Civic › Jacksonville, FL › November 17, 2026

Finance Committee - Nov 17, 2026

Jacksonville, FL City Council November 17, 2026 70 minutes
▶ Watch original video Interactive viewer Search Jacksonville meetings

Transcript

Speaker0:01

all right on that note we're going to go ahead and get started we're going to go ahead and start with introductions to my left with miss norris britney norris for the administration colleen hamsey council research mary stefopolis office of general counsel heather reber council auditor's office philip peterson council auditor good afternoon rockman johnson district 14 the west side afternoon rory diamond and george district 13 the beaches good afternoon chris miller at large group five will lane in district three mike gay district two randy white district 12 ron salem group two at large just visiting thank you all right good afternoon everyone and uh yeah the clock uh it has been wrong for quite a few weeks now so maybe we can get that fixed uh so we're going to go with public comment first and then after that we have a few reports from mr peterson and then council member salem is here for item 35 we're also going to take up item 30 while he's down here and then we'll go in order with the rest of the agenda only one public comment card carnell oliver mr oliver are you out there oh there he is i see him coming down and you'll have two minutes once you get to the podium uh yes my name is carnell oliver address is on file i'm here to speak to bill number 0808 um if this bill's gotta die until we get the framework where economic development actually provides meaningful meaningful resources for black americans so be it because for me right now i'm trying to move pieces around and as i look at our city charter uh article one two i'm sorry one three four five sixteen eighteen twenty one i'm looking for considerations of provisions to be included to create sanctuary policies that are associated with the opportunity zone 2.0 it involves possibly a division within one of the functions of one of our city agencies that focuses on making ensure that the resources that we get from the state and federal level touch the hands of black americans the the laws are there they just the city for some reason doesn't want to enforce the laws on the books it's an uncomfortable feeling to realize that some people fall underneath a different class of rights and those fall underneath a different class but you don't blame somebody like me that wants his 40 acres in a mule what you need to do is is take the responsibility up with joe biden the harsh reality of it all came out and the thing about it is that administration failed to operate in the executive branch in a functional manner now the heavy lifting and the work needs start right here locally we're trying to make amends for a lot of destruction thank you mr oliver mr pussan i'm going to turn over to you to walk us through these reports yes sir through the chair to the committee so um last or actually yesterday uh we released our um annual budget summary report which summarizes uh all the actions or not all the actions but rather uh the activity uh that is included in the approved budget uh that you adopted a little over or like almost two months ago um i do find this as a helpful resource uh for you or your constituents um it includes a lot of the schedules that you saw during the budget hearings updated for final approved numbers a couple of new schedules included in there um summarize solid waste division and the enterprise operations there the approved uh public service grants and cultural service grants after have been awarded by those into uh each each of the agencies i won't walk through the details because you lived this for a good two to three months but it just hits on a lot of the highlights of the adopted budget and happy to answer any questions that you might have thank you mr pearson i had two things to say so i'll say them now since i don't see anyone else in the queue one thing i want to point out on page one of the report you talked about how the total budget was 2.027 billion versus 2.004 billion i just want to point out those are the revenue numbers not the expense numbers so again what we finally approved was essentially a flat year over year budget i think it was 2.04 versus 2.08 correct on the expense side through the chair um so revenues have to equal expenses so that in essence those are the revenues and expense line i believe you're referring to roughly 19 million that was put into a contingency when you back that out you do get to that 2008 number you referenced thank you and then one other thing uh just a question we hardly ever talk about the entire rolled up view of everything including the independent authorities but it looks like i guess we're 30 million less year over year if i'm looking at the schedule on page four correct through the chair that's correct okay so all in the consolidated city of jacksonville did have a slight reduction year over year uh anybody else uh if not next report all right the next report has uh pages that have been placed in front of you this is a high level summary of the impact of amendment three as it relates to the homestead impact uh the chair had indicated during uh budget hearing number one that he didn't want to spend a lot of time on uh the b3 that that's what we reference it that's the schedule within the budget ordinance uh until we got passed um november 3rd now that that has passed and we know that we are going to have an impact from the passing of amendment three uh we've pulled on page one a very high level of what the surplus or lack thereof uh the gap for each of the years included in the b3 document uh and then added on top of that our rough estimates um that we went through back in late may of the impact of amendment three i will point out that at the request of the council president we are currently trying to update these numbers uh for 2026 final values that were released by the property appraiser in early october but early indications are that the 200 million is going to be a pretty close number it may give or take 10 million dollars but i still think the 200 million is a pretty good number to to have these high level conversations so you'll notice that the projections for all the fiscal years presented the four next fiscal years um are well into uh almost 300 million or higher than 300 million on an annual basis um if you flip two pages um well they're labeled 45 and 46 because we pulled these straight out of the budget hearing number one handout there are a lot of assumptions that go into this um things that are taken into account that are not yet finalized one of those being uh raises for the public safety unions they um have a collective bargaining agreement goes through september 30th of this year or sorry of 2027 so that does not yet impact these these years that are uh before you on this page uh we put the budget office put in a three percent increase there uh each one percent relates to about a five million dollar impact um those are unknowns but things that are included in the report that um will probably have to be reanalyzed now with the passing of amendment three um other items to note are uh the pension costs as it relates to the transition to frs still not sure how that's going to play out exactly on the initial years but once all the transition takes place we still do estimate that as we did back when the that agreement was approved uh close to three years ago a full hundred million dollar annual impact um but happy to answer any questions that you might have i just wanted to put this in front of you to know that the next few budget years uh as if we didn't already know are going to be uh tough tough years to go through thank