Civic › Fort Lauderdale, FL › November 17, 2026

City Commission Regular Meeting on 2026-11-17 6:00 PM - Nov 17, 2026

Fort Lauderdale, FL City Commission November 17, 2026 187 minutes
▶ Watch original video Interactive viewer Search Fort Lauderdale meetings

Transcript

Speaker0:01

Good evening, everybody. Good evening. I know everyone's excited tonight, so why don't we begin with our meeting. First of all, my name is Dean Trantelos, the mayor of the city of Fort Lauderdale, and I want to thank you all for being here tonight. For those of you who are here for the first time, welcome. We have a certain set of things that we go through when we begin our meeting, and that includes a Pledge of Allegiance. So to help lead us in tonight's pledge, I'd like to invite Sailor Torres, a fifth grader from Creuson Park Elementary, Grace McGriff, who's a sixth grader from Sunrise Middle School, Carter Park Trip Program, and Aidan Starks, a sixth grader at the Renaissance Charter, Carter Park Trip Program. If you please come to the podium and join me. If I could ask everyone to please rise. Future leaders of America. So, if you could please all join me in a moment of silence. Thank you so much. Mr. Clerk, please call the roll. Commissioner Moraitis? Here. Commissioner Glossman? Here. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Here. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Here. Mayor Trintas? Here. So we have full attendance. Tonight we are welcoming a newly elected city commissioner, and she's sitting to my left. This is Heather Moraitis. Thank you so much. Representing District 1, welcome. And congratulations on your success. Looking forward to continuing to work with you. We have an agenda announcement, which means that R5 is going to be moved to the end of the agenda because it's related to OSR 1. Excuse me. And a couple of agenda item revisions. CR4, the CAM, on page 11, were revised to correct the dollar amount the city collected in park impact fees. M6, Exhibit 6, Planning and Zoning Board draft minutes, that was added. And R7, Exhibit 2, Official Certified Results of the 2026 Special Municipal Elections District 1 Commissioner and Charter Amendments was added. So, may I please have a motion to approve the minutes and the agenda as amended? Moved. Second. It's been moved and seconded. Please call the roll. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glossman? Yes. Mayor Trintas? Yes. And those in the agenda as amended and the minutes are now approved. Now, at the beginning of the meeting, before we get into the regular agenda, we take some time to recognize individuals, organizations, or events that take place in our city. And tonight we have three presentations to recognize those things that are now happening in our city. So, our first presentation, I'd like to invite Tina Jamarillo, who's our Chief Education Officer, and she's going to talk to us about the Fort Lauderdale-Stranahan Innovation Zone Student Recognition, and she'll be calling up the individual students in this regard. Tina. Good evening, commissioners, staff, and neighbors. Thank you so much. At this time, I'd like to invite Vice Mayor Sorensen and Commissioner Beasley-Pittman to join me at the podium to help present certificates and gifts. Do you want to do gifts or certificates? I'll do gifts. Our first honoree is Minoeska Michel from Croissant Park Elementary. Here's what her school had to say. Minoeska is a kind, respectful, and responsible student who treats others with compassion and consideration. She works cooperatively with her peers, willingly helps classmates, and contributes positively to the classroom environment. Minoeska takes responsibility for her learning, follows school expectations, and exhibits strong control in her actions and decisions. She shows respect for students and adults alike, and serves as a positive role model through her honesty, dependability, and positive attitude. Congratulations, Minoeska. Our next honoree is Kayleen Alarcon Perez from Riverland Elementary. Here's what her school had to say. Kayleen truly represents what it means to be a person of strong character. She is dependable, works well with others, and treats everyone with compassion and consideration. She respects differences, makes thoughtful choices, and takes pride in doing what is right. She is also a resilient student who perseveres through challenges, learns from difficult experiences, and continues to move forward with a positive attitude. Most importantly, she leads by example and positively impacts those around her. Her character, maturity, and willingness to support others make her an exceptional role model for her peers. Congratulations, Kayleen. Our third honoree is Rosangela Conana from New River Middle School. Here's what her school had to say. Rosangela exemplifies kindness, respect, and responsibility by consistently treating others with compassion, helping her classmates and teachers when needed, and demonstrating a positive attitude toward her learning and school community. She is an active member of the National Junior Honor Society, EcoSharks, Florida Future Educators of America, Students Preventing Unintentional Drowning, and the Student Magnet Ambassadors Committee. She also competes with the NRMS Robe Team at Sea Perch Competitions, and she and her team from the Girls Who Code class won second place in the Frost Science Museum's STEM 2026 Challenge for their Hydro Seed Project. She is a shining example of kindness, cooperation, honesty, and respect. Congratulations. Our next honoree is Noor Milaji from Sheridan Technical College and Technical High School. Here is what her school had to say. Noor is a senior class president for 2027, drama club president, and an active leader in the debate program. She has earned 2,009 community service hours. She is also exceptionally organized, motivated, and a team player. In addition, Noor is the first senior this year to be accepted into college, specifically, Berry University with a merit scholarship of $22,000. Currently, Noor enrolled in Sheridan Technical College's Cosmology Program, where she actively pursues her passion in makeup and hair fashion. While this is her current academic course, her post-secondary and career goals are to graduate and work in the field of nursing. Congratulations, Noor. And our final honoree is Sasha Bennett from Stranahan High School. Here is what Stranahan had to say. Sasha consistently demonstrates tolerance and acceptance of diverse peers, including students with different personalities, backgrounds, identities, and individual characteristics. Sasha also interacts appropriately with others, respects individual differences, and demonstrates a willingness to work cooperatively with a variety of peers. Additionally, Sasha consistently demonstrates respect towards teachers, administrators, and general staff, responding appropriately to adult guidance, and contributing to a respectful and inclusive school environment. Congratulations, Sasha. Congratulations to all of our honorees tonight. I just want to ask a question. Are there no smart guys? Come on. Come on, gentlemen from Stranahan Innovation Zone. Come on. Congratulations to all the students. I want to thank the parents for being here tonight to support your children. And I also want to thank the school and the school system, our public school system, for being so engaged in trying to help these young people achieve great goals in life. I'd now like to introduce Commissioner Stephen Glassman, who will present a proclamation regarding the 11th annual Unity in the Community Grocery and Turkey Giveaway Day in the city of Fort Lauderdale. And I'd like to invite Michael Albeda, who's the president of the Lakeridge Civic Association, Pastor Dwayne Black of the Sanctuary Church, and Ron Cacciatore, who needs no introduction. Okay. And Mila Schwarzenreich from the Property Appraisers Office. Michael, good to see you. Congratulations. Thank you. Very much. Thank you, Mayor. And our esteemed guests are all arrived. That's great. Thank you. So, it is a pleasure to present this proclamation from the Office of the Mayor, City of Fort Lauderdale, in recognition of the 11th annual Unity in the Community Grocery and Turkey Giveaway. This was requested by Commissioner Steve Glassman. Whereas Thanksgiving is a time to reflect on the blessings of family, community, and country, while embracing the spirit of gratitude, generosity, and compassion. And whereas the holiday reminds us of the importance of helping our neighbors, supporting those in need, and ensuring that everyone has an opportunity to enjoy a Thanksgiving meal. And whereas Pastor Dwayne Black and the Sanctuary Church, in partnership with the Fort Lauderdale Police and Fire Rescue Departments, Broward County Property Appraiser Marty Kier, Ron Cacciatore, Director, and his Mobile Exemption Education Team, AIDS Healthcare Foundation, St. Anthony's Homeless Ministries, Food Rescue U.S., South Florida Hunger Coalition, and numerous volunteers will distribute groceries and turkeys to thousands of people in need. And whereas the 11th annual Unity in the Community Grocery and Turkey Giveaway, taking place November 21, 2026, this Saturday, at the Sanctuary Church, exemplifies the spirit of Thanksgiving by bringing together community organizations, local leaders, and volunteers to share resources, extend a helping hand, and make a meaningful difference in the lives of others. And whereas this annual tradition reflects the generosity and compassion of the Fort Lauderdale community and the shared commitment to ensuring that our neighbors feel supported and valued, especially during the holiday season. And whereas the city recognizes and thanks everyone who contributes to the success of this event, particularly community and civic activist Michael Albetta, whose dedication and hard work have helped make this annual giveaway possible. Now, therefore, we, as city commissioners of the city of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, to hereby proclaim November 2021, 26, as the 11th annual Unity in the Community Grocery and Turkey Giveaway Day in the city of Fort Lauderdale, and dated this the 17th day of November, 2026. And signed by our mayor, the Honorable Dean J. Trentalas. Thank you. Thank you. And before I turn it over to this incredible team that's up here beside me, I just want to say a word about this because I've attended this event maybe all 11 years of 11. And I will tell you, when you see the cars line up the night before on Federal Highway, on Sunrise Boulevard, waiting, waiting hours and hours and hours for the grocery giveaway to begin at 8 a.m. on that Saturday morning, and you see that that need is out there, it is so easy for so many of us that have a blessed life in this city, a truly blessed life in this city, to realize that that's not the case with every single resident in our city. And it's just an uplifting, very, very warm feeling to be a part of this event every year to see what these people do to bring that joy and to bring that meal to folks that are less fortunate than many of us are. And I just want to say thank you for what you do because it really is inspiring and it's a wonder. So I just want to say thank you. And I really hope that someone would like to say a few words from the team. Okay. Thank you. Pastor, go right ahead. Thank you very much. I have to tell you right off the bat that this unity in the community is something we truly, truly believe in. That it's bringing people together from all different religions, all different places. Thanks to the police department, the fire department, all of you. I mean, you guys, public works, you guys, we couldn't do this without you guys. And again, Ron Cacciatore, I have to lift up to you. You're behind the scenes making us go, you can do better. You can do better. You can do better. And we do. So again, I thank the community for all this. It couldn't be done without you. And if you're not, I'll see you on Saturday. Right? Okay. That's it. Thank you. Oh, is that right? Thank you, folks. Now I would like to invite Ryan Case to join me at the podium as we proclaim a recognition of Rick Case Bikes for Kids. Ryan, can you please join me at the podium? Is that your son? I won't be right on bike. What's your name? Ryder. Your name, Ryan, too? Ryder. Oh, Brian. Ryder. Ryder. Oh, wow. Okay. Nice to meet you, Ryder. So this is about something that your grandparents started a very long time ago. So from the office of the mayor of the city of Fort Lauderdale, this is a proclamation in recognition of Rick Case Bikes for Kids. Whereas the Rick Case Bikes for Kids program was established in 1982 by Rita and Rick Case and the Rick Case Automotive Group in Ohio to bring joy to children during the holiday season. The Rick Case Bikes for Kids program partners with the Boys and Girls Club, local charities, churches, and schools to collect donated bicycles and distribute them to children in need in time for the holidays. Hundreds of bicycles have been distributed to children, and they were done last year, bringing the total to more than 124,000 bicycles donated through the Rick Case Bikes for Kids program since its inception. The city of Fort Lauderdale encourages neighbors to embrace the spirit of giving by supporting initiatives that make a meaningful difference in the lives of children and families throughout our community. The Rick Case Bikes for Kids program exemplifies the generosity and compassion of our community, bringing smiles to children's faces, smile, and creating cherished holiday memories. Now, therefore, we as the city commissioners of the city of Fort Lauderdale do hereby proclaim November 17, 2026, as Rick Case Bikes for Kids Day here in the city of Fort Lauderdale, signed by myself, Mayor Dean Trantels. Congratulations. You want to say a few words? No? Thank you all very much. Like he says, it's about community. So if all of you have a bicycle you no longer need, bring it down to one of the stores, either in Plantation, Davie. Yeah, those two. And we'll fix it up for a child in need. I mean, everybody remembers. That's it. Everybody remembers getting their first bicycle, right? That's freedom. You're out on the road. You get away from the house. So bring them down. We'll fix them up. We'll get them to someone that wants one. Thanks. Thank you. Okay, now let's get on with our regular meeting. Our agenda consists of two portions. The first portion is what's called the consent agenda. These are a number of items that the commission will vote on collectively. And if there's any one item that a member of the commission wishes to pull to discuss and vote on separately, now will be the time to announce that. So I will ask each member of the commission if there's any item they wish to pull. Commissioner Moraitis, do you have any items you wish to pull? No. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? 10. C10. Commissioner Glassman? None. And vice mayor? None. Okay. CM10. This is the art museum? Okay. CM10. And only one person has signed up to speak on this toothache, but that's just for questions. So, all right. Except for CM10, do I hear a motion to approve all the consent agenda items? Move to approve. Second. Been moved and seconded. Any questions or comments, please call the roll. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glassman? Yes. Are you trying to tell us? Yes. And all those consent agenda items are now approved. So if you came to support any of these consent agenda items, you should know that you have been approved. You're welcome to stay for the rest of the meeting. Otherwise, please have a good evening and a happy Thanksgiving. CM10. Yes. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman. Thank you. Thank you. I wanted to take the opportunity to talk about the nonprofit grants participation agreements, not only for NSU Art Museum, but just moving forward, understanding where we are now with Amendment 3 being in place. I believe that we, as a commission, need to be looking at what we are donating and the amounts that we are donating and being able to support nonprofits, but also at an amount that will be able to support any services that may have been affected by Amendment 3. So I'm looking forward to the new budget year for 2028. I believe that this is something that we should look at a little bit in a new scope with those nonprofits that we are donating to and the amounts that we are. Well, I think your point is well taken, Commissioner, and I think that this particular grant has already been budgeted and provided for, so we can move forward on that. But next year, we have to look at all the particular nonprofits and events that we have supported in the past and figure out what we can afford. We'll be taking almost a $17 million hit in the first year as a result of Amendment 3. And in year 2, I believe it's been calculated that we may lose as much as $27 million in our normal income. So clearly, we have to do some reassignment of our allocations in the years ahead. Exactly. So with regard to CM10, do you move to approve? I do move to approve. And again, I pulled it to have that statement that we are fully aware, that our neighbors know that we are aware of Amendment 3, and we are going to be looking at opportunities to share those fundings across the board. So thank you. So it's been moved and seconded. Do I hear a second? Second. It was a seconded. Please call the rule. Commissioner Beza-Kutman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moretis? Yes. Commissioner Glossman? Yes. Mayor Trent Thomas? Yes. And CM10 is now approved, along with the rest of the consent agenda items. Thank you for coming. You're welcome to stay for the rest of the meeting. I know you have nothing else better to do this evening, so thank you for being here. We appreciate it. And thank you for the good work that you do at the museum and providing a great public service to those in our community. And it's an important component, art and education. And so it's really, we have to work together to make sure we can continue to see it happen year after year. So thank you. Mayor, if I also might just add to that, and I want to say that I agree with what my colleagues have been saying in terms of how we have to take a really hard look. And when we do take that hard look for the next fiscal year budget, I think we have to really look at everything holistically. And we have to see also what we are getting for that amount of money. I know just from what I read internationally, the museum, I think probably brings back to our community way more than that $500,000 because of the fact that the impact that it has on our tourism, our cultural tourism. You could not pay for the advertising and the marketing around the world that this museum brings to our city. So I think we have to also be very open to holistically looking at what each of these grants that we do, not just give us in terms of the scope of what they do, in terms of how they serve the public, what kind of programs they all have, but also a much larger picture in terms of our place in not just the local economy and our place not just in the local tourism economy, but the worldwide attention that a place like the museum brings to us. Thank you for what you do. Thank you. M1, motion rejecting all bids for invitation to bid in bulk waste disposal and processing and approving the third amendment to the interlocal agreement between Briar County and the city for solid waste disposal support services. Someone like to move the item? Moved. Second. Moved and seconded. Any questions or comments? There being none, please call the roll. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glossman? Yes. Mayor Turntelis? Yes. M1 is now approved. M2, motion approving an agreement for purchases for stormwater systems infrastructure. No one to sign up. Excuse me. I read the wrong one. I'm sorry. M2. M2, motion approving an agreement for invitation to bid turf grass maintenance fire parking plants redid with visual escape. No one to sign up to speak. Would someone like to move M2? Moved. Second. It's been moved and seconded. Please call the roll. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glossman? Yes. Mayor Turntelis? Yes. M2 is now approved. M3, motion approving the proprietary purchases for stormwater system infrastructures, estimated amount of $4,200,000. No one to sign up to speak. Someone like to move the item? So moved. Second. Moved and seconded. Any questions? There being none, please call the roll. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glossman? Yes. Mayor Turntelis? Yes. M3 is now approved. M4, motion approving an increase in contract cost capacity regarding the purchase of sodium hypochlorite for water treatment services. No one to sign up to speak. Anyone have any comments or questions? Someone like to move the item? Move. Moved. Do I hear a second? Second. Moved and seconded. Please call the roll. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glossman? Yes. Mayor Turntelis? Yes. And M4 is now approved. M5, motion approving a memorandum of understanding with the Sheriff of Broward County for replacement of an additional City Forensic Biology DNA specialist in the Broward Sheriff's Crime Lab. No one has signed up to speak. Someone like to move the item? Moved. Second. We are moved and seconded. Please call the roll. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glossman? Yes. Mayor Turntelis? Yes. And M5 is now approved. M6, this is a motion for discussion. City Commission requests for review with Site Plan Level 3 regarding 815 Southwest 14th Court. We have a couple of people signed up to speak. Would someone like to move the item for discussion? So move for discussion. Okay. Do I need a second? I move the second. Okay. So for discussion purposes, we have several people signed up to speak. Mr. City Manager, you want to tell us what this is about? M6. Yes. So M6 is a request for consideration of setting a de novo hearing for a planning application case number UDP S26013. This item was heard by the Planning and Zoning Board who voted in favor 5-4 of approving this and District Commissioner 4, Vice Mayor Sorensen, requested it be called up to discuss potentially setting a de novo hearing to rehear this item by the City Commission. Okay. So Vice Mayor, do you want to introduce the subject? Thank you, Mayor. Yes. So this is a development in Creuson Park. There's significant concern among the neighborhood, Mayor, among height, stairwell height, stormwater, drainage questions, and some other topics. And so, Mayor, if we could hear from the public maybe first and then discuss after if that's possible. Well, what was the concern of this particular project that brought to your attention the need to have this discussion? Sure. So one of the concerns is the height, the overall height. So there's a stairwell that's included in the project whose height exceeds the allowable height, but the City's Planning and Zone Board's view has been that that height is still permissible even though higher due to a stairwell. So that's one concern. Another concern is stormwater drainage. It's an area that experiences some significant inundation during rain events. So questions and concerns about that the neighborhood's raising. There are also concerns about garbage placement, bin placement, and so forth. So the standard for the setting of de novo hearing for a topic such as this is that the City Commission can adopt the motion to set a hearing to review the application if it finds the new project is in an area which, due to characteristics of the project, which are the ones I just described, some of the characteristics, and the surrounding area requires additional review in order to ensure that the development standards and criteria have been met and ensure that the area surrounding the development is protected from the impacts of the development. So in my view, in short, it's very fair to engage in a de novo hearing to just ensure that there is alignment and that this development would be positive in the neighborhood. All right. Is there someone from our building department who can talk to us about this? Yes. Ella Parker, Deputy Director of Development Services. Could you push the button? Good afternoon, Mayor, Commissioners. Good evening. Good evening. The development, as Chris mentioned, was approved by the Planning and Zoning Board 5-4, and it was subject to a very broad discussion. A lot of the topics that Vice Mayor brought up were talked about as far as drainage on site, the compatibility of the building, specific concerns about height, and the rooftop access, especially as it pertains to privacy concerns for adjacent neighbors. So through that discussion, I think that's reflected in that 5-4 vote. And I'm happy to address any questions. I know we also have the applicant here tonight, if you wanted to hear from them. I have some questions. Absolutely. So speaking from what the Vice Mayor pointed out, let's start with height. Does this violate the zoning laws regarding height? No, the height is not violated. The maximum height in this district is 35 feet. However, you can have access to the roof. And to provide access to the roof, you can have certain elements, such as stair towers, elevator shafts, extend into that area. Okay. So, but the actual parapet dwelling itself is within the 35 feet? Right. So for safety reasons, you can have actually 42 inches of additional parapet, but 35 feet is the maximum height. So the measurements as defined in the ULDR define that height, you know, those elements being able to be included. Okay. Stormwater drainage. Is there, is there a stormwater drainage program with regard to this development? There is. And stormwater was addressed through the review of adequacy requirements. And the drainage is going to be maintained on site through exfiltration trenches. Um, so the, the, all of the water that's, that's, um, you know, it's, it's supposed to be maintained on the site. That's how it was reviewed. So when you say it's, it's going to be, um, kind of retained on site, is there like a, a drainage ditch or is it injection wells? Or what is the, what does that mean? Um, right. So the, it's designed to ensure the grading is, is, uh, designed so that the stormwater runoff is directed through the drainage system rather than the adjacent public right-of-ways. Um, so specifically low points have been incorporated within the property boundaries to collect and convey the stormwater, um, to the proposed. So it's not going to spill over onto the neighbors. It's going to be, it's going to be built so that it, it is drawn from. Right. There's onsite drains that are created that there's, that the water is supposed to be, um, going towards. And where does that water go to? The drains that are created on the site, the exfiltration trenches. Okay. Um, garbage placement. Is there an issue regarding dumpsters and so forth? So again, that was, that was reviewed by the city's, um, sanitation department, um, as part of the DRC review, um, and has been signed off in order to proceed to the planning and zoning board. That signature was required. Okay. The word compatibility was mentioned, not by the vice mayor, but by you. Is there a neighborhood compatibility issue here? And are there no buildings consistent with this, uh, size or design? So I would say this, this development is not by right. The, you know, staff certainly evaluated the project as it moved along. But the reason it's in front of you is because it is up to the city commission. It was up to the planning and zoning board to approve it. It was a site plan level three. And then it was obviously subject to this city commission call up. Um, there is a variety of different typologies throughout this neighborhood. Um, there's a lot of single family and single structure, um, one level structure, um, properties. There's also a cluster that's nearby that was approved not too long ago. Um, so there's duplexes, triplexes, um, but again, that compatibility criteria is really in front of the public hearing process, the board, the input that you all hear to make a determination or a final determination on that. We understand that. But for example, um, this particular building, are there any other, uh, structures nearby that are 35 feet? There are. There are. Oh, okay. Um, so this is not breaking. It's not the only building. Okay. Right. Okay. And, um, um, um, now in terms of, um, all right, so looking back at the planning and zoning board meeting, why would, why was it so narrowly passed if, uh, all these criteria were satisfied by city staff? Well, again, so, um, I'm only looking, you know, I was sort of reviewing the minutes and in speaking with staff, I wasn't at the meeting, but in looking at the material, there was clearly a lot of back and forth and a lot of discussion about these very points, the drainage on site, the sort of scale and mass of this development in comparison to the other properties surrounding the area, um, privacy concerns about the rooftop, the height discussion, all of that. But, but while those were part of the discussion, apparently it was four people were not convinced that, uh, that those requirements have been satisfied. But yet you're telling us today, as far as our city staff is concerned, as in examine the facts and apply them to the, to the law, that the requirements have been satisfied. Is that what you're saying tonight? Yeah. Again, staff reviews primarily adequacy as part of the technical review. And that includes the sanitation, the fire service, all of those different elements, which that was another point of discussion. Um, and then this is not a level two, which is a staff review. It is a level three, which is planning and zoning board review hearing. So understanding that this development of a cluster is not a by right approval. There is this public hearing process with, with, within which the planning and zoning board can use the, you know, the staff analysis, the applicants presentation, the materials, and consider any additional input as far as that compatibility element itself. So that, that is, that was, that was something that the board determined ultimately, um, that it met and it, and it approved as a, as a board. Okay. And so we're, you know, it was called up for, it was called up, uh, for the commission to take a look at it. And this is not the first time we've done something like this before, but I, I know that we can't just make a decision willy nilly. There have to be certain standards and certain criteria that we have to follow in order for us to, if we should choose to move on to a de novo hearing. That's correct. So, um, what you're telling me is that almost everything that, that has been of a concern has been, has been resolved in favor of the developer. That it's, it's been addressed. Well, no, don't say it's been addressed. Addressed means that you heard it, you, and, but you're telling me that the height, storm water, garbage, compatibility, all those requirements have come within the guidelines of the city building and zoning. Yes, correct. The planning and zoning board approved the project. Right. Yes. Okay. That's all I, so I just want to hear that. Okay. All right. Correct. All right. Um, I have no further questions at this point. Does anyone have any questions? May I ask Ella a few questions? Thank you, Ella. Sure. Just to piggyback on what the mayor was saying, um, before planning and zoning board discussed and voted, staff basically said, according to those items that the mayor mentioned, that everything was compliant with the ULDR. With the ULDR. Yes. Correct. So help me with this. And I have a few questions because I'm going to get into the weeds a little bit on this. Uh, and what I also want to say before I ask these questions of you, um, in my estimation, we appoint folks to the planning and zoning board to hear these cases. Um, and then, uh, many times they don't come to us and we rely on their expertise and their review of the facts. And we rely on staff in terms of examining what that project is and how it meets or does not meet the ULDR. So for me, and I'm, I'm going to be really honest here for me to want to have a de novo hearing, correct me if I'm wrong. If we, if we vote to have a de novo hearing, we're saying to the planning and zoning board, thank you, but not so much because we're going to throw out what you did and we're going to start all over again. And we're going to listen to this case. Is that correct? Right. You would have to determine that there was a deviation like the criteria states. That was my next question. We would have, hold on. I don't think that's correct. Uh, city attorney, can you weigh in on, um, let's just be clear. And I stated at the beginning, but let's be clear on the standard by which the city commission can determine if there should be a de novo hearing or not. Right. City attorney, can you just, just we're all on the same page. Pardon my voice. I'll do my best. For your purposes of this evening, you're deciding whether you do want to have that de novo hearing, which you may determine at that point, there was some deviation. This evening, you are determining whether project is in an area in which the characteristics, uh, and the surrounding area requires additional review. To ensure that the project's development standards are met and the area is protected from impacts. That is your standard. It is as you wish. Um, you, you, you may call it up simply because you feel like it's worthy of review. You may not. Thank you. So Ella, um, what basically, basically what I just heard, I'm going to ask you a question. Is there anything about this project's characteristics or surrounding area that require additional review in your estimation? I think that's really up to the city commission to make that determination. Okay. Um, have staff and PNZ adequately ensured development standards and criteria are met according to our ULDR? Yes. Yes. Uh, have staff and PNZ adequately ensured that the area surrounding the development is protected from the impacts of this particular development? As it pertains to adequacy, yes. Okay. Thank you. Um, now I'll just go back to some other questions. So when I look at the ULDR section 47 dash 18.9, and I look at all of these requirements and I want to know if staff thoroughly reviewed all of this and said yes to everything in terms of this cluster development, lot requirements and density, everything okay. Yes. Access and entrance requirements to this project. Yes. Yes. Yard requirements and setbacks. Yes. Architectural elements as required by ULDR section 47 dash 18.9. Yes, 18.9 site design criteria. The front facades of the proposed development have been designed with more than 25% transparency, which helps create a more inviting and pedestrian-friendly environment from the street. Yes. I took that as a general question initially, so, but yes, as it pertains to that, yes. Maintenance agreement. Yes. Sidewalk and landscaping requirements. Yes. Landscaping requirements separate from sidewalk and landscaping requirements. Yes. Yes, all landscape and open space. Let's go to the section that deals with adequacy requirements for this project. Water and wastewater service. Yes. Transportation facilities. Yes. Pedestrian facilities. Yes. Okay, let's go to neighborhood compatibility because we've heard some discussion of that. Zoning and uses. In other words, is this property surrounded by the same residential zoning district, and have we seen similar projects to this project within the immediate vicinity? There is a similar cluster development at the corner west of the project, yes. Right. How far would you say that is away? About a block or so? A block. That's what I thought. I actually did a drive-thru because I was very curious about this. Building height, and we've had a little bit of discussion, although I still think there's a little discrepancy. Building height? Yes, it does. Site layout? Yes. And building design? Yes. Okay. Was there public participation for this project, which is required? How many people showed up from the neighborhood for the public participation? I'd have to defer that to the applicant. Okay, so hopefully I'll get the answer to that. And then we know what happened with planning and zoning. I want to address a couple of issues. I received an email from a neighbor. I don't know if my colleagues did receive the same email, but there were some concerns in this email, and I want you to address those. It says the plans don't agree on how tall the buildings are. Do we know how tall the buildings are? Yes, we do. We do. Okay. Also, plans don't agree on fire sprinklers. I guess that would be a question for the chief, but maybe you could help answer that, because I know it's hard for him to get up and down a lot. The city's building reviewer told the applicant that both buildings need sprinklers. The cover sheet now says both buildings will be sprinklered, but the code analysis sheet in the same set still marks the two-unit building as non-sprinklered. Are we okay with the fire sprinklers? The fire safety analysis was done as part of the review and signed off on. The more detailed analysis, obviously, usually happens at the building permit process stage. Fire rescue does not appear to have reviewed the project. Would that be possible in a DRC? That can't be possible. No, they reviewed it. So that was reviewed? Mm-hmm. And then flooding. And I know that this has been a concern. I watched the meeting. I read all the minutes, and I actually spoke to my two appointees on the planning and zoning board, because I really wanted to understand this. I take it very seriously when we take people's time. To set a de novo hearing takes a lot of staff time. It's an expense for everybody involved in the project, and I just want to make sure that we're making the right decision when we ask for a de novo hearing and just wipe the slate clean and start from scratch. So I did try to get as educated as possible. So with regards to flooding, neighbors testified at planning and zoning that the street is flooded repeatedly. So here's my question. Where does that responsibility lie? Does it lie on the shoulders of the people that are building this project? Or is that a city issue if we're going to start looking at streets? Do we typically look at streets in terms of flooding and in terms of what's happening? And does that apply to the responsibility of a development team? Or is that the city's concern, that we should be doing something on the streets? Yeah, no. The applicant is generally responsible for maintaining the impacts from their development and the drainage on site and make sure that it's addressed on site. And you feel that the stormwater issue here in terms of retention of water is adequately addressed in terms of the site? They did get those calculations reviewed