this is the planning and zoning board slash local planning agency it's an advisory board which makes recommendations to the county commissioners who will make the final decisions on these items items h1 and h4 are lpa items items on today's agenda will be heard by the county commission on december 10th 2026 at 5 p.m when a motion ends in any kind of a split vote a roll call vote may be taken to ensure accuracy as a reminder each member who makes a motion or a second needs to turn their microphone on so that your voice is on the record speakers for public comment on agenda items will be given two minutes please spell your last name for the record at this time if any board member has had any ex parte communication regarding any application please disclose look please disclose so now mr chairman yes sir for transparency and disclosure
purposes i did have a conversation could you turn on your mic oh get closer to your mic my sexy voice can you hear now there you go for transparency and disclosure purposes i did have a conversation with the applicant's representative before this hearing that conversation did not influence my position one way or the other and i will render my decision based on exclusively on the competent substantial evidence presented on the record today and that was for h1 and h2
all right thank you mr jordan you're welcome i'm going to need a motion for the p and z minutes on october 12 2026 so moved second got a motion by mr jordan a second by debbie all those in favor say aye aye aye aye any opposed that pass unanimously okay item h1 please good afternoon h1 and h2 are
both companion applications so we're going to read them into the record together h1 is bernard b berkland jr francis k berkland and janice lucas represented by blair knighting are requesting a small-scale comprehensive plan amendment 26s.10 to change the future land use designation from res 15 and pi to community commercial also h2 bernard bernard berkland jr francis k berkland and janice lucas blair knighting representing arrest requesting a zoning classification change from ru 2105 to medium density multifamily res and pip planned industrial park to b1 general retail commercial okay is the applicant
here and if you could get as close to that microphone as you can so we can hear you
uh and if you spell your last name mr oliver yes sir uh cole oliver o-l-i-v-e-r relatively easy to spell and it's not often that i get accused of not being heard due to the volume but uh just wanted to take a quick moment i'm cole oliver with the lounge firm representing the developer the binge development group with me have miss blair knighting she will be doing a brief presentation with a couple slides for you all and then um save a little bit of time for rebuttal and q a as as needed but appreciate you all listen to this this uh i guess afternoon so uh we'll be here thank you afternoon could you state
your name and spell your last name also for the record please yep blair knighting k-n-i-g-h-t-i-n-g certified planner is kimley horn associates and my address is one two seven four zero grand bay parkway west suite two three five zero jacksonville and our zip code is three two two five eight thank you all for your time today i'm going to try not to ignore you all over there too um yeah so we're here today where i combined the presentation the applications are for the small scale and the zoning and i combined them into one so our location we're between barna avenue and state road 407 on 405 which is columbia and we have a proposed i think these maps really tell the story well that we are requesting to just expand the existing community commercial land use category as you can see on the left map that's our existing land use our proposed is just expanding that cc where we leave also the res 15 as a buffer to gradually transition to the residential and then you see we leave the pi on that eastern portion because that's more of like a environmentally sensitive area so we we don't intend to develop over there on the east and so the proposed zoning same thing just expanding the b1 to follow the land use and the purpose of the request is to allow adequate depth for market rate modern mixed use development also by maintaining the transition of uses and this is kind of the application by the numbers you can see our app our whole parcel is 77 acres but we're only requesting to have 31 acres change from cc to b and b1 b1 and because i'm a certified planner i have to talk about the project benefits it reduces the amount of industrial across from this growing mixed use node here it does protect the eastern environmental area by keeping it pp we aren't touching that area it utilizes that as an eastern buffer and then we are we did design it intentionally to keep that backwards l as a transition of uses from the community commercial to the residential along barna and then it does provide needed mixed use in this area and then it is along a major corridor where you want growth to happen along these major corridors and then there's a couple slides that i'll talk about real quick um in terms of the staff report the staff report was uh discussed a little bit about transportation there is capacity along columbia challenger which is 407 and then also barna and then the fdot pre-app did request access on barna road as well and we are between two intersections between barna and state roads 407 and then we did want to just quickly talk about the staff report in terms of stormwater we do agree with staff we will meet all applicable federal state and local regulations as required by any development that it that occurs in the county and then we are committed to also continuing to have our experts our flood we have a floodplain expert we also have the civil engineers here to discuss that and then from initial research a compliant stormwater design path does exist we haven't got into permitting yet because this is really high level land use and zoning is pretty high level we don't typically get into the engineering until after we have the entitlements but we are looking at it right now and then just briefly there's three quotes from the staff report that i just wanted to highlight that it's not anticipated that the proposed development would cause a deficiency in the los of roads or solid waste and then at the point of site plan we will have a traffic study so i know i'm sure there's some traffic concerns but we don't we when you have entitlements you typically don't have an end user right away and so we really need to do the traffic study when we have the users identified and that comes at site plan with engineering and then the area surrounding the subject property is characterized as mixed residential commercial and industrial rather than a residential neighborhood this is from the staff report and we do agree it is compatible with the area the requested change and then one of the provisions in the comp plan says that the cc cluster should not exceed 40 acres at an intersection we're at two intersections so we really don't think that policy applies here and then because i am a planner i had to talk about the comp plan and how it is consistent our our intent is to meet the comprehensive plan and we think it meets this project meets the comprehensive plan we just listed a couple of those policies real quick and then um i respectfully request your recommendation for approval and our experts are here if you have any questions specific
questions about the project thank you for your time all right thank you is there anyone in the audience want to speak for or against this item okay if you want to start right here and we'll just go can i
do something really quick yes ma'am as i was sitting here um many many months ago the surgeon had come into my office where um we had talked about a couple different projects that are coming to not only brevard county but outside of brevard county this was one that we was a very quick overview that was discussed that i just want to make sure to put on the record okay all right sir if you state your name
spell your last name for the record yes good afternoon my name is wayne hessler h-e-s-s-l-e-r i am a resident of 5685 barna avenue in titusville each of you should have received an objection packet that we have passed our secretary to pass out to you this one has the shrek character on the front of it so you can follow along as our presentation goes i am the first of several speakers today presenting a unified non-repetitive case against the barna columbia zoning change i'm here to talk about the water our neighborhood already faces severe chronic flooding during seasonal rains and tropical storms we have standing water in our yards for days some now permanently the 75 acre parcel in question sits on a higher natural ridge next to us right now that vacant land acts as a net gigantic net natural sponge soaking up rainfall even with that sponge the water naturally drains downhill straight into our backyards we are already at a tipping point if you allow this land to be cleared and paved you're removing our only defense i live this reality every rainy season including the upcoming three days that we all know the rain is going to hit us in the next three days it is your job to not only look at future zoning changes but also to protect your resident citizens who purchased their properties based on a long-term brevard county plan already in place our younger generation brevard county needs homes and future well-paying jobs i'm asking you to do your job and protect our homes and land from unnecessary and unneeded commercial land development thank you very much thank you ma'am i think she was did you
want to speak um we got an order to go in so it makes sense if that's okay they're all coming up as
okay thank you name and spell your last name for the record please sir jose nunez last name is n-u-n-e-z i'm a registered professional engineer in the state of florida and reside at 5523 river oaks drive which is just right behind this property in question i respectfully urge you to recommend denial of rezoning application 26 c triple zero 37 and companions amendment 26 double s triple zero ten based on unresolved concerns under all five factors of the bar county code section 62 dash 1151 c first factor surrounding land use character homes boarded this property to the north and west with conservation areas to the east as of october 27th the county confirmed that no compatibility assessment have been developed addressing lighting building placement deliveries or residential separation second factor change conditions what documented changes justify expanding commercial zoning into an established residential neighborhood third factor traffic utilities and neighborhood impacts public works warns that this property receives surrounding runoff and that development could worsen neighborhood floating what engineering evidence demonstrates that clearing fill and pavement will not increase flooding access restrictions on barna avenue also remain unresolved fourth factor land use plan compatibility page seven of staff comments identifies a proposed commercial cluster of approximately 48 acres exceeding policy 2.8 b's 40 acre benchmark what documented exception justifies approval and the fifth factor public health and safety welfare what enforceable safeguards will protect wetlands drainage functions wellhead protection areas and neighborhood homes residents deserve answers before rezoning not after construction begins respectfully ask for you to deny this application thank you
gary leslie leslie i leven at 5715 barna avenue mavar county has bestowed upon you as a board great power and with great power comes great responsibility i'm addressing section 62-1151 subset c subset for protection elements of our comprehensive plan The applicants are required to deliver a comprehensive and binding development plan, and to my knowledge, at this time, they have not. This plan would be needed by the board in order to make an informed decision. I come to you today with concerns about the applicant's petition to change the zoning of 31 acres adjacent to my property. The applicants have stated that they only intend to change 31 acres out of the 75. The remainder of the acreage is wetlands, and they contend that it will be left untouched as a natural barrier. However, the sand dunes that make up most of the 31 acres in conjunction with the wetlands are all part of a natural filtration system that recharges a bowl-shaped aquifer that is found in a substrate of this property. It is only recharged by rainfall. There are no arterial feeders coming from other areas to replenish the aquifer. The entire filtration system is at the mercy of the contaminants imported into or upon it. The City of Titusville uses this aquifer as part of its water resource for the citizens of Titusville. Any planned usage of this property should be of great importance to them as a possible contamination of their water resource. Without a binding development plan, this board cannot make an informed decision that will affect the great population of Titusville. Not only this...
Okay, thank you, sir. Thank you.
Good afternoon. My name is Christina Sokol, S-O-K-O-L, and I'm a resident at 5555 Barna Avenue. I am concerned about this specific parcel.
If you could just get as close as you could. There you go.
Better?
Yes, ma'am.
Apologies. This specific parcel we're discussing serves as a vital ecological envelope for both federally and state-protected wildlife. My question is, has an environmental impact survey been done on this property, and will that be provided both to the board and the residents concerned? Titusville is a critical, internationally recognized stronghold for the threatened Florida scrub jay. To survive, these birds depend on stable, contiguous xeric oak scrub and pine flatwood matrices. Wiping out dozens of acres of this habitat fragments their territory, which is in direct violation of the conservation element of the Brevard County Comprehensive Plan. Furthermore, given the documented population density of the critically endangered gopher tortoise along the sand ridge on Barna, this site undoubtedly contains active burrows. Both the tortoise and its burrow are protected under state laws by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. The gopher tortoise is a keystone species whose burrows shelter the federally protected eastern indigo snake. This snake cannot dig its own shelters, and it relies on tortoise burrows to survive freezing winter temperatures. In addition, hundreds of other species of native mammals, amphibians, reptiles, birds, and invertebrates also rely on the habitat created by these burrows. Granting an open-ended commercial zone allows for destructive mass grading. Without a binding site plan layout, heavy machinery will entomb these animals and tear apart their foraging ranges. We have a legal and moral obligation to defend these species from blind commercial clearing. I implore you to reject this rezoning request.
