Civic › Jacksonville, FL › November 19, 2026

Jacksonville Waterways Commission - Nov 19, 2026

Jacksonville, FL City Council November 19, 2026 132 minutes
▶ Watch original video Interactive viewer Search Jacksonville meetings

Transcript

Speaker0:00

Good morning, everyone. We'll go ahead and get started, and I'll call the Jacksonville Waterways November 19th meeting to order, and we'll start with introductions to my left with Mr. Hardesty. Mark Hardesty, Waterways Commission. James Hobson, Waterways Commission. Robert Bertellin, Waterways Commission. Matt Jones, Waterways Commission. Andrew Frayden, Waterways Commission. Mike Gay, District 2 Vice Chair, and I'm filling in for Chair Dr. Johnson, who is unable to be here today. Thank you. Jimmy Peluso, District 7. Scott Thomas, Waterways. Mark Devereaux, Waterways. Jerry Pinto, Jacksonville University. Jim Superwaterways, Coordinator. All right, and we got Councilman Carlucci has joined us as well. We'll give him a second to come around. Yeah, that. Good morning, Matt Carlucci at Large Group 4 substituting for Dr. Bishop Rockman-Johnson. All right. Thank you all. If you would join me, please stand and let's pledge allegiance. I pledge allegiance. All right. Thank you, everyone. I'm going to use a handheld microphone so they can get the regular microphone working here. All right. Thank you for that. So going through our agenda. Next item, the approval of last meeting's minutes. Can I get a motion and a second on that? I've got a motion and a second. All in favor, it would be a voice vote. Say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Likewise, none. Motion carries. So we have approved minutes. Next, we'll go to public comment. Do we have any speaker cards? All right. Thank you. All right. First speaker, Ellen. Yeah, Ellen, I see. Come on up and you'll be given two minutes to speak to an item on our agenda. Thank you. The microphone on. It says green. Is it working? There we go. There we go. There we go. Name and address for the record, please. Appreciate it. Allen Iosu, 4389 Heathford Court, Jacksonville, Florida. Appreciate it. I felt compelled to come up here and speak real quick. I'm an avid boater and a frequenter to Fort George. And I see that there was some discussion of initiating a speed limit in that area. I highly recommend that. I have small kids. It's very dangerous up there. And, you know, definitely when you enter the inlet and you get to the Fort area, you know, there's lots of places to anchor out and people are just flying through there. It's very, very dangerous. And I think we should be looking at this for safety and welfare of all people in Jacksonville. And, you know, even people that don't have boats, but just to keep things safe up there. I highly support that. So I appreciate your time. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Our next speaker will be John J. Nooney. Come on down, sir. And you'll be given two minutes to speak to an item on our agenda. Hello. I am John J. Nooney, 8356, Baskin Road, Jacksonville, Florida, 3216, City Council District 4, Kevin Carrico, CPAC Planning District 3, Raymond Day, True Commission, and Duval County Public Schools, 2025-0867. You know, 2025, you know, that's our joint thing with CIP. Real quick, you know, I'm going to be making a donation to the 2026-0004. That's the Parks Trust Fund. You know, Ken Amaro for Pottsburg Creek Park. Agenda item, you know, I've got my FWC, Fishing with the Crew, Fishing with Crady shirt, and support that. I'm only just down to a minute. You know, ethics is gone. Here is the November 9th ethics meeting. Minutes, June, August, September. This is the minutes approval. So six months for ethics. Here it is. And here's the breakdown. And this is huge. Okay, minutes. June 3rd, legislative committee meeting. Public in attendance. Terry White, John Nooney, public comment. Mr. Muell requested public comment. Mr. Nooney provided public comment. August 19th, ethics commission meeting. Public in attendance. John Nooney, Cornell Oliver. Public comment. Dr. Freiberger asked for public comment. Mr. Nooney and Mr. Oliver provided public comment. September 9th, 2026, the internal operation committee meeting. Public in attendance. John Nooney, Rick Samples, and Cornell Oliver. Ms. Moore moved to recommend the ethics commission adopt the above changes to the internal operation procedures and review the provisions in section four regarding remote attendance and participation in ethics commission shade meetings. All right. Thank you, Mr. Nooney. Well, the whole point is. Thank you, Mr. Nooney. This affects everything in Duval County. Thank you, Mr. Nooney. All right. We're going to have to change up a little bit this morning due to some planning commission timing issues with some of the action items. So we're going to go to item number nine on our agenda for our action items. The first item will be 2026-0787. Can I get a motion on the bill? Move the bill. In a second. I've got a motion in a second. All right. Mr. Lukakovic, come on down and do your presentation. Good morning, everyone. Can we somehow advance to the PowerPoint presentation? You got the Dolphins PowerPoint, I think. There we go. Okay. Good morning, everyone. For the record, I'm Ed Lukakovic for the planning department. Also with me this morning, I have Cindy Trimmer and Josh Cockrell for the applications. Any questions that you may have regarding these presentations? Hopefully we can answer those for you. We'll look at the first application. These are on two different cycles, but ordinance 2026-787, its land use number L6161-26C. The planning commission reviewed this application on Thursday, November 5th. The first city council had its first public hearing on this application on Tuesday, November 10th, and the city council land use and zoning committee reviewed this application this past Tuesday, November 17th, and the final city council public hearing on this application will be next Tuesday, November 24th. The second application, land use ordinance ordinance number 2026-839, its land use number L6167-26C. The planning commission will look at this application this afternoon at one o'clock, and then the first city council public hearing is scheduled for November 24th, November 24th next Tuesday, and the land use and zoning committee will look at this application scheduled Tuesday, December 1st, and the final city council public hearing on this application is December 8th on a Tuesday. Now, we'll go back to this first application. L6161-26C, its ordinance number is 2026-787. Its location consists of four parcels, 1160 New Kings Road, 10980 Brad Avenue, and 6909 and 6939 Dunn Avenue. The subject site is 3.7 acres, of which there are no wetlands on the property. Its current line use category is low density residential residential and professional institution, residential professional institution, and it's proposed to go the recreation open space land use category. It's located in the Trout River drainage basin, which drains into the St. John's River. Some of the current and development standards for this application, the current development standards for residential professional institution, of which 1.8 acres of which 1.8 acres is in the application zone, you can have two scenarios. You can have up to 27 multi-family dwelling units at a density of 15 dwelling units per acre, or scenario two, you can have up to 39,204 square feet of commercial space under the floor area ratio of 0.5. The current development standards for low density residential, of which 1.9 acres is in the application site, you can have nine single family dwelling units with a density of five dwelling units per acre. However, since it is being proposed for recreation open space for the tire, four parcels consist of 3.78 acres, you can have up to 24,698.522 square feet of recreation building space at a floor area ratio of 0.15. Looking at the current land use map, looking at the current land use map, if you look north of the application site and on the west side of New Kings Road, you have community general commercial. Then if you look west of the application site is low density residential. Then if you look south of the application site and west of New Kings Road is low density residential, community general commercial, and the business park land use category. Then if you look east, and I'm sorry, if you look east, and east of New Kings Road, you have the community general commercial, low density residential, land use category, and also the Trout River. Now looking at some of the surrounding uses of the application site, if you look north and west of New Kings Road, you basically have wetlands that buffer the Little Trout River and Trout River. Then looking east of the application site, you have wetlands that buffer, you have multifamily property, and then you have mobile homes and single family homes. And then south of the application site, and then south of the application site, you have wetlands, you have wetlands, you have single family homes, you have vacant property, you also have a public boat launch where folks can launch their boats into the Trout River. And then in between the four parcels of the application site, you have a vacant RV park. This is under the same ownership of that park and the four parcels within the application site. Here's an area view of the application site, showing the four parcels in between, you have the vacant RV park. And then here's another aerial view showing the location of the photos for this presentation. Here's a northeasterly view of 10980 Brad Avenue from Brad Avenue. And a northeasterly view of 11134 New Kings Road from Brad Avenue. This is the vacant RV park. And then northeasterly view of 6909 Dunn Avenue from Brad Avenue. And another angle of 6909 Dunn Avenue from Dunn Avenue. And you're looking at a northwesterly view of 6909 Dunn Avenue from Dunn Avenue. And the same parcel from New Kings Road. Here's a southwesterly view of 11134 New Kings Road from New Kings Road. And then here's a southwesterly view of 11160 New Kings Road from New Kings Road. And then here's a westerly view of the Trout River from the New Kings Road Bridge. Now, this is an area of the map of the boat siding facility. The property has 527 feet of river frontage. But the area is in an unacceptable boat siding zone, which maybe would only allow six boat slips for the property for this particular application. Here's a coastal area map showing that 1.5 acres of the site is in a coastal high hazard area, which is a, excuse me, a category one flood surge zone would be at its maximum flood stage at that particular category. Here's a flood zone map of the property showing that the property 1.34 acres is in the 100-year AE flood zone and 1.42 acres within the 500X flood zone. And here's a map showing the adaptation action area, showing the entire site is within that zone. The adaptation action area is a combination of a 500-year flood and a Category 3 flood surge. If both events were to occur at the same time, the entire site would be flooded. Here's an elevation map showing basically the highest elevation of the property or the application site is at nine feet above sea level, and the lowest elevation is along Trout River at one foot above sea level. This is a soils map of the site. The soils map is not accurate. It gives us a rough idea what's out there, but the mapping was done in the mid-1980s. The only area that would be considered wetlands is the area that's labeled 67. That's a Cerency Loamy Fine Sand. That is no longer true. Sometime after this map was done, there was some improvements on New Kings Road and the New Kings Road Bridge, which raised the elevation, and the area of 67 is now filled. The area that was seven was mapped years ago. That's man-made land. In other words, that was filled years ago, and I suspect that area probably was one-time Cerency Loamy Fine Sand and probably Salt Marsh, but that's no longer the case. This is a slide showing most of the area is within the 500-foot wellhead protection zone. That basically, the well is located on the vacant RV park, and if there's no potable water on New Kings Road to service the site, that well will have to serve as water supply for the