mosquitoes because they are a threat to public health. There are many mosquito born illnesses that they can pass on to humans and other animals, therefore we want to mitigate their populations and we're only spraying whenever we have justification and that could come from our surveillance data or from our inspectors who go out and are looking at different larval production sites every single day. We don't have a spray schedule because everything we do is based on data that we collect. So it's based on the number of mosquitoes that we find in our traps every day. It's based on what the inspectors are finding out in the field. If they're finding a lot of breeding, they'll obviously treat then, but we don't have a set schedule because everything is based on data that we find. We don't do any individual spray requests. You can always submit a request for spray, a request for a property inspection, or report any standing water that you have around your house and we'll come send out an inspector. They'll come look at that area, see if it's breeding, and then based on the data that they find, we'll see if that area is eligible for treatment, but we don't do treatment based on special events. We're spraying right at sunset because dawn and dusk are the most active times for mosquitoes. So in order for our treatments to be the most effective, we obviously want to treat when the mosquitoes are most active and we're gonna be able to mitigate the population best at those times. Good evening, everyone. If I could have your attention, please. We're gonna start the hearing. If everybody could have a seat, I'd appreciate it. Good evening. If you could please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. Thank you. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Please have a seat. Good evening. I'm gonna welcome you to the November 16th, 2026 zoning hearing master hearing. My name is Susan Finch and I will be presiding as the hearing master over tonight's agenda. Let me start by introducing Ms. Michelle Heinrich. She's with the Development Services Department and she will introduce other staff members that will participate tonight as well as go over any off the agenda changes. Ms. Heinrich. Good evening, Michelle Heinrich, Development Services. We also have on the other side Rick Perez with Development Services Transportation. To my left, Mary Dorman with the County Attorney's Office and to her left, Jillian Massey with the Planning Commission. And we do have one off the agenda item to announce. And that would be agenda page eight, item C five, standard rezoning 26 dash 1580. The applicant has withdrawn this application. All right, thank you. Let me just regarding that application, I saw there was one person signed up virtually Mr. Jerry Khan. Mr. Khan, are you online? Yes, I am. Okay, I just want to make sure that you're aware that this application has been withdrawn completely. Okay, thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you. I appreciate your time. All right, then with that, let me start by going over our hearing procedures. Our hearing today consists of agenda items that require a public hearing by a zoning hearing master. I'll conduct a hearing on each agenda item when we'll file a recommendation within 15 business days following tonight's hearing. Those recommendations are then sent to the Board of County Commissioners who will make the final decision. Our hearing tonight is informal. I'll ask questions related to the scope of direct testimony. I may call and question witnesses as I deem appropriate, and I will decide all questions of procedure. I'll take evidence but will exclude evidence that is irrelevant, immaterial, or unduly repetitious. Evidence may be presented in written form, and all testimony must be under oath. Here's the evidence may be used to supplement or explain other evidence but shall not be sufficient alone to support a finding by me unless it would be admissible over four objections in a civil action. Our order of presentation tonight is as follows. Ms. Heinrich of the Development Services Department will make a brief introduction for each agenda item. Next up is the applicant. The applicant goes first with their team and they have 15 minutes total to make their presentation. We'll then go back to the Development Services staff planner that was assigned the case. They will have five minutes to explain the county's findings. And then the same is true next when we go to the Planning Commission. The Planning Commission also has five minutes to make their findings of consistency with the county's comprehensive plan regarding each application. Then we will turn to proponents, anyone who would like to speak in favor of an application. Everyone combined, 15 minutes. The same is true next when we go to opponents, anyone who would like to speak against an application. Everyone together, 15 minutes. We'll then circle back to the Development Services Department for five minutes to see if they have any changes or comments based on tonight's testimony. And then the last word is had by the applicant. The applicant has five minutes for rebuttal. We have a number of applications tonight where people have signed up to speak both in support and in opposition and that is terrific because that's how this process is supposed to work. So because we have so many, I want to make sure that we keep to this schedule as closely as we can. That 15 minutes both for proponents and opponents. If you have a spokesman, that's often an efficient way of using your time. Otherwise, what we will do is we will ask for a show of hands for those people that want to speak. We have people participating both in the room and we also have people participating virtually. So we'll get a hand count of how many people want to speak and we will divide that 15 minutes as equally as we can. When you do want to make your presentation, if you're going to speak, either in the room or online, start by giving us your name and address for the record. We are recording this hearing and we want to make sure we have your information correct. If you are in the room at the podium and you finish your thoughts, when you are done, if you could see Susan and Lily at the end of the dais, they are with the clerk's office and they are keeping a written log. So see them and sign in with your name, address and the case number to which you spoke. All right. So with that, we will now turn to Ms. Dorman. She's with the County Attorney's Office and she will provide the legal requirements which govern your participation at the Board of County Commissioners meeting. Ms. Dorman. Good evening. Mary Dorman from the County Attorney's Office. Tonight's public hearing is the first step of a two-step rezoning process. This hearing is the time for rezoning applicants and interested parties to present evidence and testimony. Any evidence presented tonight will become part of the complete factual record of each application and no additional evidence can be introduced after the closing of each application. The second step of the rezoning process is a public meeting before the Board of County Commissioners where the Board will make a decision on each application heard tonight. Tonight's applications are scheduled to be heard by the Board at its January 12, 2027 land use meeting unless a different date is stated by staff. When considering applications, the Board will only review the record and the recommendation made by the land use hearing officer for each application. The hearing officer will file a recommendation for each application heard tonight on December 9th, 2026. The Board of County Commissioners has established a policy that directs which rezoning and major modification applications are to be placed on the consent agenda of the Board's land use meeting. The following applications may not be placed on the consent agenda. Applications that propose to add density outside the urban service area. Applications on roadways with a failing level of service. Applications that do not have consistent recommendations of approval. And applications that have had evidence or testimony in opposition provided to the record by non-applicant parties of record either prior to or at tonight's public hearing. The Board will allow testimony by any party of record at its public meeting to consider the land use hearing officer's recommendation for any item on the regular agenda. Testimony by a party of record shall be limited to the record of the proceedings before the land use hearing officer unless additional evidence has been found admissible in accordance with Section 10.03.04D of the Land Development Code. A party of record is an individual who fits into at least one of the following four categories. First, someone who's present tonight and presents testimony or documentary evidence. Second, someone who's been certified by the U.S. Postal Service as having been mailed notice of tonight's hearing. Third, someone who submitted documentary evidence to the master file at least two business days prior to tonight's hearing. Or fourth, someone who submitted documentary evidence by proxy at tonight's hearing. The content of oral argument before the Board shall be limited to the content of the testimony and other evidence submitted verbally or in writing to the land use hearing officer. It's the role of the County Attorney's Office to ensure that only individuals who have met these requirements are allowed to speak before the Board and to ensure that no new evidence or testimony is introduced or allowed at the Board's public meeting. For these reasons, please make sure that all information you wish the Board to consider at its public meeting is entered into tonight's record. Thank you so much. All right. As I mentioned, all testimony must be under oath. So if you plan to speak tonight, if you could please stand and raise your right hand and I'll swear you in. Do you solemnly swear that the testimony you're about to provide is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Thank you so much. Please be seated. All right. With those formalities out of the way, Ms. Heinrich, we are ready to call the first case. Ms. Finch, before we do that, did you want me to go over the other continuances and withdrawals? Is that part of the published agenda? It is. Okay. I didn't think we were doing that anymore. Do we need to? Sometimes we have, but more than happy to just go ahead and get to the first one. I think we'll just go ahead and if you want to know, they're in the front of the agenda and they are published and the only one off the agenda was the withdrawal that we mentioned. So let's proceed with the first item. Sure. Our first application is Item C1, Standard Rezoning 26-0785. This is a rezoning from AR and AS1 to RSC2 with restrictions. It is combined with a comprehensive plan amendment and therefore, instead of the land use meeting, it will be heard on the January 14th CPA public hearing. And Michelle Montabano with Development Services has reviewed this. And will provide staff findings. Sure. Sure. As participants know for Development Services, this was reviewed by staff in accordance with LDC section 10-03-04-H, which states that a rezoning contingent on a comprehensive plan amendment is to be reviewed under the proposed future land use as if it's been approved. All right. Very important. All right. Thank you so much. Is the applicant here? Good evening. I think your microphone is not on. There you go. Perfect. Good evening. Madam here, officer for the record, Michael Brooks, 400 North Tampa Street, Suite 1910 here in downtown 33602. I am here on this evening on behalf of GLH Enterprises, which is Dr. Greg Henderson's, one of his family holding entities. Obviously, we're the Land Use Council. We're going to go through the project team here. Elizabeth Albert from HALF is here as our planner. Todd Amidin is in the audience this evening, as is Michael Yates from Palm Traffic. And we are going to be relatively brief here this evening. The rezoning is essentially for Strawberry Farm on County Road 39 that is south of Lithia Pinecrest. It is in the rural service area. And as Ms. Heinrich just said, there is a pending future land use change. That number is 25-22 that would change the land use from AR to Res 1 on the site. And I want to spend just one slide just to kind of give you a procedural context for how we're here. And you might recognize this would be a slide that we would have showed at the CPA hearing. And so even though we are in the urban, the rural service area, you can see that in this particular area as you go east on Lithia Pinecrest, there's a significant amount of Res 1 that extends largely out to Plant City. There is a significant mix of environmental land, which is the crosshatch land. I know there's a lot of busy lines on there. But the point is, is that much of the land, in fact, as you're going to see, much of the land surrounding the subject farm is Res 1. And I want to, just on that point, for procedural context, we did not initially file a companion rezoning for this CPA. The application was filed when we started looking at the property, which Dr. Henderson bought the first folio in 1982, so 45 years ago. He bought the second parcel of the farm in 1992. In both of those time periods, the land that he bought had a rural residential at that time in 1989, which is a one to one. In 1994, that are the rural residential was changed to Res 1 and it was somewhere in December 1998 in the last year amendment that part of the farm got taken out of the Res as part of a part of a global area wide change. And so, the intent of what we were attempting to do is just put the farm back to Res 1. We weren't proposing a rezoning at that time. At the transmittal hearing, and I'm going to advance one slide before I bring up Ms. Albert. At the transmittal hearing, there was conversation and discussion at the dais about a potential effective date on the future land use approval that would run concurrent with the completion of an intersection improvement, planned intersection improvement in the CIP at County Road 39 in Alethea Pinecrest. And so, this petition, this RSC 2 restricted was a vehicle by which we could then impose conditions to try to satisfy some of the things you're going to hear tonight and the things that we heard from at least the prior board back in February. So, with that, I am going to hand this over to Ms. Albert. I would like to, I've got some documents that I want to put into the record and if I may approach while we're doing a transition, I will drop a copy off for you. Let me, before you leave Mr. Brooks, let me ask you a quick question to make sure I understand the timeline you just explained. So, it's your testimony that since 89 that designation for the comprehensive plan has been rural residential and then sometime in 98 during an EAR update, it was changed to agricultural rural, is that correct? Yes. And so, between 98 and today, what happened with trying to rectify that? Dr. Henderson was not aware that the change had occurred because it, for this most of this entire time, it has been, since he's owned it, it has been farmed. There are no development plans, which is why we weren't proposing that. But he was not aware until as we were looking at, you know, his land holdings that we pointed out that half of this farm has a split land use zone. In current time, that's when he became aware. Yes. I see. Okay. That's my question. To that point, I'm going to, one of the documents I'm going to leave you is our PowerPoint presentation from the CPA. And when you follow that, hopefully you can follow it without the, you know, just based on the slides, and you can see that progression that we dug into and laid out for the board. Understood. Thank you. Good evening. Thank you. It's Abel Albert with HAP 1000 North Ashley Drive, and I am a certified planner. So as you heard from Mr. Brooks, this property has a split future land use. You've got the residential one and agricultural rural here. It's highlighted. I don't know if you can see, but it's sort of like an orange, which is the pending comprehensive plan amendment for, um, for rest to convert it back to the residential one. And it also has similar zoning, which is split from ASC one and AR. So what we have is, uh, as you heard, we're requesting a rezoning for residential single family, um, two with restrictions. And one of the restrictions was to, uh, comply with the underlying, uh, future land use of residential one, which would limit the number of units of one per acre. As well as making sure that the minimum lot size under the rest two is 0.5, but we increase it to 0.75 in order to be more compatible. As you can see with the surrounding development, um, adjacent to us to the north and to the east, uh, to the south or some ag lands and to the southwest is all swift month land. But as you can see, the most of the development adjacent to us is, uh, quite intensely developed. We're also included in condition of approval, addressing this, um, strip of land property owners to the east, uh, in blue outline, have a right of easement over it. And we want to make sure that they're maintain their rights. And therefore we're including a condition to confirm and, uh, make sure that there's going to be no development there. And then there's this, this condition, which Michael Yates is going to go through to explain why we have this condition in the record. Thank you. Thank you. Don't forget to sign in. Good evening. Good evening. Michael Yates with Palm Traffic and I have been sworn. I'm actually, uh, they can pull back up the, uh, presentation. I'm actually going to go to the next slide first. Uh, we did a trip generation comparison so you can see, uh, what the existing land uses would allow from a development standpoint and from the proposed, uh, land use standpoint. And from the staff report, uh, County Road 39 operates at an acceptable level of service today. Um, however, as you will probably hear, uh, through the opposition testimony, uh, there is a intersection deficiency at the intersection of County Road 39 and Lithia Pinecrest. Um, there is a funded CIP project for that. Um, the information up there on the estimated project schedule was taken from their website, from the county's website. Uh, it's been updated a few times. They've removed some of the, uh, timelines from the website, but, uh, I know Public Works is actively working on this. Um, and then so to address the concerns that Mr. Brooks alluded to in his presentation, um, at the request of the board, we have put in restrictions that, um, there are two. That it's condition three of the staff report, uh, that no site development, uh, is permitted to start until the construction of, uh, the intersection improvements. And then there's a second that no CO shall be issued until the intersection is substantially complete. So this is intended to delay the, any development on the project until these intersection improvements are realized. So the roadway operates at a level of service. It's the intersection. There is a school in the southwest corner of the intersection that is causing some operational issues along with some geometry deficiencies at the intersection. Okay. Um, if I could, let me ask you and if we can leave this slide up because I think this is the crux of it, that, uh, restriction three, one and three, two. So in just let's talk dates and this terminology that you're using, right? So the developers, it says 3.1, the developer shall not commence site development permitting of the single family, uh, uses on the property prior to the commencement of construction. Of the interstate of the intersection improvement. So what does that mean? Site development permitting and the commencement of, of construction. What's the date? So we don't have a date. That's part of the problem that we've had with this intersection improvements. Uh, the public works department is working through developing those dates, uh, but they have kept sliding. So we don't have a specific date. Although you can see some estimated dates up there that, uh, you know, it could start as maybe 2030, but we, there are no set dates that have been established as of yet. So what we've done is we've tied it to when they start construction of the intersection, then that gives us time to start site permitting, you know, get through site development, you know, build all the infrastructure, build the roads, and you could start construction of the homes. But then condition 3.2 goes into that we cannot get a CO until the intersection is substantially complete. So, and that's my next question. I'm just trying to nail this down and I understand you don't have all of the information, um, but substantial completion of the intersection improvement. What does that mean? What is that milestone? I, so that is, I think that's going to be kind of up to interpretation when you get to the very end as to the, it being done. But from what I would interpret that is to be that the, the intersection is completed, the geometry is in, they're waiting on final acceptance of the intersection. That could be the holdup, but the intersection is functioning with the capacity to allow the traffic to utilize those lanes. All right. I understand completely the intent of those two restrictions. Um, the, the problem is from an enforcement standpoint, you're at the end, you've permitted and you're waiting for your CEO based on someone at the county to tell you that the intersection improvement is substantially completed. Who tells you that? It, it will be, it will be the county being able to make that determination as to when that is complete. Okay. Probably public works. All right. And so assuming, and I'm not going to hold you to these numbers because you don't know, you're just estimating. I understand. But let's just say that the commencement of construction for the intersection improvement is 2030. How long does it take to build? I, it probably would take a year, maybe a year and a half. All right. Uh, there is some right of way acquisition that, uh, these plans showed me to be acquired. Uh, that is part of that, uh, funding numbers. You can see, uh, the land in there. There's about $2 million of right of way acquisition that needs to. All right. And, and it wasn't your testimony that the project is completely funded. It is completely funded. Through construction. Yeah. And all. Okay. All right. Those are my questions at the moment. Thank you so much. Don't forget to sign in. Thank you. Was that the end of your presentation? Mr. Brooks. I just wanted to add the substantial completion for beneficial use is a test that we have used on, uh, most recently that I know of on the Westlake project. And what that means, at least to the transportation folks, is that the improvements have been done. They're open for the public, but the final certifications and maybe like all the warranty bonds and some of that back end stuff, uh, is not yet done. But the road is open is the key. So it would be fair to say someone could drive through this intersection. That, that is the test. And that would meet your understanding of substantial completion for beneficial use. Yes. Okay. Based on other projects in that same language. All right. Thank you. Isabel Albert, just for the record, and just closing out, um, just to say that the reviewing agencies, um, had no objections. Planning Commission staff, in their staff report, you'll see numerous policies, um, stating, uh, how this was done. Understanding, uh, how this is consistent with a comprehensive plan, as well as development services, finding it, uh, compatible with the surrounding area. And I'm here if you have any questions. Uh, nothing further at this time. I appreciate your time. Thank you. Thank you so much. I appreciate it. Development Services. Good evening. Good evening, Michelle Multimodal Development Services. The applicant is proposing to re-zone approximately 160 acres of property from AS1 and AR to RAC2 with restrictions. The re-zoning is running concurrently with CPA request 2522 to change the AR15th feature on use, uh, portion of the property to RES1. Therefore, our staff's findings are contingent on the CPA approval to RES1. The applicant is proposing to several restrictions to the re-zoning, including restricting the total density of the project to one unit per acre. Also, the minimum lot size shall be restricted to 0.75 acres. The other proposed restrictions relate to permitted vehicle access points and instituting timing thresholds to phase permitting based on improvements to the Pincus Road and County Road 39 intersection. Due to the proposed conditions and subject to approval of CPA 2522, staff finds the rezoning approvable. I'm available if you have any questions. Um, I just had a question, but I see you've submitted revised transportation comments. Yes. So that was my question because it appeared there was an incorrect zoning. Yeah, the chip generation calculations were fixed. All right. And then, Mr. Perez, if you could just verify what the level of service is before and after the project for that segment of, uh, 39. Uh, so our staff report does speak to the current level of service. Um, we do not, uh, evaluate, uh, post level of service at the time of zoning. Um, that would be considered a concurrency review. Ah, understood. All right. Um, but per, per the report, uh, that segment of County Road 39, uh, level of service standards is D and the peak hour directional level of service is D. All right. Thank you for that. I appreciate it. We'll turn to the Planning Commission. Good evening. Uh, Jillian Massey with Planning Commission staff. Uh, the site's located in the rural area and was, is within the limits of the South Shore area-wide systems plan. The request is concurrent with comprehensive plan map amendment HCCPA 25-22, which is a request to change the future land use category of the site from agricultural rural 1-5 to residential 1. Because the resident, because the rezoning is dependent upon the approval of the comprehensive plan amendment, it has been evaluated by Planning Commission staff under the proposed residential 1 future land use designation. which is intended for rural residential uses compatible with short-term agricultural uses. The subject site consists of approximately 160 acres and based on the maximum density of one dwelling unit per gross acre, the site may be considered for a maximum residential development of 160 dwelling units. The site is generally surrounded by the residential 1 category to the west, north, and east, with resident, or with agricultural rural 1-5 to the south, as well as two small parcels located to the north. Future land use section policy 1.2.5 encourages clustering to protect natural resources and to allow for the continuation of agricultural uses. While the request is for a standard rezoning and does not include a site plan, the proposed residential 1 designation allows for future development to be designed in a manner that incorporates clustering and minimizes impacts on natural resources. The environmental and sustainability section also mentions clustering in policy 3.7.5 as a method to minimize impacts on open space, environmental resources, and floodplains. Residential uses are located on all sides of the subject site, making the proposed single-family residential use generally compatible with the established development pattern in the surrounding area. The proposed restriction limiting the overall project density to no more than one dwelling unit per gross acre further supports compatibility with the future land use categories. Future land use section objective 3.1 and its associated policies relate to compatibility. While there is not RSC 2 zoning district directly adjacent to the site, the adjacent ASC 1 and AS 1 districts both permit residential uses. Based on the surrounding zoning and future land use pattern, the ability to cluster in any future land use category, as well as the presence of residential uses in the area, the request is consistent with future land use section objective 3.1 and the associated policies regarding compatibility. The site is within the limits of the South Shore Area-wide Systems Plan. Outlined in the cultural and historical objective of the plan, the community desires to promote sustainable growth and development that is clustered and well-planned to preserve the area's environment, cultural identity, and livability. The proposed rezoning would provide single-family residential development, which will contribute to the area's growth while still preserving the character of the area. And based upon these considerations, the Planning Commission staff finds that the proposed rezoning is consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies of the unincorporated Hillsborough County Comprehensive Plan, subject to the restrictions proposed by the Development Services Department. Thank you so much, I appreciate it. All right, at this time we're going to call for those who would like to speak in support. If you are in the room, if you'd like to speak in support. Mr. Brooks, that's an odd time to talk. Yes, Michael Brooks again. I have been asked to enter into the record. In fact, I have already entered into the record. You say you have it. A letter of support from Nicole Davis. She's an owner to the west of the property. And so you have that letter both at the clerk's and at your desk. Perfect. All right. Thank you so much. I appreciate it. Is there anyone in the room or online that would like to speak in support? All right. Seeing no one. I had one person signed up, a Terry Muse, but I guess she's not here. All right. Then we'll close that section and we'll go to testimony in opposition. How many people would like to speak in opposition? Raise your hand. Okay. So I see three, four. Okay. I have four in the room. Is there anyone online that would like to speak in opposition? Okay. Seeing no one. Then those four people, if you could go ahead and stand up and line up by the podium and we'll do four minutes. Susan, we'll do four minutes a piece to make it fair. Okay. Yes. Oh, all right. So do you all plan to speak? Okay. So how many people total want to speak? Four total, myself included. Okay. But like if you need to- And the gentleman just relinquished his time. So, all right. How about this? How about we- we'll go with four minutes a piece. If you want to- if that's not enough, then we'll let you go over and then we'll figure it out at the end with the other three gentlemen. Thank you, Madam Magistrate. Let me see if my report is here in the record. I did send it. I can. Road 39-101-5. There's Talal. This one? No, that's for Talal Hills. Hold on. Okay. Here. I have a- my apologies, ma'am, here. I have a power thing here with the presentation. Oh, here. Sorry about that. Yeah, if you want to just pull up. It should be there on the- on the drive. Yeah, that one towards you. I hear it should be that one in the future. This first one? No, the power PowerPoint. Okay. That's it. Okay. Madam Magistrate, can you hear me? I can. Okay. I am the principal of Torreya Design and Consulting. We are a private land use firm out of Gainesville, Florida. We're here on behalf of Preserve Rule Lithia. Excuse me, sir. I'll need your address, please. Yes. My address is 129 Southeast 16th Avenue, Apartment M, as in Mike, 204, Gainesville, Florida 32601. Thank you. I'm here today to present on behalf of Preserve Rule Lithia. Again, let's look at the existing conditions of the application. As you see, yes, the applicant did notate that, yes, they have one, two, three, four, five parcels total. Let's see, one, two, three, four, five, six parcels total. One of them being R1, the rest are being AR. So, technically speaking, not half of the farm is R1. It's more like 20% of the farm is R1 and RES1. Again, these are the comp plan policies that we're going to go over today in regards to our internal review of the application and how it stands today. Specifically in policy 1.2.1, within rural areas, density shown in the land use map may be no higher than one dwelling unit per five acres unless located within an area identified of higher density. Again, the parcel that actually has the RES1 density, that one is actually suitable for this, but the rest of the parcels should stick to the one dwelling unit per five gross acres. And, again, the application has not met the associated things and it's not a planned development, it's not an environmental community, it's a rural community and it should adhere to the one to five. Again, policy 2.2.1, each character of the land use category defined by the building type, residential density, functional use, physical composition of the land, the integration of the factors, and the general atmosphere and the character of each thing. Again, this is a fringe parcel, people. This is basically where we have the more higher density of one unit per acre to the north, but then we have one unit per five acres to the south. So, this is kind of where we're in the in-between. That's why we call the word fringe. And, therefore, I believe that the application has not properly addressed this criteria. And, again, like I said, the surrounding parcels are AR. There's two R1 parcels to the north. The R1 designation would create incompatibility, in my opinion, as a land use planner. And, therefore, it should be heavily scrutinized more than what it's been. Objective 2.3, utilize density and intensity requirement to encourage growth in an efficient and predictable pattern throughout the Hillsborough County. Again, this is outside the urban service area. This is an area where there's no centralized water and sewer. Again, you know, the county, to preserve the natural and rural character of this area, should not rush to increase the density tenfold. Again, like I said, there's the adjacent uses. As you see, we have the AR to the north, the two parcels. We have all of the AR to the south. Again, like I said, you see the neighbors, one dwelling unit. Objective 3.1 has a mix of one dwelling unit to the south and one dwelling unit to the north. And, again, like I said, increasing the end densities will create incompatibility. 