Good afternoon. I am Carolyn Messersmith, Purchasing Manager and the Meeting Facilitator. I would like to call to order this initial evaluation committee meeting for requests for proposals, number PNC-213-2144-P1, Architectural and Engineering Consultant Services for the Construction Management Division. The time is 12.38 p.m. on November 20, 2026. This meeting is being held through Microsoft Teams representatives from the county are physically here in Room 430 of the Governmental Center Building, located in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, or virtually through Teams. Attendees, please mute the microphones on your devices to limit the background noise. This is a public meeting and is being recorded by Broward County. The video recording will act as the official recording of the meeting. The recording will be made available on the Purchasing Division website under the RLI RFP repository. Information reviewed by the evaluation committee as part of the evaluation process will also be posted on the repository. This meeting has been publicly noticed. The purpose of the meeting is to determine the responsiveness and responsibility of the proposing vendors. Only those vendors that have been determined by the evaluation committee today to be both responsive and responsible to the solicitation requirements and shortlisted may proceed to the final evaluation committee meeting for presentations and ranking. At the time of the solicitation deadline, 2 p.m. on September 4, 2026, 16 proposals were received. Meeting attendance is recorded in the following ways. The Purchasing Division records attendance of county staff physically here in Room 430. All virtual attendees, including county staff, please click on the link or scan the QR code that is currently listed in the Teams chat section to complete the sign-in sheet. For attendees that cannot access the link or QR code in the Teams chat, email the purchasing agent Melissa Cuevas at mecuevas at broward.org with the subject EC meeting attendance and indicate your name, your title, and the company you represent in the email body. The following are the county's project staff, Andrew Bennett, Senior Purchasing Agent, Todd Manning, Project Manager, Construction Management Division, Javier Navas and Amanda Tolbert, County Attorney's Office, Danielle, Office of the Economic and Small Business Development, and Colleen Ponnell, Risk Management Division. We have a quorum present with the following evaluation committee members. Committee members, please say present after your name is called, and make sure you turn on your microphones. Laura Sotomayor, Registered Architect, Seaport Engineering and Construction Division, Port Everglades Department. Present. Thank you. Jill Thompson, Construction Project Management, Supervisor, Parks Planning and Design Section, Parks and Recreation Division. Present. Thank you. Richard Luce, Construction Project Management, Supervisor, Construction Management Division, Public Works and Environmental Services Department. Present. Thank you. Irina Tokar, Construction Project Management, Supervisor, Capital Projects Division, Aviation Department. I did not. Yeah. It's a note. You have to turn on the mic. Present. Thank you. What did I miss? Oh, I'm sorry. Alvaro Barrios, Construction Project Manager, Facilities Management Division, Public Works and Environmental Services Department. Present. Thank you. It is the evaluation committee's responsibility to review the vendor's submittals to ensure solicitation requirements are met and to evaluate the submittals and make a recommendation to award a contract. Each evaluation committee member was appointed by the county administrator to serve on this committee based on their experience. The evaluation committee members are responsible for following the county's established committee procedures to select vendors which provide the services that are in the best interest of the county. At the discretion of the board, the evaluation committee members may be requested to substantiate their recommendation and discuss their submittal reviews. In accordance with Broward County Procurement Code, each evaluation committee member must affirm that they are free of conflicts of interest as provided in Part 3, Chapter 112, Florida Statutes, and the Broward County Employee Code of Ethics. All evaluation committee members and the project manager assigned submitted the required Broward County Disclosure Forms and responded that they can be fair and impartial to all vendors. The cone of silence has been in effect since the solicitation's advertisement. Vendors are prohibited from discussing the solicitation with the commissioner's office, county staff, or a member of the evaluation committee. The cone of silence terminates when the awarding authority takes action which ends the solicitation. During the cone of silence, inquiries regarding this solicitation should be directed to the project manager or the director of purchasing and or his designee. Also, vendors may communicate with designated representatives from the Office of Economic and Small Business Development at any time regarding the solicitation's small business enterprise or county business enterprise participation. The summary of vendor rights regarding Broward County's competitive solicitation was issued in the solicitation. Broward County will be utilizing a consensus approach to provide a summarized group consensus evaluation score at the final evaluation committee meeting. At this time, the purchasing agent will report on the findings on the responsiveness and responsibility and identify if any exceptions were taken to the county's terms and conditions. Thank you. Proposals were received from the following vendors. AECOM Technical Services, Inc., Austin Fox Architecture, LLC, BEA Architects, Inc., Bermelo Ahamel & Partners, LLC, Brooks Scarpa Hoover Architects, Inc., CSA Central, Inc., Eric Dempsey Architect, LLC, Gurri Matute, PA, Guri Matute, PA, Indigo Architecture Consulting, Doing Business as Indigo Architecture, Jorge A. Gutierrez, Architects, LLC, Justin Architects, PA, Press, ENG, LLC, Salts Michelson, Stratus, Inc., Stratus Team, LLC, Tectonic Group International, LLC, and the Tamara Peacock Company Architects of Florida, Doing Business as Peacock Architects. The