entire application site. This is the drainage basin map showing the location of the application is within the Trout River drainage basin, and then the final slide shows that the application drains into the Trout River and then drains eastwardly into the St. John's River, and that's the last slide for the application. On the application of what it's trying to become, what exactly is it trying to become? I'll have to let Cindy Trimmer discuss that. Good morning. Cindy Trimmer, 1 Independent Drive, Suite 1200, on behalf of the applicant. Thank you for moving us up so that we don't run up against Planning Commission agenda. I represent Justin Crumbly, who acquired the center portion, and it was an existing mobile home RV mixed-use park dating back to the 70s. That project had about 41 open violations when he acquired the property and has since fixed it up. I know that Mr. Lukakovic referred to it as vacant. Those are a little bit dated pictures. Since fixing up the property, building a kitchen, showers, restroom, those type of amenities in the center of the park, it's been operating on a continual wait list. So Mr. Crumbly has acquired the additional parcels surrounding the park that have been primarily dilapidated, a lot of them unoccupied. His intent is to be able to expand the RV park. The plans specifically for this northern portion along Trout River are to create an amenity. So he wants to do playground space, kayak launch, fishing access, things to really capitalize on the amenity that is the Trout River and activate that space for the park. Excellent. Thank you. All right. I'm not seeing any other speakers in the queue. A couple questions I got. Mr. Trimble, you had mentioned that there was open violations on the old RV park area. But on the parcel, the 11160 that he's, I guess, acquired now, is there any violations on any of those parcels along the Trout River? Because I noticed that it's been, there's been some field that's taken place there and some work along the bank and all. So I didn't know if St. John's Water Management has addressed anything or if there's any open violations on that. Through the chair, on the ones specifically subject to this application that are under contract and being part of the assemblage, there very well could be on those. But the intent would be to do exactly what he did with the primary parcel, clean everything up, and then beautify it and bring anything that would be outstanding into compliance. And he's shown that track record. All right. And these kayak launches are going to be open to the public? He is open to that. All right. So that'll make a lot of people happy. So any other speakers in the none I see? All right. We've got a motion and a second on this. Does this need to be a ballot vote or just a voice vote? Just voice vote. Okay. So it'll be a voice vote. All in favor of this, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Likewise. None. Motion carries. So by your action, you've approved 2026-0787. Thank you. All right. Next item will be 2026-0839. Can I get a motion on the bill? Can I go back to the PowerPoint? Let me get a motion and a second on the bill first. All right. I've got a motion and a second on the bill. Now, Mr. Lukakovic. Can we go back to the PowerPoint? I had the second half of the PowerPoint on that presentation. Okay. Our next application, ordinance number 2026-839. Its land use amendment is L6167-26C. It's located at 10491 Normandy Boulevard. The subject's size is 7.29 acres, of which 1.06 acres is wetlands. It's currently low-density residential, and the proposed land use category is neighborhood commercial. It's in the sub-drainage basins of McGirtz Creek and Ortega River, which then drains into the St. Johns River. The current land use development, the development standard for this particular parcel, as it is now, you can have 36 single-family dwelling units based on a five-dwelling unit per acre density. Under the proposed neighborhood commercial, you have two scenarios. You can have up to 142,899 square feet of commercial space at a floor area ratio of 0.45, or a scenario two of 145 multifamily dwelling units based on a density of 20 dwelling units per acre. Now, saying that, it is also possible that it can have a combination of both scenario one and scenario two with less commercial space and less multifamily, but there has to be a combination of both of those. Okay, now looking at the land use map, if you look north of the application site, the application area is all low-density residential. And then if you look west of the application site and north of Normandy Boulevard, it is low-density residential and community general commercial. Now, if you look at some of the surrounding uses of the application site, if you look north, you have single-family development. You have some power lines that also cut through this property, and then you have some vacant land, and you have some wetlands that buffer McGirt's Creek. If you look west of the application site and north of Normandy Boulevard, you have mobile homes, some wetlands, a park. And then if you look east and north of Normandy Boulevard, you have single-family homes, you have commercial structures, you also have a church. And then if you look south of the application site and south of Normandy Boulevard, you have the wetlands that buffer Ortega River. You have single-family homes and some vacant land, whatever. Okay, here's an area of view of the application site. You'll notice that the western portion of the site is wooded, and then you have a center area that's open field, and also the power line runs through it. There's a small excavated pond, excavated down to below the water table years ago. That area now, through eutrophication, is becoming a freshwater marsh. And then on the east side, you have some open areas and some wooded areas. This is the side that's most likely will be developed. Here's a close-up aerial northerly view of the property so that you can see it a little bit better. You can see the high wire tension lines crossing through the property. Here's a northerly view of the property. You can see the power lines. And there's a small utility building. I'm not quite sure what this is. It may be something related to the power lines and JEA. Here's another northerly view of the property from Normandy Boulevard. We're looking at the wooded section of the property. Here's a northwesterly view of the southeast corner of the property from Normandy Boulevard, and also the entrance to the adjacent commercial property. And here's a westerly view of the northeast corner of the property from Blair Road. The property begins at the fence line. Here's a northerly upstream view of McGirt's Creek from Normandy Boulevard, and then the southerly downstream view of Ortega River from Normandy Boulevard. For some reason, north of Normandy Boulevard is called McGirt's Creek, and then south of Normandy Boulevard is called the Ortega River, even though it's the same drainage system. We're looking at a flood map of the application site. 3.29 acres of the application site is in the 100-year AE flood zone, and 1.01 acres of the site is within the 500-year X flood zone. And then we're looking at the adaptation action area. It's 4.9 acres that cover this area. And then again, this is a combination of a 500-year flood and a Category 3 hurricane flood surge. This would cover the flooded area if both events were to happen at the same time. Here's an area which I call the wetlands map. I had a look at it a lot closer than what's on the city GIS system. And basically, you only have 1.06 acres of wetlands. You have an area called the Category 2 wetlands. This is the area that has a direct impact on the city's waterways, in this case, McGirt's Creek. And then you have two areas which we call Category 2. One area is the excavated pond, now going into a freshwater marsh system. And then you have another Category 2 wetland area. This area is kind of unique. It was bulldozed years ago because on the west side of that area is a earthen mound or a dike that was put in and it is now overgrown by vegetation, by trees. This area used to be part of the Category 2 wetland, but it is now separate and does not have a direct impact because of that higher elevation between this area and the wetland system that buffers McGirt's Creek. This is an elevation map showing that the highest elevation is located in the northeast corner of the property. I believe that's 64 feet above sea level. And it then drains down to 46 feet above sea level. And 46 feet is the elevation where the Category 2 wetland begins that buffers McGirt's Creek. This is a soils map. Even though it's not accurate, it gives me an idea what's out there. The only wetland soil is that rutledge, mucky, fine sand. Of course, that has been disturbed by bulldozing activities some time ago in the past. This is a drainage map of the area showing that the application site is within the Ortega River system. And then the final slide shows that the application drains into McGirt's Creek, which then crosses Normandy Boulevard into the Ortega River. And then it travels southeasterly till it just about crosses over into Clay County. And then it drains back up north again in Ortega River. And it then empties into the St. Johns River. And that's the last slide. And then again, Josh Cockrell and myself will be happy to entertain any questions you have. All right. Thank you. I'm looking at the queue. Any speakers with any questions? Any commissioners? Commissioner Freighton, you recognized. Thank you, through the chair. On this one, the west side of, let's say, the power lines, the A.E. flood zone, is there plans for construction on that side of the property? Well, I'll have to let Josh Cockrell answer that for you. Josh Cockrell, 200 North Laura, through the chair, to Commissioner Freighton. Real quick, first, I'm not sure why we're even here already today. I'll be honest with you. There's no planning report available to you or even a planning commission report. We have planning commission today. So, again, I don't know why we're here already. So, let me just state that for the record. It seems premature. Second, where the wetlands are, there's going to be no wetlands impacted. So, I'm just going to put that on the record. And that's all I can say at this time. Thank you. All right. No other commissioners in the queue. So, okay. All right. I didn't see you. All right. Mr. Harder, so you're recognized. Through the chair. What are you planning to build on this property or what are you planning to do with it? We're changing to commercial development. So, there's no current plans at the moment, but it's going commercial. All right. Thank you. Yeah. Yeah. So, yeah, I mean, it's on our agenda to address why it's on our agenda. We don't really get into, dive into that, but it's before us. We're the Jacksonville Waterway Commission, and we have a responsibility to look at it. So, that's why it's on the agenda to the commission. So, with that, I have no, Mr. Barker, you are on it. Go ahead, sir. You're recognized. Thank you. Commercial. What kind of commercial? Shopping Plaza. Shopping Plaza? That's correct, sir. Okay. All right. Thank you. All right. One last final call. I don't see any other commissioners on the queue. Mr. Jones, you're recognized. Thank you, Chair. I just have a question. If it's premature to be before the Waterways Commission, will our voting on it today have any impact on the outcome of the project? In other words, if it's premature of being here, why are we voting on it? Can anybody answer that? I don't know if I would call it premature. Ms. McGillis, could you respond? I also question why it is on the Waterways prior to it going to planning in a planning report. I expect that it's about the timing of Waterways meetings being month to month. But, yeah, there is a risk always if, because there is not enough information before this body at this time, if this body voted to not recommend it, yes, that could affect how this bill travels in the future. You can defer it, you can request that it get discharged, or you can vote on it. Right. Mr. Jones, is it you should? I'd like to make a motion to defer. Second. We've got a motion and a