you mr peterson uh yeah and i mean we we pretty much knew that that's what it would look like but again that's representing uh the status quo essentially that if we continue to look like we did this year so we know there's going to be a lot of decisions uh that the administration is going to have to make and then that we will have to approve uh one thing i wanted to say first off i want to acknowledge councilmember boylan for uh for joining us councilmember gay i'm going to finish but one thing i was going to say that i'll call you here um if you go to page 44 this is uh and i've been saying this for the last time it wasn't just the 200 million dollar potential reduction uh but it's kind of the hole we've dug with these completion grants and we've actually made it 12 million dollars worse in two weeks we added three million dollars as an unfunded one percent loan we're not going to get back for 20 years and then we added nine million against this with the the public's vote passing uh 11 to 8 last week so again as these type of things come before us in the next year my train of thought is there's two things right there's going to be a lot of work to get our budget to be balanced within that uh projected reduced revenue but then also we got to make sure we are not making it worse like we've done pretty much two council nights in a row we've added 12 million dollars to these numbers here which i believe are not even factored in yet or maybe they are mr peterson yeah if there's any good news i can bring is that the public's was factored in at 28 million so maybe it got better by 19 million for that single year but your point stands that there are a lot of uh completion grant type items that are coming down the pike that we'll have to account for i'll allow you to say it got less bad not got better uh with that uh councilman gay thank you mr chair uh through the chair mr peterson this uh so the initial 200 200 million that uh we're looking at the shortfall in 27 28 then we go to a 300 million that is not a cumulative that is another 100 million correct so through the chair to councilman gay it's an additional 100 million when you are looking at the 28 29 budget but given that the b3 numbers had property taxes continuing to grow and didn't take into account that first 200 million that individual year expenses will need to go down 377 million when after you've adopted the 27 or after council has adopted the 27 28 budget taking to count that first 200 million the next budget year you'll have to cut another 100 million right another 100 million not another 300 million that's correct and that's the same so the 29 30 we will basically be at the projected 300 million lower at the end of that year that's correct based on what is in state law currently um what but what was factored into the b3 revenue projections had those had no impact so the revenue will go down that 300 million for the 29 30 year you referenced so of the expenses portrayed to you the there will have to be a 300 million dollar reduction now that year over year will get easier as right right that that's that's kind of where i'm going once we flat we flatten out there then we're able to start uh not having to worry about cuts we're worried about uh keeping our budget flat through the chair i i don't want to say we won't have to worry about cuts because i don't know what we don't know how ad alarm is going to react with the homestead exemptions in place and then the five percent cap on non-homesteaded property until we get a our first year under our belt and see how that's going to react i don't necessarily want to say that we won't have to cut in future years because that may be an item but we i don't see us having a 300 million dollar hit that's correct all right thank you like to welcome all the way from district 7 councilman peluso and dr johnson you're recognized thanks so much mr chair thank you for that report uh to mr peterson question do you have any projections on what i know the chair just mentioned uh some of the uh incentives that that came about in previous council meetings do we have any idea of projections on what those um what kind of revenue though just let let's take a look at the the n7 project what kind of tax revenue will that generate through the that's a great question um however n7 is in the downtown area that those revenues stay within the downtown cra so unless something occurs with the cra like what mr diamond mentioned two weeks ago the impact to the general fund is zero it is but i wanted to know specifically and so i'm going to look at the numbers that i have from university of north florida an additional 30 mil excuse me over 30 years uh because i wanted wanted to be understood while i certainly appreciate your vantage mr chair i totally disagree i know you think we're digging ourselves into a hole but we're taking dead property and we're bringing it online and bringing it on the tax rolls to bring additional tax revenue in so according to unf over a 30 year period there would be literally about half a billion dollars in tax revenue generated from the projects downtown only going by what economists are saying and while i certainly am not i have not crunched that those specific data myself i think it's important that we look at all of the variables than just sit and nitpick on certain small things but to say what is the opportunity for the possibility to move our city forward and that's what this does thank you uh mr boylan thank you mr chair through the chair mr peterson i'm a little thick here i apologize um i see what page one that you shared in your handout but i'm confused as by the page numbered 43 just exactly what does that reflect through the chair to councilmore boylan so that is the uh budget office's best estimates as to the revenue in those applicable fiscal years and the expenditures in those applicable fiscal years based on keeping status quo and the items that we know are coming into play it takes into account the 200 anticipated 200 million dollar shortfall in ad valorem taxes on page on the first page page 43 does not that take that into account so because this was developed too okay this was submitted by the mayor in her proposed budget it was revised by finance committee during the first meeting prior to amendment three passing so using that as the assumption so what i'm seeing in on the 20 fyi 28 year or 27 proposed what 28 we are looking at a 278 million dollar shortfall through the chair to councilor boylan to keep everything status quo that is correct okay that's what i'm just trying to understand the differentiation thank you sir thank you mr chair dr salem thank you chair for recognizing me through the chair to mr peterson three questions did i hear you say that pension costs for police and fire frs are not reflected in the b3 is that correct uh through the chair to councilor salem uh that is not correct i apologize if you misunderstood me um they are factored into the best of our knowledge of what we think is going to happen there there's more than likely going to be pluses or minuses ultimately when everyone rolls off of the current pension system the db system of the city it will be a cumulative hundred million dollar annual impact from what we are experiencing currently you made some assumptions like 50 will will join frs and 50 will stay in the existing system or something like that were those your assumptions through the chair to councilor salem so we assumed that all of the dc so defined contribution employees would join frs and then that as the db employees retired they're the people that take their positions would are required to join our frs however there is an opportunity for employees who are currently in the pension system to make the jump over to frs but we