Okay, thank you. Anyone else?
How are you, sir? Very well. Thank you for having me here. My name is Rafael Nicolares of 5725 Barna Avenue. That's N-I-C-O-L-A-R-A-S. So, I came here today. I won't be staying long. I have to get back to work. I'm a mechanical engineer, an aerospace engineer at one of the rocket companies here. My job literally is to take only data and deductive logic and make rational decisions for mission success and to protect people here. I'm a big proponent of development moving forward, developing our city, our country, and the whole form of capitalism overall. However, in this circumstance here, for data I have seen so far on my property, for instance, is two acres. I do not have a lake. As of three weeks ago, I have a 0.9-acre lake. There is problems with drainage, as is, I am not a surveyor. I'm an engineer. When the surveyors came out a few months ago for this project, I encountered them on my property thinking they were trying to break in. However, I let them in, take their measurements and so on, and asked their opinion of this project based on their professional experience. It's them not knowing the project themselves mentioned there was effing insanity for somebody to build here with the low level and the flooding that's going to happen based on the data they have. And I have to concur with that with what I'm seeing on my own property. I do believe in the aquifers refilling and filtering through the sands of Bonner themselves, but also the future of not only our homes, but also the project and the people who will buy into this project not knowing what's going to come afterwards with nature. And the flooding that happens here, and so on. So that's what I have to say. I will share this picture with you. I could not print it for it to make it look good. This is yesterday. You would have to get that. There's a projector here? Yeah. There you go. So I kept it on my phone because, as you can see here in the top section, the date is yesterday. And this is literally all water here on my property since three weeks ago, since we had that rain. So that's the evidence I have.
Thank you for your time. Thank you, sir.
Okay. My name is Ann Blackman, B-L-A-C-K-M-A-N. I live at 5770 Barna, directly across the street from the parcel. Already, my traffic coming around a curve that's to the left of me, I can barely get out of my driveway some days because people are speeding down just a two-lane road, and I can't tell they're coming because they're coming blindly around a corner. So I'm wondering, why can we expect to have a change in zoning when we don't even have a plan of what's going to go there? What's going to happen right across the street from me? Is there going to be ingress and egress coming out right there where my driveway is? I can barely get out now. Also, I'm on well water, and also I have a lot of native species of wildlife in my yard coming from across the street. Is that going to be protected somehow? What is the plan when we don't even know really what's going there? My question is, have there been any studies for traffic yet? And not only on Barna, but also on Columbia. A new apartment project has gone in right across the street on Columbia from this parcel. Right now, they don't even have egress to go west on Columbia because there's no crossovers. So what is the additional traffic coming in and out of that parcel going to be when there's already a problem existing there? That's what I have to say. I respectfully request that you logically make this decision. Thank you.
Thank you, ma'am.
My name is Catherine Schill, S-C-H-I-L-L. I live at 5770 Barna and own the adjacent acre. My concern is also the traffic. As she said, we can hardly get out of our driveway as it is. And we are wondering, has there been any studies at all on where all this traffic is going to go as it comes down out of this development? What about the lights that will be in our face every day? We were just wondering, what is the plan for this? There is no plan. We have no idea what's coming in here and what to do about it. So I just want to know who is going to look at this and have a plan that we can see and know what we are up against. Thank you. Okay. Thank you.
Good afternoon. My name is Andy Sokol, S-O-K-O-L. I'm a resident of Barna Avenue at number 5555. Look, I agree with everything that all my neighbors are saying here. It's pretty clear here that the intent of these rezoning requests is to allow this developer from Jacksonville, who will not be dealing with the fallout of these changes, to come in and bulldoze this land, to grade it, and to build on it. Build a hotel. Build an apartment. Build a shopping center. As you can see today, the residents do not want this. We're seeing this all over Titusville. Natural lands laid to waste in the name of commercialism. Even when there are decrepit eyesores of dilapidated buildings littering the town. Those are the properties that should be bulldozed and built up again. Not the few remaining virgin lands and the habitats of our endangered wildlife. The question for this commission is what specific change in neighborhood conditions justifies eliminating this multifamily land inventory when Titusville already has vacant commercial plazas. Again, the residents don't want this. Something else we also see commonly these days are videos from all over the country of town and county meetings just like this one, where brave citizens come and speak up to their elected leaders, who then proceed to ignore them and vote in favor of developers and commercial interests instead of their concerned constituents. Don't let this be another one of those meetings. We don't want more land bulldozed. We don't want more hotels. We don't want more apartments. We don't want more shopping centers. If we truly need these things, then they should replace the existing abandoned structures in the town. We don't want animal habitat destroyed. We don't want more of the unprecedented flooding that we've seen in recent weeks, and we're going to see again this week with the weather coming in. And we don't want our property values adversely affected by the encroachment of unwanted businesses. Please hear us, and please do the right thing. Reject these rezoning requests to prevent future undesired overdevelopment. Thank you.
All right. Thank you.
Hello. My name is Teresa Hessler, H-E-S-S-L-E-R. I live at 5685 Barna Ave. I'm addressing Section 62, 1151, Subsection C, Subsection 2, which mandates evaluating whether local change conditions justify rejoin our zoning maps. There's absolutely no planning justification for this change in Titusville and North Rivard. They are currently facing a shortage already of PIP industrial land. We had this property zoned out 20, 25 years ago. We felt fortunate that we had forward thinkers that saw the need to preserve an area for aerospace technology, manufacturing jobs, low footprint, that will continue to bring our young generation here, that would keep them here, and give them jobs that they could afford a living in, not commercial strips of land that have some of those lowest-paying jobs in the area, wiping out over 31 acres of this land that we don't need. Blair Industries comes up and is telling us this is things we want and need. Within three to five minutes, going all four directions, we have so much commercial property. All four directions within three to five minutes of that property. We have Walmarts, Targets, hotels on 95, hotels along US-1, strip malls. We don't need any more. We need our protected lands. We need to keep industry there for our youth. You have five criteria deciding rezoning permits. From what we can see and from what we gathered, and we looked very carefully, not one of those five areas meet the criteria, not one of five. And two are in really bad shape when you talk of water and traffic. Please deny this zoning change.
Okay, thank you. Anyone else want to speak for or against this item? Sir, you stood up first. Hold on one second there.
Take your time.
If you could just state your name and spell your last name for the record, please, sir.
My name is Robert. My last name is Ouellette. That's O-U-E-L-L-E-T-T-E. I have property and a house at 5625 Barna Avenue that I built in 1979. The map that I have here shows this area is all less than 20 feet. The only areas that are above 20 feet are this area here and some dots in there. This is part of what they call an Anastasia bubble. The city of Titusville has a well field down here. They have wells all up and down Barna Avenue and on Sisson Road. They're taking water out of this. They wanted 3 million gallons a day. They can't get that. Now, the difference between an Anastasia aquifer and an Anastasia bubble is the water that's in the bubble is less than 50 years old, whereas in an aquifer it could be hundreds or even thousands of years old. So, this is being recharged as we sit here due to these rains. And the only area that I can see, like I said, was the area on Barna. There's a sand ridge that runs up there that's 50 feet tall. And unless they're going to push some of that into the other area, I don't see where they're going to get, as they stated, 32 acres of land that they could develop. Okay. Is that it? Primarily, that's it. I only found out about this last night, so I didn't have much time to prepare. I was at the doctor's all morning. So, anyway, that's what I've got. Thank you. All right. Thank you, sir.
Sir in the blue shirt.
My name is Mike Carter. Last name C-A-R-T-E-R. I live on 5675 Barna Avenue. I have a picture here I want you all to see. My yard is a flag lot, which the property they're talking about is my line. I want you all to see this right here. Can you all see this? This water is less than 100 feet from my door. Vard County. Vard County. I went to the county. I've got an email from them. This property, all this property back here, has no drainage. Nowhere. No drainage ditches. Can't even leave the area. This has been going on for 15 years. I went to the city. The city said it was the county's problem. I went to the county twice. The county said it was not their problem because it's wetlands. And they sent me to St. John's River Water Management. And they said the only thing they take care of is roadways. My stepfather, 20 years ago, called Tallahassee the state. And they sent people over to look at this property back here. It is wetlands. Non-buildable property. Because the water probably has been going on the road for 20 years. There's no drainage. Can't go anywhere. That's what my backyard looks like today. Half of my property. It's got nowhere to go. So if you develop this area, all this water is going to go in my house and have some pieces of houses sitting in here. Thank you. All right.
Thank you. Yes, sir. Come on up.
Good afternoon. My name is Gerald Lebeau. L-E-B-E-A-U. I live at 5730 Barna Avenue. I want to speak about what I believe is a proposal to put a hotel on this property. I'd like to point out that nowhere along the 75 miles of the I-95 corridor that runs through Brevard County are there any hotels of the size and magnitude that is being proposed for this site that are any further than roughly a half a mile away from the interchange. This site is located two miles from the nearest interchange. There are currently several vacant buildable sites within the half mile distance of the 95 Highway 50 interchange to allow this type of a project to move forward in. If you allow this kind of change to go through, I think it will be setting a first-time precedent that it could open the floodgates and create ramifications for dozens of residential communities across Brevard County. Thank you. All right. Thank you, sir.
Anybody else want to speak for or against this item? Okay, because I'm fixing to close it to public comment.
We had questions that we submitted. When do we get to address those? They're all on everybody's envelope. I put them in order.
Go ahead, Ms. Jane.
Are you looking for a response from the Planning and Zoning Board or from staff?
So when do we get to address our questions?
So if you would like to submit that to staff, and then we can look into those questions.
Well, that's what we did. We submitted them here. That's what we were told to bring our questions.
So we never received them in advance in order to prepare answers for you. So bringing them today, are you looking for a response from the Planning and Zoning Board or are you looking for responses from staff?
Well, when I called, they told us to bring 10 to 11 packets with our concerns and our questions and present them, which is what we did.
Well, I can respond to that, staff and counsel, if you want to jump in, the legalities here. But, I mean, we don't actually address questions on the way down. I mean, we're just a Planning and Zoning Board, and this is about zoning, and that's what we're doing.