3.12, gradual transitions. Again, going back to that point about the fringe. In policy 3.1.2 of your comprehensive plan, it actually addresses these kinds of issues. And, so, therefore, we have the 1 to 1 to the north and we have the 1 to 5 to the south. Something in the middle should be addressed on this parcel. That is something that is more wholesome, it is more proactive, and it's good planning practice, and it would actually satisfy policy 3.1.2. And, again, 3.1.3, this is the county's definition of compatibility. And, as you see here, again, I reiterate before, we have R1 to the north and we have AR to the south. Again, bringing that R1 more southern is going to just create incompatibility. Goal 5, with a future land use element, specifically says, provide for a variety of agricultural and rural residential land uses to meet the needs of a diverse population and support sustainable and thriving communities. Again, increasing the density is not, is canonically opposite to providing for thriving and quality rural communities. Again, Hall Creek Preserve. Again, Hall Creek Preserve is just completely, is out of whack when it comes to this area. And, as you see, with them using the justification that this is to the north, this is inconsistent with Goal 5. Objective 5.2, recognizing the continued existence. That's the four minutes, if you want to keep going. Okay. Yeah, fine with me. Again, recognizing that the continued existence of agricultural activities is beneficial. The county will develop coordination with the appropriate entities and economic centers to encourage and expand agricultural activities. Again, again, we know this, that once this, if this future land use change and rezoning comes through, farming activities are going to cease on this property. Okay. Hypothetically, if it was to one to five, you probably still see some little farmlets or what we call ranchettes up in north Florida. Again, here's some of the farms that are around the area. Okay. And again, here's just a, here's just an example of the incompatibility in the area already of the scale. As you see, we've got the massive homes that, I mean, they look like quarter acre, 50 foot wide lots. And then you've got, you've got the little ranch lands that are more at the one acre mark. Again, in policy 2.2, it says each potential use must be evaluated for components of the goals and objectives and policies of the comprehensive plan with the applicable development regulations. And again, so far as we have shown, it's already in violation of these multiple policies. Therefore, it is in violation of 2.2.2. Again, 3.3, water resources. Again, an increase of a density in this area where there's no centralized water and sewer is going to introduce, like I have said before, septic and well. Again, we don't know exactly if this is in a BMAP zone. We have not seen anything. And again, this is not being addressed. And we believe that this is in violation of 3.2.3 and it has not been addressed. Zoning change. Now, as you see, and as you know, the Planning Commission and the applicant have all stated, RSC is nowhere to be found in this area. Therefore, this is considered spot zoning. Spot zoning is illegal in the state of Florida. The pertinent case law I'm going to refer here is Dade County versus Envisionaries Rafa Ma. The applicant attempted to change the zoning from EU1, I think it was, to EUM. And his justification was that it was across the street. Now, as you see, EU1 and EUM in the Dade County zoning code at that time were similar uses. However, though, the Planning Department issued saying that it's spot zoning and that eventually the District Court of Appeals in that case eventually ruled that yes, the right-of-way is considered a demarcation and the Planning Department was within its right to deny that rezoning. And so, with those two things, just because it is RSC and ASC is nearby, there is no RSC in the area. Therefore, this is spot zoning and this application and this rezoning should not be considered. And again, like I've said, I've reiterated, you can see, there is no RSC in the area. Therefore, applying RSC to this would literally create an island or a spot of zoning that only benefits this one landowner. Staff even said right there that it's not compatible with the area. Excuse me, not compatible, my apologies. And then concerning matters that we know, again, policy states encourage early neighborhood-based input and rezoning which require public hearings to facilitate. Madam Magistrate, my clients have told me, because they live in the area and they will attest to this after my hearing, that they haven't seen anything. The applicant hasn't reached out to anybody in the meeting, so I don't even think if a community meeting has been held. In my conclusion, the application is deficient of policy 1.2.1, policy 2.2.1, 3.12, 3.13, goal 5, 3.23, 2.2, 3.1, and the rezoning is considered illegal spot zoning. And again, 5.5 and 5.2, I'm available for any questions. Thank you. Thank you, sir. I appreciate it. Don't forget to sign in. All right. Next, please. Next, please. If we could not clap, it just takes up your time. Yes, sir. Give us your name and address, please. Go ahead and give us your name and address. My name is Terry Muse. I live at 920-0 Welcome Road in Lithia. Mr. Muse, I had you in support. That's why I thought you heard me call your name earlier. Sorry. That's my mistake. So that's a problem. Sorry about that. No problem. All right. Go ahead, sir. Okay. Yeah, I'm here to speak a little about water and wastewater management at the site. I am a retired professional engineer. I practiced about 30 years in Florida and Arkansas in water and wastewater engineering, hazardous waste management, and heavy civil construction. In Florida, seasonal high water table often lie only three to four feet below ground surface. As noted in the referenced article attachment one, septic tanks often sit close together, just inches from groundwater. As you know, we have sandy soils and karst limestone geology in Florida, which encourages rapid transmission of septic discharges through ground into our groundwater. The private well pumping of groundwater will speed up flow rates of discharges from these septic grain fields, thereby reducing much needed residence time to achieve required treatment of the waste. Septic systems will be the method for treating residential and commercial waste from this proposed development. The proposed increased density in this application exacerbates the problem with septic systems. It increases the number of tanks two to three fold compared to the existing land use of AR15. It also increases the number of private wells two to three fold. The increased density of wells and tanks is problematic as water wells will potentially speed up the flow of septic discharges to private wells, thereby adversely affecting people who purchase these homes as well as nearby existing homes. It should also be noted that in October of 25, I believe the County Planning Commission had concerns about this development because it was outside the urban service boundary and would therefore require use of private wells and septic systems for drinking water and wastewater treatment. The one water component of the county's comp plan states minimize adverse impacts of septic tanks. This applicant's proposed changes do not minimize adverse impacts of tanks. Finally, the Basin Management Action Plan for the Alifaya River, and this outline, the BMAP and the star shows the approximate location of the development. As such, it will be required to meet the more stringent requirements for on-site septic treatment disposal systems stipulated in the plan. Quoting from the plan, within all BMAP areas, if central sewer is unavailable, then the owner must install a DEP approved enhanced nutrient reducing OST DDS that achieves at least 65% nitrogen reduction or other waste system that it leaves similar reductions. This requirement will increase the operating the capital cost for homes as well as the operating cost of the homes for folks that buy in this development. I'll note that nitrogen is one of two limiting nutrients which are responsible for the degradation of Florida's fresh and salt water habitats. I, therefore, strongly urge the Board to vote no on this proposed change to the plan and zoning. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Appreciate it. Is there another person that wanted to speak in opposition? All right. While she's coming up, you can- Absolutely. Absolutely. You can enter them in. If you want to come forward, just put your name and address on the record and then you can submit them in. Ma'am, go ahead. Come forward. Good evening. Good evening. My name is Lynn Ryder. I live at 817 Old Welcome Road in Lithia. I just have a short presentation and then I want to put some things into the record. That's all right. Thank you. But I'll need your address, please. 817 Old Welcome Road in Lithia. Thank you. Okay. On an excerpt from the article appearing in the Tampa Bay Times newspaper on November the 1st. I'm sorry. The author was Ben Albritton, a Florida State Senator and the sitting president of the Florida State Senate. Quote, Florida farms protect the wild beauty of the Sunshine State. The land that supports food production also plays a key role providing essential wildlife habitats, recharging the aquifer, and reducing oxygen for us to breathe. If row crops are replaced by rooftops, all that is lost and can never be restored. End quote. In my opinion, those excellent points can be applied to the reasons for opposing this rezoning, although they were not written about this particular rezoning. And I don't know if it's of an interest, but I do have pictures of, it's actually where I live, and it's the rural area that you're looking at. And so we're on 5 acres, 10 acres, 30 acres. We've got wildlife rehabilitation centers, small farms, nothing that speaks to a subdivision like we're talking about across the street from Old Welcome. Thank you. Thank you for your time and coming. You're welcome to, when you sign in, to submit your documents into the record. Sir, before you sit down, if you could just put your name and address on the record, that go with the documents that you submitted. Just on the microphone, just give us your name and address. That's all. My name's Tony Parker, 818 Old Welcome Road, Lithia, Florida. Perfect. Thank you so much. I appreciate it. Great. Seeing no one else that would like to speak in opposition? All right. No one. Okay. Then we'll close that section and we'll go back to development services. Ms. Heinrich, do you have any comments? Nothing further unless you have any questions. My question is for Ms. Massey to tell me, I forgot to ask you the status of the comprehensive plan amendment. The status of the comprehensive plan amendment is that it's still pending. It's a large scale amendment because it's over 50 acres. So it went to a transmittal hearing last year, or no, earlier this year, excuse me. And the board voted to transmit it to the state. And now it's just pending until the rezoning will line up with an adoption hearing. And what is the recommendation of the planning commission on the plan amendment? The planning commission recommended that the plan amendment be found inconsistent. And that was at their October 13th, 2025 public hearing. All right. Thank you so much for that. I appreciate it. All right. Let's see. I think that was the end of my questions for staff. So we'll go back to the applicant who has five minutes for rebuttal. Thank you, madam. Hearing answer, we won't take the full time. I just want to hit a couple of points that were made, not in any particular order. There was a comment about the ROC2 zoning being spot zoning. Interesting argument. I think that it's a statement made without consideration for the conditions that are applicable. And I would ask, we wouldn't think of a plan development in this location being spot zoning. And we shouldn't think of ROC2 restrictive as anything different. There was use of the term fringe. And I'm not really sure if that is a comp plan term or not. But the basis of the applicant's argument, and again, I don't want to get too much into the CPA because it's not an issue here. But the argument for the applicant is that it's limited infill under provisions that do allow limited infill. And so I think maybe there's a misconnection on what our argument is. Two final points. Res one is a rule category under the comprehensive plan. Lastly, there was mention of right to farm statutes. Right to farm statutes protect the owner, farmer in this case. And as I just started this, I made the point that Dr. Henderson has owned this property, portions of the property for 45 years. We have no intention. In fact, we weren't even proposing to zone it because there's no immediate plans to develop it. So a voluntary commitment was made relative to the intersection improvement. We're at least five years probably at least away. And that's a voluntary concession that was made by the developer. I'm going to ask Todd Amidon to come up, the project engineer and address ground water. Good evening. Hey, good evening. Todd Amidon, 8515 Palm River Road, Tampa 33619. Just real briefly talking about the groundwater and the septic systems. The current property as it exists has a swift water use permit that's permitted for 294,500 gallons per day to be extracted from the ground from this property. Just as a comparison for staff's benefit, assuming a maximum of one home per acre, we're talking about 160 acres. The annual average daily use for a home is 300 gallons per day. That equates to 160 lots, 300 gallons per day. 48,000 gallons per day would be extracted for a potable water situation for the homes, which is about 16%, 1 6% of the current permitted, 294,500. And the only comment I have on the septic systems is that is the standard in the rural service area. Thank you. Thank you so much. No. Thank you, ma'am. At this time. Thank you. Appreciate it. All right. Mr. Brooks, is that complete? All right. Thank you then. So the first application, I will go to step 785 and go to the next case. Our next application is item C2, standard rezoning 26-1287. The applicant is requesting a rezone property from ASC1 to RSC9 with restrictions. Logan McCaig has reviewed this for development services and will present staff findings and also for the benefit of anyone in the overflow room. in the overflow room. Now would be the time to come up if you want to speak in regards to standard rezoning 26-1287. You know, Ms. Heinrich, I think I neglected to mention the overflow room at the beginning. Just for the benefit of the audience, there is a room downstairs where the, if you're waiting towards the end of the agenda, if you'd be more comfortable down there to get a seat, and the meeting is televised so you can track it and then come up when it's close to your turn. So thank you for that. I appreciate it. All right. Is the applicant here? Good evening. Good evening. Catherine Coyle, Boggs Engineering, 607 South Alexander Street, Plant City. The applicant property owner is here as well. Mr. Bala is in the audience. Let's see. Please remind me how to fast forward this. Thank you. Oops. The property is located Joe Ebert Road, which is a collector. The land is approximately 5.78 acres, and it is within the urban service area, as you can see on the map in front of you. The land, again, is 5.78 acres. The future land use is currently res 4, which is 4 units per acre. The development potential is a maximum of 23 for this particular lot. The lot does measure 56 feet at the front along Joe Ebert, 231 feet at the rear, and just over 1296 feet long along the western side, which is the longest length. Current zoning is ASC 1, which is a maximum of 1 unit per acre. Development potential is maximum 5 as it currently sits. You'll notice in the surrounding area, on the zoning layer, there's a mixture of zonings are from RSC 3, RSC 2, various PDs, and you can see the lot pattern as well. And again, this is right at the edge of the urban service area. To the west of the interstate is the TSA, the Tampa service area. So this is that ring of the urban service area before you hit rural. I kept the zoning layer on this, but then showed you the aerial underneath just for visual purposes. I've highlighted the four developments surrounding the property that have a mixture of development. Laurel Lakes is a townhome development to the west at Williams. That's A. B is called Oakmont Reserve, which has 134 single family homes, 50 foot minimum lot width, which is also an RSC 9. And that is approximately 600 feet to the northwest. Toulon is immediately to the rear. That's a maximum of 250 single family units in the PD. It's a hundred foot lot width minimum. And it also came with a 6.4 acre park and a middle school site. That was rezone in 1999. And the final one is D Williams Point, 133 single family units to the east on Joe Ebert, 6,000 square foot minimum lot up to 8,400 with a 50 foot minimum lot width. That was rezone in 2020. The roadway and trip generation was cited in the staff report as well, that the roadway is approximately 55 feet in width. It's a collector road, two lane undivided. There is a five foot sidewalk along the roadway, but it is on the south side in front of this property. The peak hour directional level of service is C. The regular level of service is D for the roadway. And one of the restrictions that's being proposed is that instead of the 23 max there, we're limiting to 17 because of the geometry of the site. With 17 single-family homes, the AM peak trips are 17 and the PM peak trips are 19. The overall proposed restrictions, the number one is that it's 17 lots maximum. And then the proposed restrictions for the lot area and dimensions, it's a 7,000 square foot lot, 70 foot width, 35 foot height, 20 foot front setback, seven and a half foot sides and a 20 foot rear with a 40% maximum building coverage. You'll see that how that compares to the standard RSC nine, where we've put in the restrictions for the larger lot area and width and a larger side setback. And it really is due to the geometry of the lot being long and narrow, putting that 50 foot roadway down, the lots become a little bit shallower, so it made sense to make them wider. As far as the comprehensive plan and consistency, given that this is in the urban service area, objective one is that, and this is the growth strategy for the county, that the county shall proactively direct new growth into the urban service area with the goal of at least 80% of the population growth occurring within the USA on the planning horizon. The site does lie within the urban service boundary. The second policy 1.2, and that was objective one, policy 1.2, all new residential land use categories shall have a density of four units per acre or greater, which this one does. It's a res 4. Further, it states within the USA and in categories allowing those, that density of four units per acre, new development shall occur at least 75% of the allowable density unless the development rates criteria of policy 1.3, which we'll get to on the next slide. For reference, it is res 4. The restricted cap puts the proposed density at 2.94 units per acre, which is well below the four, and that's 73.5% of the maximum density when used through the basic calculation. Policy 1.3 further states that new rezoning proposals for residential development of less than 75%, which this is 73.5, it's right at the cusp, of less than, has to meet one of the criteria or should meet one of the criteria below. The first bullet is development at 75% or greater would not be compatible and would adversely impact the existing development pattern within a thousand-foot radius, so it gets much tighter. As I mentioned before, the the let's see, where's the page up? I just need to go up really quick. The development marked B is within 600 feet direct from the property, and that one is Oakmont Reserve. That is an RSC 9 with a 50-foot minimum lot width, and then from there it varies. Toulon to the south are half-acre lots with 100-foot minimum, and then D, down the street, it's out, it's about 1,800 feet away, not quite the thousand. That's where you have another 50-foot minimum lot width. The best approach we could come with this one, restricting to 17, given the geometry of the lot, was to meet somewhere in between, essentially. We didn't want to go down to 50 because that just didn't make sense with the the two that are close by, but then it's a mixture, anywhere from 50 up to 100 for the half-acre, so we fell somewhere in between, and then capping at 17 units. I noted that within a thousand feet there are a mix of single-family and agricultural uses on lots ranging from 50 feet in width, 5,000 square foot minimum area, which was the Oakmont Reserve, to a hundred feet width, half an acre, which is Toulon to the south, and then a hundred foot minimum width, and one acre minimum, which is the northeast and west, because there is AS1 and ASC1 surrounding as well. The proposed restrictions set the minimum lot width at 70 and the minimum lot area at 70 in an effort to limit adverse impacts to surrounding properties, while meeting the county's overall goal and objective of targeting growth within the urban service area. And policy 1.4 I included for compatibility's sake, this is the definition of compatibility, specifically that it doesn't mean it has to be the same as everything else, it just has to fit essentially. It refers to sensitivity of development proposals and maintaining the character of the existing development, and there is a mixture of development pattern in this particular area. In summary, the maximum is capped at 17 versus 23, which is allowed under the rest four. Proposed overall density is 2.94 versus four units per acre. Larger minimum lot width and area and the standard RSC 9, 70 feet versus 50, 7,000 square foot area versus 5,000, and then larger side setbacks as well. Standard is 5 and RSC 9, we're proposing 7.5 to get a little bit more space between the units. As a restricted euclidean rezoning, the development site is subject to the land development regulations at time of subdivision review and permitting. We're not asking for any special deviations or exceptions or variances or waivers. The applicant intends to just simply meet the subdivision code and land development regulations at time of permitting. Planning staff, Planning Commission staff did find it consistent. Development services, they'll go through the report, they request, they found it approvable. There were no other objections from the reviewing agencies. The school board comments came back and there was adequate capacity in all the schools. Therefore, on behalf of the applicant, we do respectfully request your recommendation of approval to the board and I'm available for any questions. My only questions pertain to the surrounding lot sizes and your graphic explained that so I have nothing further. Thank you so much. Thank you, appreciate it. Don't forget to sign in. Development services, good evening. Good evening, Logan McCaig, development services. The applicant is requesting to rezone 5.78 acres from ASC 1 to RSC 9 restricted. Property exists along Joe Ebert Road and that's a notice asked community plant area and the res for future land use. Within the vicinity of the property exists a mixture of zoning from ASC 1 with one acre minimums down to RSC 9 and 5,000 square foot plots among standard zoning as well as half acre lots along PD 990396 to the south and lots varying in size from 6,000 to 8400 square feet along PD 20-0101 to the east of the subject property. Subject property and the immediate surrounding area are all within the urban service area while the rural service area is located to the northeast of the property. Under these consideration staff finds the recommend recommends approval subject to the applicants proposed restrictions maximum of 17 lots, 70 foot width, 7,000 square foot minimums and minimum size yard setback of 7.5 feet available for any questions. None at this time. Thank you so much. Planning Commission. Jillian Massey with Planning Commission staff. The subject site is located within the urban service area and within the limits of the Tonota-Sassa community plan. It's designated as residential 4 and the future land use map. The request is to rezone the site from agricultural single-family conventional 1 to residential single-family conventional 9 with restrictions to allow for single-family detached residential subdivision with a maximum of 17 dwelling units. The proposed restrictions are more stringent than the standard RSC 9 requirements and are intended to maintain compatibility with the surrounding area. Future land use section objective 1.1 directs the majority of the county's anticipated population growth to the urban service area while future land use section objective 2.2 and policy 2.2.1 establish the allowable uses and densities within each future land use category. The residential 4 designation permits residential development at a maximum density of 4 dwelling units per gross acre allowing consideration of up to 23 dwelling units on the subject site. The proposed maximum of 17 dwelling units is below the allowable density and is consistent with the intent of the residential 4 designation. Additionally future land use section objectives 3.1 and 4.4 and associated policies require new development to maintain compatibility with the surrounding uses and provide appropriate transitions in density and intensity. The surrounding area is predominantly characterized by single-family residential uses with some agricultural uses to the west. The proposed single-family residential development is consistent with the established residential character of the area and the larger minimum lot sizes, wider lot widths, increased side yard setbacks, and maximum building coverage restrictions