second to defer, so I've got two speakers in the queue, and so if you're to speak, it'll be on the deferral. So, first, I've got Mr. Hardesee. Oh, okay. So, Mr. Palouseau, go ahead, you recognize me. Through the chair, just to make sure the body's aware of this. I mean, if we defer this bill, in all likelihood, it's not coming back to us. If it goes through planning commission and then goes through the normal committee process, the council president is, in all likelihood, going to discharge it out of our hands, which is perfectly fine. I'm just making sure everyone knows that. If we defer right now, we're probably not going to see this again. Either way, I know that the council members up here are going to vote on it, but if you want to hear it now, that's fine. If not, then deferral just means we probably won't see it. All right. Thank you, sir. And let me go to Mr. Hardesee. Commissioner Hardesee, you recognize? Yeah. I mean, we're here to vet things on behalf of the Waterways Commission and everything, so I don't think it's fine at all if this thing, we defer it and we don't get to hear it back. I mean, we've just sidestepped our purpose, and it seems, why are we even sitting here? And so the bottom line is, I mean, my inclination right now is there isn't a planning report, there isn't any substantial information. And I hate to deny this thing based on zero information. And it's a throwaway vote. It's a joke, quite frankly. We need to get our process in order. We need to get this deferred. We need to get it into a systematic schedule of how we're going to handle these things. And that's why we are circumventing the entire process. That's why we are in the process. And to simply take us out because somebody didn't schedule it correctly is ludicrous, in my opinion. All right. Thank you. Let me go to Council Member Pelluso. Thank you, Chair. Yeah, just to the body. I mean, again, this is just about a timing issue, and we're coming up against the holidays. I imagine the applicant's probably going to want to move this forward, and it's probably going to request to the Council President, hey, let's move this up for a vote. Planning, these, they're not wrong. If the planning department has not provided a report, this is a little bit half-baked. By the time they provide the report and it goes to the planning commission, they may make substantial changes. So even by the time it gets to us, it might be well in advance of where this body should have seen it. So it's just more of a timing issue. Deferral basically means we're going to let the planning commission, the LUZ committee, and city council probably just take this on, and that's perfectly, you know, that's okay. It's just I want to make sure if we really want to hear it, let's listen to them now and not defer it. But deferring it, you know, probably means we're not going to see it. Thank you. Mr. Hardison. Well, I would say through the Chair that if we're being forced, we're being forced to circumvent the process and the whole nine yards, and we're looking at deferring it, which would be the effect of being silent, being muzzled on the whole thing, then, and the applicant wants to move forward, then I would make a motion to deny this. Okay. So the, right now, the motion on the floor that we're talking about is a deferral. And so any more speakers on deferring this is what we're going to take a verbal vote on. Commissioner Jones. Question to legal. Am I allowed to withdraw my motion to defer? It's been seconded. It belongs to the body at this point. You should take a vote. Got it. And if it's too close, you might want to hand count. Okay. So on the floor, right, go ahead, Mr. Jones. Like, maybe, I agree with her, maybe we can do a hand count around the horn for yays and nays. Well, that'll be doing the vote. On the deferment. On the deferral. Correct. So, Council Member Carlucci, you're recognized. So, I'm an alternate, so I'm not sure I should, you know, should even be asking the question, but why are we discussing something that is like a zoning and it doesn't even have wetlands on it? I mean, why are we even here? The Waterways Commission, right? So, through, for Mr. Carlucci's question, Mr. Lukakovic, this does have the wetlands and the McGirt's Creek connection? That's right. Because the application is on a city waterway and it has wetlands that does have a direct impact on the city's waterways, that's why the Planning Department has to bring this application for the Waterways Commission review. Okay. Well, is there anybody from Planning Department here? Can I say something? Well, wait a minute. I got the floor, I think. Yeah. Is there anybody from the Planning Department here? Yes, I am. Oh, okay. Well, we have a lot of zonings that come before the council. Do they all, and a lot of them have wetlands that connect to all kinds of waterways we have. Do they all come before the, and again, that's why I say maybe I shouldn't even be asking this because I don't come to many of these meetings at all because I'm an alternate. No, there are a lot of wetlands. And do they come before waterways? No, they don't because most of the wetlands within the city do not have a direct impact on the waterways. Okay. They're isolated pockets or they're depressional wetlands that don't drain anywhere except down into the soil. Okay. So that's why you don't see everything with wetlands. Okay, but this one does. This one does. Oh, okay. All right. No worries. I just didn't understand. All right. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Next, let me go to Mr. Devereaux. I know we have a deferral on the table, but then it seems like we also have a denial on the table. And so it seems to me that both should be voted on. Right now, the action on, the motion on, that we're dealing with that's on the floor right now is for the vote on the deferring. So that's the action that we are before us right now. And Chair, if I could ask this just for clarification. So if we were to vote no on the deferral, do we then vote on Mr. Hardesey's motion for a denial? So we would take a vote on the deferral, whatever that vote is, then we would, if it's denied and it's back on the table to be voted on, then we would take a vote and then each one would have the opportunity to vote yes or vote no. Thank you, sir. All right. Thank you. Next, let's go to Commissioner Frayden. Thank you, Chair. This referral, I understand the reasoning for it until we find out we don't get to vote on it again. I'm going to refer to a different situation that came up to this board a few years ago where we voted on a sandwich shop on Atlantic Boulevard by the fire station near San Marco. We voted on it, and a few years later, now it's a warehouse, basically. So we're voting on one thing, but something else ends up becoming built there, and it's a little uneasy, so to speak, is what we're talking about on this situation. Thank you. Right. All right. So now let me go to Commissioner Thomas. Sure. I guess I'm getting a little confused here. So our first vote, the first motion was to deny, correct? No. Or defer, defer. All right. So let me walk back through where we are. Thank you, Chair. So we, as a commission, we move the bill and second it for approval. Then there's a motion on the floor right now to defer. So that's what we're in the process of voting on would be to defer or not to defer. If it is voted up or if it's voted down, if it's voted down, then we come back to the original motion to vote on accept it, yes or no. Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Chair. I'd like to have a moment before you all decide to deny this. Okay. I don't have any other speakers in the queue. Go ahead, Mr. Cockle. So the planning report did come out on Friday, just so you guys know, and it goes to planning commission today at one o'clock. The planning department did recommend approval on both the land use change and the zoning change, just so you are aware. I don't know why you aren't aware otherwise. Pull back up, if you would, Secretary, the map that shows the wetlands so the commission can see, please. You're going to pull that presentation back up. Thank you. Here's what I'm not understanding, and maybe you guys need to see this map again. The wetlands, when she brings this back up, there are JEA power lines, the large power lines that run straight through the center of the property itself. The wetlands that are talking about the Category 3 and the McGirt's Creek is way on the west side of the area. I just need to kind of interrupt right now and not to discuss the presentation, but we're on the deferral, and so that getting back into the bill, and we really wouldn't. I'm trying to bring some light to it, Mr. Chairman, because apparently there's some uncertainty and lack of understanding that you guys are wanting to make a motion to denial due to lack of information, so I'm trying to provide this. Through the chair to the applicant, this body is here, and they're going to speak on this issue as they see fit. Let's keep order here, and I understand the desire to bring more information, but I think the commission is dialed into what we need to vote on, whether we want to go ahead with the information that's provided or if we want to defer, and I've got another, Councilman Carlucci, you're in the queue. Okay. So, to our planning department, gentlemen, the planning department has made a recommendation on this of approval. Is that correct? Okay. So, if there has been a recommendation, then I would recommend that we support, I think Mr. Jones was going to make a motion to withdraw his motion to defer. I think that's maybe what I heard him say, and if he made a motion to withdraw his motion to defer, then I would second that if there was not a second. I was not going to vote for it if there was no recommendation from the planning department, because I'm not going to vote on anything without a recommendation from the planning department. But since there is, then I'm prepared to vote one way or the other. All right. Thank you, sir. So, Ms. McGillis, if Mr. Jones wants to withdraw his motion to defer, he can introduce a request, a motion to withdraw his motion to defer, correct? Theoretically, yes. Your best course of action is take a vote on the deferral, either hands up on a yay or hands down on a nay. That's your cleanest. Get that off your table. If now there's new information that there is a planning report, that can affect someone's vote on whether to defer or not. If you vote a deferral down, then you can then ask more questions about the planning report. That's my suggestion. All right. Thank you. So, let me now get Commissioner Hardersey. Thank you. Just to help the other commissioners here, the way this process goes is it has to balance around in the different committees eventually goes to the LUZ, and then it goes to the full city council. The purpose of all that is to give input to the LUZ and then to the city council to vote up or down. We appear to be an important aspect of that, although the way this has been treated, we are not at all. I was chairman of the planning commission for a number of years and was on the planning commission for, I think, six years. And I will tell you that just because there is a planning department recommendation for approval or denial, that is just that piece of information that goes to the committee. I can't tell you the number of times that the planning commission would vote opposite of what the planning reports were. There's a reason for that. There's a reason we're here and sitting as a body to do this. We're all volunteers with the exception of the council members. We're all here to, in our heart, do the right thing, in our mind to do the right thing. And right now, we're being completely disregarded. I will tell you that when I was on the planning commission, it was outrageous the times that we would get this before the, I mean, after the LUZ met on the thing, and we'd get a planning commission issue on the planning department report and that sort of thing, and the whole thing was backwards. This is backwards as well, guys. It really is. We got a process, and, you know, you diminish the process, you kick the can down the road, say, so what, and that