did not make that assumption because we don't know what employees are going to do okay that that's that's and raises are factored in for police and fire through the chair to councilor salem a three percent raise was put in even though there's not a collective bargaining agreement in place for each of the years thank you last question you mentioned completion grants are you aware of completion grants that are coming to the council in the next seven or eight months um i'm not aware of any through the chair to councilor salem um next committee cycle there is the uh riverfront plaza pad b and and and you know that's coming out of dia it's a little bit different but i understand your point and other than that one i want to say there's another dia one but i'm drawing a blank i'm not aware of anything that's outside of a cra outside of the cra thank you thank you chair thank you good questions mr mark thank you mr chair for recognizing me i came in on the tail end of the presentation but uh it prompted me to ask a couple of questions to mr peterson through the chair to mr peterson you've been consistent in your assumptions as to uh losses i was curious and you may have touched on it uh property valuations through the property appraiser what assumptions are being made there as to increases for uh 27 28 28 29 so through the charity councilor morrow when looking at page 43 so that's prior to the amendment 3 uh passing there's a five percent assumption in ad valorem growth that tracks back over multiple years if not decades that's a fairly accurate number that ad valorem would grow on an annual basis as it relates to amendment 3 when we uh came up with the 200 million dollar number in late may that was based off of the final values from 2025 because 2026 values were not yet certified by the property appraiser i did mention the council president has asked us to look into updating those numbers so we are in the process of looking through the 2026 final numbers that were certified by the property appraiser in early october but early indication is that 200 million is a pretty good number it may go down a little bit um but it looks to be a fairly for purposes of of a high level discussion it's a pretty good number thank you uh second question through the chair to mr peterson um i i look at the uh economic incentives that that you've provided here uh i don't see uh uf or cia so through the chair to uh council member morrow are you referring to the single page handout yes okay so on that um the uf is near the middle of the page it's uf health and financial tech graduation education center 12 and a half million each year that totals the second 50 million that was approved for uf the first 50 million was approved upon the initial project so that is included in these numbers and then the cia um while we don't have an agreement with the cia an official agreement at this time there is 30 million dollars set aside for a block of property basically from um the main street bridge west to ship or east to shipyards west park that would in my mind be the funding source for any development that occurred on that park which is where the cia is supposedly going to go if they decide to come here thank you uh through the chair i was just given the uh the sheet that you're making reference to so thank you thank you mr chair and mr boylan you recognize then i'll have a comment and then we'll get on future thank you mr jerry just mine is a comment in the context of this process um obviously we've got a very different year ahead of us and many of us won't be here to address it unfortunately too many of members sitting at this council in july august and september the next budget comes will be totally reasonably unfamiliar with this process i'm trying it's a long way of saying what are we going to do now to prepare for that traditionally the mayor proposes and you know we decide but perhaps it's a process that needs to be started sooner rather than later so that we can get some sense of what the next iteration looks like now it may be a different mayor and i understand that but at the same time i don't think we can wait and afford to wait till july 1 and see what the administration whichever administration it is proposes it and then for us to react rather be proactive in this process so any thoughts to perhaps advancing uh some conversations and working with administration and saying what does a proposed budget look like for next year yeah only thing i'll add is the council president the last council meeting said he was going to set up a notice meeting this month i believe to hopefully kick off what we as a council what we want to do to help be part of that and i think that would be wise to do and i hope it's sooner rather than later all right anyone else uh so two things uh in regards to cia mr peterson hit on it we approved the resolution we did not approve the appropriation and so the funding source for that will be this 30 million dollars or i think we're going to have a lot of no votes because as far as i know that is the only funding source out there that could potentially be used if we do go full bore ahead with the culinary institute of america uh the other thing too and again it it passed but i just want to again remind us what we voted on last week uh it's a 75 long-term rev grant that we also got attached to this uh in addition all that money and someone said it's going to go back into a very specific part of jacksonville for every dollar we invest we may get a dollar and 10 cents back there's a lot of sensitivity with that analysis and for that we're paying nine million dollars from 14 other council districts right now forfeiting that cash to have as we navigate what the next couple of years look like so with that we will start i believe at item 30 right nope item 35 so we'll get to item 35 this one mr salem or dr salem's bills i'm 35 20 26 0901 can i get a second on the emergency got motion a second on the emergency miss reber can you explain the emergency through the chair to the committee the nature of the emergency is that the paperwork indicating the city has chosen to opt in with the settlement must be submitted by december 30th known in the key all those in favor of the emergency say aye aye any opposed say nay emergency passes got motion a second on the bill as emergency i'm going to go to committee member diamond first i just want to commend our colleague for doing such a good job on these i always know i i can breeze read it and know that everything's been handled correctly so thanks for all the hard work dr salem well first of all let me recognize tiffany pinkstaff in the audience she's the attorney that is assigned to this as most of you know long-term litigation over the opioid crisis the money comes into the feds it's passed to the states and then it's passed from the states to the individual communities albertson's is the most recent pharmacy to participate in this and this is so we can accept their share um i appreciate the kind words been very involved in this but uh miss pinkstaff does most of the work and uh she should get congratulations as well all right thank you miss pinkstaff and dr salem uh dr salem do we have any idea of the magnitude or the timing of this um i i don't know the amount but i know the money's been accepted and we have to let the state know if we're going to participate which is the reason for the emergency i'll let miss pinkstaff if she knows the dollar amount yes mr chairman i i do not know the dollar amount for this particular settlement but just by way of update um when we started this process back in 2017 we ended up in a settlement with the majority of the defendants for 80 million dollars over 18 years time um to date we have collected approximately 31 million