would help maintain compatible compatibility with surrounding properties. Additionally the proposal supports Goals 2 and 4 of the Tonota Sasa Community Plan by maintaining the community's residential character and providing housing compatible with the surrounding properties and based on those considerations Planning Commission staff finds the proposed RSC 9 with restrictions consistent with the goals objectives of the and policies of the unincorporated Hillsborough County comprehensive plan. Thank you so much I appreciate it. All right is there anyone in the room or online that would like to speak and support? Anyone in favor? Seeing no one. Is there anyone who would like to speak in opposition? Let me see how many hands. I see one. All right anybody online? Go ahead and come forward. Anybody online that would like to speak in opposition? All right seeing no one. Good evening if you give us your name and address. My name is Deborah Harrell and I live at 9611 Joe Ebert Road. I own the property that abuts the entire adjacent west side of the proposed development. I chose the property because it has no wetlands or lowlands. It's high and dry and it would have no high density development around me. The site of the proposed project is a small flag lot with a gross buildable area of 231 feet by a 1,023 feet because you can't use the long easement in. It's too narrow. I knew that they could only build four or five homes under the future land use because they could not build home roads sidewalks with the lot size and setbacks of RSC 4 found in the LDC lot requirements. RSC 4 which they're saying they meet requires a 10,000 square foot lot size, 75 foot wide, 25 foot front setback and 25 foot rear. There's no way that they can put 17 homes in utilizing those requirements and that's why they're asking for RSC 9 which is above the future land use. The applicant cannot meet the loan requirements and the planner suggests that it's consistent in the future land use and it's not. It's RSC 9. The future land use is 4 and they cannot meet the set requirements. While the lots don't need to be same, they do need to be compatible and they clearly are not. The comprehensive plan of Hillsborough County is also clear and what is required in a flex from a future land use and the applicant must provide in writing they meet the criteria of 2.24 of the comprehensive plan and they have not on numerous level. The applicant never addressed the inadequacy of the low gravity sewer line that currently per the agency comments is pumped through the city of Temple Terrace and there are currently hydraulic limitations between the two systems and that improvements are needed before there are additional users. The current 12-inch water line has severe capacity issues handling with all the recent growth in the area and local residents have severe pressure issues. These are things that are talked about in the opposition that is lying. It is extensive. There also is a compatibility issue with the adjacent parcel because they are proposing high-density homes 20 feet from a horse pasture with an electric fence to stop a 1,200-pound horse. Manure and broadcast spraying that are normal during my pasture management. Appropriate buffers are needed even if they are not required between ASC 1 and RSC 9 lots. There is a huge safety issue as they have refused to provide a buffer or fence as it is not required between ASC 1 and RSC 9. And the existing equestrian greenbelt agricultural business is a breeding operation. I have mares and foals at their side. Any intrusion into their pasture would be a threat and they would protect the foal by kicking or biting. Kids with a back door 20 feet from cute little foals will not understand the danger of attempting to pet ponies nor the electric fence. In the last year I had to bury two coyotes who entered the pasture and were killed by the mares protecting their foals. There must be a buffer and solid fence to protect the children and pets in this development or there will be injury. There could even be death of a child, definitely from pets. I contacted the agent, Ms. Coyle, and offered to decline all opposition if they would put up a barrier to protect children and they said a fence would be too expensive. Traffic is congested on Joe Ebert and the applicant does not have the road frontage to establish a left-hand turn lane to prevent issues on this county connector road. The development will also fail to meet the Hillsborough County requirement to not change drainage patterns to the detriment of neighboring properties. They do not have the necessary square footage with all these houses on this little narrow lot to have stormwater easements that would be necessary on both the west and the east of this property. There will be no land to absorb the property when you're building homes and streets and sidewalks that will cover all the grass. This is a classic case when someone is focused on profit rather than benefiting the community. In addition, this is not a savvy builder. Mr. Bala tends and tends to build this out himself. He doesn't have the resources to manage a challenging small irregular flag lot and meet all the zoning requirements. I have come to know by personal experience, while Mr. Rafa Bauman put his young son on the deed, he is the one that owns it. He provided the purchase price and he's making all the decision. If you review his prior history, he has never built a house before if you look at all his contractor history. And he also does not have a lot of experience following local zoning laws. He will mow down every tree, including all my grand oaks that bordered the property. If you look at the property he just built two parcels over, he did just that. He was found guilty by the Natural Resources Committee for unpermitted grading and unpermitted removal of all the trees by Palin Dujarante of the Hillsborough County National Resources Department. There's also was numerous code enforcement on Mr. Bala's property for what he's done that has been illegal thus far. I could continue to list all the reasons why this application should be denied, but we don't have the time to go through them all. All of the neighbor properties oppose. Please read the opposition of John Robinson. He's across the street. All these are going to go right into his driveway. He and his wife are both retired officers and have lived there for many years. Kenneth Fallos, he also put in opposition. There's no need for more property. There's tons of available homes for sale at this point. There's no need for her houses right now. Maybe in 2045, but not right now. Royce Branch talked about all the natural wildlife. They didn't even address that this is a wildlife location. All the development has pushed all the wildlife into these areas. There has been enormous opposition for this project, but none supporting it. All of the properties within 600 feet. Actually, the property you referenced was 690 feet, not 600 feet. All the properties within 600 feet are over half acre. They are all existing people who have lived and retired in this area. I am asking for this application to be denied, as it is above the future land use, not compatible with the adjacent landowners, and without appropriate buffers for safety because of the pre-existing agricultural business, children could be harmed. Mr. Bala can make a lot of profit building four or five large homes, and Hillsborough County can provide safe development that is compatible with the comprehensive plan, meets the future land use, and supports existing agricultural uses. This is just a lot of lawsuits waiting to happen. Thank you for coming down. I appreciate it. I have some information for you as well. Absolutely. When you sign in. Oh, is it for me? Okay. If you could please not clap, I'd appreciate it. Is this identical to the information you're going to submit? Okay. When you sign in, if you could submit it to the clerk. Thank you so much. Okay, perfect. All right. Seeing no one else in opposition. Ma'am, we do need you to sign in. Thank you. Is there anyone else in opposition that would like to speak? All right. Seeing no one, we'll close that period and we'll go back to Ms. Heinrich of the Development Services Department. Do you have anything you want to add? I would just add, as the application proposal is, is the density, even though this is an RSC 9 restricted that they are seeking, it would be limited to the future land use, which is four units per acre. Okay. And if you could address the buffering and screening requirements that this property would be subject to, to the west and the east. For a single family, there's no requirement for buffering and screening. Okay. Thank you so much. I appreciate it. All right. Then we will now go back to the applicant who has five minutes for rebuttal. Good evening again. Catherine Coyle for the record. Addressing the comments that were just made as well as the general written comments that were given. Just to reiterate this, it was, it was said over and over again, these are high density residential. This is not high density residential. It's 2.94 units per acre for the site. Well within the four that's allowed under the comp plan. The utilities, whether they're deficient or not, they are part of the subdivision review. They will have to meet the requirements for connection to those water and sewer is located within Joe Ebert Road. This is not a flex under the comp plan provision as was mentioned by the the speaker. So that isn't relevant. I would also add that any violation that he has on another site is also irrelevant to this case. I can only assume that he's learned from that and we'll move forward on this particular one. The property, the Oakmont Reserve, I did say 600. I meant 690 is what I had in my report. Approximately 690. Just to be clear though, as the distance to the northwest, it is still within the thousand feet that's referenced in policy 1.3. Whether it's 690 or 600, it's still within the thousand feet. In speaking to my client, due to the issues with the horses and the potential adverse impact, he is willing to install a solid fence along that side. If that's something that we could propose as a condition tonight. So that would be on the west side. On the west side. And if you would like to suggest the language so that we can add it to that would be acceptable to you. Yes, to install a six foot high solid fence along the entire western property boundary. All right. I mentioned before the schools had capacity according to the school board report. Let's see. Generally speaking here, the, I will say, I don't want to put this in the record too. One of the, one of the objections, because a lot of these objections didn't have, they don't have addresses. They didn't list like where they lived or anything. So I couldn't actually look up much, but I did find one for the Shogun Farms. Because she mentioned the business that it was, it says in the, in the record that, in her letter, that it's just to the south and she's worried about drainage. When you map it out, it's over a mile away to the south, Shogun Farms. And I actually have an aerial that I'll submit for the record with a measurement on it. Um, I think that's pretty much it. Um, as noted before, it's a low density development and the restrictions are for 7,000 square foot lots. It's the 2.94 density, which is considered low density. And we are within the urban service boundary. So I'm available for any additional questions. No more at this time. Thank you so much. I appreciate it. Then with that, we'll close rezoning 26-1287 and go to the next case. Our next application is item C3, standard rezoning 26-1349. The applicant is requesting to rezone property from AS1 to CI with restrictions. This is, um, with a companion comprehensive plan amendment, which is scheduled for the January 14th CPA public hearing. And again, I will note, uh, for this, this was reviewed by development services staff in accordance with LDC section 100304H, which states that the rezoning, when a rezoning is contingent on a CPA, it's re, it is reviewed under the proposed CPA. And Michelle Montobano with development services has reviewed this and will provide, uh, provide staff findings. All right. Thank you so much. Good evening. Good evening, hearing officer Todd Pressman, 200 2nd Avenue South, number 451 in St. Petersburg, Florida. I'm here with, uh, Mr. Magno and his family who are here in the front row, as a property to own the applicant. Uh, zoning staff recommend support. Oh, let me also begin by saying, um, the first slide has an error refers to the comp amendment. We're here, of course, for the zoning. That's my error, but I wanted to put that on the record. Uh, zoning staff recommend support meets locational criteria. Transportation, transportation department has no objection, as well as just about all the other county departments and agencies, EPC, natural resources, all no objections. We're located out near Plant City on State Route 60, specifically at Turkey Creek Road and State Route 60, which we encompass the intersection as shown here. The zoning area, however, is just the central area. The two residential, uh, properties that you see there have been excluded from the zoning and from the land use amendment. So they will remain as is and remain as residential. So the issue is AS1, agricultural single family, one unit breaker to commercial intensive with restrictions. And we have some pretty significant restrictions. And as Ms. Heimrich said, there's a companion comp amendment. So restriction number one is the use would only be open storage of commercial and domestic vehicles, equipment, materials, and an accessory office. So the use under CI is significantly tremendously reduced. Additionally, materials to be clarified materials refer specifically to aggregated materials. In other words, dirt, rocks, crushed stone, sand, and gravel. We're also increasing the buffers from 30 to 40 feet, abutting any single family resident use or zoning. And we've also placed recently, somewhat recently, a cap of eight vehicles permitted on the site at any one time. So looking at the roadways, FDOT traffic count on Turkey Creek is 8,400 a day. State Route 60 is 28,000 vehicles per day. State Route 60 is a state principal arterial roadway. One of the, um, or one of the most intensive roadways in the county. Very importantly, both roadways are designated on the Hillsborough County Truck Route Plan. Both Turkey Creek and State Route 60 are part of the county truck route plan. And Turkey Creek itself is a urban minor arterial as rated under FDOT. Now, importantly, Transportation Department has no objections. They've indicated in their report, as they show here, the difference of trips would be 36 trips, which is very low. Just one in the AM peak and five in the PM peak. And again, very importantly, significant restriction is a maximum of eight vehicles permitted on the site at any one time. So looking at zoning, zoning the site is AS1, as I indicated, and we surround an intensive intersection. We do meet location criteria, which are the standards that determine where certain non-resident use can go and may be considered within predominant residential or agricultural future land use categories. Looking at future lands category is R1. In R1, current comp plan category, typical uses are listed as agricultural farms, neighborhood commercial offices, multi-purpose projects, up to 30,000 square feet or 0.25 FAR. Now, there's a large PQP to the north and PQP uses are very intensive. They're, quote, major existing governmental facilities, churches, hospitals, schools. In this case, it's two particular schools, major recreation, tourist attraction. You also find to the south a lot of future land use category with the EIPs, which are industrial manufacturing processing, alternative energy production, and another large PQP to the south. So looking at the site as a whole. Looking at the intersection specifically for the uses, you have a gas and sea store, shed and sales storage abutting the site, auto repair sales, gas and sea store on the corner. Across the street is vacant, but also open storage of auto parts and service. You can see that's directly across from the site, which looks like this is a zoom in, which is a commercial auto open storage, salvage and repair. And then abutting the site is a Sprint utility facility, a church, and shed sales. Only access would be on state road 60. Very importantly, we do have the support of the abutting residential, which is to the north and abutting residential to the east, as well as one part, which is the church on Turkey Creek. The rest is either utility or the shed sales, which is a commercial activity and commercially zoned. So we believe, we don't believe, but we have good support from the abutting owners who would be the impact or potentially impacted property owners. These letters are in the file. This is two of them. This is the third that we received a little bit ago. As I've indicated, we also increased buffers to 40 feet against any single family to ensure that we're going to provide enough buffer and of course the associated screening. Looking at ground level, this is the shed sales at the corner. You see the one sea store, the second gas and sea store, and then you see the auto sales, auto repair, and the open storage, which you see here. Now we did meet with the community about a week ago. Once we started hearing or seeing that there were some concerns from neighbors, we were able to meet with the neighbors again about a week ago. And I think it's very important that there was a lot of misunderstanding and confusion, certainly unintentional. But when you look at the petition specifically, this petition refers to all the commercial intensive uses, which quote refers to auto body shops, which is the CIU's, contractor yards, heavy outdoor equipment operations. So a lot of people got an unintentional misdirection on this just by looking at petition. One thing we were able to do with the community meeting was try and clarify some of that and make folks a little bit more aware of what's proposed. Also notes on the petition cannot provide the massive environment or visual safety buffers, adverse traffic and safety overlap. But again, transportation department indicates no opposition. We've restricted it to a very, very low trip rate, extremely low. So in regard to those issues, we feel that those have been well addressed. Now zoning department supports requests and they do note that open storage is one of the lesser intensive uses that could be considered under the ally future land use category and exceeds the standard LDC requirement for buffering and screening. The interesting thing is when you look at an agricultural site and what would be permitted compared to what we are proposing is virtually the same thing anyway. Under agriculture, you can do this on the left, but we couldn't do that on the right. You could do this on the left because it's ag oriented, but we couldn't do this on the right. Same thing. We could do this today under agricultural zoning and future land use on the left, but we can't do this. And that example goes on and on. So you can have very heavy equipment operating all day very intensively and trucks coming and going pretty much unlimited. And what we're proposing is tremendously a very, very small fraction of that element. I will mention regard to petitions, which have great respect for the residents. In fact, we met with them. They were very nice. We had a really good discussion. The great majority of petition petition signers are over on Farkas Road and some on Turkey Creek, which is quite a long distance away from the site. We would submit to you that they're not really impacted by the use as proposed in that respect. So in summary, you have zoning staff support, the Buddy Neighbor support, Kind Transportation, EPC. Most other agencies, departments have no objection. Meets comp plan locational criteria. State Road 60 and Turkey Creek are on the truck route plan. And we are including far reaching serious restrictions, met with the neighbors to try and clarify issues. And we feel that we've tried to make every effort that we can to make this a site that works under other restrictions on the proposals. Happy to answer any questions you might have. I do. The proposed restriction clarifies what vehicles mean. It says commercial and domestic vehicles, and you've committed in the two restrictions down that there will only be eight of those at any one time. That's correct. Are there any employees, staff, any structures on the property that someone would drive to? No, it would be just for the use of the property owner. There is a, under the use, there is noted an accessory office, just a small office for simple, infrequent managerial or type type issues. But that would be only considered to be the only structure at the time. But let me ask Milo. That's pretty much. Yes. Yeah. So Milo is answering. Mr. Magno is answering. That's correct. Okay. And then the first restriction also clarifies what materials means, fabricated materials, dirt, rocks, crushed stone, stone. So I understand that. The third thing is not clarified in terms of the permitted uses. And that is, it states that you are allowed, if this were to be approved, the open storage of equipment. What does equipment mean? I mean the first restriction. Okay, you're looking at... The first restriction permitted uses shall be restricted to the open storage of vehicles, materials, and equipment. And you've defined vehicles and materials, but not equipment. Equipment would be any type of commercial equipment. It's very... That would be very broad, but primarily it would be for trucks is the potential use. But there is from time to time a piece of equipment or two. Is that correct, Mr. Megan? You have to come up on the record and give us your name and address, please. Yes. Yes. My name is Magno Mello. The address is 5302 Turkey Creek Road, Plant City, Florida. I'm the property owner and an applicant. What it means with equipment is a loader or skid tier to load up the trucks. Thank you, sir. I appreciate it. If you could sign in with the clerk's office. So Mr. Pressman, if you're going to limit how many vehicles to eight, would you not then limit the equipment? Because that could be perhaps objectionable in an open storage capacity. I'm sure that's the case, Mr. Magno. So it would be eight vehicles or eight pieces of equipment. Eight would be the total number of... You'll need to speak on the record. Yeah. Yes. It would be total of eight with that equipment and the skid tier. So if someone were to come out, they could count total cars and equipment and the sum of those would not be more than eight. Is that correct? Correct. Correct. Okay. All right. Thank you for that clarification. That was my only question. Thank you. Thank you. Appreciate it. All right. We will go to development services. Mr. Melton on Development Services. The applicant is requested to zone approximately 4.2 acres of property from AS1 to CI with restrictions. The rezoning is running concurrently with CPA request 2532 to change the property's future land use designation from Res1 to LI. The applicant agreed to exclude the two homes currently existing on the parcel from the rezoning. These two homes will stay zoned AS1. Prior to any commercial development, the parcel must be subdivided to split the residential lots into their own parcels. The applicant is proposing to restrict the rezoning to only the open source of domestic vehicles, materials such as dirt, rocks, stone, and equipment with an associated office. The applicant is also proposing to increase the buffer area to 40 feet adjacent to residential uses. Staff finds the restricted use to be one of the least intensive uses permitted in the LI future land use. Therefore contingent on approval of CPA 2532, staff finds the rezoning approvable. Melville, if you have any questions. Just one, just following up on my question, Mr. Pressman. He and his client agreed that the number three, the restriction number three, would not only mean a maximum of eight vehicles, but vehicles and equipment is what I believe he just agreed to. So that restriction would need to be. We could advise that. Thank you. Appreciate it. That was my only question. Thank you so much. Planning Commission. Jillian Massey, Planning Commission staff. The site is located within the rural area and is not located within the boundaries of an adopted community plan area. The request is concurrent with comprehensive plan map amendment HCCPA 25-32, which is a request to change the future land use category of the site to light industrial. The applicant is requesting a rezoning from AS1 to CI restricted to allow open storage of vehicles, materials, and equipment. Because the rezoning is dependent upon the approval of the comprehensive plan amendment, it has been evaluated by Planning Commission staff under the proposed light industrial designation. While the proposed light industrial designation would allow consideration of industrial uses and a maximum intensity of 0.75 floor area ratio, the proposed commercial intensive zoning district must also be evaluated for compatibility with the surrounding development pattern. Future land use section objective 1.2 seeks to preserve and support long-term agricultural activities, large lot rural development, residential red development, and undeveloped natural areas within the rural area. While future land use section objective 3.1 and its associated policies require new development to maintain compatibility with the surrounding uses. Although the proposed light industrial designation would allow for consideration of industrial uses, the surrounding area is predominantly characterized by larger lot single-family residential development with residential properties located to the north, east, and west. While heavy commercial uses do exist south of State Road 60, these uses do not establish a compatible development pattern for the subject site, particularly given its immediate proximity to residential properties. Future land use section policy 2.2.1 states that not all of the potential uses are routinely acceptable anywhere within that land use category. So although allowed by the category, the proposed commercial intensive use causes compatibility concerns for staff. Future land use section objective 4.4 and policy 4.4.1 further require development to be integrated with the surrounding neighborhood through appropriate transitions in intensity and mitigation of potential adverse impacts. The proposed CI zoning district would introduce a more intensive commercial use directly adjacent to established residential properties and would not provide an appropriate transition between the existing residential development and proposed commercial intensity. Although the applicant has proposed increasing the buffer width from 30 to 40 feet along the property boundaries adjacent to residential uses, the additional buffering does not sufficiently address the underlying compatibility concerns associated with the proposed zoning district. Furthermore, the Euclidean rezoning process does not require a site plan review or conditions of approval, limiting the ability to evaluate and address site-specific compatibility considerations such as building placement, orientation, orientation setbacks and overall site design. The proposed restrictions limiting the permitted uses to open storage of vehicles, materials and equipment along with office uses do not sufficiently mitigate the incompatibility associated with introducing CI zoning into an area predominantly characterized by residential development. And based on those considerations, Planning Commission staff finds that the proposed CIR zoning is inconsistent with the goals, objectives and policies of the unincorporated Hillsborough County comprehensive plan. Thank you so much. I'll ask you what the status of the comprehensive plan amendment is. So that was one thing I wanted to clear up for the record is that this actually hasn't been heard by the Planning Commission yet. This is an application. The plan amendment has been continued. Due to what the applicant was stating was he had to remove some of the acreage where the residential pieces are. So he's continued to our October cycle, which would mean that this application would be heard by the Planning Commission in January and then likely go to the board sometime in February or another month after that. And so the Planning Commission themselves has not voted on this plan amendment. Not on the plan amendment. Is there a recommendation from staff on the plan amendment? Not at this time. Okay. Thank you so much. I appreciate it. All right, then now we'll turn to anyone who would like to speak in favor. Is there anyone in support either in the room or online? Seeing no one. And now we'll go to opposition. How many people would like to speak in opposition? Let me see. So three, four, four in the room. Is there anyone online that would like to speak in opposition? I had one person, Jim Fortenberry. Are you in the room? Oh, okay. Perfect. All right. So we'll do four minutes apiece. Susan, if you could, if you could all, it speeds up the process of you all go ahead and stand up and wait your turn goes a little faster. And whoever would like to start is welcome to. Thank you. Good evening. Hi, good evening. My name is Jana Lee Jones. I live at 5108 Turkey Creek Road, Plant City. I am in opposition or request denial for zoning application number 26 dash 134. I am in opposition or request denial for zoning application number 26 dash 134. My name is Jana Lee Jones. I live at 5108 Turkey Creek Road, Plant City. I am in opposition and request denial for zoning application number 26-1349. Before you make your recommendation tonight, look beyond the property lines and think about the mother driving her children to school, a teenager driving alone for the first time in our area, or grandparents waiting for their children, grandchildren at the four surrounding schools next to this. There