So, yeah, if I could just add to that, Mr. Chair, so staff's received the application. They've reviewed it for compliance with our Code and Comprehensive Plan. That staff report's been provided to this board here. It sounds like you've presented some additional questions that you all would like answered. That's something that staff can consider between now and when the Board of County Commissioners has their meeting, which is going to be on December 10th.
So, can we get answers to those questions prior to that vote so we have something to come back with to our County Commissioners? I mean, we have to get those questions answered to be able to write them. I mean, those are questions from your staff reports. We went through your staff reports, and we had questions based on what your staff found.
Okay, and if that's the case, then I believe staff has those questions now. And if we need to shore up or address those in an updated addenda or something along those lines for the Board, then that will take place between now and the Board meeting. But you have to give us the opportunity to review them and consider them and address them.
So, who do I get back with, then? What's a good time? What's, like, an appropriate time?
We can probably talk to you offline, maybe, and then we can give you some contact information. Okay. And then if you want to disseminate it with your folks. Thank you. Sure.
See, the County Commissioners are going to make the final decision on this, not us. We're just going to – hold on now. We've given everyone out there a chance to talk. We're not going to talk no more. We've closed it to public comment, and now we're going to come back, and we're going to get the applicant. And he's got all his notes where everyone spoke, and he's going to try to answer some of them questions. I hope I'm not putting words in your mouth. I'm going to try. Okay. Okay. But thank you all. Okay, sir.
Yes, sir. Thank you. First, to address a lot of the generalized concerns that were brought up regarding, you know, the flooding and the drainage and the traffic and the lighting, those are all site plan-specific comments. That's not zoning-specific comments. We're committed to meet all of those standards of, you know, every level of government that we have to. I mean, it's easy to commit to something you've got to do. So we plan to, you know, address all any concerns at that time once we know what the actual footprint's going to be, what the impacts are going to be. There has been an endangered species study done. I think there was one or two gopher tortoises identified. If those end up being in an impacted area, they will be mitigated under the county and state's rules that allow for such. So we know that, and the developers committed to making that effort. You have to. Again, we have to. You know, there were a lot of comments on the rezoning all of this property from PIP to commercial. We don't want all this commercial, this BU-1 commercial. Well, BU-1 uses are permitted uses within the PIP zoning district already, I believe. So we're really not changing a lot of the permitted uses that are allowed there. It's just cleaning up this zoning district that was put in place back in, I think it was 1988, when the original zoning was done. And what's changed is, obviously, we've all witnessed the aerospace job growth. That area is developing differently than it was in 1988. We've got residential apartments on the other side. You've got the new Wawa. Titusville just approved 450 acres of their planned industrial zoning, you know, a mile or two up the road. So this concern of losing this industrial zoning, I think, has been ameliorated by the fact that there have been large chunks that the Tyco Airport has made available for that type of development. And the reason, let me see if I can figure out how to scroll back to the map. And if I break this, apologies, I'm usually not allowed to touch computers. Okay. So if you look at the map, the left and the right, the left is the current zoning, and you'll see that there already is the BU-1 allowed along Barna. And there are no access restrictions there today. And you see the vast majority of what is being changed from PIP to BU-1 is that area that connects through the existing BU-1. And we're shrinking the RU, gosh, my eyes, the RU-210 smaller to provide that transitionary buffer as the planner has testified. So we're keeping that transition of medium-density zoning residential between the single family and the already existing commercial properties that are there with no access restrictions. We do believe we meet the 40-acre test because we're at two intersections, and it's a permissive standard of should on one intersection. We're at 47 acres on two intersections. And, again, it's not even a requirement to stay at 40 or below at one intersection anyway. You know, otherwise, let me see if there were any other major concerns, but those, you know, those were the main ones. We do believe, agree with the staff report that this is, the character has changed. We do believe we've stated why on the record. And, you know, we're here to address any concerns that you have. We do have our engineers, traffic, et cetera. We know we'll be doing a full traffic impact analysis at the time of site plan when we know what's actually being built. And we'll meet the standards that are required at that time. And apologies for you guys over there. I'm just not used to having the board members sitting on that side. So apologies for not looking your direction during the conversation.
All right. So hearing that, I bring it back to the board. Does anyone have some questions for the applicant?
Mr. Chair.
Yes, ma'am. Mr. Tracy.
Can you explain what projects that you are looking to actually put in this property?
Yeah, we're hopeful that there will be a grocery store with some of the retail that goes in front of it to serve this public that has been growing up around here with the apartments on the other side of the street, the ones that are coming in up on US-1 with the tranquility development and the growth of the area with the planned industrial developments that are coming in in the Tyco area. You know, so it'll be a mix of townhomes or single family along what's remaining as the RU-210 and your BU-1 uses, which are hotel, grocery store, commercial retail that will go in front of it.
Okay. And you mentioned the gopher tortoise, but has there actually been an environmental impact study completed on the totality of the property?
I don't believe there's been an environmental impact study yet. That would come as we go through the site planning process, but we do know we will be getting one.
Okay. And BDP, the status on that in your group?
We would not like to at this point because we're still trying to figure out who the end customers will be. And the binding development plan, we don't want to be locked into that at this time. Okay.
Thank you. All right. Mr. Eric. Existing zoning map. Is there any development on that land yet? No, sir. Not yet. Okay. Is there a site plan of some sort of what's going to go there? I mean, why are you expanding before you develop that piece that you already have?
There's conceptuals of what we would like to do, but until the market answers, you know, is there a demand for it, we do not know for sure.
So why are you expanding if you haven't even decided what the market is?
Because this would meet the depth of what the commercial shopping, not shopping centers, but your grocery store anchored centers require for their depth in order to get a shopping center with the sufficient parking and the truck movements and stuff that you would need.
And finally, if you were just to generally address 80, 70 percent of the concerns that you heard about water, what's your answer to that?
That we intend to absolutely meet all the engineering standards required to hold all of our water on our site.
Mr. Henry. You know, I just got a couple, but is your site aligned with both 407 as far as signalization, et cetera? So there's some potential you could put a light there?
I mean, I believe that the 407 and 405 is signalized there. And if you look at the map, this, sorry if I broke the map.
I think it's a T-intersection treatment now, isn't it?
Yeah, this is the FDOT intersection already with the wide sweeping turn. So that is already public right away in that kind of egg-shaped area. So we believe that we could have access there with a line with this light. And I believe there's already a light here at the Barna intersection. And FDOT has requested that we have access on the Barna for safety concerns by removing at least some of the traffic off of an arterial roadway.
So technically or theoretically, you could maybe make some improvements if something happened.
We believe it will improve the intersection personally. But, you know, we concur with the staff support that there's capacity in the roadways as is for the development.
You know, I'm just going to mention one thing. I mean, this board, I think we have a tendency to want more data than applicants can provide. And I am very – I've been here a long time. And there's no way, as loose as we get sometimes here – I know that language a little bit. But that we could ever require you guys to go through the gyration, you'll spend a lot of money just to show something. And we could say, well, we don't like it. And that's – I hope we never get to that. But it's just nobody can afford to do it, even if you put a trailer park in. It's just – I think we have a tendency to get a little loose there. On the water retention side, I think your requirements are going to be significant. So you're going to probably have a pond of some magnitude there. I mean –
I presume it would be a very large pond. You know, I am not an engineer. I've barely got out of grade school with math.
If anything, it's got to help some of the – maybe some of the people on Borna.
I think that, again, not being an engineer, I believe that we'll be able to hold all the water as needed, or we just can't build the project. I know Mr. Weisworth makes fun of me because I'm committing to something that's required by law, but we know we're going to meet it, and we're prepared to do what we have to do.
You're going to be required to. That's correct. So those are only a couple things I have.
And by doing that, too, though, you're going to relieve a lot of the surrounding areas.
I can't make that commitment. I'm not an engineer. I would presume that it would provide benefit.
Okay, Mr. Jordan. Okay. I've been listening to everyone, and I can tell you we're actually taking the cart before the horse. Everything that the neighbors were talking about is going to be taken care of later on. He's only asking for a rezoning. And I'm going to try to be clear so everybody can understand because I hear you, and I hear my neighbors because I get standing water also in Titusville. And my business actually is across the street from all of this. But once we make our decision and say, yeah, we're okay with the rezoning, it has to go to the county commission. Correct. Remember that. They're the final vote. We're not the final vote. We're just basically giving them our opinion based on what we hear. Every question that you had is going to be answered one way or the other based on what happens next. And what happens next is if the zoning goes through, then the next thing, he has to do a site plan. The site plan consists of the building location, the parking, the access drives, the landscaping, the lighting, the stormwater facilities, and the utilities. Okay? That's the site plan. The next thing, someone was talking about gopher tortoises, and I don't think anybody said anything about these. Scrub jays. Scrub jays, yeah. I knew all about those things for sure. And by the way, I'm a civil engineer too, so I know a little bit. I was listening to the young engineer there and appreciate you being here for sure. Data is important. I promise you. But then you have to do the environmental review, and of course, as Brevard County Environmental Resource Management reviews the project for wetlands, protected species, stormwater requirements, shoreline impacts, and natural resources. Then, if there's any kind of subdivision approval, if he creates lots, then, of course, the property has to be divided, and you have to get approval for that. Then we go into the utility and infrastructure approval. And then, of course, what I love is the impact fees. I like my developers to pay for some of this stuff for sure. And then you have to do the building permit. So there's a lot of stuff that has to happen after this. I hope that staff will definitely try to answer all those questions before you get to the county commission. But if they don't, there's still all of these other things that the developer has to do before they can build for sure. The guy who had all the standing water, you've got to feel for him because that's ridiculous. Absolutely. It's totally ridiculous to have that kind of water. But I'm going to be honest with you. You know, I believe in people having the right to develop their land. If you're living in development now, which you are, I'm very familiar with that area. That was a development. And, of course, if that development didn't happen, you wouldn't have a home. And then you wouldn't have a chance to come here and complain about another developer wanting to build on their land. So I hope I explained it well enough so you can understand there's a whole lot more that this person has to do. If we give him permission today, that is not going to give him carte blanche to do anything except go to the next level. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Correct. Thank you, Mr. Jordan. Thank you, Mr. Brothers. Yes, sir. Mr. Brothers.
Do not get this as if it is zoned. Possibly an industrial park or one of the other zonings that you could do, which an industrial park would be a lot less desirable than a shopping center.
You know, I'm not sure that my client would, but the underlying landowner does, I believe, have other offers out there that may use it for whatever purposes are allowed under law now. And, again, I'd reiterate the prior comment that the BU-1 uses, which is the majority of this rezoning application, are already allowed in the PIP zoning districts, I believe. So I think it would be the same thing for the most part. There may be a little sliver less on the RU-210 that gets rezoned, just to be totally honest. Mr. Chairman.
