Okay, good evening and welcome to the November 19, 2026 City Commission meeting. I'd like to call this meeting to order and we are going to start with our invocation and pledge of allegiance by Jen. Please stand. Let us begin this meeting by taking a brief moment of silence and reflection as we enter the holiday season. Amen. I pledge allegiance to the life of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Okay, we're going to start with presentations and we had kind of a special presentation tonight. Donation of the POW MIA flag to the City of Dunedin from District 21 VFW Auxiliary and I'll call Stoney up and maybe you can bring up whoever else you need and introduce them. More the merrier. More the merrier. Mayor and Commissioners, thank you for welcoming us this evening. I'm Stoney Lawrence Edwards, President of VFW Auxiliary District 21. Joining me are, is my District Senior Vice President Nancy Hess, our VFW Post 2550 Commander Mark Alla, Post 2550 Auxiliary Senior Vice President Mary Ernie, and several other members in attendance from Post 2550. On behalf of VFW Auxiliary District 21, please accept this POW MIA flag for display at the VFW Post 2550 here in Dunedin. Awesome. This flag honors America's prisoners of war, those who remain missing and unaccounted for, and the families who continue to await answers. May it fly as a visible reminder of our community's commitment to remembrance, to seeking a full accounting of those still missing, and to keeping the promise written upon it, you are not forgotten. Thank you for helping us keep that promise. And thank you for all you do. As you know, we love our veterans. This is a very important part of that, remembering the MIAs, the POWs, and this means a lot. We really, to Stoney, I loved when you emailed and suggested that, you know, you guys could do this donation, and it really means a lot to us, and it will be flown proudly. So I think we want to get a picture, though. One picture? Okay. Hey, Sue, should I come down and make anything kind of flip the flag? Come off. Turn it off again, Stoney. Stoney. Stoney. Stoney. Turn it off. One, two, cheese. One, two, cheese. Thank you. Okay. All right. Don't go anywhere. Okay. All right. Let's see. May I'm a little that way. That way? A little way. Oh, Commissioner. Sorry. It took ten minutes. Stand up. Right. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Lori, after the depth of the scene. I'm totally glad. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. That puts us in the right mood, right? So we're going to go to citizen input. Does anyone in the audience wish to speak on a topic that is not on the agenda tonight? This would be the time to come forward. A topic that's not on the agenda. Okay. Seeing no one, I will close citizen input. We're going to go to consent agenda. So we have approval of the minutes for the October 6th, 2026 workshop, October 8th, 2026 regular meeting. We also have board and committee appointments for Board of Adjustment and Appeal, Dineen Causeway and Coastal Waterways Committee. We have housing authority, Public Safety Committee appointments, U.S. Military Veterans Advisory Committee appointments. And we also have 2C, Standard Parking License Agreement with BayCare Health System, Miestan Eden Hospital for parking lots at the northeast corner of Virginia Street and Milwaukee Avenue and northwest corner of Virginia Street and New York Ave. And those are the three. Does anyone wish for anything to be pulled off or removed? I would like to pull off 2B for a couple of questions. 2B? Maybe it's because I'm new, but 2B. Okay. That's okay. 2B. And I should have said, welcome to your first official meeting, Commissioner Bennett. Let's give her a hand. Okay. So we're pulling off 2B. So for 2A, which is approval of minutes, and for the parking license agreement, can I have a motion? So moved. Second. Okay. Does anyone in the public wish to come forward and speak on those two consent items? Okay. Seeing no one, I will close public input, and I will go to voice vote. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes unanimously. Okay. So now we're going to go back to board and committee appointments, and you had a question. On the board and committee appointments, who makes the recommendations for the appointments? I'm going to, I'll go ahead and let you, Michelle, just go ahead, since you're kind of under your turf. The members make the recommendations and commission appointments. Of the individual board? Each individual board, the members make it? That's correct. Okay. And how, what is the basis of the recommendations? They are, they tend to recommend the longest waiting, most qualified applicant. That is the suggestion. But not always. I'm just going to jump in. That's correct. Because I know there's a, there's certainly committees that they basically pick, you know, you know, sometimes people go to meetings a lot, and that kind of draws attention to somebody. Um, some people, they actually interview them, and then they select the best ones at the most qualified. Um, so it, it does depend, but it can vary a little bit. So I, I don't want to make this more onerous than it needs to be, but is there a possibility with these, we could have, like, at least a paragraph from the chairperson saying the board recommends this, and these are the reasons why we recommend this person's appointment? There has been, we, we do have a resolution in place, 99-13. It's, it's been somewhat, um, we've gotten away from it a little bit. We, there is, there have been attempts to come back to that. We, yes, the, the answer is yes, that, that could be put back into play. If that's the consensus of the commission, if I may. Yeah, I mean, I, I have no problem. I think, I think if it's just, you know, I would go back and check, but I, I, as long as it's not too onerous, I would think that's a good idea. That way, if somebody asks you, like, you know, I applied for that. Is there a reason why I wasn't appointed and someone else was? We'd at least have some explanation as to the board's thinking on that particular subject. I know some boards have very specific makeups, and they have to fill specific spots and things like that, but I, I think that would help us to respond to people that do apply, because most of the boards had a reasonable application list. We have a draft memo and a draft Excel spreadsheet that could help with that process, and, and, and most cases, I think the liaisons, rather than the chair, with the chair's assistance, but the liaisons would be, get those to the clerk's office, and then the hope would be to get them to commission a couple of weeks prior to it coming before you. That would help me. Thank you. Yeah, you're welcome. Well, we talked about this a little bit, too, because, you know, we never want to become a stamp of approval, so to speak, you know, and, and so we actually make the appointment, and it, it is important that we agree, you know, and concur that that's the best possible choice, so, because they're LA advisors to us, even though they're important to the board or to the committee, so, so good suggestion. Any other questions on it? No, that was the entire questions I had regarding that. Great. Thank you, Commissioner. Okay, so we're going to go ahead on board and committee appointment approvals for who's on there. I need a motion. So moved. Second. Okay, and does anyone in the public wish to come forward and speak on this issue? Holy smoke, former, former Commissioner Gao's in the house now. Well, look, look at that. Oh, he's trying to keep his head down. That's not going to work. Okay, anyway. Okay, so, does anyone in the public wish to come forward on this? Okay, seeing no one, I'll close public input. And I'll go to voice vote. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Motion passed unanimously. Okay, we're going to go to action items. So, our first action item is going to be 3A, Dunedin Causeway and Coastal Waterways Committee Continuance. And I think it looks like there's a staff presentation. Joe McLemore and the Chair, Hank Hode. Am I saying that right? Hank Hode? I should know that, and I apologize if I didn't say it right. But anyway. Heidi. Heidi, sorry. I'm way off. Yeah, that's the same on me. Anyway, yes, if you want to come forward, we start with staff, I guess, right? Well, I was just going to just kind of summarize. We're here to seek the continuance of the Dunedin Causeway and Coastal Waterways Committee. And I'll hand it over to Hank Hode, the Chair of the Committee, that makes a few words. Thanks, Tony. Good evening, Mayor Freeney and the Commission, members of the Commission. I'm really glad to be here. Again, my name is Hank Hode. I serve as the Chair of the Unedin Causeway and Coastal Waterways Committee. I thank you for the opportunity to report on the committee's work over the past year, as we're proud of our collective responsibility and our collaborative work. I would like to begin by thanking the commission for its decision earlier this year to keep the committee independent when the city looked at consolidating its advisory committees. The causeway sits where the city, county, and state responsibilities overlap, and residents, boaters, and visitors bring their concerns to us because we focus on that one corridor. So we appreciate your confidence in that role and believe this past year has shown its value. Our most visible work this year was on motorized watercraft. For several years, the committee documented conflicts on the causeway beach, including unlicensed commercial activity, high-speed traffic, and shared water with swimmers and paddlers, and damaged seagrass and the shoreline. When the 2024 hurricanes closed the beach to launches, we were able to see what the causeway looks like without disturbance as marine life flourished and congestion dropped. The commission adopted Ordinance 2608 to make that change permanent, and the city is now working with Pinellas County and the Florida Fish and Wildlife Commission on signage and enforcement. We see this as a good example of how the committee is meant to work, with citizens raising a concern, the committee studying it, and the commission responding. Swimming safety has also been a steady focus for the committee because the waters off the causeway are shared by swimmers, paddlers, and boats. We have kept the exclusion zone at Rotary Park on our agenda throughout the year, and I've worked to city staff and the county to restore markers and buoys that keep boats out of the swimming area. Looking ahead, the committee endorsed the city's Weaver Park Living Shoreline Project, which uses natural methods to stop erosion and restore habitat along St. Joseph Sound. Resilience was another major focus of our work this year, and we will continue to be. The committee reviewed the Pinellas County-Duddin Causeway Vulnerability Assessment and Resilience Plan, which found that storm surge is a major threat, as seen by Hurricane Helene, and that design and engineering practices will need to be considered to protect the county's causeway's infrastructure and the recreation areas to withstand future impacts. All this work was carried out by a committee that has rebuilt its membership over the course of the year. We began with seven members, and today all nine regular seats and both alternate seats are filled, with more than a dozen additional residents holding applications on file, several of whom bring backgrounds in marine science, environmental permitting, and boating. The committee also went through a leadership transition this spring, and I want to thank Nancy Schmidt for her years of service as a chair and for the groundwork she laid on issues we've been able to resolve. We have worked to keep the public involved by moving citizen comment to the start of every meeting so that residents are heard first. We have had even one meeting this summer where 15 participants came to speak on the watercraft launching. Our meetings have also brought Pinellas County engineering and staff to discuss the bridge repairs, traffic, park capacity, shoreline projects, while our members serve as liaisons to the marina, stormwater, public safety, and environmental quality committees so that issues on the causeway stay connected to the rest of the city's work and residents' interests. Several issues will need continued attention in the coming years. The causeway bridge repair, bridges under repair, the FDAL alternate 19 project will affect access to the causeway for a number of years. Shoaling in the channels is grounding boats and causing confusion, and we expect water-based recreational activities to increase. In 2027, the committee will make it a priority to work more closely with the county on its resilience plan, including next steps and any action items we can take together. Each of these issues will benefit from a committee that knows the causeway well and can help bring the city, county, and state together around it. The causeway is one of Dunedin's most valuable public spaces and the gateway to busiest park in Florida. Our volunteers are committed to protecting it for residents and visitors alike. On behalf of the Dunedin Causeway and Coastal Waterways Committee, I respectfully ask that you continue the committee for another three years. Thank you, and I would be happy to answer any questions. So questions for Tony or Hank. I'll start with Commissioner DeGuard. There's a recent purchase of the Cala DC Island expansion. Do you expect that to affect the causeway in any way? I haven't. I've heard of it. I haven't looked into it. I don't know about affecting the causeway, but I would say from a waterway standpoint, it's going to benefit by making sure that natural areas are preserved and protected. How would you describe the relationship with the state park and its leadership? We know the local state park staff, and we're actually looking forward to having one of their members at one of our future meetings to talk about ongoing activities there, education and outreach, as well as some of the changes that they've had post-hurricanes. So we know the staff. I don't know about state leadership, though. Can you tell me if events on the island cause you or the causeway committee any concerns, or do they contribute to the environment? We've already addressed that with the launching, I believe. So moving forward, I know the bridge is causing a lot of consternation, right? It needs to be replaced. I think that's going to be a major item when that actually moves towards design with the county. The resilience plan has shown that the county is vulnerable, sorry, the causeway is vulnerable to storm surge, as I mentioned, and future tidal impacts. And that plan actually proposes different types of engineering methods to secure the roadway and to make sure that it's stable and stays in place. As we look forward into the future, we need to see how impacts will also affect the recreational areas. So that's why we're making it a priority this coming year to work with the county on that plan, as it was just completed from a grant that they accomplished. Thank you. That's helpful. Have there been any plans to do any flora fauna inventories since the motorcraft launch is now suspended? I'm not aware of any, but I can't say if the city has any plans for the county at this time. But I think that that's a very valid question. I know that there's a number of environmental organizations that supported the ordinance that was recently passed. And there's been a noticeable increase in flora and fauna. As far as a specific study, I'm not aware. Okay. Thank you, Mary. That's all I have. Okay. Questions for Tony or for Hank? I will go to Commissioner Bennett. So I did attend a few of your meetings when I was campaigning, and they are very interesting. I noticed that we had a 2025 annual report. Is the 2026 report available yet, or you're waiting for 26 to finish to complete that? I can go ahead. Yeah. That's usually completed at the beginning of the following year to just kind of recap all the activity. Okay. And I'm sure it will include some of the items I just stated. You did a summary of a lot of them, but I read the annual report, and I'm like, wait a second. This doesn't sound like the meetings I went to, but it was 2025, not 2026. Okay. Thank you. That's it. Thank you. Okay. Questions? Vice Mayor. You know, no, I have comments, so thank you. Questions? Same with me, Mayor. No questions for him, so I'll have comments for Hank. Yep. Sounds good. Okay. So I'm going to open it for public input. Anyone in the audience wish to come forward and speak on this issue? Kevin, I see you're a new regular member now. Look at that. So there you go. Yeah. You're everywhere. Okay. Anyone in the public wish to come forward? Okay. Seeing no one, I will close public input. And I would ask for a motion. So moved. Second. Okay. I have a motion and a second. And we'll go to commission comments, starting with Vice Mayor, maker of the motion. You know, Hank, I've been to a few meetings of the Causeway Committee. And I have to say that I, in this case, the decision to retain and make this an independent committee is exactly the right one because you guys are just a wonderful voice for that area over there. And I really do support what you do. You were so instrumental in maybe turning the tide a little bit, pardon the pun, with regards to the motorcraft. And anyway, I just, you guys do just an amazing job. So thank you. I'm in favor, obviously. Commissioner Sandberg, and final comments? Yeah, very similar. You know, I had a chance to get to know you, Hank, and some of your members sitting back here, you're exactly what we need for Dunedin, your type of committee. You get out there, you come up with the answers, and I have absolutely no question about supporting the continuation of this. And thank you for everything that you do. I see your notes and how much you do. So thank you, Hank. Thank you. Okay. Final comments? Commissioner DeGuard. Thank you, Mayor. First of all, I'm in support of this motion. But I want to express my gratitude to the committee for what they did in advising the commission, relative to the powered motorcraft issue. That was not easy. It wasn't easy for you. It wasn't easy for us. There were a lot of different voices on that particular action. But I think that between the two of us, we came across well. Thank you for that. That's all I have, Mayor. Thank you. Okay. Final comments? Commissioner Bennett. Well, it is easiest to go last because most everything has been said. Thank you for what you do. Some of those decisions were very difficult. And I'm looking forward, annually, Southwest Florida Water Management District does aerial counts and coverage of seagrasses, usually January, February-ish. And it'll be very much interesting to see how the entire ecosystem is recovering and track it over more than the couple of years the causeway was closed. So, anyway, thank you for what you do. And I am in support of this motion. Thank you. Hank, again, thanks. I mean, I think that it's funny because when you guys all came and you didn't want to be merged into any other committee, and we heard you loud and clear. And I think we heard you loud and clear mainly because you are such an active committee. And really, the causeway is kind of its own thing out there. And it's got a lot of unique situations, unique issues. And you're just a very active committee doing a lot of good stuff. And so, thank you for doing that. I keep doing it. I absolutely am in favor of this. And you've got a solid committee. And we appreciate the advice and the help. So, thank you. Thank you, Mayor. Okay. Okay. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passed unanimously. Here we go. Thank you. Okay. We are going to go now to, let me just get back to my place here. Resolution 26-26, a resolution of the City Commission of the City of Denene, Florida, electing to use the uniform method of collecting non-ad valorem special assessments for more than one year levied in the City of Denene, Florida, to fund costs incurred by the City in providing annual fire protection services, stating a need for such levy, providing for the mailing of this resolution, and providing for an effective date. Jen, can you please read Resolution 26-26 by title only? Yes. Resolution 26-26, a resolution of the City Commission of the City of Denene, Florida, electing to use the uniform method of collecting non-ad valorem special assessments for more than one year levied in the City of Denene, Florida, to fund costs incurred by the City in providing annual fire protection services, stating a need for such levy, providing for the mailing of the resolution, and providing for an effective date. That was Resolution 26-26, read by title only. Okay. I need a motion. So moved. Second. Okay. Commissioner Sandbergen and Commissioner DeGuard is a seconder. And we will go to staff presentation by Nicole. Excuse me. Good evening, Mayor and City Commission. Nicole Delfino, the Strategy and Sustainability Manager here today. And if you can just bear with me for a few moments, I'd like to provide a little bit of history as to how we have arrived here today with Resolution 26-26 before you. On May 19th, earlier this year, Chris Rowe, attorney for Bryant, Miller & Olive, who is joining us in the Zoom land today, this evening, presented at a public meeting to the City Commission on the general process and purpose of a fire assessment. A fire assessment is used as an alternative or supplemental funding mechanism for fire protection services. Fire assessments create a dedicated funding source specifically for fire protection, operations, and infrastructure, which are separate from general property tax revenues. At that May City Commission meeting, the Commission provided direction to staff to draft a request for proposal, or RFP, for a fire assessment consultant to perform the study, data analysis, methodology, report, and recommendations of creating a fire assessment. Staff drafted that RFP, 26-2611, and brought it before the City Commission on July 9th of 2026. At that meeting, Commission approved the request to advertise the RFP, which was done following that meeting the next day on Demand Star on July 10th. The posting for that advertising was closed on August 7th. An evaluation committee consisting of five members reviewed the proposals during publicly advertised meetings held on August 20th and August 27th. Staff then returned to the City Commission on September 17th with a recommendation of award of bid of that RFP 26-2611 to Cypress Revenue Solutions. The City Commission approved the recommendation and awarded the bid. And here with me today is Peter Napoli of Cypress Revenue Solutions, which I know he'll answer some questions as we move through this item. Starting back at that approval in September, we have been working with both Peter and Chris Rowe on this project and have provided to Peter several data sets and requests for information so that he may begin his analysis and recommendations. However, today we are here simply to check a legal box relating to the resolution requirement. In order to follow and adhere to the legal and required documentation as part of the assessment implementation, the City Commission must adopt a resolution expressing the intent to consider a fire assessment fee on or before January 1st of 2027 in order for that to be implemented in the November 2027 truth and millage notice or trim notice that's mailed from the tax assessor's office. The resolution must state the city's intent to use the uniform method, state the need for the levy, and include a legal description of the boundaries of real property subject to the levy, all of which are provided in Resolution 26-26 before you today. I do want to clarify, adopting the resolution does not impose an assessment or commit the city to impose one. It simply preserves the city's ability to collect a fire assessment on the tax bill beginning in November 2027. If the city moves forward, the commission will review this project at several future public meetings, public notices will be mailed to residents, and the city commission will ultimately adopt or would ultimately adopt the assessment role at a public hearing via an ordinance. As a requirement of the resolution before you, special advertising has been completed through the Tampa Bay Times on four consecutive Sundays. The notice of intent was included in the publication dates of the Times on Sunday, October 25th, November 1st, November 8th, and November 15th. Tampa Bay Times has provided an affidavit of publication following the last notification. Due to the last publication occurring just this last Sunday on November 15th, the affidavit has been attached to this agenda item as a supplement. With that, staff does recommend approval of Resolution 26-26 to use the uniform method of collecting non-ad valorem special assessments. Okay. I will go to questions for staff. I will start with Vice Mayor. Thank you, Mayor. It was a very comprehensive presentation. I do, the money that we awarded for Cyprus, that was in 2026 money, right, funding? Yes. Okay. And just to confirm, basically we are, an approval here would allow this to go forward specifically on the 2027 trim notice. And would essentially maintain our eligibility to continue to do our due diligence on this while Cyprus does their work and provides us the data. Yes, sir. Okay. All right. I have no further questions. Okay. Questions, Commissioner Sandberg. So I just want to make sure that I'm clear. Tonight we're here to talk about the resolution, not start diving into costs and how this may be funded. That's correct. I'm getting from, okay. The study is ongoing for that. Okay, good. I just want to make sure. As we're, you know, working our way through this, are we following some kind of like a state guideline or a county guideline for, how is this all being put together? I will defer to growth, Chris and Peter being the experts on fire assessment. Can we get Chris up here? Chris, oh, on your screen? Yeah, we don't see him on our screens. We don't see it on the screens. I'm here. He's behind you. I cannot see the chamber. I can hear you. You're in the room. We're just not. We have to turn. It's like the Wizard of Oz up there. Yeah. Okay, here he comes. You kind of asked what I said. Are we following a state guideline or a county guideline? Yes, sir. There are state statutes which govern the imposition of special assessments. Assessment authority largely derives from your home rule authority, your municipal home rule authority. So you have broad discretion to determine the details and various aspects of the assessment program. If you're going to collect an assessment on the property tax bill, which is what this resolution is all about, then there is a statute that prescribes the process for doing so. And as Nicole gave an overview of, it basically involves published notice once a week for the four weeks leading up to the meeting. And then you conduct a public hearing and receive public input before you adopt this resolution. If the commission is inclined to adopt it, then upon its execution, you send a copy of the signed resolution to the tax collector and property appraiser. When you collect an assessment on the tax bill, you will need the assistance of those two officers in order to facilitate the process. So the statute that governs this is really intended to give them the notice in advance that you will be considering this next year. And if you move forward with a fire assessment, you'll need their help in collecting it on the tax bill. So when we send that signed resolution, will that cost the city of Dunedin any money going forward with the county? Well, what happens is if you eventually decide to impose a fire assessment, then both the property appraiser and the tax collector are entitled to reimbursement for the administrative expenses. They will incur in assisting with this process. And it differs from county to county. Some property appraisers, for instance, might charge you $1 per parcel for the parcels that are subject to the assessment. The tax collector typically charges a percentage of collections. So it might charge, again, it varies from county to county, but he or she may charge 1% or usually not more than 2% of the amount collected. And they merely net that off the top once collection begins and remit the proceeds to the city. Okay. And have we taken that into consideration, what this will cost us? We will. We will. As we go through the methodology. Okay. Just two other real simple ones. I don't know if this is for you, Chris. I've assumed unpaid, uncollected taxes that will be handled by Pinellas County? Yes, that's right. Really, the advantage of collecting your assessment on the tax bill is that if someone doesn't pay it, then the enforcement and collection responsibility are assumed by the county tax collector. Okay. You, as the city, don't have to get into the business of chasing after someone to ensure they pay it. The tax collector handles it in exactly the same way they handle delinquency or nonpayment of ad valorem taxes. So there is an option that we, as a city, could bill like we do our utility billing. And, obviously, we wouldn't want to do something like that as an option? Is that what he just said? You absolutely could direct bill this assessment. In other words, instead of using the tax bill, you could determine, hey, we just want to send everybody who's been assessed a bill directly to the effect of your property has been assessed to carry a portion of the cost of fire services next year. Your assessment amount is X dollars. Please remit payment within 30 days. Yep. That's all, Chris. That's all I had, Mayor. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner. Okay, Commissioner Gard, questions for staff. I have just one question. The reading of this, I need a little clarification. It's a methodology of collecting non-ad valorem special assessments. And the assessments gives me a little pause. Does this open the door for more than just a fire assessment? You, as a municipality, have extensive home rule authority to impose assessments for a wide range of services and also capital improvement projects like road repair, sidewalk installation, that sort of thing. You have to follow the legal requirements in order to impose any assessment. And those primarily consist of notice to affected property owners indicating what you intend to assess them for and the estimated amount of the assessment you'll charge to each parcel and the time, date, place of a public hearing to consider it. And then you, of course, have that public hearing. You receive the input. And once you receive that input, you vote as to whether or not to impose the assessment. Some of the classic uses of assessments include stormwater, as I mentioned, the capital improvements like sidewalks and street repair. Very often throughout the state of Florida, assessments are used to fund fire protection. In most cases, they can fund a very substantial portion of your overall fire budget, often right up to 100%. It really depends on the nature of your fire department and the services it's providing. That was the most eloquent yes I've ever heard. By the way, sir, this resolution you're considering this evening only preserves your ability to collect an assessment on the tax bill next year for fire. So it is restricted to fire for next year. Yes. You could adopt a different type of assessment next year, for instance, stormwater, if you don't already have one. But you would not be able to collect that on the November 2027 tax bill. You'd have to collect that by direct billing and then move to the tax bill in the second year. That is due to the timing of the trim notice. Is that correct? Yes, sir. And the statutory requirement that this particular resolution you're considering tonight be adopted prior to the end of the calendar year, immediately preceding the commencement of collection. There is a limited exception to that. If the county tax collector and property appraiser consent, you could adopt a resolution any time prior to March 1st. Typically better to do it in December, however, so you don't have to seek their approval. Thank you. That's all I have, Mayor. Okay. Questions? Commissioner Bennett. So if we pass this resolution tonight, is the City of Dunedin required or obligated to impose a fire assessment? No. No, Mayor. Absolutely not. This is merely a statutory prerequisite to preserve your ability to collect an assessment on the tax bill starting next November, one year from now, if you take a series of steps between now and then to approve the assessment roll and formally adopt and levy the special assessment. That process will unfold over the time period, which typically culminates by September 15th. It will begin in earnest with Cypress' development of an apportionment methodology. He will come back before the commission to present the results of his study and make a recommendation as far as the assessment methodology and the rate structures that will result from the methodology. If the commission is inclined to move forward at that time, you commence the process for the levy and imposition of the assessment, and I'll help with that, of course. It typically involves adoption of an ordinance, which describes the local process and procedure you'll follow to not only levy the assessment in the first year, but to administer and maintain it over time. It typically calls for two resolutions adopted about four to six weeks apart. The first resolution describes what you're assessing for and some of the key details about the assessment. Schedules the public hearing. You then give mailed and published notice. The mailed notice is an important factor in all this. You have to provide a mailed notice to each and every property owner you propose to assess, indicating not only the time, date, place of the hearing where they can be heard, but also how the methodology works and what the assessment proposed for their property is. So they can make an educated decision on whether or not to accept the charge or if they should turn out at the public hearing and make their objections known. You then commence the public hearing at the designated date. You hear all the public input. And if you're so inclined following public input, you adopt a implementing resolution, which approves the rate for the upcoming fiscal year and direct certification of the assessment role, which is the database listing all the properties subject to the charge, to the tax collector's office for collection. So as you can tell, there are many, many steps that have to be followed between now and then to actually do an assessment. This is merely a statutory prerequisite to allow you to collect on the tax bill next year if those steps are in fact undertaken. So we would have time to coordinate this with all of our budgeting efforts across the board, look at what all of our expenses are, what are all of our revenues, and if we need this at all? Yes. Okay. This is a little bit technical, and I apologize, but should the legal description and map attach to this resolution, should that match the corporate boundaries of the city, or should it match the Dunedin Fire Taxation District? It must, by law, match the corporate boundaries of the city, and the reason that is is because your municipal powers end at city limits unless there is a statute which expressly authorizes you to exercise your powers outside city limits. There aren't very many of those. There's one I know of dealing with special assessments, and that is for limited circumstances involving where you are obligated to extend water, wastewater utilities outside your limits to people being served in the unincorporated area. In that instance, and that instance alone, do you have the authority to impose assessments outside your city limits? For that reason, for something like a fire assessment, the legal description is confined to the boundaries of the city. So, how will non-residents that are taxed and served by Dunedin Fire pay a fire assessment, or will they pay a fire assessment? They will not pay a fire assessment. You would basically, I don't know how it's currently funded. Is it through an interlocal arrangement with the county? Does the county contribute funds to the city to cover the cost of service outside the city limits? It is through an agreement, and actually, I think that I saw their advertisement in the paper for doing something similar so that they were able to pay us for the fire service we provide. I believe that's correct, and I'm getting a yes from the chief. You did, yes. The county's planning on a fire assessment for unincorporated Pinellas County. Yes. That's the end of my questions. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner. I think everything's been, I was going to actually ask if I had seen that for unincorporated area. That was going to be my only question, so I'm going to open it up for public input. Is there anyone in the audience who wishes to come forward and speak on this issue? Come forward, name and address for the record, and three minutes. Hi. Good evening. Renee Chia. I live at 1229 Royal Oak Drive here in Dunedin. Good evening to all of you. Welcome, Ms. Bennett, to the bench. I just wanted to come here tonight. I realize that this is a resolution to do a fee. It's not implementing the fee right now, but I wanted to get in on the conversation early on and say it's time to start talking about priorities, and I think we're going to get to know each other even better through this conversation and through the coming conversations in the spring regarding priorities. I appreciate some of your questions tonight, Mr. Dugard and Mr. Sanderbergen, on I think you're focusing in on the fact that starting to go after fees when we haven't even assessed what the costs are and whether or not we need it, when we haven't seen what the legislature is going to say about how to implement Amendment 3, and what the county is going to do or not do regarding this. I just want to go on the record that nobody wants to see fire cut, right? Nobody wants to see us not have fire surfaces or anything like that, but it's a matter of priorities. There's already been a lot of time, energy, and money, it sounds like, from your lovely presentation, thank you, spent on trying to figure out how to tax and fee the people rather than look at what you can do elsewhere to not have to do that, and that would be my preferences if you start looking at those types of things. I would like to see, right off the bat, you sent out a list of the things that you would cut or that possibly could be cut, and it was all punitive, in my opinion, because it was all the things that nobody wants to see cut if this passes. And then you were prepared, obviously, to move forward with that at a pretty quick rate before, I feel like it's premature, before finding out some of these other things. And I think that at this point, you should table this and maybe look at it down the line. We know in 2027, it's only going up to 150 of the, what's it called, the homestead, right? So, the fact that you feel like you might have to assess a fee so quickly, I think, is also very premature without looking at other things. I would like to see a list of what you are wanting to fund rather than what you're wanting to cut. And I'm not sure who the right contact would be for me to PRA that, but I will send a request in to all of you, because I would like to start seeing a list of what are you choosing, what are you prioritizing to fund over FIRE. So, that's all I have to say for this evening. I hope you listen to this and take it to heart and maybe table this or put this resolution off to a later date. But thank you. And just for your information, we did, we cut about a half million dollars out of our, after our, a couple months ago during our current budget process. And we have a meeting on December 2nd where there's a proposed another 3.4 million cuts. And again, we're welcoming the community. We'll, we have community input on all that. We actually had those proposed cuts, the contingency budget, in a public meeting probably three months ago. So, we're trying to be proactive on both the reduction and also, you know, looking at other things. I just wanted to inform you. I want to go back and forth. I appreciate that and I will, you know, come back for the December 2nd as well. We want everybody that can. We're going to be making these decisions as a community. But thank you for your input. Really appreciate it. Thank you. Okay. Anyone else in the audience wish to come forward and speak on this issue? Name and address for the record and three minutes. Rita Foley, 700 Mies Plaza, Dunedin. Good evening, Mayor and Commissioners. I'm speaking tonight in support of the resolution electing to use the uniform method of collecting non-ad valorem assessments. A basic tenet of physics is for every action. There's an equal and opposite reaction. Well, Amendment 3 passing was an action and property tax revenues are being drastically cut across the state and the city must adapt to find reasonable solutions to that. Contrary to what some frustrated posts on social media are claiming, moving forward with this resolution is not a punitive measure or retaliation by the city. In fact, this exact fiscal reality was transparently laid out and predicted months ago during the educational sessions hosted by the city, the fire chief, and our sheriff. When primary revenue streams are restricted at the state level, cities have to utilize lawful alternative funding tools to maintain the high level of public safety with which we have come to expect and rely. Taking this procedural step tonight simply keeps the necessary options open. I think I heard the attorney say that this resolution needs to be passed before the end of the calendar year, so we really only have six weeks. I don't think it can be tabled. I urge you to pass the resolution. Thank you. Thank you very much. Anyone else in the audience wish to come forward and speak on this issue? Okay. Seeing no one, I will bring it back to the commission and we'll go to commission comments. I'm going to start with the maker of the motion, which was Commissioner Sandbergen. Thank you, Mayor. You know, to sort of continue on what you said, Renee, right? You've spoken many times. Tonight I have 12 separate questions and I probably have a half a dozen more at home. So before this goes, obviously tonight what we talked about is the resolution. I have a lot of questions. Oh, man. I mean, when these meetings come up, it's going to be a long night. I understand, you know, there's a lot to get through, but as far as the resolution, I support it going forward just to continue to move this and then we'll bring everything out on the table and bring everything into the light when we start figuring out how to fund all this. So I'm good with it. Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Commissioner. Seconder of the motion was Commissioner DeGuard. Final comments. Thank you, Mayor. As a commission, it is our obligation to ensure one thing above all others, and that's the safety of our citizenry. That is to keep them as safe as we possibly can. In fact, that's one of the basic tenets of the formation of government. As we look at what Referendum Proposition 3 did to us on a financial basis, we see that being exceedingly difficult and even keeping the lights on. Without this kind of latitude, we may not be able to keep people as safe as we wish. We haven't decided how much yet because we need more information. We're just trying to make sure we have the capacity to do this, and it is a linear issue within state government. It takes a long time to move a paperclip in government. So, in order to even have this latitude, this action needs to be taken now. I'm in full support. Okay. Final comments. Face, Mayor. Thank you, Mayor. Let's not forget how we got here. First of all, the Amendment 3 was passed. The voters did speak, and you have to pay attention to that. But, Renee, to your point, Tallahassee hasn't discussed anything about implementation to this point. And please know that I'm not 100% sold on this, but here's the deal. We have a responsibility for fiscal responsibility up here, and we hired a consultant because this is a very specialized field, and we need the experts involved here so that we do it right. And as part of that fiscal responsibility, we need to have all of the data and study all of the data so that we can do our due diligence to determine, make the right determination. So, subsequently, I am in favor of this resolution, but there's a series of events here that we're going to go through to get the answers that we need because, you know, us sitting up here, we don't have all the answers. And it most certainly, as we start talking about these other costs, you know, by parcel, fiscal, that sort of thing, you know, I've already, I already have concerns. But, again, fiscal responsibility, due diligence, we need the data, and we need to keep this moving down the track until we are able to make that decision. So, I am in favor of the resolution. Okay. Final comments, Commissioner Bennett. So, Amendment 3 was a clear message from the majority of voters in Dunedin that they want tax relief, and we hear it. We hear you clear. The commission has heard you. I've heard you. The administration has heard you. I don't take any credit in this because I was not sitting in this position. However, Dunedin was aware of the public's desire to lower their costs from their local government, and as such, the fiscal year 27 budget that was adopted in September was 11% lower than the fiscal year 26 budget. So, we are moving in the right direction to control cost. Again, like was said, there's going to be another special meeting on December 2nd to institute further cuts to the tune of another $3.4 million off of a budget that was already less than the previous year. We hear what the voters said. We're not ignoring that. But this fire assessment study hasn't been done yet, hasn't been completed, or provided to the commission. But I can assure you that it is mine and most likely my colleagues' intentions to try to get every efficiency, you know, get this pared down to the things that the voters really and the residents of Dunedin really want to have as services, core services. And then, when we have all of our costs in line, we'll try to figure out what we can afford and how we can fund those things. And this is just one more tool for us to be able to do that. And for us to keep this tool at our disposal, we have to pass this resolution. So, I'm in favor of passing this resolution. However, you know, I don't know how it's going to end. I don't know if we'll have a fire assessment at all or what the fire assessment cost would be if we had to impose one. That will be worked out through this process. Thank you. Yeah, I also want to say I completely respect the will of the voters. I think that there's an affordability crisis around this country. We all know that. And people wanted relief. And this was a relief valve. That being said, when the state of Florida legislature put Amendment 3 on the ballot, they were fully aware property taxes are the main funder of critical services. in local communities. Although there was random discussions of ways to backfill some of these revenues, no impact research or plan was put in place. Therefore, as elected stewards of this community, we, this board, must ensure proper funding of critical services. We need to be proactive about reducing expenditures, reducing the footprint of government. We hear that. And we take it seriously. We actually started to do that because, you know, we had our own challenges as well, trying to, and we heard people to reduce these expenses. Again, I'll repeat, we did that by reducing the budget this past year. We have another $3.4 million of possible cuts that we're looking at on December 2nd from 1.30 to 4 o'clock because we're trying to be proactive and get these cuts on the board. Some of them are painful cuts. But everything's open for discussion. We're open for ideas. We're open to hear you. But there's, there's no punitivity here. We love this city. We love, everybody up here loves this city. We don't want to hurt this city. You know, people say, oh, I'm worried about our special events. I love our special events. We don't want to hurt our, we don't want to hurt it. We are going to be very diligent about trying to do the right kind of surgical cuts that will preserve who we are as Dunedin. But cuts do need to be made. Some will be low-hanging fruit and will be less noticeable and some will be more difficult for all of us. But at the same time, we have a responsibility to fully explore additional revenue sources, whatever they are. And, and the possibility of putting in place a fire assessment is, is, is one, a very important one. So, and, and again, I just reiterate that adoption of this resolution does not commit or require the city to impose any assessments at all. But if you're sitting up here, guys, as stewards of this city and loving this community and loving the people of this community, we've got to make sure we've got all our options on the table. And that's all this is right now, is an option, as we work through cuts and potential revenue sources to make sure we secure the, the critical resources and critical services of the community. And, and we don't even know what kind of increase we may be getting from the sheriff yet, because he's got his own battle of what he's got to cut. So, I am fully in favor of this. Okay, so we will go to, roll call vote. Commissioner Bennett. Aye. Vice Mayor Walker. Aye. Commissioner Dugard. Aye. Commissioner Sandbergen. Aye. And Mayor Freyney. Aye. And that motion passes unanimously. And, and thank you to everybody. Let's keep talking as a community and, and please let us know what you're thinking. Okay, we're going to go to, do we want to take a short break? Yeah, let's go for a short break. Okay, we're going to reopen the meeting. And we've got a start item, Resolution 26-27, amending the marina boat ramp fees. And this is just a motion to put it on our agenda. Can I get a motion? So moved. Second. Okay. I have a motion and a second. And so, all in favor of putting this on the agenda. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Opposed? Motion passes unanimously. Now that it's on the agenda, the staff has requested that Resolution 26-27 be continued to the December 17, 2026 regular scheduled 6 p.m. City Commission meeting being held at Dundee City Hall in Commission Chambers. I'm assuming this is because we needed to have it on because it got continued to this and then we didn't have it on. and in order to have it continue to another meeting, we had to have it on? We mentioned continuing it, and then when you approved the agenda, it was not on, so we had to do a start. All right, okay, got it. Okay, so motion to continue it to December 17th. Do I have a motion? So moved. Second. Okay, all in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passed unanimously. Okay, we will go to 3D, Resolution 26-30, combining the Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee, the Hammock Advisory Committee, and the Edgewater Drive Advisory Committee. Jen, can you please read Resolution 26-30 by title only? Certainly. Resolution 26-30, a resolution of the City of Dunedin, Florida, to combine the Hammock Advisory Committee, the Edgewater Drive Advisory Committee, and the Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee into one advisory committee with a new title of Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee, and repealing Resolution 03-11, which established the Hammock Advisory Committee, Resolution 01-03, which established the Edgewater Drive Advisory Committee, and repealing 92-06, which established an 11-43, which renamed and amended the Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee, providing for duties, membership, and term of office, providing for organizational structure, providing for reporting responsibility, providing for record-keeping, providing for appointment removal, providing for review by the City Commission to continue the committee's existence, and providing for an effective date. That was Resolution 26-30, read by title only. You've got to love it when it's such a long title, right? Okay. Can I have a motion? So moved. Second. Great. Motion and a second. Staff presentation. Tony. Good evening again, Commission, Mayor, Vice Mayor, members of the public. Tony Mulkey, Parks and Recreation Director. This is a long effort to try and make our committees more efficient and more aligned with the mission that we want them to kind of provide the feedback and advice to the commission. The direction on this started in February with a commission workshop as well as a March planning session, and the direction was originally to combine the Parks and Recreation and Hammock Advisory Committees. During the March strategic planning session, there was additional direction to investigate overlapping and unclear duties of these committees that we were reviewing, and the Edgewater Drive Advisory Committee was originally planned to combine with the Public Safety Committee. That changed after a June committee workshop where a determination was made that the Edgewater Drive Advisory Committee would fit better with the mission of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee that was being proposed. So this new committee, the approach for putting this together in the resolution in front of you, was built in an effort to have a holistic view of topics that Parks and Recreation is involved with. Main areas of focus are the planning, development, improvement, and use of facilities in open spaces, conservation, preservation, and responsible stewardship of public lands, natural areas, and environmental resources. Also incorporate community interests in the need for recreation, parks, and improving the quality of life for Dunedan residents. And recommendations on policy, planning, improvements, and priorities, especially when it comes to budget decisions. As well as promote community awareness about the Parks and Recreation offerings that are available in the community. Some of the areas we really wanted to make sure, based on the feedback of the committee members, as well as the commission during the workshops, is that we are tackling programming. We are tackling parks. We are tackling the environment. We are tackling aesthetics. And we are tackling efficiencies. Moving forward with forming the new committee would be populated with the remaining members of the three previous committees. It would consist of nine members and two alternates. And there's an option of non-voting ex-officio members. So if we needed representation from groups like Friends of the Hammock, our athletic leagues, or our senior population, that we would have the ability to have them have a voice. I think that's important. And that was some of the feedback that was brought to us. And I'm happy to answer any questions on the resolution. Okay. Questions starting with Commissioner Degard. Were we able to compress all of the members of the various committees into one committee? What's our process there? So the original process on the consolidation for the new committee would have been that all active members would be named onto the committee and serve out their existing terms. And as attrition happened through members falling off with their terms ending, we would get down to the nine plus two. So what would that mean, the size of the most immediate committee as it seats? How many members would then be on that? Currently, I believe it's nine. So it's nine now? Correct. So we don't really have compression. Correct. Oh. No more questions, Mayor. Okay. Questions. Commissioner Bennett. I believe Commissioner Degard just asked my question about how many people on each committee. Thank you. Vice Mayor, questions? You know, that makes it pretty easy when it compresses down to exactly the number you want. But I'm just curious, what kind of feedback you got through this process from the various committees? So the Edgewater Drive, they expressed the desire that they were more aligned with parks. And I believe Michelle was a part of that process more so than I, though I did have conversations on the side about that. Some of it was to ensure that the missions of each one of these committees was incorporated into the language. And the language is somewhat broad to have that holistic approach because while we had a hammock advisory committee, we also have newer places like Gladys Douglas. And we have other areas that we want to have the same considerations for preservation of our natural environment. So we kind of opened up the language to make sure we covered the programming, to cover the environmental, to cover parks, and want all those voices and perspectives included. Okay. So it sounds like it was fairly positive. I mean, you really didn't get any pushback or? There are concerns that voices would be lost, but it is a member committee, so the members will drive the priorities on that. Okay. All right. No further questions. Okay. Commissioner Sandbergen, questions? I think I just wanted to clarify. There's nine members on this committee? Nine members and two alternates. Okay. Because when I went and read about it today, okay. No, that's all I had. Thank you, Tony. You're welcome. So it looked like, and I know that Michelle had, I had asked for some stuff and she sent me, but I didn't have a chance to look at it. So I think in the staff memo, it says that of the nine members that will then be on the committee, four of them will be from Reckon Parks, one from Hammock, and four from Edgewater Drive. That sounds correct. Is that correct? Yes. So my only concern is, what was the exact, what was the duties of the Edgewater Park one? Like, what were they supposed to have been doing? Because it seemed like very, I mean, it was very honed in to obviously their scenic, maybe scenic corridor, their... So it involved in topics of both the transportation corridor there, but also the aesthetics and maintenance of the space, which is a combination of city property and FDOT right-of-way. And that has its own agreement with the city, but discussing the maintenance of that area, that's also Hubbard Park. So it's a linear park, it's a linear park, it's the gateway into the city, and it kind of aligned with a lot of the things that our staff actually performs out there with maintenance. So any concern at all about the fact that, and I don't even actually know who's on that, I know a couple of them, but the fact that you're taking Reckon Parks, which is a very broad spectrum of all the facilities, to a group that's going to be just as big coming off Edgewater Drive, that's a very kind of neighborhood centric. Do you have any concerns about that? Absolutely. And I hope we manage our groups. Once the new committee kind of gets seated, we're going to have to go through kind of a framework of how all topics are considered. And we want to help facilitate that to make sure that it's not just directed for one neighborhood. I think the directed for one neighborhood isn't necessarily a bad thing, because we can kind of open up the perspective to say, okay, you have this concern here, we're having the same concern over here, how do we address that? And that's that holistic look to be like, this is a citywide issue and not just a linear mile. Yeah, I was, you know, kind of hoping that there was a lot more on the Reck Parks that would have, but, you know, again, not knowing who the people are, they'll kind of come into a broader perspective view, so. And I agree, there could be some advantages. Okay, I don't have any other questions. I'm going to open it for public input. Anyone in the audience wish to come forward and speak on this issue? Okay, seeing no one, I will close public input, and I will go to commission comments, starting with maker of the motion, Vice Mayor. Thank you, Mayor. Yeah, so I think, you know, obviously this is a process we've started some time ago, and it still makes sense, and it's the right thing to do, just in the terms of efficiency. I actually, the feedback I got was just, you know, in particular, that the committees still have the ability via process to bring up their own issues. And so I think that's how this works, and, yeah, I, you know, we started this over a year ago, or actually it's longer than that. So I'm, I'm in favor of it. Okay, so seconder in motion was Commissioner Bennett. Final comments? I think we've been going through citywide trying to get some streamlining and some combining of these to, where there's overlapping commonalities. And I, I think that, you know, you've convinced me that this makes sense to combine these, and yet people will still have a voice for maybe something that they have a passion for. So I'm in favor of it. Okay. Commissioner Dugard, final comments? Thank you, Mayor. Commissioner, I am in support of this motion for all the reasons mentioned so far. However, I've come to learn through my experiences that a park is not just a park, that we have various kinds of parks and types of parks with different goals and missions. My only concern is that we make sure that we put every one of our decisions in context with the goals of that particular site and facility's purposes. That may be a little bit of a challenge for just a nine-member committee, but it's one I'm sure the staff can help guide. I am in support. Commissioner Sandberg. You know, reading, reading the, the roster of those three, you know, I, you know, I know the majority of them, and each one of them have the same focus, and that's for betterment of the city. I, you know, we worked on this for a long time. It's a long time coming to combine them, and, you know, this is a group that cares about the city of Dunedin, and we'll surely look forward to making it even better. So thank you, Tony. Yeah, I fully support this. I mean, obviously our efforts were to, you know, streamline the committees, make them more productive. At the same time, we were getting that from the members, and we were getting that from our staff. And, you know, we don't need to have more committees than we need for no reason at all. So I think this is good. I know it was difficult because it's still kind of pushing together different, different priority levels. But it sounds like these are going to be a good fit. Of course, we always have friends of the hammock. It'd be nice to have a friend of Gladys Douglas Preserve, but maybe that'll still happen from a volunteer group. But I think this is a good move all the way around. So I fully support it. Roll call vote. Commissioner Dugard. Aye. Commissioner Sandbergen. Aye. Commissioner Bennett. Aye. Vice Mayor Walker. Aye. Mayor Franey. Aye. And that motion passes unanimously. You know, Mayor, I think that this is the completion of the board and committee, or the committee consolidation. This is the last to be combined. Oh, is this it? Is this the last one? Yeah. We'll go get it. Oh, there's one more. There's one. Isn't there ADA? ADA Social Services? We did it. No. Oh, there's one? Okay, good. All right. Well, let's get that out, Mayor. Okay. It's been nine years coming, but anyway. I know, I know, I know. Well, it's tough because you're really, yeah. So, okay. Sounds good. Okay, we're going to go to Resolution 26-19, Fiscal Year 2026, Final Budget Amendment. Jen, please read Resolution 26-19 by title only. Resolution 26-19, a resolution of the City Commission of the City of Dunedin, Florida, amending the City's operating and capital budget for fiscal year beginning October 1, 2025, and ending September 30, 2026, and providing for an effective date. That was Resolution 26-19, read by title only. Okay, I need a motion. So moved. Second. Okay, staff presentation, Les and Gene. Good evening, Mayor, Vice Mayor, Commissioners. Les Tyler, the Finance Director. I'm here with Gene, our Budget Manager. This resolution is our last budget amendment for fiscal year 26. Florida Statute 166-241 provides for a city to amend its budget anytime during the fiscal year or within 60 days following the end of the fiscal year. The proposed amendments are on pages 2 through 4 in your staffing report today. The total impact on fund balances as shown on page 2 in the staffing has a total impact of all the funds impacted to $340,000. I would like to briefly go over the budget amendments starting with the general fund. The first item is an increase in operating expenditures of $49,500 in the fleet replacement ISF account in the general fund for the fire department for two fire department vehicles, which were included in the fiscal year 25 fleet replacement plan, but the cost of the outfitting for the vehicles had not been included in the replacement cost budget. The outfitting for the fire rescue vehicles includes decal wraps, stripes, city logos, emergency lights, sirens, and loudspeakers and cabinet storage for the equipment. The budget amendment is moving the cost of this outfitting to the general fund and taking the cost out of the fleet fund for the same dollar amount of $49,500. We will see this in the fleet fund budget amendment in a few minutes. This was for vehicles 171 and 172. One is a marine truck and the other a logistics truck. I want to mention this. The individual purchases, the outfitting of the vehicles were under the city manager's delegated authority threshold. I did want to mention that in talking to the fleet manager, in 2026 and future years, we are including these outfitting costs in the vehicle's replacement schedules to where we should not have situations where the funding was not there for the vehicle moving forward. Next. Yeah, Les, because that was actually going to be one of my questions. You're saying it was not budgeted and it should have been, and now you've put something in place to make sure that it doesn't happen again? Yes, that's correct. Yeah, the budget for the vehicle was covered. We had extra budget for the vehicle. But back in 25, we did not have the funding for the outfitting for those two vehicles, which totaled $49,000. And talking to our fleet manager, since then, he's including that estimated outfitting in his estimates. So when the next round comes around, we'll have the money for the vehicle, plus the outfitting for future vehicles. I'm just going to say that's disappointing. It is. That's all. Yes. Okay, go ahead. Increase operating expenditure. The second item is an increase in operating expenditures by $112,000 in a professional services account for the fire assessment fee study that was discussed this evening. The increase is for Cypress Revenue Solutions Consultant for $74,200 for the rate study, and also Bryant Miller-Auliffe of $38,600 for legal services pertaining to the fire assessment study. This results in a decrease in fund balance, and this item was presented to the City Commission on September 17th, RFP 262611. The next item is an increase of $382,000 in federal ARPA grant funding revenue and also $331,000 in capital spending for the Highland Verkardic Complex by using the final $382,000 in ARPA grant funding to offset the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office contract cost, and this falls under the federal revenue replacement category that's available in the ARPA grant funding guidance. The city can fund the aquatic complex moving forward in the general fund resulting, and this results in a net decrease in fund balance of $51,000 in the general fund. This item was presented to the City Commission on October 8th, 2026, and I want to just mention that basically in a nutshell, we've moved federal funding into the grant fund of $382,000, and we're spending that, we're drawing that down on the sheriff contract cost to draw the grant down, and by doing that, we're freeing up cash in the general fund for the same amount, and then we're applying that freed up amount to the Highland Aquatic Complex to be paid for by the general fund moving forward. Next item would be an increase in expenditure budget of $393,000 in the disaster recovery fund, and these are for expenses related to Hurricane Helene in September 24 and Milton in October 24, and this is a 2026 year-end entry for items that have not already been allocated or budgeted during the year. For this budget adjustment, the expenditure budget is being increased as follows. We've got about $376,000 of increase in Helene storm costs and about $16,800 for Hurricane Milton. As the disaster recovery fund expenses roll, they roll into the general fund, as we've talked about before, we have a fund 199 that rolls into the general fund for reporting purposes, and this will result in a decrease in fund balance of $393,000, and we expect reimbursement from FEMA in the months ahead, 75% FEMA and the 12% from the state. Most of these items were included in references to prior commission meetings. $308,000 of this amount was included for an award for, in 2025, stormwater pipelining project to Vortex Services, and that was a piggyback agreement that was approved. And also we had $36,500 that was included in the Farnrach Lighting America Delegated Authority memo for the Marina Boardwalk Lighting Project. Moving to the Public Art Fund, we have a small adjustment in the Public Art Fund, an increase in expenditures of $70 for interest expense, just a small adjustment here. We budget that as a separate line item, so we wanted to make this adjustment. This increase is in accounting entry. We had an interfund loan between the building department and the Public Art Fund. It was fully paid off at the end of September 30, 2026. This is an interest adjustment in the final year of payment. The next is the County Gas Tax Fund. We have a transfer