of the 80 million and we also had a a separate settlement with mckenzie in the amount of 675 000 so that's where we stand today we have the remnant defendants um settlement that was um passed i think this summer um and i don't know how much we're going to get from that one and i don't know how much we're going to get from the albertson's one because it all goes through the state the state did all the negotiation all right great no one in the queue open the ballot record your vote thank you miss pinkstaff seven yay zero nays by our actions we have passed 2026 0901 we're now going to get item 30 2026 0885 it's the and can i get a motion on the neighborhoods amendment do i motion a second on the neighborhoods amendment uh miss reber please through the chair to the committee the neighborhoods amendment will remove references to the 10 of the fees to be deposited into the affordable housing special revenue fund it'll include a reporting requirement to provide a report to council after a six month mark and a 12 month mark and then it will include a rebate refund process that will be developed by public works and it'll correct scrivener's errors thank you councilmember boylan are you on the amendment okay you recognize just a question for this rebar there was also an amendment in rules did you mention that as part has that been rolled into this neighborhoods amendment through the chair to councilmember boylan this includes the rules amendment and the ncs uh committee included the rebate refund i just want to make sure you didn't mention specifically i want to make sure it was rolled down uh councilor diamond are you on the amendment you're recognized uh thank you mr chair so the amendment includes this increase of the fee from 20 000 to 40 000 so i'm going to vote no for that purpose or allows it to happen but i would like an amendment to the amendment that requires this to come back to council if there's going to be increase in fees to me that's our job i know councilman uh salem had this amendment it made perfect sense at the time time so i would make that amendment now essentially the same amendment councilman salem did if we've got that mr popolis yeah through the chair and just to make sure i have it correct councilmember diamond to articulate what was discussed yesterday in neighborhoods was that the fee would be twenty thousand dollars and anything above twenty thousand would have to come back to council rather than having that twenty to forty thousand in the bill as proposed correct your intention okay thank you so just so i'm clear councilman diamond you're you have an amendment to the amendment that we're taking for action did anyone did anyone second that i'll second it for discussion well and just to explain i mean our job is to is to literally approve policy related to taxes and fees on the city of jacksonville to allow the doubling of a fee from twenty thousand to forty thousand without any input from us maybe it makes perfect sense but we should have a chance to look at and kick the tires on the doubling of a fee by the the way based on my understanding of this getting into forty thousand dollars is going to make this program irrelevant so i mean i don't like these types of fees generally but to just give the blank check to double it like that and it's not going from fifty bucks to a hundred bucks twenty thousand forty thousand is not insignificant so that's why i made the motion okay we are on the amendment to the amendment i'm going to recognize dr salem and then miss norris thank you chair uh i think councilman diamond captured it that the present bill has anything over forty thousand does come back to the council my concern was uh between twenty and forty presently the the uh the cao can make that approval i think i thought it should come to the council and i think that's the uh the intent of councilman diamond's amendment it did uh it was a very close vote in neighborhoods or very close vote in neighborhoods but it did fail thank you thank you i'm going to call on miss norris and then i got a couple questions on the amendment to the amendment miss norris thank you chair through the chair to the committee um sort of what we spoke to yesterday that range allows us to uh identify exceptional projects that would incur a lot of staff time and therefore staff hours possible consultants to help to help um it would help us regulate projects if we have a crush of projects someone can pay a little bit more and move forward in the line um also the idea of this is to expedite the permitting process to provide a hands-on opportunity for larger projects which we discussed yesterday as well having this go through council anytime we determine a project needs to be over a twenty thousand dollar fee adds time and really kind of defeats the purpose of expediting this work so we are wholly not in favor of this if it's above forty thousand more than happy to come back to council but this range does give us some flexibility and freedom to serve our customers customer gay thank you mr chair uh we uh work through this in rules and and this we had these discussions with miss sickler and all about the uh the twenty thousand and the time that it would take to do a do larger projects uh and i i agree with councilman diamond about just it fluctuating up to forty thousand dollars on a arbitrarily uh here's what we think that it's going to take uh so without really a a pricing matrix it's it's really hard to uh uh approve the to be able to go up to the forty thousand uh but then i'm also concerned about if we have it if it's going to take more than the twenty thousand to go that it's got to come back to council then i see that it uh through the chair to mr diamond would that be on every project then then we're slowing down the the whole process again uh through the chair to councilman gay i think what's lacking here is a structure for or any sort of like uh any sort of way of saying distinguishing between projects right now it could be totally arbitrary all i'm looking for is if you want to get up to forty thousand okay but then it's got to have okay this is the value of the project this is the number of units this is the area of town this is the it needs more what i would my preference would be is that we defer this for two weeks to go ahead and just get that structure in there for how they can get to a higher fee because i don't know any place that just has arbitrary fees of twenty thousand dollars more you could just pick developers you like and say all right you're ten thousand dollars more you've done ten with us before so you're free and the next one's forty grand to me it shouldn't be arbitrary so i i just want that meat in there so and i i agree maybe a a two two week pause uh to look at a deeper dive into it uh but i do know the uh miss sickler and them what they had said it was an incremental charge so at different phases there would be a charge so that would kind of be a a measuring point to evaluate at this point we we we still got to get the rest of this approved then it's going to take this much more uh so maybe with that miss norris if we can uh take that back this information back with miss sickler to try to uh get this dialed in because i am uncomfortable with just the uh being able to go up to forty forty thousand dollars so it i don't know if that would be uh okay with y'all and and the the uh chair to uh defer this that's what i would recommend thank you councillor diamond you were next in the queue did you want to speak again there for now okay i'm gonna go to i'm gonna go to dr johnson for the first time i want to hear a little bit more discussion and i got some questions on my uh by myself that i want to get to get answered before we make a decision to defer so dr johnson