are families who call Turkey Creek home and not a business. We respect property rights, but those rights must be balanced with the safety of the people who already live there. A business can relocate and a life cannot be returned. This property has been residential and agricultural for decades, homes surrounded on all sides. School property is to the north and a church is adjacent to the south. The zoning was known, the zoning request was known at the time of his purchase. It was not bought to live in or to farm as consistent with everything around them. The intent was the out, from the outset was to rezone it to have large trucks rather than buy already zoned commercial property a few miles north in an industrial park because of most likely the cost associated to it. He bring, the Mr. Pressman brought up the information and the information on the slides breaks down. The documented serious accidents and fatalities, including a 2026 double fatality at a red light stopped right at that intersection. The right turn lane and solid white line raised questions about safe truck turning. Large vehicles cannot safely use the current infrastructure and no traffic impact analysis was provided to support this. If you can look to the parts where he has designated the current shed company that's there, there's no entrance for him to the east of that and to the west of the current property that's there on the south side that abuts Highway 60, there's no entrance for him. So he would have to make an entrance there. And they would also go along with the proposed buffers that he says that he's implementing. The only surrounding people that approved it are the people that sold him that property, Mr. Jones, who also is affiliated with the Jones Church that is the other church that supports him. Nobody surrounding in the common areas, north, south, east, or west supports this business. There is no access, going back to this, there is no access northbound, southbound, or eastbound. The only proposed access is at a right turn lane on westbound Highway 60. So when you pull westbound, you have to turn north onto Turkey Creek and his house is like a half a block up. And that's where he's saying, that's the only current access point for this. Also, there's no infrastructure built for a turn lane because the trucks are gonna have to come eastbound on Highway 60 to then, there's no turn, U-turn area. And those trucks at that size don't have DOT approval to do U-turns to turn into his property. Then you take the traffic coming westbound from State Road 39, and that's the same issue as being the infrastructure to be able to turn into that. The trucks would have to come through small neighborhood roads or make a U-turn on busy Highway 60. On an exit, they would be forced onto high volume Turkey Creek Road or make dangerous maneuvers at that intersection, and that is not a safe plan. The consultant just said that the use is tremendously reduced, and points to a transportation note of 36 additional trips. That figure is not based on a sign sealed and delivered analysis of commercial truck turning movements, the existing right-turn lane geometry, or school arrival and dismissal periods. No such study has been provided. Will you relinquish your time? Yes. Okay, thank you for that. I appreciate it. Do she need to give her name? No, go ahead, and we'll get to you. You're going to speak next, right? Okay, perfect. The existing right-turn, oh, I'm sorry. No such study has been provided. An eight-truck limit that is non-enforceable is only on a simultaneously on-site cap. It does not limit daily trips. He also states that the access will only be from State Road 60. The practical geometry of a right-turn lane and solid white line does not safely accommodate large trucks and neighbors that have raised Turkey Creek Road access will be needed for the operation to function. That conflict has not been resolved. The proposal has already grown from three to eight trucks, and a pinky swear promise to keep it at eight trucks at any one point in time. There is no limit on daily trips, and no guarantee access stays limited to Highway 60. Once operation starts, further changes can be requested, and there is no lasting restrictions on future owners. When asked what equipment is, he just said that is very broad term. Well, what is equipment? At the application's Gibsonton Drive, which he attempted to do the same thing, at 6911 Gibsonton Drive, he came before the Zoning Board and requested the same request, and he was denied. He did not follow code, he was restricted by code enforcement, and a 2021 rezoning request was denied, seven to zero for incompatibility and comprehensive plan inconsistencies, which is the same thing that the zoning, or the planning has already mentioned. Staff noted work had already started at the time. This just shows a tactic and behavior that is what financially is beneficial for him and his business and not the community. He has several properties within Hillsborough County, and I can bring those up. I am gonna bring this next slide up, I apologize. This is talking about zoning and conditions in the area, and these slides show what small amount of rain the beginning of last week did to the culverts in the area. This next portion talks about the schools and where the schools are plotted on the map. The very north side is Walden Lake, then you have Robinson Elementary, Turkey Creek Middle School, and at the south is Durant High School. That all plays into safety-based issues with the trucks and approximately 2,000 students with no designated sidewalks for safety. This thing goes into his request at his property, was request to turn an ASC1 to CG on 1.24 acres in a residential area. The zoning hearing master recommended denial on February 15th, 2021. Board of County Commissioners denied 7-0 on April 13th, 2021. The findings are incompatible with surrounding use of zonings and inconsistent with a comprehensive plan. Staff noted Ariel's already showed large truck parking. He's doing the same thing there, here. He just feels as though we're old country folk and we're just going to let it pass. And it's absolutely unfair and inconsistent, and it's a safety-based issue for our community. What he's doing is all for financial benefit for him and his business. He purchased this house and in February of this year, he immediately opened a business on SunBiz for this storage and shed. It also goes into the things that he says that he's going to store on the property, go into materials. But what about the vehicles and equipment that will be stored? All trucks, no matter how new they are or not, leak oil. They leak antifreeze, transmission fluid, and other chemicals which he'll be bringing on that property. Brake fluid. It can take one ounce of brake fluid to contaminate up to 10,000 gallons of water. We're all on private wells from the same source. So he could potentially be infecting all of our well waters in the area. He does not have a plan set up that is strategic and is conducive to our community. It only benefits him. That's it. Thank you so much. You're welcome to submit your documents into the record. Who is next? Do you want to come give your name and address for the record? Good evening. Hi. Good evening. My name is Tonya Anderson Scott. I live at 5206 Turkey Creek Road and have lived there for 30 years. It's three houses down from the address that we're talking about. All right. I'm going to submit mine for the record. Perfect. Thank you for coming down. I appreciate it. Yes, ma'am. Are you next? Good evening. I will continue to see you on the phone at 5108 Turkey Creek Road, Plant City, Florida. I'm opposing this and I'm adding to a couple of things that have been previously stated. The public water sewers is available for the property nowhere near him. There's also one tablespoon of antifreeze will destroy up to 10,000 gallons of drinking water. turkey creek watershed is right where he is going to be his business also he had made a comment about his skid row okay that means not just the storing of the rock and the sand that means that he can actually bid to tear up the asphalt of a road and store that asphalt at his place if he is approved of that because he will be as a business that asphalt contains oils of all kinds and antifreeze which in turn can sit there and leak into our very concerning water table the over the noises and so forth will be unbearable the beeping and so forth and actually how many vehicles will he have there and the size there's three different size of dump trucks and he had stated at one time he will be using the three he's also stated at a meeting that we had and also in an email that y'all have already approved him this is just formality thank you thank you for your time yes sir good evening good evening my name is Jim Fortenberry and I live on Farkas Road one-third of a mile from the property in question as the noise flies on turkey creek road near highway 60 a house with adjoining property was purchased it's a residential neighborhood it's his own residential agriculture and to the south of it there are homes to the north of it is homes property and school property there are farms land to the west of it and homes to the east there's a small church adjacent to it on its south side the property zoned residential agriculture and this was known at the time of the purchase if this proposal were approved but the applicant was not satisfied with the zoning today why would he not be so dissatisfied again and come back next year and request a different zoning in a different type of use it's zoned residential but the home was not purchased to be a residence it's a zoned agricultural but the property was not zoned to be purchased to be farmed the purchase was made from outside the area an attorney was retained from outside the county there was no intent ever to live on this property or raise crops or livestock here rather than purchase a suitable property already zoned commercial industrial a mere three to four miles north on the same road the intent from the outset was to purchase this piece of residential agricultural property and petition the county to rezone it in order to bring large trucks in and out of the property with neither regard nor respect to the residences access in and out environmental impact on the water traffic volume traffic safety impact on local schools etc for these large trucks there is no access to this property northbound there's no access to the property southbound there's no access to this property eastbound the only access into this property for these trucks according to the proposal being submitted is for them to position themselves westbound on highway 60 in a turn only lane to line themselves to get up into this specific turn lane means they have either come in from highway 39 or they have driven through us on a small road through a residential neighborhood on Calhoun Road or on Mud Lake Road small roads trying to support these large trucks or they went eastbound past the entrance and made a u-turn on highway 60 to get in there upon exit these trucks will once again be in the right turn only lane westbound on highway 60 by default they will be either taking an immediate right to go north on turkey creek road or they will merge into westbound highway 60 which is a high volume traffic they can only go north or west unless they cut across multiple lanes of traffic to go south or make a dangerous u-turn at the busy highway 60 and turkey creek intersection these trucks have limited access to the property and the proposal presented to the attorney is that they will only enter by the attorney will is that they will only enter and exit from that access point on highway 60 but fencing lighting and buildings will introduce irreversible impact on the property and its surroundings add to this the impact of the trucks themselves the fluids they will leak in to the ground and whatever materials they bring in and out or just bringing in and leaving as well as tires batteries and other mechanical parts this request right now says it's just involving it was presented to us that the community last week has three trucks now it's eight trucks so it's already doubled in less than a week before it even got to the hearing but if this were approved there would be no restriction on the number of trucks really that this would not give this would not introduce any restriction on the number of trucks it doesn't have to stop at three or eight large dump trucks could turn into semis more than just eight even there are no restrictions on what materials are being brought onto the property or what's being done on the property and so I think at a certain point they come back and say we have to have access from highway 60 is that it that's it unless this gentleman okay perfect go ahead sir an aerial photo from 2025 of the applicant's current property in gibson drive shows only two over 20 semi trailers and numerous structures the property on turkey creek road is not zoned for this type of traffic nor should it be it cannot support it case number l two four eight four one five is a case from september twenty twenty four where the hillsborough county code enforcement had to hear a case regarding unpermitted disposal of fill material code enforcement in this residential area is already stretched beyond capacity and so when this goes from the proposed use there's not going to be any fix in it there's not going to be able to bring it back I don't think anybody going to come back and say what you're doing isn't going to work you're going to have to close that down there's just not going to be any going back I don't think there's probably going to be any plan to expand code enforcement as part of a prerequisite for considering this zoning change we the neighborhood cannot enforce code compliance the the applicant has already demonstrated disregard for code and if the county doesn't have the resources to enforce compliance we would not want to see this approved this property is completely unsuitable for bringing large trucks in and out for the numerous stated reasons fortunately for the applicant the industrial park is just a few short miles north providing an ideal location for an enterprise of this nature as strongly as possible we respectfully urge the county to dismiss this rezoning proposal and take all steps necessary to protect this property and this neighborhood from this intent thank you sir I appreciate it all right seeing no one else did you want to put your name and address on the record I know you relinquish your time but you're more than welcome to retain your party record status sir if you just put it on the record on the microphone just your name and address that's it William Thornton 606 southern graceway plant city for Florida 33567 thank you so much and go ahead and sign in thank you all right seeing no one else in opposition we'll go back to development services miss Heinrich did you have anything you wanted to add I would only add I know we have the CPA date listed on our staff report is January 14th that for any reason that has to continue it would be publicly known either prior to or at that meeting and of course if there's any questions they can always give our office a call for any confirmation all right thank you I did have one question regarding the development services recommendation I see the land development code has a provision that if there is a pending plan amendment that you review the zoning matter as if the comprehensive plan amendment had been approved and so the plan amendment is to change this to light industrial and so the plenty commission has decided and they have that they're under the same policy to review it as if the plan amendment passed but we have differing so miss Heinrich can you elaborate on the decision is it the restriction does your support of this way more on the restriction to it's only for the open storage and not every CI use that is permitted under the code is that the overriding factor to that sways the staff to support it yes that's that would be accurate the CI just with no restrictions would allow very intense uses auto body repair shops junkyards other types of uses and being as the applicant regulated this to this specific use with the restrictions that he put in place also increasing the buffering from any residential that's what resulted in addition to the staff policy to our recommendation of approval and what do you say to the last gentleman's testimony regarding the enforceability of restriction number three that it it is would be a code enforcement a maximum number of vehicles a maximum number of pieces of equipment is not something code enforcement is going out and this is my question is it not they're not going out and looking at it it's based on a complaint called into them and then they have to go out and count at any one point if there's more than eight vehicles and pieces of equipment is that correct correct yeah they are complaint driven rather than going out and surveying areas and you know we do in the restrictions want to put parameters that make it straightforward for code enforcement to be able to look at that and easily say if they're in or out of compliance and then take it from there okay thank you so much for that I appreciate it all right so now we'll go back to the applicant who has five minutes for rebuttal with great respect hearing officer before we start the five minutes can I ask Ms. Massey a question for clarification sure I just want to make sure I understand in the report there's a lot in the report that talks about all the CI uses can you clarify the planning commission look at this under the restrictions we proposed or all CI uses I just want to have a clarity on that please sure my understanding is that at the time that we filed our report the only restriction that was in the record was the first one which was limiting the use and the one about the buffer those were the two only two restrictions that we were aware of at the time that we filed you asked my question I just want to be sure thank you make sure I had clarity hearing officer there were quite a number of inconsistencies that were presented to you I'm sure unintentionally um number one they referred to attorney I'm not an attorney I don't know it was me but I always put that on the record um in regard to Mr. Magnus proper and Gibsonton which really has no validity here we did I handled a future land use amendment to SMU six that was successful um so when they refer to Gibsonton I'm not sure why they're referring to Gibsonton but I want to make aware that that was an issue that was successfully approved there was a lot of discussion about traffic and transportation as you well know we're at the first step here of a standard zoning as what we've done today the transportation department county is coming forth no objection we've reduced this to a tremendous low number of trips we're on both roads on Hillsborough County truck route going forward if successful as you're well aware and as I'm stating for you and for the future of course transportation is going to look at this very carefully county and state all those issues are going to have to be addressed there was an inconsistency noted that the budding owners that we've given you um support from were from all the property uh owner that Mr. Magnus bought this property which is incorrect one of the owners was a neighbor the other two on the north and to the west were not owners and did not sell this property to Mr. Magnus and in that regard we didn't hear from any other property owner that is in immediate vicinity um I'm very proud of the fact that we had I'm estimating 45 maybe 50 people at the community meeting a week ago so I'm thrilled that we only had four people because we did a really really good job and we really tried to reach out to neighbors to make sure they understood the issues and I think we did a really good job and that's evident by how many neighbors came forward today the fact of the matter is under agricultural future land use and zoning there could be any number of trucks working every day coming and going agriculture is given a tremendous amount of leeway on their use and how intense their use is under the county favors agriculture uses the comparable here was we're only having eight um I used to serve on the co-enforcement board I deal with co-enforcement a lot on an everyday basis they when they get in a complaint they are extremely diligent they go out they produce a list of what does a list of what does not comply with a plan and that's we have to go and fix that's not the case here yes Mr. Magno had some code enforcement citations he responsibly took care of them there are none pending I'm aware of I asked Mr. Magno he said there are none so yes there were some code enforcement citations at other properties but he was responsible property owner he responded to those there was another risk inconsistency stated that there were only going to be three trucks what was what was presented at the community meeting as Mr. Magno currently has three trucks but the condition or restriction would be eight so I can understand why there would be misunderstanding but I want to clarify for you why that misunderstanding might occur by the public in regard to the 2026 accident I looked up the record just on Google it was stated very clearly that accident was caused by a person who ran a red light I don't have that with me but that is easily obtainable uh so again in regard to residents we think we did a really great job of working through um it's evident by what you heard tonight uh we're glad to have the support of the zoning department and the affected directly impacted residents and we're happy to answer any other questions you might have none at this time thank you so much I appreciate it then with that we'll close rezoning two six dash one three four nine it's eight o'clock we take a five minute break at this point so if you all could be back back to the zoning hearing master for November 16th if everybody could take their seats we are ready to resume the hearing thank you so much five minutes went by very fast all right Miss Heinrich we are ready to call the next case our next application is item C4 standard rezoning 26 dash one five six nine the applicant is requesting to rezone property from AS1 and CG to CG for development services and provide staff findings all right is the applicant here good evening uh good evening my name is Mariela Lugo address is two six one seven Fritzky Road all right go ahead with your presentation um I'm here today because I'm the daughter of the property owners uh we currently have a business that we sell appliances and do repairs on appliances right now the property can I ask you to stop is there someone on the phone or talking or something uh we're contacting to everyone so if you need to go outside that'd be awesome alright thank you so much go ahead I apologize uh the property is currently zoned as um CG and the back side of the property is ASC1 uh we're trying to get the property to be fully CG as the back side of the property um we don't really use it for agricultural purposes as it's located on 92 and there's no way for us to put any animals or anything on there what's on the property right now um we can we currently sell washers and dryers doves and refrigerators um we're currently working on getting some more permits for buildings on the property and um we just want to expand the business a little bit so we can use it to its fullest potential okay I understand thank you so much I appreciate your coming down if you could please sign in development services good evening Logan McKay development services uh resume 26 1569 applicants requesting to rezone from ASC1 and CG uh into fully CG uh subject site uh subject site uh already is already majority commercial general zoning the remaining ASC1 section is not usable as the ASC1 zoning due to pre-existing access and acreage minimum requirements neighboring property to the east was rezoned under the same conditions uh back in 2025 under case 25 14-18 staff finds the uh application approvable uh and there is uh existing uh violation on the property uh for unpermitted uh constructions and permits uh available for any questions none at none at this time thank you so much planning commission Jillian Massey planning commission staff sites in the urban service area and within the limits of the safner mangrove community plan it's designated as residential 4 on the future land use map the proposal is to rezone the site from CG and ASC1 to CG the surrounding development patterns show a mix of uses with commercial uses oriented along US highway 92 which is consistent with future land use section policy 3.1.3 which requires all new development to be compatible with the surrounding area the subject site meets commercial locational criteria which is established in the future land use section under objective 4.7 policy 4.7.2 allows neighborhood serving commercial uses including office uses um to be permitted within the future land use category with when certain locational standards are satisfied the nearest qualifying intersection to the subject site is US 92 a state principal arterial roadway and north kingsway road which is a county collector roadway and the site is within the required 1 000 feet from this intersection the subject site is within the limits of the safner mango community plan goal 3 of the plan directs commercial development towards US 92 and martin luther king junior boulevard corridors recognizing their established commercial character within the urban service area the plan further encourages the revitalization and redevelopment of older commercial areas and existing commercial uses in this context the proposed rezoning from CG and ASC1 to CG is consistent with the intent and strategies of the safner mango community plan as articulated in the livable communities element and based on those considerations uh planning commission staff finds the proposed rezoning consistent with the goals objectives and policies of the unincorporated hillsborough county comprehensive plan thank you so much is there anyone in the room or online that would like to speak and support anyone in favor seeing no one anyone in opposition to this request no one all right miss heinrich anything else no ma'am the applicant i've lost you you have five minutes for rebuttal but you don't have to take it okay perfect then with that we'll close rezoning two six dash one five six nine and go to the next case our next application is item d1 major mod 26 dash zero five four six the applicant is requesting a major modification to pd 98 dash zero seven eight zero sam ball with development services has reviewed this and will present staff findings all right is the applicant here good evening uh good evening uh dallas evans flamingo civil design 3709 north rocky point drive suite 104 tampa i'm here on behalf of the applicant north tampa church of christ and i have been sworn um i can start with a little background on the church and the property this is the north tampa church of christ it's located at 3611 east county line road in louis the current church building was built in 2008 but the property has a much longer history as a church site there had been a church here many years ago that burned around 1930 that was never rebuilt but the cemetery on the west side of the property has been there since that time the property is about 15 acres on the south side of county line road roughly a mile west of i-275 pasco county and single family subdivisions are across county line road to the north with ag and undeveloped land to the east and south and a cemetery to the west this is the currently approved gdp or zoomed in version of it before 2004 this pd had been approved for a cemetery with a funeral home mausoleum and crematorium facility the church came in with minor mud or major mod 04 1585 to replace those issues with those uses with the church campus that included a thousand seat worship facility up to 75 000 square feet of administrative and classroom buildings and athletic fields and playground while keeping the 10 000 plot cemetery now that's the plan that you see here with the worship facility located in parcel b a little bit difficult to see here but b is the roughly square shaped parcel um and then c is the more rectangular wider one to the bow below it um so worship facilities were to be in parcel b administrative and classroom buildings were to be in parcel c uh to the today the site has the existing church building about 9900 square feet along with the cemetery parking and playground what we're asking tonight is just to combine parcels b and c into a single parcel nothing else is proposed to change this is the proposed plan with those two parcels merged this would allow for uses to be combined between those two uses so the existing zoning splits them into separate uses in b and c however churches use their buildings for a variety of uses even if a building is primarily the worship center it's also used for administrative classroom activities and so forth this issue came up when we proposed a small administrative office building in parcel b zoning staff at the time correctly noted that only worship facilities are allowed in parcel b for that application we revised the building's location to move it to parcel c but we realized at that time that this could all cause issues down the road at that time crown castle had a rezoning in the works for the property for a wireless communication facility um that was an applicant that was under contract with the church we asked them to include this minor change in their application they later decided not to move forward with this case um but they did allow the church to continue the application for this one uh minor change if this hadn't started out with the tower application it would have qualified as a prs rather than a major mod just to make sure we're clear what is not changing the uses the square footage height limits setbacks and buffers all stay the same as what's