Mr. Jordan. Can we do this together? We can. I heard what you said. All right. I move that we approve H-1.
Mr. Chairman.
Yes, sir. Mr. Rowan.
I had a question before we proceed. All right. Can you hold that motion? One second. You're the chairman. Do you plan to have any affordable housing in these multifamily units?
I don't believe that the intent is to develop any of the affordable housing as is defined under the Live Local or any of the different financing mechanisms out there through the state. This would be a garden market-style, market-rent-garden-apartment-style project, is my understanding, if, in fact, an apartment developer doesn't decide to go here.
Would you be willing to have a BDP that limits the multifamily to 320 units?
I'd have to address that with my client. But I think if I could have just a second to speak with them, I could ask. But at this time, if that's the only condition of it, we might be able to get somewhere in there. But I'm not sure it would be the 320, just given the fact that it's 70-plus acres of land in total.
My concern was when I looked at that, I see a whole lot of BU-1, which under Live Local then could be developed into affordable housing.
I believe under the PIP, it would do as well as an industrial district.
Yeah, and that would create traffic problems, I think, even far worse than what you're talking about. So I'm very concerned about that.
One brief second on that question.
Good afternoon. My name is Tony Benj, B-E-N-G-E. I'm the president of Benj Development. Relating to your question, we did look at that analysis, and I'll be off, but roughly I think it was over 950 units that could be done under Live Local. We would agree not to pursue that number at all. We think that would be catastrophically bad to have that many units at this location. I can easily commit right now to go half that as a max, and I think we'll still fall well below that even as a – We developed the property across the street as well, where we're currently doing two phases of multifamily, which was a four-story urban product that was surface parked. We see something very similar to that going here, and I believe across the street on both phases was 550 units roughly. So you're looking at somewhere between – we'll round a little bit and say 300 is roughly what we think the market will tolerate there. But, again, we like to give ourselves a little bit of leeway. Again, this is the first step, as the gentleman was saying. Before we can approach retailers and everything else, they want to know they have the right to build this there before they'll take it through any of their committees or give it any serious consideration. If we go to them and say, hey, we think we can get this rezoned, they literally look at you like, call me back when it's rezoned. We're wasting my time. If we were to leave it as it is now with the dimensions of the property, you end up getting the second and third or even fourth tier retailers and users. Everybody – if you think of a grocery-anchored center, everybody has the one Florida-based group they love, and if your pad does not accommodate their footprint, they don't come. It makes it that simple. We're trying to set the table for success to have the best possible users, the highest quality, much as we demonstrated from across the street. We are – you know, we are investing millions in this community. The last thing we want to do is do something that is adverse to the community. Go ahead. Thank you.
So you would be willing to have a BDP of, say, limit to 400? Would that be adequate?
I believe he said half. How about 450, we called it. 450? And the only reason I say this is we really have not gotten that far in the planning. Yet, of just – but I know anything more than that, just – I could see the problems that it would generate, so that's a very easy, off-the-cuff, sure, 450, no problem. Okay. Won't exceed that.
Thank you. Mr. Ron, you good?
I had a couple more – or another question. When I looked at the survey, it looks like there's an awful lot of wetlands in the area that you intend to develop. How are you going to address that situation?
There would be a mitigation study done, and it is on a mitigation-qualified roadway. And so we'd have to analyze the wetlands, their quality, and then we'd come through again with what's called a public interest determination and have to prove that the mitigation of the wetland is in the public interest.
Explain what mitigation is.
There's a couple of levels to it. So there's both on-site and off-site mitigation. There's different components. So the environment has come in. They score the wetlands on a score of, I believe, 1 to 10 or technically 0 to 1 per acre. And they, through various different criteria, they come up with a number and say you need three credits in order to do this. And those three credits can either be done on-site through conservation on-site, wetland restoration on-site, invasive species removal, a variety of different mechanisms to provide on-site lift to get a portion of those. And then once you prove that you can't do it on-site, then you can go to an off-site mitigation strategy, which can either be through a mitigation or other property that is under the control of the developer. And you do the same analysis there on lifts. So essentially you end up with no environmental loss, no net loss. It's a standard that you have to meet in the mitigation.
Okay.
And those are basin-specific.
Okay. I just wanted to be sure everybody else understood what mitigation was. We throw that word around, and it sounds like, oh, that's a great thing. But for some things it's not.
Are you good, Mr. Rohn? Yes. Okay, Mr. Jordan. Mr. Chairman. I'm going to drop it for discussion because he was going to make a motion. I wanted to make a comment.
Go ahead, sir. Although I recognize Mr. Jordan ready to accept it, I just want to say for the record that I'm not going to go for it only because of the reason that, and it may be not the petitioners for it, maybe the way that Brevard County does zoning, you know, preliminary approvals, is that to me it's too speculative. We have no idea, not even a draft of an idea of what's going to happen in this place. They're not required to have that. I understand that, and for that reason, I'm not comfortable.
Thank you.
Okay. Mr. Jordan.
Okay. I'm going to respect what you just said, but the process takes care of that. And I understand what you're saying, but we would like to have, you know, the whole Bible in front of us to say this is exactly what's going to happen if we rezone, but that's not the process. And it takes a long time and a lot of money to do that. So that being said, I would like to move for approval for H-1, requesting a small-scale comprehensive plan amendment to change a future land use map from planned industrial and residential 15 to community commercial. Yeah, I'll second that.
I think you beat him, couldn't you? I don't. Okay, on item H-1, we've got a motion by Jordan, a second by Deb. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Opposed. We have Tracy and Mr. Eric.
We get it, staff? I thought I heard three nays. Was that Mr. Wise as well? Okay. I'm sorry. I didn't get that, Robert.
Okay, Mr. Jordan, item H-2. Okay.
I move for approval, but I was looking for staff. Tell me where the staff requirement, request about a BDP.
There's a recommendation at the end of the staff report for the rezoning under the board consideration. The board may wish to consider for the parties to voluntarily agree to a binding development plan condition that would prohibit access to Barna Avenue from the commercial and multifamily portions of the development to further address the locational criteria intent of policy 2.8A.
And for purposes of the record and Senate Bill 180, we are voluntarily agreeing to a BDP, limiting it to 450 residential units in the multifamily.
Okay. That's my motion.
And I'll second it.
You're agreeing to the BDP for the 450 units, but not for the restriction of the commercial access off of Barna?
Yes, sir. That's correct.
Thank you. Okay. Do you need him to clarify his motion?
The recommendation?
I'm going with the recommendation of staff.
With the 450. The recommendation of staff was prohibiting the access to Barna. Are you not agreeing to that? We can't agree to that. FDOT has requested it onto the Barna for safety concerns in our pre-app meetings, and we already have access there now through both the community commercial and the RU210 zoning as it stands today.
Okay. Well, you've got to abide by the law, right? All right. But I like the reduced units. I think Ron was talking about that, right?
So that would be my motion. Okay. Item H2, a motion by Jordan, a second by Debbie. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Mr. Wise, are you opposing? Okay. Just you, Tracy? Yes, sir. And Eric's abstaining.
What's the basis for the abstention? You either have to vote or there has to be a reason why there's a conflict, so.
Well, it's to do it.
So you vote no, then? There has to be a reason to abstain, so. I'm sorry I cut you off there. I cut you off. I'm sorry. I just didn't hear the end there. So you're either voting for it or against it, or is there a reason for an abstention?
If I can, if it doesn't make sense the way I'm abstaining because I was in denial of the original plan, then I'll vote to deny if you can't abstain. Okay. Thank you.
All right. Thank you, sir. Thank you, sir. And to everyone that spoke on this item, it's going in front of, we're an advisory board. We're not the county commissioners. The county commissioners are going to make the final decision on this, and so hopefully by then you can get with staff and get some answers for some of your questions. All right.
Well, hopefully it doesn't give us much, but I'd like a yes or a no. We'll get our questions answered. It would be nice.
Okay. Item H3.
Mrs. Hessler. Can you come? Mrs. Hessler? Ma'am. Come over here.
Okay. Item H3. TCLM Incorporated. Aaron D. Lyons, representing, is requesting a CUP for outside consumption of alcohol, 26Z00039 in District 1.
Is the applicant here? Here they come. Sir, if you could state your name and spell your last name for the record.
Yes. My name is Thomas Miller, M-I-L-L-E-R. I'm the president of TCLM, Inc. Hello, members of the Planning and Zoning Board. This all begins... You're going to have to get near that microphone. Okay. I'm sorry. There you are. This all begins back in the summer of 2006 when I came to the county to ask what was required to put a deck on the side of my building and install a door to access a deck so that we could relocate some of our seating outdoors so we can make the indoor smoke-free. I had sketches of the proposed work and discussed this with Elena Scruggs from Planning and Zoning and Yolanda Epidaka from Perdemiti. I still have their business cards. They informed me that the deck did not need a permit because it was elevated, it was not elevated, and it was not attached to the building. They also stated that the seats from the inside being moved to the outside did not increase our capacity, so nothing else was required there. They did, however, say that a permit was required for the door because it was a structural issue through the side of the building and required engineering drawings and certifications for the door. There was never anything mentioned about having a conditional use permit for the deck. We did what they asked for and obtained the permit and the door was completed and the deck was completed and the county signed off on it. Now, over the last 20 years, we've been using the deck without issue. The fire department has been inspecting and counting our seating capacity, including the seating outside. Our seating capacity has not changed from the time we purchased Pintos almost 30 years ago. And for the last 20 years, the outside deck and seating here has been beneficial to the community. We've had numerous benefits, celebrations of life for the people in our community. The people in our community support us, so we support our community. We have raised and donated tens of thousands of dollars for the community. We partner with Toys for Tots every year. Last year, we filled from the community donations over six Toys for Tots boxes along with 14 bicycles. So if we are in violation, then this responsibility lies solely on the county for being neglectful and guiding me when I requested what was required back in 2006. So respectfully request that the common sense prevail and that this conditional use permit be approved without any restrictions on our outdoor seating. Thank you. And my lawyer is going to continue.
Aaron Lyons for the petitioner. I'm not going to go through the whole application. The important part is that we have agreed that the outdoor area is not intended to increase the capacity. Capacity is at 75, which is the interior. People don't go to the outside area to be seated. They go out there to take their drink and smoke a cigarette, which is what they've done for the last 20 years. The calculation of the area, the square footage that's used to determine the number of parking places, that's not particularly well defined, but elsewhere and arguably the intention is within the walls. And this deck is a floating deck, not attached to the building, so it's not even an extension of the building. It's just an additional deck. So, all of that said, we request that the planning and zoning make a recommendation to the board to pass our application.