sort of thing. And guess what? The community, y'all's constituents, folks, my neighbors, they look at this like a clown show. And so the bottom line is, is that if we're going to do it right, do it. If we're not going to do it right, then I don't want to be a part of that. I'll flat out tell you. But to come here without any information, without a planning report, without just learning that we have an approval, that's a mess. And then we're met with the dilemma of, okay, well, if we defer it, which would be the reasonable thing to do, everybody, because then we give them an opportunity to provide the information and provide a basis for me to vote yes or no. But I don't have any. And so I will tell you, the system in this situation, how it was set up, is quite frankly a mess. And I'm not going to vote for something where I have a duty to look at the wetland impact and that sort of thing on a, you know, a project that we're going to have significant rezoning. And we are going to be left with, well, why did you do that? Why did you do that, Hardesty? And I'm going to say, well, because if we didn't, we'd defer it. And if we do defer it, guess what? We don't even come into the discussion. We don't, we aren't even part of it. We have circumvented the entire system and the way it's been set up. So, you know, this isn't, this isn't the end of the world stuff here, folks, but when you think about the process and what should be going on, it's an important thing. And so if we do defer it, we become absolutely, we, we, we aren't a factor. We aren't anything. All right. Thank you. All right. Let me go to Commissioner Devin Rowe. Through the chair to, through the chair to Commissioner Peluso, a few minutes ago, you had mentioned about just the process of how this would proceed, that if, if we were to defer this, that it may never even come back to us and just basically bypass us. Is, is that how the system works? You're, you're so much more familiar than I am with this. Through the chair to the commissioner. I'm just saying based on experience, right? The applicants usually don't like waiting for another month because we only meet monthly. And I don't know, are we even going to meet in December? We are. Okay. So, so we do even meet in December. I don't have that answer for you on the, the agendas as far as the meeting, but to, to elaborate on what, what the question is, is that it can be the council president can go ahead and remove it from this committee and keep it moving forward. So to answer your question, yeah, it can be, uh, removed from here. And, and as you've heard many say that it will probably not come back here to keep the process moving forward. So if that answers your question, um, we, we have a, a withdrawal on the floor, a motion and a second of it. We're going to take the vote by hand. So all in favor of the withdrawal, please raise your hand. Did you mean deferral? I'm sorry. Yes. Thank you. Did I say withdrawal? I meant defer. All in favor of the deferral, raise your hand. The deferral. Deferral. This all, if you want to, granting a deferral, please raise your hand. All right. Those that oppose the deferral, please raise your hand. Okay. So it's pretty well unanimous that the, we will not defer. Uh, we're back to the bill that has a motion and a second on it for approval. So any discussions on the bill, uh, commissioner for Italian to the chair, as much as I hate to deny anything, anything that could be a, you know, to move something forward that could very well be a benefit to the, to the city and all, uh, I, I have to agree with Mr. Hardesey, uh, Commissioner Hardesey. We, you know, it's, if, if we pass this thing, we're basically saying our opinion doesn't matter. And the, the process I've heard over and over, it's become more, it seems to become more prevalent to where the things that come before us or they don't come before us because of the timing issue. Uh, and, uh, you know, I, I think it, uh, I think our opinion does matter. As, as he said, we're all volunteers here. Um, we do this out of our, you know, concern for where we're moving forward. Um, and, um, I think our opinion matters and I think we need to get the process right. So the stuff does come to, uh, in front of us in a timely manner that, that we can at least voice our opinion. At the end of the day, our opinion doesn't matter. The city council is going to do whether we recommend or whether we don't. I mean, that's a, that's a hard fact, but at least we have the, the opportunity to give our input to them and any reasons or logic why we should or should not, or where they should or should not pass something from the waterways, uh, perspective. So, um, I'd just like to say, I, I think we need to get the process correct. All right. Thank you. I don't see any other speakers in the queue. Council member Carlucci. And, uh, trying to get a little more familiar with this. What is, and I apologize because I, I, I, I missed through this. What's being proposed to be, um, constructed here and what is the rationale for the, um, recommendation of approval? Well, basically when the planning department reviews, uh, applications for, uh, line use amendments, they basically look and say, well, uh. What's being proposed to be built here? And then why did y'all recommend approval? I need to, I need it in that order. Well, basically when they, when they look at it, they look and see what the trend is. No, I need to know what is being proposed to, to be built here first. And then you can, and I know what your process is. Yeah. I, I, I've been, I know that. What's being proposed to be built here and then why, not how, not how did you get there, but why did y'all recommend approval? What's, what is the reasoning? Well, there are various reasons why there's. I don't want to hear the reasons right now. I, I, look, I, I love the planning department. I always have, and we, we will be best friends always. I just need to, what's going to be built here? And then tell me what were the reasons that y'all gave approval for it? If, if I, if I could, if I could, uh, first of all, this is a proposal for a neighborhood commercial. Hold a second, Mr. You need to hold off for the chair. Okay. All right. Hold off just a second here. Uh, I want Ms. McGillis to kind of give a, a overview of what we're supposed to be doing here, because we cannot get into zoning, uh, issues or any kind of quasi judicial, uh, type of, of discussion on, on, on, on zoning issues. It's mainly wetland, uh, waterways impact. So I, I want Ms. McGillis to kind of refresh our, our direction here. To the chair, through the chair, to the commission. Pursuant to ordinance code section 95106E, it is a duty of the waterways commission to, quote, cooperate with planning and development department in the accomplishment of its purpose, act as a specialized advisor on the St. Johns River, all tidal waters, and all saltwater, estuine, and river, river, river, wetlands, wetlands, class one, class two. Um, that's why this comes to you, but this is a land use. It does have a companion bill that is a zoning. Pursuant to that same section 95106E, this commission has authority only over the land use. The zoning aspect is a quasi judicial matter, which if there is testimony taken, which would usually become the, um, the answer to a question, then there are certain members of this commission that then are, are part of an ex parte communication that would have to declare the same. That's not the end of the world, but it should be avoided. Action on land use amendment is a legislative act. What's in front of you is land use. Action on a land use amendment is a legislative act. It is the making of new law, and this commission can consider a myriad of information to aid in a legislative decision, including, to an extent, material related to the companion zoning bill. The companion zoning bill is a quasi judicial matter. It is the application of existing law to specific circumstances. For example, code criteria for changes to zoning as applied to this particular land. Decisions on quasi judicial matters must be based on competent substantial evidence presented at a noticed public hearing on the zoning bill. That is not what we're doing. Please refrain from making any comments on the zoning bill, zoning bill material, or any questions that indicate that you have a position one way or another on the companion zoning bill because it is not before this commission. In addition, any information or material regarding the companion zoning bill, which the applicant will very, very much point out if they're asking a question that then gets into the zoning aspect, it is considered ex parte. Okay. So I'll try to stay away from that tripping wire and just ask you, I know what LDR is, low density residential. Uh, so I think it's fair for me to ask what is, um, uh, NC and ND? Mr. Luka Kovic. NC is a land use category we call neighborhood commercial. Uh-huh. Okay. That, uh, it's different than zoning. It's land use. We can't really discuss it here. Yeah. And, and, and what is ND? Neighborhood? There is no ND. Okay. I just saw him. Uh, maybe that's, uh, maybe that's the initials of, uh, somebody. Okay. So neighborhood commercial. LDR to neighborhood commercial. And, um, so something within the neighborhood commercial is going to go on this property. That's correct. And, um, and that, and that's why we are, uh, sitting here because, uh, something in that NC category, and we have to determine whether that would have some type of effect on the wetlands. And, uh, that would eventually encroach into, uh, the, uh, the, uh, the, the riparian lands and the creek and so forth. But there's no wetlands. Um, so I have no idea what, uh, what could be built that would cause a problem. Thank you. All right. Mr. Thomas, you were, Commissioner Thomas, you were in the queue. Thank you, Chair. To the Chair and through the Chair. Um, and I don't know if I could ask this question, but what is the impact to our river with this particular development? Uh, what is, uh, the impact to the wetlands? Is there going to be some runoff, erosion? Can I ask that question? Mr. Lukakoba? If you're asking me, there's always a potential of impact. Um, the problem is, is then when it comes to design of the project, there has to be certain issues involved, which you folks don't get involved with. For example, there's got to be sediment and erosion control. There has to be stormwater management facilities. Those have to be put into design as required by development services. That's not something we address here. All right. Thank you, Mr. Thomas. So we don't know the impact. You will not know the impact. All right. Let me go to Commissioner Barker. So while this doesn't have direct wetlands, which I'm actually looking at wetlands within the box, which is a little bit confusing to me, um, it's the power lines and everything in here sits in that drainage base and the flood, there's flood zone 100% surrounding this thing, top, bottom, both sides, if you look at FEMA flood maps. So again, I see the consternation and I, I do as well. I mean, we've had people come in here and ask to put old diesel trucks next to wetlands with no infrastructure and nothing to assure us that you're not going to be bleeding transmission fluid, not you, but that they weren't going to be bleeding transmission fluid, diesel fuel into the wetlands, which then goes into the salt marsh, which then goes into the river and so forth. And that's what we're here to ask. Those are the questions that we're here to ask. So we don't mean to try your patience, but saying, okay, we're going to do something. And then I have to ask secondarily, well, okay, what, what, and you say a commercial building, well, what are you going to smelt nuclear waste here? Or are you just going to put a shop here? What's your plan? And I think if you tell us your plan so that then we can say, hey, no big deal, even if they do have runoff from a parking lot, okay, minimal risk, then we've done what we need to do. And I think we're in full cooperation at that point with planning. And I think you need to know that we want you to be able to do what you need to do. I mean, I've been out there and I've seen it and I would love