approved today the administrative classroom buildings are still accessory to the church and the existing condition prohibiting a private school stays in place since the development program isn't changing there's no change in trip generation either staff's revised conditions keep the two existing driveways with the west one reserved for the cemetery east for everything else require trip generation and access analysis with each phase of future development address right away for county line road at site plan review turn line requirements would be set by pasco county since county line is maintained by pasco as far as compatibility since we're not adding uses intensity or access the only thing that changes for the neighbors is where the buildings can go inside the site and the setbacks and buffers that protect them don't change staff found the reconfiguration will have minimal impact on the surrounding area we've received favorable recommendation from all departments we're in agreement with staff's proposed conditions and we respectfully request a recommendation of approval answer any questions just to confirm for the record um no no change in the entitlements no change this is more reshuffling the already approved uses yes the only change we have is those two parcels b and c um had been split between church and administrative and educational uses we're just looking to merge those two together to allow those all right understood thank you so much i appreciate it don't forget to sign in development services good evening good evening sam ball hillsborough county development services the applicant is requesting this major modification to pd 980780 to reconfigure the general site plan the subject property is approximately one mile west of interstate 275 along the south side of east county line road the properties to the north are located in pasco county jurisdiction and are developed for single family use the development south of east county road is predominantly consisting of single family and institutional uses development to the south and southeast it's constrained by wetlands um if this if this is approved the proposed configurations would allow the worship facility to expand into the parcel designated for administrative and classroom use and allow for a portion of the canopy to extend into the vehicular use area based on the surrounding zoning and development pattern uh and proposed use the staff finds that these modifications will have minimal impact on the area and find that the requests are approvable uh that concludes my presentation if you have any questions no none at this time thank you so much planning commission jillian massey planning commission staff the site is in the rural area and within the limits of the loose community plan it's designated as residential one on the future land use map future land use section objective 2.2 and policy 2.2.1 establish the future land use map as well as the allowable range of uses for each future land use category the proposal is consistent with the uses under the existing residential future land use category and therefore consistent with that policy direction future land use section policy 4.4.1 specifies that any increase in density or intensity must be compatible with the existing proposed or planned development and that the development or redevelopment should be integrated with adjacent uses through the establishment of like or complementary uses mitigation of adverse impacts provision of transportation and pedestrian connections and a gradual transition of intensity public and quasi-public and institutional uses are prominently present in the immediate vicinity so the request to combine parcel b and parcel c into one parcel aligns with these principles and is consistent with uh said policy direction and based on those considerations planning commission staff finds that the proposed major modification is consistent with the unincorporated hillsborough county comprehensive plan subject to the conditions proposed by the development services department thank you so much is there anyone in the room or online that would like to speak in support anyone in favor see no one anyone in opposition to this request no one miss heinrich anything further no ma'am mr evans you have the last word okay no thanks all right then with that we'll close major modification 26-0546 and go to the next case our next application is item d2 major mod 26-0553 the applicant is requesting a major modification to pd19-1344 jared fallen with development services has reviewed this for development services and will present staff findings after the applicant's uh presentation and if not already provided to you there was a revision in regards to some of the trip generation numbers um if that wasn't provided to you beforehand i'm sure jerry will provide it to you right after all right yes i have not seen that okay all right thank you so much good evening good evening miss finch william molloy 325 south boulevard tampa florida what we have here is a major modification to an existing and approved plan development the meat of the request is really an acceleration of the density were approved for 34 units right now the request would take it to 55 which is much closer to the r4 existing future land use designation this slide kind of shows the trickle down effect of the additional lots although the lot development standards are going to um accelerate or reduce accordingly i would point out the third to final line buffer trees we are doubling the amount of buffer trees that were offered the first time around these trees will be three inch caliper 10 feet tall and every 20 feet on center rather than 40. two other developments in this effort are the southern building setback we were able to find 25 more feet there so that is a very significant setback and then i believe you were the hearing master on the original pd you may recall there was some issue with the county park just to the north of us and the viability of perhaps providing a recreational trail and even emergency access we couldn't pull that program together at the time but we have since then and that's a very important part of this application here we have just a brief overview of staff findings development services did find it approvable the planning commission did not like it two of the highlights i think from development services that i'd like to focus on are that the emergency access and the public trail to the north on the county land actually do support the new density um they kind of give a substantiation to it we're in court incurring more quiet costs obviously but we're bringing more homes to the site to offset that a bit uh second to that besides the planning commission we do not have any agency objections that's just a project location which i think we're all aware of future land use map this is a little bit telling we do kind of look like a little island of r4 in between r4 and r2 i think it's important and very very relevant to point out the r2 directly to the west of us that was done by a citizen initiated comp plan amendment to down zone that was r4 back in 2019 they switched it to r2 you'll notice there's a few holdout lots of r4 that did not participate i'm not saying that was a direct assault on compatibility but it didn't help what we were trying to do at the time obviously this is our general site plan i'm going to have mr cash and our project engineer speak to this a little bit more but a very important part of this one is we have four significant ponds on here to capture and make sure that this is a completely closed project that we're not releasing any uh runoff or discharge into the neighborhood uh mr sullivan's going to speak to the emergency access and the trail he was the principal in negotiating most of that it's a pretty simple program i think it makes a lot of sense for the neighborhood and historically should solve some of the flooding and um almost like being trapped problems that they've had before where neighbors could not get out to a public right away finally this is a detail miss finch of our accelerated landscaping program this just indicates that we will be planting the trees every 20 feet on center rather than 40 which should provide an excellent buffer and then as for transportation mr yates is here to speak to any of this this is the delta in trips from the original to the proposed it looks pretty benign actually we have a significant condition about a turn lane that mr yates can explain in the timing of how that's going to be produced and then this is just a public benefit slide of what what we'll be paying in impact fees doubling the foliage for the buffer providing the emergency access and as mr sullivan likes to do he's creating an entirely too much sidewalk from the project to semino uh elementary school so with that i'm going to ask mr sullivan to come up and explain this program right here william sullivan 26336 state road 19 how in the hills florida i'm uh the applicant and the owner of the property i wanted to uh go forward before i start the trail i want to go back a little background on and we're going to go to let me find the background here we go we had a community meeting on the 3 24 26 and 6.6 and a half minutes was devoted to the emergency access issue basically this neighborhood cannot get out when lithia pinecrest floods and lithia pinecrest is going to be wide and improved but williams road which is where this is and adelaide road are not scheduled to be lifted out of the hundred year uh flood situation and our engineer is going to explain that a little bit because he'll explain where we are in the flood and and where that is on the flood so we had not only did we have the meeting but then third there 18 of the emails sent to hillsborough county referred to flooding on lithia pinecrest road or evacuations and one of the quotes says not to mention flooding during the last hurricane our community only has two exit roads both were flooded leaving us unable to leave our home several for several days so then let's go back to the so when i heard this when we we discovered this situation because we do not live there therefore we you know don't see it on an active basis we have met with the the county uh powers and we are looking if if it's deemed approvable by the county to build uh this this uh this will using the county parkland is we are proposing one is a 15 foot wide access trail that will tie uh the the tavolo hills with bloomingdale the access trail will also have and that access trail is going to be a stabilized road bed for emergency vehicles it'll have knock boxes at both ends 20 foot knock box cases at each end five foot wide gate on the side to let pedestrians get through during uh hours of uh sun sunrise to sunset there will also be an easement in there uh where the you know for public access easement from sunrise to sunset uh there'll be 20 there as a five foot uh pedestrian loop as well uh a pervious pedestrian loop so that people if they want to take their dogs or whatever it is and want to take in there they'll have a rounding through it we also the hoa will be maintaining it and it's funds sinking fund of 20 percent of construction costs every year so that if something were to cap catastrophically were to occur that there would be the money to take care and fix it so and that's uh that's where we are on that um so we show the trail and then also just so you know it'll be the the park property would be uh fenced the entire park property would be fenced by a six foot pvc fence and the only portion that would be aluminum picket would be there along the the retention pond to the north i'm going to allow sean cash in and now talk about the uh the uh drainage and i'll go to the drainage slides here you go here you go sean good evening good evening sean cash in 13825 icob boulevard clearwater florida uh this slide represents the the fema flood map or firm map as you can see the site is located outside of the blue shaded areas which are a zones within the hundred year flood this site is a little bit higher and it's located in flood zone x outside the hundred year that being said the this site is within the alafia river watershed this watershed is comprised of thousands of acres the county has studied uh this entire area um the uh where this site is is kind of on a little mound uh our existing elevations vary from 61 to 68 and it tapers to the north the south southeast southwest um the in the county's alafia river model uh some of the 100 year basins that they have studied uh to the southwest uh the southeast and the north vary from elevation 37 to 55 and again we're up quite a bit higher at elevation 61 to 68 uh this site is also within what the county classifies as a volume sensitive basin and there's certain criteria that needs to be adhered to during the the site plan review stage and and that is that the pre post 100 year storm volume has to be totally contained within the site and then there is a limited discharge off site in this case that discharge would be uh to a certain degree to the south within the ditch system on hideaway lane and more so to the north which would be to the the county uh property which has an existing pond located on the north end of that property um one other thing i wanted to to add is uh in addition to the emergency trail that we are proposing going through the county property to the north we are also extending approximately 140 feet of sidewalk to the southeast of the site to connect to uh the elementary school and i'm here to answer any questions um not on your subject matter thank you all right thank you don't forget to sign in miss finch i think that can conclude our presentation unless you have any transportation questions um i do but i i think well i'll ask my question i think it more pertains to staff but i will um ask it and there is uh i think this generates from the county's transportation comments but i had a question about why it's i believe condition number eight proposes to um allow permits except when you get to lot number 52 three four and five mr yates if you could help me explain that and if you want me to talk to mr perez i'm glad no i can give an explanation okay uh michael yates with palm traffic and i have been sworn um so in our traffic study that was done for the project uh we warranted a southbound right turn lane by three trips and so what we did is because of the widening of lithia pinecrest which would rip out the turn lane and because of the difficulty to build that southbound right turn lane we determined that there were three lots that would cause the warrant for the turn lane so without those three lots we would not warrant the southbound right turn lane so the first part of that condition is saying that if we we can hold off building those three lots until such time that this section of lithia pinecrest to widen to four lane divided is initiated we would hold off on building those lots there is a condition b to that that allows for us to build the turn lane and construct those three lots in advance of the lithia pinecrest um perhaps i don't have the most up-to-date conditions i know it was in the i have condition eight that talks about lots 53 54 55 but there is no b in the version that i have in the transportation section i know there is oh in the transportation section so that would be a critical piece of information to be added to the conditions yeah okay all right it just gave the out that because again like the other project the lithia pinecrest is funded but i know they're working through a lot of the design issues and right-of-way issues out there and so as to the timing of that we are not exactly sure when that is going to be we anticipate that it is going to be one of the first sections of lithia pinecrest that is constructed but at this point it has not been let for construction so we do not then know the timing of it that's why we had the condition in there about delaying those three lots and then the county had the option to build the three lots by building the turn line but unlike the prior project where it was virtually the entire project couldn't go forward until the intersection improvement was complete this is only the bulk of this project goes forward except for three lots correct understood all right thank you so much i appreciate it thank you does that conclude the applicant's presentation all right thank you mr malloy development services um i think that that condition he was referencing is number nine i believe uh it's not b it's just there's eight and nine so both uh cover that situation you're right you're right it is okay thank you for that um and also the handout of additional pages for the transportation report um they were in early versions of the staff reports and optics but the most recent didn't include which is covers design exception information thank you uh but yeah good evening jared fallen with development services uh so this is an application that seeks to modify pd19-1344 the current pd zoning permits 35 single-family homes with the minimum lot size of 10 000 square feet and a width of 75 feet this modification proposes to increase the number of single-family homes to 55 uh and also reduce the number of lot size to 6 000 with a width of 50 feet the subject site is located within a residential neighborhood primarily zoned is as-1 with most lots over one acre in size or larger the site is also adjacent to a single family neighborhood to the north that is platted with smaller lots size at around 4 000 square feet or more with the proposed reduction in minimum lot width from 75 to 50 and lot size the majority of the additional lots will be internal to the project and along the northern boundary where there are similar adjacent lot sizes along the eastern western boundary adjacent to the larger one acre lots based on the difference and change in minimum lot widths the number of lots along each of the boundaries will increase by approximately three to four additional lots to minimize impacts to the surrounding neighborhood the previous approval provided a 10-foot landscape landscape easement screening with a six-foot fence and planted trees over 40 feet along the eastern and western boundaries this application enhances the easement screening area by providing a six-foot fence and planting trees every 20 feet land development code does not require screening and buffering between single family uses regardless of differences in lot sizes but the proposed screening would be comparable to what would be required if office or commercial uses were proposed adjacent to the existing single family additionally the 30-foot rear yard setback will remain in place for homes along those boundaries along the southern boundary the water retention areas take up much of the area and 125-foot building setback is proposed as for the proposed site layout the development will provide better connectivity within the existing neighborhood including better access to the nearby elementary school additionally lithia pinecrest road which is the main access road in and out of this site is slated to be widened via the future capital improvement plan while the design of this project is currently under review this funding of the project has not been secured i'll also note that a traffic light was added to the intersection of adelaide avenue and lithia pinecrest since the last rezoning approval in 2019 um so yeah we've covered the they are they would be permitted 52 units today if it was approved today um but they would have to do those improvements or do the turn lane uh to do the additional three uh the pd also involves a track to the north um that developer will be required to develop as a park with a park trail that also serves as an emergency access for the project and the surrounding neighborhood while the development proposes a higher density residential development within a lower density neighborhood the proposed density complies with underlying res 4 future land use classification and the adjacent residential the east and west is rest to include future land use therefore development services concludes the proposal to increase the density of the development is supported by the enhancement of the east-west buffer the proposed emergency access and the addition of the second traffic light at the intersection with lithia pinecrest and adelaide avenue as a result development services does not foresee any compatibility concerns with the proposed major modification and finally approval subject to the proposed conditions happy to answer any questions i have a couple yep um the staff report where it talks you state um and you said it tonight the majority of the additional lots will be internal to the project and along the northern boundary where there are similar adjacent lot sizes when i look at the approved um site plan for the 10 000 square foot lots it is a bubble plan and almost identical to the proposed um major modification plan and just replaced with six thousand six thousand square foot lots so how are the majority of the lots internal i could see if you had the perimeter lots were 10 000 and then they were asking for the internal lots to be six thousand but this is a complete change from ten thousand to six thousand how are the majority of them so i think what we're getting down there is along the boundaries uh east to west boundary there's going to be an additional three or four that could be located within that area um but you know without if you take out the additional whatever's left most of it's going to be internal or to the north along the north boundary okay so what is it increase of 35 to 55 oh and by the way there's just a typo on the first page of your staff report where it says it's approved for 35 lots it but the conditions read 34. oh so i just want to make sure that that's correct okay um and then my second question is um the fourth paragraph down it says it should be noted the site layout of the development will provide better connectivity within the existing neighborhood including better access to the nearby elementary school to the southwest across hideaway lane and it's basically my same question that the site plans are almost identical how is that possible that they get better access i well i think what we're getting at is it's not built yet um i guess it's not really an increasing kind of activity we're just mentioning the fact that the major modification is still keeping that connectivity in place i guess it wouldn't be an increase it would just be so it's not better it's just providing connectivity i see okay all right thank you so much um i believe that was my only questions thank you very much planning commission jillian massey planning commission staff the site's located in the urban service area and within the boundaries of the brandon community plan specifically within the garden estates district the site is designated as residential for on the future land use map while the proposed residential use and overall density remain within the allowable limits of the residential for future land use designation the proposed modification represents a significant departure from the previously approved development pattern and the established character of the surrounding neighborhood future land use section objective 1.1 directs the majority of the county's anticipated growth and development to the urban service area while future land use section objective 2.2 establishes the allowable uses and maximum densities in each future land use category the proposed residential development is consistent with the residential floor designation and remote remains below the maximum allowable density however future land use section policy 3.1.3 requires new development to maintain compatibility with the established character of the surrounding neighborhoods and policy 4.4.3 requires residential lot sizes and densities to reflect the character of the surrounding area the subject site is located within an established neighborhood characterized by larger lot single-family residential development the original approval of 34 dwelling units with minimum 10 000 square foot lots provided an appropriate transition between the larger lot residential development pattern and the density permitted by the residential floor designation in contrast the proposed the proposal to increase to 55 dwelling units and reduce to 6 000 square foot lots would substantially increase development development development intensity and diminish the compatibility measures established through the original approval additionally future land use section objective 4.4 and policies 4.4.1 and point 2 require new development to integrate with the surrounding neighborhoods through appropriate transitions and density lot size design and internal circulation mobility section goal 4 and objective 4.1 further encourage interconnected neighborhood street networks the proposed development does not provide meaningful opportunities to for connectivity to adjacent residential areas and would function largely as an isolated subdivision the site is also located within the garden estates district of the brandon community plan which emphasizes the preservation of larger lot residential developments and the established neighborhood character the proposed 6 000 square foot lots would depart from the district's preferred development pattern and are substantially smaller than the lots previously approved as a compatibility measure based on these considerations planning commission staff finds that the proposed major modification is inconsistent with the goals objectives and policies of the unincorporated hillsborough county conferencing plan thank you so much is there anyone in the room or online that would like to speak and support anyone in favor seeing no one anyone in opposition to this request okay i see one hand sir are you going to speak okay so that's two how many do we have i'm just trying to get a count how many people want to speak okay but i'm talking about just how many i'm just trying to get the time of how much to allocate two people all right is there anyone online that would like to speak in opposition okay so the two of you um it's seven and a half a minutes a piece but however you want to allocate it it's 15 total um i noticed that the timers seem to start a little late for those guys so i don't know if you notice that believe me we'll make sure you get your time i'm sure you will all right thank you yeah that's fine my name is margaret jamski i live at four towards you just a little bit there you go perfect 4406 loma vista drive in val rico i've lived in an area for 43 years and i would just like to comment before i start my presentation that i've never had a problem getting out of the neighborhood so the emergency access seems to be kind of excessive in our minds and the letters that came in were kind of from new neighbors that had never experienced the type of flooding we had in tampa with the 100-year flood so it was highly crazy unusual situation also the sidewalk that keeps being mentioned neither our children in the neighborhood nor those in the connective bloomingdale neighborhood are zoned to attend chemino elementary so i really don't know who's going to be using those sidewalks um in the right turn lane that has been talked about after he gets the first 51 homes done adelaide avenue in lawful lithia pinecrest adelaide is a switchback turn it's a very dangerous intersection even now with the school bus coming in there pick kids up it's a very difficult turn for them to make coming heading um south so we would request even whatever happens that we do need a right turn lane in there with all the traffic coming to drop children off at chemino school that's just what i want to put that in there okay i don't know how to do this okay so i'm here tonight to introduce you to our neighborhood this is to valo hills it's been there since 1973 oh this thing didn't start i'm sorry i'm not very good at this part there it goes sorry about that um before the usa and flu boundaries were drawn in our area as you can see it's a very rural setting the uh neighborhood has been encroached upon by the development around us to the uh left of the slide you'll see the area in mention many of us had to have give up our horseback riding because of the traffic from the schools coming in and that's why we're here tonight for decades we were essentially a forgotten neighborhood overlooked as development rapidly transformed southeastern hillsborough county while our community remained rural suburban zoning began encroaching upon us without the appropriate transition as you can see in this slide here the compatibility protections outline the county's own comprehensive plan forgot about us and actually the uh situation with the r2 and r4 in our neighborhood when we when we came to the planning commission back in 2019 when this started they told us wow those lines were probably erroneously drawn and yes you have every right to to request to be r2 so we did that's how that came about again here again you can see the rsc9 the s1 there's no transition whatsoever in 2021 the board of county commissioners made a decision on pd 19 1344 and the developer was requesting 58 homes the board approved 34. that decision reflected the board's recognition of the compatibility concerns surrounding our established neighborhood and what would work best for our community and we were in agreement with it now mr sullivan is attempting to persuade you that they were wrong and he knows what's best for our community but nothing has changed our neighborhood hasn't changed the comp plan hasn't changed the land development code hasn't changed the only composition i'm sorry the only thing that's changed was the composition of the board this past election and i think he wants to convince them that that board was wrong in their decision we're not opposed to the responsible development at all we've talked to mr sullivan from the beginning the garden estate plans states half acre lots and we asked him for 30 homes only he got 34 and that was a decision made