All right. Well, you're right there. Is there anyone in the audience want to speak for or against this item? Sir, if you could take a seat real quick. Ma'am, would you like to start it off? If you could just state your name, spell your last name for the record.
Thank you. It's Catherine Jones, J-O-N-E-S. I represent over 8,000 people that have visited Titusville and that have resided in Titusville. Alice said I could hand this out to you guys. Unfortunately, what was not disclosed is that this deck, and I have a presentation here, is not being used to what has been discussed in 2006. It's being used to extend a music venue and outdoor seating for drinking. And, in fact, I have there pictures of an outdoor bar service. A waitress stays out there with all the alcohol, the seating. The capacity does exceed routinely. And, in fact, when code enforcement went out to review, they recommended to remove it. And then, if you see on second page here, that still has not been adhered to. So what you have is, back in 1991, a CUP was issued for an indoor license. That institution was a quiet, indoor, daytime restaurant, which we welcome. That's nice. What's happened is, 10 years later, the current ownership wanted to make more money and expand their outdoor music venue as well as indoor music venue. And the noise level has routinely daily plagued us. We've lost money. I've tried to install a fence to help with the cause. And I just want to share with you, I worked with Logan on this, but bear with me here. I'm going to see if it plays for me here. Is Logan available? He was able to get it up and running for me. I apologize.
Try double-clicking. Be right there.
Thank you. I apologize. And this all is evidence taken off the Facebook page. In fact, Pinto's Lounge brags how they are the music venue of the area, alcohol. And so, one thing that was not disclosed is repeated years of disregard for code enforcement. And fines mean nothing. They aren't being issued. So, not only has there been repeated abuse of that original CUP, the outdoor alcohol consumption, the bar installed, the noise levels day and night are excessive, and I'm about to show you. Um, we've had, um, parking spots on the grass, uh, and all, et cetera. And so, yeah, thank you, Logan. I apologize.
It's actually probably a control click. Let's try that.
They were bragging how packed inside and out was. And this is routinely day and night for us. And if you see here, our fence is right here. It's 10 feet. Sorry. It's 10 feet away from our motel rooms. And mind you, our motel was built 80 years ago. We've been established for a long time. It's like a historical place. And 10 feet away, this was built. Let me just share with you one more video. I, I don't have a lot of, uh, people.
I'm going to give you one more minute because we had issues there.
Okay. Okay. The next video. I appreciate it. The dark. Yeah, there you go. And these noise levels, um, are happening when people open and close doors. Um, and essentially we've lost business because of this, um, and the original CUP is not being honored. All these ordinances are being ignored. And in fact, code enforcement has tried to ask them and nothing has happened. Um, if you issue this new CUP, then I've lost my, my life savings in our business and our family. Um, I also would recommend why isn't the original CUP being honored? Why aren't fines being acknowledged? And I believe they're making more money to enjoy breaking these ordinances. And I ask that we revoke the original CUP unless they change and started hearing to ordinances. Thank you for your time.
Okay. Thank you. Anyone else want to speak for or against this? Ma'am, come on up. And if you would state your name, spell your last name.
Yes. Thank you. I'm Jessica Jones, J-O-N-E-S. And I've actually been a Brevard County resident my entire life. I was born and raised here on the Space Coast. So I love this county. Um, it's not a matter of not having fun. We understand this is great for their business, but it's intruding and it's breaking the law and intruding on our own. So I'd like to just share that the seven last or the last seven years has shown that no fines could be realistically collected. And all current fine structures are small compared to the double of revenue that TCLM has collected from non-conforming use of the original 1991 CUP. Looking at Section 62-1901D of the county code, TCLM's abuse of the ordinances is a perfect example of how the original 1991 CUP needs to be revoked. TCLM has had over seven years of adequate opportunity to correct delinquent activity. TCLM has failed to comply with any of the conditions and restrictions imposed in the 1991 CUP. TCLM created an unforeseen negative impact. Again, as Catherine said, the continuous noise that causes substantial and adverse effects on the general health, safety, and welfare of adjoining and nearby property owners and residents. Does the travel inn of Titusville, which has been there for decades, no longer have a right to provide a comfortable and quiet room for its guests? As a small family business owner of a historical motel, are we supposed to just let Pintos keep expanding more and more, getting louder and louder, serving more and more alcohol, disturbing the guests who have paid good money to have a good night's sleep? They have moved their alcohol service outside and are playing raucous music just 10 feet away from the travel inn of Titusville until 2 a.m. and throughout the day. The noise can be heard 500 feet away, and as has been shown, thousands of dollars has been spent on a wall.
Okay. Thank you, ma'am. Ma'am, come on up.
Can you hear me okay?
Name and spell your last name for the record.
Sure. Helm, H-E-L-M. I'm also born and raised in Brevard County. I do the booking of the entertainment for Pintos Lounge, and some of the statements that were made are non-factual. We do not have full bands outside on the deck, ever. We have solos and duos, and we have an open jam where individual musicians and singers come, and they showcase their talents, get comfortable with it. Do people go outside and sit and drink and smoke and sit there long and listen to that? Absolutely do. We do that during football season because inside our patrons are watching football, and they don't want to hear music as well. Band-wise, we have decimal readers that we use inside, so there is no disturbance, and the tenants of that motel come over and eat and drink with us and say what a great place it is and that they don't hear any noise from their motel rooms. So, I don't understand, sincerely, the concern that's being expressed here, and I adamantly disagree with it. The video that she showed you with the full deck of people, that was a benefit. That was three bands playing for our friend Jack Nowling, who passed away, and we raised money for his daughter to bury him. That's what that video is. So, I just wanted to share that with you, and I do not agree with her position.
Okay. Thank you. Anyone left? Sir, if you want to come up.
Hi, I'm Ben Nettleton, and I reside at 101 May Drive. I own the nine-acre flag lot behind Pinto's Bar. I'm a physician at the VA. I have concerns. First of all, I'll say that what Catherine Jones, the owner of the motel, has said is true and accurate, the noise can be heard at least a quarter mile of a way. That's how far my house is. I hear it down there all the time. There's, you know, it frequently goes till one or two in the morning. I don't know how many people play in these bands, but there was a time before I realized what was happening. For months, I kept hearing this loud music, and I was looking around trying to figure out where this major music festival was. I figured there must have been some fairgrounds nearby or something. I feel kind of foolish for not realizing it was coming from Pinto's, but it was indeed. And I believe that the owners of Pinto's have not shown any respect for the community, which is why I'm here opposing this. I don't think that promoting the expansion of a bar that has, it's not bursting at its seams, it has already burst at seams. I think all of you drive by on US1, if you pay attention, there's times when, even in the middle of the afternoon, long before the evening, there's not a single parking spot left there. Drunk people do come out. People have died because of drunks coming out of that bar in the past. My neighbor Jim was ill. He couldn't be here tonight. But he just told me he's woke up at one or two o'clock in the morning with motorcycles riving. And I respect people's desire to have fun. But that fun should not come at the expense of others. And if they're going to expand the bar in the face of noise ordinances that are not being enforced, that's a problem to me. I think that any conditional use permit should state that they have to stop selling alcohol at 10 p.m. I think that would go a long ways towards resolving it. And the burden of proof towards proving that that is being observed should be based on them. Thank you. Thank you, sir.
Anyone else in the audience want to speak for or against this? Ma'am, if you could just state your name, spell your last name.
Kayla, J-O-R-D-A-N.
Okay.
My name is Kayla. I am opposed to the CUP request by TCLM for outdoor alcohol sales. As a neighbor living next door to Pinto's and manager at the Travel Inn of Titusville, I have seen so much harassment and danger from TCLM. Guests who start to check in and hear the loud noise and see drunk patrons passed out on the grass of our frontage area asked to cancel and refund for fear of safety. This has occurred several times. Guest reviews and complaints that they weren't able to sleep are extensive and have had a financial impact on the motel business as I hear about the chargebacks. Those reviews have discouraged potential customers. We have guests demanding refunds because of the noise. The live music, outdoor speakers, and drunken guests yelling and sitting outside can be heard at my house, which is over 100 feet away. This is all night sometimes to 2 a.m. On Sundays, they have karaoke and amplifying speakers outside. The noise from yelling patrons and thumping bass is such a difference to sleep for them. We've had drunk patrons threaten our cleaning crew to get on the ground after they were disgruntled from the veterans event being allegedly canceled by our motel. We've had examples of drunk Pinto's patrons wandering to our occupied motel room and peeing in front of a doorstep where we had to give a full refund for the suite. We get law enforcement pulling over DUI suspects in our parking lot, several cars flashing lights scaring our patrons. The Pinto's parking lot is also on the U.S. highway shoulder. The stretch of U.S. 1 is one of the most dangerous stretches of the road in the county. The TLCM owner and a patron were confrontational in the past with me from their outdoor bar area, and the patron yelled obscenities at me while with my 7-month-old baby.
Thank you, ma'am. Sir, did you want to come up and speak?
I do.
Take your time. Take your time.
I apologize for the crippledness, but I'm just here on behalf of my good friends. Could you get just a little closer to that microphone? I'm here on behalf of my, in support of my good friends. I'll need your name and address, spell your last name for the record. It's Robert, B-R-O-Z-M-A-N, Brosman. I've been a business owner in Brevard County. I've been here since 72, most of my life. And Pinto's actually ran in, the bar itself was my ex-wife's aunt owned that before it was even Pinto's. So it's not changed anything in all this time. So what we really don't know is that my friends have been harassed by the people who bought the motel. They didn't even like their sign, but it's been there forever. They don't, it's too close to the highway. They put a camera up on the fence just to harass them. I don't think they're doing anything besides providing, you know, a good place to go outside and enjoy the outside rather than the inside as far as that goes. So for what it's worth, I don't think they're changing anything that they've been doing for 20 years. So I think they're being harassed by the neighbor, and I think you should know that. That's why I'm here.
All right. Thank you, sir. Anyone else want to speak for or against this? One second, ma'am.
I'm DeAngelis, D-E-A-N-G-E-L-I-S, 4245 Lee Hall Place, Cocoa, Florida. I've been a resident for 41 years. Obviously here to, you know, promote our friends to continue with this, you know, getting the CUP. They're an asset to the community. Some of the things they've done have gone beyond recognition with benefits, and it's almost like the noise these people are talking about or during those functions. It'd be like I live next to an empty lot, and it's quiet. When the circus comes to town, I've got to put up with it for a day. So it's not a continual thing. It's for the good of the community. They're an asset. They've been there for over 30 years, and I'd like to see them to continue to run the business the way they run, which is professional, and that's what we're here to promote. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, sir.