to have somebody improve that corner. So just tell us what's going in and then you'll put it to rest. If I may, through the chair, as I've stated earlier, I said a shopping plaza, a shopping plaza does not include smelting, sir. And I'll do respect a shopping plaza. You mean tenants that you would see at any other commercial shopping plaza. You're not going to develop anything underneath power lines or west of power lines. Your dry lunch, if you go back to that map is all on the east side of those power lines. So let's make that clear. I tried to state that earlier. You know, when you look at any sort of civil design plans, those all have to go through land use and planning and permitting processes and everything else and comprehensive planning department. It's way past you guys, way past the zoning process. We don't get into that here. Any zoning matters you don't get into nor do you discuss here. We're talking about the wetlands and the mitigation or any problems with the wetlands potentially, which again are on the west side of those power lines, which is up against the creek itself. We're not touching any of that. As I stated when I started this conversation with you guys. Well, your property does touch it. So it is something that we have to look at. We're not impacting those wetlands that I made clear when I started this. Through the chair, excuse me. I'm sorry. Yeah, let's keep proper protocol here. You know, we got to keep this on track and maybe getting emotional, but we're going to keep this in a proper order. Go ahead. Just through the chair, what I thank you for is that you said basically retail strip center is what you're talking about. Okay. Which wasn't clear to me in your initial answer. Okay. So now it is. And it gives us, I think, a heck of a lot more clarity so that then we can say, oh, okay, great. No problem. Or if somebody has a problem with that, fine. So with that, if you're talking about putting in something akin to a strip center here, that's what I needed to know. And I think that it makes some other people at least more clear on what they're going to make the decision on. And that's why we felt like we were a little bit pulling teeth. But I understand it. Now we're clear. And I appreciate what you've done and I appreciate your clarity. Okay. And I didn't mean to say that you were really going to smelt anything there, but it's just we've had so many people come up and give us some very interesting non-answers. And all due respect, usually I avoid coming to this commission by putting the wetlands in conservation. This time I didn't because you're not going to build anything underneath power lines or, and there's no usable land to the west side of those power lines. So this time I did not put the wetlands or that area into conservation because, again, there's nothing developable to the power lines west. So hence why I'm here this time. Okay. So I've never seen. Thank you. Through the chair. Thank you. Thank you. And once again, conversation needs to go through the chair. And not just to freely outburst. You know, so we've got to keep order to respect the chair. And, yes, I'm the vice chair filling in for the chair on this. So I'll try to keep order. So, Mr. Jones, you were in the queue. You're not now. And so right now I don't have any other speakers. Commissioner Hardersey, please go, sir. Just going back to the process, understand that until those details are put into a planning department document and then studied and reviewed, whatever's said here right now is just conversation. And I'm not saying that the applicant would do that, but I'm saying that it is out there and it certainly can be changed. Like, people change underwear. I mean, as quickly as we walk out the doors, it can change to, you know, it's going to be the diesel station or whatever the case might be. Understand that there are no details that we are seeing what the impact is on the wetlands. I'm just sharing that with you because that is the reality. All right. Thank you. Let me go to Commissioner Frayden. Thank you. Thank you, through the chair. So you're stating that nothing is going to be built underneath the power lines and west. With the planning commission also here, is anything able to be built underneath the power lines or west? Are we safe on that part? Through the chair. Through the chair. I mean, the power lines, there's an easement, and I've never seen anything where something was built under power lines. Soccer fields, doll parks. I mean, but no buildings or anything. The answer is no, best of your knowledge. Best of my ability, I would say no. And that's to the west of it also, where the considered wetlands are at also. That's what we're concerned about. I got a feeling. Then again, we don't know. Someday, somebody down the road may want to fill the wetlands or whatever, but that's not what's being asked here. We're just asking to change the land use category on the whole parcel. Not saying that the whole parcel is usable. It's just not, really. All right. Thank you. Let me go to Council Member Carly. Okay. I'm just trying to figure out, Mr. Chair, are we ready for a motion? We have a motion and a second on the floor right now for approval. For approval. Okay. Well, I am going to support this. And I do think there are some guardrails, and I suppose I don't want to get too close to talking anything ex parte. But I will say that the NC category is a step below CG, if I'm not mistaken. And so that does have guardrails, so I don't see anything that – so I think – I feel comfortable enough to support this and to let it go to the next phases of the Planning Commission, as Commissioner Hardesty has stated, and then it will go to LUC. I feel comfortable with it and to move on, and I appreciate knowing that at least we did get a recommendation. If we hadn't gotten some kind of recommendation from the Planning Department, I wouldn't have voted one way or the other. But that's just my observation for whatever that's worth. Thank you. One more, Commissioner, in the queue, and then we'll go ahead and take it for a vote after that. Commissioner Hobson. Through the chair. Thank you, sir. Just so we're all clear, of the seven-plus acres, essentially what we're looking at is the three acres to the east that's being developed. I mean, I think we need to – it's not – obviously, it's not the whole thing. Well, the land use – the proposed land use is for the whole parcel. I understand. But in reality, yes, east of the power lines is the area that will most likely be developed. Okay. Gotcha. All right. Thank you. There's no other speakers in the queue, and I just want to – kind of little tidbits on the power line. JA is not going to let structure be built up underneath there, so that won't be a concern. So we'll take this vote by hand. I've got a motion and a second to approve. 2026-0839. All in favor of approval, raise your hand. All right. Those in opposed of this, raise your hand. Okay. So we've got a five-to-five. Normally, that would be an automatic deferral. But right now, we're going to let Ms. McGillis go back and review the actual procedure on that. And if we need to take another action on it, we'll come back to that. I noticed we've got another representative with the planning department. Did you have anything you wanted to add? Helena Perola with the planning department. Not on this particular item, but just on procedure as far as when these applications come to the Waterways Commission. They generally do come before Planning Commission. The Planning Commission and the LUZ – I might have missed some of the earlier conversations, so I might be speaking out of line. But the Planning Commission and the LUZ wants to see the recommendation of the Waterways before they make their recommendation. There are a few applications that come after Planning Commission. That's just all to do with scheduling and when things are filed. Sometimes that does happen. But overall, we look to have the application reviewed by Waterways before Planning Commission. All right. Thank you for that information. So I guess Ms. McGillis will go ahead and start working through our agenda. And Mr. Lukakovic and Mr. Cockrell, if y'all will just bear with us until we can get a little clarity on the direction. And as soon as she's got that, we'll bring that right back up on the table. Thank you. All right. So that takes us back to our beginning of our agenda. We're on item number six, presentation on the Jacksonville Estuarine Dolphins. Come on down. Go ahead. All right. If you would give your name and address for the record and go ahead and start with your presentation. Sure. It's Quincy Gibson. I'm at the University of North Florida, which is 1 UNF Drive in Jacksonville, Florida, 32224. So thank you for your time today, commissioners. I am here to talk to you about the UNF Dolphin Research Program, which was founded in response to an unusual mortality event that occurred for St. John's River Dolphins in the summer of 2010. And so unfortunately, due to limited knowledge about the dolphins at that time, the investigation was inconclusive. And so I was brought in to fill that knowledge gap. Our research program broadly fits into two main categories, population monitoring to assist with conservation management, as well as behavioral ecology. Within the realm of population dynamics, we primarily focus on monitoring abundance patterns, movement, and residency within the river, as well as reproduction, which is essential for long-term viability of the population. We also monitor population health, and that includes both body condition and skin lesions as non-invasive indicators of individual health that allows us to assess the population levels as well. We also track exposure to harmful algal blooms and cyanotoxins, and we've evaluated data for dolphin exposure to those. Within behavioral ecology, we primarily focus in social structure, looking at community networks and community dynamics and how those are impacted by disturbance events. We've also prioritized investigations into male alliances. It's worth noting that the St. John's River dolphins are famous in the marine mammal research community because our dolphins have a rare level of social complexity that's only exhibited in two populations worldwide, Shark Bay, Western Australia, and here in the St. John's River. Our males form multi-level alliances, and it assists with reproductive opportunities, and I'd be happy to tell you more about that another time. With foraging ecology, this is a relatively recent area for my research team, but we have started analyzing long-term records of habitat use and identifying specific core areas for foraging behavior and also interactions with local fisheries, primarily the commercial blue crab fishery. Our primary method of data collection is photo identification surveys. We cover the area from the mouth of the river to downtown Jacksonville. During the summer, we're out there every week for 10-plus hours a day. During the rest of the year, it's twice monthly. And we also have a long-term collaboration with Fish and Wildlife, specifically their marine mammal stranding response team. We're able to get dolphin tissue samples as well as stomach contents to be able to evaluate dolphin health and behavior. Our primary method of collecting data is photographs, and so we are able to non-invasively track individual dolphins over time without causing them harm. Each dolphin has a distinctive dorsal fin, and we can track changes and additions to the nicks and notch patterns on their fins. We name them and give them all codes. We're also able to track maternal relationships through the siblings. You can see on the bottom row, all of those are Athena's calves. She's one of our supermoms in the river, and her second calf, the one that was born in 2011, just recently gave birth to her first calf this summer. So using these data, we've been able to determine that the St. Johns River has one of the highest reported dolphin densities in the world. In the winter, we average almost four dolphins per kilometer squared. During the summer, that bumps up to almost six dolphins per kilometer squared. To put that into context, if you look at the next closest dolphin