for now thank you so much mr chair uh if i may i'd like miss sickler to come up i do want to understand if if this happens though and this committee is saying that we want to push it back for two weeks it seems like that would um i mean we've been work this is something we've been working on for for a while could you bring me up to speed and let me know how this would not just hurt the process that has gone into the progress but also how it could affect the development community with this thank you thank you good afternoon nina sickler public works through the chair to council member johnson so appreciate the opportunity to discuss this the that fee was intended to cover workload um if a large number of permits were to come in uh then we would either have to supplement by overtime or consultants and uh so that that was to provide the ability to respond immediately if we received a rush of say 40 applications at one time in order to continue to meet the needs of the applicants um you know i i would prefer not to defer it because the goal is to get this on the street faster this this has been requested by nefa uh since the since the divisions came to the department um in early last year and so we've been working to get that in place um i would be open of course to discussing whether that range is more reflective of the workload required um i'd even be uh open to thinking about a negative or positive range that is that the that the department has the opportunity to reduce based on the cost of services by say 30 percent or increase by 30 percent in that range without coming to the council um if that's not of interest uh potentially removing this particular range and requiring to come back to council uh would certainly of course be open to to that as well thank you ms sickler mr boylan thank you mr chair chair ms sickler gentlemen yesterday from there who came and spoke to this and said you know time is money and looked at this as in many respects a true cost savings for developers in this process so i i guess the the process so you've got a developer comes to you you take a look at the scope of the work you will give them a number and they can make a determination of whether or not that is an acceptable number of them to to have an expedited process is that fair we expect the vast majority of projects to be the twenty thousand dollars base fee agreed so um if there if a certain project comes in and it's larger or will or there's too many that come in at one time that would be the only time that we would expect to adjust the fee to accommodate that workload so my hesitation in in having to come back to us each and every time let the developer decide whether it's too much money and for them to obviously be able to justify what it is in that process uh secondly and that's why i brought it up in the rules committee we added that six month review process we get a chance to see how this works and get the ball rolling on it and maybe at that point in time if we get a better sense of of what the justification is for the fee whether it's 20 30 or 40 we can take a look at it at that point in time i just hate to see us hold this up because uh we want to again extend the time that these uh larger ones get uh addressed because they have to come through us thank you mr chair thank you i'm gonna ask one of my questions since ms sickler is there given the time of year are we actually delaying anything if we defer this two weeks i mean we're approaching thanksgiving then christmas were you going to start this program before january if it got approved next tuesday night we are uh able to get started we are in the testing phase of the of the um the electronic portion of this and so as soon as we are able to get this uh passed we are in a good position to start so just to clarify there is a difference between us approving this coming tuesday and two weeks from this coming tuesday really it's the development community's um goals and so we would certainly accommodate whatever the the committee decides i just don't know there will be specific benefits to waiting but that's you know that's certainly within your purview okay i'll keep on listening to my colleagues i i would like to bring this to a conclusion one way or another just because i i don't want us to be the ones perceived perceived as slowing things up council member gay thank you uh through the chair to ms sickler what what is the current matrix of pricing the permit fees now it's a very complicated answer uh you mean just overall with all of the permits overall submitting a permit what what what is your matrix now uh so from the building side it's a it's a combination of project value primarily uh and size but this is mainly for the site development this is for both so this this process will allow you allow a developer to get both their civil site as well as building within that 30 days concurrently which is not happening right now right right okay so but what what would be the the normal permitting fee uh that that would be charged so i'll i'll ask chief cabin to talk about the civil side um if that's of interest so that you'll get a sense of scale yeah i just want to be able to kind of draw a parallel to uh what we're doing now as as opposed with with the man hours that we're putting into it and what we'll potentially be doing on the expediting how do we correlate the two matrices uh uh to establish that fee the civil permit is just a flat fee it's uh between seven six seven eight hundred dollars depending on whether it's um subdivision or other type of utility um the building permits get very complicated with the sliding scale but depending on and i don't want to speak for them but it does depend on a lot of different factors right okay i think that's critical you know but looking at a the civil permit being seven hundred dollars and so then we're looking at you know potentially nineteen thousand three hundred dollars more for for the uh uh expedited building permit uh so that that's to me that's a big big big big reach when you look at the number of hours that you would normally have already incorporated into doing a regular permit if i may so the um the cost for this program is based based on the very hands-on uh direct conversations with the design professionals and the developer and the owner so we have a minimum of five meetings mostly virtual but uh that that we get all of those entities together so that there are not multiple revisions and resubmittals that's really the key to this process so we meet with all of those individuals so that there are no questions about the comments and everybody leaves those meetings knowing exactly how to resubmit in five days um typically that's not the case and and there are you know it takes time for them to understand what what any deficiencies are this cuts out all of that and it's those five meetings that make the difference and that adds up to over 110 hours of staff time uh in order to attend all those meetings and prepare for them and so that that's really the time that's involved and we have heard from multiple developers through our coordination meetings with nefba as well as a special committee that we have at the mayor's request and um there have been there's been absolutely no pushback on the dollar amount if you compare it to the cost of one day of revenue for a for a fast food restaurant it um it's about the same scale one day right and i appreciate that so i i guess my my biggest concern on the whole pricing uh structure and that's what i shared with y'all before is that you say it's based on an influx of permits and so really that's that's not uh fair to the developer that's submitting a permit and you've got 10 others that's backlogged you and that they have to pay an additional amount