by engineering and signed off, yes. Okay. And we're good with that and we're good with what the engineer, I thought the engineer did a good job at the planning and zoning board. So I'm just looking to see if there's any more concerns in this letter. I think I'm okay with all of that. So basically, again, I'm looking for a reason to have a de novo hearing. I'm not hearing a reason to have a de novo hearing. Is there anything I'm missing? Is there anything that planning and zoning board missed? I did, by the way, and I'm going to be very honest with my colleagues if you didn't happen to watch the meeting, I felt that the city attorney's office did try to steer the board towards its responsibility when it comes to looking at projects like this because people were sort of going every which way and were getting a little bit off course. I think the city attorney's office did a good job. They were trying to say, look, this is what's in front of you. This is your charge here. And you can only look at this X, Y, and Z in terms of this project. The rest, although you might have a concern for it, is not necessarily a concern that should be addressed by the planning and zoning board, basically is what they were trying to say. And I think to answer your question, Mayor, that's why it was such a close vote because of that fact. But I feel, you know, in talking to my appointees on that board, again, I don't think staff has made an error anywhere. And I think that we would almost, in setting a de novo hearing, have to say that staff made an error or the planning and zoning board made an error. And I don't think that we should be having a de novo hearing simply to just hear this all over again. So again, this is the last chance for you to tell me that I'm missing something. Or is there a topic that all of us have discussed so far that I'm just not paying enough attention to? No, the board reviewed it. I don't, as staff, have anything else to add. Okay. Well, I thank you. Thank you, Mayor. You're welcome. Any other questions? There may be some, but let's just have the public speak right now. Okay. And we'll get back to it. Sounds good. Thank you. I'll call your names three at a time. Steve Gannon, you said questions only. Is that still the case? Okay. Could I ask him a question? I'm just going to say questions only. He's only going to speak if there are questions. Could I ask him a question? Oh, okay. If you have questions. Sure. Yeah. Mr. Gannon, can you please come up? Steve Gannon served six years on the Planning and Zone Advisory Board as a member. And thank you for your service on that board. And I appreciate it. I watch just about all of those meetings, and I really do appreciate your input on that board. So I'm going to ask you this question. You voted in favor of the project. Correct. Why? Because the developer was not asking for anything extra, no setbacks, no parking reductions, often things that we normally get. Everything was there by right. And the only reason that was there was that a cluster home does have to come in front of the P&Z is what it is. That's all. But it's really a conditional use. And it's mostly often approved. Now, when these, I'll mention that neighborhood compatibility, when you have a place that has low one-story homes, and a lot of these might have been converted to duplexes. They look like single-family homes. There's a lot of yard space around them. So when it's zoned as an RD-15, that's 15 density there, which could put six units on there. Long ago, when it was zoned that, the intent is for it to have it redeveloped. As new things get built, you build higher density there. Now, the first ones that come in, of course, it's not going to be visually compatible because you have the old stuff. But you have to take the compatibility with what the zoning says can be. 35 feet tall, and it's roughly, that was six units available on those two lots. These were two lots that were back-to-back, by the way. Very unique. The family owned them since 1978, and the family was redeveloping them. This wasn't the developer that just came in to do something and flip. But one of the lots empties on one street. One lot empties on the other street. So there's a driveway that goes straight through, which means trash cans would go different ways. You've got two streets to go. Traffic was very good. It would be split on two streets, not on one. There are so many things the developer did. I'll mention that the flavor of the night was that everyone was complaining about flooding. We know how that is. We had a lot of stories, gut-wrenching and emotional stories about flooding in the neighborhood. But as the engineers told us, the filtration trenches that bring the water down into the center and down under the ground, they're tested. And that particular area was very permeable underneath the topsoil, in fact, the top level. And so it's going to drain very well, much better than the homes that have just topsoil, grass, everything else. They get saturated at the top, and it doesn't drain as fast down below on a heavy rain. So there were so many mitigating factors that said this was going to be good. It was definitely not going to contribute and be much better than the other homes that were already there. Were there any concerns that you had that were not addressed by staff or in that planning and zoning board meeting? No, it was a lengthy discussion, and everything was covered, and staff did a great job, in my opinion. They covered everything. And as you mentioned, the city attorney, the assistant city attorney that was assigned to us, he took very careful time to explain. The engineer that talked about the water percolation and everything else took time. They were very patient. We just had a lot of very emotional people from the neighborhood. You can imagine how flooding is. We've just been through that flooding issue, and there are a lot of emotional folks there. And if I can render my opinion about the vote, it was a very close vote, and had it gone the other way, you would have been in trouble, not doing the right thing. Now, my opinion and the reason that we got a five to four vote, we have four people that are relatively new, less than a year on the board. And they're getting their feet wet, they're getting the hang of things, and we even had a discussion after the meeting, 15-minute discussion with the city attorney and the development services as to how this all works and what we're allowed to do, what we can't do, and whatnot. And some of those people were under a different impression. One of them mentioned, well, what am I doing here? They thought they could be a jury and make any decision they wanted, a subjective decision. So everyone's coming on board. Like I said, that's what it is. We have some new folks that are idealistic, and they're swayed by things that you can't be swayed by. Right. So basically, you're saying that if a project meets all of the requirements of the ULDR, you really do have your hands tied. A lot of the other things that you said are either emotional or they're just not subject to what is under your purview in terms of reviewing a project like this. Exactly. I understand. Correct. Well, thank you. I appreciate it. Steve, question for you. Sure. How long has Jackie Scott been on planning and zoning? Jackie Scott has been a long time. Right. So your characterization is not accurate. You're right. But three folks that were new, and Jackie's been around a while. Jackie was very fixated on the trash problem. One thing about the trash, these are fee simple townhome slash cluster homes. They're not going to have a dumpster in that environment. They're not commercial, and no one's going to want a big lumbering dumpster truck coming down their street and doing that in a residential anyway. But the idea was we've got six homes now, and there's three trash cans per home. They're all going to be right there on the street. But what was overlooked was the fact that we have two streets. So two homes would go to one street, and four homes would go to another street. Also, with a cluster home, and there's little pervious in landscaping that really needs to be done there. It's a landscaper that comes by. They're not going to have yard waste cans. So they'll have two cans. Once a week, you might have two cans for each. You'll have eight on one side and somewhat on the other. And the other time, you'll have a few. But Jackie was fixated on the trash a lot. If you look through the minutes, you'll see it. She brought it up three times throughout it, different times throughout our discussion. The minutes show that. So that's what happened with her, I think. And we love Jackie, always. No question. Or else. Yeah. Always making friends. Yeah, there we go. Thank you, Steve. Okay. Thank you, Steve. Carlos Wang, followed by Ted and Sierra, followed by Jared, is he Galis? Is Mr. Wang here? Wang. W-A-N-G. It's Wang. I have a handwritten with a doctor, so I apologize. Yeah, that doesn't look like Wang. Yeah. Sorry. It's okay. Okay. If the clerk is here, I'll have a presentation. Yes. Please call me Carlos. Okay. Great dance moves last week, by the way. Okay. Okay. Good evening, mayors and commissioners. My name is Carlos Lang. Oh, thank you. I'm a board member for the Croissant Park Civic Association and board member of the Council of Civic Association. I'm also a firefighter and a certified fire marshal. But today, I'm speaking as a resident of Croissant Park on item M6. I support the motion to set a hearing. Tonight, I'm not asking you to stop this project, but simply to take a look at it one more time. I'm asking you to see this as what a fire crew would do if an incident occurred. First off, and I apologize, I read a lot of information, so some things have been cleared up, but there's a couple things that I do want to address. First, fire never signed off on it. Your code puts fire rescue on the DRC in Section 47-29.4. But on June 9th, DRC reports listing eight reviews and no fire. The case planner wrote me that fire is not part of the DNC review. Fire reviewed, wrote that it was a sign-off, that a sign-off was granted, and that the DRC for fire is not a penalty. As an inspector, I know the difference. A review is an opinion. A sign-off is a document. Again, if there's a sign-off, with my public records request, I never saw that. So that's up there. Okay, then next slide. Next, the ladders don't make it to the roof. Ground ladders on engines usually run between 24 to 35 feet. You set a safety angle for a 35-foot extension ladder. It leaves you about roughly a four-and-a-half-foot gap. If you guys look at the slides here, this is coming from... So how do your ladders address other situations where the height of a building is 35 feet? So in a situation like this, you would have to ask for additional resources, like an aerial. It takes time to set up. And it would take longer to assist in a situation. But we have that capacity, right? We do. We do. But when life safety is an issue, this is something that should be considered when building something like this. So you're saying that we shouldn't allow 35-foot height buildings? I'm saying that it should be in a neighborhood where it's not compatible. I think that it should be the same standards as every other place in the neighborhood. So what I'm saying is... I don't know what you're saying. So what I'm saying is, do we need to have it at 35 feet? Can we have it lower? Well, the zoning allows for 35 feet. Just because it allows it doesn't mean it's right. So, excuse me, but when the law allows somebody to do it, then we have to give it to them as a matter of right. I understand. You can't make it up as you go along. I understand. But we can make accommodations. That's all we're asking. And we are making accommodations. There are many, many homes in the city that are 35 feet. I understand. And I imagine we have the capacity, in terms of our equipment, to accommodate a fire situation where a house is 35 feet. And I agree with you. But we're asking, what the residents are asking, or at least what I'm asking, is, do we have to make it three stories? Can we lower it? Okay. Carlos, did you attend the public participation meeting that was required for this project before it went to PNZ? I did not. You did not? No. I was brought on this a little bit later, and I started looking at it and reviewing everything. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Next. There are the sprinklers. Mr. Commissioner Glassman, you mentioned the sprinkler system. Unless it was later on, like you said, Exhibit A showed that it didn't have it, then it did have it for all buildings, and then they took it away. So there's a conflict there. I just want to be able to see some documentation that says that it's consistent across both buildings. That's what we're asking. Finally, this is all the ask is. If all these cases, I respectfully ask that you find the project to require an additional review, to revisit the conditions before approval, that meets the documents of fire signs off in it. The water flow, I never saw a document that shows the water flow for the sprinkler system. If there is, that hasn't been provided. A combined condition of sprinklers for both buildings, a written zoning decision on height and story, and one consistent label for both buildings. So everybody knows what the fire rules when they come out here. Okay. Thank you. All right. Ella, these things, are these requirements or just aspirational? They're requirements, and I can clarify some of the fire prevention questions. Yeah, absolutely. So I actually had the fire reviewer that was assigned to the project respond to this directly, and he indicated that it was reviewed by him, city staff fire plan reviewer. And it's in full compliance with the eighth edition of the Florida Fire Prevention Code. He also said that the project complies with the adequacy requirements of the city's ULDR, Unified Land Development Regulations. And that explicitly includes fire protection service, supply, fire flows, and emergency accesses. While the DRC reviews the land use, site design, and public service enforced through the life safety plan review will happen during the building permitting phase, like I mentioned. Okay, so these four points that Carlos just pointed out, are these requirements in this particular cluster? You know what? I will have to defer to fire chief for the specific requirements. I mean, either they are requirements or they're not. I mean, just let's let the fire chief respond, if you can. If you can. So, Mayor, I would say the fire chief probably hasn't reviewed this set of plans in detail. Maybe he has. But when you have a DRC application, and that goes everything from a cluster development all the way up to a high-rise tower, we aren't requiring a civil set of plans. So when you get into the details of things like this, a lot of these are conditions and advisory comments that when this comes in for building permitting, as Ms. Parker said, they will have provide that documentation and engineering on how these things are being achieved. So we're not often looking at these things as much as we're conditioning that upon building permitting, they'll have to meet these types of fire code requirements. So these are requirements, then? They just aren't required at this stage? Right. So if they have a sprinkler system, they're going to have to show that they have adequate flow from the city water system that serves the project. But if the fire protection code requires sprinklers in the buildings or some of the buildings on this site, they'll have to include the buildings in their building permit plans. But do we know if a sprinkler system is required? So good evening, Mayor, Vice Mayor, Commissioners, Stephen Golan, your fire chief. So it is not required. However, it does change some of the things within the structure. So means of egress, height, some of the concerns with the reachability by the ladder. So what we're looking at by having fire sprinklers in there is the means of egress of the occupants of that building. So in order to have what is currently being proposed, the buildings would have to be sprinkled under Florida Fire Prevention Code to move forward. Okay. So if the planning and zoning approves this, then there's still another level of approval process that they have to go through. That's correct. That's not the final word. That's correct. And even if the city commission were to ask for a de novo hearing and let's say it were to approve the application as it currently exists, it still needs another level of approval if I'm not, if I understand you correctly. Is that correct? Okay. So, so, so at this stage, we're only looking at elements or requirements of a certain level. And then there's still an additional level that has to be addressed in terms of all these fire, all these fire issues. Okay. And that's correct. And at this time with what has been presented, it is meeting the Florida Fire Prevention Code right today. So once it goes to the next, then of course, we will review it again and make sure that it continues to be in compliance. Okay. All right. Well, I guess that clarifies things a little bit. Go ahead. If I could just say thank you, chief. So I was made aware of a, of an email that went from Mr. Stranhagen to Mr. Lang to address all of these issues. And I'm not going to read it. It's a very long detailed email, but have you read that email? Yes, sir. I have. So just from, again, not to take up the time and read all of this, but it makes it very clear that the project was reviewed by the Fire Plan Review Committee and says in full compliance with the eighth edition of the FFPC. And since it was in compliance, no comments were entered and a sign off was granted. And then, as you said, a lot of this detail will be fleshed out as this project moves forward in the process, correct? That's correct, sir. Okay. Because I'm reading this email and it looks like all of Mr. Lang's concerns have been addressed. Would you concur with that? That's correct, sir. In the email in between Captain Stranhagen and Mr. Lang, all of the concerns are outlined in that email were addressed. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mayor. Okay. Thank you. You may be seated. Thank you. You look really nice there. Mr. Ancerra. And I want to give Mr. Ancerra an A for penmanship, by the way. He spells his name right. I can read it. Thank you. Thank you very much. My name is Ted Ancerra. I'm the president of the River Oaks Republic Civic Association. I think Mr. Gannon has some things incorrect. For one thing, these boards are not perfect every single time. Let's see. And everybody's human. People were not emotional that night. I think they were. He confused emotional for being factual. So that's one thing. And I guess what I took when he was saying they're not getting the hang of it, does that to me, that means they're not getting the hang of just approving everything. I guess that's what he was talking about when he said that the new members don't quite get the hang of how they're supposed to vote, which is basically, I guess, Mr. Gannon, yes, yes, yes. But this, Croson Park, is very dear to me. I was a graduate of the Croson Park Elementary School, class of 1967. And so 9th Avenue separates Croson Park from River Oaks. Too bad we don't have the gentleman here that was from the Sunshine Cathedral, because this street is right on the Sunshine Cathedral. And there are times when they've had to cancel events because you can't get there because of flooding. I don't buy the thing that's, you know, believing that these developers can keep everything on property is what got us into this mess from the beginning. We have these things, six, eight cluster homes in there. Oh, they can show you that how they're going to keep everything. We got a French drain over here. We got a swale over here. But then when it starts raining, baby, that that water just flows. And these streets in particular, 14th Street and 14th Court, hold the water longer than I would say almost any other street in the neighborhood. I mean, we have the stormwater system on our side, but on Croson has not gotten that yet. And so, I mean, the water just stays there for days and days and days. And and it's just that insanity. We're just we just keep doing the same thing over and over building in these neighborhoods. I mean, maybe these big, long, big, huge towers with their wells, they can keep all the water on property. That's why I guess you don't see so much flooding in the Flagler Village in those areas. But on these neighborhood properties, it's a different ballgame. These people are not keeping their word. They're not keeping the water on their property. And and there's no way that they're going to be able to prevent spillover from the neighbors into the streets, into the the yards and into the houses. Thank you. Thank you. Chair. Yes, go ahead. Can I ask Ella just to address some of those allegations about not being able to keep the water on their property? And why do you feel confident that this project would be able to keep water on their property? Sure. So regarding the drainage system, you know, as part of the building permit, again, the applicants going to be required to obtain a stormwater management license from Broward County. And part of that requires them to show that they don't have these impacts on it. So some some of the criteria that are established by Broward County include things like the design and the capacity so that they don't result in any ponding or overflow and that they don't have any impacts on adjacent areas. So that South Broward County surface water management license needs to be obtained before commencing any construction. So they'll have to show those those flows as part of that process. And where is this particular street and neighborhood with regards to our Fortify Lauderdale project? There's projects coming forward for this particular area to address stormwater? I'm going to have to defer to Public Works for that. I could. Brad, Fortify, Fort Lauderdale. This is between Southwest 14th Court and Southwest 14th Street. OK, we don't have it right now. Yeah, we can get that answer. Thank you for that. You're welcome. I'm good. Thank you, Ella. You're welcome. OK, Jared, followed by Fritz Kramer. Does anyone else wish to speak? Those are the last two. OK, great. Thank you. Thank you. That was one of the more pleasant exchanges I've ever seen with Ted and the commission before, I have to say. It's a new commission. So I just want to want to say thank you guys for letting me speak here briefly about this project. I am, as of this year, the new president of the Croson Park Civic Association. This is the first item we've had called up, and it really created something that we were emotional about. My wife was eight months pregnant when our house flooded in the floods, and I want to do everything I can to prevent that from happening again. I want to focus on a couple items. I do have a presentation that if it could be brought up. So I did send the presentation. I don't want to hold us up here. But basically, there are several concerns in addition to the fire and the flooding. Several of them have to do with just parking overall. Some of the renderings that were provided by the development team and the design team for this project were actually showing the vehicle's parallel parking out next to, like, in front of the garage. I see two-car garages here. Okay. So any homes that have more than two cars, it will be difficult. I don't want to focus on that. I do want to focus on the height and the actual compatibility. That word has been mentioned several times. So let's talk about the height. Let's talk about the height. What's the issue of the height? So not one of the cluster projects in the community have three stories with a rooftop terrace. Not one. The only development there that has anything like that is three stories and a third-story balcony. But I think, as it was explained to us previously, the law permits 35 feet up to the parapet and another 42 inches for elevator shaft or stairwell, which apparently is consistent with the design. I see a glass railing around there, which I assume you're talking about a rooftop. There's a rooftop terrace in this. So there's not one cluster home development within the community that has a rooftop on top of the third story. So Ella, is that something that's not permitted to sit on top of your roof? It is technically non-habitable space. That is how it is looked at. It's, you know, the code permits you to have access to your roof. Right. And so that's why you can have those stairs extend into the height. Um, but yes, it is technically not supposed to be habitable. It's just a, okay, like a sun deck. Right. Okay. I also, if you'd like, have a quick update on Brad indicated that the consultant, um, that ranked the projects, it's, it's about number seven and that would be about seven years or so away. Seven years? Seven years or so. Okay. So I understand the code and the height and everything that's legal, but again, we were talking about compatibility from the beginning. Um, you know, my, my issue going back also to the board and what Mr. Gannon mentioned was I'm on the board of adjustments as well. I understand we are new. We make these kinds of, you know, decisions based on what, what the, what is expected of us, required of us. Um, and one of the members told us that when, you know, there's flooding in our streets to call the FDOT to help us with the flooding. That's the most irrelevant thing I ever heard. And it was most disappointing thing I ever heard because that person also voted yes, uh, for this project. So somebody that didn't have complete understanding of exactly who does what makes me question some of it and some of the board and how it works. I'm not trying to criticize them. I know it comes off that way because I understand it's hard to make those decisions, but I just want to make that point, uh, regarding that. Um, going back though, to the actual design, uh, if you look in this slide, uh, there's only one three story example that the developer presented in the entire community. The rest of them are two story ones. Um, additional ones that were, uh, were put on their presentation, Las Olas Villas at 923 West Las Olas Boulevard, not even in our realm of the same area. Uh, and then in Rio Vista at 910 to 920 Southeast 12th street, again, not in the same community. So, uh, I'm a real estate broker. That's not even a comparable. You can't, you can't use that as a comparable property, uh, or, or parcel. So I do want to bring that up as far as an issue. Yes. Maybe they have a, uh, forced, they have a rooftop terrace, but again, my point is the compatibility. That is the number one, uh, you know, it's the word, it's the biggest word. RD 15 district permits single family dwelling units, including zero lot line dwellings and cluster dwellings designed in a manner that is compatible and complimentary to the surrounding area. And I think that that is the most important thing to have this reviewed. We are not against development. We are, we understand that that will happen. And that's what happens with, you know, progress and that is the direction that the city is going. However, again, we do expect things to be done responsibly and to become bad, compatible with the community. Okay. Thank you so much, sir. Thank you. May I, may I answer a question? Thank you. Absolutely. First of all, thank you for your service as a neighborhood association president. It's not always the easiest role to assume. Um, that being said, were you able to attend the public participation meeting? Yes. Thank you. Uh, and I, so I'm assuming all of these concerns, your concerns and others were brought up to the development team. I want to get a feel of how that meeting went. What were the responses to you from the development team? By the way, how many people attended that meeting? So they, according to the attorney and counsel for them, they stated that only a few, uh, I think they said two or three. I don't remember. I know that there was some correspondence, but I believe there was probably around eight to 10, it wasn't a significant, uh, you know, significant participation, but certainly, uh, Mrs. Patricia Rathburn, uh, was involved, uh, Rhonda and Fritz Kramer, who owned three properties on the same street. Uh, so we did have significant, as far as participation from people who very much understand the neighborhood and have been there for a combined probably 60 years. Uh, so, uh, yeah, there, there was a lot of questions in participation and it did seem like it was kind of like, well, too bad. This is what's going to happen. Okay. Well, I appreciate that. And I'd like to eventually ask the question, uh, to the applicant as well, because I want to see public participation meetings are not just so that, you know, the, the applicant can hear concerns and then they'll say too bad. It's just what it's going to happen. There should be some dialogue. There should be some give and take. There should be some, some movement, some compromise, but I was just trying to ascertain whether any of that happened. Yeah, there was a minimal, minimal, minimal, minimal, but there, there was certainly dialogue. I feel like, you know, when you make this out, when you make an application for something like this, it's a box that has to be checked and there has to be a public participation meeting. So going through the motions, I totally understand that. Um, but at the same time, we also, again, the compatibility and that is, you know, putting a rooftop terrace so that you're looking into people's homes, uh, in their backyards is certainly not compatible. No one would have an issue with three stories and, and having it that way and not having this top deck. Uh, I think everyone would be okay with that. Is it our favorite thing that they're doing in the neighborhood? No. But again, we also understand there's certain definitions and guidelines that have to be met and followed. And if they meet those, then that's okay. But pushing it to this point and, you know, basically there's no privacy and, and it's not compatible. That's where the issue lies. And it's, I can talk about other things, but I really wanted to make that the focus of this with my time. But even with that rooftop space that we're talking about, even if you took that away, wouldn't 30 feet, wouldn't people still be able to look into other people's yards or whatever? Well, if you don't... Like, how would you alleviate the privacy issue? So you basically are, instead of being at 35, I believe it's 34 feet, six inches is the height. And that's, if you're standing on top of the roof, then I'm six feet tall. So you're basically six feet higher. So you're at, you're 41 feet. Math wasn't my strong subject. So anyway, but basically, basically we're at 40, you're, you're at 41 feet. So you're at 41 feet high looking down into somebody's backyard versus if you're on the third story on a third story balcony. I'm not a designer, builder, architect, but how high are you when you're on a third story balcony versus, versus a... But 30, 30 feet would still look down on a person's... How about, how about, how about on a rooftop? And, and that's what I mean is pushing it. It's, it's, it's not, it's just, again, it's not compatible. None, there's not one property in the neighborhood that has three stories with a rooftop balcony. So again, compatibility is important. Thank you. Thank you. Fritz, is it Kramer? Good evening, sir. Good evening. I'm not a public speaker, so I'm a little nervous. I've lived on, my wife and I have lived on 14th Street for, since 1980. And we've raised two kids there. And this, this, this proposed construction would be very incompatible, as we are two lots away from the back of the, the buildings. And also, they've got a two-car garage, but who puts cars in their garage? Not in our neighborhood. I've got a two-car garage. There's no car in there. It's all this stuff. Incompatible. You're on your floor, four floors. You know, you say three, and then a rooftop terrace. Well, that's fourth to me. So, yeah, they're going to be looking in my backyard, and I got a hot tub. So, that's it. Okay. We understand. All right. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else who wishes to speak on this item? Okay. Vice Mayor, this is your request to call up. Do you have any further comments you'd like to make? Yeah. Did you sign up to speak? Okay. Do we have any questions of her? Well, I was just going to ask that one same question in terms of during the public participation. Was it, as we just heard, an opportunity to check a box, or was there any kind of dialogue that resulted in any kind of changes? Can you please say your name and who you're here for? I'm sorry. I apologize for not signing the form. My name is Ari Grossfeld. There were about eight to ten people anywhere in that range. The concerns were mainly what was discussed today and what was discussed at PNZ, so drainage and height primarily. We did make some concessions. If you want to hear from the architect, we're happy to, the architect is here as well. We added some more trees. We removed gates to address problems with parking and parking stacking, and we added more aesthetic features following the meeting. So, concessions were made. Whether they were material or not is obviously subjective, but we believe that we were cooperative throughout the entire process, and we did have, I believe, one more meeting than was required by code as well. Can you specify those aesthetic improvements that you just mentioned? Yes. It's about the facade facing streets, but I'm not entirely sure. I can't clarify more than that, but we do have the architect, if you would like further clarification. I'm okay. Okay. And you had an extra public participation meeting? Yes. I believe we had a voluntary one with an association a few months prior to the required meeting. Yes. Thank you. Any other questions? No, but I do would ask you, when you're finished, can you go up to the clerk outside and sign up and just sign up so we have that as a record? Okay. My apologies. Thank you. No problem. No problem. Okay. Vice Mayor. Thanks, Mayor. So, as you've heard, great discussion. A lot of questions and concerns, both from the commission, from the neighbors. So, that is the standard by which you can set a de novo hearing. Again, just to review, if the surrounding area requires additional review in order to ensure the development standards and criteria have been met and to ensure the area surrounding the development is protected from the impacts of the development. Thank you, Mayor. All right. There's a motion on the floor. Does someone want to second it? All right. There's no second. So, the motion fails. All right. We move on to R1, appointment of board and committee members. Mr. Clerk, please read the names into the record. Thank you, Mayor. Second. Sorry. Before I go into the ones for this evening, there are a few vacancies now on some boards after Commissioner Herbst leaving that I just wanted to bring to your attention. Well, there's his vacancy, which is what we feel tonight. Well, right. There's now an opening on the Greater Fort Lauderdale TMA, the Risk Management Committee, and also the Wastewater Large Users Advisory Board. That one again. Oh, because he served on those. Yeah, he served on those. Correct. What were they again? The Greater Fort Lauderdale TMA. Welcome to the City Commission. Yeah. Yeah. Those should definitely stay in District 1, I think. So, yeah. So, it's the TMA Risk Management Committee and the Wastewater Large Users Advisory Board. Okay. Well, let us take that under advisement now that we now know that, and perhaps at the next meeting we can address those. Okay. Yeah. I believe the only one that is meeting towards the end of this month, or in December, would be the Risk Management Committee. The other ones aren't meeting until 2027, so we have a little time. Okay. All right. And thank you. And, David, can you just let me know when these groups meet? Yeah. And then, so, yeah, I'll just check all that. Yeah. All right. All right. For the December 2nd resolution, Beach Business Improvement District Advisory Board, Anelsha Like, alternate member for Courtyard Oceanside. Caroline Montoya, alternate member for the Senesta Fort Lauderdale Beach Resort. Citizens Committee of Recognition, Mary Pelequin. She's consensus for the Council of the Civic Associations. Homeless Advisory Board, Raymond Dettman. And that's nominated by Vice Mayor Sorensen. And for tonight's resolution, Aviation Advisory Board, David Cooper, nominated by Commissioner Glassman. Downtown Development Authority, Kenneth Stiles, nominated by Mayor Trentel. Steve Hudson, nominated by Mayor Trentel. Economic Development Advisory Board, Kim Ray Hill, nominated by Commissioner Beasley-Pittman. Elena Hercule Jean-Francois, nominated by Commissioner Beasley-Pittman. Historic Preservation Board, Steve Witten, nominated by Commissioner Glassman. Yvette Giles-Stewart, nominated by Commissioner Beasley-Pittman. And Homeless Advisory Board, Paula Youkna, nominated by Commissioner Glassman. Michael O'Brien, nominated by Commissioner Beasley-Pittman. And Amy Schimmel-Fing, nominated by Vice Mayor Sorensen. And that rounds it out. Okay. Are there any additions or modifications to those nominations? Okay. There being none, would someone like to introduce the resolution appointing those board and committee members? Moved. Introduced. It's been introduced. Please call the roll. A resolution, City Commission of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, appointing or nominating, if applicable, board and committee members as set forth in the exhibit attached here to and made a part here of. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glassman? Yes. Mayor Trentals? Yes. And we want to thank those folks for wanting to volunteer their time to join those board and committees and for their continued commitment to make Fort Lauderdale the great place that it is. R2, resolution approving the secondary street name of Northwest 7th Terrace between Northwest 4th Street and Northwest 18th Street to be known as the Levi-Henry Jr. Way. That's in Districts 2 and 3. So I would like to introduce the resolution. Introduced for approval. The resolution has been introduced for approval. Any questions or comments? No one has signed up to speak. Please call the roll. A resolution, City Commission of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, adding Levi-Henry Jr. Way as a secondary street name to the segment of Northwest 7th Terrace between Northwest 4th Street and Northwest 18th Street and providing an effective date. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glassman? Yes. Mayor, turn to us. Yes. And R2 is now approved. R3, resolution approving a subdivision improvement waiver for the proposed plat known as ECOAR. ECOAR. ECOAR. Plat, 1000 Southwest 26th Street. We have a couple people signed up to speak. I did not. I'm sorry? I forgot to sign up. Okay. I'm presenting. I've got something to present. Heidi? That's okay. Would you like to speak? I would love to. I'm getting a card. I promise. Okay. Okay. Are you here on behalf of the applicant? I am. Okay. So, please go ahead. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening, commissioners. Welcome, Commissioner Moraitis, for your first meeting back. I'm Heidi Davis with the law firm of Gunster here tonight on behalf of Edgewood Oaks LLC, which is now formerly known as ECOAR LLC, the owner of the property located at 1000 Southwest 26th Street. We are here tonight to request a waiver for right-of-way improvements in a 25-foot right-of-way that Edgewood is dedicating to the city as part of its development plat. Pursuant to Section 4724-5E3, we respectfully ask the commission to waive the requirements of improvements to allow a greenway instead of a roadway. With me is the owner of the property, Daniel Kermatis, and we have our development team if you all have any questions. So, the property is located just south of State Road 84 and east of I-95 in the Edgewood neighborhood. The property is a vacant five-acre parcel, zoned RM15, allowing townhouse projects up to 15 units per acre, and also a land-use designation of residential medium. How do you propose the ingress and egress if you want to eliminate that as a street? No, no, that's not a street. We'll get to it. You want me to keep going? Yeah, of course. Okay. Why isn't this behind? This is not a... This is just a right-of-way waiver. No, no, but your diagrams are not part of our application, are they? I don't see them. No, because it's just the waiver requirement. Okay, so don't show this to us because we don't have it as part of the record. Okay, I'll go back. Okay, so the question is that... Oh, did I do that? There's a five-acre parcel. We are dedicating 25 feet on the north side of our property and 25 feet on the west side of our property. This is our west side of our property right here. Okay. And we own the property on the east side of this white wall. Okay. So the waiver request currently is this 25 feet right here is from the west plat that dedicated to the city a right-of-way. We have a lot of mature trees, as you can see, on our property, and we don't want to have to tear them down in order to create a road. And this is what the waiver request is. The development is a 67-unit townhouse development. We've dedicated one acre of land of that five acres for a conservation easement. This also dedicating this 25 feet on this side and 25 feet on the north side. We're just asking the city to waive the right-of-way requirements because once you dedicate, you have to construct a road. So have we approved the site plan on this? I thought we did. We rezone... This is like a two-year process, all right? This is the last hearing. I know the client is really excited about it. Yeah. And, Mayor, just to add more context, we've been working on this. Heidi's been doing a fantastic job. Thank you. The developers, yes. I've seen this wall. We have been working on this. Yes. Good memory, Mayor. You still got it, Mayor. You still got it. It's the Red Bull. It's the Red Bull. Whatever it is, it's working. So we have been working for a long time, and the developer has done a great job in saying, okay, how can we preserve as many old-growth trees on this amazing parcel as possible? Well, this has been... Heidi has done a fantastic job, and city staff, we've had to work, Mayor, with the county, with the city, through all types of different iterations to finally get to this point where we can preserve an amazing part of this parcel in perpetuity. Okay. So this isn't really controversial. It's good news. This isn't controversial. It should not be controversial in my view. Do I introduce the resolution? I'd love to introduce it to approve. Okay. Yes. We're done, Heidi. Thank you, Heidi, for your work on this. But I've got two other people who want us to speak. Okay. All right. Sure. Alex Sheffer, to approve. Okay. And Damon Ricks. Okay. You're both connected with the project. Okay. Anyone else wish to speak on this item? Okay. The item's been introduced. The resolution's been introduced. So please call the roll. A resolution of the city commission of the city of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, approving a subdivision improvements waiver for the plant entitled ECHO-R-Platt and providing for an effective date. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glassman? Yes. Mayor Tentals? Yes. And thank you, Commissioner Sorensen, for everything. Thank you. Thank you all. And don't forget to sign up. Okay. She got the card. R4 resolution creating an auditor selection committee and appointing a member of the city commissioner of the city of Fort Lauderdale to serve as chairperson. Why do we want this? I think that was Commissioner Herb, so it should be, again, Commissioner Lawrence. Number one. Yeah. Number one. It's amazing. Number one. It's just... Is that the 4th floor? You need to get your feet wet, Commissioner. We have that much trust and confidence in you. Welcome back. Yes. Yes. I personally have no interest in this whatsoever, so let's just move on. Yes. She needs to fill up her calendar. All right. It's right. Come on. I'm happy to serve. This is just her first day already. Thank you. She's happy to serve. She's happy to serve. Fantastic. We appreciate it, Commissioner. Thank you. Are you still on the garbage committee, Steve? I hope you are. That's the vice versa. He unloaded that onto me. Thank you. I'm proudly on the garbage committee. He dumped it on him. Thank you. And after nine years, I learned. Yes. Linda is very happy to have you on this, Commissioner Moraitis. Is that still going? Yes. It is still going. We'll give you an update. Okay. Moving forward, R5 resolution setting, the semi-monthly city commission meeting time. Do you need to vote? I have to introduce that. I can't hear you. I have to. We need an introduction for Moraitis. I need to read it. I'll introduce for approval that Commissioner Moraitis serve in this capacity in R4. Thank you. No, I thought we were going to eliminate the idea of having a selection committee. Do you still want to have an auditor selection committee? I think we have to have one. We have to. Okay. This is an outside auditor. Yes. Right. Okay. It's outside. We're not replacing the auditor. Resolution has been introduced. No one signed up to speak, so please call them all. A resolution of the city commission of the city of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, creating an auditor selection committee, appointing a member of the city commission to wit, Heather Moraitis, as chair of the auditor selection committee, specifying the powers and duties of the auditor selection committee, and providing for an effective date. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glassman? Thank you for your service. Yes. Mayor Chantelle? Yes. And R-4 is now approved. R-5. Now moving on to R-5, resolution setting the semi-monthly city commission meeting time. This is with regard to the... We're moving now into the end of the meeting to come after the ordinance on second reading. Right. Okay. Never mind. R-6, resolution approving a local agency program agreement with the Florida Department of Transportation for construction of the Tarpon River and Shady Banks neighborhood improvements, $1,961,544. Mr. and Sarah, is the only one who signed up to speak? Would you like to speak? I know you're a favorite. I know. You know me so well. Ted and Sarah, president of the River Oak Civic Association. I generally don't like to speak on more than one item per night, but the president of... No, really. I usually only do one. The president of Tarpon River, Vanessa Pothaker, had to leave, and she asked me if I would speak in her behalf, because we think the same way on this matter. You talk about... We are talking about the ultimate just checking the box for public participation. This is almost like the definition of that, because when... And this was done by the city. When they came to the... And I was there at the Tarpon River Civic Association to present this, it was met with no nobody liked it. Zero people liked it. It was with the roundabout. I can only speak on the Tarpon River aspect of this and not the Shady Banks aspect, but it was met with disdain. Nobody liked it. This is based on a 2016 FDOT survey. I mean, it's a 10-year-old study, and trust me, Tarpon River doesn't look nearly the same as it did now, as it did in 2016. And so when the city came and presented what they wanted to do, and nobody liked it, and then, you know, right now, what they presented to you is the same exact plan. They listened to nobody. Didn't you bring this up once before? Yes. Yes, exactly. Yes, I did. And it's the same argument as before. It was just... Well, at least you're consistent. There you go. Not everybody agrees with me, but you know what? I say the same thing to everybody, no matter who I'm talking to. So that's the... I don't change it around depending on who I'm talking to. But yeah, so nothing was done. They took zero considerations into anything that the Civic Association in the neighborhood said. Because, I mean, I was there because I know that they presented the same exact plan that they presented to the Civic Association. So that, my deduction is that they just wanted to check that box, we presented it, and here's the same plan anyway. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Vice Mayor, what are your thoughts on this? Thanks, Mayor. So, yep, I was at the same meeting. So, city managers, as we've talked about, this is, one, this is transportation traffic plan for two neighborhoods, Tarpon River and Shady Banks. City managers, we've talked about the, it's been very healthy, good feedback from the meeting that I attended to today, concerns from the neighborhood specifically about the roundabout that's proposed. And as you and I have talked about, but love to get an update on that, is that it's my understanding that, number one, if we do not approve this, we're going to lose substantial amounts of money for neighborhood traffic improvements. Number two, that the design of those improvements can be adjusted to meet the neighbor's desires as we continue to shape and form this project. So, we've been in contact with the MPO, who is where the funding is flowing through to the city on this project. We have continued to have conversations with them about the opportunities for the roundabout at this intersection. In this project, again, it's two neighborhoods, like you said. Tarpon River has two features within this. One is the roundabout at 9th, and I believe 9th. The other is a raised intersection. The bulk of this project is actually in Shady Banks, where most of these mobility improvements are going to be received. The last word we got from MPO, and this was very recently, we haven't received it in writing, but it was verbally, was that we have to move forward with the project as designed. We'll continue to have those conversations. We'll continue to look in the future at that intersection, if that roundabout is constructed, about what we can do around it or what we can do in lieu of it. But as of now, the feedback we received from the MPO was that in order for us to receive the money, the agreement has to be executed with the roundabout at 9th and 9th. Okay. Right. But the opportunity, so the opportunity to, so approve as exists right now in terms of plan, but the opportunity to adjust in the future remains. Is that right? I think the opportunity for conversation exists. As of now, the MPO is saying the roundabout needs to be part of the project. Okay. I could not guarantee today that we would be able to, through this project and this agreement, not do the roundabout. Now, what we do in the future as a city with our intersection, you know, those are things we can discuss in terms of what our flexibility and options are in the future. But I couldn't guarantee to you today the roundabout wouldn't get constructed under this agreement, based on what I've heard from the MPO as recently as this morning through staff. So, Vice Mayor, what are your thoughts on this? Yeah. I mean, it's just, it's frustrating because we've heard conflicting things from different entities at different times. So, I can't support it if this is, if city manager is saying we can't change it, we're not sure if we can change it. I can't support it. Thanks, Mayor. Yeah. And I think the conflicting information is accurate. We had gotten some information a while back that we could potentially alter this, but the more recent communication from MPO is that we're not able to at this time. So, who was, so I know how the MPO works. They work at a snail's pace and the design of this project must have taken a long time. So, who was heading up this design project to the point where the neighbors didn't want any of the elements of it? I mean, who were they, who were they designing it for? So, I'll let Colette Satchel talk a little bit about the history, but as you've heard and what's in the cam, this project's been going on for a number of years. So, at one point, this was the design that was determined to be the design that was, that there was interest in or achievable. Since then, obviously, when we get to that more complete design package and we represented it to the community, there's been some changes in opinions on what these features are, it sounds like. Hi. Good evening. Colette Satchel, Capital Projects Director. Back in 2017, 2018, we did a number of rounds of presentations to the community. And in order to advance the project, we really had to get letters of support from each of them. So, we do have a letter of support from the Tarpon River Civic Association, and that is the basis of the design for the project. As you know, we started with a concept, a master plan. We moved through getting community support, and then we go after funding. It took us several years to get funding for this project, and the funding did not arrive in, if I'm incorrect, it arrived in 2024. So, we've really only been designing since 2024. So, we've been working with FDOT and the MBO. Well, that's two years. And the design is complete. When we presented to the Tarpon River Board in June, it was a project that's at 90%. We were presented with the agreement for this agreement was presented to us first in August. So, there wasn't any time between then and August to really make changes to the design. No, but I mean, all this time that this design was evolving, and you were receiving neighborhood input, and the design professionals were collaborating with neighborhood voices, and now we're hearing that nobody wants it? I don't understand this. I am new, but the first that I heard of this was in June of this year, when we went to provide an update to the neighborhood. Since we've taken over, we've made a process of actually reaching out to the neighborhoods, engaging them, and advising them of the project. We've met with Shady Banks twice. We've met with Tarpon once. But it was at the Tarpon River that we heard this for the first time in June of this year. The design was already at 90%. FDOT was already preparing the agreement that is for the funding that we're presenting here today. But you said you have a letter from Tarpon? Yes, back in 2017, I believe, or 2018. Yes. 2018? Yes, sir. But that was the basis. That's a few years ago. But that was the basis for the funding. Remember, when you go for the funding, you have to show support. I understand that. I understand that. Yes. Mayor, it's frustrating for me that just this process, we heard, so June was, what, six months ago, and we heard real concerns about the specific part of the roundabout, not wanting to have the roundabout. It's just, I'm not saying it's anyone's fault, but it's just frustrating that we can't adjust and pivot. I mean, you serve on the NPO, I serve on the NPO, you know, that we can't adjust as needed. I think anything can be adjusted. So do I. So that's what's so frustrating to me. Well, no, no, no. I'm saying, while Chris spoke correctly and properly in saying that, you know, it's in stone what we're doing. Nothing's ever in stone, knowing the process, knowing that it'll continue to evolve. I know we're at 90%, but I do know that changes could always be made. So I would support this because I don't want to see, I was staring $2 million in the face. It took eight years to get it. You guys have worked so aggressively. You know, it's not an easy process. And I think that once we have the money in hand, we can figure out what to do with it after that. So I'm going to support this. So, all right. Yeah, and Mayor, I did talk to Vanessa Apotheker, the Tarpen River president, last night and earlier today about this. And I asked what their primary concerns were with the roundabout, which she told me were two things. One was there was concerns that this would create a little bit of gridlock at that intersection with folks trying to use that roundabout, as well as the overall maintenance. There's been some roundabouts in the community that the landscaping and some of the features in that have not been maintained in a very, in a nice way. You know, I live in a neighborhood with one of the busiest roundabouts in the city, 15th Avenue. Yeah. Okay. And it is not a, it does not create a bottleneck. It actually helps facilitate cars to go through that intersection. So, you know, I just think that's a misnomer. I think it's an unnecessary fear. And I think, you know, we should respect the, the, the integrity of the design consultants, as well as the many neighbors who participated in this project. And I think that, you know, going forward, there can be adjustments made to the design of a roundabout. But I, I mean, I don't know why the city is so fearful of roundabouts, but we have many successful ones. There are a number of them on Bayview Drive. I mean, I remember when they. Yes, we just put them in a couple of years. Yeah. And everyone protested before the roundabouts went in because they said they were going to be clogging traffic and there are traffic hazard and all that. And not everybody loves them. Yeah. Actually, they want another one. It does slow the traffic down a little bit. Which is what they're intended to do. Right. So they actually like them now and they're requesting another one. Yeah. So, okay. Thank you. Go ahead. Go ahead. I have one question on the backup, too. I was looking at the other neighborhoods that are part of the master plan. Twin Lakes North, Palm Air Village, and Corbett Country Club Estates. So those are in my district also. Do they receive funding and the project's already done? Or are we, where are we with those projects? I will ask Milos. Yeah. Or I can get an update later, too, if they're still ongoing. We will have to provide you an update on that. Okay, great. I'd love to get that when you have it. Milos, can we do it for all of those neighborhoods listed in the camp? Not just, if you could also do, no, I'd like to know what the update is on the district two ones also that are listed. Thanks. So, I believe those are neighbors with mobility master plans, and Karen