and i think that we all settled that that was fine so we're not opposed to it but we want growth that does not come at the expense of an established community or the planning protections intended to preserve their character this is what is being requested in the middle of our neighborhood and this is what it will look like crammed into this space this is a northeast section the north and northeast section of that piece of property i have their written proposal when lines drawn homes will be there up against the one acre lots next year we have a gentleman here on the bottom of the slide that has passed the funeral horses there's no way those horses are going to be able to maintain any kind of stability with those homes in there this is the whole eastern side you see the number of homes that will be up against there's still no transition this is the west side again no transition whatsoever the application will also continue to cause an already dangerous situation at our new light that we have in there and mr sullivan tells you there's another way out but he fails to tell you the road other way out is completely blocked by this traffic here and it sometimes takes three to four light cycles to get through that light just to get out of our neighborhood so we're not asking for you to do anything different but for us to present specific policies objectives and compatibility standards that we believe won't denial of this major modification and tonight i have mr hill here who will present for us the policies that you will need to deny this thank you good evening thank you madam magistrate give me one second let me get my thing up okay okay hold on one second let me go back okay all right we are live okay madam magistrate michael hill torreya design and consulting 129 southeast 16th avenue apartment m204 gainesville florida 32601 and i have been sworn again as you said and as you've seen from my client that this is the tavala hills neighborhood as you see it's very sparse very semi-rule is what they would consider it in hillsborough county again here is our application that the potomac land company on the hawk of fishhawk developments is featuring a modification to increase the density from 2.66 to roughly about 3.55 again in the land development code in section 5.03.01 of the regulation states that these districts are used for customized purposes in cases where standard district regulations are inadequate to protect surrounding property where designed and again like i said these districts intend to encourage create innovate and or mixed use development and to ensure promote land use compatibility and harmony for the land that is to be planned and developed as the whole in the single that is the key word there is promote land use compatibility and harmony in the land development code specifically in section 6.2.12 change is approved to a development to um plan developments as you see in section c review modification that it says review submittals for procedures shall be shall be for major market shall be consistent with pd rezoning as referred to as section 6.21 of the manual and as you see in section 6.21 as you see in section 6.21 plan development rezoning you got the narrative and then b it says how the proposal conforms to all applicable hillsborough county comprehensive plan policies so therefore we have established that all major modifications must follow the pd rezoning criteria and the pz rezoning criteria says that all pds must be in harmony with all applicable comprehensive plan policies of the hillsborough county comprehensive plan so here we're going to address the deficiencies in the comprehensive plan with this application objective 3.1 new development should recognize the existing community and be designed in a compatible way as design and future land use policies 3.13 with the established character of the surrounding neighborhood the new modification violates objective 3.13 as you can see historically the neighborhood is one acre lots 150 feet wide and right now we're right now he is attempting to basically create 6 000 square foot wide 6 000 square foot lots that are 50 feet wide again two very different things you can fit essentially three houses of his in one of the neighbors in tavalo hills again comp plan 3.3 is the county's definition of compatibility within within their comprehensive plan and as you said some elements affecting compatibility include the following height scale mass bulk and structure we believe with the increase in density you are violating the scale and mass of this section and so therefore they're in violation of policy 3.13 as mentioned by the planning commission again going back to policy 3.12 which talks about gradual transitions again to the north we have 4500 square foot wide lots to the south and tavalo hills we have one acre lots we need to find something that is a happy medium the original approved pd for the 34 acres is that happy medium in my opinion and again in policy 3.14 lots on the edges of new developments that have both physical and visual relationship adjacent to properties that are parceled or developed developed at a lower density should mitigate such impact with substantial buffering and or compatible land sizes again compatible lot sizes excuse me this modification is not adhering to policy 3.14 or policy 3.12 here's a rendition kind of basically of the lot layout as you can see again you know we're going 50 foot wide in the existing tavalo hills neighborhood you could put three houses on one of those on one of those lots objective 3.12 hillsborough county is diverse of many communities and neighborhoods conference plan is effective in the overall growth management strategies for development the entire county strategies shall be developed and ensure that long-range viability of the communities through plans and special studies and effort policies this is what would this is what created the lead of the brandon community plan the brandon community plan is what needs to be considered here here's an example of incompatibility in this gainesville florida where i am at when we're talking about scale those are duplexes and single-family homes and that is an apartment building could you imagine going out in your backyard and seeing that objective 4.4 as you see neighbor protection the neighborhood is a functional unit there's a need to protect existing neighborhoods and communities again the pd modification has made no effort to address these issues with the application is in violations of these policies specifically section e of the gra of the gradual transitions here's the dimensional criteria of the existing as one of tavalo hills as you see we got 50 foot wide 50 foot setbacks 150 foot wide lots the approved pd at 0.22 acre 10 000 square feet with 20 20 and 10 and then the modification again i reiterate you can fit three of the proposed modifications in one of the tavalo hills neighborhood lots now let's talk about house bill 399 now house bill 399 as you know essentially addressed some changes to the florida statutes in 163 about compatibility and again here as you see i've highlighted the section of the criteria that are copied directly from the florida statutes on the florida senate website and so essentially in this guideline that um we would make the call that 3.13 3.12 4.41 and i think 4.11 are the county's compatibility guidelines and criteria and the applicant we and we have demonstrated the applicant is not meeting that criteria therefore a denial by the county commission is not in violation of house bill 399. again the brandon community plan as you see we have the tavalo hills neighborhood again just some excerpts and again it says lot size is at least half an acre they may retain agricultural zoning including related horse and farms and again brandon community said half acre the county approved a quarter acre the neighborhood is fine with the quarter acre lots but again the developer is not playing games something else i noticed too in the review of the site plan there's no open space calculation so again i don't know exactly how you can approve a plan with no open space calculation that's kind of concerning and again community six of the brandon community plan established the historical hospitable family-oriented character through thoughtful planning and the semi-rule lifestyle again you can see the rendition there of the houses these 6 000 square foot lots are not semi-rule by any means and then again as you said pertinent we have the established neighborhood in the as1 in part 222 goal 5 again goal 5 provide a variety of agriculture rural residential land uses to meet the needs of a diverse population tavalo hills is semi-rule 6 000 square foot lots with 800 square foot backyards is not rule it's not even a rural residential or a rural lifestyle at all tavalo hills is a semi-rule neighborhood as you see the character should be considered in the design of new developments and preserve the community for generations to come like i said livable communities density bonus should be utilized for the incentive to encourage development for more affordable housing again we haven't seen anything the applicant has said the three hundred thousand dollar homes are affordable that's absolutely insane to me because that means i need to think a minimum of three and a half three and a half percent that's almost 20 000 or i think somewhere in that ballpark and again like i said you know preserve existing trees again i will i will commend the applicant for saving some trees and adding more that is great again here's a printout of ecosystem services done by the university of florida about the loss of trees and then we have the flood risk as you see this is in this was in the general area and then here's our recommendation the application does not meet section 5.031 the application does not meet 3.12 does not meet 3.13 does not meet 3.14 objective 4.4 4.41 goal 5 1.3 it also does not adhere to the brand and community plan of goals 2 and goal 6 the application does not demonstrate the county's definition of compatibility as set out in the previous things therefore a violate therefore a denial of this application is not in violation of house bill 399 and again because it cannot meet the applicable comprehensive plan policies it's in violation of 6.21 and 6.212 please help correct the oversight thank you madam madam magistrate i'm available for any questions none at this time thank you so much don't forget to sign in all right so with that we'll close the we'll close the um sir if you could sign in please we'll close that portion of the hearing for opposition and we'll go to development services miss heinrich do you have anything to add um the only thing i wanted to add real quickly is um just to add to jared's comments to your questions about the improved connectivity this proposal versus the previously approved proposal um both the previous and the current have uh cross access to the west east and south the previous one did not have vehicular cross access to the north for this application um while it won't be a full-time vehicular connection to the north it will serve as an emergency access to the north um up to the bloomingdale area that this neighborhood and the other surrounding homes would be able to utilize which wasn't in the previous um proposal all right i appreciate that my my question to him was because um the staff report says that it improves act it includes better access to the nearby elementary school to the southwest across hideaway lane and my question was i believe it's the same and i think he answered that but i appreciate your clear your clarification and regarding that access to the north in i was looking at the prior approved the currently approved uh conditions where it was encouraged not a requirement it was encouraged that this park access be provided if they could work out the deal with the county is that correct all right yes that was at the board's request okay and it seems that they have so it was always a requirement that it was encouraged but it's not that um it seems that that is the mitigating one of the mitigating factors for the development services support of this that they are now providing that access correct that's one of one reason and um also in terms of the uh school access conditions i believe transportation probably has some other items to add that weren't required before but are required now um if you would like to hear from mr perez yep mr prez if you'd like to add on to that i'd be glad to hear it uh yes uh one small improvement that's not currently included in the existing pd is a sidewalk connection and crosswalk to the southwest crossing uh hideaway lane and tying into the semino elementary sidewalk so that's new to this proposal as opposed to the prior uh entitlements it is yes and it's documented in the design exception for substandard roadways okay thank you so much for that i appreciate it all right anything else miss heinrich before i move on not unless you have any questions no that was it thank you so much all right mr malloy you have uh the last word with five minutes for rebuttal good evening william malloy again 325 south boulevard i'll be brief on this rebuttal um the gentleman in purple did provide a report for us indicating his concerns with the project we reviewed that thoroughly and what we were able to take out of it in terms of tangible things that we can accomplish listed right here these were very particular requests you know in that report that we're happy to oblige these are not a problem at all um other than that and i do not say this lightly i very much disagree with the assertions the interpretations of the comp plan that were provided tonight i think there's a fundamental philosophical difference in how you can read certain provisions of the comp plan it's very subjective and what we heard tonight was not competent or substantial evidence to overcome any of those policies it was just reading those policies in a certain way i believe this project stands on the merits the first time we're bringing additional benefits the second time around that support the additional density thank you thank you for that i appreciate it all right then we will close major modification i think bill's going to say one more thing oh sorry i thought you were done sorry about that that's all right it's william sullivan again um let me pull up that slide presentation where is that slide presentation guys uh how do i i don't know how do i open this thing guys sorry please do hawk springs that one right there okay um i also wanted to close with a couple things one is we we want you know if if it is allowed by the county we would like to add those additional conditions that were shown up that were shown here on the slide uh if you put it up on the slide uh of that and then also i wanted to close and that is that all exterior lighting including street lights will use you know full shielded fixtures we understand the the existing area uh around us is uh is not is you know light pollution sensitive other than from the north so we are aware of that so we want to work on that we also uh incorporate native plant species uh that they in their report the gentleman mr hill when he did his report a minute ago he didn't show that part and then also the project will conform to volume sensitive criteria of section 3.3 if these could be added conditions to the to the report that would be great and then one more point i wanted to leave on closing is that the school is uh the school board uh is in favor of us building the the uh the emergency access because they had to open the emergency access to uh the residents after a day and that's not an acceptable period of of response if something were to happen in there it would be very important for the county to be able to bring somebody in right away say somebody were to get injured or died or you know you know i'm saying there's a lot of other things that could happen during a crisis i mean people in during hurricanes they get uh you know they give electricity and they you know falling power lines and they get so there's there's a definite need for that so i just wanted to end with that thank you all right thank you so much does that complete your rebuttal testimony yes all right so then we will close major modification 26-0553 and go to the next case our next application is item d3 pd rezoning 26-06 665 the applicant is requesting a rezone from cg to plan development i've reviewed this for development services and provide staff findings after the applicant's presentation and again this is a companion cpa item and it was reviewed in accordance with section 100304 h which reviews the rezoning um in light of the proposed future land use being approved all right are you the applicant let's give it about a minute just so you don't have to talk over it we'll just give it a minute to clear the room it seems like we're losing the bulk of the room all right it looks like we're good to go we're ready for the applicant thank you for your patience good evening good evening colin rice with the law firm of older lundie here on behalf of the applicant i'll put a couple of visuals up 1000 west cast i have been sworn all right so we're here tonight on a rezoning um from commercial general to plan development and as miss heinrich had alluded this does have a companion comprehensive plan amendment uh that is 26-08 uh going from future land use designation residential four to light industrial plans uh that received the unanimous recommendation from planning commission back in april um so i'll walk you through uh what we're looking to do here and ask for your support so the specific request uh in tonight's pd is uh for contractor's office with open storage uh green tech the property owner and applicant has been operating from here for years serving the community orient you we're in the finota sasa community planning area between harney and fowler as they converge uh to access us highway 301 heading northeast our site's about 1.3 acres so again here we're in the r4 uh amending to lip light industrial plan um the r4 covers the area northeast and west uh and as you go further to north nice is sm6 zooming into our site we're bordered in red we're three parcels together uh wedged again between harney and fowler and then to the immediate east is an auto repair use and further east is a convenience store uh and gas station so this is from fowler facing south towards the north boundary of the property this is from harney looking north towards the southern boundary of the property they were facing east along harney so that you can see the adjacent uh auto repair and convenience retail uh adjacent to our site it's all commercial zones uh adjacent to our site i'll show you this to emphasize the the existing conditions out here uh and show you how this overall will result in a compatible project and just to highlight for you um what light industrial planned future land use category seeks is it specifically requires a companion site plan uh so that rather than having the higher end unknown range of industrial uses with a different category you go in knowing that it's going to be carefully managed and i think that we've done a good job of of reaching that goal so this is our site plan so to the south we have the existing uh operations office this is the contractor's office there now um the request is for up to a maximum of 10 000 square feet of contractor's office so this building represents a conceptual balance of that 10 000 about 4700 total conceptual the open storage will occur here in the north there's no access along fowler that's been agreed upon for closure and we have buffering to the west and to the north because these while these rcg zone their residential uses we've added buffering to accept possible there um and all the open storage will be screened so to the north it's buffered and screened to the south there'll be a gate that's capable of closure and screening so there won't be any visible open storage in the area and again just a couple more points and i'll add these to the record with the comprehensive plan really encouraging compatibility and through and i want to thank staff for their help through this a lot of negotiation back and forth we've got their support we're very proud of that uh to reach a compatible site plan again just more comprehensive policies um comprehensive plan policies to support this ask and we're not aware of any objection um we're proud to have near universal support we appreciate planning commission staff's input here and and they'll they'll give the presentation i'll speak a little bit more to compatibility subsequent to that but every other reviewing agency has no objection or finds it supportable so with that i'll conclude i'm happy to answer any questions we do have uh margaret perez theopetrich and um bruce mccarthur from landis evans if there are any technical questions i'm sure they can cover it um not at this time i saw that the natural resources objection was resolved originally and so um no questions at this time okay i'll submit these to the record and i'll sign it all right thank you so much i appreciate it development services michelle heimer development services staff reviewed a rezoning request from cg to pd for property located west of the fowler avenue and harney road intersection in the thanona sasa community the applicant is limiting the permitted uses to a contractor's office with accessory open storage at a maximum far of 0.17 and maximum building height of one story as shown on the proposed general site plan the use will utilize an existing building along harney road while the northern area will be used for another possible building location and the accessory open storage the required 20 foot wide type b buffering and screening will be provided with the exception of one minor area along the west which is the southwest area closer to harney and this will be reduced due to the location of the existing building they're unable to provide the 20 feet in that a small area they will provide a 10 foot wide buffer and provide a fence and ornamental tree plantings that property to the west is zone cg but it is currently occupied by residential use so it does require still despite the zoning the buffering and screening access is limited to harney road no access and buffering and screening is provided along fowler avenue the location is currently zoned cg within a node of other parcels zoned for commercial uses the zoning will be limited in use and intensity below with the maximum permitted in the lip future land use category and most importantly buffering and screening is provided provided we're adjacent to residential zoning found in the northwest and the north and also just to note for the residential to the north they are separated by fowler avenue which is a 60 foot wide right-of-way based on these considerations development services staff has found the request approvable subject to proposed conditions and to subject to the approval of the comprehensive plan amendment thank you so much i appreciate it planning commission jillian massey with planning commission staff the properties in the rural area and within the limits of the tonota sasa community plan it's currently designated residential four on the future land use map however there's a pending comprehensive plan map amendment to change the designation to light industrial planned the request for the plan development is considered concurrent and dependent upon the approval of hccpa 26-08 the analysis provided is based on the pending lip future land use designation approval the comprehensive plan language clearly anticipates and supports light industrial uses within the designation as such the proposed development request which introduces light industrial uses is generally consistent with the intent and purpose of the future land use section objective 2.2 because the request falls within the range of uses expressly contemplated within the lip future land use category while consistency with objective 2.2 is established through the allowance of these uses with the applicable land use designation consider current considerations related to site design buffering operational characteristics and compatibility with the adjacent residential development remain subject to further evaluation under the comp plans comprehensive excuse me compatibility policies while planning commission staff appreciates the efforts to improve compatibility and acknowledge the applicant's commitment to screening the open storage areas from residential uses through an appropriate fence and gate staff continues to have concerns with the request given that the site remains surrounded by the residential for future land use designation and existing single-family residential uses while the proposed revisions provide some additional measures to improve compatibility they do not fully address underlying concerns regarding the site's relationship to the surrounding residential development from both the land use and site design perspective the operational characteristics of the proposed use could generate traffic noise additional lighting and that causes compatibility concerns accordingly the proposed rezoning does not satisfy the compatibility and neighborhood protection policies under future land use section objective 4.4 and policy 4.4.1 and based on those considerations uh planning commission staff finds that the proposed plan development is inconsistent with the goals objectives and policies of the unincorporated hillsborough county comprehensive plan thank you miss massey um mr rice testified that the planning commission voted unanimously to approve the lip amendment on april 13th of this year i just want to confirm that with you they they voted to find it consistent with the plan yes and uh recommended that it be uh found consistent um um by the board which um that adoption hearing is currently scheduled for january 14th of next year thank you for that information i appreciate it all right we'll go to anyone who would like to speak and support anyone in favor seeing no one anyone in opposition to this request no one all right miss heinrich anything to add no ma'am all right mr rice you have the last word if you'd like it just a couple uh colin rice again for the applicant um not a lot to add i'll just reiterate um our gratitude for development services uh finding of supportability and provability of this project subject to proposed conditions all of which we agreed to it's currently zone cg which can have some interesting uses out there already so this has the benefit of a site plan that's carefully considered as we saw tonight we don't have any opposition at all so i'll close with that if you have any questions happy to answer them otherwise request your support tonight yeah nothing further for me thank you so much i appreciate it we'll close pd rezoning 26-0665 and go to the next case our next application is item d4 pd rezoning 26-0801 the applicant is requesting to rezone property from ldc to plain development sam ballwood development services has reviewed this and will provide staff findings after the applicant's presentation good evening cammy corbett with gardner brewer hudson 400 north ashley drive suite 1100 subject property is 3.7 acres it's along the north side of lutes lake fern road it's in the rural service area and the future land uses res 6 and the as they said the current zoning is lutes downtown center but we'll talk about what the uses are actually approved on the site are in a minute that's just a graphic uh the applicant is learning gate community school they're a tuition free a rated public charter school founded in 1983. they have two locations this is the lutes lake fern campus uh their focus is environmental and they are the first florida's first environmentally focused charter school in 2000 they became designated as that and they are recognized as a u.s department of education green ribbon school so this site actually notwithstanding the zoning has a history of special use approvals for this school um the original special use was in 2007 it was approved for private charter grades k-5 in child care and then there was a special use permit again in 2014 that when you have a special use when you apply for a new special use it effectively rescind your prior use which is not the case with the pd rezoning but ultimately uh in that 2014 amendment or revision to the special use permit they got approval for 205 total children and that's what we're asking for today but we're asking for some flexibility we filed the pd instead of the special use because of that issue with every time you want to make a change you're filing a new special use application as opposed to the new special use application as opposed to being governed by the rules of a pd which provides actually more process for the public uh because there are two hearings uh and it actually goes to the board of county commissioners but it also allows the school a little bit more flexibility so we're not changing the number of students and we're actually proposing to remove an office building off at this site we are asking for two pd of pd variations to allow an existing six foot tall chain link fence to uh with native vegetation along lutes lake urn and to allow an existing vinyl coat fence uh there along the eastern property lines and staff is supporting those pd variations just to allow the existing conditions to occur oops uh staff has found it uh both planning commission and development services have uh found it consistent and supportable and with that we'd respectfully request your approval it's late in the evening all right thank you very much development services good evening uh good evening uh sam ball with uh development services uh the applicant is requesting uh to rezone 3.78 acres from loose downtown center to plan development to allow for a child care and expansion of the existing use from grades six through eight to k-12 with up to 205 children um students and students combined uh the property currently operates as