tomorrow at 11 a.m. in the Henry Cook Room of this building, there will be a meeting about Yes in God's Backyard, which is a new affordable housing proposal that allows religious institutions to unlock a lot of their property so that they can use it and create those opportunities. So I hope you'll join me tomorrow, 11 a.m., Henry Cook Room. Thank you for that, Mr. Chair. All right. Thank you so much. With that, this meeting is adjourned.