population in the Indian River Lagoon, their average is 1.2 dolphins per kilometer squared year-round. The highest that's been reported anywhere outside of the St. Johns River is at 2.67. So we have an exceptionally high density of dolphins in the river. In terms of having high density, it comes with challenges, meaning that resources are limited for these dolphins. We also know, unfortunately, that our dolphins are facing cumulative impacts of multiple stressors. There is an increasing prevalence of severe emaciation. You may be able to see the ribs visible on this adult female. Her name is Amelia, sorry. And Amelia has a nursing calf, and she's unable to produce milk at the level of emaciation that she's exhibiting. On the bottom panel, we also see an increasing prevalence of freshwater skin disease, which is indicating that these dolphins are spending too much time far upriver in low areas of salinity. And this is our poster child for that. His name is Lava, and he was born in the river in 2011. So we've recently started investigating dolphin diets. We have conducted the first dolphin prey assessment in northeast Florida, and the results were very surprising. So we know that the primary food source for our St. Johns River dolphins is Atlantic croaker. That's typical for most of the southeast dolphin populations. But their number two prey item is a fish species that no other dolphins have been documented eating anywhere in the world, and those are violet goby. And through our partnership with Florida Fish and Wildlife Fisheries Independent Monitoring Team, we know that they're primarily catching violet goby in the Ortega River, which is primarily freshwater. And so these dolphins have shifted their foraging habitat farther upriver than they should be for their own health. We also see an increasing prevalence of dolphin entanglements, both lethal and sublethal. We have the highest number of dolphin entanglements in the state per FWC, and my team has been actively monitoring crab pot interactions with dolphins in the river, which have been increasing over time. In the bottom right picture, you can see a dolphin that's diving on a crab pot buoy. The line that attaches the buoy to the crab pot is how these dolphins are getting entangled, and we see this frequently, and our data indicates it's primarily adult males who are doing this behavior, and it is currently spreading among male alliance members. And so the behavior is very risky, and it is increasing over time. So why is all of this important? We hope that by covering all of these different areas of research, we can increase knowledge about this very special population of dolphins, hopefully to improve management and conservation efforts. If we can protect the dolphins, hopefully we can protect the broader ecosystem as well. And with that, I would be happy to answer any questions that you may have. Thank you again for your time. All right. Thank you. Let me go first to Commissioner Bertalin. Yes, through the chair, I understand just last week there was a dolphin found in the river right in the Blunt Island area. Was there anything to that, natural causes, or what? Yes, we were actually out at the Right Whale Festival with FWC when the call came in, and so I've been able to review the reports. We know that it's an adult female, and she's in our catalog. I just haven't been able to pull her long-term sighting records yet. But there was no evidence of an entanglement or human interaction. But in a lot of cases, it's inconclusive because when they become decomposed, if they've been floating or sitting on the shoreline for too long, some of those marks disappear. And so for that one, it could not be determined in terms of cause of death. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Let me go to Commissioner Jones. First, through the chair, I'd like to thank Dr. Quincy for coming. This has been a long time in the making. A lot of us have grown up on the river watching these dolphins. I have since I was a little, little child. And the amount of data that I've learned from her just, what, a couple of months, three months, talking back and forth, I had no idea that our dolphins were born here and they stay here. I find that amazing because, for some reason, I always thought they migrated just like every other fish, but then they're not a fish. They're a mammal. They breathe air just like us. And the highest population. There's just under 600. Is that what I heard? Just under 600 right here in our St. Johns River. It's amazing. Yeah. Our number right now is at 520, but it's not including all of the calves. And we're a few years behind in terms of adding new individuals. So we expect that it probably is well over 600. And that is one of the highest in the world. One of two. So that's pretty impressive. I mean, it says a lot for us as Duval County and our St. Johns River. The dolphin know that we're the river city, obviously. I love the red fish picture. Or do they have to follow slot size? I'm going to say no. They do not. But interestingly, they don't chew their food. They have to swallow it whole. So there are limitations on how large of a fish they can actually consume. But I didn't have time to talk on it. But we have evidence that our dolphins are starting to prey process, which means that they're breaking up the fish before they consume them. And that's a really big indicator of high intelligence. Taking taste tests. Yes. Interesting. And the crab pots to finalize it. I know we've got to shorten things up, extend the meeting. But there's just a lot of valuable information in there. And second thanks to Chairman Johnson and Rebecca, you also. A lot of work's been done to get Quincy here today, and I appreciate everybody's effort. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Let me go to Captain Suber. Through the chair. Great presentation. I just learned a little bit myself here. My question is, of these issues that develop through the research, is there an after action to those issues? In other words, do you all have mechanisms or means of making corrections or to helping the dolphins that are in stress? That's a great question. Thank you for that one. We are currently working with Fish and Wildlife and NOAA Fisheries, who is our permitting agency for the research that we do. There is a working group attempting to deal with the dolphin and crab pot entanglement issue. And so we've been providing data and guidance based on our information, what we're seeing. And they're, in return, telling us what they are working on. Right now, there are efforts in place to trial new types of line to see if that can reduce entanglement for the dolphins. We're also launching more investigative studies using drones or UAS photogrammetry to be able to monitor how the dolphins are maneuvering around these crab pots. Thank you. Good job. Thank you. All right. No other speakers in the queue. Thank you for coming and sharing and bringing the enlightenment to us. So with that, I want to go back to Ms. McGillis to give us more information on the 2026-0839 that we had the tie vote on. Thank you. To the chair and through the chair, to the commission, thank you for the opportunity to look something up. Because what I wanted to make sure was that the waterways commission rules did not change from the city council rules. So you are, and they do not. So you are under the city council rule 4.601. The tie vote is a no action. This body is here for a report. It's not a, like at the rules committee, at finance, you are voting to pass a bill or not pass a bill. This body is voting on a recommendation, a report, and a tie vote is no report. Your options right now are to leave it as such, and it would just be indicated as tie, no report. Or you could have a motion for reconsideration if somebody is inclined to change their vote, and then you would have a vote that is either deny or approve. Those would be your options, yeah. And on, because it is a tie, either, it does not matter the prevailing vote because there was no prevailing vote. So any vote can call for reconsideration. So with that explanation, so the opportunity is now, if there is a motion to reconsider, then we would entertain a motion to reconsider, and we would need a second. I've got a motion to reconsider, and I've got a second to reconsider. So the motion would be to reconsider and to vote on, I guess, Ms. McGillis, we vote on the reconsideration if we are to reconsider. Yes, what you will be reconsidering is the motion that was on the floor, which was a motion to approve, to have a report reading that you approve. That was the motion on the floor that was voted on, and now has been reconsidered. We have to vote on the reconsider to reconsider first. Yes, yes, please. Right. So we've got a motion and a second on the floor to reconsider. All in favor, there'll be a hand vote. All in favor to reconsider the vote. Raise your hand. So there was only four votes to reconsider, so the reconsider fails, and I've got Mr. Barker in the queue. So the motion to reconsider failed, so the vote, the tie vote, no report, stands. Okay. So you're out of the queue. All right. So Commissioner Hardesty, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Chairman. My question to Ms. McGillis, is there ability to outline with our tie vote to outline why there was a tie vote? There's no procedure really for that. There's no procedure to explain as a body the vote, but I will say this is all recorded, and I think the minutes will be amply reflected, especially, like, for instance, your explanation that this seemed procedurally unusual to come to this body so early, and many of the members talking about not having adequate information. Well, I think that this is quite clearly outside of procedure, number one, as to how it's come about, and to simply enlighten the next folks that take it up with the different reports that that procedure was in question. And then secondly, regarding the – it's being recorded and everything, but generally the kind of thing is fairly obscure. You've got to go dig for it and that sort of thing. My question is, will this be included in the packet that goes with the particular legislation or new plan that goes forward to the Planning Commission, to the LUZ, to the full city council? Otherwise, we look like we just – well, we didn't – we had a tie vote, so it's deferred. And then we get – we get basically shelved into obscurity again. As to – as to – through the chair, to the commissioner, as to how this would be reported to the LUZ and Planning, I would defer that question to Mr. Lukakovic. I think, but I would suggest that on the – the short title on the bill on the public-facing forums that it would read, because it does read that it comes to JWC, that it would read as a tie vote, and I would recommend, parentheses, no report. So, thank you, Mr. Hardesty. Let me go to Mr. Barker, Commissioner Barker. I share your frustration entirely, and my purpose for the motion for reconsideration was so that I might be able to change from yes to no. I'm sorry that we didn't – I didn't get that opportunity. But I have some comfort in this in that the JEA easement is going to contain an awful lot of what they can do and what they can't do, an awful lot of that. And I don't like the idea that we were left with a tie vote, which means no voice, and that was the reason for the reconsideration. I'm sorry that we didn't have the discussion period. I would be able to say that, but it's done. We've done what we're going to do. I appreciate the chairman's leadership – the standing chairman's leadership on that. This has been probably the craziest mechanical situation I think I've seen in my entire time here. So, well done. Thank you. Thank you. But I will say this, that what you said here today, the concerns, the opposition support, all of that is definitely recorded. And the five votes for, five votes against the tie, that is still a flag that's waived on why it ended up in that situation. So a tie vote is never just ignored. And so it will be – basically, it is a – with all the council members, it will be looked at and concerned. So to say if it will pass or fail, I'm not saying that. I'm just saying that