Warfel, can you come up and talk about those mobility plans and kind of the lab program overall? Before Karen shares, I just have a question before we go in a different direction. In regards to if this does not pass, how does that affect Shady Banks? Because this project is really connected to two communities. So, if we do not move forward with this, does that eliminate the opportunity for Shady Banks? Yeah, I can answer that. Karen Warfel with the Transportation Mobility Department. It won't only impact Shady Banks. It will impact Northeast 15th Ave, an upcoming project through the same program, as well as South Middle River, another project we have programmed, and we also applied for Riverside Park this year. So, it would impact any future projects we have in the pipeline, as well, if we give back this money. It's through the local agency program with DOT. So, they look at how we perform, how we're doing, if we're meeting timelines, those types of things. If we give money back, we will not be looked favorably. And we wouldn't be able to apply for several years moving forward, as well. Yeah, that's... Thanks for that. It's about, probably, we have right now, I did calculate, it's about a little over $10 million in the pipeline we have through this program moving forward, including this one. Thank you for that clarity. Thank you, Karen. And then I did one about the master plan. So, the city had a mobility master plan program several years ago. We've done a variety of neighborhoods across the city. We've implemented some of the priorities. So, the process was, we had a series of about four meetings per neighborhood. So, there was a lot of community engagement in these plans before. It wasn't just created out of nowhere. We had four different meetings. We met with the community, asked what their challenges were first, then came up with solutions, developed those, worked with them on priorities, and then applied for grants. So, Bayview is one that came out of that program. These are priorities from the neighborhoods back then. And as you know, our program for funding, it's, when we apply, we're applying for five years from now. And in this process, it adds an extra year. So, it's actually six years that you're going to design. So, unfortunately, it takes forever. But we did receive a lot of community engagement. I know there was a question. There was, I, we went before we applied for those applications that we're talking about tonight to each neighborhood and got their consensus. And there was at least 120 people in the room that day because there was a development of contention that night. So, there were a lot of people engaged and who gave support for that application. All right. Thank you. City Manager, who at FDOT is saying this can't be adjusted? So, I'll ask Milos. I know he had some conversations with the NPO. So, maybe Colette. We had a meeting with Maya Williams and her team. And that was the direction we got. We also got that same from several members of the NPO. I don't have the names with me. Okay. So, staff members are saying you can't, has to be a roundabout right there. You can't change that. Well, not that it has to be. But we cannot change the plans at this time because the agreement that you see in front of you, these plans are the basis for that agreement. Any changes to the scope of work changes not only the agreement, but then it has, the whole project has to go back through the full review process. So, we would not be able to meet the deadline to spend the funds in this fiscal year. So, we've used up all of the contract time. We have to spend these contract funds in this fiscal year, which ends in June, or at least then cumber in June of next year. So, any change that we make is going to delay the project. If it's even to, say, switch from a roundabout to a raised table, which was a request, it's going to send us back to 30% design. We've got to go through a full constructability analysis. We have to, the entire permitting process. What percent design are we at now? We're approaching 100. Okay. Do projects ever reach 100% and then there's a change from 100% to the actual construction? Does that ever change? Typically, no. No. Once we get, yeah, once we have an agreement for the funds, it's very difficult to do that. So, there's no way to ever change this. Okay. It starts over. Yeah. Thanks. Okay. Thank you. No one else has signed up to speak? Would someone like to introduce the resolution? Introduced. Okay. Resolution has been introduced. Please call the roll. A resolution of the City Commission of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida approving a local agency program agreement authorizing the acceptance of grant funds from the State of Florida Department of Transportation for the local agency program grant in the amount of $1,961,544 for the construction of the Tarpon River and Shady Banks neighborhood improvements delegating authority to the City Manager to execute the local agency program agreements together with any and all documents necessary or incidental to accept such grant funds on behalf of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida and providing for an effective date. Commissioner Beza Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? No. Commissioner Moretis? Yes. Commissioner Glassman? Yes. Mayor Trentaels? Yes. And that item is now approved. R7, resolution declaring the results of the 2026 special municipal elections. We declare the results. What do we do? So what do you, we just have to, we just have to approve a resolution accepting the, okay. Someone like to introduce the resolution? Interjust for approval. Okay. Introduce for approval. No one signed up to speak. Please call the roll. A resolution of the City Commission of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida accepting the Broward County Canvassing Board certification of the November 3rd, 2026. City of Fort Lauderdale special municipal elections, City Commissioner District 1 and Charter Amendments declaring the results of such special municipal elections and providing for an effective date. Commissioner Beza Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moretis? Yes. Commissioner Glassman? Yes. Mayor Trentaels? Yes. An R7 is now approved officially. PH1. This is a public hearing, a first reading, quasi-judicial ordinance, approving a rezoning from Commerce Center District to Uptown Urban Village Northwest, 6301 Northwest, 5th way. Anyone who wishes to speak must be sworn in, and the commission will announce any site visits, communications, or expert opinions received and make them a part of the record. This is with Barbara Hall. Did we have any communications, Barbara? This is your item, right? I'm sorry? This is your item, correct? Okay. Do we have any communications with any of the commissioners? I didn't think so. Get with me. You did with me? District 1. Yeah. Oh, okay. I caught it. I caught it yesterday. Okay. So, Commissioner Moretis, did you have any disclosures? Well, yes. Barbara Law and I spoke yesterday. Okay. Or 1113. Yes, 1113. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Like a year ago about this? I don't think this one. Not this one or something else. Yeah. I'm going to say no, no disclosures. I have no disclosures, Commissioner Glassman. None. No. None. Thanks, Mike. No. Very good. It's only me. Okay. You're just here for questions, correct? Yeah. The city is actually the applicant on this. This is one of those properties up in the Uptown District, which is being changed to the Uptown District, so it can be developed as a mixed use. It's already, the site itself has ground-level parking and an office building, and the ground-level parking area is going to be turned into a multifamily project. Okay. Very good. Yeah. So, it needs to be rezoned. Okay. Thank you. No one else has signed up to speak. Would someone like to move to close public hearing? Move. Move. Second. Move the seconded. Please call the roll. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glassman? Yes. Mayor Trim-Tiles? Yes. Public hearing is now closed on PH1. Would someone like to introduce the ordinance on first reading? Introduced. The ordinance has been introduced on first reading. Please call the roll. In ordinance to the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, amending Section 47-1.6.B of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida Unified Land Development Regulations through the revision of the Official Zoning Map of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Schedule A, Revised Compilation Tester 2, and by reference made a part thereof. So is the rezoned from Commercial Commerce Center District to Uptown Urban Village, Northwest District, Lots 24, 25, 30, and 31, and a portion of Parcel C Corporate Park at Cypress Creek. According to Platt, thereof is recorded in Platt Book 108, page 11 of the Public Records of Broward County, Florida, located north of West Cypress Creek Road, east of Power Line Road, west of North Andrews Avenue, and south of Northwest 65th Court, all said lands being in the city of Fort Lauderdale, Broward County, Florida, providing for conflict, providing for severability, and providing for an effective date. Commissioner B.C. Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moretus? Yes. Commissioner Glassman? Yes. Mayor Trentos? Yes. And PH-1 is now approved on first reading. PH-2, public hearing, first reading, quasi-judicial ordinance approving the vacation of a right-of-way 501 Solar Isle Drive. Anyone wishing to speak must be sworn in. The commission will announce any site visits, communications, or expert opinions received that make them a part of the record. Mr. McAloon has signed up to speak, I assume, for questions. Commissioner Moraitis, do you have any disclosures? I don't believe so. Yeah, no. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? None. I have none. Commissioner Glassman? Site visit and also had a conversation with the Neighborhood Association President, Dr. Ruddy. None. Okay. You're just here to answer questions? Yeah, I have a full presentation, but in the interest of time, I'll just be available to answer any questions. Okay. Would someone like to move to close public hearing? Move. Second. Move. Seconded. Please call the roll. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glassman? Yes. Mayor Trentos? Yes. And public hearing on PH-2 is now closed. The backup is pretty straightforward. Anyone have any questions with Mr. McAloon on this item? No, just that this is a win-win for the neighborhood and the property. You know, we have a couple of seawalls that are really lacking in that neighborhood, and I'm looking forward to seeing at least one get done, and hopefully the second one as well. Thank you. All right. Would you like to introduce the ordinance? Sure. Okay. The ordinance has been introduced. Please call the roll. In an ordinance of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, vacating approximately 979-square-foot triangular portion of Rio Coral Canal of Riviera, according to the plot thereof, as recorded in Plot Book 6, page 17 of the public records of Broward County, Florida, located west of Solar Isle Drive, north of New River, east of Flamingo Drive, and south of Solar Plaza Drive, all said lands, being the City of Fort Lauderdale, Broward County, Florida. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glossman? Yes. Mayor Trantos? Yes. And that's approved on first reading. Thank you. Thank you. PH3, public hearing, and first reading, an ordinance approving of public purpose use and structure for a 13,941-square-foot fire station. Yes. I have a lot of questions. Yeah. I have a lot of questions on this one. Mr. Kice and the people that have signed up to speak already. It's related to the project, so I assume they're for questions only. Someone would like to move to close public hearing? So moved. Second. Moved and seconded. Please call the roll. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glossman? Yes. Mayor Trantos? Yes. The public hearing on PH3 is now closed. Would someone like to introduce the ordinance? Introduced. Introduced. Does anyone have any questions or comments? There being none, please call the roll. In order to the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, approving pursuant to Section 47-18.26 of the City of Fort Lauderdale Unified Land Development Regulations, the location of a fire station as a public purpose use and structure on property within the Parks, Recreation, Open Space Zoning District, legally described as a portion of Government Lot 6 in Section 36, Township 49 South, Range 42 East, Broward County, Florida, said portion being within Hugh Taylor Birch State Park, being 200 feet in width and 160 feet in length. Lying adjacent to the north right-of-way line of East Sunrise Boulevard and being 739.90 feet west of the southeast corner of said Section 36, all said lands being the City of Fort Lauderdale, Broward County, Florida, and identified by the United States Postal Service Address 2871 East Sunrise Boulevard, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, granting relief from zoning regulations codified in Section 47-8.30, Section 47-20.2, Section 47-21.12, Section 47-21.12. Section 47-21.13.B.1.A. and Section 47-21.13.B.1.16 of the ULDR, providing for conflicts, providing for an effective date, and providing for conditions for the termination of public purpose status. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moretis? Yes. Commissioner Glassman? Yes. Mayor Trentals? Yes. And PH-3 is now approved on first reading. PH-4. Thank you, folks. Public hearing, second reading, an ordinance amending Chapter 11, Section 11-25, civil penalties to increase the uncontested and contested fine for alcoholic beverage violations. No one has signed up to speak. Would someone like to introduce the ordinance? Introduced. It's been introduced. Wait, we still have to close public hearing. I'm sorry. Would you like to move to close public hearing? Move to close public hearing. Do I hear a second? Second. Moved and seconded. Please call the roll on closing public hearing. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moretis? Yes. Commissioner Glassman? Yes. Mayor Trentals? Yes. Public hearing on PH-4 is now closed. Now it's introduced to resolution. I just have a question about it real quick. Is this a fine per person that has it or per establishment? Does the business get fined or the person holding the alcohol? I know it went, it's going up, but I just don't know who looks like it might be the establishment, but do we find people? Yeah. Commissioner, it could be both. So it could be an establishment that's serving improperly, but it could also be somebody consuming a beverage in a way that they shouldn't be consuming that beverage. Okay, so if an establishment breaks our ordinance, they just get a $500 fine? Wait, doesn't the state preempt us on persons? Isn't there a state statute regarding? No, for open container? No. It's a state statute with regard to drinking age. Right, but we can cite for open container and things like that. That's what this relates to. Okay. Okay, so both would maybe technically get fined, where they come from and the person holding it. Okay. Okay, any other questions? There being none, a public hearing is now closed. The ordinance has been introduced by the vice mayor. Please call the roll. In ordinance of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, amending the City of Fort Lauderdale Code of Ordinances, Section 11-25, to increase the uncontested and contested fine for alcoholic beverage violations, along with delegation of staff authority, providing for severability, repeal of conflicting ordinance provisions, codification and correction of scrivener's errors, and an effective date. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glossman? Yes. Mayor Trent-Holks? Yes, and PH-4 is now approved on second reading. OFR1, these are first reading in ordinance, correcting ordinance C-26-11, and ordinance vacating a 50-foot-wide by 102-foot-long portion of the right-of-way of Coconut Drive. No one has signed up to speak. Would someone like to introduce the ordinance? Introduced for approval. The ordinance has been introduced for approval. Please call the roll. In ordinance of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, correcting Exhibit A in ordinance number C-26-11, pertaining to the vacation of a right-of-way adjacent to Blocks 4 and 5, the next subdivision, according to Platt-Therap, as recorded in Platt Book 22, page 22 of the public records of Broward County, Florida, located west of Southwest 11th Avenue, north of West Davie Boulevard, east of South Fork, New River, and south of Southwest 9th Street, all said lands being the City of Fort Lauderdale, Broward County, Florida. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glossman? Yes. Mayor Trent-Holks? Yes. Reading. ORF R2, first reading, an ordinance amending Chapter 28 of the Code of Ordinances to correct the wastewater volumetric rate for commercial accounts. No one has signed up to speak. Would someone like to introduce the ordinance? Introduced. The ordinance has been introduced. Please call the roll. In ordinance of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, amending Chapter 28 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, to correct the wastewater volumetric rate for commercial accounts, provide for severability, provide for repeal of all ordinances in conflict, and provide for an effective date. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glossman? Yes. Mayor Trent-Holks? Yes. And OFR2 is now approved on first reading. Moving on to OSR1, this is an ordinance of second reading, amending Section 2-26 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, by modifying the commencement time of City Commission meetings and modifying the days in which public hearings, ordinances, resolutions, and motions may be heard. No one has signed up to speak. Would someone like to introduce the ordinance? Introduced. I just have a question real quick. Please go ahead. Take your time. Reading the back up, I see the 9 a.m. and the 1 p.m. Are we changing it to 9 a.m. just in case we want to meet earlier that day? Commissioner, I'm so sorry. This ordinance enables you to change the date by resolution. The resolution is following, and you're setting that for 1.30. You've been continuing to lose your voice. It's getting worse. I know. I'm so sorry. It's a cold in her throat. Okay, so we can have a meeting earlier. Yeah, this enables you to change the dates and the times of the meetings by resolution instead of changing the ordinance. Instead of changing the ordinance. Are we considering having earlier meetings, like 9 a.m.? No. I'm just curious where we're going with this. So, 1.30. I'll be deferring to the board. I'll be deferring to the vice mayor. I'm just going to point at the four boards. No, we're going to schedule all our future meetings around your account. Don't worry. We're going to be okay. We're going to be okay. All right. Thank you. I'm good. Any other questions? No. Okay. The ordinance has been introduced. Please call the roll. In order to the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, meeting section 2-26 of the Code of Orders of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, by changing commencement time of the city commission meetings and providing for severability, repeal of conflicting ordinance provisions, correction of scrivener's errors, and an effective date. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moretis? Yes. Commissioner Glassman? Yes. Mayor Trentals? Yes. And OSR 1 is now approved on second reading. We'll now go back to R5, resolution setting of a semi-monthly city commission meeting time. Someone would like to introduce the resolution? Introduced. Resolution's been introduced. No one has signed up to speak. Please call the roll. A resolution of the City of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida setting, the commencement time of the city commission meetings and providing for publication rescission of conflicting resolution provisions in an effective date. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Hurt? Yes. Or Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glassman? Yes. Mary Trental? Yes. I hired you. Careful. Yes. Yes. Yes. So R5 is now approved. Now the last item, OSR 2, we have quite a few people signed up to speak. Can we just take like a five to eight minute break before we go into that? Thank you all for your patience. The commission needed a little break. So a number of people have signed up to speak on OSR 2. I would ask as a courtesy, if you've already spoken on this item, like the first time we had this on the agenda, I'd appreciate if you chose not to again to speak because it's getting kind of late and I think we respected your opinion the first time as much as we respect it now. So anyway, a number of people have signed up to speak. City Attorney, are there any comments you'd like to make with regard to the ordinance that relate to any changes or modifications that were made to the ordinance since the first reading? No, Mayor. But with my voice, I'm also deferred to... Say it again? No. However, I would also like to defer some of the questions to the Deputy City Attorney, Mr. Spence. Mr. Spence, where are you? Thank you. Are there any comments or modifications you'd like to relate to the commission tonight before we proceed? Sure. And during our first hearing of the ordinance, which was a public hearing required by the ordinance for the decertification, the City Commission directed us to make certain adjustments to the ordinance. The ordinance before you, as adjusted, now revokes immediately all of the privileges afforded for the 111 Properties Special Entertainment District, also known as the Hemerslee District. With the exception of the distance requirements for establishments, the ordinance provides a 180-day period for all establishments to come in compliance with the distance requirements. So those are the only modifications. So those who have currently been operating under the ordinance now have 180 days after today to come into compliance? With the distance requirement. That's correct. Okay. The distance separation. And that wasn't there the first time around, correct? That's correct. Okay. So that modification, that accommodation now has been made to any particular business owner? That is correct. Okay. Even if they were operating illegally under the ordinance, we're still going to respect the fact that they were operating and that should they have the ability to come into compliance, they would give them 180 days. So as you know, there are some establishments that were not a part of the Special Entertainment District, but somehow obtained licenses to sell alcoholic beverages and were also obtained business receipts to operate. We've acknowledged that some of them have mistakenly operated under the presumption, is how we phrase it in the ordinance of operating under the privilege, and they too can seek compliance. Okay, great. All right. Excellent. All right. Thank you. So a number of people have signed up to speak. And like I said, if you spoke the first time around, we'd appreciate if you would defer to others to allow them to speak. I'll call your names three at a time. You'll have two minutes to speak. Start out with Sandy Faye, followed by Connice Brown, followed by Ian Lowe. Good evening, sir. I want to push the button at the bottom of the speaker. I pressed that it did not stick. Good evening, again, Mr. Mayor, Mr. Vice Mayor, Commissioners. I did speak previously on this, but if you'd hear me out a couple seconds, I'm not here to argue against the motion today. My name is Sandy Faye. I speak on behalf of Her Rock Center Limited, the owner of a property in the Hemeristry District since 1986. Three of the establishments that are part of the existing Hemeristry SED, E-BAR, Dicey-Riley's, and Club Bureau, operate from our building. And as tenants have operated successfully in the district for many years without major incident. We understand the City Commission is deciding to decertify the Hemeristry SED. While that's not the outcome we wanted, we understand that's the committee's decision, and I'm not going to waste your time trying to change your minds here today. What I'm here for today is to discuss what happens next after the certification takes place and the substantive impacts to your decision. During the past several months, when we had discussions over almost a year now, discussions with staff and the commission regarding the future of the SED, what we heard was people wanted a structure that had enforcement and teeth. We had that with the proposed extended hours permit ordinance that you all decided to table at the October 20th meeting. Again, not a decision that we wanted, but we understand that that's what the commission decided to do. The certification ordinance that we're discussing today will give the establishments, as you noted, 180 days to become compliant with the distance requirements. For the existing businesses in the district, that's really a heavy task. And for the most part, not feasible, because these businesses can't move their physical locations, and it is very difficult to convert their existing business to something that would be otherwise exempt from the 300-foot requirement. We understand that the commission has directed the staff and the city attorney's office to craft what we're calling a transition ordinance to allow some sort of grandfather status to people that are in the existing SED. What we ask is that the certification and implementation be taped, be delayed pending the implementation of that new ordinance. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Mr. Brown, followed by Ian Lowe, followed by Michael Peter. Good evening, Mayor, Vice Mayor, Commissioners. I did speak on this the first time. I wanted to cover a couple things tonight, though they're a little bit of an update to the commission, so I'm not going to go through Dicey Riley's history and all that. I'm here on behalf of Dicey Riley's. And the essential point of what I want to break up is it's the same theory I've always had, that being that we should have a grandfathering in provision. And what has happened since the last meeting, obviously we thought that the two ordinances would be handled together, the one calling for the permitting as well as the one that we're on tonight. But the permitting ordinance was tabled, and I know last time, Mayor, you said that, you know, I would get to speak on that later. It didn't happen because of the tabling. In my mind, the key thing that has to be addressed here is the grandfathering aspect, because we do have seven of the surviving originals that were parties to all of this and have been relying all these years on the distance separation. That's what I'm focused on, because our situation is Dicey Riley's has over $2.4 million in improvements to that building, structural. They can't move the building, and they've spent more than $250,000, $250,000 in the last round to buy, basically, lease extensions out through 2054. And they don't have any way to get that money back. So they have an enormous, overwhelming investment in that location. And my concern is, at the moment, we're on a 180-day leash in terms of, let's say, that 181 days from now, we don't have anything in place on grandfathering. It's still up in the air. You know, what happens that day? Do we shut that whole business down? And what I would like to do is, I would like to amend, by interlineation tonight, the ordinance to indicate that the decision on suspending, that essentially, until we get a decision on grandfathering, we keep the distance separation suspended. And when you look at most of the complaints here, they haven't been about the distance. They've been about other stuff the commission has already fixed. Well, let me ask you a question. Sure. If you're asking us to grandfather in the existing businesses, what have we changed? Well, I think what we- Nothing. I'll answer the question for you. Nothing. We've accomplished nothing. So why would we want to grandfather? It's like saying, we want to change it, but we're going to let everybody stay the way, the status quo, and we're not going to change any of the things that we hope to accomplish. Isn't that what you're asking tonight? No, Mr. Mayor. I would respectfully disagree with that, because all we're asking, you guys have already made your decisions on 4 o'clock. We're not asking for that. That's what these clubs all wanted to start with. Right. You guys have already made your decision on the noise, okay? So the two things that all the complaints were about were those. All we're asking is- Those that- Okay, go ahead. So we're not really dealing with the same businesses at all, and one of the things that has to happen under this new regime, those businesses will have to transform into businesses that are substantially different. There's nowhere around it, because they were based on the whole late night hours concept. If that's out the window, then that business shouldn't be out the window. It should just get the same opportunities to everybody else, especially- Dyson's has been there since 94. 94, to throw people out like that, or just shut them down, because they were within the ordinances in the past, but those ordinances were no longer popular. I don't think we're wanting to shut businesses down. We're just asking businesses to comply with the requirements of the law. But at the moment, the requirement that we don't have settled is a distant situation, because as I explained, you can't move that bar physically. Believe me, if you could, that would be a debate. I understand. And we're sort of stuck in that location because of all these years of reliance on this. And not only back when the thing was initially renovated, including structural, which certainly can't go anywhere, but in addition to that, we've since spent all this money to get the lease extensions. And no one would have ever done that if they were going to get wiped out in 180 days. We just need to get some certainty that we will be able to go forward on a grandfathered basis, and the new rules are going to be what the new rules are. You know, if we're being a competing business at other bars in town. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Ian, followed by, is Michael Peter here? Oh, okay. Followed by Vincent Alexander. Good evening, Mayor and Commissioners. I have spoke on this before. I just wanted to touch a couple of subjects real quick. The goals are making the district safe and getting rid of the underage and the violence, right? Vote yes, and you'll be removing 10 to 15 police officers off the street every single week, paid by the businesses. I personally pay $45,000 to $50,000 a year for my detail officers, and I'm a smaller business. The bigger businesses pay more. So does the commission have a plan, $500,000 yearly plan for security with FLPD? Because we're not going to be paying that anymore after tonight. Are they ready for this weekend? Are they ready for the holiday season? I also believe that the district does fall back under the 18 and up city code and state code if it's not in an SED district. If the whole goal is getting rid of the underage, how are we making it easier for the underage bars? I believe that voting yes will fall back to that. And then the kicker is the bad actors are only open a few days a week, and they don't care about the hours. My business, one of the more responsible businesses on the street, has been open seven days a week for food until 3 a.m. for 25 years, with an outstanding record and reputation with the city. Mr. Hopper from PAC and New River Trading Post asks, where the entertainment is in the entertainment district? My business employs 400 music acts a year, 365 days a year, two acts on Friday, every single night live music. Why is fat cats collateral damage in this? The good actors. Why are the good actors getting punished and the bad actors seem to be doing okay because they're not worried about the hours? Rebuilding the SED contract, bringing the district back to 21 and up, and a new FLPD security plan accomplishes your goals without hurting and damaging the good actors. If this is really about violence and underage, why are we making it easier? I hope that you guys consider this, and then we can work on something else. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Michael Peter. Mayor Trantalis, commissioners, thank you. My name's Michael Peter. I actually don't have any association with these businesses, but I attend events at chemistry quite often downtown Fort Lauderdale. In 1992, Fort Lauderdale created the framework allowing qualifying establishments to serve until 4 a.m. 34 years ago. If the hours haven't changed, what has? Well, Hemercy, in my view, has become a street gathering destination itself. Like I said, down there regularly for EDM events at chemistry, and I've experienced life-changing joy and community inside that venue, and I've seen what happens outside it. We don't have an open-too-late problem. We've got a loitering and a street disorder problem. Outside of specific events, we should not allow Hemercy to be Broward's weekend street party. Yet currently, that's exactly what's happening. So why are we treating the hours as the problem, especially when we already have laws to fix the real issue? 1671 prohibits obstructing streets and sidewalks. 1672 prohibits loitering that creates reasonable safety concerns or interferes with pedestrian or vehicle access. 1673 addresses gatherings that hinder passersby and authorizes police to order dispersal. Yet I've never personally witnessed any sort of disbursement before closing time, not a single time. Further, FS 162.22 and 901.15 allow arrests for qualifying ordinance violations. And our ordinance already carried fines and possible jail time under City Code 1-6. FS 856.021, 856.011, 877.03 also provide comparable criminal enforcement tools. So how many dispersal citations, arrests have been made under these laws? And of the arrests being cited to justify this proposal, how many involved patrons of these businesses versus people who never even entered them? Don't we have a more obligation to try consistent enforcement before jeopardizing people's livelihood? And do we honestly believe closing one hour earlier will fundamentally change that atmosphere? Why would general hooliganism suddenly change? Or a group blocking a sidewalk suddenly alter their behavior because bars they don't enter close an hour earlier? They won't. How many of you guys have experienced hemorrhage between midnight and 4 a.m.? Commissioner Glassman, you and I know each other through pickleball. By the way, Commissioner Glassman, great pickleball player. I would love to go with you in this entire commission to an event at Chemistry, honestly. Let me show you the magic inside, and then let's walk outside and see the difference together. We say we want to compete with Miami, where many venues operate until 5 a.m. Some operate around the clock. We're already at a disadvantage. We should be exploring extended hours for responsible establishments, not driving customers, and spinning south. Miami Beach has used targeted policing and controls as part of its response to comparable disorder. Why not give those tools a serious test here? I want hemorrhage safer. I want it thriving. Hold the people loitering, blocking our sidewalks, and causing safety concerns accountable because you can't solve an enforcement problem by changing the clock. Let's be better than Miami because we all know we can be, and we all know we should be. So I'm asking a commissioner to move to defer this ordinance and direct the city manager working with the city attorney and the chief of police to develop and implement a targeted comprehensive enforcement plan and report back on activity and results before we take operating hours from these businesses. Will somebody make that motion? All right. Thank you so much, sir. Mr. Alexander, followed by Steve Burke, followed by Rafael Rebby. Good evening. Good evening, Mayor, commissioners. First, Vincent Alexander of Schutzen-Bowen Law Firm on behalf of Revolution Live, Sway Night Club, and Munchies Pizza Club. Obviously, we're here on OSR, too, and we respectfully oppose the second reading and moving forward with it as written and planned. Yesterday, we also submitted a letter to the city attorney. I'm not sure if that letter was passed along. We do have copies of our letter if anybody needs one that I could present to the commission as well. So tonight, I'm not really going to speak about what we wrote in the letter, because we believe the letter steaks for itself in terms of the legal implications and in terms of how this is proceeding. But we also respectfully request that the letter be made part of tonight's record. Outside of the legal concerns, which I'm not going to run through, there are some other concerns that we think are just as important and need to be addressed that led to the creation of this district, the investments made in reliance on the creation of this district, and the success that has followed with respect to this district. More than 25 years ago, the city created this district to turn around a struggling part of downtown, to bring in private investment, draw visitors, and create establishments in terms of a nightlife to help this district become revitalized. Our clients answered that call and continue to answer that call today. They and other owners have invested millions of dollars. You've heard from people today regarding the amounts of money that have been invested into their businesses, and these are businesses that work for the community, work for the people who work there. And we think that a lot of it will be wasted now with the passing of this. We've paid for police detail. We've paid for security. The numbers that have gone out, it's a lot of money for these businesses, especially some of the smaller ones. This ordinance essentially will take away the district. And with the rules, these businesses were all built around and they rely on. That puts real jobs at risk. There's several of the people here who will speak on that. Cooks, security, staff, bartenders, musicians, and their families. Our clients want what was agreed to years ago, a district that stays in place. We hear the city's concerns. We want to address the concerns. We believe that by deferring this, that will give the businesses and all the interested parties further time to consider options to make sure that this district can remain vital and the businesses can still succeed and come up with a path forward. Because I think that's what everybody wants, is a path forward that works for everyone. Thank