Okay, ma'am, if you'd like to come up.
Cindy McGowan, M-C-G-O-W-A-N, and I come as a resident 500 or less feet away from Pintos on Bonita Street, 157. I come to object to the change in zoning classification for Pintos, and the main reason is nighttime noise and music that I can hear in my house. And there's been – I bought the house back in 98, and summertime, I always find that it's loudest then when you're not inside at night. But I can hear it at night in the dead of night when they're outside playing the music, and I have two concerns. It's really the excessive noise and the privacy of people leaving Pintos or walking around, and you can see them in my backyard sometimes on the roadway. So it's kind of a highly residential area there. There was a lot of side roads, and a lot of people impacted with the noise. But there's danger with US-1 out there, too, with a lot of cars coming out. But I appreciate having a good time, same as the others, but not at the expense of the neighborhood there.
Okay.
Yeah, okay.
All right. Thank you, ma'am.
Okay, thank you.
If you'd like to come up, we know the drill now, right?
Ah, sort of. I'm a little short, so I'll move it a little lower. But I'm Jen Redman, R-E-D-M-A-N. I've worked for Pintos for five and a half years. Absolutely adore the place. The owners are amazing. The amount of – their hearts are so big. They do so much for the community. And the events that they're talking about, the harassment, the calls, the cops being called when there's absolutely nobody in there at 1 o'clock, and it's quiet, and they come in, and they're like, why are we even called? You're taking away resources when they should be on the road, taking care of other people, instead of calling on us when there's nothing going on. And it's been multiple times. The cameras that are watching us is insane. And the amount of stuff that Pintos does for the community is just amazing. I'm shaking. I'm just so like, oh, my God, because, wow, I just can't believe this right now. And I think it should be expanded. I think they do enough for the community. And so many things that people don't even know about, I hear from customers all the time, and they're not trying to get a pat on the back. It's just things that I find out through customers that the owners have done for them from a loss or losing a job or whatever it may be and how they take care of everybody. It's an awesome place. I'm pretty sure I've seen you in there getting food, too, so thank you.
All right. Thank you. Anyone else want to speak for? Ma'am, come on up. Hello.
My name is Michelle Nesworthy, N-E-S-W-O-R-T-H-Y. I've been in Varne County 55 years. I have known the owners for a little over seven years. I have attended many of the events. I am not a typical bar attendee. I go to the fundraisers. I bring money. I have known this deck that they're referring to before it ever had chairs on it. It literally was just a board, and it was meant to give us an area to go smoking, and nobody used it until we made the inside venue non-smoking. And if you know any smokers, if you drink, you probably are smoking. So the way we were getting rid of all the smokers inside was to give them a seating area on the outside. I have never seen any alcohol being served outside unless there was a very special event or one Sunday a month where we have an open jam. It's a very small speaker setup. I can understand that there might be a noise ordinance violation. I am only standing here to also tell you that I have witnessed the owners repeatedly encourage the staff and put up signs to make sure that none of the doors are open during the venues that are inside. So if they have an event inside where they're hosting live music on their stage inside, they are literally encouraging the staff, keep the door closed, keep the door closed, keep the door closed. There are signs on the door to keep the door closed. I can understand if there is a noise issue, but we are not increasing the capacity because you'll see when you come to these events, like if we have open jam and we have a couple musicians outside, they're really a very small. It's not a full – they're not allowed to bring in drums. They're not allowed to bring in big speakers. It's very small, and they aim it away from the – sorry. Thank you. Thank you.
Anyone else want to speak for or against this? If not, I'm going to close it for public comment. I don't see any hands, so I'm going to close it for public comment. If you all could come back up to the podium here, please.
Okay. I'd like to address all the concerns that you've heard here. First off, yes, there is music outside on Sundays from 3 to 7. That's when we have the music on the deck. Okay. Other than that, there is no music out on the deck. There is a TV out there for the sports fans and whatnot. As far as the noise level goes, we have not been ignoring code enforcement. We have not been ignoring the sheriff's department. They have come out with their decibel meters, and I have a decibel meter myself. Okay. And we go stand in their parking lot, and the readings are supposed to be under 65 up until 10 o'clock and under 55 decibels after 10 o'clock. Okay. The road noise from the vehicles going up and down U.S. to Highway 1 is louder at any point in time during the day or night. So the traffic is actually louder than the music that we're – and the people talking out on my deck. Okay. You can look at the code enforcement thing where they made us take down. We had put up a covering over it without a permit. We were told by the person that sold it to us, the carport, that we didn't need it because it wasn't permitted and connected to the building. Well, that was a lie. You guys made us take it or the county made us take it down. We took it down. But as far as that goes, that's the only thing we've done, and that's what started this whole thing is from our neighbors who seem to be – think that their hotel is the only hotel around. They were actually in competition with my hotel. I've been there 30 years. They bought their motel in 2018. Both motels were built in the 1940s. Pinto's has been a bar well before it got a conditional use permit. It's been a bar for 50 years, 60 years. Okay. It's been there forever. These people come in. The first thing they called was code enforcement on me saying my sign was too tall and too bright. That was in 2018 when they first bought the business. Okay. They have a little 12 by 16 sign that's on the ground. It's made out of concrete black. They must have sign on me. I don't know. That was the first thing. Then they started calling the noise complaints in. Every time the sheriffs come, they don't shut us down. They ask us sometimes to, okay, can you respectfully make sure the door doesn't open? Okay. And we tried to do that. But as far as going out, they've been there with the decibel meters. So has code enforcement. Curtis Britt was there. He went out. It states right in his report that he went out there. And when he was there that night, it was not above the required decibel. Now, I'm not saying it doesn't happen. Okay. It probably does when we have benefits for people. These people, ask them how many benefits they've done for the local community since they've been here. They've done none. They've raised zero dollars. Okay. They don't do it. We do it. We try to work with you. They called my wife up the very first thing and told her she had a shutdown at 10 o'clock. Never offered anything. Never tried. Never even came to talk to her. Said she came in. This is the first time I've ever seen this woman. So now I know what she looks like. Okay. They live in Arizona. They call in noise complaints from Arizona. So how can you do that? All right. And as far as my customers being drunk on their property, ask them when they harbored the murderer that murdered the woman up in Titusville. And the cops came in and took over, came into their motel. Okay. Ask them how many times the cops come into the motel for the drug addicts that they rent to. Because they'll rent to anybody. We only rent weeklies. We rent to the workers, the people who work out at the space center, work down at the power plants. That's who we rent to. So as far as any of my clients being drunk and running around the neighborhoods, if they're doing it, call the cops. Have them put in jail. Okay. But it doesn't happen like they're saying.
Well, we need to kind of draw this back in. Okay. Because you're here for a CUP for the outside. I'm not just trying to explain it. No, no. I understand. We're a planning and zoning board. You know, we're not the code enforcement or nothing. Right.
So why do you need two CUPs? I don't know. They never told us that. When we came to the county 20 years ago, and I told them what we were doing. We're going to build it back outside. We're going to put the door out. Hold on one second, sir.
The existing CUP only covers the indoor area only. And they're going to go outside.
And they want to drink on the outside deck. So they need to expand the CUP. Why wasn't I told this by the county 20 years ago? When I came and asked.
I didn't work for the county 20 years ago, sir. I can't address that.
But that's why we're here. What I'm saying, we don't mind getting the conditional use permit for the deck now. Okay. Because you're saying I require. But I should have been told this 20 years ago. We would have done it then. It's not like we tried to do anything nefarious. We didn't try to hide anything. So.
And they've also put a fence on my property with a camera. I'm talking now, please. I'm trying to be like you, Mr. Jordan. You know, to see both sides. It's tough. So, do we have any?
Mr. Eric. Mr. Chairman, I, in light of some of the testimony hearing about noise, that's not a zoning issue. Correct. And nor is drunks or lauderers or bikers or whatever else is going on. We're here for zoning. From my understanding, this bar has existed for a long time. And I don't know that the expansion of this patio area is going to change, elevate, or reduce the noise level in any way. Am I correct? Correct. It's going to stay the same. So, with that, if I can, I'll just move for approval.
Well, we've got a motion. Do you want to table it for discussion? Yeah, I do. Can you hold your motion, Mr. Eric, for discussion?
You know, for years we've handled CUPs and we've been very liberal with those CUPs. I can only attest to Merritt Island, I think everybody that has a driver's license has also got a CUP for liquor. I mean, it's always, we've been very liberal with CUPs. He's already got one, and I just can't see and listen to all the people here. It's a very unique situation when you have a hotel in the back and a bar in the front. It's been that way for years. I don't need to tell them how long I've been here. But, to me, it's just difficult to do the expansion, and I think that's exactly what has to be done. You need to do a second CUP for outside. That's always the way it's been, so I don't think, in defense of the county, I don't think that. They've got one. They've got their license, and I'm just not in favor of giving them the second CUP.
Yes, sir. Staff brought up parking, that if you do get the CUP, you would need 18 additional parking spaces.
That was brought up because they were saying my capacity increased. My capacity did not increase. I have 75 seats and have had it for 30. Since we purchased the business, the fire department comes out and counts it regularly. They count pool tables as a seat. They count video games as a seat. They've counted all my seats, and we've been spot on for 30 years. We've kept it at 75 seats. And I'm not saying that, okay, maybe when we have a benefit there might be some money, but it's an ebb and flow. You can never tell, really, how many people are coming and going because it's a benefit. They're coming in. They're buying auction items, doing whatever, donating money. Yes, sometimes if they want to come check when that's happening and have me weed out the people, I'll do that. But on a regular basis, we stay well under our 75 seating. Friday night is our busy night. That's probably the only night that these people will hear music because the door opens up or whatever. But still, the decibel meter does not lie. And like I said, the sheriff.
So you're saying you don't need additional parking.
Does staff agree with that? Why do I need additional parking when I haven't changed anything?
I'm asking staff now.
Why do I need additional parking when I have done nothing? And when I was told 20 years ago that I didn't need anything more. I'm asking staff.
County site plan regulation, 62-3206, parking for restaurants, cocktail lounges, and other eating and drinking establishment. One space for every 100 square feet of gross floor area of the building, including outdoor seating. So if you have outdoor seating, that space is included in the parking requirement.