don't feel like you – your efforts here were just useless today. Y'all have been a resounding voice for the community, and I appreciate that. And also just know that, you know, I appreciate y'all here as volunteers. And don't feel like you – like I say, it's not beneficial for you being here. It is. You speak up for the community. And I'll always support our community and make sure y'all have a voice to be a voice for the community. So, yeah, we're done with that. And we'll move on to our next item on the agenda. Chair, if I may. Yes. It – OGC will endeavor to find out a better process. The process is not OGC's process, but OGC will work with legislative services and planning to make sure this doesn't happen again. And if it happens, here's the why. This was odd. And for a couple months prior, we've been having stuff come on the agenda that was voted on the night prior. Yes, you are heard, and OGC will work with legislative services and work with planning to try to sort it. Right. And thank you for that, Ms. McGillis, and I, as well, being the rules chair, I will make a special inquiry into making sure we get it right or trying to eliminate this as much as possible. Mr. Harder, see you recognize. I just wanted to say thank you. Thank you very much, both Chairman Gay and Ms. McGillis. That's all we can ask for at this point, and we very much appreciate it. That was, quite frankly, the entire reason why I'm so adamant and brought this up, because it's important what you guys are going to do now. So thank you very much. All right. Thank you. All right. With that, moving on, just to reiterate, 2026-0839 was a tie vote, and that is basically a no report that will be going out of this commission. So state in that for the record. That will take us to item number seven in our agenda, sub and special committee reports. And let's go ahead and start with the Fort George River Sandbar Vessel Speed Regulation Task Force with Commissioner Jones. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Commission, just waiting on the presentation to come up. Everybody, I'll have to scroll to it. I'm sorry. Do the other commissioners in the board have anything in front of them? I'll give everybody a minute just to get to the first page there. Okay. We'll go ahead and start this, because I know the meeting's extended, and this is probably not going to be a long one here. The first page basically just gives some background on the task force while we were assigned to collect data. The task force consisted of myself, Commissioner Hobson, and Commissioner Thomas. And we have collected data until we're blue in the face. We've done the best we could. I think we've got everything there. And I'll keep saying this to keep it short, but it's impossible to keep short, because there is so much encompassed into accomplishing this vessel speed regulation zone. We've got points to hit in Florida Administrative Code. We've got points to hit in Florida statute for FWC to accept an application. It's a very long process. There's different ways to go about it. The data that we have collected as the task force suggests to really try for it as using the sandbar as a navigational hazard in and of itself. The sandbar is created, and when I say sandbar, we don't mean just one small sandbar that boats collect on warm summer months. It's a sandbar from one end of Fort George River to the other with very small channels between the sandbars. And once again, those constantly shift due to the tidal waters that come in and out of that river from the Atlantic Ocean. There's an aerial, I don't even know what page I'm on, page three, there's an aerial satellite image for those that haven't been keeping up with the task force. That is pretty much what it looks like right now. I don't, it's 2024. It hadn't changed too much since then. Some channels have shifted left. Some have shifted right. Right below that is satellite imagery over the past 65 years, roughly. And you can see the amount of sediments that have been deposited into this Fort George River with the photo on the right. That is what I believe has created the navigational hazard. And you'll see that more apparent coming down some. The next photo on page four is what the sandbar looks like at low tide. Fully exposed. Once again, that gives you a good idea of the navigational fingers, for lack of a better term, to kind of get through the sand, get to the other side, go where you want to anchor your boat and have a good time for the day. If we scroll on down to page five, that's a picture from an aerial ambulance. It gets pretty packed out there. And really, that's one of probably about four areas that residents like to congregate at and just have a good time. We take our families out there, and it's a slice of heaven we're able to enjoy being Floridians. Page seven is that same photo at low tide. Right below that is a picture from the Kingsley Dock at high tide. And I did that page for comparison purposes only. Coming into the Fort George River, eastbound from Sisters Creek at high tide, that's what the captain of the vessel sees. Now, to the experienced boaters that have been going out there for decades, we all know to slow down. We know what's ahead. We don't want to run aground. We don't want to tilt our motor. We don't want to throw anybody out of the boat. So if you've been going out there for an amount of time, you know to slow down. Where we're at now, not everybody going out there is seasoned and knows that. So when they come in there at high tide, a lot of them are coming in at full throttle due to lack of signage. So that lower picture is a really good illustration of what it looks like coming in. Because you can't come in from the Atlantic. So everybody's coming in from the Sisters Creek. I can't say you can't come in from the Atlantic, but it's a whole other beast on that end. Photos next really have no legal bearing with the FWC. They're in there because people do congregate on the bar and have a good time. They anchor their boats. I wanted these photos to be in there for illustrative purposes only, even though the commissioners, or excuse me, the attorneys in Tallahassee, that won't go into any consideration without other studies being done. But I wanted at least the Waterways Commission, for those that don't go out there, to see actually what it looks like. That's any given. You can look at the dates. That's not Memorial Day weekend. That's not Fourth of July. That's an average Saturday in Fort George in the summertime. The next page just basically summarizes things that can happen. Those are mainly points that we're not really focusing on for the permit. A lot of those require vessel congestion studies, wave and wake studies, which in the end equal to spending taxpayer dollars. It's money well spent because we're trying to keep people safe. Obviously, we would like to try this the route to cost the taxpayer as minimal as possible. The next section is just basically logistics of where the Fort George River is. Really, the proposed zone is intended to protect boaters and swimmers by reducing serious public safety risks. It also addressed increasing recreational use as Jacksonville's population grows. And that's a pretty key point. Every year, Jacksonville gets more boaters. I mean, I don't want to cite the wrong number, but every year more vessels get registered. Every vessel that gets registered has a very high chance of eventually ending up at Fort George. Word travels fast. Our goal is, as the Water Waste Commission, long-term stewardship. The Jacksonville Water Waste Commission has an opportunity to use available legislative processes to recommend appropriate safety boundaries before a preventable tragedy occurs. Protecting the Fort George River serves both immediate safety needs and intergenerational responsibility. Supporting a permanent slow-speed minimum wake zone. It's not a no-wake zone. The proposal is for a slow-speed minimum wake zone. We'll help ensure that future generations of Jacksonville families inherit a safer, more orderly, and well-preserved waterway capable of supporting sustainable recreation for decades to come. And that is the goal, to keep it safe for everybody that goes out there. And not just us, my grandchildren, my kids. I mean, people are going to be going there as long as they can go there. So with that task force report finding, once again, we believe we have a good approach of using the sandbar as a navigational hazard in and of itself. When it's high tide, you can't see it. When it's low tide, you can see it. Even when it's low tide, there's no signage out there to slow boats down from coming in there. That is the most critical time out there as far as safety goes for people disembarked from their vessels and actually enjoying the area. The dangerous time coming in is at high tide, running the ground, striking the sandbars. We see it happen every weekend of every summer. There's not a Saturday or Sunday that any of us have been out there that are regular enjoyers of that area that don't see a boat hit that sandbar. Knock on wood, I haven't seen anybody ejected from a vessel. The next page is the best I can do with Google. I'm just going to be honest. I'm not a surveyor. I'm just a normal guy just like the other two commissioners on the task force. That's a general idea of what we would like to see accomplished slightly west of the Kingsley Dock because that dock is getting beat up pretty good. Now, this won't have anything to do with FWC, but Kingsley Plantation fully supports us. We've got a letter of support from the Department of Interior to do everything we can to accomplish this. They see it. They see it on a daily basis at one of the task force meetings. The superintendent said that on multiple occasions people come from the sandbar to the public dock, which is an important note. That is a public dock. People can at will tie off to it and use it as needed, but they get injuries coming in there. They're not licensed to treat injuries. They can offer Band-Aids, ice bags, but that's about it. They don't make documentation of it because they're not licensed medical providers. Below that is our letter from the Department of Interior. While we're on, before we go down to Kingsley's presentation, as I was driving here, I was on the phone with the commander of the southeast region of the Coast Guard, stationed at a Mayport, Commander William Hickey. They are in full support of this. He's getting with his legal team as we are having this meeting to get the letter drawn up. It's not going to be called a support letter through my extensive research on past permits issued throughout the state of Florida. It is a non-objection letter, and that has been what FWC has accepted on all previous submitted applications. As long as all the other legal stuff was done correctly. I'm also in process of getting that same letter from the U.S. Army Corps engineers. Unfortunately, I have to wait for them to email me back. I don't have any contacts there. But, you know, we want to do it the right way, and every permit issued that I studied and researched had those two letters attached to it. So, maybe Ms. McGillis can confirm this. I believe they have to be on there. Yeah, I'm pretty sure I saw something in a Florida administrative code where you had to have the letter from the Coast Guard and the Army Corps engineers. So, one of those is taken care of. One's hopefully in the works. Only time will tell. So, the next is just a presentation that Kingsley put out to try to get this established, I believe, in 22 or 23. They needed support from the city of Jacksonville for whatever reasons. It didn't happen at the time, but they haven't given up. They still support it. They still need it. They still want it. The picture of their doc is contained on a link within that Department of Interior support letter. It's just a short YouTube video, but if you get a chance, just find that video. It's amazing. It shows the boats coming in, and it actually shows how much motion is in that dock. It's every bit of probably 8 to 12 inches up and down with every boat that passes multiple times. It's not one up, one down. It's constant. Well, it appears to be enough to easily toss