a charter school for up to 205 students grades six through eight under special use um 140470 the property is located approximately 600 feet west of us-41 along the north side of west loops lake fern road except for the residential subdivision to the immediate west that was developed in the 90s many of the residential properties in the vicinity were developed in the 1920s um nearby uses also include a church approximately 150 feet to the west a 960 square foot office across the street to the south and a mixed-use property with a county library and fire station is located across second street northwest to the east staff finds that the variance to allow the continued use of chain links fences with mesh greening and increase to the allowable fence height along second street northwest to address safety concerns will have mental impact on the area additionally staff finds that the current buffering and screening adequately adequately mitigate the impacts of the neighboring properties i'd also like to add that a lot many of the lutes downtown center standards are included in the conditions of approval as critical design features based on these considerations staff finds that the proposed plan development would be compatible with the zoning and development pattern in the area and based on these considerations staff finds proposed rezoning to pd approvable subject to conditions that includes my presentation if you have any questions just to confirm uh you submitted a revised staff report to me earlier and i just want to confirm that was to include the transportation comments is that correct that is correct all right there's no other change that is correct perfect that was my only question thank you so much planning commission jillian massey planning commission staff the site is located within the rural area and in the limits of the lutes community plan it's designated as residential six on the future land use map which is intended for low density residential development the total proposed building area is well below the maximum permitted within the residential six future land use category therefore consistent with the future land use section policy 2.2.1 the applicant has requested two variations in connection with the site that are related to buffering and screening staff supports the requested variations as they will continue to provide adequate mitigation for the use and the adjacent properties while enhancing safety for the students at the school the property is surrounded by compatible public and posit public and residential uses the proposed development will maintain the existing school use with no anticipated adverse impacts to the surrounding surrounding uses therefore the proposal is consistent with future land use section policy 3.1.3 future land use section policy 4.6.1 allows residential support uses within residential commercial and industrial future land use categories provided that the facility is designed and scaled to serve the surrounding neighborhood and remains compatible with the surrounding uses and zoning as the proposed use meets this criteria the request is consistent with those aforementioned objectives and policies the lutes community plan encourages rural fencing materials including chain link fencing as proposed the plan also promotes the use of native vegetation which is also incorporated into the proposal along the portion of the site adjacent to the lake and based on those considerations planning commission staff finds the proposed plan development consistent with the goals objectives and policies of the comprehensive plan subject to the conditions proposed by development services thank you so much is there anyone in the room or online that would like to speak in support see no one anyone in opposition to this request no one uh madam madam madam chair yes ma'am we do have uh somebody online in opposition okay give us your name and address please is that miss let me not mispronounce your name is it gashel gashler uh theresa gashler 422 lock dev and drive loots florida my property is directly behind the learning gate school property which is west of the school uh i have maintained a positive relationship with the administration of learning gate uh in september the principal provided me the opportunity to meet in person and reviews all the proposed changes associated with the requested permit um i wanted for the record uh to note that i currently work from home on a full-time basis and i expect to retire within the next few years so as a result i'm at my residence throughout most of the day i have direct ongoing experience with the school's impact on my neighborhood and the surrounding neighborhood uh the one thing that has not been brought up is the fencing on the western portion of the property and i know that it's been said that they're going to keep a wooden fence but the school currently utilizes that western portion of its property for student resource and outdoor activities and as expected with the school environment there's daily noise and activity associated with student play on numerous occasions students have called out to me personally over the fence while i've been walking my pets in the backyard um and then at night the school operates exterior lighting throughout the night for safety and security purposes but that shines over the fence and i understand the need for adequate security lighting and fixtures but um these shine right into our bedrooms at night and i physically had to tape room darkening material on my bedroom window just to reduce the impact of this um so i just wanted this to be entered into public record because they do relate to some of these proposed changes of the fencing um along the uh southern and eastern portions of the property uh as it poses to them my concern is making sure that there is additional buffering and greenery uh so that it's not such an eyesore for the uh chain link fence with screening um but most importantly um i i need to know that the western portion uh is uh when they do update it that they install a two-foot berm along the western property line before they install a new six-foot fence that way we have a little uh an eight-foot buffer between us uh our neighborhood and the school and it will reduce the visual impact it'll be a more effective separation between the school property and the existing residential neighborhood and um and with that um the only other thing i would say is uh with the school damry zone to host smaller children uh i request the reassurance from the administration that the west side of the property no longer be used for playground for recess and so those are my comments that i wanted to place for record and thank you for your consideration thank you for your time and participation i really appreciate it all right seeing no one else to speak in opposition we'll move back to development services ms heinrich um michelle heinrich development services i just wanted to add that for buffering and screening purposes the maximum height um that is allowed is six feet if they uh wanted eight feet the two two foot berm with the six foot fence that would require a pd variation which isn't part of this request understood all right thank you very much i appreciate it we'll go back to ms corbett you have five minutes for rebuttal cammy corbett again uh just for the record there we are not changing the fencing we're not proposing to change we're asking for pd variations to allow us to keep what we have and just for that clarity and then the school is already approved all we're doing is changing the number the type of grades that could actually um be on the property at any time i'm sure the school will continue to work with their neighbors and try to work out any issues but i don't think anything that was brought up is really germane to what they asked this evening is so we'd respectfully request your approval all right and also i did put some letters of support into the record as well okay earlier thank you thank you very much i appreciate it then with that we'll close rezoning uh pd26-0801 and go to the next case our next item is item d5 major mod 26-1225 the applicant is requesting a major modification to pd05-1107 this has been reviewed by chris greenlenard but i'll present his staff findings tonight after the applicant's presentation all right good evening good evening jennifer malone with gardner brewer hudson 400 north ashley drive suite 1100 i'm here to present on the major modification to a plan development um mm 261225 just to orient everybody the site is about almost 20 acres it is vacant at the northern portion of east college avenue east of 18th street southeast the future land use is residential 12 and it is located within the urban service area the surrounding area um there's a tico substation to the northeast as well as some mobile home parks there is a um law or a commercial office along college avenue to these sites west and a couple scattered commercial uses along college avenue um a little bit of history here in february the site was approved for a plan amendment to the resident to the residential 12 and staff was supported it um this it's citing the increased need for housing and um the evolving character of the college avenue corridor the site is also eligible for the residential infill bonus um consistent with the objective to direct new growth into the urban service area it met all the criteria um specifically it's within the urban service area it's along a collector or arterial the portion eligible for the residential infill bonus is within that 660 feet perpendicular of an arterial or collector the planning commission staff found that the density increase was compatible with destroying development patterns and most importantly i think is promoting residential infill on a vacant site applied through the rezoning um so with that the request before you is 256 dwelling units within multiple buildings we are requesting two access points along with a couple infrastructure improvements um a 10 and 5 foot sidewalk along 18th street a sidewalk along along third some milling and resurfacing um per our approvable design exception and remaining sensitive to the surrounding area it's um the height is greater along college avenue but lower um per the conditions of approval to the east to that residential that that it butts up against and we are complying with the um two to one setback within the land development code um there's a lot of comprehensive plan support i've kind of already touched on this but here's a couple policies that the planning commission staff cited supporting a range of housing options and affordability to meet the current and future residents doing that by providing a variety of housing options which this application is doing um and it was found approvable consistent and no objections from the rest of the departments and the request before you is that this is recommended approval subject to the conditions of approval and that concludes my presentation i have one question i understand there's a plan plan development variation request yes for um the trees that are in proximity to power lines and so forth yes um my question was the requirement is it's a scenic corridor requirement that they be planted every 40 feet and so my question is are you just talking about changing the type of tree but you'll still provide the required number of trees trees are you asking for trees that are a more low growing in proximity to those or are you reducing overall the number of trees i would actually that variation was added and i there was some back and forth at the last minute with development services because we thought that we could handle it in a condition of approval um and we want to make sure that we're meeting that corridor but there are overhead lines and so what is before you was we came to an agreement with the county staff but i would need to look at that language again and confirm with miss heinrich about the the specifics okay um so i guess we can address that when we go to your part all right yeah perfect okay all right thank you thank you perfect don't forget to sign in yes miss heinrich michelle heinrich development services staff reviewed a major modification of pd05 1107 which seeks to modify the permitted uses from 76 townhomes and 24 000 square feet of office and commercial uses to 256 multi-family units uh utilizing the residential uh residential density bonus infill bonus found in the comprehensive plan the resulting density will be 13 units per acre year the project proposes a maximum building height of 50 feet and they will comply with the two-to-one setback for non-front yards required buffering and screening is also provided uh the applicant does request one pd variation which is to the urban scenic corridor requirements along college avenue uh the requirement is per the code is twofold it is uh one street tree per 40 feet and then one shade tree tree per 50 feet and what the applicant is proposing which was agreed to by natural resources is to only provide the street trees and this was mainly due to there's some limited right-of-way and also overhead power lines all right that answers my question thank you and uh staff received no objections from reviewing agencies and recommends approval subject to proposed conditions all right thank you so much um planning commission jillian massey planning commission staff the subject sites in the urban service area and within the limits of the ruskin community plan and south hillsborough county plan it's designated as residential 12 on the future land use map based on the existing land use contact surrounding development pattern and the site's relationship to nearby commercial residential and vacant uses the proposed multi-family development is compatible with the surrounding area and consistent with future land use section objective 3.1 and policy 3.1.3 regarding compatibility the applicant is requesting to utilize future land use section policy 4.9.6 for a residential density bonus for infill development after reviewing the site staff determined that the project meets all the required criteria and provides for residential infill on a vacant or redevelopment site that is within the urban service area where strip residential currently exists and the site is within 660 foot distance of an arterial or collector with approximately 11.67 acres within the qualifying area that is 660 feet from a collector or arterial the site may qualify for a maximum density of 280 units the applicant is requesting a total of 256 units which is under the maximum allowable density with the infill bonus and is therefore consistent with the future land use section policy 4.9.6 the sites located within the limits of the Ruskin community plan and south hellsboro county plan goal 5 of the Ruskin plan seeks to provide for a diversity of home styles and types while protecting Ruskin small town character one strategy outlined under this goal is to support housing to accommodate a diverse population and income levels the addition of multi-family units within an area with a mix of residential types including single family two-family mobile homes and multi-family development aligns with goal 5 and its associated strategies by providing additional opportunities and types of housing along a major corridor within the community and based on those considerations planning commission staff finds that the modification is consistent with the goals objectives and policies of the unincorporated hillsborough county comprehensive plan subject to the conditions proposed by the development services thank you so much is there anyone in the audience or online that would like to speak and support anyone in favor seeing no one anyone in opposition to this request no one miss Heinrich anything to add no ma'am unless you have any questions no no you answered my question thank you so much we'll go back to the applicant anything further you went too far um nothing further thank you okay thank you so much then with that we'll close major modification 26-1225 and go to the next case our next application is item d6 major mod 26-1231 the applicant is requesting a major modification to pd 17-1397 uh sam ball with development services has reviewed this and will provide staff comments um also i believe uh mr ball already handed to you or will be handing to you there is a revision uh from natural resources to condition 17. he did yes thank you so much good evening good evening cammy court with garden brewer hudson subject property is located south of big bend um right along us 301 just north of simmons loop road it's an 18.91 acre site future land uses sm6 and it's currently zoned pd and you can see there are many pds around it the ipd to directly to the south is self-storage and you've got multi-family uh surrounding the property this uh zoning was originally approved in 2018 the site is owned by tampa general hospital and affiliated um entities associated with them the permitted permitted development allows up to 288 a thousand four hundred twelve square feet of medical office retail bpo and other cg uses what we're asking for is two options one is to option one to retain the existing approvals just as it is so there's no effect to the uh existing zoning and then an option two which essentially breaks up the site into two building envelopes one envelope a for 50 000 square feet of uses uh retaining the original development standards and then envelope b which is 145 000 square foot of large-scale retail uses uh with the setbacks that set forth on the the zoning site plan uh in order to gain staff support uh due to the proximity of the multi-family on the west side we are providing additional uh buffering and uh screening and uh a eight foot masonry wall which we have a pd variation for along that western boundary uh a lot of those structures that are directly adjacent to that property are parking structures at the apartment complex but we did agree to go ahead and provide that wall anyway and then we are providing 20-foot type b buffering around the rest of the perimeter and so we have two a couple pd variations again no buffer along the northern pd boundary where vehicular and pedestrian access is shared cross-axis is shared in both the north and south side and then we're also asking for a waiver to the ldc outdoor display areas for large big boxes and that's one of the reasons why you see the 20-foot type b buffer all the way around the site was to sort of as an alternative to screen them within the site and these are typical things that you would see at a big box store sheds and those types of things that are a pretty typical and staff is supporting the waiver we have no objections from any reviewing agencies planning commission is in support and development services has found it's provable subject to the conditions we've not had any phone calls there's not any letters of objection that we're aware of um we'll certainly hear if there's anyone here this evening that has any objection but i think it's pretty straightforward request and we'd respectfully request your approval just one clarification the pd variation is only in the area of the cross access to the north and south is that correct there's a pd variation allowed to allow the eight foot masonry wall right so we have a pd variation for that then there's pd variation pd variations pd variations for the cross access yeah i think that's what i missed i missed the the eight foot wall i was assuming they were two variations because it's two cross access to the north and the south but you're saying there's an eight foot wall yes along the western boundary okay i'll find it thank you so much i appreciate it uh development services if you're done okay good evening good evening uh sam ball of hillsborough county development services uh pd 17 1397 was approved in 2018 to allow the property to be developed for bpo and cg uses the applicant is requesting this modification to allow for the second development option which would allow for retail excuse me large-scale retail medical office with or which with or without emergency room use and uh in reconfiguring what would be option a uh the the subject property covers approximately 18.9 acres located along the west side of us highway 301 uh approximately one half mile south of big ben road the immediate area is primarily developed for single-family and multi-family use other uses in the area include medical office office and religious institutions if approved the allowable development for the new option would be a maximum of 195 000 square feet um which of a medical office emergency room large-scale retail and the other uses permitted within bpo and uh cg zoning districts um the c the two to one setback would not be in effect for buildings taller than than 20 feet uh the type b buffer along us 301 is intended to shield the um outdoor display areas which the for the uh for the waiver uh its approval would also include that eight foot wall in the rear of the property where six feet would normally be the maximum uh and the um the the landscape buffer in the front uh instead of having a six foot wall the the wall or fence or shrubs basically they would be limited to four feet with the plant b um type b plannings uh staff finds that all the variations and waivers meet the intent of the code and will have minimal effect on the neighboring properties additionally staff finds that the 93 412 square foot reduction in gross floor area and the 30 foot max height reduction from 75 feet associated with envelope b would reduce the impacts of the neighboring properties uh based on the surrounding zoning and development pattern and the proposed development standard staff finds this request approvable that concludes my presentation if you have any questions none of this time thank you so much appreciate it planning commission jillian massey planning commission staff the site's located in the urban service area and within the boundaries of the riverview and south hillsborough county community plans it's designated as suburban mixture six on the future land use map future land use section objective 1.1 directs the majority of the county's anticipated growth and development into the urban service area while objective 2.2 and policy 2.2.1 establish the allowable uses and maximum intensities within each future land use category the proposed maximum building envelope area of 195 000 square feet represents a floor area ratio of approximately 0.24 and is below the maximum intensity permitted by the designation additionally future land use section objective 3.1 and policy 3.1.3 objective 4.4 and policy 4.4.1 require new development to maintain compatibility with the surrounding uses and provide appropriate mitigation of potential impacts the applicant has proposed enhanced buffering and screening along along the residential property boundaries including a 20 foot wide buffer with type b screening along the northern boundary an enhanced 20 foot wide buffer with evergreen shade trees planted every 15 feet along the western boundary an eight foot masonry law a masonry wall along the western pd boundary an additional additional operational restrictions are proposed that are intended to reduce potential noise visual and operational impacts to the adjacent residential properties the proposed development also supports the riverview community plans vision for the u.s highway 301 corridor as a mixed use area with a variety of businesses and services that contribute to the community's economic well-being and based on those considerations planning commission staff finds the proposed major modification consistent with the goals objectives and policies of the unincorporated hillsborough county comprehensive plan subject to the conditions proposed by the development services department thank you so much is there anyone in the room or online that would like to speak in support seeing no one anyone in opposition to this request no one miss heinrich anything further no ma'am all right miss corbett anything can be corporate just i wanted to clarify i have seen that revised natural resources condition and i we are in agreement with it which just tracks more closely with the code than the prior condition so i understand that with that we'll close thank you so much i appreciate it then we'll close major modification 26-1231 i'm going to take um normally i break at 10 but i'm going to break now and then we'll come back in five minutes so if you could be back here by nine let's just say 9 55 and we'll finish out the hearing thank you so much all right welcome back to the november 16th 2026 zoning hearing master meeting hearing we are back from our break and miss heinrich we are ready for the next case our next application is item d5 major mod 26-1358 the applicant is requesting a modification to pd 86-0149 tim lampkin with development services has reviewed this and will provide staff findings after the applicant's presentation all right good evening good evening clay matthews from smoker matthews 100 south ashley drive suite 850 tampa florida 33602 and i have been sworn um also with us here today is our client's traffic engineer steve henry um we are here on if this is is this showing the presentation i see it now yes okay uh we are here on an application for a major modification to a planned development um in short we are seeking to redevelop a site of an existing gas station into a new gas station which includes a needing establishment and a drive-through and development services staff has found the project supportable with conditions which we are thankful for the location just to give your bearings the property is located in dover at the corner of us 92 and mcintosh road just some brief background about the subject property the zoning is obviously pd the future land uses as res one we are in the rural service area the site is 3.82 acres and we are in the sefner mango community plan area we are not in an overlay district as to the surrounding uses we are surrounded by a mix of uses with the more intense uses around the intersection of us 92 and mcintosh road to the north there's a warehouse rv park private school to the east there's another gas station with gas pumps um a convenience store and to the south and west are agricultural uses or agriculturally zoned parcels with single family residences and to the west there is um there are a lot of crops and what appears to be a fairly intense agricultural or farming operation um the current existing um pd approval is pd 86 149 and that approval was for 4 130 square feet of for a convenience store and gas pumps along with 19 425 square feet for commercial for the max building height 35 feet and we provided an excerpt of that prior pd approval there on screen um as you can see the the proposed convenience store right there is the only thing that's out there on the site currently that was constructed along with the gas pumps the proposed commercial retail center you see there on the southern part of the parcel that was never constructed so that was approved but but never constructed for the proposed major modification that we're on today the proposals for 5 000 square feet convenience store which includes inside of it a 1200 square foot eating establishment with the drive-through and my client just advised me that they recently determined that that drive-through that eating establishment will be for a new coffee concept with typical coffee shop operating hours that's relevant which i'll i'll get to in a moment the use also includes 12 gas pumps and a maximum height of 25 feet obviously we are removing the 19 425 square feet of commercial so while that was previously approved we're taking that out of the entitlements we're including a 20 feet type b buffer on the southern and western property boundaries on the southern side we our client has agreed to include a six foot high masonry wall to provide additional screening to the residential use to the south although that's not required by code our client has agreed to add that i'll i'll touch on that more in a moment and there are no request no waivers requested that's the transportation steve henry is here to testify it's anything transportation related but i'll just add a few notes on transportation related issues the staff has found the connectivity and cross access that to meet the ldc transportation staff has no objection subject to conditions um the proposed the proposal removes two access connections and i will scroll back up to the prior the prior site plan on the northeast corner of the parcel there you can see the two access connections that are pretty close to mcintosh road in us 92 the intersection of in us 92 and mcintosh road we're removing both of those access connections and we are adding right-of-way improvements on us 92 and mcintosh road we're adding a right-hand turn lane on us 92 and a left and right-hand turn lane on mcintosh road and our client has applied for administrative variance for access spacing on mcintosh road which is found to be approvable by staff and again mr henry can answer any questions you may have on that administrative variance again development services staff has found the proposal supportable with conditions which we appreciate there's been no objections from any other agencies and again the transportation staff finds administrative variance approvable planning commission they i think their their staff report is overall mostly favorable to our proposal um in their in their staff report they note that the proposed commercial use and overall intensity generally is consistent with the res one future land use designation the site meets commercial locational criteria and the proposed use supports the visions and goals of the seffner mango community plan however they found the proposal ultimately to be inconsistent with the comp plan due to one limited issue and that list that issue is the distance between the proposed speaker box and the single family residents to the south on that agriculturally zone parcel and we i think that issue sort of derives from from land development code