so it's it's somewhat it's not justifiable if i may yeah um the the naming of the program as express lane um for those who are familiar with the roadway express lanes there's you know what's called a capacity pricing and so there is a little bit of that process of needing more resources whether it's overtime whether it's consultants and so the price reflects that capacity requirement so just as by way of explanation of how that was determined all right thank you mr mr peterson you have something to share with the group through the chair just wanted to add that the twenty thousand dollars is on top of all of the other permit fees and when mr gaye referenced the 19 300 they would still pay the 700 700 in that example plus the 20 000 nothing changes with the permit fees civil plans fees it's just the 20 000 is totally additional the 20 000 is just to get into the queue for this express lane essentially okay councilman diamond uh just maybe to move this along because i think it's important discussion but um my issue is is it kills me that we're like we're going to make you pay more because we can't process these fees on an efficient manner but i'll just put that aside my issue is the 20 000 40 000 jump without any criteria so what i could do is i can withdraw my amendment to the amendment but what i like mr chair's language from the administration on what the criteria should be for going from 20 000 25 000 or 30 to 35 or whatever it is just some criteria so that it's not we like this person i mean that can't be it or we this project feels this way just something that's in writing because if there is a problem down the road with one developer feeling like they're not being treated the same then we've got a a record that says look no this this project was bigger this project was whatever we need just some criteria and we could do that next by next tuesday this isn't like super complicated ms sickler is that something maybe in five thousand dollar increments you can put some sort of uh table together that tells us what triggers the increase from 20 to 40 so we know uh that it's not just uh that there's a lot of thought going into what when we're going to potentially double the cost because it seems to be a potential sticking point on being yes on the entire bill so is that something forget tuesday you think by this friday it could be an email to every one of the finance committee what that looks like absolutely and i believe that's completely fair so yes okay so councilman diamond has withdrawn his amendment to the amendment with the understanding by this friday we will get further information emailed to us by public works or someone with the administration council member miller are you on the original amendment now are you on the bill okay let's go ahead uh i have no one else in the queue for the amendment all those in favor of the amendment say aye aye any opposed say nay we have one nay council member diamond the amendment passes can i get a motion on the bill as admitted got motion second on bill as admitted council member miller thank you very much mr chair through the chair i just want to say in general i've been been taken in for two different committee meetings now everyone's input um as i referred to earlier because northeast florida builders association has been so intimately involved with all of this and because um there is a reporting mechanism back to us where we can see how it how things are progressing and see if we need to make any adjustments um i'm going to be supporting this today um and however i will say i spent a lot of time working with leaders talking about the permitting process and about incentive packages when i was with a chamber leadership trip in cincinnati a couple weeks ago um went into great detail on what they do and what they've been doing for 22 years um and and i'm sure it took them a while to get there and i'm sure it's going to take us a while to get there but where they are right now the maximum time for permitting regardless of size or complexity of the development is 15 days max and most of their simple projects are same day walk-in permitting again i know it takes time to get there but i throw that out there as a possible goal long-term goal so we don't have caring costs extensive loan mortgage not mortgage loan caring costs for developers that go right into the cost of the home and they make the homes less affordable um we all have to have that i believe as a as one of our goals so it is possible and i'm happy to link anyone up with those same leaders i met with in cincinnati um to maybe get some best practices for the way forward so i just say that in general as a whole but given what's going on here we we have to take steps and i support uh this is one of those one of those steps even though i don't like it it feels like a workaround for me um to pay extra to get to the front of the line and then it implies others go to the back of the line or go behind you um i don't like that as a as a practice however um again because nefpa has approved it and there's a reporting mechanism back to us i'm going to be supporting this at this time no notes on cue about record your vote and then we're going to be going to items 12 and 46 so we can get the district seven council member back to district by our actions we have passed 20 26 0 8 8 5. uh item 12 which is on page 8 20 26 0 8 4 9. got motion second on the bill i have known in the queue from the ballot record your vote and if you're catching up council members it's item 12 on page 8 it is the use of the district council members cba dollars six days zero nays by our actions we have passed 20 26 0 8 4 9 now we're going all the way to page 46 which is an emergency it's item 20 26 0 9 1 2 can i get a motion got motion second on the emergency miss reber please through the chair to the committee the nature of the emergency is to make funds available to the district as soon as possible knowing the queue all those in favor of the emergency say aye aye any opposed say nay the emergency passes got motion second on the bill as emergency i did have a question on this mr peluso so i believe we made this a taxing district right last year is this just to give the initial seed money from your cba to this district is that correct through the chair that's exactly correct and even when we created the district this was something i had mentioned from the get-go that we would be doing and i appreciate your support okay it is with your district cba dollars so i'll support it known in the queue over the ballot record event jay zero nays our actions we approve 20 26 0 9 1 2. all right back to item 1 20 24 0 9 6 6 this is deferred but it will be an administrative withdrawal on the agenda because it's at the two-year point on tuesday night item 2 2025 0 3 6 1 is also deferred as our items 3 and 4 20 26 0 2 2 7 0 3 2 0 item 5 and 6 are deferred 20 26 0 3 7 7 0 6 7 7 item 7 20 26 0 8 0 8 is deferred item 8 20 26 0 8 0 9 can i get a motion to withdraw got motion second on the withdrawal known in the queue open the ballot record your vote six jay zero nays fire actions we've withdrawn 20 26 0 8 0 9 item 9 20 26 0 8 1 item 10 20 26 0 8 4 7 got motion second known in the queue i did have a number of questions uh so councilmember areas uh was unable to make this i believe it was at the other committees uh but my understanding i just want to fill put on the record all three of these are essentially redesignating what his council strategic initiative from a prior year was there is no new incremental here it's simply a change in how he's using the money that had been designated to him correct through the chair to the chair yes that is correct there's no general fund impact it's just a redistribution of funds okay so the fact that i