somebody off the dock. The other is just was part of the presentation. It's just land erosion, which FWC will not consider at all. It's got to be about public safety, and that's really the reason we'd like to get it. Beyond that Google image map is just some wave data that they've got. Like I said, that won't be enough for FWC to consider it because there's more studies that would have to be supported and submitted with the Kingsley if they would even accept the Kingsley at all. Once again, I'm not a scientist either. I don't know of the methods that they use. One thing I can tell you with studying with what Ms. McGillis has recommended me learning from is Florida Administrative Code, when it comes to FWC issuing these permits, they are not willing to actually issue the permits, contrary to popular belief. In the entire state of Florida, there are 156 of these permits statewide. With that being said, we have a navigational hazard. So I feel strongly that we are a contender for the next permit to be issued, but we just don't know until the legal framework starts to get put together. We've got the data to show it. I believe we have the data to prove it, based on the shifting of the sandbar being the navigational hazard. Just today, I did find some stuff, and Chapter 33 is federal regulation, whereas Administrative Code for Florida Statutes is state. The definition of a navigational hazard means an obstruction usually sunken that presents sufficient danger to navigation so as to require expeditious affirmative action such as marking, removal, redefinition of a designated waterway to provide navigational safety. Definition of obstruction means anything that restricts, endangers, or interferes with navigation. And that is, I'm about to wrap this up, Councilman, I know it's time to get. That's under Title 33, Chapter 1, Subchapter C, Part 64, Subpart A. I think I put a copy around the horn at everybody's station. That's probably what you've been looking at, wondering what it was. On the second page is Title 33, Chapter 1, Subchapter C, Part 64, Subpart D, 64.31, Determination of Hazard to Navigation. Once again, keep in mind this is federal, but it does come into play with the FWC's decisions. We hit Box A, Location of the Obstruction in Relation to the Navigable Channel and Other Navigational Traffic Patterns. We hit Box C, Depth of Water over the Obstruction, Fluctuation of the Water Level and Other Hydraulic Characteristics in the Area. We hit Box E, Physical Characteristics of the Obstruction. We hit Box F, Possible Movement of the Obstruction. And last, we hit Box I, Length of Time that the Obstruction Has Been Existence. So, to wrap things up, it's time to get it in legal hands that are more intelligent than the three commissioners that are on this task force and get the ball rolling on that side. And that's what I would like to request of Chairman Johnson. If he's not here, I can submit it through Vice Chairman Gay. And with that, I'm done. We're wrapped up. All right. Thank you, sir. Oh, one more thing. I would like to go on record thanking the gentleman that came for public comment. I didn't catch his name. I think he was here for something totally unrelated. But if he ever watches this, I do want to thank him for the public support because the public does support this. All right. Thank you. Good bit of information. I appreciate the subcommittee's work on diligently working on that. The next item on our agenda will be the George Crady Bridge update, which I went to our Duval delegation meeting last Friday and shared with them that we as a city cannot take and do request the funding and the restoration of that. That's a state bridge, state fishing pier, and requested the Duval delegation to get on board with us to look at doing the restoration of what we have there, whether incremental or the whole, if we get all the funding. But we've got to get a plan and start moving forward with it, and it's time to get some action and quit all the talking and get moving forward with it. I feel like we've got enough money that from the Duval County side and from the Nassau County side that's being contributed yearly that we can take that money to go ahead and do the study and the analysis to get a plan to move it forward. And without that plan, we're all just talking in circles. And so that's my push right now is to get that action moving forward. So it was pretty well received with the Duval delegation, so we'll see how it goes from there. So I appreciate everyone's support on that. And the other issue that I am working on that's kind of correlating with Commissioner Jones and all out in that same area as the Shad Creek, we did get a reply back from Fish and Wildlife Friday, I believe it was Friday, Friday the 13th, that the legislation did go forward that it increased the no wake or the minimum wake slow speed zone up to 1,000 feet now. There's a criteria that we'll have to meet, and with Brian Burkett and the Parks Department and I think Captain Suber, we can get everybody dialed in to the criteria to establish for the big factor there is that blind curve, that we can get that basically information on that to get it into the FWC and to get the ordinance from the city to FWC. I think we can get that big hazard resolved there because this kind of little back story is when the DOT FDOT redone Shad Creek Bridge, they did not do a navigational study, and when they didn't do the navigational study, nobody paid attention when you had bridge piers that were five feet apart, just speculatively speaking, and now when they redid the bridge, they went to 50 foot apart and went to the higher bridge. It allowed bigger and faster vessels to go through there, and you've got several turns that happen real quick, and the boats, even though we did a 300 foot minimum wake zone, you've still got the ones that don't pay attention to it, but you've got the ones that ramp up and ramp down, and then they take right back off and go right into the blind curve. So I feel like with this legislation now that's been approved with 1,000 feet, we can finally get in there to rectify the problem with Shad Creek. So we'll be diligently working on that. So that will take us to the next item, Commissioner Hardesee on the artificial reefs. Thank you, Chairman. As a quick update, I think I had announced at the last meeting or meeting before that we, or that CCA, Coastal Conservation Association, had received a vessel, 124-foot vessel, by the name of the John James Audubon, and that is going to be sunk. I think I'd made the announcement it was going to be sunk on the 18th as an artificial reef in the Harms-Ledage area. Due to weather constraints, that was postponed. I don't have a new date for us right now, but this reef will be utilizing one of the City of Jacksonville permits that we've all talked about, and it was a fairly seamless transfer to get this vessel. It was originally down in Miami and was scheduled to be deployed down in South Florida. There was some issue regarding the finances or something down there, and we saw this thing available and agreed with the CCA to utilize one of our permits to go ahead and get this thing deployed out at Harms-Ledge, which is a godsend. It's a great little gift at the end of the year. As you know, we sunk the first one the beginning of June, I mean July, I'm sorry, of this year, after many, many years of the city not doing artificial reefs. So we're back in that reef business. We also had a preliminary meeting. I was alerted to it by, quite frankly, Brian Burkett, and was able to make contact with FWC as well as the Florida Department of Transportation. As you know, Commissioner Gay, there is a project where the Browns Creek Bridge will be replaced, and so we don't know the final plans of that right now, but what we do know is that that rubble needs to go somewhere, those old bridge pilings, and that sort of thing. So we have jumped into that process from a standpoint of seeing if it's feasible to collect that, the rubble, concrete rubble, to make yet another artificial reef, and with the volume of concrete that will be available from that project, that bridge demolition could conceivably provide us enough rubble for probably four to six reefs. So it's a tremendous opportunity to build more reefs, and I would imagine that effectively that would be out around 2027, end of 2027, beginning of 2028. All right. Thank you. So with that, appreciate all the work we're doing on the reefs, and it's good to see it moving forward. And if you would, through legislative services or Ms. McGillis, let us know what the new date is, if it comes about before our next meeting. I'd be more than glad to. I also wanted to, if I could, not regarding artificial reef, but a development that occurred, and it's regarding the coal ash. I don't know if the members that are on this commission that were on it several years ago, there was the attempted resolution of asking the city to prevent the importation of this arguably carcinogenic byproduct of burning coal that's being shipped from Puerto Rico to Jacksonville and then loaded onto trucks that's taken up to folks in Georgia and put in a landfill. And I just wanted to let you know that there has been a federal lawsuit that was filed by the Riverkeeper regarding that. In the meantime, it was discovered that Keystone Terminals did not have a solid waste transfer facility permit. And so they have been shut down from importing additional coal ash, this waste, from Puerto Rico. That has been shut down, and they have 45 days to remove the remaining coal ash from that facility. My understanding is that the next process is that the Keystone will come in front of the city council and request a permit be issued for that. And so that's going to be going to the commission. But I will just share with you that this has tremendous impact on our waterways. And so I just wanted to make that announcement that a significant event has happened regarding that. All right. Thank you. So let's go to our next item on the agenda, the St. Johnson River Status Report on Water Quality and Manatees with Dr. Penta. Thank you. There's not that much to report. It's a quiet time of year in terms of manatees. Most of them have left the area. The water temperature is down to about 68 degrees, which is actually a critical temperature for manatees that if they're exposed to that for a long period of time or a short period of time, they go into coal stress and invariably need to be rescued. But now, of course, we have the zoo that can accept those animals if they're rescued over there. You've noticed also recently we've had a lot more rain, particularly south of us, a lot more flooding reported. All that water will be washing into the river and moving through the system for probably several weeks. And that's reflected in the salinity values you see here in this little table on page one. They're normally a little higher than that. But with this increased freshwater input, the salinities are all lower. We do have algae in the river. It's mixed algae and no toxins have been reported. So the last sampling was done at the end of October. And so no problems to report regarding algae in the river. And I suspect that a lot of this fresh water moving through will flush a lot of algae out of the river too. Manatee deaths, we haven't had any manatee deaths for a couple of months now. The last one was in August. So that reflects the fact that there are not many animals around also. In terms of rainfall, we're almost caught up in Jacksonville with what we'd normally expect with the rain data from the International Airport Station. But looking at the lower St. John's River Basin, I mean the St. John's River Basin, the lower basin, we're still at a little bit of a deficit coming out of the drought before all this rain arrived. And with that, I would be happy to take any questions. Thank you. I don't see any speakers in the queue. So that brings us to the end of our agenda. I appreciate everyone's due diligence here and your efforts you put in. And once again, thank you for your service to the city of Jacksonville and to your community. And we are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned. We are adjourned.