of $35,000 in expenditure budget from the annual IT licensing account to the principal and interest accounts in the payment management project. So this is a transfer. There's no impact on fund balance. This transfer is the result of the roadway management technology software that needs to be classified as a GASB 96 subscription-based information technology classification, and this is for governmental accounting purposes. There's no change in fund balance here, and basically this GASB 96 requires us to, if we have agreements, software agreements that are over 12 months, we need to treat them as liabilities and amortize them over the year, over the life of the subscription. And this is just following that accounting process for this item. And next is the ARPA fund. This is the other side of the general fund entry where I mentioned that we transferred the ARPA dollars. This is on the ARPA side. ARPA fund, it's a decrease in capital expenditures of $331,000 for the Highlander Aquatic Complex Project. That was moved to the general fund. And the $382,000 decrease in deferred revenue account in the ARPA fund on the balance sheet, this will offset it to decrease and result in a $51,000 decrease in fund balance. And this item, again, was presented on October 8, 2026 as the final ARPA update. And the Marina fund, we have one adjustment. We've got an increase in capital expense budget of $167,000, and that was for the Marina bulkhead repair and replacement project. This increase is due to increases in design costs of $44,000, permit fees of $6,000, and construction management costs of $59,000. The remaining $57,000 was included in the budget adjustment is for funds we anticipated spending in 2025 that was not included in the 26 budget. Delays of construction kept the funds from being expended in 2025, and no budget was available to carry forward for the increase in expenses in 2026. This results in a decrease in fund balance, and we expect reimbursement from FEMA and also the state for the remainder of this project, which is near completion. And this item was presented to the City Commission on July 17, 2025, awarded bid for the Marina East Wall project, repair project. We also had a couple of references. We had a reference meeting on July 23rd where we had an addendum to the contract with Ardura for some construction management services for $34,000. And also August 6, 2026, we had an adjustment to some of the design work that Kim Lee Horn is doing for us at the Marina for $43,000. And next is the fleet fund. This is the other side of what I talked about earlier in the general fund, the $49,500 for the outfitting. This is the revenue transfer in from the general fund in the fleet fund and then to pay for that outfitting. And that concludes the general comments. And I just wanted to mention that the last page in the staffing attachment, C, shows the estimated ending available fund balance by each fund impacted. It shows the beginning fund balance and then the estimated ending fund balance after the amendments are included in the numbers and all the funds meet or exceed their reserve targets. I'd be happy to answer any questions. Okay, questions. I think we're starting with Vice Mayor. You know, I really went through this pretty thoroughly. I don't have any questions. Okay, I'll go to Commissioner Sandbergen. So the ARPA money now is down to zero? Yeah, we fully spent the grant down now. And that $167,000 in the marina, I was going to question where that went and if it's all been spelled out now. How about, has there been any FEMA recapture or reimbursement money? Yeah, we've had, over the last month or so, we've had quite a few small projects obligated, you know, probably totaling $500,000 or $600,000. The ones that are really moving slower, the larger projects, we still have not received our debris removal, which is, they still owe us $3.1 million for debris removal. And that's, you know, that's probably the one we've been pushing the hardest. They gave us, the cost was $5.2 million. They paid us $2.4 million. They still owe us about $3.2. It's close to obligation, but it's moving through the process, but very slow there. We hope to get that in the next couple of months. Also, we've got Dock A and B is moving slow. That's another large project for the marina. That's, again, they're reviewing it, but still moving slow. And also, the Pier project's moving fairly slow. The larger projects are moving slow. Dock A and B, that will be FEMA reimbursement? Yeah, we expect, well, for Dock A and B, we're fortunate because we received the $3 million grant from the state appropriation. So our plan is to spend the first $3 million of that project using those funds, and then the remaining $2 million would be FEMA. Good. Now, that's all I had. Thank you, Mayor. Okay, questions. Commissioner Degard. Thank you, Mayor. I want to refer to Exhibit C, and I want to be sure I understand Exhibit C. I want to be sure that, as I read it, the impact of all of our budget amendments is $6.3 million. Am I reading that correctly? Not just this amendment, but all prior. In Exhibit C, the shaded column in the middle is the budget adjustments that we're discussing today that total $340,000. Those are the amendments that we're discussing today, the ones that have the shade to it. But on the general fund for what we've done during year-to-date, we're at $6.3 million in the column next to that. Is that correct? Yes, that's correct. Yes. Does that seem a little high for budget amendments for a fiscal cycle, just for general fund? It all depends on the year. We've had some large adjustments this year for storm stuff, but you want to add to that, Jean? Yeah, that also includes any carry-forward items on purchase orders and projects that were carried forward from fiscal year 25. And like Les said, given that we've had a lot of activity with the storm, there's things that have not completed. So that should level out in the years ahead when we don't have proper fingers for hurricanes. Yes, and we're working on trying to reduce the carry-forward as much as we can. I'm just wondering if we have a target level so that we don't see budget amendments of this degree in the future. This seems a little excessive to me. If I went back and looked, this is larger than most years. The carry-forward moves around, but the carry-forward in the general fund was, I think, at least $3 million in this year. So that was probably half this number, maybe more. So we are working on, as you know, we are working towards reducing carry-forward. We've made some headway this year. We're going to continue to work on that. But we expected it to hopefully be lower moving forward. I don't know if it would be beneficial to my colleagues, but I would benefit from a trend line on budget adjustments by year to see what our totals are. So if you want to do that sidebar, that's fine. But if you want to share it with the commission, I'm okay with that, too. Thank you, Mary. That's all I have. Okay, questions, Commissioner Bennett. So I have a fairly specific question on the Marina Fund. You talk about the addendum to, and we had to increase the limited construction management professional services. My question is, was this due to the contractor delays? And if it is, is there any ability to recover this from the contractor in the form of our liquidated damages? Yes. Thank you. Okay. Short and sweet. You good? Okay. So I just want to make sure I understood. On item F, that's all storm related? Yes. And so the Vortex work, Vortex services work, the pipelining, that was storm related? A good portion of it. So the total award was about $600,000, but about $300,000 or $300,000 to $400,000 was related to storm damage. So what I think they did that year, so what I think they did that year is they have their schedule of what they do every year with Vortex, with storm water pipelining. And I believe that year they allocated, instead of doing what was scheduled, they moved on to items that were storm related and pushed, worked that through. So when we put that into, instead of it being in the storm water fund, it's being paid out of the assessment. And then the marina boardwalk lighting, that was storm related as well, storm damage? Yeah, that was. Okay. So, okay. So anything else in here that we weren't already aware of or wasn't in the budget? The only couple of things that we, we have a couple of year-end accounting entries that we had to do. I mean, we had a $70 adjustment that we had to do for interest, and then we had that GASME 96 we had to follow. But other than that, all these have gone to the commission or been discussed with the commission. And also a lot of it was included, a lot of the general fund items were included in our long-range plan forecast. Like, we knew about certain things. We didn't know how much for the fire assessment, but we had put a placeholder in. So a lot of that was already kind of in some of our calculations already. I'm used to no surprises, and I appreciate the transparency about the 49,000 that was a surprise and disappointed by it. But, again, I know that's actually, I don't remember it happening before. So, but I appreciate your highlighting that, because that's always my thing. Is there something that got missed and should have been known and whatever? So I do appreciate that. And I know that Scott took care of it in 26. He did it, budgeted it correctly, included the outfitting as part of the fleet replacement plan. Right. So that going forward, everything will be handled at the time of the purchase of the vehicle. And I'm particularly sensitive, because I know some of those vehicles can be a lot to fix up. So I don't want it to be kind of a hidden, oh, sorry, here's another 50,000. So, okay, no, I appreciate that. Okay, it will, let's see, we are going to, we're going to open it up for public input. Anyone in the audience wish to come forward and speak on this item? Okay, seeing no one, I will close public input and go to commission comments, starting with maker of the motion, Commissioner Sandbergen. Really nothing to add. I mean, I guess it's a lot of work. Stay on top of it. It's complicated. It's complex, but certainly in good hands. So thank you. Okay, seconder of the motion, Vice Mayor. No additional comments. Okay, Commissioner Degard? No comments. Commissioner Bennett? No comments. I don't have any either, other than I appreciate it. Before you carry on, just a point of clarification, Commissioner Bennett has asked for, I'm sorry, Commissioner Degard asked for a trim line of budget amendments in the past, maybe the past five years. Would that be sufficient? Yes. And we'll send it to all of you. Great, that sounds good. Thank you. No, thank you for that. I think that'll be helpful to see. Okay, so we need a roll call vote. Commissioner Bennett? Aye. Commissioner Degard? Aye. Vice Mayor Walker? Aye. Commissioner Sandbergen? Aye. And Mayor Franey? Aye. And that motion passes unanimously. Lots of roll call votes tonight, huh? Okay, okay, we're going to go to 3F, first hearing of application DR-2026-0002, request for design review approval for the development of a multifamily residential project called Sunrise Townhomes, consisting of a two-story building comprising eight townhomes located at 1161 Martin Luther King Jr. Avenue, 534 Howell Street, I guess, is the technical. Okay, so this item is quasi-judicial, so as we open the public here, I'm going to ask City Clerk to swear in all who wish to provide testimony on the design review application. Okay, does anyone have any ex-parte communications to disclose for the record? Okay, seeing no one, I don't either. Okay, staff presentation, George, you're on. Mayor, Vice Mayor, Commissioners, thank you very much. It's George Keeney on behalf of the Community Development Department, and welcome to our new member, Commissioner Bennett, and congratulations to Vice Mayor Walker for his re-election. That comes from my staff, by the way, and myself, of course, but they wanted me to convey those congratulations. Very nice, very nice. Thank you, Mayor. As indicated, this is a request for design review. It is, the project name is Sunrise Townhomes. The owner applicant is Marla Hocott. The representative is behind me with this team, Greg Presby. The street address is 1161 Martin Luther King Jr. Avenue. It's literally right across the street from the wastewater treatment plant, just south of Laura Drive. Land use plan, as you can see, is residential medium. Zoning district is multifamily 15. And the applicant is requesting design review approval for a multifamily residential development called Sunrise Townhomes. The project consists of one two-story building comprising eight townhomes. And you can see a little picture of the kind of a street view rendering to the upper right-hand side and kind of a planned perspective at the lower bottom, at the bottom of the slide, with the private driveway that would service those eight particular units. This is going to look familiar to, I think, four of you, because it was heard back in August of 2024. At that time, the City Commission did unanimously approve this application for design review. Unfortunately, the owner applicant did not obtain infrastructure review approval and vertical building permits within the 12-month time frame required to do so. And it, of course, is now back before you for a second consideration. There is one change between the first read and the second read that you can see. When it initially came in, it came in as a singular lot. And if you'll recall, to the east where you see the 534 Howell Street nomenclature, that's the existing assisted living facility that was on the site. Below that is the single-family home where the owner resided. And the parcel we're talking about is kind of labeled at this point as 1161 MLK Junior Avenue. Ms. Hulquette acquired the property in August of 2015, subdivided earlier this year in January of 2026. So for this particular request, what you'll be looking at while you see two parcels on the right-hand side, it is that .59-acre piece that is directly north of the homes that abut Howell Street. From a land-use perspective, again, we're just kind of dialing in on that .59 acres. The permitted primary uses in residential medium do include multifamily, which is the request here. Again, this is a request for eight new townhomes. You can see in the chart below and to the right that residential townhomes for the .59-acre site would be permitted at nine dwelling units and eight dwelling units is proposed. So it is consistent with the land-use designation. From a zoning district evaluation standpoint, again, the property zone multifamily 15, all dimensional standards are met or exceeded, and there are no non-conforming situations that would be created by this approval. The chart on the lower right-hand side kind of shows those dimensional standards, and you can see by the column on the very far right-hand side that it does conform to all standards. As is normally the case, we also do the compatibility analysis and analyze the project against the existing character of the residential community that surrounds it. In this particular case, we looked at 36 existing buildings. The area provides for a mix of one- and two-story buildings and a variety of uses ranging from low- to medium-density single-family and multifamily residential, as well as some limited commercial and municipal uses. The average height in looking at those 36 existing buildings is around 20.2 feet. The subject property is proposed at 24.35, which is significantly less than the dimensional standard cap for that particular zoning category. As the Commission also knows, we evaluate the proposal against certain standards in the Land Development Code. Those are articulated in this slide. You can see, and I will just hit on a few of them from a common open space standpoint. You can see that 100 square foot per dwelling unit is required. Applicant has actually provided more than 6,000 square foot or roughly 25 percent of the site in open space. The circulation and mobility would be accommodated by the private driveway that you saw on that one previous slide. Off-street parking, 12 spaces minimum are required. 