you for your time. And again, if you need the letter, we can submit that as well, city attorney. Okay, great. Thank you so much. Stephen Burke, followed by Raphael, I think, Remy, followed by John Farino. Good evening, Mayor and Commissioners. I'm going to speak frankly. I want to be real about what this decertification is. I don't believe it's about public safety, as crime has decreased in the neighborhood year over year for the past several years. I don't believe it's about a shooting, as there were way more shootings on the beach, and you're not doing anything about that entertainment district. It isn't about underage drinking, as him or she has no more of an underage drinking problem than Miami, New York, Chicago, or LA. In fact, the chief of police and the head of ABT, just one month ago, in a public meeting, said that the kids these days are using AI to create fake IDs that can beat the government scanners. So if they can beat the government scanners, they can certainly beat our scanners. So if it isn't about public safety, and underage drinking isn't a problem unique to him or she, what is this decertification really about? Is it possible that a developer wants to build a building in the entertainment district on city-owned property and can't get their approvals or financing without the entertainment district being decertified? Is it possible that's why we're being targeted? And when I say targeted, I really mean targeted. The city has used every resource it has at their disposal to abuse their power and target my business. We've had the FLPD code compliance, the fire department, and ABT come almost every single night over the past month. And let me be clear, I do not believe it is because the city is trying to make the block safer. But it is damaging my business and making my establishment inhospitable so patrons don't want to come back. Because if it was about safety, crime, or underage drinking, there would have been arrests in the past month. There were zero. The him or she businesses are resilient. And you may not think we have the knowledge of what's really going on or that we don't have the resources or the willpower to fight back. But we do and we will. Therefore, I urge you to postpone the vote on the second reading today. Stop harassing the businesses and instead work with the businesses to come up with a solution that works for everyone. Thank you. Chief Schultz, Chief Schultz, would you mind coming up here for a second? And by the way, sir, what business do you have? Munchies? Mayor, while Chief Schultz is coming up, if I may, just to remind everyone the reason for this decertification tonight, Mr. Burke is correct in that the points made are not directly why we're suggesting to decertify the district. The reason behind the decertification is because the common control element required from the district has not been in place for several years. And that's the basis for the decertification ordinance tonight. Okay. Thank you. Chief, can I ask you a couple of questions? Certainly, ma'am. Have you been out on Hemershey Street on patrol with members of your agency within the last couple of weeks? I have. And were you also accompanied by the state representatives of the Department of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms? Yes, I have. Okay. Were there any enforcement actions taken on behalf of the city or the state? Yes, there have been some enforcement actions. I will go through just a brief synopsis of what we have just over the last three weeks, three to four weeks. We have had 25 arrests for alcohol violations and narcotics. We've had 17 notices to appear for alcohol violations, confiscation of 80 fake identification cards. We had 75 traffic citations issued, also with the assistance of Florida Highway Patrol. And through that time, we had three vehicles towed. And I do have ABT's preliminary results from a three-week span within October up until about November 1st. And there were 19 total violations. Violations of what? Those were underage possession of alcohol and one possession of cocaine within one of the establishments. And fraudulent IDs total 56 in one week alone, 20 in one week, and then eight in one week. All right. Thank you very much. I appreciate that. You're welcome. Mr. Remy, Rafael. How are you guys doing? Got it. All right. My name is Rafael Remy. I've been downtown for 16 years. I'm the owner of Club Euro. I do want to say that the city of Fort Lauderdale, the police department, has been doing a great job. After we had a meeting with them and the state, and they put their action plan into place, immediately they started cleaning up the streets and getting rid of the loitering. And that was almost immediately. And we saw a difference with the streets immediately. Secondly, as far as the time, like we spoke about before, or what you guys were speaking about before, this economy is horrible. And there's people that can't get food. There's people that can't put gas in their car to go to work. And I know you guys think putting an hour back, one hour is not a major deal. But basically, cutting any revenue at all is a major deal, because it's hard to make it right now as it is in this economy. So losing an hour, losing a minute is basically going to put a lot of businesses out of business. And for a business like mine, I'm on the second floor. And I don't have a footprint on the first floor. So me becoming a restaurant is impossible, because I can't put a grease trap down. So there's no way I'm being put out of business. There's no way I can survive. And there's other businesses that can't survive. And with payroll going up, cost of goods going up, everything is going up. And we can't really pass that along to customers, because they're not going to come. It's hard enough to get them to come anyways. So there's nothing that we can do to survive if this ordinance goes past. So I would love if there is a path forward so that we can go forward, even though the district has been dissolved for a while. And we spoke previously about trying to do other things to move forward, and whether it was different businesses being licensed to move forward. But I would love for us to be able to move, find a way we can move forward and not have to go out of business. Okay. Thank you so much. All right. A question for you. Thanks. What's your name? Rafael. Rafael. Yeah. So what business do you? Club Euro. Club Euro. Okay. And so if I heard you right, you said this will force you to go out of business? Right. Because you... Go ahead. There's a few reasons. One, I can't become a restaurant. I have no footprint on the first. Um, secondly, um, as already tight as it is, because payroll went up, cost of liquor went up, insurance went up, uh, my, my rent went up, everything has gone up. Yeah. And now going back an hour, I'll be losing that little bit of revenue that I was making that would help me. Yeah. So under, completely understandable. So part of this plan will be to allow for paths forward, for you to explore paths forward so that you don't have to go out of business. In other words, there's going to be a process that city attorney's working on to say, hey, if you need, if you don't meet the distance requirement, right, which it sounds like you don't, right, that there, there are going to be ways, paths for you to explore, to get a waiver, to allow you to continue to operate. But are those, are those, um, plans in effect now or there, where there be, yeah. So good question. So they're being shaped and we're going to have more insight into those soon, but there will be paths that you can explore. So are those, is there a way we can have those paths before we decertified it and have to not be able to operate like we've been operating? So, city attorney, there, there's a grace period, tell me. 180 days. Yeah. So, yeah. So in other words, you're going to have 180 days. And during that time, we're going to determine paths. Vice mayor, there are also existing opportunities currently to apply waiver through the board of adjustment. Right. Mr. Spence could tell you more if you'd like. Yeah. So she's losing her voice, but what she said is basically there are, uh, ways now you can seek a waiver from, it's called the board of adjustment. Again, well, it's a lot of kind of legal, um, jargon, but there are ways that you can explore now to seek a waiver so that you don't have to go out of business. So we'll be able to still operate till the same time and not have the time, not the time. The time is going to, if this passes, if this passes, but to operate as the type of business is there's going to be paths to explore that. Yeah. And we'll help educate and, and walk you along what that is. Well, I think we more so need help on being able to bring that lost revenue back because losing an hour will give people an opportunity to just go other places because it's already bad enough that they have to pay for parking or a lot of places they can go for free to park and not have to pay for parking. And for example, um, I do a poetry event once a month that's during the daytime and people complain having to pay for parking when there's other events when, um, there, when there's other events downtown. So paying for parking $20, $30 to go to poetry is not feasible for people. So, um, we're talking about, you know, eliminating things, but we're not really talking about things to help bring more business downtown where we're already, already, already struggling. And then one more thing, um, with, uh, when the chief was talking about the enforcement that they have done, um, if, if possible, if you could speak about the improvement that they have done, cause he didn't really, he just talked about the things that, um, were done and the things that they caught, but their improvement that they have done is tremendous cause the loitering, which was the main problem has been almost eliminated. So if he can talk about that, that'd be great. Thank you guys. All right. Thank you. John Farino. John, there are two, you've signed, someone signed two cards for you, two completely different handwritings. These both you, uh, if this says my name, it is, I'm not sure how that happened though. Oh, you did? Okay. I'm pretty popular in here. There's someone impersonating you. I want to make sure he was here. Uh, good evening. Um, for the last month, the city of Fort Lauderdale has expelled every resource on our district to quote unquote, crack down on the violence and underage drinking that apparently is being allowed in our establishments. Supposedly the two reasons they intend to decertify our district and remove our 4am license this evening. The war zone like atmosphere that was created with the barricades, bright lights, and hundreds of officers across six different agencies every single night accomplished one goal. That goal was to hurt our business even more than the media segments, newspaper articles, and defamatory statements, defamatory statements that have been made in these commission meetings. Shining flashlights in pedestrians' faces and yelling at them to show identification is not proper practice. Have some decency. Harassing community members and decent human beings for enjoying a libation after a long week at work. Harassing our staff members with finger pointing and false accusations with zero evidence whatsoever. Raiding our establishments with multiple officers causing disruption to the entertainment that we all provide. You've managed to scare away a large portion of the hard-earning, tax-paying, law-abiding residents of Fort Lauderdale that need a cold one on the weekend or that need to dance to some good music and enjoy coming to our district to forget about the bills and stress of life that they sure enough will be coming, that they know sure enough will be coming again on Monday. Your minds are made up already, this I know. I just want it to be stated for the record that this egregious abuse of power will not go unanswered. To blame us for a problem on the street that the city cannot control is irresponsible. Take some accountability. Train your officers better and empower them to enforce the street better. Not harass customers inside of our establishments and punish business owners in our district. But we all know that that really isn't the issue, right? And when we are decertified, who is going to pay for the officers that patrol our block, by the way? Because we won't be. We can barely afford it as it is with this fiasco. And with these officers gone, do we expect our block to be safer without them because we close at 3 a.m.? Also, when someone gets shot at 2 a.m. Or the violence continues on the street, just as it is all over Fort Lauderdale, all over Broward County, all over Florida, and all over our nation, will you blame us again and rescind us to 1 a.m. closure? Will you continue to take from us until we close our doors for good so the developers we all know you are connected to can come in and start building? I think so. And many others do as well. Just know that this will not go away as easily as you think, and we will not walk away as quietly as you hope. We have bills also. We have families as well. My two children and my wife rely on me to provide for them, and you are putting that liability in jeopardy. You are jeopardizing the welfare of hundreds of other employees and business owners as well. But as long as the donors are happy, right? Thank you for allowing me the time to speak, and I hope you all have a happy Thanksgiving. Thank you. Last person, Francois. Is it Shidiak? Yep. Right. We meet again. I spoke last year about the container thing. You know, I'm just, I don't have any hands in the cards in the businesses here. I'm just a guy that grew up in Fort Lauderdale. I've been going out to the Himershi District about 20 years. I actually bought my house right by here to be able to go over to the Himershi District, because I know that is where to be in Fort Lauderdale. I think it's a great place. You guys are ruining a gold mine by doing anything. And I think it's the way you're doing it seems very corrupt. I'm just a guy looking at things, and I've seen this on the news that you're doing this. But, you know, the first thing I got to say is that you're on the news and you're saying, okay, well, we want to make it more family friendly. And I saw you say that, Mr. Dean, Mayor Dean. And the first thing is, I find you a little misguided, because you have a family. I mean, you're not striking me as a family kind of guy. So it's kind of like a fish, like saying, how do I climb a tree? You know, teaching how to climb a tree to be saying, you know, to be saying what's family friendly. But what I can tell you is I have a family. I just had a newborn child, and you can see him right here. And I'm very busy. And I was able to come here tonight, you know, in very little time. Because what I want to say is life is busy, especially when you have children. And being a family man now, when I have a night off where, you know, the child's been taken care of and I can go out, I want to be able to go out to downtown Fort Lauderdale. And I want to go out until 4 o'clock in the morning or as long as possible, because it's fun. It's one of the best places that there is. And right now, I don't see why. We live in a time where we have self-driving cars and Ubers and all this thing. There's a lot less problems than obviously 20 years ago when I was going there. Now people can just take an Uber home. We're not having drunk driving and all this. You know, we have things to go around that. The area is getting better. We also have street interviews and all this social media, putting Fort Lauderdale on the map. So that's why you're getting rid of a gold mine doing this. And if you want to hear family-friendly, I want to go back into that. My cousin met his wife down there at America's Backyard. They have two children, beautiful children. My sister, one of my brother-in-law, when I first met him, we went and danced at the poorhouse together. Me and my wife, we went out to Fat Cats. So this is families. This is family-friendly. And, you know, quite frankly, 3 to 4 a.m., all it is is revenue. You're just putting pressure on these businesses. It's corrupt. It's corrupt. Let capitalism decide. That's freedom. That's America. Let capitalism decide. Not some political corruption that I'm seeing here. And, you know, honestly, the rest stats didn't even sound that bad for, like, any city. So... Okay. Thank you so much. We appreciate your comments. Is there anyone else who wishes to speak on this item? There being none. Do we have to move to close public hearing? No. I don't think so. Okay. Comments, questions? Someone would like to introduce the ordinance? Introduced. The ordinance has been introduced. So, Mr. City Manager, could you please repeat exactly what is the nature of this ordinance? Yes, Mayor. So this ordinance proposes the decertification of the 111 properties or the Hemershee Special Entertainment District based on the fact that the common control element of that district has not been in existence for several years. And that's really the crux of an entertainment district here in Fort Lauderdale. It's the common ownership or common control element. So, if any of the requirements or elements of this SCD are not being met, the commission can adopt an ordinance to decertify the district based on that failure to have that element. So, if the city commission were to decide at some point to reconstruct an entertainment district, it would have to use certain criteria, which right now, the basis upon which the current entertainment district has been established is no longer in effect. Right, so a new district would have to meet the requirements and elements of an entertainment district in the code. There's a series of things that would need to be met, or the commission would create some other type of scheme to establish a district in a different form. Okay, I understand. All right. Does anyone have any questions or comments? I know this is your first time, Commissioner Moraitis, so do you have any thoughts or do you have any other questions? Have you heard enough? No, thank you. I've been following it. Okay. All right. Very good. All right. Does anyone else have any questions or comments? I know we discussed this at length the last time. So, all right. Mr. Clerk, please call the roll. In order to the city of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, decertifying the special entertainment overlay district established through the execution of a special entertainment overlay district agreement with 111 Properties, Inc., in accordance with Section 5-57, the Code of Ordinances of the City of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, providing for conflicts, providing for severability, and providing for an effective date. Commissioner Beasley-Pittman? Yes. Vice Mayor Sorensen? Yes. Commissioner Moraitis? Yes. Commissioner Glossman? Yes. Mayor Trenthalus. Mayor Trenthalus. Yes. And OSR 2 has now approved a second reading. And hopefully we can come up with opportunities to try to work with each and every one of these businesses in order to maintain a level of profitability and existence so that it works for both them and the city at large. So, is there any further business of the commission? Nothing further. Any member of the commission have anything further to ask or to comment on? There being none, this meeting is concluded. Thank you.