solicitation had two responsiveness requirements involving compliance, criminal history screening practices certification and lobbyist registration certification. The Director of Purchasing recommends that all 16 vendors be deemed responsive to all the responsiveness requirements. The solicitation had six areas of responsibility requirements, affiliated entities of the principal, financial information, financial ability, insurance requirements, registered architect license, litigation history, Office of Economic and Small Business Development program requirements. Fourteen of 16 vendors provided the required documentation for evaluation committee review for responsibility. The following compliance concerns were identified. Press, ENG, LLC did not meet the OESBD and licensing requirements. Refer to the OESBD review memorandum and the Director of Purchasing memorandum for additional information. The solicitation required vendors to state whether they accept Broward County Standard Terms and Conditions or if they do not accept them to identify the agreement provisions and vendors proposed changes. Fourteen of 16 vendors accepted the County Standard Terms and Conditions without exceptions. The following vendors took exceptions to the County Standard Terms and Conditions. Brooks Scarpa Hoover Architects, Inc. And CSA Central, Inc. The specific exceptions taken by these vendors are identified in each submittal and will be addressed prior to presentations if vendor advances at the final evaluation committee meeting. This concludes purchasing remarks and is presented for the consideration of the evaluation committee. Thank you. The next order of business is to determine vendor responsiveness as defined in the Procurement Code Section 21.40A. Is there any discussion from the evaluation committee regarding the determination of responsiveness? Hearing none, may I have a motion with respect to the responsiveness of the vendor submittals. This is Richard Luce. I would like to make a motion to find all vendors as responsive to the solicitation's responsiveness criteria. May I have a second? Irina Tokart, I'll second. All in favor say aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes unanimously. The next order of business is to determine the responsibility of the vendors as defined in Procurement Code Section 21.40B. Is there any discussion from the evaluation committee regarding the responsibility of the vendors? Hearing none, may I have a motion with respect to the responsibility of the vendors. Good afternoon. My name is Jill Thompson. I'd like to make a motion to find the 14 members, the 14 applications to be responsible. How do I motion? So there's two motions. Right. There's actually a motion for non-responsible, and you would list the names of those two vendors. So page 9, the bottom. Oh, all right. Let me do that again. My name is Jill Thompson. I'd like to make a motion to find Press Eng LLC and Tectonic Group International LLC as non-responsible to the solicitation's responsibility requirements. May I have a second? Irina Tokart, I second. All in favor say aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes unanimously. Now may I have a motion with respect to the responsibility of the remaining vendors? This is on page 10, correct? Correct. Okay. I'll make a motion to accept 14 firms as responsible. Or would your motion be a motion to accept all remaining? Correct. Yeah, okay. Okay, so we have a motion that would move forward the remaining responsible vendors. May I have a second? Alvaro Barrios, I second the motion. All in favor say aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes unanimously. The next order of business is to determine the vendors that were found to be both responsive and responsible. May I have a motion with respect to the vendors determined to be both responsive and responsible? Irina Tokart, I'll make a motion to declare the remaining 14 firms as responsible and responsive. May I have a second? Jill Thompson, second. All in favor say aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes unanimously. In accordance with Procurement Code Section 21.44, procedures for CCNA services states that the Evaluation Committee shall establish a short list of vendors for further consideration of award of the solicitation. Unless the Director of Purchasing determines that shortlisting would not be in the best interest of the county. Finally, in accordance with Florida's Statute for Consultants' Competitive Negotiation Act, there shall be no fewer than three responsive, responsible vendors evaluated. However, the Evaluation Committee determines the final number of vendors to shortlist. Shortlisting is based on the Evaluation Committee's evaluation of the vendors' entire submittals, including responses to the evaluation criteria. Is there any discussion regarding shortlisting? Yes, Karen, can we rank the remaining 14 firms and then decide on how many we want to shortlist? No, we just shortlist. We don't rank? No, we do not. I have a question just to confirm the number of contracts that are going to be awarded from this solicitation. Todd Manning, it'll be three agreements with the solicitation, so it'll be three firms. Thank you. Any other discussion regarding shortlisting? Somi, I have a motion with regards to shortlisting the vendors. How many would you like to shortlist down to? Can we have a discussion? Yes, yes, you can have a discussion. If this is your time, discuss, talk. So you need to turn on your microphones so we can hear you and turn on your microphones. Yes, please, all of you. And please state your name before commenting. Sorry, one second. Let's use our microphones one at a time, and if you could state your name before your comments. I have an additional question. How much time are we going to give to each vendor for presentation? That is determined later in the meeting? All right, this is Rich Luce. My suggestion is, since we have 14 firms, if we interviewed half of them, seven, since we're going to select three of them, seems like a reasonable number to me. Alvaro Barrios, I second. Laura Sotomayor, I suggest seven. Okay, we all agree. Does Todd want to add anything as a project manager? Thank you, Irina. No, I think seven is a good number for the committee. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, is there any other discussion? No. Okay, so then may I have a motion with regards to shortlisting of the firms? Irina Tokar, I'll make a motion to shortlist seven firms for presentations. Okay, may I have a second? Laura Sotomayor, I'll have a second. Okay, all in favor, say aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes unanimously. The evaluation committee will now shortlist the vendors. The evaluation committee members will be emailed a ballot link to select the vendors to shortlist. The number of vendors to shortlist is seven. Bear with us for a moment. Okay. Once all committee members submit their shortlist ballots to purchasing, I will briefly recess the meeting to allow purchasing time to tally the ballots. When purchasing notifies me that they have completed the tally, I will reconvene the meeting, and purchasing will read the shortlisting results. Are there any questions? Committee members may begin shortlisting. The purchasing division will notify me when they have received all the ballots. Hi, Mr. Pressman. Hold on. Let me get David on the phone. Hold on. Please mute. Mr. Pressman, you there? Yes. Please mute your computers and phones. Before I forget, we sent out the letters today. Hello? Whoever wants to run for the board, you need to give me a... Mr. Pressman, Mr. Pressman, you need to mute your computer. Will do. The shortlist ballots have been submitted, and we will now take a recess. The time is 1.04 p.m., and we are in a short recess. I would like to reconvene this meeting. The time is now 1.20 p.m. Purchasing will announce the results. The shortlisted vendors are as follow. AECON Technical Services, Inc. BEA Architects, Inc. Brooks Carpa Hoover Architects, Inc. Justine Architects, PA. Saltz-Michelson Architects, Inc. Estratus Team, LLC. There was a three-way tie for the seventh place, and the tie was broken using the tiebreaker criteria in accordance with the Section 2142-D of the Procurement Code, and the seventh place goes to Jorge A. Gutierrez, Architect. The tie was broken using the location tiebreaker criteria. Thank you. May I have a motion to accept the name vendors as the shortlisted vendors? Irina Tokar, I'll make a motion to accept these vendors for shortlisting. May I have a second? Laura Sotomayor, I have the second. All in favor say aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes unanimously. The final evaluation committee meeting will be held on Monday, December 14, 2026, at 9.30 a.m., and will include vendor presentations. The evaluation committee establishes the length of presentations. This time does not include the unlimited question-and-answer period. Is there any discussion regarding the presentation length? Again, question-and-answer period is unlimited. Yes, we would like to have a discussion. So please turn on your microphones. What is normally... Yeah, my two cents would be... The discussion has to be done on the microphones. Yeah. My suggestion would be ten minutes. Oh. Given my understanding of the criteria is the proposal is really what we're doing. The presentation doesn't have an enormous effect on evaluation. Yes, that is correct. The proposals is what the evaluation criteria reviews in addition to the presentations. But the presentations are limited to what's in the proposals. So it would be the same, essentially, what they already submitted to us. They're going to make a presentation on. So based on that, maybe it's going to be more beneficial to ask questions, to have more time to ask questions after presentation. So I would agree with Rich. I think it's a good recommendation. I don't know if ten minutes is... My only concern is that ten minutes is pretty tight. By the time they introduce their whole team, would we possibly consider 15? I think 15 is better because ten minutes, they don't have the opportunity to present well. Okay. Then, Albert, are you in agreement? No, I was... Alvaro Barrios, I was just thinking that a presentation that is with this time constraint, it's not much that we're going to get out of the presentation. But I guess the trend to get is that what is the essence of the presentation other than if we're just going to evaluate based on what they submitted already, then time should be spent on the questions, right? Right. And I think that's... I mean, I thought this is our point. This question and answer period is unlimited, so we can do presentation, maybe like allocate six, seven hours, so they do presentations. But we have the whole day, so there's no time limit. And they have time for questions between, so we do one each hour. Yeah. Yeah, that's correct. Javier Navas, County Attorney's Office. The question and answer period is unlimited, so the evaluation committee and the project manager can ask as many questions as they'd like of the presenters. Thank you. So if we do, Irina, if we do 15 minutes, then we know we will have 45 minutes for questions based on the presentation that they submitted. Okay. I think we're ready to make a motion, Carl. Okay, so may I have a motion to set the presentation length? Yes, Irina Tokar, I would like to make a motion to set up presentation time to 15 minutes. May I have a second? Second. Thank you. May I have a second? Oh, I'll do a second. This is Rich Luce. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes unanimously. As established, each vendor will have 15 minutes for their presentation, followed by an unlimited question and answer session. All vendors will have up to five minutes to set up for their presentation in the team's meeting. At this time, a purchasing agent will use a random list generator to determine the order of presentations. This will be viewed on the screen. The order of vendor presentation is as follows. First, Justin Architects. Second, BEA Architects. Three, Stratos Team. Four, Jorge Agutierrez Architects. Five, AECOM Technical Services. Six, Saltz-Michelson Architects. And seven, Brooks-Karpa-Hoober Architects. Committee members, is there any business, other business that we need to discuss today? No. We would like to thank all the vendors that responded to this solicitation. We appreciate your time and interest in working with Broward County. The time is 1.28 p.m. This initial Evaluation Committee meeting is adjourned. And thank you, Evaluation Committee.