Right, but I haven't changed my seating. I moved it. I didn't change it. I moved it from the inside to the outside. I did not increase my building.
It's square footage. The number of seats is irrelevant. It's square footage.
I didn't increase my building.
It's the outdoor, including outdoor seating. If you have seating on the outdoor, you increase the seating.
No, I didn't increase the capacity. I did not increase the building. The building, the deck was freestanding, ground level. And I was told by the county, I have everything right here. I have these two. Why don't you call these two people that I talked to in permitting and zoning and find out why I was given this permission.
We're going to get back to the matter. To the CU. You asked the question. Staff answered it. Right. So. Yes.
So, Mr. Eric, do you want to proceed with your motion or you want to hold on or what are we doing here?
I want to proceed because I'm assuming that these parking issues and debates that are going on are going to be something that he's going to have to respond to based on the zoning that we give him. Right. So, we don't make a decision on parking. This is just for the CUP. Correct.
Yeah. So, he's not changing the zoning. He's just applying for a conditional use permit, which under 62-1901, a lot of these things that are in the staff report can be reviewed, should be reviewed during the CUP process. So, that's why these topics are coming up. Right.
Right, but if it's granted, it's not our decision. It's going to have to be the regulation that's going to make him have extra parking if that's what they're going to ask for, correct?
Correct. Okay. The regulations will require him to do that. But earlier, you said something about why we're considering these things during this process because in our code, that's what it states. Got it. Okay.
Go ahead, Eric, with your motion then, unless you want to withdraw it. No. I'll hold the motion. I'll second. Okay. We got a motion by Eric, a second by Tracy. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Yes. Yes. Robert, you. Did you get that, Seth?
I have Mr. Jordan.
Yes. And Mr. Wise. Thank you.
Let's do a roll call. Can we just do a roll call, Mr. Chair? I think that might be cleanest. In favor, just raise your hand. All those opposed? Oh, fails. Four to five. So we'll need an opposing vote, Mr. Chair.
There you go. You're on now. Mr. Chairman, I move that we oppose this conditional use permit.
I need a second. We got a first by Jordan, a second by Ron to oppose item H3. Let's have a discussion.
All right. We'll hold the motion for discussion. I heard both sides, and you're right. I'd really like for both sides to come out at least trying to smile, but I just hear all this animosity, and I, for the life of me, can't understand.
Well, you know what? For 30 years I've been here in the two business hours before that, we had a little. Sir, I'm talking, sir. Please, talk. I'm sorry.
It's okay. I, for the life of me, can't understand how the numbers don't change when you're expanding your footprint. You're saying you're just going to move some chairs from inside to the outside. You're getting more square footage. Well, you can only have seven. I'm sorry. I'm still talking, sir. You're getting more square footage so that you can have more people there. You're a business person. You're a capitalist, so you want to expand so you can make more money. I can't. I'm a business person. I understand that part. But the challenge I have, honestly, is the fact that there are neighborhoods behind you. I've seen the video. It's loud. It's very loud. Whether it's 3 o'clock in the daytime or 11 o'clock at night, it's still loud. And I'm a firm believer that people need to have peace, especially during these days. And that's the reason why I decided not to vote for this. I'm hoping you're going to be happy because you are doing the bumper business. And by the way, there's one of the things you said that really caught me, because I raise a lot of money for different organizations. You can't compare one person to your organization and say, because I'm doing this, I should be justified to make noise. You just can't do that. So the bottom line to me is that both of you are good people. You both feel that you're totally correct. But for me, who have to make a decision about this, I really believe that it's in the best interest of everyone that we keep the CUP. I think he got inside, right? He has a CUP inside, and that's where it should stay. That's my justification.
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Jordan. Can you turn your mic on, please, sir?
After listening to the hotel owners, I looked up their hotel. I looked at their reviews, and I read through their 666 reviews. I skimmed through about 100, and there were no noise complaints or complaints about shrunkenness.
Thank you, Barry.
In fact, you'll see one in there that said they had such a good time at our venue while they were staying at their restaurant.
We've got to keep going here. We're here for a CUP. So, Mr. Jordan, you ready for your motion? Yeah. Okay. Do you want to go ahead?
Oh, I thought I already done it. Well, let's do it again. Mr. Chairman, I move that we deny the request for a CUP at this location.
Okay. Item H3 for denial. All those in favor for denial, say yay. Yay. Aye. Aye. Let's do a show of hands, if we can, for staff. Those opposed? Five to four. Is that what you got? Are we good, staff?
All right. Thank you, sir. Let's remind them that you still have to go to county commission and...
We're pursuing litigation. Thank you. Oh.
Thank you, guys. All right.
Thank you.
Item H5.
It's actually H4 and H5 are companion applications. Jacob Aaron and Sierra Daniela Rosenthal request a small-scale comprehensive plan amendment to change FLU from PI to Res4, 26SS00011. And the companion, Jacob Aaron and Sierra Daniela Rosenthal request a zoning classification change from Planned Industrial Park to SR, Suburban Residential, 26Z00040 in District 2.
Okay. And you must be the applicant?
I am.
If you could state your name and spell your last name for the record.
My name is Sierra Rosenthal. My last name is R-O-S-E-N-T-H-A-L.
All right. And a little bit about what you want to do, Ms. Sierra.
I put it here. Is there...
If you could stay near that microphone, please.
Sorry. I got the... Okay. The survey for you. The property used to have three other properties attached to it, and it was like an orange grove, and they sold off three sections of it. And those are actually residential homes that have been there for 30, 40 years now. But our property, the first property, never got rezoned from PIP industrial usage, and my husband and I would like to rezone it for residential usage because of the setbacks, the setbacks requirements for PIP versus the setback requirements for residential. We're hoping to put a metal building there on the northwest corner, and then there's not really other good options to put it on our property, and so we need to rezone in order to shorten the setbacks.
All right. While you're right there, is there anyone in the audience want to speak for or against this item? Okay. I'm closing that public... No. That's a good thing.
I figured it'd be easier. I was trying to hurry up.
All right. So seeing that, go ahead, ma'am. If you want... I think I kind of cut you off there a little bit.
No. Did you guys have any questions for me? There shouldn't be any drainage issues with the future proposed building because of the entire property slopes to the southeast, and there's a giant eight-foot ditch at the front of the property, so...
I'll bring it back to the board. We got any questions for the applicant?
Just one quick one. Are you building any driveway or access to that building?
No, sir. We already have a concrete driveway on there that goes all the way down almost to the building, but between that driveway and the house and the building, we'd be putting in the pavers that kind of look like figure eights that allow grass and drainage to...
And approximately what size is the building going to be?
30 by 40. Okay. We don't have the permits for that yet. We have to get rezoned first.
Okay.
Thank you. Are you good, Mr. Eric? Yes, sir. Mr. Brothers.
I'll make a motion that we approve applicants' requests for, what are we on, H-4, small-scale comprehensive plan amendment? Second. Okay.
Item H-4, we got a motion by Robert Brothers. We got a second by Jordan. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? That passed unanimously. Now I'll need a motion on item H-5.
I'll make a motion that we approve item H-5, that we recommend approval of item H-5. Request for a zoning classification change from PIP to SR. Second.
Okay. Item H-5, motion for approval by Robert Brothers. A second by Jordan. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? And that passed unanimously. See how easy that was? Thank you. All right. Good luck with the county commissioners.
Item H-6. Okay. Item H-6, Jerome C. and Cheryl Cicoli are requesting a zoning classification change from B-1 to SR. 26 C-0-0-4-2, District 3.
Joe, do I turn this on? It should be on, sir. You can just slide it in there. Oh, there you go.
Jerome Cicoli, C-I-C-O-L-I. What I'm requesting is, as you can see, this was one piece of property, and it covered 1.4 acres. And I am dividing it and taking one half acre off the east side, which is already surveyed, and it's going to be one half acre for building to make it a residential. It was all B-U-1 at one time, and that's it. Very simple. Okay. No bars, no music, nothing. While you're right there.
You don't have a site plan? Does anybody want to speak for or against this item? All right. I'm closing it for public comment. We'll bring it back to the board. Anyone have any questions for the applicant? Mr. Chairman. Mr. Jordan. Move for approval.
Second.
Second. Item H-6, motion by Jordan for approval, a second by Debbie. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? That passed unanimously. Thank you. Thank you, sir.
Item H-7. Okay. Item H-7, Nancy E. Ruiz, Michael Koop Sr., representing, is requesting a zoning classification change from AU to RR1-26Z-00043 in District 1. Aye.
My name is Cori Jones, J-O-N-E-S. I'm not Michael Koop, but I am on the author's act for the owner. Oh, okay. I'm here representing the rezoning request for 4360 Shamrock Drive. Thank you for the opportunity to speak. We are requesting to rezone 2.27 acres from AU to RR1 with the intention of creating two lots for the two single-family homes. The property is already designated residential one on the county's future land use map, and RR1 zoning is established elsewhere in the surrounding area. We believe this request fits the area's existing residential character. We also took the steps to understand the property's environmental conditions. An assessment by Atlantic Environmental Florida found no protected wetlands, no hydric soils, or no listed species during the September 2026 evaluation. We have a report available for the board. We recognize that the neighbors value the trees, privacies, and rural settings. Our intention is not to clear the entire property. We plan to limit disturbance to areas needed for construction and preserve wooded areas wherever practical. We've brought a sample survey showing how proposed areas of alteration in areas intended to remain undisturbed can be identified, which is the approach we intend to take with these lots. We understand the concerns about flooding and drainage. The environmental assessment does not replace a drainage review. Any future grading and stormwater plans will need to meet county requirements. Ultimately, we are asking the board to consider the rezoning request not to approve final construction plans today. We believe two single-family homes can be planned responsibly while respecting the character of the neighborhood. Thank you for your consideration. And I do have copies of the environmental reports if you guys want to see them.
Would anybody like to see them? I'm good. I'm good. All right. Seeing that, I bring it back to the board. Any other questions for the applicant?
Mr. Chairman. Mr. Jordan. Move for approval. H-7.
Second.
Tracy, was that you, ma'am? That was me. We have public comment, Mr. Chair. Yes, I did. You did. I already went out earlier. Oh, there? No. Then I blew it.
Okay, my bad.
Sorry about that.
Ma'am, if you could just have a seat there. Who wants to speak for or against this?