18 are provided in this particular request. Architectural style, while one is not required in this particular area, they did choose a craftsman style, and I'll actually hit on that a little bit on a future slide here. But the architecture actually has been enhanced at the request of the Architectural Review Committee, and with the applicant willing to do so, the architectural style actually has been enhanced since the last reveal. From a sustainability standpoint, the applicants are pursuing Florida Green Building Coalition Silver Certification. From a parkland impact fee standpoint, there are eight townhomes. The fee is a little bit more than $3,000 per unit for an overall fee assessment of a little bit more than $26,000. And then I just kind of wanted to quickly hit on the traffic impact analysis. This project obviously is very small and will generate about nine peak trips. From a committee standpoint, the Development Review Committee did consider this request on May 27, 2026. All comments that were provided by the DRC have been addressed by the applicant. It then went to the Architectural Review Committee on two separate occasions, August 4 and September 1. Again, where the ARC approved the design of the project. And again, I'll hit on a slide in a minute just to show you some of the improvements that the applicant has made. Then last month, it was before the local planning agency for recommendation to the City Commission. The LPA did vote unanimously to recommend approval of the application to the City Commission subject to a couple of recommendations. And those were kind of highlighted in those arrows on the lower part of the screen. One of the things they discussed at that particular hearing was would it be feasible, or if it is feasible, the City could consider entering into a right-of-way use agreement with the Homeownership Association to maintain any landscaping, trees, and fencing installed to provide a buffer between the pros' development and the homes directly to the south. That probably doesn't make sense now, but I have a slide that will kind of show you exactly how that discussion unfolded. And then there was a little bit of a discussion on solid waste collection, where those pads were going to be, how they were going to be handled. So I also have a slide on that to follow really quickly for you. But before I get to those, our staff recommendation is we do find that the applicant has met all of the design review criteria and is consistent for approval subject to our four normal conditions. I'll just read those quickly for the record, that the applicant developer is responsible for meeting the minimum criteria of the Land Development Code and for acquiring all our jurisdictional permits and approvals. That construction plan shall be consistent with the approved design review plans and drawings. That design review approval shall expire in 12 months from the date of city commission design review approval unless the applicant obtains infrastructure review approvals and vertical building permits. And it is my understanding that they have those permits in and they're fairly locked and loaded and ready to go. And number four, incorporate the conditions recommended by the LPA on October 14, 2026 into the approval. So quickly, I just want to run through those so you can see those visually. Here is the enhancements to the architecture. The top left slide shows the structure as it was contemplated in 2024. In the 2026 street view, you can kind of see how the roof line's been modified a little bit to create a little bit larger pitch. And there's been the introduction of corbels to the project, making it a little bit more street presence friendly. Regarding the dumpster locations, I was able to confirm with solid waste shortly after the LPA meeting that plan sheet C3 in your civil drawings do show the bin pads and they are appropriately located according to solid waste. So there are 16 individual pads there. So obviously a recycle can and a regular trash can for each unit. And then finally, now this is not necessarily part of the design review. And really where this spurred was literally the day before the LPA meeting. I received an email from some residents on Howell Street. So if you see those four, they're lots 8, 7, 6, and 5. There are four lots on the north side of Howell Street, which are directly south of the subject property to be developed. You can see in between there, there is a 12-foot right-of-way that has been partially vacated. You can see the split between the red boxed area. And the consideration was, would the city be willing to look at that strip and maybe do some additional plannings or fencing or something like that to create a better buffer between the existing homes and the project area. So in laying in the project, you can kind of see what that might look like. There's that driveway coming in from Martin Luther King running to the east, just north of that existing right-of-way. And the homes are a little bit farther north, so there is a little bit separation over the driveway. But the Planning Commission suggested if the city was willing to do something in there, maybe we could even enhance that a little bit more. So I did, again, I did confirm with the engineering, I met with Clay, and Clay's here, and he stayed just for my benefit, so I appreciate that, Clay. But I did confirm with engineering that there are no utilities in that existing right-of-way. There were two, I think, wooden structures in there that have been removed. And engineering, at least engineering, is acceptable to vacation, to either vacating that right-of-way, i.e., where you see where it was already partially vacated, in which case, if you vacate, six feet of that vacation would go to the project area. The other six feet would go to the House Street residence along that north property line. Or the alternative is a right-of-way use permit, should the Commission want to keep that right-of-way. And wherein the applicant has already agreed in front of the LPA to consider additional landscaping and fencing that would be maintained by the homeownership association that they create. So with that in mind, that's kind of open for discussion, but again, not necessarily part of the design review. We are recommending the design review regardless. So I think that kind of concludes my presentation at this point. And I know the applicants are here if you have additional questions from them, but I'm happy to answer any questions you might have. So there's really going to be no set applicant presentation, or is there just questions? Okay, so I'll, I'm going to, so, well, we'll start with questions for George. But if it kind of filters in, we may have someone come up. So we're going to start with Commissioner Dugard this time. Are these properties fee-simple, or are they condominiums? They're townhomes, but I believe they're going to be set up to be fee-simple, correct? Yes. So these will be owner-occupied? They will be owner-occupied, yes, sir. Okay. I'm about ready to throw something in the middle of the room, and I'm almost sorry to do it. Because when we do something like this in the future, we've got to consider city revenue and taxing. Have we got any kind of impact study on the value of these and what revenue that may or may not mean for the city? And then subsequently, if they don't bring revenue, how much is our liability going to be to protect them? We do, as part of the design review package, Commissioner, require them to do a fiscal analysis on what that impact will be. And I don't have the application in front of me. It's literally on the application. So I believe you have in your staffing that it would bring in ad valorem taxes of $11,500. So if you don't mind, I was actually going to ask a similar, like, is that actually accurate, or is that based on old tax versus the new tax system that will actually be probably considerably less? That's a great point, Mayor. It might be considerably less. Now, these are not homesteaded properties, so I would assume that they're not going to be immediately homesteaded until residents actually move in and then claim homestead exemptions. No, correct. But, again, they're considered... That's going to be five years. Right. Okay. That's helpful. That's helpful. That means we at least get five years of revenue. But point noted going forward that we're probably going to be much more... We're just going to have to do that because of the existence. We want to approve homes. We want more residents. But we also need to realize that those new residents may bring a liability to the city with zero revenue. And it's just something we're going to have to bring greater attention to. Mayor, may I? Sure, go ahead. There actually is, and I'd have to dig it up. There is a study that was done many, many years ago over what the value of a home needs to be in order for it to add warm taxes. And underneath that particular value, it means we're actually providing services. We're subsidizing. Yeah. We're actually subsidizing that. But so if I may, let me dig around and see if I can find that study and we can apply it moving forward to Dunedin. The rough numbers that I've seen, and Manager, you may want to correct me on this, is that at the completion of the two-year period of the change of homestead exemption, 62% of our residents will pay no property taxes. Is that a correct statement? That's correct. That's why we have to do this. And we're going to have to do it. I have absolutely zero objections with this development. In fact, I think it's a great one. I drive that road every day because I live down the road from it, and I'll welcome the residents that go there. But the reality is sitting up here, I have to consider those other kinds of things. Thank you, Mayor. Okay. Questions, Commissioner Bennett. Where is the visitor parking? So the, there's no, it's my understanding, they don't anticipate parking anybody on the private road, and all of it will be, there's, you can see on the end of each, it's hard to see. Let me see if I can pull up a better thing. So each unit has two, and then each end cap has two more. So let me see if I got a better picture of it so you can see it. Which one? Yeah, it's, no, that's not showing it either. I wish I could get up there and point at the screen. I see one to the west, and there's, is that two spaces or one? So there's two visitor parking spaces total for eight units. If by chance people don't pull into the garage, how do we get emergency vehicles in there to respond or garbage trucks? So they've asked that it be posted, no parking. Because it's really difficult to park on MLK. Yes. So I'm just concerned that there's not enough. If you're going to speak, though, you will have to come forward to the mic and just name, you know, an address. Greg Presby, I'm a climber for it in Barley Engineering. I'm the project manager and representative for the property owner of Merle Hawk. Thank you. There's going to be two car garages for each unit. We added additional spaces on both sides of the parking. There's no parking along the drive aisle. And then per the fire department conversations with them, they'll have access through the drive. And then there's an existing assisted living facility on the east side of it. There'll be a breakaway or a fence or a gate, I should say, with a breakaway Knox box lock that they can come out and exit out on Howell Street. So it kind of makes a loop through there. So there will be fire department access through there. Turn the corner and not have to back back out. Yes, ma'am. Will the garbage truck have access to that? Garbage will be picked up. Out on closer to MLK? Yes, and the containers will be inside the garages, so they won't be sitting out just on the night of pickup or morning of pickup, I should say. So night, back out the next day. But they're going to be rolled out towards some pads closer to MLK? Yes, ma'am. Okay. If it meets the land development code. But I'm just concerned that, you know, no more than two visitors at a time, because rarely will a visitor pull into a garage. Eight units, two visitors, the holidays, the math doesn't work real well. I know. We do exceed the required parking for it, though. I understand completely what you're saying. Twelve spaces are required. We're providing 18 out there. And you've got nothing in front. I mean, there's no front lawn or anything where they can park in front of the garage. I'll leave that to your expertise. Yeah. I mean, so from a code standpoint, they meet code. But, you know, if there's an issue with it, well, you know, I'm sure we'll hear it from fire. We'll have to figure out how to address it then at that point. We'll hear it from the residents, too. Yeah. Well, you can't get through there. Well, yeah. So I actually pulled up another site, another picture here. That just shows the swing gates that he's referring to. So there'll be two swing gates on the end of the driveway. But they're breakaway, like you said, for fire to be able to get through the ALF. Just fire. Yeah. But that gives them the loop back to Howell Street, like you said. So it provides a loop system. But you're right. Parking mayor may be made an operation. Parking will be a problem. So that's it. Okay. Questions face, mayor? Thank you, mayor. Yeah, I actually had questions about the parking, too. Just a little confused here. You said you exceed the parking, 12 parking spots. Does that include the two spaces, the two car garages? We've got 18 spots that include the two car garages. 18. So 16 plus one. Eight units, two garages. That's 16 plus the two visitor spots on the side. Two. And where are those two located again? One on each side of the building. Okay. So you can see the one. And this is on the far end. You see the arrow coming down off the top. It's kind of pointing to where that space would be. There's a similar one on the other end. Okay. And what was the issue with the permitting? What happened? It took longer than expected to get through the site infrastructure plan review process. And the building permits weren't submitted until later on in the process. And by the time they were ready to be approved, the previous design review approval had expired. And just kind of dropped the ball and didn't ask for the extension when it should have been asked. Yeah. When do we have a date, a desired date to start the construction? Immediately. As soon as we get out of here, if this is approved. Tonight, right? Yeah. In fact, we're requesting a waiver of the second reading since this is a re-approval of previous approved plans. That's how anxious she is to get started on this. The site infrastructure permit, I've been working with Clay last year very hard on this thing. So, he's ready to go. The building permits are ready to be pulled as well pending this approval. And as soon as I just had a meeting with the site contractor, we're ready to get the silk fence up, the sediment and roads control inspected, get the pre-construction meeting going, and get construction started. And she's very anxious to get this project constructed. You're satisfied, George? Yes, sir. And to hit on something that you discussed, Vice Mayor, we have made it a practice, a new policy, basically, to alert developers when they're getting close to their expiration date so that this doesn't hopefully happen again. Okay. All right. No further questions. Okay. Mr. Sandberg, any questions? I did have a few. So, just clarify that, how it went from Howell to MLK. It's the same piece. This building will have an MLK address? Yes. Okay. Okay. And I think I'll kind of go along with what Commissioner Bennett just talked about. So, there will be no public access between this building and the adult living facility. It'll just, a pedestrian walkway? So, the access to the ALF is via Howell Street. So, you, and that hasn't changed. That's the way it is now. So, you'll come in off of Howell Street. You'll make the left past the single family home. And there's an improved driveway that runs back. Presumably, that's why that portion of that alley was vacated, so that you could get back to that ALF. Okay. Any concern about marketing and selling these for that wastewater treatment plant immediately to the west? No. She's got people lined up for these things. Oh, okay. Okay. Good, good. You know, I was concerned about people parking along, you know. So, two-car garages, obviously. So, if there's two, the people can pull in. Can you go back, George, to the picture, the architectural rendering? Oh, the architectural rendering? Yeah, it was showing the blue color. Oops. Wrong way. Yeah, that. Okay. So, for example, the red car, he would pull into his two-car garage. I don't know why, but I just have concerns about people parking along and blocking the fire department. So, I have a thought while you guys were discussing that. So, if the commission believes that vacating that strip of 12 feet, that would provide six feet to that property owner to possibly do a little bit of off-drive parking, that would be out of the way from a fire perspective. It's interesting. It's tight. Yeah, because I was thinking. Because typically you want eight foot in width. If we can remove that, then that would remove our responsibility to maintain it, I'm assuming. It would, yes, it would go to them fee simple. So, it's theirs, and then they could have pay. Vacating the right way, they would get six feet, and then the other six feet would come to the Howell Street residence. Okay, because I was a little concerned about the long term of trying to maintain that. Okay. I would like to point out, too. I kind of like, go ahead, yeah. The St. Christopher Townhomes on St. Christopher Drive, or St. Christopher Drive, is basically the same project. There's no parking allowed in the driveway. They've got, in fact, I don't even believe they have, or they do have a garage, one single-car garage, and two parking spots out there. And I don't believe they're having any problems with parking. Okay. So, I'm familiar with that one. I think I was on the LPA when that one came to town. Yeah. How about the stormwater runoff? What are the plans? What can we tell the neighbors when they get concerned about? The site drain's internal. There's a series of stormwater inlets in the driveway. There's going to be an underground storage vault that will release to an outfall control structure that's near the intersection of the Private Drive and Martin Luther King. Okay. And then it'll be piped down to an existing storm manhole at the intersection of Howell Street. Okay. And so that's all the city's looked at that? We're comfortable with that? Okay, good. And then one real simple question. Is this property going to be gated? Will the residents only? It won't be