provision that does not apply in this situation and staff agrees that it doesn't apply but they just want to see some additional mitigation i do want to touch on that that that that that code provision just to talk through it very briefly flint development code section 611 25 b addresses eating establishments and drive-through services for eating establishments and under b1 which provides and i've highlighted the language there no order box used in the ordering of food or beverages from a drive-through window shall be located within 200 feet of any property zoned residential the parcel to the south which is the parcel in concern it's zoned asc one it's zoned ag so it's not that that provision does not apply and we discuss it with staff they agree it doesn't apply but they just wanted to see some additional mitigation offered for that for that residence we're obviously doing the type b buffer which is required 20 foot type b buffer but our client has agreed to do a six foot high masonry wall although not required by that provision we had a lot of conversations with staff about trying to address the the concerns with the compatibility of the residents they suggested potentially moving the improvements north to increase the distance but we cannot move the improvements any farther north due to right-of-way preservation on the north side along us 92 we were reserving about 80 feet on the north side along us 92 so we can't move anything more north they also suggested potential hours of operations restrictions but our client isn't isn't willing to do that because it would limited potential new users down the road but for now that user is going to be a coffee shop user which is going to have typical coffee shop hours of operation which will hopefully end you know early in the in the evening will not go late into the night or certainly not all night long so i think the hours while our client isn't willing to agree to a condition of approval i think the hours issue will sort of resolve itself given the actual user and notably our client did go to the residence about a year ago and they when they started pursuing this project and spoke to the owner and the owner and told them they'd be constructing a new gas station with the drive-through and the owner didn't express any opposition we haven't received any opposition today i don't i don't know if that person's here today but we haven't seen any opposition um to date notably that the the where the speaker box will be our civil engineer measured it to be about 135 feet from the residence and i've included a little aerial that's overlaid or a site plan that's overlaid on an aerial with that measurement and he measured it to be about 135 feet so while we're not 200 feet away and i know that provision doesn't apply we're pretty close to meeting the code requirement um anyway there and finally we're second to last here we i've included an aerial from 1992 showing that that residence has been next to this gas station since at least 1992. i think if the pd was approved in 86 it was probably developed sometime in the late 80s so that house has been there next to that gas station for well over 30 35 years and they've existed um in harmony next to each other um and um and i noted that our client met with the owner and to wrap up um just to respond to staff's comments the planning commission's comments and their staff report they noted that based on the speaker box issue we're inconsistent with a couple objectives and policies we respectfully contend that we are consistent with those those policies i'm just to touch on a few points that relate to these on the screen the project replaces an existing use with an almost identical use in an almost identical configuration it's been there for a long long time and we think that recognizes the existing community and is designed in a way that it's compatible with the established character of the surrounding neighborhood policy 3.1.3 notes that some elements affecting compatibility include the following height scale mass and bulk of structures pedestrian or vehicular traffic circulation access and parking impacts landscaping lighting noise odor and architecture we think our proposal improves and is sensitive to almost all of those items we reduce building height we reduce the scale of entitlements we reduce the entitled mass and bulk of structures we improve vehicular circulation our traffic and circulation by making them much more safe by removing some of those access connections doing the right-of-way improvements in the neighborhood adding landscaping buffering um in that masonry wall we've you know i think improved the landscaping screening buffering buffering out there so we think that improves and enhances the surrounding community which addresses the the second objective in policy that the planning commission has noted um and i think that those same arguments apply to objective 4.4 as to policy 4.4.1 um again this is a creation of a like use it's the same use that's currently existing um we are creating uh complementary uses the coffee shop is certainly a complimentary use to it to a convenience store um it's right along the lines i think it's a perfect comment complimentary use for an existing neighborhood commercial use um and we think we've adequate more than adequately mitigated for the adverse impacts and we're doing everything we can do to mitigate for those potential adverse impacts um and obviously the transportation connections will be vastly improved by removing the two connections and making right away improvements so lastly just to wrap up and some development services staff support supportable with conditions the use is consistent with res 1 and meets locational criteria supports the vision and goals of sephner mango community plan improvements to access connections offside right away improvements and we're reducing the entitlements by removing those 19 000 plus square feet of commercial we're reducing the the permitted building height we are not requesting any waivers from the land development code and we're not aware of any public opposition including the resident to the south which seems to be the only the only issue here before you so with that um respectfully request your recommendation of approval and here to answer any questions you may have just one quick question regarding the um 1200 square foot eating establishment fast food piece is that included in the 5 000 square feet yes could it be a separate structure it's not to my knowledge it's planned to be one structure the intent is all within 5 000 square feet and then the order box is in that building that one building correct perfect that's all i needed thank you so much i appreciate it don't forget to sign in all right development services good evening good evening uh tim lambkin development services so this request is to rezone approximately just under four acre property uh it's located on the west side of mcintosh road and south of us highway 92 and the proposed development is consists of a 5 000 square foot structure with a maximum height of 25 feet it's consisting of a convenience store with up to uh 1200 square feet dedicated to an eating establishment the subject property is it's uh surrounded by a mix of existing land uses including an rv park to the north gas station to the east private school to the northeast uh property immediately west is agriculturally zoned and contains a single family and the stormwater pond will be located east of the required buffer providing additional separation although the land development code does not require an additional speaker box adjacent to agriculturally zoned property it was identified uh compatibility concerns given the existing single-family residence on the adjacent property and as the applicant uh discussed uh they're providing the required 20 foot with type b uh screening and um with the six foot high masonry wall in this instance um so the wall is proposed as a condition of approval it should be noted that the existing residence to the south as the applicant stated is located further approximately 65 feet south of the subject property resulting in an effective separation as they showed of more than 100 feet and the proposed masonry wall will provide additional compatibility protection regardless of the existing residence location the applicant has not requested any variations of the land development code and based upon those considerations staff finds uh the request supportable do you have any questions i do not thank you so much appreciate it planning commission julianne massey planning commission staff the site is in the rural area and within the limits of the cefner mango community plan it's designated as residential one on the future land use map the subject site meets commercial locational criteria as established under future land use section objective 4.9 goal 3 of the cefner mango community plan states that commercial development should be directed to us 92 and martin luther king boulevard corridors and further encourages read of revitalization and redevelopment of older existing commercial areas and uses the proposed commercial redevelopment is located along us highway 92 and aligns with goal 3 of the community plan future land use section objective 3.1 and policy 3.1.3 require new development to be compatible with the surrounding existing development patterns the existing land use pattern in the immediate area is predominant predominantly comprised of single-family residential and agricultural uses which is established which establish a low density rural residential character with the addition of the drive-through eating establishment there is a proposed speaker box that is oriented towards and within 50 feet of the southern boundary of the site directly abutting the southern boundary where the speaker box is oriented is in an existing single-family residence the southern property adjacent to the site is currently designated asd1 which according to the hillsborough county development services staff is considered an agricultural zoning under the land development code and therefore the speaker box is not required to meet the requirement in the code about the ordering of food or beverages from a drive-through window being located within 200 feet of any property being zoned residential the applicant is currently proposing a masonry wall along the southern property line with a 50-foot separation from the speaker box to the property line while the speaker box is not required to meet these requirements in the land development code planning commission staff has concerns with the distance of the speaker box from the property as it contains a single-family residence under current conditions the planning commission staff requested additional mitigation measures such as operating hour restrictions for the drive-through use and the speaker box only however the applicant has been unable to commit to any operating restrictions or adjust the call box location in any way based upon the proximity to the single-family and distance of only 50 feet from the abutting property from the proposed speaker box the proposed rezoning is inconsistent with the intent of future land use section objective 3.1 policy 3.1.1 objective 4.4 and policy 4.4.1 based on those considerations planning commission staff finds that the proposed rezoning is inconsistent with the goals objectives and policies of the unincorporated hillsborough county comprehensive plan thank you uh miss massey i just want to confirm for the record the planning commission acknowledges that it's not a requirement they don't have to there's not a separation requirement because it's zoned agricultural um the gentleman testified that it was i believe 134 feet between the establishment and the single-family home with a commitment to put in a not required six foot masonry wall but the planning commission still has compatibility concerns yes um staff acknowledges that the that the requirement that they're not required to meet what the code says about um the distance because technically it's not zoned residential however there is a residence on the property and although there are physical barriers that have been um proposed that certainly help with the concerns i think um the concern still lies with some of the operational characteristics such as the noise and um you know that like the hours of operation thank you for that i appreciate it all right we'll call for anyone who would like to speak in support in the room or online anyone in favor see no one anyone in opposition to this request no one miss heinrich anything else no ma'am all right sir you have the last word if you'd like it just a couple quick points um i just want to emphasize that we're doing everything we physically can to to mitigate for the speaker box issue like i said we can't move the improvements north due to the right-of-way preservation and then we can't move the speaker box anywhere else on the building it has to be on the south side where the the parking and the traffic will queue up to the speaker box and then allow it to exit out to the access connection on macintosh if you put it anywhere else the cars will queue and then distribute um in a way on site internally that could cause conflict points and would be unsafe and mr henry can testify to that if needed so there's just nowhere else to put the speaker box um in terms of the location planning commission noted um that you know the speaker box is 50 feet from the property boundary and while that is true and that is a condition of approval there still is another 85 feet from that property boundary to the residence so like i like the aerial showed 135 feet from the residence to the speaker box and there's no there's no evidence in the record that would what that would demonstrate that you could even hear the speaker box from the residence from that far away especially with the landscaping and the wall put there um and on top of that even if you could hear there's no evidence in the record that would that it would exceed the noise that's been coming from that gas station for the past you know 35 plus years so in all likelihood it might just be consistent with what's been going on with that gas station and the gas station across the street on the corner and the other intense commercial uses that are around that intersection which actually is fairly intensive um at that intersection and so and to the contrary we submit that the speaker box would be consistent with your typical neighborhood commercial type uses which are permitted on that parcel and are compatible with that residential use and the future land use designation which permit neighborhood commercial obviously um and again i'll just reiterate um the the intended user the user that they've determined is going to be a coffee shop and so you know the hours while our clients not agreeable to the hours of operation condition of approval this might just resolve itself because the hours are going to be reasonable anyways they're not it's not going to go late in the night it's not going to be overnight it would not be disturbing that residents to the south i mean again no opposition from that residents to the south and so with that again we respectfully request your recommendation of approval thank you so much thank you and we'll close major modification 26-1358 and go to the next case our next application is item d8 pd 26-1366 the applicant is requesting to rezone from cn to planned development james bakerwood development services has reviewed this and will present staff findings after the applicant's presentation all right it's the applicant here good evening good evening again colin rice uh 1000 west cast law from boulder lending for the applicants a couple of visuals for you all right so here on behalf of the property owner and applicant uh mag genesis property holdings llc are requesting rezoning from commercial neighborhood to plan development i'm again joined by margaret perez bruce mccarthur and theo petrich of landis evans should you have any technical questions so more specifically um mag genesis um is associated with a number of car dealerships in the area the intent for this site is to have overflow storage of new vehicle inventory with supportive features like detailing reconditioning and fleet management the site will not be open to the public um no car sales will take place on site so to orient you uh we're in the greater carolwood northdale community planning area off of bears and i-275 it's about 2.4 acres future land uses oc20 uh not proposing to change and is shared by all adjacent property owners zooming in here our site is outlined in red wedge between 275 and fdot owned property to the north this is an ihop this is an extended stay hotel here's just an image from the northern end of the ihop uh property into the undeveloped land we're proposing for tonight here's just a zoom in of the site plan pretty basic no no far requested no heated area it's it's really just ingress and vehicular storage uh they'll pave the dry vials but the the vehicles will be on grass per the conditions um and again no structures but they'll have things like sheds or carports for detail and not to exceed 20 feet in height we're fine with all the conditions of approval uh we're grateful for finding of approvability from development services and all reviewing agencies um so i will conclude and happy to answer any questions you have all submit these to the record as well just to um for the record just to talk about the pd variation that you're requesting um that 30 foot buffer to 15 and you're reducing the screening um can you just go over the reasons for that sure set this back here so uh as you'll see in the conditions of approval as well this is a somewhat wooded site so the overall area available for the intended use is is already somewhat constrained and so there's some features there that we're being cognizant of and particularly as you see the ingress up to the north if you were to go to 30 feet there it would really pinch your ingress point as well so given the existing uh development use patterns out there we felt as though the 15 foot was acceptable and we're fortunate that staff has uh submitted a approval staff report as well okay so due to the stormwater requirements that's what constrains the ability to provide that buffer stormwater and the existing vegetation because we don't know which trees are slated able to be removed or not so it's it's a balance in trying to provide some buffering but keeping operative space too i see okay that was my only question okay thank you so much appreciate it development services good evening good evening james baker development services the applicant's requesting to rezone the property that's zoned currently commercial neighborhood to plan development 260672 for open storage of overflow vehicle inventory vehicle detailing and reconditioning fleet management and other functions in support of off-site automobile automobile dealerships also the pd variation is for a 15 foot buffer with type b screening where a 30 foot buffer with type c screening is required along the western property boundary also there's a slight correction in terms of the property that is to the west is actually a multi-family property it's no longer a static stay hotel so it is changed but it was a pd that they changed it from a extended state to a multi-family apartment complex is that the reason for the revised staff report well that's part that's partially it as well the subject site is located one parcel north of bears avenue immediately west of interstate 275 which directly abuts the eastern boundary the site is situated behind adjacent to existing commercial development along bears avenue to the north is undeveloped land owned by the florida department of transportation is designated for um stormwater retention pond and to the west is the planned development designated for multi-family residential use while a restaurant ihop is classified as a neighborhood commercial use that's located to the south staff does not foresee any compatibility issues and so we approve subject to conditions all right if you could just tell me um the reason for the uh revised staff report just so i make sure i pick it up well this one's a situation where there was a apartment complex or extended stay and now it's multi-families of pd it was changed several years ago i think it was okay and so that's the reason that's the reason okay perfect yeah i think also the transportation report was included i think right and transportation they were kind of delayed so we had to go ahead and submit the update okay perfect all right thank you very much i appreciate it no further questions planning commission uh jillian massey planning commission staff the site is in the urban service area and within the limits of the greater carolwood northdale community plan it's designated as office commercial 20 on the future land use map the proposed open storage use is within the permitted development intensity for the site and consistent with future land use section objective 2.2 and policy 2.2.1 future land use section objective 3.1 states that new developments should recognize the existing community and be designed in a way that is compatible with the established character of the surrounding neighborhood the proposed use for the site is consistent with the site's office commercial 20 designation one of the most intensive categories on the future land use map for unincorporated county and is compatible with the surrounding development pattern which consists primarily of commercial and vacant properties excuse me the applicant is requesting a variation to allow a 15 foot buffer with type b screening or a 30 foot buffer with type c screening is required along the western property boundary this boundary is adjacent to a commercial use and the requested relief is not anticipated to have an adverse impact on the adjacent property and is expected to maintain compatibility between the proposed use and the surrounding development the site is within a center and connection area which is intended to focus the county's redevelopment and infill efforts by promoting residential and commercial choices encouraging economic growth improving present conditions of infrastructure and leveraging reinvestment in these areas the proposed development supports the intent of the this designation by contributing to the range of commercial activities within the area and based upon those considerations planning commission staff finds the proposed plan development consistent with the goals objectives and policies of the unincorporated hillsborough county conference of plans subject to the conditions proposed by development services thank you so much is there anyone in the room or online that would like to speak in support anyone in favor seeing no one anyone in opposition to this request no miss heinrich anything else no ma'am mr rice you have the last word like it thank you just one other quick note uh colin rice for the applicant um with respect to the open storage proposed it's pretty different in character and intensity from what you typically think of as open storage it's not shipping containers it's not slabs of granite it's just operative passenger brand new passenger vehicles that are staying there until they go to the dealership lot so i just wanted to put a little finer point on why another reason for the variation all right with that i'll conclude and thank you thank you appreciate your time all right we'll close rezoning pd 26-1366 and go to the last case our next item is item d9 pd 26-1370 the applicant is requesting to rezone property from ar to plan development this does have a companion comprehensive plan amendment which is scheduled to be heard on january 14th and as noted earlier in the uh meeting for other cases for development services staff we did review this under ldc section 100304h which assumes that the uh comprehensive plan amendment that's been proposed is approved thank you so much jared follen will review uh provide staff findings okay perfect good evening thank you good evening isabel algrop with half i'm a certified planner 1000 north ashley drive uh as ms heinrich said this site is um located at the southwest corner of cockroach road and 41. it is approximately seven acres and there is a pending application for light industrial plan it is currently zoned ar and we are requesting for plan development so here's the um pd plan it's basically reflecting what's currently there right now uh we are requesting for up to 51 700 square feet of manufacturing processing and assembling uses and um this is again going to be heard um concurrently with the comprehensive plan amendment that we have um here we are requesting two variation because of the proposed use adjacent to agricultural um zoning to the um west we are required to have a 30 foot buffer with a type c screening and require we're requesting a 30 foot buffer with the type b screening the property to the uh adjacent to us is um actually has been used and used for pretty intensive agricultural uses for um and therefore we found that the 20 or the 30 b does still meet the intent of compatibility between the two uses and the other uh variation that we're requesting is for the buffer and screening along the railroad track and we're required requesting to waive that because there's going to be no compatibility issues whether we have it or not it was supposed to be a 15 b so again in terms of compatibility this area is in the south shore area and um it is quite uh you know intensive in terms of non-residential use it's pretty heavy agricultural uses or commercial uses we have teco farms there and so therefore there's no compatibility concerns and with that that's why staff from the planning commission found it consistent uh with the comprehensive plan and again uh stated numerous policies in their uh staff report as well as the development services staff found it that uh it was uh comparable uh it's late the evening it's a great request all right thank you so much and again i'm here if you have any questions not at this time thank you don't forget to sign in development services good evening jerry fawn with development services uh so yes this is a request to rezone a site zone ar agricultural rural to a pd in order to allow up to uh 51 700 square feet of uses permitted in the m manufacturing zoning district uh so this site um it's located in a primarily agricultural area uh there is a commercial node to the to the east uh it's also some residential not very close by um the site is up against a uh was owned by csx transportation railroad track uh which is also up against highway 41 uh the site is also it's currently developed with about 18 000 square feet of warehouse use currently um and so this this pd will increase that amount of permitted uses for m to be about uh increased by about 18 000 square feet um so they're asking for two variations one to the west which is uh adjacent to ar uh it's currently being used for crop agriculture uh there's no uh single family to the adjacent side um we're not finding any compatibility issues with that variation request um they are asking for basically far of 0.17 which is much lower than what's usually allowed in the m district and the height uh that they're proposing is 50 feet rather than 110 feet so all in all we don't have any compatibility concerns with this project and recommend approval thank you so much i appreciate it planning commission jillian massey planning commission staff the site is in the rural area and within the limits of the little manatee south community plan and the south hillsborough county plan it's currently located in the agricultural rural one to five future land use category however there is a pending comprehensive plan amendment to change the future land use to light industrial planned this request for a plan development is considered concurrent and dependent upon the approval of hccpa 26-27 and the analysis is based upon the pending uh lip future land use designation approval based on the site's location surrounding land use pattern and rural character of the area staff found that the proposed request is compatible with the existing and planned development in the vicinity the request is consistent with the intent of future land use section objective 1.2 policy 3.2 3.1.2 and 3.1.3 as it would allow for development in a manner that can be integrated with the surrounding uses while maintaining compatibility and protecting community character the proposal is consistent with the uses and intensity allowed under the light industrial planned future land use category therefore the request is consistent with objective 2.1 and policy 2.2 point 1 in the future land use section given its location between agricultural industrial and vacant land the subject site functions as a transitional area where higher intensity non-residential development can be integrated without disrupting the character of the surrounding development the proposed plan development aligns with these principles and is consistent with future land use section objective 4.4 and policy 4.4.1 the proposed request is consistent with and furthers the intent of goal 5 of the little manatee south community plan and goal 1a of the south hillsborough county plan as outlined in the livable communities element of the comprehensive plan as the proposed plan development would provide economic development for the area so based on those considerations uh planning commission staff finds that the proposed plan development is consistent with the goals objectives and policies of the unincorporated hillsborough county comprehensive plan subject to the conditions proposed by development services thank you so much i appreciate it is there anyone in the room or online that would like to speak in support see no one anyone in opposition to this request no one miss heinrich anything further no ma'am miss albert anything okay then with that we will close rezoning pd26-1370 and adjourn the hearing thank you all for your time and testimony