Patrick Connor, 4515 Bogan Villa, C-O-N-N-E-R. And we first need to thank all of you for volunteering your time up here. It's a thankless job, I know. I've lived in this subdivision since 1983. I've only flooded a couple times, but I'm way up in the air. I've got neighbors that come about that close to going in their front door. If we bathtub them out by putting two properties on this one lot or two residences on the one lot, it's definitely going to increase our stormwater runoff. And we're already having problems. I mean, our road, water goes right straight over it. It was that way just a few weeks ago. So, there's a simple binding development plan. And I don't think anybody in our subdivision would mind one house the way it was developed. Everybody in our subdivision is two and a quarter lots. And I'm sure there's been people up here in the past who's tried to split them. I don't recall going to any meetings or being aware of it. Otherwise, I'd have been here. So, we just respectfully request that you do not allow two houses on one lot, even though it may be broken down. It's not anything. Our entire subdivision is all the same size. That's going to depreciate our home values. So, we're all sitting on two and a quarter. Let them sit on two and a quarter. Thank you.
Thank you. Anyone else want to speak for or against this?
Hi, my name is Ross Coffin, C-O-F-F-I-N. I live north of this property, borderlines it. My concern is that all the houses in this area are older development. And, I mean, everything sits, you know, pretty much so ground level. And with two homes going in on big mounds of dirt, all that water is coming toward me and the surrounding neighbors. We're already in a flood zone, and we do have a lot of standing water when it rains a lot. So, I mean, that's my concern. Everybody else is on two and a half acres or two or more acres in the neighborhood. So, I don't understand why we have to split this up just because the contractor wants to. They already split up enough property in the surrounding areas and MIMS. So, I just don't think it's good for the neighbors and myself. Okay.
Let me ask him a question. Yes, sir. Is your house, if I use the terminology, are you built to grade of the crown of the road or are you elevated?
I'm on the crown of the street. I mean, my house was built in 78, so it's right there on the street. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. So, when Joe waters his yard, you get it. Right. Okay. That's all I need. Yeah.
That's it. Thank you. All right. Thank you, sir. Thank you very much. Anybody else want to speak for or against this item?
Afternoon. My name is Terry Broadwell, B-R-O-A-D-W-E-L-L. I'm at 4485 Burcomb. I'm catty-cornered from this property. And my point is exactly as has already been stated. My father and I built this house in 1980. It's the way it's always been. Nobody else has wanted to sit there and break up property. It's the way we like it. It's the way we want to keep it. And we appreciate it if you would agree with us. Thank you.
Okay. Thank you, sir. Anybody else?
My name is Lindsay Risto, R-I-S-T-O-W. I live in this neighborhood. We bought this house in 2019 when I was pregnant with my first child, and we renovated. We were so happy to buy a house on such land so that we can raise our kids to not have devices and to live on this property with the character of the neighborhood just having one home per two, less 2.2 acres. We recently had a rain, you're aware. There was lots of flooding in Palm Bay, Melbourne area, where people had to be rescued. So I went through our neighborhood and I took pictures of what happens in Robinswood from Darla Roth's house all the way to our house to where the runoff of the St. John's comes. So when it comes to rezoning from AU to residential, you know, we like to have the one house per, that's the way that we bought it. That's the neighborhood. And we know most of our neighbors, you know, we're not trying to rezone, to have somebody come in and be a developer just to make money on two acre, on two one acre plots. Like each one of these people that buy a home in Robinswood, they all live there. They're not trying to make money on anybody. They live there. So I want to show you the rest of my time with these pictures, if you would. And is this on? Terrible. Is there a way to fix the glare?
It's okay. Yes.
Okay. This is the corner, your property, I believe, with, what's your name? Yeah. Mine. Yes. Yes. Yes, that's his property. That's what happens with all the water in the area.
I'm going to be a nice guy and I'm going to give you five minutes to finish. Okay.
I'm just going to show you these. Sorry. I've, I've had a sore throat for a long time and I'm like really trying to, to get it out there.
I said five minutes. I was just kidding. Oh, okay. But I'm going to give you, I'm going to give you one more minute.
This is, this is Ross's property. He was talking about all the water. This is all water right through here. And this is the property right here in question, which has wetlands, which becomes like a sponge. I'm going to show you the next picture. This is, this is the property on the other side of the parcel in question. And you can see that there is no flood water there. And, and if you look at the, um, the wetlands map, it shows that part of that back part of the property is wetland. So it acts like a sponge. So I'm going to continue on through the neighborhood. This is across the street from the picture I just showed you. All of that is, um, just right there in the area, but not including their yard. This is when you turn down shamrock. If you can see their whole, that's their entire yard.
Okay. Thank you, ma'am.
Wetlands.
Oh, I'm sorry.
This is the runoff to the St. John's where my house is.
I got to cut you off, ma'am. Okay. I give you more than enough time. I appreciate that. All right.
Two minutes is not enough.
Yes, sir.
Hello.
I'm, uh, James Risto. I live at four, four, four zero Fernwood drive. I'm Lindsay's husband. Um, I'm opposed to the rezoning. Um, you know, it was talked about preserving the neighborhood character. Um, you know, I think that's, that's really key to this development. You know, all of us have kind of bought into these larger lots because that's the kind of quiet lifestyle that we, uh, desired and enjoyed for our families. Um, you know, Robinswood is established in the seventies. Most houses were built around the eighties. You know, it's been that way for a long time. Uh, my kids ride their bikes through this really quiet neighborhood. And one thing that I wanted to point out is that, uh, you know, who better to describe the character of the community than the people that actually live there and not the, uh, surrogate of Mr. Cooper, Mr. Coop. Um, we talked a little bit about environmental constraints. I think the only thing I want to say there is that rezoning to put two houses, two pads, two driveways divides the ability of the land to absorb water from the surrounding homes by half, right? Simple math. Uh, the neighboring residential RR1 property is not really a comparable precedent. Uh, despite being rezoned in 1997, it remains 2.24 acre property and it doesn't establish and it does not demonstrate an established pattern of smaller residential lots. There's still only one house on that property and it's stipulated to stay that way. Uh, and lastly, there's no demonstrated need for rezoning. The property is already a legally recognized, buildable, non-conforming lot under AU zoning. Rezoning is primarily intended to double the residential development, uh, by a developer who will not be living in this neighborhood. And if Mr. Coop would like to develop the property, play it by the established rules in the community. There's no good reason to rezone here. So I oppose this rezoning. Thank you for your consideration. Okay. Thank you, sir.
Anybody else want to speak for or against this or I'm going to close it for public comment? Ma'am, if you could come back up to the podium and I bring it back to the board. Do we have any questions or any more concerns with the applicant?
Is there currently a, a, uh, building on there, a house on there?
No, it's an empty lot.
It's an empty lot. And it's how many acres? 2.27. Same as pretty much all around? About. Okay. And if I missed it, I apologize, but what's the reason why you want to subdivide it?
He's two single family homes on it. You build one house on that big of a lot, nobody's going to be able to afford to buy it in this economy. But, and also to, to defense of the wetlands, I do have an environmental report that was done in September that states there's no wetlands on the property.
Mr. Eric here, you? I'm good, sir. Mr. Jordan.
Yeah, I, actually, that's the word I was going to ask for. You were doing good until we found out we didn't ask the public about this.
No, I knew it. I knew, I knew it was going to happen. I seen the Facebook post. Oh, you did? Yes.
I didn't, for sure. I was well prepared. Well, looking at the pictures from the young lady there, there's certainly a lot of water around.
I'm curious to know what roads those are on, because it was just, we were just told, okay.
All of them. Story of the road.
Okay. But it wasn't stated when it was being presented, so I wasn't sure. Okay. If that was, like, at the lot that we're talking about, or if those are other streets in the neighborhood.
Okay.
We can't get back into this. All right. We've listened to y'all. Let's listen to her so we can be done here.
To be fair.
The county commissioners are going to make the final decision.
Correct. And to be fair, I've done a lot of due diligence. I've spent a lot of time on the phone with a lot of people from the county, natural resources, zoning, going over the wetlands. The wetlands are in the very back of the property that aren't even going to be altered, like the back of the neighboring property is where wetlands are, not on the property that we are at. Correct. Ma'am, please. The wetlands are on the property abutting to us. Abutting to us, there are wetlands. The whole property is wetlands. We are not, which is on this report. I would happily give it to you.
Okay.
We've got to get back to the point.
We've got to get back here. I think the challenge that I have now is I look at the GIS map, and all of the land that is owned by the neighbors are consistently at least two acres, and this one would be split in half, which to me kind of changes the character of the neighborhood, wouldn't you think? Yeah. And the only reason why you're doing this, I think you're saying it's the economy. Right.
Right. I mean, to be able to afford an acre in men's right now, acres are going for hundreds of thousands of dollars, so.
Yeah. Okay. I've got a problem with this because I always put myself in the place of the neighbors to try to figure out, you know, could I live with something like this, especially if I moved in a certain neighborhood because I like the character of the neighborhood, and then a future person comes along and says, no, we're going to change that because I own the land. I certainly respect the ownership of the land, but then when you're talking about, you always want to be a good neighbor. The challenge that you have, in my mind, that I would have is I'm the developer, I'm going to build, and I'm going, right? And then there's going to be two new neighbors there that people are not going to like very much because they are on a smaller lot, but I think my biggest thing, because we can't just, I can't use my feelings to decide whether I want to do it or not, the environmental thing, to me, you say you've got to study, right, but staff is saying you really need to focus on this because you've got some plants and trees and all of that that could cause you some challenges in the future for sure. Yep. All right? Yep. Okay. Thank you, sir.
Right.
One, is this in your neighborhood? It's close.
Is it close enough to respond?
Well, there are a lot of small, there's some small lots up there on Berkman. Yep. But those lots have been in that configuration for decades. Yeah.
Ron, could you get next to your mic, please? Sorry.
And the mic turned off. I was trying to make up for it with yelling, but that didn't work. I mean, there is a subdivision there called Robin Wood. It's unrecorded, but it was put in a long time ago. Yes. It's almost all developed. It looks to me like there's only one or two lots left. It's because it's well-developed. I think it needs to stay that way. I don't see a need to change it.
I've got tremendous reservations. I mean, you know that end is, I know it pretty well, too.
Yeah.
So I move that we recommend denial, listening change.
And I'm going to jump on if you make that motion. I did. You got a second? I'll have to go to second.
Okay. Item 8-7, motion for denial by Ron, a second by Henry. All those in favor of denial, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? That got denied.
Okay. Thank you. All right. Thank you.
Okay. Meeting adjourned. The opinions expressed by any member of the public during any period of public comment do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of the Board of County Commissioners of Brevard County, Florida, Space Coast Government Television, or the program sponsor and are solely