gated on MLK, but it will have the gate from the assisted living facility. Okay. And my last question is, you know, we've ran into this a couple of times. These architectural drawings are beautiful, but then when it's done, it's not what we just looked at. You guys are familiar with the Highlands Crossing townhomes? Yes. They're going to look very similar to that, even the blue color. Well, also, George, if you want to elaborate on that. Yeah, so we've thrown in a few institutional controls to make sure that it does go down the way you're seeing it. Okay. We actually pull. What we see is what we get. Yes, I know we walk around town and find some that didn't. You're right. Okay. We actually pull. When the permits come in, we actually pull it and we do it. We do basically another DRC meeting to make sure it meets up. Okay. Good. Concrete block or frame? Frame? I believe it's frame, isn't it? Block. First, right. Yeah, block. Okay. First, right. Good. That's all I, that's the only questions I had, and it's quite an improvement from what's there. How about any feedback from the neighbors up there? We've had some comments about concern about the screening, and the developer, Marilla, has stated, even though it's not showing on the landscape plan that was submitted here, she has and is committed to planting additional trees, even though she's not required to along those adjacent residential properties along the north. The north side of it? She's going to plant additional trees there. Okay. And if we can, in that area that George is talking about where that alley is, I mean, it's literally a foot, a foot and a half between the driveway and the property line, which I don't think you can fit a tree inside that. That'll survive. Okay. But if we can work something out, you know, with the easement, that we can plant something there, and she'll maintain it, she's amenable to doing that as well. So, is there a sidewalk along MLK there? Yes. Okay. Is that where the trash cans will be set? They'll be set at the curb line. At the curb line. At the curb, good. Yes. That's all I had, Mayor. Thank you. Great. So, really, no change from the last time, except for kind of the little bit different architecture and the roofing and the paver type. Correct. I think they added some windows, too, along the east or the west building side. Yeah, the architecture. So, it wasn't. Pretty much kind of how things were, the footprint. Layout. It's the same. Yep. Layout's the same. And then, again, I'm still confused about the right-of-way area because I had the same thing to Commissioner Sandberg, and I'm like thinking about us improving it and then maintaining it with what we're facing. There's no way. So, I'm just trying to understand, so what are we going to do with that? So, if you wanted to go with a vacation, what we would say, as part of this approval, you need to make application for vacation to the city engineer. And then, they would bring that application to vacate that right-of-way to you. Because there's plenty of projects where we require that buffering of the developer. Yeah. So, if it's vacated, it becomes their – so, six – if I understand it correctly. Right. Six feet of that 12 feet will come to the Howell Street, folks. Six feet of that 12 feet will go to that property on the south side. And then, that becomes part of their meets and bounds, and it's fee simple. And we don't know of any use that we have or any reason we wouldn't want to do that. Not at this point, no. So, there's no – as far as what I understand, there's no utilities and there's no structure in there. I mean, do you think that's a good thing? So, I'd actually like to meet with staff a little bit about that. So, vacating the right-of-way, right? The test is that you've extinguished all public interest in the right-of-way. So, in that case, though, as we've said, you know, six feet goes to one property and six feet goes to the other. A right-of-way license agreement, the entire 12 feet, could be used, and you could use it for parking and, you know, and additional landscaping. And as long as we never, ever have to maintain it – Yeah, because we're not going to be able to maintain that. I mean, I'm just one person, but with what we're facing, we don't need to be taking any more on. And the adjacent property owners may or may not want another six feet to maintain and to pay taxes on also. So, you know, I'd like us to work on that a little bit more and arrive at a really good solution. But it's an opportunity is what I see. But as long as, Mayor, if I may, the commission is very clear that we are not interested in planting or maintaining anything along – May I say one thing? And that right away. Yeah, it's about that. Go ahead. So, yeah, obviously that's kind of how I introduced it is we sure don't want to maintain that. So would that mess up the – whether they've approached us about avoiding a second reading? How could we move forward to not jeopardize their timeline? Well, you know you're going to see it no matter what it is. I mean, you would see a vacation or you would see a right-of-way use permit. So I would say let the, you know, let the design review move forward. If you're so inclined, waive the second, you know, hearing. And then we'll bring back to you whatever the solution is. Good. Thank you. I mean, is everybody in agreement that we don't have any willingness or ability to maintain that right away? Do you have a question first? I want to be sure that the builder does not have an issue if that were not to be vacated. No, if it wasn't vacated, no. Okay. So you're green light, even if that's not, but it's better if it is. Absolutely. Okay. Thank you. That's all, Mayor. So, again, we're not – we don't want to maintain it no matter what. We're all – I agree that we don't want to maintain it. And I also think with the discontinuousness, we don't have, like, connectivity from MLK to whatever that next avenue is to the east. It really – I'm trying to think what we could possibly use the property for. Is there a cross-access agreement with the house? She owns both properties, so there will not be a cross-access agreement. She owns both of those properties, the assisted living facility and the townhome property. There will be an HOA or a condominium association for the open space areas. But if she were to sell the home in the ALF, then that gate would be unusable without a cross-access. If she decides to sell that, then we would put a cross-access agreement into that place. She has no intentions of selling that assisted living facility. If anything, she's going to develop that property. But if she ever does, we need a cross-access? We would put a cross-access agreement in, correct. Well, and she is going to sell all of the parcels to the west in this project. Yes. And there will be some common space associated with it. So it will be separate ownership once this is developed. Yes. It seems like a cross-access agreement would be prudent to get it in place now while you can. It's harder later. The roadway is still part of the common area. The roadway isn't part of the individual condos that are going to be sold. Right. So they'd have to negotiate with the HOA and whoever purchased the other properties. Correct. Who she'll be the manager of. She'll be the manager of that HOA for the open space area. So she'd be negotiating with herself. I haven't seen the deed restrictions. If I may, though, but I think the point is that is there something where if things do change in ownership, there is a way to lock in the fact that that has to remain there. Absolutely. You can put it as part of your conditions of approval. But do we need that? Do we need anything to say that that is locked in for the future? Because otherwise our fire plan doesn't work, right? So I don't know if that was part of the review that DRC considered or not, but it makes sense to me. I mean, fire is going to use it regardless. If they've got a situation, they're coming through. They're not going to worry about a cross-access. I don't think they need a cross-access easement if it's a fire, right, an emergency. So city attorney, do you feel comfortable that that can't backfire sometime in the future with change of ownership? Because I think Commissioner Bennett said it's a good question. I think that if they were to sell in the future and you need the cross-access now to ensure that it should be a condition, an agree to condition in the approval, because then you have it. Okay. So that needs to be part of our motion to condition that. Yeah. I think that would be the best way to address it. I agree. And are you comfortable with that? Absolutely. I agree 100%. So how would it be conditioned for a cross-agreement in regards to the fire access? How would you say that? I would say for this approval, I mean, if the owner's the same, she's giving herself a cross-access agreement. Right. I'm just trying to see the exact wording that she recommends for the motion. Do you want to attach it to this approval, or do you want to attach it to a future sale of that assisted living facility? We wouldn't see that. We wouldn't see the sale of that. We wouldn't see that. True. Like I said, it doesn't matter. I'm fine. If you guys want to put a cross-access agreement as part of a condition of approval of this, that's completely fine. You would be granting that. I mean, now is the time to execute it. Why don't we do this? So the cross-access agreement, what we can do is condition it that the cross-access agreement is in place prior to the issuance of the first CO, or the last CO. That's fine. Probably the first one, because then the people were looking at it. I was going to say, probably the first one, yeah. That's fine. Well, I mean, just not to be crazy, but the first certificate of occupancy, they're all built. So what if they just say, forget it? Then we're just talking to the CO. You don't issue the CO. Okay, I got it. So I make sure there's no backdoor here. Okay. And so we can still proceed tonight. This will not slow down our vote tonight, then? No, but it does mean, if I can, City Attorney. So I would basically, I'm just trying to be clear here, the maker of the motion is Commissioner Sandberg. And so he would actually make a friendly amendment that his approval, his motion is also conditioned upon approval of a cross-access agreement in place prior to the first CO. Prior to issuance of the first CO. Prior to issuance of the first CO. Are you okay with that, Commissioner Sandberg? Will I have to specify the addresses, or is that good enough if I just refer to it as a cross-access agreement? You can say between the project area and the ALF and the assisted living facility site. Or I can give you the addresses. Yeah, 1161. I think I have them here. It's 1161. 1161. 1161 Howell? No, Dr. Oh, that's M.O.K.? Junior Avenue. Okay. And 5-something? 534. 534 House Street. All right. Okay. Tell me, yeah, so are we going to open it up for anything else? Well, I just, if you're okay with the friendly amendment, and I just want to make sure it's on the record correctly. So, conditioned approval, conditioned, the approval is conditioned on cross-access agreement in place prior to the first CEO between, issuance of the first CEO between, you have the rest. Yes. What is it? So, it would be the approval of the cross-access agreement between the project at 1161 MLK, as well as the property at 534 Howell, would be my condition. Can you state it correctly so that, and he, and then, I just want to make sure you're okay with it, City Attorney. Then you just have to agree, so you don't have to say anything. And then you'll have it. Vice Mayor. It's a good point. I think we're going to have to come back to this. Yeah. We're going to have, we need time to figure out exactly where that is. Okay. Okay. Fair enough. Okay, so we'll figure that out at a later time. And when is that next one? That would be December? Oh, 17th. 17th. Okay, because we don't know we have another meeting before that, or does it have to be a month apart? I don't think we can get the advertising in. Or no. Yeah, we'll check. We'll check it. We'll check it. See, if we can do it earlier, we'll do it earlier. But we'd have to do a specific. Earlier would be December 3rd. Right. About as soon as we can. Okay. We're going to have a second one. We'll have to do the advertising. Yeah. Just in terms of, so I'm just going to ask the question. Are we being unnecessarily restrictive by imposing this condition on approval? I don't think so. I mean, I think that we're all trying not to make you have a second hearing, which usually we don't. We always have a second hearing, and I don't think it's unreasonable. That's my personal opinion. Do we have a motion? No, we don't have a motion in a second. I thought we made it. So, do we have a motion in a second? I think that no, because we have to amend the motion to get this stuff in. Okay. For the amendment, motion is? No. That was where I was confused when I asked about the second. Because. I did not have a first or a second. I did not have a motion or a second. Commissioner Sandberger was going to do a friendly amendment, and the Vice Mayor would have to have seconded that friendly amendment, so we do not. So, we're still kind of muddling through whether it makes sense to try to add to it or not. Well. I'm not talking about the, you're talking about the proposition. Yes. We have a motion and a second. We have a motion and a second. Yes. And the discussion had to do with whether or not we were going to do a friendly amendment. And in my opinion, based on the fact that we are trying to not have to have a second reading, but it doesn't look like that's possible, unless you guys have a solution. I'd actually. Or an answer to Vice Mayor's question. I'd rather take a step back and make sure that we know exactly what we're doing. Okay. All right. So, in that regard, well, then let's go on to our main meeting and put aside this waiver and put aside the amendment for now. So, okay. So, any additional questions? And I think, Commissioner Dugard, did you have any additional questions you indicated? Do you mind? I see, too, it has to do with getting closer. Yeah, you've got to get closer. I'm sorry. You're not hearing it. Yeah. I was having trouble informing my questions, so getting close to the mic just seemed impossible. There's actually three issues, if that helps you. Oh, great. There's the main approval of this project. That's right. To move forward to a second hearing. That's right. And then the second one became, knowing in the back of our heads, that they want to request the waiver, but that hasn't happened yet. Yes. But then there was a second thought about, okay, should we condition this cross-access agreement to protect the fire protection in the future? Number two. The other issue is totally separate, which has to do with the right-of-way. Right-of-way. Right. So if we bring it back in December, we should be able to zero in on that right-of-way and have a better path forward with that, and then the issue with the cross-access easement. What damage do we do to the developer by pushing this out again? Push this back to start a construction date. Okay. All right. Good to know. Thank you. Okay. Well, I will say, though, just if I may, Mayor, there was no guarantee that you were going to waive this tonight. So if you have a construction date, it should be predicated upon the second. Yeah, no. Right. I'm just stating what we were trying to push forward with something. We were asking. I understand. That's all it was. And in fairness, until a few years ago, we never waived any of these. And this is maybe the third one that I know of where we've been asked. And this is there and lies the problem if we start to feel like we're obligated or want to so much that we don't do our due diligence. It's a mistake, in my opinion. So I think, you know, and I feel bad, honestly, because we've seen this before. But at the same time, stuff happens. We understand. Okay, so we're going to go back to the main hearing, the first reading. And I'll ask, are there any other questions before I open it for public input? Yeah, I just want to confirm the cross-access piece of it, because I'm horribly confused right now. Okay, so the reason that we are wanting to impose this is because of the possibility that the assisted living property gets sold and what's in place right now with the cross-access would go away. Is that kind of it? That's correct. And just to say, a lot of times between first hearing and second hearing, these kind of questions get worked out, and that's kind of why we have that. No, I understand. Yes. Yeah, I do. To give you the short answer, yes. My opinion. Am I missing everybody? I don't believe there is anything in place right now other than a casual acceptance that there's a cross-access. There's no guarantee of a cross-access at this point. Because at this point, it's the same owner. Right. Same owner. Yeah, okay. There doesn't need to be because it's the same owner, but in the future, they could separate the lots. Okay. Okay. No further questions. Thank you. Thank you, Vice Mayor. Commissioner Sandbergen, you had something else? Yeah. I hate to muddy it anymore, but if we're now, we're that 12-foot, is it 12-foot the alley? If we're going to go ahead and make, you know, move forward with that becoming, so it's six feet to them, six feet to the neighbors, huh? If you vacate. If it's vacated. If you decide to vacate. Do you think there's