had to do the same about a year ago with some of mine i will support uh the way he is redistributing what had already been budgeted to this specific council member knowing the queue open the about record your vote six jay zero nays our actions we approve 20 26 0 8 4 7 item 11 20 26 8 4 8 got motion second on the bill no in the queue open the ballot record your vote six jay zero nays our actions we approve 20 26 0 8 4 8 we've taken up item 12 already item 13 20 26 8 50 can i get a motion got motion a second on the amendment i will let everyone read it themselves it's one sentence right there no one in the queue all those in favor the amendment say aye aye any opposed say nay the amendment passes got motion second on the bill as amended i do appreciate mr jeffrey reaching out to us ahead of time to brief us on these bills known the ballot or no one in the queue open the ballot record your vote six jay zero nays fire actions we approve 20 26 8 5 0 item 14 20 26 8 5 1 got motion second on the bill no one in the queue open the ballot record your vote six jay zero nays fire actions we approve 20 26 8 5 1 item 15 20 26 8 5 2 got motion second on the bill no one in the queue open the ballot record your vote 226 0 8 5 2 item 16 20 26 8 5 3 got motion second on the bill known q open the ballot record your vote Six J's, zero nays. By our actions, we approve 2026-853. Item 17, 2026-854. Got a motion, second on the amendment. Another simple one to read in the agenda, so I will not make Ms. Reber do that. I have no one in the queue. All those in favor of the amendment say aye. Aye. Any opposed say nay. Amendment passes. Got a motion, second on the bill as amended. No one in the queue, open the ballot, record your vote. Six J's, zero nays. By our actions, we approve 2026-0854. Item 18, 2026-0856. Got a motion, second on the bill. Just want to point out, I'm actually going to co-sponsor this bill because this is taking extra money we had and it's putting it towards the Multi-Year Programs and Initiatives Fund, which is essentially reducing the cash completion grant deficit that we talked about at the beginning of the meeting. So I do appreciate the administration doing something with this money that helps us in the future. So with that, open the ballot, record your vote. Six J's, zero nays. By our actions, we've passed 2026-854. I'm sorry. It should be 856. It's showing 854 on my display. Do we vote on the right one? We'll give legislative services just a minute here. Okay, we're going to redo the vote here. So we are re-voting on item 18, 2026-0856. So you can open the ballot whenever. Six J's, zero nays. By our actions, we have passed 2026-856. Item 19, 2026-857. Got a motion, second on the bill. I have known the queue. Open the ballot, record your vote. Six J's, zero nays. By our actions, we've passed 2026-857. Item 20, 2026-858 is deferred. Item 21, 2026-861. Got a motion, second on the amendment. This one seems pretty self-explanatory. I have no one in the queue. All those in favor of the amendment say aye. Aye. Anyone opposed say nay. The amendment passes. Got a motion, second on the bill as amended. I'll note that the next two are simply cleanup bills. Open the ballot, record your vote. Six J's, zero nays. By our actions, we have passed 2026-861. Item 22, 2026-0862. Got a motion, second on the amendment. Ms. Reber, can you explain this one? Through the chair to the committee, the amendment will correct the fiscal year of appropriation. It will include an additional fund balance cleanup in the amount of $165,159 and remove a $30,000 appropriation of a transfer in, so this will increase the appropriation amount to $899,000, $899,517.08, and then attach the revised BT for those changes and correct scriveners. And with the amendment, this is still just moving money around within budget lines within the downtown CRA, correct? That is correct. Thank you. No in the queue, all those in favor of the amendment say aye. Aye. Any opposed say nay. Amendment passes. Got a motion, second on the bill as amended. No in the queue, open the ballot, record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. By our actions, we have passed 2026-0863. I'm 23, 2026-0863. Can I get a motion on the amendment? I got a motion, second on the neighborhood's amendment. Can you run through this one with us, Ms. Reber? Through the chair to the committee, the neighborhood's amendment will correct the fiscal year of appropriation. It will remove passive from the bill. It will define seller as 2626 River City Investments, LLC. It will place a corrected purchase and sale agreement on file to remove pages that are not needed. It will include an authorization to amend the CIP and correct scriveners. Thank you. I'd like to recognize our council president, Howland, for joining us. I have no one in the, Councilman Howland, are you in the queue also for the amendment? Well, before we vote, I was just going to say to legislative services, I don't need to vote on this. I'm just here to ask some questions on the bill. Thanks. Okay. Thank you. We have no one in the queue for the amendment. All those in favor of the amendment, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, say nay. The amendment passes. Got a motion, second on the bill as amended. I have some questions. Councilman Howland, you said you had some questions. Do you mind if I ask mine first? Or do you? Okay. So, I don't know if it's for Mr. Joseph or if it's for the auditors, but this fund, so as I understand this fund, it has quite a few million dollars on it. This fund can only be used for the purchase of essentially new park land, correct? Can it be used for operating costs? Like, what are the limits as to what we can use this fund for? Through the chair to the chair, the fund itself says these funds can be used for the acquisition of environmentally sensitive land and the developing of new park lands and recreational amenities and renovating existing park and recreational facilities. Okay. Thank you. And then, I guess, Mr. Joseph, so if this bill is approved, I understand it is, we're adding five parcels to basically replace two parcels. Is there a down-the-road incremental impact to the general fund if we do this? Because my concern is just referencing the budget summary we talked about at the beginning of the meeting. So, parks got $59 million last year or this current year budget. Just the reality is that's not going to be the budget next year. So, I just want to make sure this is not adding incremental costs to our park system before we decide what the reductions are going to be, because all 14 council districts are probably going to have to have decisions made in them. So, I'm just a little weary of approving an increase one place before we kind of know what the overall strategy is going to be on what our park system starts to look like in the future. So, just to make it easy, will this have an increased cost to our general fund if it's approved? Darrell Joseph, Parks Department, through the chair and to the committee, this was a deal that was constructed back in 2019, the purchase of the Classical Academy over off of Forest Street. So, this land, the developer actually paid into the Jacksonville land acquisition account. So, they provided funds that went into that account that we are now using since we've been able to identify funds to replace that land. To answer your question, there will be a minimal cost to maintain the land since we didn't have this in our inventory. The further cost will come when we decide to develop the property into park space. So, okay, thank you. That's great. That's new information for me then. So, this goes back a ways. I just looked at the black and white on this, but I guess there was a deal made, money was deposited in this account, that we would then use it in the future for what we're doing with it now. Yes, sir. Based on code, we removed park land to actually build that charter school. So, this is actually making the code complete by replacing that park with, replacing that land with new park land. Okay. Thank you for that history. Because, again, just, I thought this was, we were purchasing new land for new parks, given everything in front of us. I just want to make sure that we weren't expanding the park system, knowing that it's going to have to get reduced in the future. Council President. Excuse me. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Those were exactly my same questions. And then, I was going to ask further questions about why we need it with, you know, Holly Brooks so close and Mallison Park so close. So, can you explain that again? I joined council in 2022, so it sounds like this was an agreement in 2019. Yes, sir. So, the Jacksonville Classical Academy came to the city back in 2018, 2019. The land was actually sold to the charter school to actually build the school. In return, they deposited funding into the land acquisition account. We were then to go out and find land. We've had several meetings with the community to make sure that we found properties that would actually accommodate the type of park that was previously in that area. So, we have identified that land, and we have a game plan to actually make that into a park that will actually accommodate the needs of the community. Can I, Mr. Chair? Okay. So, the community has weighed in and said they want a, quote-unquote, passive park in that area, despite the two parks that I mentioned being two blocks to the north and four blocks to the west? Due to, Chair, to Council President. So, that was one of the amendments that were made in neighborhoods to remove the passive language. This property will replace what was there, which was an active park space. So, there was basketball courts, a ball field, playground. So, this will be like amenities that were taken away from the community. Okay. And then just one final thought, because I shared the same concern that Mr. Laina did. We're the biggest park system in the lower 48, as I understand, or in the nation. And so, there's probably no reason for us to add parks. There's more reason for us to improve parks. Did you propose to the community that instead of a new park here, that you would consider investing in Hollybrook or Mallison instead? So, through the Chair to the Council President. So, Hollybrook, of course, is in that area, which is less than an acre, a really small park. So, we couldn't put those same amenities on that park space. Mallison is in a totally different neighborhood, and they didn't feel like those amenities would actually be accommodated as far as children being able to walk and use that park space. Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you. No one else in the queue. I'll be a yes on this. I get it just stuck out to me. It looked like we were purchasing new land for more parks, but thanks for the explanation and the history. So, with that, no one in the queue. Open the bow. Record your vote. And I'd like to welcome back Council Member Paluso, who's now leaving already. Six yays, zero nays. Fire actions. We approve 2026-0863. Item 24, 2026-0866. Can I get a motion on amendment? I got a motion to second on the amendment. I will not make Ms. Reber read those two bullet points. We got no one in the queue. All those in favor of the amendment, say aye. Aye. Any opposed to say nay. Amendment passes. Got a motion to second on the bill as amended. No one in the queue. Open the bow. Record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. Fire actions. We pass 2026-0866. Item 25, 2026-0867 is being deferred at the request of Council Member Gaffney. Item 26, 2026-0868. Can I get a motion on the rules amendment? Got a motion to second on the rules amendment. I will let everyone read it there briefly. No one in the queue. All those in favor of the amendment, say aye. Aye. Any opposed to say nay. Amendment passes. Got a motion to second on the bill as amended. No one in the queue. Open the bow. Record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. Fire actions. We approve 2026-0868. 27, 2026-0876. Got a motion to second on the bill. No one in the queue. Open the bow. Record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. Fire actions. We approve 2026-0876. Item 28, 2026-0877. Got a motion to second on the bill. No one in the queue. Open the bow. Record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. Fire actions. We approve 2026-0877. Item 29, 2026-0878. Got a motion to second on the bill. No one in the queue. Open the bow. Record your vote. Six yays, zero nays. Fire actions. We approve 2026-0878. I just want to point out that we just approved pretty quickly three bills. The first of which will be for 95 units, the second of which will be for 180 units, and the third of which will be for 172 units, all of which support affordable housing. Thank you, Mr. Jeffery. Item 30, we have already taken. Yes, that's the one we took up. Item 31, 2026-0886. Got a motion to second on the amendment. This one's pretty important. I'll let everyone read it, but this just basically says the amendment is we will not increase the financial obligations or liability of the city of Jacksonville. No one in the queue on the amendment. All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed, say nay. Amendment passes. Got a motion to second on the bill as amended. No one in the queue. My only comment on this, I think it was taken care of with the amendment yesterday. This money has been budgeted for a while, is my understanding. I believe since 18-19, fiscal year 18-19, and so I just want to make sure it doesn't come back and they say that it's now going to be 200,000 instead of 90,000, so my understanding of the amendment yesterday, they would have to come back to us in the event they cannot get this done with what was already budgeted. So with that, no one in the queue, open the ballot, record your vote. Six J's, zero N's. Fire actions, we have passed 2026-886. I'm 32 and 33, 2026-898, 899 are on second. Item 34, 2026-0900 is on second. We took action on 35, 36, 37, 38 are all on second. 902, 903, 904, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, which are bills 905, 906, 907, 908, 909, 910, 911 are all on second. We took action on 46. Item 47, 48, 49, 50, which are 913, 917, 918, 920 are on second. Item 51, 921 is also on second, which is item 51. Item 52, 922 is also on second. I'm going to go to Dr. Johnson first, then Dr. Salem, and then if any other doctors hop on, I'll recognize them as well. Dr. Johnson. Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. Quick announcement. Thank you for a great meeting. Tomorrow at 11 o'clock, I'm doing a noticed meeting, I hope everyone can attend, about a project called Yes in God's Backyard. It is an extension of a piece of legislation that the state has done that allows religious institutions to unlock some of their property to build affordable housing. So it could go a long way in helping us move into meeting those 2045 comp plan goals to have affordable housing there. I'll do a notice meeting on that tomorrow, 11 a.m. in the Henry Cook room. I hope you can attend. Thank you. Dr. Salem. Very good meeting. Two hours and 10 minutes. Can someone please, for my own sanity with Dr. Salem, just fix the clock before the next meeting? Through the chair to Dr. Salem, I've made a request to public buildings. Chief Roy says he will take care of that, so hopefully sooner than later. If Dr. Salem pays $20,000, will it become the first item they work on? $40,000, and we'll do it right now. We are adjourned.