any way possible that you could come up with some kind of a sketching so we could see the number of additional visitor parking spots along that before? I mean, that's, obviously, that's come up. I think there's three of us that have brought up the same thing about guest parking. You know, I saw on the end of the building that one suspect, it was like 23 feet wide, and the garages are only 19. I don't want to muddy this any worse for you, but you know. I can take a look at it. Okay. I honestly don't believe the additional six feet is going to generate enough space for additional parking out there. Okay. I guess I was thinking, like, more of a parallel parking type. But your parking spaces are nine foot by 18 feet long, so you're only getting six plus. Like I said, I think there's a foot between the existing edge of drive, or the proposed edge of drive, and the property line. So you're only going to have seven feet. So we would, if I don't mean to interrupt, but we would work with the applicant on a license agreement. Okay. Where they get the whole 12 feet in order to. Which would solve. Parking and landscaping. What I'm talking about. Rather than six, it would be the full 12. Okay. That's all I had, Mayor. I don't want to continue to muddy this up. Yep. Anybody else? Any? Okay. Cool. Okay. So we are going to open public input. Anyone in the audience wish to come forward and speak on this issue? Okay. Please come forward. I've got two people. Name and address in three minutes. Hi, Renee. Renee Chia again, 1229 Royal Oak Drive. Again, we're going to talk about priorities. So a lot of you ask really good questions. Even some of the notes that I already had that I was going to talk to you about, some of you asked those questions. And thank you for that. Thank you for your concerns. I think the increase to the impact of the services, where we were just talking about the fire fees, is extremely relevant. I think that, you know, the reality is renters don't pay taxes. I know these homes, it sounds like, are going to be sold. But they're not going to pay eight times the fire fee that the rest of us are going to have to pay on our properties, even though they're on, you know, one piece of property. It's probably going to be assessed for the whole value of that particular parcel. And so they're probably potentially going to be paying less than the rest of us who own homes here. And then, of course, my concern with the infrastructure, again, with putting more high density. And I know we talked about this when that affordable housing project was approved that's going in behind Lukens. And I heard the attorney tonight speaking about, oh, yeah, well, later on you can just add on storm drain fees and this fee and that fee. So to just give you input from what the residents are hearing, all this high density is going up, all these townhomes that everybody hates, all these short-term rental approvals and high-density apartments, while our fees go up and up. That's why Amendment 3 passed, frankly. So I'm glad to hear that you all are not going to waive the second hearing on this either. It sounds like it was kind of for practical reasons, but I do appreciate that. And I appreciate you, Mayor, bringing up that people are asking and it was not your usual course of business, and I appreciate that. Because I think it is bad governance and policy to waive potential public participation things as a regular, you know, thing. I could see if there wasn't so much contention. But you all ask really great questions. I am going to stay to see how you vote on this tonight, because I have also seen you before all ask really great questions and then unanimously vote for something that's a train wreck. So I'm hoping to see a different result tonight. So thank you. Thank you. Anyone else in the audience wish to come forward and speak on this issue? Okay. Seeing no one, I will close public input, and I'm going to go to commission comments, starting with the maker of the motion, Commissioner Sandberg. I'm certainly in favor of that there, you know, being renovated and upgraded like that. We just have to clean up these small details, and I'm sure between our city manager, our city attorney, and George and his department, we can get that cleaned up and get this moving forward. So that's all I have, Mayor. Okay, great. Final comments? Seconder of the motion, Vice Mayor? No additional comments, Mayor. Okay. Commissioner DeGuard, final comments? I have a question. Between this reading and the second reading, all of this is going to be packaged. Is that what we're going to see? I believe that's correct, right? All right. Okay. That's all I have. Thank you. Okay. Commissioner Bennett, final comments? No final comments. No. I mean, obviously, I think this is a good project, and it's certainly within the code. And so I would, I'm in favor of it, and I think we've got a couple remaining issues for the second hearing, and so we'll see you then. And we need a roll call vote. Commissioner DeGuard. Aye. Commissioner Bennett. Aye. Vice Mayor Walker. Aye. Commissioner Sam Bergen. Aye. And Mayor Franey. Aye. And that motion passed unanimously. So we'll see you next time. Okay. We're going to go to first hearing. Oh, sorry. I kind of skipped that. How did I do that? Oh, you know what? You're right. I was looking at the motion and the second. Hold on, guys. Hold on. Hold on. My bad. Because I was looking at the maker and the seconder from last time. So I actually do need a motion and a second for approval of that, just to be so 100% clear. So I need a motion for the one that we just approved. But I was pulling from my former motion, and I had Sandberg and Vice Mayor. So I need, so if we want to do the same, but. So moved. Can I have a second? Okay. And we've had that discussion. We did our commission comments. And now let's go ahead and do the roll call vote again. Commissioner Dugard. Aye. Commissioner Bennett. Aye. Vice Mayor Walker. Aye. Commissioner Sandbergen. Aye. And Mayor Franey. Aye. And that motion passes unanimously. Second reading is scheduled for December 17, 2026. Commission meeting. Yeah. Sorry about that. No, ma'am. No additions or deletions. And anyone else have anything that they want to poll or talk about? If not, it's on the following one, actually. This is the December 3rd meeting. So in order to give them time to do it. Okay. So, okay. Motion to approve the agenda for December 3rd. So moved. Second. Okay. And all in favor? Aye. Aye. Okay. And motion passes unanimously. So informational items. So first one is the workshop, which we don't vote on that, but it is City Commission 2027 Legislative Priorities Discussion and Impacts of Senate Bill 1134, Official Actions of Level Government, otherwise known as the DEI Bill. Um, and then City Commission Community Engagement, uh, and I assume the community engagement is in regards to Amendment 3 and, uh, cuts or just in general? No, actually, this one was, um, uh, requested by Commissioner Sandberg and, and, uh, to discuss on the dais attendance at events and how we do that and how we coordinate. We'll talk about who goes and so on and so forth. I would have no idea that's what that was, but I'm glad you, you didn't lose sight of it. Okay. Sounds good. We, we, we would probably pass it. Okay. So that's just for information only. So now we have commission discussion or comments. And so I'm going to, I'll go to Vice Mayor. Thank you, Mayor. Uh, so I came to my attention that, uh, this is actually good news. Um, the, uh, Caldese Island is open. Water's been restored. Slips are all open. Um, so it's open for business. And the second thing, uh, we have 17 entries into the light of boat parade. Oh, good. Yay. So we're making progress. Yeah. Okay, good. Good. Okay. And that's all I have. All right. Commissioner Sandberg. Um, this past week, Vice Mayor and I attended the, uh, 10 year anniversary of CUNY Brewery. And, uh, when I, I had the microphone talked a little bit about, you know, the years and what they've done for the community has been volunteering, uh, just your typical nice Dunedin event. Uh, yesterday, I guess it was, yeah, it must have been yesterday. I enjoyed, uh, national, you know, the teach-in day. Boy, those kids are, I'll tell you, they're, they're good. Uh, a couple of the great questions I know I sent to a couple of you, the questions. One was, another guy asked me how well I knew Donald Trump. Someone asked me, at least three or four kids asked, it was sharp on the marina. They had some very smart questions. And, um, the main question was, they all wanted to know how much I make. And I thought that, you know, these kids are 10 years old. And, uh, I'll tell you what, we got, we got a good future with, uh, the youth of today. And, uh, I, it's one of, I think of everything I do, you know, I'm engaged every day in the community, nothing more enjoyable than that. Uh, as far as on the Blue Jays front, I'm working and listening and I can't get anything more than what we read in the, on online news about the possible lockout, which could happen on December 2nd. You know, it's something that obviously it's on my radar because I, you know, I and all of us know what that would do to our community if there was a time we didn't have spring training. So I'll let you know anything I hear and, but they're very close. They keep it very close to the best. That's, that's all I have, mayor. Uh, did you want to bring up the Garrison Jones thing, the playground? I actually, uh, had a talk today with Craig Borden of the Jaybird podcast that you and I have been on before. And, uh, I've offered up the, I'm going to bring in the Dunnade high school coach, uh, little league president and we'll talk about the, the size of that $100,000 playground grant that the, the, the Jays foundation have done. So, you know, and I told him when I go on his podcast, it's not all about the, the baseball on the field. It's about what they are as a community partner. So that's actually in the, in the making of, I'll keep you posted. All of you posted on, you know, when I go on that podcast with them. So, and you guys are aware of the Garrison Jones playground and Dunning Blue Jays foundation. Um, yeah, so, yeah, so go ahead, Steve. Just, I just wanted to make sure people know Garrison Jones. Yeah, every, at the spring training games, there's an event, whether it be, we've seen it in Toronto and we've seen it here many times, uh, the 50, 50 drawing. And of course, when you're in Canada, it's in Canadian dollars and here it's, it's, it's in U S dollars. And the money that is collected here at the stadium goes to the Jays foundation and the Toronto Blue Jays, um, it was, uh, the decision I understand was made locally here to help Garrison Jones because they are a partner. They share a lot line up at the player development and they came up with a $100,000 amount through the Jays foundation, which I've brought up and we've talked about before. And that money was raised during the, during the spring training with the 50, 50 and they gave it back to our kids. And I, I made it very clear how much I appreciate them giving it back and for the future and many generations to come. So again, our number, in my opinion, our number one economic partner doing what they do best. So thank you, mayor. And it's pretty cool because it's a, it's a baseball theme. So, okay. Um, uh, commissioner Dugard. Yes. Thank you, mayor. Um, well, I, I would like to believe that the Blue Jays might be our number one partner, but last night I was on Honeymoon Island at the Friends of the Island meeting and they have data that says they're the number one partner for Dunedin. And by the way, we do say the home of Honeymoon Island when we say Dunedin. So there might be a small rivalry here. One that I'm pleased to say both of them are performing at great levels of expectations. There, there might be a subtle difference there though, Tom, subtle, uh, the numbers are incredible for Honeymoon Island. Uh, they're seeing record numbers again. They exceed, uh, I think, and I believe this is correct. Robbie might want to correct me that they have more visitors than all the other state parks combined in the state of Florida. That is a fact. So it is an incredible attraction. It brings tons of economic energy to our community. And I'm pleased to say your city commission has two members on the board. We don't get to talk much though. Thank you, mayor. Awesome. Uh, commissioner Bennett. Well, so I attended the same event out at Honeymoon Island and it was put on by the friends of Island Parks, Honeymoon in Calidisi, which I had somehow never heard of living here for 30 years and working here. Um, and what I wanted to say was, you know, I've, I've done a lot of environmental volunteering and, and looking for opportunities like that. And here was one right under our nose when, when I retired the first time I went all the way down to Tierra Verde to volunteer with Tampa Baywatch and build oyster, um, balls to put in. But there, there's plenty of volunteering here for students that are looking for community hours or people that just want to do something environmental. And the friends of the Island Parks offer, you know, by being a member, you get 12 free admissions to the Island. So, you know, somebody that's not a, doesn't justify going out with an annual pass. I would just encourage people to, when they're looking for environmental stewardship opportunities to look closer to home, because I know it was one that I had totally overlooked personally. Cool. And we're going to need it more than ever. Um, so, well, since everybody's talking about friends of Island Parks, I'm a lifetime member, friends of Island Parks, but not on the board, gentlemen. Um, oh, listen to you. Uh, so the, um, 45th, uh, anniversary, they actually just did a video for them for their 45th anniversary, which was funny because it was just like, and you'd be the same way, Commissioner Sandbergen, because what, what year did you come? Did I need? 1982. Yeah. So I was like 84. So, and they just opened like at eight in 81. So it was kind of crazy. Um, anyway, so, um, so congratulations to them for that. Um, Celtic Festival is Saturday. Yep. So I'm not sure of the exact hours. Do you, do you, do you know? Yeah. Okay. But anyway, I mean, it's going to be a great event that, uh, what is it? 11 to seven. That's always awesome. Okay. Do I have a dress code? Kilts. Kilts. Except Nan gets a year before she asks me. I don't know. It's supposed to be chilly. Yeah. You know, of course, Ash. We, we talked about it. We talked about it. Um, and, uh, you know, obviously next, uh, next meeting we'll be doing the reshuffle, um, where, um, you know, we'll vote on a new vice mayor and, uh, and then that'll swap everybody's seats. And, uh, so that's always, uh, interesting time, fun time. Um, I can remember big battles over that in the past, but I have a feeling we'll be pretty collaborative, um, and then, um, obviously, uh, obviously, uh, you know, happy Thanksgiving. We have a lot to be thankful for in this community. Uh, no storms, no storms, no storms. Um, okay. We're going to go to city clerk update. Thank you, mayor. Nothing new to report. City manager update. Nothing to report, mayor. Any questions of the city manager? Because I have one. A thing came up today. I don't know who brought up Cala DC. Um, um, so Cala DC, um, with the city, um, and the city, um, and the city, um, and the city is an extra 20 acres. Yeah. How will, will there, will, will we still be the entrance? I mean, or is it a walkover from Clearwater beach or how, I was trying to, I'm trying to think. It's not a walkover. Yeah. It's not a walkover. Cause I didn't know. It is. It is at low tide. Well, you used to be able, when the sandbar was that you could walk to Cala DC. It, it, but at low tide, you, you can do it. But the part, the problem is, is when the tide comes in, the water is pretty fast. And it's, uh, it's not recommended. In fact. Well, I'm not going to do it. I'll give you the, well, I'll give you, I'll give you the fairy spiel. You know what I'm saying? Oh yeah, that's right. Yeah. People say, well, well, can, can we walk back? And I said, you know, I would always say, well, I guess it all depends on the tide right now and how many bugs are out there. And I, I, oh, I, I can tell you stories. I've, I've seen people that walked up and they come on the boat and they're just, they've got welts all over them because of bug bites and all this stuff. And, uh, anyway, um, so we will be the access to the whole thing. I don't see how, I don't see how, but they don't retain it. Um, I don't know, you know, it's going to be really interesting to see how they do that. We'd have to, yeah, have a look. I don't know. It's like a, it's like an island all on its own. Yeah. That was privately owned. Yeah. Quite a piece of, the guy that owned the Clearwater Beach. I want to stay in the house. Yeah. What's that? It was privately owned. Yeah. There was an article about it. Clearwater Beach. Clearwater. Oh, that, right. I mean, it's in that area. Well, that's, yeah, that's true. Um, and I had one, oh, when will the contingency budget be available? Tomorrow. Okay, great. Because I'd like to get a hard copy of it to take away with me. Yeah, absolutely. Okay. Yeah. Anybody else have a question? Okay. Um, and then, um, city attorney update. No update. Okay. So if there's nothing else good for the order, meeting is adjourned. All right. Congratulations, Commissioner.